Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diet Book Review
Diet Book Review
Jessica Kozlosky
28 November 2020
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 2
Caroline Wheater, author of 1993’s The Juicing Detox Diet, asserts that poor diet, stress,
pollutants, and the sluggishness of one’s organs overwhelm the body’s kidneys, liver, colon,
skin, lungs, and lymph, allowing toxin buildup (Wheater, 1993). She touts fruit and vegetable
consumption of them boosts immunity, accelerates metabolism, rests the GI tract, reduces bodily
acidity, compensates for organ dysfunction, and eliminates bodily toxins (Wheater, 1993). Her
book includes one day, two day, one week, and two week diet plans; the prior two consist solely
of consumption of 8 fl oz of fruit juice at meals while the latter feature an 8 fl oz cocktail of fruit
and vegetable juices at each meal alongside solid foods (See Appendices A, B, C, D, and E).
While Wheater occasionally offers sound advice, she bases much of her guidance on
misunderstandings of the anatomy and physiology of multiple body systems and ignorance of the
dangers of restrictive diets. Combined with the fact that the benefits of her plans can be found in
less extreme diets, The Juicing Detox Diet is at best, a waste of consumers’ time and effort and at
and fruit juices, encourages proliferation of neutrophils, T-lymphocytes, and B-lymphocytes and
bolsters the phagocytic abilities of neutrophils (Carr & Maggini, 2017). A 2018 study published
compounds found in plants and plant derivatives (Ding et al., 2018). It also reported
polyphenols’ ability to inhibit the formation of IgE antibodies, immunoglobulins responsible for
allergic reactions. Moreover, polyphenols have been shown to increase T-cell mediated immune
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 3
responses to cancer cell death, also known as immunogenic cell death (Ding et al., 2018).
However, Wheater’s one and two day plans omit nutrients vital for immunity such as zinc and
linolenic acid, thus working against this claim. While her longer plans do encourage the
inclusion of linolenic acid and zinc sources such as seaweed and pumpkin seeds respectively,
more popular sources like linolenic acid-rich fatty fish and zinc-rich meat are excluded.
Alongside bolstering immune function, Weather’s diets also have the potential to impact
metabolism. Diets including daily consumption of 300 mL orange juice for 60 days have
decreased blood glucose, insulin resistance, total cholesterol, LDL, and triglycerides in women
(Cesar et al., 2020). Studies utilizing pomegranate juice (PJ) have prompted decreases in LDL
oxidation and free radical activity (Hou et al., 2019). In participants with Type 2 Diabetes
Mellitus (T2DM), intake of 40 mg PJ for 8 weeks resulted in lower levels of triglycerides, LDL,
and LDL/HDL and TC/HDL ratios. Two studies, one using T2DM patients and the other healthy
stress (Hou et al., 2019). In another study, daily 26 gram supplements of beetroot juice increased
urine concentrations of glycocholic and chenodeoxycholic acids and AICAR, implying increased
bodily levels (Kozlowska et al., 2020). The acids are associated with heightened brown adipose
muscle cells and improves insulin sensitivity (Kozlowska et al., 2020). Yet, it should be
acknowledged that some of these studies possessed a longer duration than Wheater’s diets and it
is unlikely that all juices produce the same effects as the ones tested.
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 4
Unlike her prior assertions, Wheater’s claim that GI muscles need to be rested in order
for them to function and that juices will provide such reprieve is incorrect and rooted in a
misconception of GI physiology. It is true that in cases of trauma to or disruption of the function
of the GI tract, such as following major abdominal surgeries like a Whipple procedure or
intestinal resectioning resulting in short bowel syndrome, a brief break from GI stimulation
grants time for affected organs to marginally recover from dysfunction (Jiang et al., 2019;
food-induced peristalsis has been associated with hypoplasia of intestinal villi (Madnawat et al.,
2020). Furthermore, enterocyte maturation and function requires contact of intestinal mucosa
with digested nutrients and the presence of chyme in the intestinal lumina. Absences of these
factors, such as during total parenteral nutrition, have resulted in decreases in the surface area
and height of villi, depth of crypts, and amounts of epithelial cells and induced atrophy of GI
muscles as quickly as 24 hours after the cessation of GI stimulation (Madnawat et al., 2020).
Ultimately, the most restrictive of Wheater’s diets still provide some stimulation and so will not
result in atrophy, yet her idea of the need to rest the GI tract is nonetheless mistaken.
In a similar vein, Wheater’s position that juices reduce bodily acidity, approximated to
blood pH, ignores the existence of blood pH buffers. The lungs’ carbon dioxide exhalation and
kidneys’ excretion of acids and reabsorption of bicarbonate maintain blood pH in the slightly
alkaline range of 7.35-7.45 in the face of outside forces that act upon the body (Seifter & Chang,
2016). If one shifts focus to GI acidity, organs of the tract also possesses means to regulate pH.
Hydrochloric acid secreted by gastric parietal cells, combined with stomach churning and
activity from enzymes such as pepsin, reduces food boluses in the stomach to acidic chyme
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 5
(MacFarlane, 2018). After entering the small intestine, chyme is neutralized by alkaline
bicarbonate secretions from the pancreas and duodenal Brunner glands (Ma et al., 2020). It
remains neutral to slightly alkaline as it continues digestive and absorptive processes and
ultimately becomes feces (Azzouz & Sharma, 2020). The aforementioned GI secretions easily
alter the pH of food boluses regardless of the foods’ pH. Furthermore, fruit juices are themselves
acidic and thus cannot raise the pH of most other substances (Reddy et al., 2016).
While juices lack notable GI pH altering abilities, some foods present in Wheater’s one
and two week diet plans such as whole grains, fruits, and vegetables do possess this potential.
Food-derived fibers that pass through the small intestine undigested can be fermented by colonic
flora to produce short-chain fatty acids. However, these byproducts lower colonic pH rather than
Despite the body’s use of pH regulatory systems, these mechanisms can be overridden.
Such phenomena, however, are undesirable. In the GI tract, one example is hypochlorhydria,
high gastric pH, and small intestine bacterial overgrowth due to overuse of substances akin to
proton pump inhibitors (Haastrup et al., 2018). This less acidic pH allows pathogens, namely H.
pylori, t o easily reproduce and lead to the development of peptic ulcers and occasionally cancer
(Sharma & Pernitzsch, 2017). Other pathogens that take advantage of altered GI pH
environments and cause infections include C. difficile and C. jejuni ( Haastrup et al., 2018). A rise
in blood pH outside normal limits, known as alkalosis, can be the consequence of metabolic
Wheater’s primary claim that fruit and vegetable juices detoxify the body of food
additives, waste, heavy metals, and pollutants has a weak foundation; limited evidence exists for
it and arises from situational circumstances. Daily ingestion of 30 mL of lemon juice and extract
for six weeks has been shown to reduce serum uric acid (Wang et al., 2017). However, given that
Wheater’s diets last a maximum of two weeks and include many juices, they may not provide
enough time or lemon juice to reap benefits. In a study concerning aluminum overload, malic
acid, citric acid, and succinic acid, all found in fruits, increased fecal excretion of aluminum in
mice (Klein & Kiat, 2015). Succinic and citric acid also decreased the amount of aluminum
stored in bones, reducing the metal’s osteomalacic effects. However, the amount of aluminum
administered was 50 mg/kg-1, 25 times the WHO-established limit of 2 mg/kg-1, and the acids
were administered via intraperitoneal injections (Klein & Kiat, 2015). In humans where
aluminum intake is lower and malic, citric, and succinic acids are obtained via intestinal
lacks a scientific definition. Wheater does not provide a concrete definition for “sluggishness”,
but implies that it is a sudden, self-resolving, and periodic decline in function. However, abrupt
declines in bodily function usually signal damage or disease. For example, one metric used to
assess kidney function is glomerular filtration rate (GFR), which indicates the volume of blood
the kidneys filter per minute (Levey & Inker, 2017). GFR naturally declines with age, but
sudden, large drops are abnormal (Levey & Inker 2017; Pottel et al., 2017). If one takes the
liberty of assuming that sluggish kidneys are ones in which GFR suddenly drops below the
like an acute kidney injury (AKI). While it is true that dietary changes such as increases in
kilocalorie and protein intakes can help alleviate the catabolism that often occurs alongside an
AKI, these changes cannot restore kidney function; resolving an AKI involves treating its
vegetables, nor their juices are particularly viable sources of protein, they are not even first
choice foods when the aforementioned dietary changes are pursued (Doyle & Forni, 2016;
impaired drainage of lymphatic fluid related to trauma, parasites, or improper lymphatic vessel
development (Goss & Greene, 2018). Lymphedema is not a natural, periodic occurrence in
healthy persons nor is it a temporary condition; it is a chronic, multi-stage disease that often
In addition to touting false claims, Wheater’s diets, namely her one and two day cleanses,
are harmful. The 24 ounces of juice consumed per day in these cleanses provide approximately
77 grams of carbohydrate, 1.5 grams of fat, 5.2 grams of protein, and 335 kilocalories per day,
falling far below the macronutrient and kilocalorie requirements for healthy adults (Orange
Juice, Fresh). Wheater does warn that this restriction is not safe for children, the elderly, or
people with diabetes, hypoglycemia, candidiasis, or seriousness illnesses, however, such intakes
are not safe for anyone and lead to unwanted catabolism of glycogen, adipose, and proteins
(Rolfes et al., 2017). Continuing to the topic of inadequate advisories, despite the absence of
animal products from her one and two day plans and relative lack of them in her one and two
week diets, Weather does not inform readers about potential vitamin B12 deficiencies. She also
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 8
fails to warn readers that grapefruit juice, one of the many juices she promotes, interacts with a
variety of medications and may be dangerous for some participants to consume (Bailey 2016).
Amidst the drawbacks of Wheater’s diets, her one and two week plans, while flawed, lay
recommendations to supplement juice intake consist mainly of produce, some grains, and beans
and yogurt; the latter two are exclusive to the two week plan. By expanding beans and yogurt to
the one week plan and adding fish, poultry, non-tropical plant oils, milk and nuts, and additional
whole grains, a diet rich in macro and micronutrients and low in saturated fat and added sugars
can be created. Of course, it is very possible that participants in these diets will not make any
additions and instead follow guidelines as they are listed, resulting in suboptimal eating patterns.
In conclusion, the diets proposed in The Juicing Detox Diet f ail to deliver on many of
their claimed benefits- they will not reduce bodily acidity, compensate for organ dysfunction, nor
rest the digestive system and are unlikely to assist in toxin elimination. Although they do have
the potential to bolster immunity and improve metabolism, such benefits can be found in any diet
featuring fruit and vegetable juices. Furthermore, the hypocaloric nature of Wheater’s one and
two day cleanses presents unnecessary risk to participants while her one and two weeks plans,
although more sufficient, still require independent addition of foods to be nutritionally adequate.
Weather also fails to inform readers of the risk of nutrient deficiencies and drug-nutrient
interactions posed by her diets, therefore jeopardizing the health of participants. Ultimately, the
false claims present in The Juicing Detox Diet, dangers posed by its one and two day cleanses,
and availability of its benefits in less restrictive diets make the book unworthy of reading or
References
Azzouz, L. L., & Sharma, S. (2020, July 27). Physiology, Large Intestine.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK507857/.
Complicated Process. Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics, 42( 2), 125–127.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jcpt.12463
Carr, A., & Maggini, S. (2017). Vitamin C and Immune Function. Nutrients, 9( 11), 1211.
https://doi.org/10.3390/nu9111211
Cesar, T., Fidelix, M., Sivieri, K., & Millenkovic, D. (2020). Daily Consumption of Orange
Juice Modulated Intestinal Microbiota and Improved Glucose and Lipids Metabolism in
https://doi.org/10.1017/s0029665120005832
Cheng, W., Lu, J., Li, B., Lin, W., Zhang, Z., Wei, X., … Yuan, J. (2017). Effect of
Ding, S., Jiang, H., & Fang, J. (2018). Regulation of Immune Function by Polyphenols.
Doyle, J. F., & Forni, L. G. (2016). Acute Kidney Injury: Short-term and Long-term
Flores-Mireles, A. L., Walker, J. N., Caparon, M., & Hultgren, S. J. (2015). Urinary Tract
Goss, J., & Greene, A. (2018). Diagnosis and Staging of Lymphedema. Seminars in Plastic
Granzow, J. W. (2018). Lymphedema Surgery: The Current State of the Art. Clinical &
Haastrup, P. F., Thompson, W., Søndergaard, J., & Jarbøl, D. E. (2018). Side Effects of
Long-Term Proton Pump Inhibitor Use: A Review. Basic & Clinical Pharmacology
Hou, C., Zhang, W., Li, J., Du, L., Lv, O., Zhao, S., & Li, J. (2019). Beneficial Effects of
Jiang, Z., Wen, C., Wang, C., Zhao, Z., Bo, L., Wan, X., & Deng, X. (2019). Plasma
Klein, A. V., & Kiat, H. (2015). Detox Diets for Toxin Elimination and Weight
Kozlowska, L., Mizera, O., & Mroz, A. (2020). An Untargeted Metabolomics Approach to
Levey, A., & Inker, L. (2017). Assessment of Glomerular Filtration Rate in Health and
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 11
Disease: A State of the Art Review. Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 102(3),
405–419. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpt.729
Ma, Z. F., & Lee, Y. Y. (2020). Small Intestine Anatomy and Physiology. In Clinical and Basic
Madnawat, H., Welu, A. L., Gilbert, E. J., Taylor, D. B., Jain, S., Manithody, C., … Jain, A.
https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1002/ncp.10461
Nahikian-Nelms, M., Sucher, K. P., & Lacey, K. (2016). Diseases of the Lower
Cengage.
https://www.calorieking.com/us/en/foods/f/calories-in-fruitvegetable-juices-juice-drinks-
orange-juice-fresh/EPSrLWPETdqgFkAAY2mPlw.
Pottel, H., Delanaye, P., Weekers, L., Selistre, L., Goffin, K., Gheysens, O., & Dubourg, L.
https://doi.org/10.1093/ckj/sfx026
Reddy, A., Norris, D. F., Momeni, S. S., Waldo, B., & Ruby, J. D. (2016). The pH of
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 12
Beverages in the United States. The Journal of the American Dental Association, 147(4),
255–263. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.adaj.2015.10.019
Rolfes, S. R., Whitney, E. N., & Pinna, K. (2017). Metabolism: Transformations and
Brooks/Cole.
Seifter, J. L., & Chang, H.-Y. (2016). Disorders of Acid-Base Balance: New Perspectives.
Sharma, C. M., & Pernitzsch, S. (2017). Multiple Acid Sensors Control Helicobacter pylori
18
Wang, H., Cheng, L., Lin, D., Ma, Z., & Deng, X. (2017). Lemon Fruits Lower the Blood
Uric Acid Levels in Humans and mice. Scientia Horticulturae, 220, 4–10.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scienta.2017.03.023
2 fl oz celery
1 fl oz papaya
2 fl oz apple
2 fl oz peach 3 fl oz watercress
DIET BOOK CRITIQUE Kozlosky 15
2 fl oz pineapple 2 fl oz celery
Fruit Juices: Apple, grape, grapefruit, lemon, mango, melon, orange, papaya, peach, pear,
Appendix C: Approved Foods for One Week and Two Week Vitality Plans
Lunch: Mixed salad (lettuce, red cabbage, white cabbage, beansprouts, cucumber, alfalfa,
sprouting seeds, chickpeas, watercress, carrot, fennel, radish, celery, tomato, green and red
pepper), steamed or stir-fried vegetables, any fresh fruit from juice list, brown rice, millet, barley
Dinner: Steamed, stewed, raw, or stir-fried vegetables, mixed salad (same as lunch), any fresh
Anytime: Kombu, wakame, and dulse seaweeds, oat and rice cakes, hummus, tahini, prunes,
cranberries, raisins, sultanas, pumpkin and sunflower seeds, carrot, cucumber, and red pepper
Anytime: Goat and sheep yogurt, beans, pulses, tofu, cous-cous, rye bread, stewed dried fruit,