17 Mar 2017 12464090376W7HDXBannexures

ANNEXURE I
DATA
SHEET
DATA SHEET
MONITORING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS

Ministry of Environmental and Forests
Regional Office, West Central Zone, Nagpur.
Monitoring Report
PART – I
DATA SHEET
1. Project type: river - valley/ mining/ Residential Project

Industry / thermal / nuclear/ Other
(specify)
2. Name of the project “VICINIA”

File No. : SEAC-2212/CR-398/TC-1
3. Clearance letter (s) / OM/ no and date:
Dtd. 18th July, 2016.
4. Location CTS No. 15A, 15C, 15D, 15E, 15F at village of
Chandivali, Kurla, Mumbai.
a. District (s) ---
b. State (s) Maharashtra.
c. Latitude / Longitude ---
5. Address for correspondence
a. Address of concerned project Chief Mr. Sreeram Kuppa.

Engineer (with pin code & telephone /
Address: Shapoorji Pallonji Real Estate, SP Center,
telex / fax number)
41/44, Minoo Desai Marg, Colaba, Mumbai-400005.
Tel. 022-67490283.
b. Address of Executive Project Engineer Mr. Yogesh Mulye (Project Head)

/Manager (with pin code / fax number)
Forbes Compound, Opp to BASF, Off Chandivali Farm
Road, Chandivali, Mumbai-400072
Tel. 022-28578387.
Half Yearly Post Monitoring Report (July, 2016 – December, 2016) Page 1
M/s. Forbes & Company Limited “VICINIA”
DATA SHEET
6. Salient features
Total Plot Area = 27,263.50 sq.mtrs.
a. of the project
As per FSI: 50,895.40 sq.m.
Non FSI: 44,473.09 sq.m.
Total construction Area: 95,368.49 sq.m.
Buildings and Configurations:
Wing Name Configuration
A,B,C,D 3B+Stilt+20 Flrs
E,F,G 3B+Stilt+21 Flrs
Club House G+1
b. of the environmental management plans 1. Sewage Treatment Plant:

Sewage Treatment Plant with total capacity 350
KLD will be provided for treating the wastewater.
Recycled wastewater will be used for Flushing,
gardening etc.
2. Water Management:
Rain Water Harvesting shall be provided to
recharge the ground water table.
3. Solid Waste Management:
• Dry waste: Handed over to authorize recycler.
• Wet waste: Shall be processed in the OWC.
• STP sludge: Shall be used as manure.
7. Break Up Of the project Area
a. Submerge area: forest & :non-forest Non Forest

Total Plot Area = 27,263.50 sq.mtrs.
b. Others
As per FSI: 50,895.40 sq.m.
Non FSI: 44,473.09 sq.m.
Total construction Area: 95,368.49 sq.m.
Break up of the project affected:
8. Not Applicable.
Population with enumeration of those
losing houses / dwelling units, only
agriculture land only, both dwelling units
and agriculture land and landless labourers
/ artisan
a. SC, ST / Adivasis: ----
DATA SHEET
b. Others ----
(Please indicate whether these figures are

based on any scientific and systematic
survey carried out or only provisional
figures, if a survey is carried out give details
and years of survey)
9. Financial details
a. Project cost as originally planned and Total cost: 382 Cr.

subsequent revised estimates and the year
of price reference
b. Allocation made for environmental Capital EMP Cost: 344.95 Lakhs

management plans with item wise and year
Cost for EMP O & M: 46.27Lakhs
wise break-up
c. Benefit cost ratio/ Internal rate of return -----

and the year of assessment
d. Whether ( c ) includes the cost of -----

environmental management as shown in
the above
e. Actual expenditure incurred on the project Rs. 24 Cr. (approx.)

so far
f. Actual expenditure incurred on the Rs. 4 Lakhs

environmental management plans so far
10. Forest land required
a. The status of approval for diversion of The land is of non-forest type hence not applicable.
forest land for non-forestry use
R.G. Area on the ground: 5589.13 Sq. mt.

b. The status of clearing and felling
A combination of native evergreen trees and
ornamental flowering trees, shrubs and palms are
planned in the complex. There will be tree plantation
of about 291 Nos. Different species will be selected
as per CPCB green belt guidelines and common
species available in the proposed area.
c. The status of compensatory afforestation, if
-----
any.
d. Comments on the viability & sustainability N.A.

of compensatory afforestation program in
DATA SHEET
the light of actual field experience so far.
11. The status of clear felling in non-forest N.A.

areas (such as submergence area of
reservoir, approach roads), if any with
quantitative information.
12. Status of construction
a. Date of commencement (Actual and/or 16.03.2016.

planned)
b. Date of completion (Actual and/ of ----

planned)
13. Reasons for the delay if the project is yet to N.A.

start
14. Dates of site visits
a. The date on which the project was -----

monitored by the regional office on
previous occasions, if any.
b. Date of site visit for this monitoring report 20.08.2016, 01.10.2016.

M/s. Forbes & Company Limited,
15. Details of correspondence with project
Address:
authorities for obtaining action plans/
Forbes Building, Charanjit Rai Marg,
information on status on compliance to
Fort, Mumbai-400001.
safeguards other than the routine letters for
logistic support for site visits.
File No.: SEAC-2212/CR-398/TC-1
Dtd. 18th July, 2016.
COMPLIANCE
REPORT
Compliance Report
COMPLIANCE REPORT
TERMS & CONDITIONS
1. This environmental clearance is issued subject to 1. Land use is for the residential purpose as
land use verification. Local authority / planning per the DP.
authority should ensure this with respect to Rules,
2. Planning authority has approved the
Regulations, Notifications, Government
same as per the prevailing DCR.
Resolutions, Circulars, etc. issued if any.
Judgments/orders issued by Hon’ble High Court, 3. Notifications and GR orders regarding
Hon’ble NGT, Hon’ble supreme court regarding RG, wildlife act etc. will be followed from
DCR provision, environmental issues applicable in time to time.
this matter should be verified. PP should submit
exactly the same plans appraised by concern SEAC
and SEIAA. If any discrepancy found in the plans
submitted or details provided in the above para
may be reported to environment department. This
environmental clearance issued with respect to the
environmental consideration and it does not mean
that State Level Impact Assessment Authority
(SEIAA) approved the proposed land use.
2. No services in the basement to be provided. No services like STP, OWC is proposed in

basement
3. One parking at the corner to be removed where the Parking at turning in all basements has been
vehicles are turning in all basements (where the removed in the revised layout.
ramp is turning) to improve the movement of
vehicles.
4. PP to avoid 2-wheeler parking in basement. 2-wheeler parking (78 nos.) is proposed in

proposed on ground
5. Electrical panel to be outside and pump room at Electrical panels and pump room is proposed
stilt level should be provided to avoid electrical on ground.
accident in the basement.
6. E-waste shall be disposed through Authorized Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
vendor as per E-waste (Management and the same.
Handling) Rules, 2011.
7. This environmental clearance is issued subject to As the site does not fall within the radius of
obtaining NOC from Forestry & Wild life angle Forestry & Wild life area and hence NOC is
including clearance from the standing committee notapplicable.
of the National Board for Wild life as if applicable &
this environmental clearance does not necessarily
implies that forestry & wild life clearance granted
to the project which will be considered separately
on merit.
8. PP has to abide by the conditions stipulated by All the conditions mentioned in the EC shall
M/s. Forbes & Company, “VICINIA”
Compliance Report
SEAC & SEIAA. be followed rigorously.
9. The height, Construction built up area of proposed The heights of buildings are accordance with
construction shall be in accordance with the DCR and FSI. Approval is already obtained.
existing FSI/FAR norms of the urban local body &
it should ensure the same before approving layout
plan & before according commencement certificate
to proposed work. ULB should also ensure the
zoning permissibility for the proposed project as
per the approved development plan of the area.
10. “Consent for Establishment” shall be obtained from Applied for the Consent to Establish from
Maharashtra pollution Control Board under Air MPCB.
and Water Act and a copy shall be submitted to the
Environment department before start of any
construction work at the site.
11. All required sanitary and hygienic measures should Mobile STP is provided in construction phase
be in place before starting construction activities and proper care regarding sanitary and
and to be maintained throughout the construction hygienic condition will be maintained
phase. throughout the construction phase.
General Conditions for Construction phase-
1 Provision shall be made for the housing of The provision for the construction labour
construction labour within the site with all within the site with all necessary
necessary infrastructure and facilities such as fuel infrastructure and facilities such as fuel for
for cooking, mobile toilets, mobile STP, safe cooking, mobile toilets, mobile STP, Safe
drinking water, medical health care, crèche and drinking water, medical health care, etc. is
First Aid room etc. made.
2 Adequate drinking water and sanitary facilities Adequate portable water facility for drinking
should be provided for construction workers at the purpose is provided for the workers at the
site. Provision should be made for mobile toilets. site during construction phase.
The safe disposal of wastewater and solid wastes
generated during the construction phase should be
ensured.
3 The solid waste generated should be properly The solid waste generated shall be properly
collected and segregated. Dry/insert solid waste collected and segregated. Dry/insert solid waste
should be disposed off to the approved sites for shall be disposed off to the approved sites for
land filling after recovering recyclable material. land filling after recovering recyclable material. In
order to avoid problems associated with solid
waste disposal problems, an effective solid waste
management system is followed by segregating
the wet and dry garbage and handover it to the
local authority for disposal.
4 Disposal of muck during construction phase should All construction waste is collected and
not create any adverse effect on the neighboring segregated properly. Most of that is reused
Compliance Report
communities and be disposed taking the necessary for the construction activity.
precautions for general safety and health aspects of
people, only in approved sites with the approval of
competent authority.
5 Arrangement shall be made that waste water and Covered sewage system has been proposed
storm water do not get mixed. which is connected to STP for the treatment
and reuse of the treated water. Excess
treated water shall be disposed off into the
sewer drain. Separate tanks for waste water
and storm water are being constructed.
6 All the topsoil excavated during construction Excavated soil is expected from the project
activities should be stored for use in horticulture / site is used for landscaping.
landscape development within the project site.
7 Additional soil for leveling of the proposed site There is no need of importing any soil from
shall be generated within the sites (to the extent outside.
possible) so that natural drainage system of the
area is protected and improved.
8 Green Belt Development shall be carried out • The green area will be approx.
considering CPCB guidelines including selection of 5589.13sq.m.
plant species and in consultation with the local
• A combination of native evergreen trees
DFO/Agriculture Dept.
and ornamental flowering trees, shrubs
and palms are planned in the complex.
• There will be tree plantation of about 291
nos.
• Plantation Details: Species will be selected
as per CPCB greenbelt guidelines and
common species available in the proposed
area.
9 Soil and ground water samples will be tested to Soil testing is done, according to the reports
ascertain that there is no threat to ground water all the parameters are within limit and so
quality by leaching of heavy metals and other toxic there is no threat to groundwater quality by
contaminants. leaching of heavy metals and other toxic
contaminants.
10 Construction Spoils, including bituminous material • There will be no generation of hazardous

and other hazardous materials must not be waste at site but proper care would be
allowed to contaminate watercourses and the taken following the norms to disposal of
dumpsites for such material must be secured so the bituminous and other hazardous
that they should not leach into the ground water. material at site.
• Also silt traps and other measures such as
additional on-site are constructed to
control surface Run-off.
11 Any hazardous waste generator during Paint & used oil would be generated from the
Compliance Report
construction phase should be disposed off as per site, will be disposed through authorized
applicable rules and norms with necessary vendor.
approvals of the Maharashtra pollution Control
Board.
12 The diesel generator sets to be used during About 100 KVA capacity DG set is used for
construction phase should be low sulphur diesel backup during construction phase. These are
type and should conform to Environments environment friendly make and provided
(Protection) Rules prescribed for air and noise with acoustic enclosure to avoid noise
emission standards. emission.
13 The diesel required for operating DG sets shall be The quantity is less than 2500 lits.
stored in underground tanks and if required, Permission of competent authority is not
clearance from concern authority shall be taken. applicable.
14 Vehicles hired for bringing construction material to The PUC checked/authorized vehicles are
the site should be in good condition and should allowed on the site for transfer of material.
have a pollution check certificate and should
conform to applicable air and noise emission
standards and should be operated only during non-
peak hours.
15 Ambient noise levels should conform to residential Following care is taken regarding noise levels
standards both during day and night. Incremental with conformation to the residential area.
pollution loads on the ambient air and noise
1. Use of well maintained equipment fitted
quality should be closely monitored during
with silencers.
construction phase. Adequate measures should be
made to reduce ambient air and noise level during 2. Noise shields near the heavy construction
construction phase, so as to conform to the operations are provided.
stipulated standards by CPCB/MPCB. 3. Construction activities are limited to
daytime hours only.
Also use of Personal Protective Equipment
(PPE) like ear muffs and ear plug during
construction activities.
16 Fly ash should be used as building material in the Yes, Ready mixed concrete (RMC) with fly
construction as per the provisions of Fly Ash ash gets used in the construction.
Notification of September 1999 and amended as on
27th August, 2003 (The above condition is
applicable only if the project site is located within
the 100Km of Thermal Power Stations).
17 Ready mixed concrete must be used in building Yes, RMC with fly ash gets used in the
construction. construction.
Compliance Report
18 The approval of competent authority shall be • Fire Fighting Designed: As per National
obtained for structural safety of the building due to Building Code 2005.
any possible earthquake, adequacy of fire fighting • Wet riser system to be provided in
equipment’s etc. as per National Building Code complex
including measures from lighting. • Adequate no. of hose cabinets shall be
provided at each level
• An external ring main with suitably placed
Yard hydrants will be laid around the
entire complex.
• The certificate of the structural engineer is
enclosed.
19 Storm water control and its re-use as per CGWB Rainwater from terraces and other open area
and BIS standards for various applications. will be diverted to recharge pits for ground
water recharge.
20 Water demand during construction should be RMC is being used regularly.

reduced by use of pre-mixed concrete, curing
agents and other best practices referred.
21 The ground water level and its quality should be The ground water levels and its quality are
monitored regularly in consultation with Ground monitored regularly.
water Authority.
22 The installation of the Sewage Treatment Plant STP will be provided to treat the waste
(STP) should be certified by an independent expert water. STP will be provided by established
and a report in this regard should be submitted to consultant and operation and maintenance
the Ministry before the project is commissioned for shall be done by the technical persons of
operation. Treated effluent emanating from STP consultant. MOU has done for the
shall be recycled / refused to the maximum extent maintenance.
possible. Treatment of 100% gray water by 01 No. of STP 350 KLD capacity will be
decentralized treatment should be done. Discharge provided.
of unused treated affluent shall conform to the
norms and standards of the Maharashtra Pollution
Control Board. Necessary measures should be
made to mitigate the odour problem from STP.
23 Permission to draw ground water and construction The ground water is not used for
of basement if any shall be obtained from the construction purpose; we use only tanker
competent Authority prior to water for construction.
construction/operation of the project.
24 Separation of gray and black water should be done Yes, Grey and black water are separated by
by the use of dual plumbing line for separation of the use of dual plumbing line.
gray and black water.
Compliance Report
25 Fixtures for showers, toilet flushing and drinking Adequate measures are taken into
should be of low flow either by use of aerators or consideration to minimize the wastage of
pressure reducing devices or sensor based control. water.
26 Use of glass may be reduced up to 40% to reduce Glazing area is maintained around 25% of
the electricity consumption and load on air- the façade area for the residential buildings.
conditioning. If necessary, use high quality double
glass with special reflective coating in windows.
27 Roof should meet prescriptive requirement as per • Roof insulation 50 mm expanded

Energy Conservation Building Code by using polystyrene or equivalent insulation.
appropriate thermal insulation material to fulfill
• Heat reflective double glazed glass
requirement.
provided on external façade for the
residential buildings.
27 Energy conservation measures like installation of • Reduction in basement lighting by 35% as

CFLs / TFLs for the lighting the areas outside the against IGBC Green home baseline of 0.23
building should be integral part of the project W/Sq.ft. Target LPD is 0.15 W/Sq.ft which
design and should be in place before project can be achieved through LEDs/CFL.
commissioning. Use CFLs and TFLs should be
• Reduction in Common is lighting by 40%
properly collected and disposed off/sent for
as against IGBC Green home baseline of
recycling as per the prevailing guidelines/rules of
0.37 W/Sq.ft. Target LPD is 0.22 W/Sq.ft
the regulatory authority to avoid mercury
which can be achieved through LEDs/CFL.
contamination. Use of solar panels may be done to
the extent possible like installing solar street lights, • Due to variable speed drive, proposed
common solar water heaters system. Project elevator can save approx. 30% of energy
proponent should install, after checking feasibility, as against sta
solar plus hybrid non-con ndard elevators.
ventional energy source as source of energy.
• Due to better envelope parameters (AAC
blocks, efficient glazing, and roof
insulation) as against IGBC Green home
parameters of concrete block wall and
non-insulated roof.
• Proposed Basement ventilation system
will have CO sensors.
Speed of jet fans will be controlled on
basis of CO levels. Thus we can save the
energy for Jet fan.
• As all proposed external lighting fixtures
will be operated on solar there won’t be
any energy consumption.
• Hot water through solar will be provided
for 580 Nos. of occupants which can save
us given amount of energy.
Compliance Report
28 Diesel power generating sets proposed as sources D.G. sets will be provided as back up for
of backup power for elevators and common area Residential buildings.
illumination during operation phase should be of
About 320 KVA (1No.), 250 KVA (1No.), and
enclosed type and conform to rules made under
750KVA (2 Nos.) capacities of DG Set shall be
the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. The
provided with silencer & acoustic enclosures.
height of stack of DG sets should be equal to the
The stacks shall be provided as per MPCB
height needed for the combined capacity of all
norms.
proposed GD sets. Use low sulphur diesel. The
location of the DG sets may be decided with in
consultation with Maharashtra Pollution Control
Board.
29 Noise should be controlled to ensure that it does • Construction equipment’s producing the
not exceed the prescribed standards. During most amount of noise are fitted with noise
nighttime the noise levels measured at the shields. This shield is a physical barrier
boundary of the building shall be restricted to the (Composed of brick and mud, with a non-
permissible levels to comply with the prevalent reflective internal plastering) approx. 3
regulations. mtrs. In height which is provide adequate
noise attenuation.
• Trees /species for noise abatement shall
be planted along the project boundary.
• Noisy construction equipment’s are not
permitted during night hours.
• Works employed in high noise areas are
rotated. Earplugs / muffs or other hearing
protective wear are provided to those
working very close to the noise generating
machinery.
• Anti-honking sign boards shall be placed
in the parking areas and on entry and exit
points.
• The site is barricaded by 6 meter height.
GI sheets all along the periphery for noise
mitigation purpose.
• This effect would be prominent during
30 Traffic congestion near the entry and exit points construction as well as operation phase. The
from the roads adjoining the proposed project site probability of inconvenience faced due to the
must be avoided. Parking should be fully frequency of truck movement during
internalized and no public space should be utilized. construction phase would be minimized by
better control of traffic movement in the area.
Noise levels expected from the planned
operating conditions have been assessed and
are likely to be within acceptable levels. The
impacts have been mitigated by the suggested
measures in the “air control and management
section”.
Compliance Report
• Anti-honking sign boards are placed in the

parking areas and on entry and exit point. The
project will be provided with sufficient road
facilities within the project premises and there
will be a large area provided for the parking of
vehicles.
• Traffic signage boards are displayed at every
chronic point.
31 Opaque wall should meet prescriptive requirement The building construction has been proposed
as per Energy Conservation Building Code, which is as per the NBC norms.
proposed to be mandatory for all air-conditioned
As per Energy Conservation Building Code
spaces while it is aspirational for non air-
Opaque wall to meet prescriptive
conditioned spaces by use of appropriate thermal
requirement by use of appropriate thermal
insulation material to fulfill requirement.
insulation material to fulfill requirement is
being done.
32 The building should have adequate distance The building has adequate distance between
between them to allow movement of fresh air and them to allow movement of fresh air and
passage of natural light, air and ventilation. natural light, Ventilation.
33 Regular supervision of the above and other Regular supervision done by our site
measures for monitoring should be in place all engineer to take care of the construction
through the construction phase, so as to avoid activity and of the surroundings.
disturbance to the surroundings.
34 Under the provisions of Environment (Protection) Environmental Clearance is already obtained.

Act, 1986, legal action shall be initiated against the
Applied for the Consent to Establish.
project proponent if it was found that construction
of the project has been started without obtaining
environmental clearance.
35 Six monthly monitoring reports should be Six monthly reports are submitted and
submitted to the department and MPCB. attached.
General Conditions for Post-construction/operation phase-
1 Project proponent shall ensure completion of STP, Condition noted.

MSW disposal facility, green belt developed prior
to occupation of the buildings. As agreed during
the SEIAA meeting, PP to explore possibility of
utilizing excess treated water in the adjacent area
for gardening before discharging it into sewer line
No physical occupation or allotment will be given
unless all above said environmental infrastructure
is installed and made functional including water
requirement in Para 2. Prior certification from
appropriate authority shall be obtained.
Compliance Report
2 Wet garbage should be treated by Organic Waste OWC will be installed/Shall be installed after
Converter and treated waste (manure) should be occupation as per the requirement.
utilized in the existing premises for gardening.
And, no wet garbage will be disposed outside the
premises. Local Authority should ensure this.
3 Local body should ensure that no occupation Condition noted.

certification is issued prior to operation of
STP/MSW site etc. with due permission of MPCB.
4 A complete set of all the documents submitted to A complete set of all the documents
Department should be forwarded to the MPCB. submitted to MPCB at the time of obtaining
consent to establish.
5 In the case of any change(s) in the scope of the Condition noted.

project, the project would require a fresh appraisal
by this Department.
6 A separate environment management cell with Separate environment management cell with
qualified staff shall be set up for implantation of qualified staff is formed and implementing
the stipulated environmental safeguards. the same.
7 Separate funds shall be allocated for EMP cost has been worked out and allocated
implementation of environmental protection for all air pollution devices and other
measures/ EMP along with item-wise breaks- up. facilities.
These cost shall be included as part of the project
cost. The funds earmarked for the environment
protection measures shall not be diverted for other
purposes and year-wise expenditure should
reported to the MPCB and this department.
8 The project management shall advertise at least in The advertisement is published in Marathi
two local newspapers widely circulated in the and English language local newspaper. In
region around the project, one of which shall be in Marathi newspaper ‘Navshakti’ dtd. 28th July
the Marathi language of the local concerned within 2016 & in English newspaper ‘Free Press
seven days of issue of this letter, informing that the Journal’ dtd. 28th July 2016 respectively
project has been accorded environmental Xerox copies of same are enclosed for your
clearance and copies of clearance letter are ready reference.
available with the Maharashtra Pollution Control
Also, the advertisement is displayed on
Board and may also be seen at Website at
website of company.
http:ec.maharashtra.gov.in.
9 Project management should submit half yearly We are submitting herewith six monthly
compliance reports in respect of the stipulated reports to Environment Department,
prior environmental clearance terms and Mantralaya & MPCB.
conditions in hard and soft copies to the MPCB and
this department, on 1st June and 1st December of
each calendar year.
Compliance Report
10 A copy of the clearance letter shall be sent by The PP comply the condition.
proponent to the concerned Municipal Corporation
and the local NGO, if any, from whom
suggestions/representations, if any, were received
while processing the proposal. The clearance letter
shall also be put on the website of the Company by
the proponent.
11 The proponent shall upload the status of Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
compliance of the stipulated EC conditions, the same.
including results of monitored data on their
website and shall update the same periodically. It
shall simultaneously be sent to the Regional Office
of MoEF, the respective Zonal Office of CPCB and
the SPCB. The criteria pollutant levels mainly; SPM,
RSPM, SO2, NOx (ambient levels as well as stack
emissions) or critical sector parameters, indicated
for the project shall be monitored and displayed at
a convenient location near the main gate of the
company in the public domain.
12 The project proponent shall also submit six Condition is noted and six monthly reports
monthly reports on the status of compliance of the are submitted to regional office of MoEF. We
stipulated EC conditions including results of are submitting herewith six monthly reports
monitored data (both in hard copies as well as by to environment department, Mantralaya &
email) to the respective Regional Office of MoEF, MPCB.
the respective Zonal Office of CPCB and the SPCB.
13 The environmental statement for each financial The PP shall comply the condition. Shall be
year ending 31st March in Form – V as is mandated followed as per the form-V.
to be submitted by the project proponent to the
concerned State Pollution Control Board as
prescribed under the Environment (Protection)
Rules, 1986, as amended subsequently, shall also
be put on the website of the company along with
the status of compliance of EC conditions and shall
also be sent to the respective Regional Offices of
MoEF by e-mail.
14 The environmental Clearance is being issued Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
without prejudice to the court case pending in the the same.
court of law and it does not mean that project
proponent has not violated any environmental
laws in the past and whatever decision of the
Hon`ble court will be binding on the project
proponent. Hence this clearance doesn’t not give
immunity to the project proponent in the case filed
against him, if any or action initiated under EP Act.
Compliance Report
15 In case of submission of false document and non Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
compliance of stipulated conditions, Authority/ the same.
Environment Department will revoke or suspend
the Environmental Clearance without any
intimation and initiate appropriate legal action
under Environmental Protection Act, 1986.
16 The Environment department reserves the right to Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
add any stringent condition or to revoke the the same.
clearance of conditions stipulated are not
implemented to the satisfaction of the department
or for that matter, for any other administrative
reason.
17 Validity of Environmental Clearance: The Condition is noted and the PP will validate it
environmental clearance accorded shall be valid once it expires.
for the period of 7 years.
18 In case of any deviation or alteration in the project Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
proposed from those submitted to this department the same.
for clearance, a fresh reference should be made to
the department to assess the adequacy of the
condition(s) imposed and to incorporate
additional environmental protection measures
required, if any.
19 The above stipulations would be enforced among Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
others under the Water (Prevention and Control of the same.
Pollution) Act, 1981, the Environment (Protection)
Act, 1986 and rules there under, Hazardous Wastes
(Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 and its
amendments, the public Liability Insurance Act,
1991 and its amendments.
20 Any appeal against this environmental clearance Yes, we noted the condition & agreeable to
shall lie with the National Green Tribunal, the same.
(Western Zone Bench, Pune) New administrative
Building, 1st Floor, D-wing, opposite council Hall,
Pune, if preferred, within 30 days as prescribed
under Section 16 of the National Green Tribunal
Act, 2010.
ENERGY
CONSERVATION
MEASURES
Energy Conservation Measures
ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES
Energy conservation program will be implemented through measures taken both on energy demand
and supply. It will be one of the focuses during the complex planning and operation stages.
SUPPLY ENERGY DEMAND

CONSERVATION
- Reduce consumption.
- Use energy– efficient appliances
- Create awareness.
The energy conservation efforts would consist of the following:
 Reduction in basement lighting by 35% as against IGBC Green home baseline of 0.23 W/Sq.ft.
Target LPD is 0.15 W/Sq.ft which can be achieved through LEDs/CFL
 Reduction in Common area lighting by 40% as against IGBC Green home baseline of 0.37 W/Sq.ft.
Target LPD is 0.22 W/Sq.ft which can be achieved through LEDs/CFL
 Due to variable speed drive, proposed elevator can save approx. 30% of energy as against standard
elevators
 Due to better envelope parameters (AAC blocks, efficient glazing, and roof insulation) as against
IGBC Green home parameters of Concrete block wall and non-insulated roof.
 Proposed Basement ventilation system will have CO sensors.
Speed of jet fans will be controlled on basis of CO levels. Thus we can save the energy for Jet fan.
 As all proposed external lighting fixtures will be operated on solar there won’t be any energy
consumption
 Hot water through solar will be provided for 580 Nos. of occupants which can save us given amount
of energy.
HALF YEARLY POST MONITORING
ENVIRONMENTAL REPORT
OF
“Residential Projects”
For
JULY, 2016 – DECEMBER, 2016.
Developer
M/S. FORBES & COMPANY LIMITED.

Forbes Building, Charanjit Rai Marg
Fort, Mumbai-400001.,
Prepared by
ENVIRO ANALYSTS & ENGINEERS P. LTD.,

ANNEXURE II
nd
22 Jan 15
ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT
FOR MOEF CLEARANCE
SPRE RESIDENTIAL TOWERS AT CHANDIVILI , MUMBAI

Prepared for
SPRE RESIDENTIAL TOWERS
CHANDIVALI,MUMBAI
Prepared by
AECOM India Pvt Ltd (Formerly Spectral)
Building Engineering - Sustainability Solutions Group
A-197, Sector 63, Noida 201 301, Uttar Pradesh
India
In association with
22nd Jan 2015
© AECOM
The information contained in this document produced by AECOM India Pvt Ltd is solely for the
use of the Client identified on the cover sheet for the purpose for which it has been prepared
and AECOM India Pvt Ltd undertakes no duty to or accepts any responsibility to any third party
who may rely upon this document.
All rights reserved. No section or element of this document may be removed from this
document, reproduced, electronically stored or transmitted in any form without the written
permission of AECOM Middle East Limited.
Quality Information
Document
10th
Ref Date Feb
Prepared by Anubahv Saxena Reviewed by Arpan Saha
Revision History
Authorised
Revision Revision Date Details Name/Position Signature
ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE: 22nd Jan 2015

AECOM
Contents
Executive Summary................................................................................................................................. i
1.0 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................... 1
2.0 SIMULATION RESULTS.............................................................................................................. 4
3.0 DETAILED ENERGY MODEL INPUT PARAMETERS ................................................................. 7
4.0 APPENDICES .................................................................................................................................. 9

AECOM
Executive Summary
This Energy simulation report is prepared by AECOM for SPRE Residential towers at Chandivali,Mumbai This
report is part of a process towards obtaining MOEF Clearance for multidwelling units. The specific objective of
this report is to evaluate annual energy usage for energy credits under the Energy Efficiency (EE) category.
It is determined via simulation that the project saves 12 % in Energy costs over the ECBC Basecase

1.0 INTRODUCTION
The ECBC Basecase building is simulated with actual orientation and again after rotating the entire building by
90,180 & 270 degrees and then averaging the results to get the Baseline Energy consumption. Following is the
point structure for Energy Performance.
The projects have been modeled using the e-QUEST energy analysis software. e-QUEST uses the DOE 2.2
Building energy simulation engine. It has the ability to explicitly model all of the following:
 8,760 hours per year
 Hourly variations in occupancy, lighting power, miscellaneous equipment power, thermostat set points and
HVAC system operation defined separately for each day of the week and holidays
 Thermal mass effects
 Part-load performance curves for mechanical equipment
 Capacity and efficiency correction curves for mechanical heating and cooling equipment.
ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE: 22nd January 2015 1

AECOM
Residential Towers at Chandivali is a multidwelling residential building located in Mumbai. The project has been
designed by architect M/S Kapadia Associates Pvt Ltd and built by M/s. Forbest & Company Ltd. It has a total
built up area of 12,67,677 ft2 approximately distributed in 8 towers of 21 Storeys plus 3 basements and the
overall window to wall ratio is approximately 45%.
Project View

AECOM
Representative plan showing typical detailed model zoning

AECOM
2.0 SIMULATION RESULTS
Basecase Energy Consumption: The Basecase model is based upon the proposed design, but the performance
parameters listed are defined to reflect the minimum efficiency levels that Annexure - I of ECBC system defines
for various building components. Based on the energy simulation results, it is observed that the averaged
basecase building consumes a total of 9319 MWh/yr.
ENERGY-USE COMPARISON FOR ALL END-USES
BASECASE (MWh)
10,000
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
BASE
0° 90° 180° 270°
CASE
COOLING 3410 3430 3393 3428 3415
HEATING 0 0 0 0 0
HOT WATER 250 250 250 250 250
FANS 1065 1075 1053 1073 1066
PUMPS 0 0 0 0 0
EXT. USAGE 21 21 21 21 21
EQUIPMENT 2865 2865 2865 2865 2865
LIGHTING 1702 1702 1702 1702 1702
TOTAL 9312 9342 9283 9338 9319
The primary energy end-uses are Cooling (38%) followed by equipment (32%), lighting (19%) and fans (12%), as
illustrated by the following charts. The results are as-expected for the warm & humid climate and building type
(Residential).
ENERGY-USE
CHARACTERIZATION
BASECASE (%)
18%
38%
32%
0.6% 12%
COOLING FANS
HEATING HOT WATER
PUMPS EXT. LIGHTING
EQUIPMENT LIGHTING

AECOM
Design Case Energy Consumption: In accordance with the above breakdown, the proposed design
incorporates a AAC block wall and an Solar PV cells catering two tubelights and 1 Ceiling Fan per dwelling unit
and 20% Solar hot water. These strategies offer the biggest potential for energy savings.Detailed performance
parameters for the design case are listed at the end of this report. Overall, the design case consumes a total of
8,217 MWh/yr.
ENERGY-USE COMPARISON FOR ALL

END-USES
BASECASE vs DESIGN CASE (MWh)
10,000
9,000
8,000
7,000
6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
BASECASE DESIGN CASE
COOLING 3,415 2,988
HEATING 0 0
FANS 1,066 1,101
HOT WATER 250 200
PUMPS 0 0
EXT. LIGHTING 21 10
EQUIPMENT 2,865 2,733
LIGHTING 1,702 1,185
TOTAL 9,319 8,217
ENERGY-USE CHARACTERIZATION
DESIGNCASE (%)
18%
38%
33%
0.6% 11%
COOLING FANS
HEATING HOT WATER
PUMPS EXT. LIGHTING
EQUIPMENT LIGHTING
ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE: 22nd January 2015

AECOM
Energy Cost Comparison: The design case shows annual utility cost savings of 12 % over the ECBC basecase.
The table below lists the costs related parameters

AECOM
3.0 DETAILED ENERGY MODEL INPUT PARAMETERS
DESIGN CASE ECBC BASECASE
EXTERIOR LOADS
Exterior
U-Value: Btu/hrft²⁰F U- 0.11 U- 0.07 (Appendix II)
Walls
Roof U-Value: Btu/hrft²⁰F U-0.20 U- 0.046
WINDOWS
Window Wall Ratio 45% 45% (Same as Design Case)
Frame Width N/A 1.3"
Frame U-Value :
N/A 2.38
Btu/hrft²⁰F
Glazing
U-Value :
1.00 0.58
Btu/hrft²⁰F
SC 0.62 0.3
VLT : % N/A Same as Design Case
SKY LIGHT
Shades Self-Shading N/A Yes
OTHER LOADS
Exterior
kW 9 6
Lighting
Elevator (kW) 140 kW (20 kW/lift) 109 kW (20 kW/lift)

Process
Loads 210 kW (Efficent water fixtures
STP/ Jockey
reduces the power consumtion
Pumps 270 kW
of pumps)
INTERNAL LOADS
Parking Area 0.3

0.15
(W/sqft)
Interior Lighting for
LPD,
Residential Units 0.7 0.7
Building Area
(W/sqft)
Method
Lighting for
Common Areas 0.22 0.37
(W/sqft)

AECOM
DESIGN CASE ECBC BASECASE
Daylight Perimeter areas

N/A N/A
Sensors only
Occupancy
Sensors N/A N/A
sensors
EPD (W/sqft) 1.0 Same as Design Case
Occupancy Sqft/Person 2 Person/Bedroom Same as Design Case
Fresh Air cfm/Person Same as Design Case 6.5 cfm/person
AIR SIDE HVAC SYSTEM
HVAC
System Type Split Units Split Units
System
0
For Cooling - 78.8 F
Setpoint Temp °F 0 Same as Basecase
For Heating – 68 F
For Cooling – 3.4 (5 Star ACs) For Cooling – 2.8
COP
For Heating – 2.5 For Heating – 2.5
Basement
CO Sensor Yes N/A
Parking
ACPH 10
10
Renewable 80 kW (Considering 2 tube None
Solar PV
Energy lights + 1 Fans)
Hot Water None
reruirement
50 MWh
Through
Solar

AECOM
APPENDIX- II
ENVELOPE DETAILS
Type-1: Exterior Wall Assembly: 200mm AAC block wall +15mm plaster
(Assembly U-value 0.11 Btu-Hr/Sqft-°F)
External Wall Construction

S.No. Material Thickness Resultant R
(inch) (F-sqft - hr / Btu)
1 Outside Air Film NA 0.17
2 Plaster 0.5 0.05
3 AAC Wall 8 8.16
5 Plaster 0.5 0.05
6 Inside Air Film NA 0.66
11 9.09
Assembly U value (btu/hr sqft deg F) 0.11
Roof Assembly: 20mm plaster+200 mm R.C.C Slab+ 50 mm Screed+ 50mm extruded polystyrene Insulation+
20mm Plaster. (Assembly U-value 0.09 Btu-Hr/Sqft-°F)
Fenestration Details:
Light
S. NO Shading U-Value
Glass Type 2 Transmittance
Coefficient (SC) (W/m -K)
(VLT, %)
1. ST 150 (Saint Gobain) 0.62 5.6 51%
ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE 06th August 2013 13

AECOM
Window Frame conductance for Design Case:

The frames are unlabeled and an area weighted frame width of 1.3 inches for each window is calculated for the
Design model. The frame conductance considered for evaluation is 1.8 Btu/h-sqft-F based on Aluminum Frame
without thermal break, fixed double glazed windows.The table below is taken from the ASHRAE Handbook of
Fundamental.

AECOM
APPENDIX- III
Details of Internal Loads:
Lighting power density

Equipment Fresh Air CFM
(W/sqft)
Occupancy power
Spaces
(person) density CFM
Base Proposed (W/sqft) ACH per
case Case
person
Bedroom 2 0.46 0.46 1 - 6.5
Living Room 2bhk 4 0.46 0.46 1 - 6.5

Living Room 3bhk 5 0.46 0.46 1 - 6.5
Toilet 0 0.46 0.46 0 - -
Kitchen 1 0.46 0.46 1 - -
Lobby 0 0.37 0.22 0 - -
Parking 0 0.23 0.15 0 10 -

AECOM
Hot water Calculation for basecase
Domestic Hot Water Consumption

Hot water requirment 25 liters/persons/day
Number of Hours 2 Hrs/day
Months of Uses 4 Months
Total Number of Hrs uses 240 Hrs/Year
Total number of Persons 2870 Persons
Per day requirment 71750 liters/day
Hot water through Solar (20%) 14350 Litres/day from Solar
Flow rate 597.9166667 liter/min (Assming uniform flow)
Flow rate 157.9700572 gal/min
Tank Storage requirment 18956 gal
Temperature water input 25 °C

Temperature outlet 50 °C
Specific heat of water 4.18 kJ/ kgK
Approximate Electric Heating 7497875000 Joules/day
2082.743056 kWh/day
Balance energy consumption for Solar 249929.1667 kWh/Year
200 MWh/Year
Seconds in day 7200

Hours in a day 2
Flow rate (L/min) 597.9166667 Litres/min
Flow rate 9.965277778 L/sec
Q 1041 Kw
No of days in year 120
Total hours in a year 240
Total energy consumption 249929 Kwh
Balance energy consumption for Solar 200 Mwh
PERCENTAGE BY SOLAR 20%

Saving of Energy Through Solar Hot water 50 MWh/Year
Total No of Solar hot water Panels 115 Panels
Total Area required for Solar hot water Panels 253 m2

AECOM
SOLAR PANELS SUMMARY

No of Flats Solar Panels Per Tower (kW) Space Req per Tower m2 No of Solar Panels
Tower A 40 5.6 67.2 22
Tower B 40 5.6 67.2 22
Tower C 84 11.76 141.12 47
Tower D 84 11.76 141.12 47
Tower E 82 11.48 137.76 46
Tower F 82 11.48 137.76 46
Tower G 82 11.48 137.76 46
Tower H 80 11.2 134.4 45
Total 574 80.36 964.32 321
TOWER A+ B (FLAT POINT-2 TUBE +1 FAN)

Solar Power Generation
Total Demand Load Requirement for Proposed development is 11.20 KW
Total Working Days in year Considered is 365 Days
Total Working Hrs Per Day 12.0 Hrs
Annual Energy Consumption is 49056 KWhr/year
As per information received from vendor - Each 1KWp capacity of solar

panels can generate avearge 1400KWh units annually.
35.04 KWp
Hence 35.04 kW is the estimated Solar Power requirement.

AECOM
TOWER C+D+E+F+G+H (FLAT POINT-2 TUBE +1 FAN)

Solar Power Generation
Total Demand Load Requirement for Proposed

development is 69.16 KW
Total Working Days in year Considered is 365 Days
Total Working Hrs Per Day 12.0 Hrs
Annual Energy Consumption is 302921 KWhr/year
As per information received from vendor - Each 1KWp

capacity of solar panels can generate avearge 1400KWh
units annually. 216.372 KWp
Hence 216.37 kW is the estimated Solar Power requirement.

AECOM

AECOM
Hot water Calculation for Designcase
Domestic Hot Water Consumption

Hot water requirment 25 liters/persons/day
Number of Hours 2 Hrs/day
Months of Uses 4 Months
Total Number of Hrs uses 240 Hrs/Year
Total number of Persons 574 Persons
Per day requirment 14350 liters/day
Flow rate 119.5833333 liter/min (Assming uniform flow)
Flow rate 31.59401145 gal/min
Tank Storage requirment 3791 gal
Temperature water input 25 °C

Temperature outlet 50 °C
Specific heat of water 4.18 kJ/ kgK
Approximate Electric Heating 1499575000 Joules/day
416.5486111 kWh/day
Annual Electric consumption 49985.83333 kWh/Year
50 MWh/Year
Seconds in day 7200

Hours in a day 2
Flow rate (L/min) 119.5833333 Litres/min
Flow rate 1.993055556 L/sec
Q 208 Kw
No of days in year 120
Total hours in a year 240
Total energy consumption 49986 Kwh
Total energy consumption 50 Mwh

AECOM
A-197, Sector – 63, NOIDA, UP - 201301
T +120 4049000 F +120 4049001
www.aecom.com
Effective 29 August, 2012, Spectral
Services Consultants Private Limited has
merged with AECOM India Private
Limited (AECOM). AECOM is a global
provider of professional technical and
management support services to a broad
range of markets, including
transportation, facilities, environmental,
energy, water and government. More
information on AECOM, visit
http://www.aecom.com
To enhance and
sustain the world’s
built, natural and
social environments
AECOM
A-197, Sector – 63, NOIDA, UP - 201301
T +120 4049000 F +120 4049001
www.aecom.com
Effective 29 August, 2012, Spectral
Services Consultants Private Limited has
merged with AECOM India Private
Limited (AECOM). AECOM is a global
provider of professional technical and
management support services to a broad
range of markets, including
transportation, facilities, environmental,
energy, water and government. More
information on AECOM, visit
http://www.aecom.com
To enhance and
sustain the world’s
built, natural and
social environments

17 Mar 2017 12464090376W7HDXBannexures

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

17 Mar 2017 12464090376W7HDXBannexures

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

ANNEXURE I

MONITORING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL SAFEGUARDS

1. Project type: river - valley/ mining/ Residential Project

2. Name of the project “VICINIA”

a. District (s) ---

b. State (s) Maharashtra.

c. Latitude / Longitude ---

5. Address for correspondence

a. Address of concerned project Chief Mr. Sreeram Kuppa.

b. Address of Executive Project Engineer Mr. Yogesh Mulye (Project Head)

Wing Name Configuration

A,B,C,D 3B+Stilt+20 Flrs

E,F,G 3B+Stilt+21 Flrs

Club House G+1

b. of the environmental management plans 1. Sewage Treatment Plant:

7. Break Up Of the project Area

a. Submerge area: forest & :non-forest Non Forest

(Please indicate whether these figures are

a. Project cost as originally planned and Total cost: 382 Cr.

b. Allocation made for environmental Capital EMP Cost: 344.95 Lakhs

c. Benefit cost ratio/ Internal rate of return -----

d. Whether ( c ) includes the cost of -----

e. Actual expenditure incurred on the project Rs. 24 Cr. (approx.)

f. Actual expenditure incurred on the Rs. 4 Lakhs

10. Forest land required

R.G. Area on the ground: 5589.13 Sq. mt.

d. Comments on the viability & sustainability N.A.

the light of actual field experience so far.

11. The status of clear felling in non-forest N.A.

12. Status of construction

a. Date of commencement (Actual and/or 16.03.2016.

b. Date of completion (Actual and/ of ----

13. Reasons for the delay if the project is yet to N.A.

14. Dates of site visits

a. The date on which the project was -----

b. Date of site visit for this monitoring report 20.08.2016, 01.10.2016.

2. No services in the basement to be provided. No services like STP, OWC is proposed in

4. PP to avoid 2-wheeler parking in basement. 2-wheeler parking (78 nos.) is proposed in

SEAC & SEIAA. be followed rigorously.

General Conditions for Construction phase-

10 Construction Spoils, including bituminous material • There will be no generation of hazardous

20 Water demand during construction should be RMC is being used regularly.

27 Roof should meet prescriptive requirement as per • Roof insulation 50 mm expanded

27 Energy conservation measures like installation of • Reduction in basement lighting by 35% as

• Anti-honking sign boards are placed in the

34 Under the provisions of Environment (Protection) Environmental Clearance is already obtained.

General Conditions for Post-construction/operation phase-

1 Project proponent shall ensure completion of STP, Condition noted.

3 Local body should ensure that no occupation Condition noted.

5 In the case of any change(s) in the scope of the Condition noted.

ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES

SUPPLY ENERGY DEMAND

The energy conservation efforts would consist of the following:

JULY, 2016 – DECEMBER, 2016.

M/S. FORBES & COMPANY LIMITED.

ENVIRO ANALYSTS & ENGINEERS P. LTD.,

SPRE RESIDENTIAL TOWERS AT CHANDIVILI , MUMBAI

22nd Jan 2015

Prepared by Anubahv Saxena Reviewed by Arpan Saha

Revision Revision Date Details Name/Position Signature

ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE: 22nd Jan 2015

ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE: 22nd Jan 2015

ENERGY SIMULATION REPORT DATE: 22nd Jan 2015