Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ACE y Trastronos Somatomorfos
ACE y Trastronos Somatomorfos
The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease • Volume 192, Number 5, May 2004 337
Maaranen et al. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease • Volume 192, Number 5, May 2004
The purpose of our study was as follows: to 1) measure sample into subjects with high somatoform dissociation
the prevalence of high somatoform dissociation in the general (SDQ ⱖ30) and subjects with normal somatoform dissocia-
population using the SDQ, 2) characterize basic sociodemog- tion (SDQ ⬍30).
raphy associated with high somatoform dissociation, and 3)
assess the relationship between high somatoform dissociation Adverse Childhood Experiences
and both single and cumulative ACEs. Six questions were used to assess ACEs (Haatainen et
al., 2003). The alternative answers and their classification are
MATERIALS AND METHODS presented in parentheses after each question.
each of the following factors: years of education (high, ⱖ9, TABLE 1. Prevalence (%) of high somatoform dissociation
versus low, ⬍9); employment status (employed, on sick (SDQ ⱖ30) according to sex and selected sociodemographic
leave, or student, versus unemployed); working ability (good variables
versus reduced or unable to work); and financial situation
(good or fairly good versus fairly poor or poor). Prevalence, %
Men Women Total
Statistical Analysis Variable (N ⴝ 742) (N ⴝ 997) (N ⴝ 1739)
The statistical methods included the Pearson chi-square
Age (y)
test for categorical variables, the independent samples t test for
26–35 7.4 6.4 6.7
continuous variables, and the Mantel-Haenszel test for linear-
36–45 8.5 8.2 8.3
by-linear associations. The nonparametric Mann-Whitney U test
46–55 11.4 8.1 9.6
was used to analyze the between-group difference in the mean
56–65 16.8** 10.5 13.2**
SDQ scale score because of the skewed distribution of this
Marital status
variable. The Pearson correlation was measured between the
Married 10.0 8.5 9.2
ACEs. Multiple logistic regression analysis was used to identify
Single, divorced, 14.5 7.8 10.3
factors independently associated with high somatoform dissoci- widowed
ation. Data analysis was conducted with SPSS 11.0. Place of residence
Urban 11.4 7.5 9.1
RESULTS Rural 10.2 10.4 10.3
The prevalence of high somatoform dissociation was Education
9.4% in the total sample and was higher among men than High (ⱖ9 y) 9.5 7.6 8.4
women (Table 1). The prevalence of high somatoform disso- 18.2**
Low (⬍9 y) 13.0* 15.7***
ciation in the total sample increased with age, low education, Employment status
unemployment, a reduced working ability, and a poor finan- Employed, on sick leave, 9.8 7.6 8.5
cial situation. or student
The mean SDQ score was 23.3 (SD ⫽ 6.1) in the total Unemployed 22.1** 14.3* 17.5**
sample, and the mean score of men was higher than that of women Working ability
(23.8 关SD ⫽ 6.9兴 vs. 22.9 关SD ⫽ 5.3兴; p ⫽ .002; data not shown). Good 5.2 4.3 4.7
High somatoform dissociation was more prevalent Reduced 22.1*** 15.7*** 17.9***
among women with different ACEs, except for a poor rela- Financial situation
tionship between parents (Table 2). Among men, high so- Good 8.1 6.2 7.0
matoform dissociation was associated with a poor relation- Poor 21.5* 17.4*** 19.4***
ship between the parents, an unhappy childhood home, and Total 11.1a 8.2a 9.4
physical punishment. *
p ⬍ .05.
In multiple logistic regression models (Table 3), when **
p ⬍ .01.
both the sociodemographic variables and ACEs were in- ***
p ⬍ .001.
cluded, a reduced working ability, a poor financial situation,
a
Difference between men and women, p ⫽ .047.
and physical punishment were associated with high somato-
form dissociation in both sexes. There were some differences
between men and women: A poor relationship between par- tween high somatoform dissociation and an increasing num-
ents increased the odds of high somatoform dissociation ber of ACEs in both genders. As a large ACE study (Dube et
among men and alcohol abuse in their childhood home al., 2001; Felitti et al., 1998) has shown, simultaneously
among women. considering the impact of multiple experiences is important,
The prevalence of high somatoform dissociation in- because ACEs are strongly interrelated and also related to
creased linearly with an increasing number of ACEs in both poor mental health. A review article in which adult retrospec-
sexes (Table 4). The adjusted relative risk of high somato- tive reports of more than one form of child maltreatment were
form dissociation increased threefold in men and more than assessed also showed that the maltreatment types do not
fivefold in women with four to six ACEs. occur independently, and that a significant proportion of
people do not just experience repeated episodes of one type
DISCUSSION of maltreatment but are likely to be victims of other forms of
In addition to the associations between single ACEs abuse and neglect (Higgins and McCabe, 2001). In a recent
and somatoform dissociation, we measured the impact of study (Roelofs et al., 2002), patients with conversion disorder
multiple ACEs and found a strong, graded relationship be- with multiple traumatization had more severe somatoform
TABLE 2. Prevalence (%) of ACEs according to sex and level of somatoform dissociation
Men Women
Somatoform dissociation Somatoform dissociation
Normal High All Normal High All
ACEs N ⴝ 660 N ⴝ 82 N ⴝ 742 p-Valuea N ⴝ 915 N ⴝ 82 N ⴝ 997 p-Valuea
Poor relationship between parents 17.8 29.3 19.1 .013 21.7 30.4 22.4 NS
Unhappy childhood home 11.7 21.0 12.8 .019 16.3 33.8 17.7 ⬍.001
Hard parenting 39.5 50.0 40.6 NS 41.5 61.0 43.1 .001
Physical punishment 69.2 81.7 70.6 .019 53.0 72.0 54.6 .001
Domestic violence 10.3 17.1 11.1 NS 9.8 24.4 11.0 ⬍.001
Alcohol abuse at childhood home 28.9 30.9 29.1 NS 27.6 42.7 28.8 .005
a
Differences between normal and high somatoform dissociation.
TABLE 3. Adjusted odds ratios (AORs) for high somatoform dissociation (SDQ ⱖ30) in separate multiple logistic regression
models for men, women, and all subjects
dissociative symptoms than those who reported only one type ment among both men and women. However, domestic vio-
of traumatization. lence, including both sexual and physical violence in
Previous research has shown a relationship between childhood, was not associated with high somatoform disso-
physical and sexual abuse and adult somatoform dissociation ciation in our population-based sample. Domestic violence
(Nijenhuis et al., 1998b). Recently, it has been suggested that had statistically a significant bivariate association with high
somatoform dissociation would be more clearly associated somatoform dissociation among women, but the relationship
with physical abuse in cases in which there is a threat of was not found in multiple logistic regression analysis.
inescapable physical injury, and somatoform dissociation In previous childhood trauma studies, physical abuse
could be understood as a set of adaptive psychophysiological has included all kinds of physical violence and punishment in
responses to trauma (Waller et al., 2000). Our results partly childhood (Roelofs et al., 2002; Waller et al., 2000), or
support these findings, because we found a strong relation- culturally accepted physical punishment has not even been
ship between somatoform dissociation and physical punish- rated as abusive (Pasquini et al., 2002). Physical (or corporal)
TABLE 4. Prevalence (%) and adjusteda relative risk of high somatoform dissociation (SDQ ⱖ30) according to sex and the
number of ACEs
Men (N ⫽ 733)d
0 5.1 1.00 (Reference)
1–3 10.9 2.03 (0.83–4.95) NS
4–6 19.4 .001 3.05 (1.11–3.36) .030
Women (N ⫽ 982)e
0 3.4 1.00 (Reference)
1–3 8.0 2.65 (1.16–6.04) .021
4–6 16.6 ⬍.001 5.43 (2.22–13.28) ⬍.001
a
Adjusted for age, marital status, place of residence, education, employment status, working ability, and financial situation.
b
p-Value for linear association.
c
p-Value compared with the reference category.
d
Missing cases because of incomplete data (N ⫽ 9).
e
Missing cases because of incomplete data (N ⫽ 15).
punishment is defined as the use of physical force with the lence of high somatoform dissociation was quite high, sug-
intention of causing a child to experience pain, but not injury, gesting that somatoform dissociative symptoms are rather
for the purpose of correction or control of the child’s behavior common at the population level. To compare our results with
(Straus, 2000). In Finland, physical punishment has been those of clinical studies is difficult. We found that men scored
criminalized, and we consider it abusive for the child. Phys- significantly higher than women in the SDQ, and the scores
ical punishment has been shown to increase a risk of the child increased with age, findings contrary to previous studies in
developing major social and psychological problems, such as which gender and age did not affect the SDQ scores (Nijen-
antisocial behavior (Straus et al., 1997), depression, and huis et al., 1996, 1998a). More men than women did not
alcoholism (Holmes and Robins, 1988). Physical punishment participate in the study, and the nonresponding men were
is also a risk factor for physical abuse (Straus, 2000). It can younger than the responding men, but no such difference was
be considered a long-term childhood adversity that exposes a found among women. This might have influenced the sex
child to recurrent experiences of pain and a threat to physical difference observed by raising the mean SDQ score among
well being. Somatoform dissociative symptoms can be un- men. There is also a possibility that older, less educated
derstood as adaptive responses to repeated episodes of phys- subjects could report more frequent somatic symptoms, and
ical punishment. this might also have influenced the results, although it has
Adverse childhood experiences other than physical been shown in a previous study that somatoform dissociation
punishment also revealed significant associations with high cannot be equated with a tendency to report physical com-
somatoform dissociation. A poor relationship between par- plaints (Nijenhuis et al., 1999). The oldest subjects in our
ents predicted high somatoform dissociation among men and sample were born just before and during World War II. The
parental alcohol abuse predicted it among women. It has been traumatization of World War I combat soldiers with an
found that children in alcoholic households are more likely to unprecedented incidence of somatoform dissociation disor-
suffer from other forms of ACEs, and depression among adult ders and symptoms has been studied (Van der Hart et al.,
children of alcoholics appears to be largely, if not solely, a 2000). The years during World War II were also a time of
result of the greater likelihood of having had ACEs in a home suffering and fear for civilians, including children. In this
with alcohol-abusing parents (Anda et al., 2002). In our respect, the high prevalence of somatoform dissociation in
study, women were more vulnerable to parental alcoholism, the elderly subjects could be partly a result of wartime
showing more somatoform dissociative symptoms in adult- traumatization. There was a similar trend with the sociode-
hood. According to our results, factors other than just a mographic factors to our results in a Turkish patient study
specific threat of physical injury also have implications for (Sar et al., 2000), in which a weak positive correlation
high somatoform dissociation. between high somatoform dissociation and older age was
To our knowledge, no previous studies have examined found, with negative correlations between high somatoform
somatoform dissociation in a general population. The preva- dissociation and education or socioeconomic status. In our
study, high somatoform dissociation associated bivariately suicide throughout the life span: Findings from the Adverse Childhood
Experiences study. JAMA. 286:3089 –3096.
with older age, unemployment, low education, a reduced Felitti VJ, Anda RF, Nordenberg D, Williamson DF, Spitz AM, Edwards V,
working ability, and a poor financial situation. Koss MP, Marks JS (1998) Relationship of childhood abuse and household
Earlier studies with different diagnostic patient groups dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults. The Adverse
gave some indications of the optimal cutoff point to identify Childhood Experiences (ACE) study. Am J Prev Med. 14:245–258.
Haatainen KM, Tanskanen A, Kylmä J, Honkalampi K, Koivumaa-
subjects in a general population with a significant level of Honkanen H, Hintikka J, Antikainen R, Viinamäki H (2003) Gender
somatoform dissociation. A higher cutoff point would prob- differences in the association of adult hopelessness with adverse childhood
ably have increased the specificity in discriminating subjects experiences. Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 38:12–17.
Higgins DJ, McCabe MP (2001) Multiple forms of child abuse and neglect:
with dissociative disorders, which is more appropriate for Adult retrospective reports. Aggress Violent Behav. 6:547–578.
selected patient samples (Yüsel et al., 2002). Holmes SJ, Robins LN (1988) The role of parental disciplinary practices in
The use of a random, general population-based sample the development of depression and alcoholism. Psychiatry. 51:24 –36.
Nemiah JC (1991) Dissociation, conversion and somatization. In A Tasman,
and a satisfactory response rate were strengths in our study. SM Goldfinger (Eds), American Psychiatric Press Review of Psychiatry
Clinical samples have often included mainly female subjects (Vol 10, pp 248 –260). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
(Nijenhuis et al., 1998a, 1998b; Waller et al. 2000), which Nijenhuis ERS (2000) Somatoform dissociation: Major symptoms of disso-
ciative disorders. J Trauma Dissoc. 1:7–29.
may give different results for associations between dissocia- Nijenhuis ERS, Spinhoven P, Van Dyck R, Van der Hart O, Vanderlinden J
tion and its risk factors. Another strength of our study was (1996) The development and psychometric characteristics of the Somato-
that we included multiple types of childhood adverse expe- form Dissociation Questionnaire (SDQ-20). J Nerv Ment Dis.184:688 –
riences, all assessed individually and in clusters. This design 694.
Nijenhuis ERS, Spinhoven P, Van Dyck R, Van der Hart O, Vanderlinden J
revealed a strong association between multiple ACEs and (1998a) Psychometric characteristics of the Somatoform Dissociation
high somatoform dissociation. Questionnaire: A replication study. Psychother Psychosom. 67:17–23.
Our method of assessing the ACEs may contain some Nijenhuis ERS, Spinhoven P, Van Dyck R, Van der Hart O, Vanderlinden J
(1998b) Degree of somatoform and psychological dissociation in disso-
weaknesses. Instead of asking only one question about each ciative disorder is correlated with reported trauma. J Trauma Stress.
of the ACEs, multiple questioning could have given more 11:711–730.
information on the nature of the relationships between single Nijenhuis ERS, Van Dyck R, Spinhoven P, Van der Hart O, Chatrou M,
Vanderlinden J, Moene F (1999) Somatoform dissociation discriminates
ACEs and somatoform dissociation. However, false-positive among diagnostic categories over and above general psychopathology.
answers to the questions concerning ACEs are unlikely, and Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 33:511–520.
we have more reason to believe underreporting took place, Pasquini P, Liotti G, Mazzotti E, Fassone G, Picardi A (2002) Risk factors
in the early family life of patients suffering from dissociative disorders.
because it might have been difficult to answer intimate
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 105:110 –116.
questions concerning family history. There is always a pos- Roelofs K, Keijsers GPJ, Hoogduin KAL, Näring GWB, Moene FC (2002)
sibility of recall bias in remembering and reporting childhood Childhood abuse in patients with conversion disorder. Am J Psychiatry.
experiences. A cross-sectional study design has its own 159:1908 –1913.
Ross CA, Heber S, Norton GR, Anderson G (1989) Somatic symptoms in
limitations, especially in giving theoretical explanations for multiple personality disorder. Psychosomatics. 30:154 –160.
the results. Our findings represent associations between vari- Ross CA, Miller SD, Reagor B, Bjornson L, Frazer GA, Anderson G (1990)
ables that are not necessarily causal relationships, and con- Structured interview data on 102 cases of multiple personality disorder
from four centers. Am J Psychiatry. 147:596 – 601.
clusions must be drawn with caution. Sar V, Kundakci T, Kiziltan E, Bakim B, Bozkurt O (2000) Differentiating
dissociative disorders from other diagnostic groups through somatoform
CONCLUSIONS dissociation in Turkey. J Trauma Dissoc. 1:67– 80.
Saxe GN, Chinman G, Berkowitz R, Hall K, Lieberg G, Schwartz J,
We found a graded, positive relationship between an Van der Kolk BA (1994) Somatization in patients with dissociative
increasing number of the ACEs and high somatoform disso- disorders. Am J Psychiatry. 151:1329 –1334.
ciation. There was a strong relationship between physical Straus MA (2000) Corporal punishment and primary prevention of physical
abuse. Child Abuse Negl. 9:1109 –1114.
punishment and high somatoform dissociation among both Straus MA, Sugarman DB, Giles-Sims J (1997) Spanking by parents and
men and women. Factors associated with family pathology subsequent antisocial behavior of children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.
were also significant, providing evidence of the complex 151:761–767.
issue of somatoform dissociation and ACEs. Somatoform Van der Hart O, Van Dijke A, Van Son M, Steele K (2000) Somatoform
dissociation in traumatized World War I combat soldiers: A neglected
dissociative symptoms should be assessed more often among clinical heritage. J Trauma Dissoc. 1:33– 66.
treatment-resistant patients with somatization in mental Van der Kolk BA, Pelcovitz D, Roth S, Mandel FS, McFarlane A, Herman
health care. JL (1996) Dissociation, somatization and affect dysregulation: The com-
plexity of adaptation to trauma. Am J Psychiatry. 153:83–93.
Waller G, Hamilton K, Elliott P, Lewendon J, Stopa L, Waters A, Kennedy
REFERENCES F, Lee G, Pearson D, Kennerley H, Hargreaves I, Bashford V, Chalkley J
Anda RF, Whitfield CL, Felitti VJ, Chapman D, Edwards VJ, Dube SR, (2000) Somatoform dissociation, psychological dissociation and specific
Williamson DF (2002) Adverse childhood experiences, alcoholic parents and forms of trauma. J Trauma Dissoc. 1:81–98.
later risk of alcoholism and depression. Psychiatr Serv. 53:1001–1009. Yüsel B, Özyalcin S, Sertel HÖ, Çamlica H, Ketenci A, Talu GK (2002)
Dube SR, Anda RF, Felitti VJ, Chapman DP, Williamson DF, Giles WH Childhood traumatic events and dissociative experiences in patients with
(2001) Childhood abuse, household dysfunction and the risk of attempted chronic headache and low back pain. Clin J Pain. 18:394 – 401.