Paragraph 1- Introduction

 Paraphrase the conclusion

 Mention the premise
 Present your position on the logical soundness of the conclusion
 Point out that the argument is not well reasoned

Paragraph 2

 Make a smooth transition

 State the most obvious flaw/assumption
 Explain the assumption made by the author
 Discuss the plausibility of this assumption
 Mention what information is needed to strengthen the argument

Paragraph 3

 Ensure a smooth transition

 Describe the next flaw/assumption
 Assess the assumption and its plausibility
 Describe what else is needed to strengthen the argument

Paragraph 4

 Make a smooth transition

 State the next flaw/assumption
 Question the assumption made by the author
 Assess the accuracy of this assumption
 Describe the kind of information that will strengthen the argument.

Conclusion

 State once again that the argument is not well reasoned

 Summarize- Suggest ways to strengthen the argument.