Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Company Law
MACMILLAN LAW MASTERS
Series Editor: Marise Cremona
Business Law (2nd edn) Stephen Judge
Company Law (3rd edn) Janet Dine
Constitutional and Administrative Law (3rd edn) John Alder
Contract Law (4th edn) Ewan McKendrick
Conveyancing (3rd edn) Priscilla Sarton
Criminal Law (2nd edn) Jonathan Herring and Marise Cremona
Employment Law (3rd edn) Deborah J. Lockton
Environmental Law and Ethics John Alder and David Wilkinson
Evidence Raymond Emson
Family Law (2nd edn) Kate Standley
Housing Law and Policy David Cowan
Intellectual Property Law (2nd edn) Tina Hart and Linda Fazzani
Land Law (3rd edn) Kate Green
Landlord and Tenant Law (4th edn) Margaret Wilkie and Godfrey Cole
Law of the European Union (2nd edn) Jo Shaw
Law of Succession Catherine Rendell
Law of Tntsts Patrick McLoughlin and Catherine Rendell
Legal Method (3rd edn) Ian McLeod
Legal Theory Ian McLeod
Social Security Law Robert East
Torts (2nd edn) Alastair Mullis and Ken Oliphant
Company Law
Third edition
Janet Dine
Professor of Law
University of Essex
~
MACMILLAN
© Janet Dine 1991, 1994, 1998
All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of
this publication may be made without written permission.
No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or
transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with
the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988,
or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying
issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court
Road, London W1P 9HE.
Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this
publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil
claims for damages.
Published by
MACMILLAN PRESS LTD
Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS
and London
Companies and representatives
throughout the world
ISBN 978-0-333-71095-1 ISBN 978-1-349-14583-6 (eBook)
DOI 10.1007/978-1-349-14583-6
A catalogue record for this book is available
from the British Library.
10 9 8 7 6 5 4
07 06 05 04 03 02 01 00
v
Contents
Preface xiii
Table of Cases xiv
Table of Statutes and Directives xxiii
2 Starting a company 9
2.1 Limited and unlimited companies 9
2.2 Public and private companies 10
2.3 Minimum capital requirements for a public
company 11
2.4 Change of status from public to private company
and vice versa II
2.5 Groups 12
2.6 The memorandum of association and registration 13
2.7 Incorporation 15
2.8 Duty of Registrar 15
2.9 Off-the-shelf companies 16
Summary 16
Casenotes 17
Exercises 19
3 Corporate personality 20
3.1 The legal basis for the separate personality doctrine 20
3.2 Problems caused by the personality doctrine and
exceptions 26
3.3 Statutory intervention 27
3.4 Lifting the veil 27
3.5 Fraud 29
3.6 Groups 30
3.7 The criminal and civil liabilities of companies 37
3.8 What crimes? 38
3.9 Why convict companies? 38
VI Contents
6 Promoters 78
6.1 Who are promoters? 78
6.2 Duties of promoters 79
6.3 Disclosure 80
Contents vii
14 Shares 259
14.1 Ordinary shares 259
14.2 Preference shares 260
14.3 Voting rights 261
14.4 The exercise of voting powers 263
14.5 Variation of class rights 264
14.6 Class meetings 269
14.7 Alteration of articles to insert a variation clause 270
14.8 Statutory right to object 270
Summary 271
Exercises 271
Preface
In accordance with the intentions behind the Mastering Law series, this
book is intended as an introduction to the basic principles of company
law. Like the other books in the series the book contains features designed
to help those studying this subject for the first time. These include
casenotes at the end of most chapters which give a short account of the
facts and decisions in key cases. A number of points for further
consideration are included in the exercises at the end of each chapter. In
addition an attempt has been made to state the law in clear and simple
terms. I hope it has succeeded.
JANET DINE
Table of Cases
Dafen Tiknplate Co. Ltd v. Llanelly Steel Co. (1907) Ltd [1920]
2 Ch 124 65-6
Daimler v. Continental Tyre Co. [1916] AC 308 37
Daniels v. Daniels [1978] Ch 406 243, 2549
DHN Food Distributors v. Tower Hamlets Borough Council
[1976]1 WLR 852 35
Dimbula Valley (Ceylon) Tea Co. v. Laurie [1961] Ch 353 266
Dorchester Finance Co. Ltd v. Stebbing [1989] BCLC 498 185
Dovey v. Cory [1901] AC 477 184
DPP v. Kent and Sussex Contractors Ltd [1944] KB 146 39
xvi Table of Cases
National Dock Labour Board v. Pinn & Wheeler & Others [1989]
BCLC 647 35
Nelson v. James Nelson & Sons Ltd [1914] 2 KB 770 63, 146, 149
Neptune (Vehicle Washing Equipment) Ltd v. Fitzgerald [1995]
1 BCLC 352 27
New British Iron Company, Ex Parte Beckwith [1898] 1 Ch 324 62, 145
New Bullas Trading Ltd [1993] BCC 251 275
Newhart Developments Ltd v. Co-operative Commercial Bank Ltd
[1978] QB 814 304
North West Transportation v. Beatty (1887) 12 App.Cas 589 139
Nurcombe v. Nurcombe [1985] 1 AllER 65 240, 254
s.l2 I5
s.l3 I5
s.l4 58-9, 6I, 62
s.l6 63
s.l7 55, 267
s.l7(2)(b) 267
s.23 126, 262
s.25(1) IO, I4
s.25(2) I4
s.26 I4
s.26(I)(c) I4
s.29 I4
s.35 45, 48, 55, 72, 237, 24I, 328
s.35(A) 70, 7I, 72
s.35(A)(I) 7I
s.35(A)(2)(a) 7I
s.35(A)(2)(b) 72
s.35B 70
s.35(I) 46
s.35(2) 46
s.35(3) 46,47
s.36C 82
s.43 II
s.47(2) 11
s.47(5) I2
s.53 II
s.54 I2
s.54(5) I2
s.60(I) 84
s.60(4) 84
s.60(5) 84
s.80 86, I34, 268, 269
s.8I IO, 84
ss.89-96 85, 86
s.95 86
s.97 97
s.IOI 11
s.l11A 69, 92
s.II7 II, 304
s.II8 11
s.l25 63-4, 137, 265-7, 27I
s.I25(2) 269
s.I23(3) 268, 269
s.125(4) 268, 269
s.l25(6) 269
s.I25(7) 269
s.I27 270
s.I30(2) 117
Table of Statutes and Directives xxv
s.328 232
s.330 203, 234-5
s.330(2) 203
s.331(4) 204
s.334 204
s.336 204
s.337 204
s.338 204
s.339 204
s.346 144, 203
s.348-9 14
s.364 203
s.366 134
s.366(4) 134
s.368 135
s.369 136, 137, 269
s.369(4) 137
s.370 269
s.370(4) 137
s.370(6) 261
s.371 135, 137
s.372(1) 132
s.373 133
s.376 136, 269
s.377 269
s.378(1) 137
s.378(2) 137
s.379 136
s.379A 133
s.381 140
s.381(A) 133
s.381(B) 133
s.382(A) 133
s.391 133
s.395(2) 280
s.396(1) 280
s. 396(1 )(a) 281
s.396(1)(c) 281
s.396(1)(d) 282
s.396(1)(e) 282
s. 396(1 )(g) 282
s.396(2)(a) 281
s.396(2)(b) 281
s.396(2)(c) 281
s.396(2)(d) 281
s.396(2)(e) 282
s.396(2)(t) 281, 282
s.396(2)(g) 281
xxviii Table of Statutes and Directives
s.396(4) 282
s.397 284
s.397(3) 288
s.397(5) 284
s.398 285
s.398(1) 283
s.398(4) 284
s.399 286
s.399(1) 285, 286
s.399(2) 285
s.399(3) 285
s.400 286
s.400(2) 286
s.401 286
s.402 286
s.402(4) 287
s.402(5) 287
s.402(6) 287
s.403 287
s.403(3) 287
s.407(1) 285
s.410 277, 283
s.414(4) 283
s.415(2) 284
s.416 284
s.416(1) 284
s.416(2) 284
s.419(1) 280
s.419(5) 285
s.420 280, 282
s.425 125, 267, 293, 294-5, 298
s.426 293
s.427 293
s.428 292
s.429 292
s.429(1) 292
s.429(3) 293
s.430 292
s.430(C) 292
s.431(2)c 251
s.432(1) 251
s.432( 1)(b) 251
s.436 252
s.438 252
s.440 252
s.441(1) 252
s.447 252
s.448 252
Table of Statutes and Directives XXIX
s.449 252
s.450 252
s.451 252
s.452 252
s.458 309
s.459 41, 67, 91, 182, 244, 246-50, 258, 295, 302
s.459(2) 91, 247
s.460 91
s.461 91, 248
s.464(1) 278
s.464(4) 278
s.691 287, 288
s.703A-N 287
s.703D(l) 288
s.703D(2) 288
s.703D(3) 288
s.703L(l) 288
s.711A 44, 70
s.711A(l) 284
s.711A(4) 284
s.714 14
s.719 5, 8
s.736 12, 13, 130
s.736(A) 130
s. 736( 1)(a )(ii) 12
s.741 142, 143
Companies Act 1987
s.727 197, 201-2
Companies Act 1989 13, 43, 44, 69, 74, 276, 280, 289, 330
Part I 128
Schedule I 129
Schedule 15 287
s.3 128
s.l08 328
s.ll2(3) 45
s.ll3 133
s.ll6 133
s.l31 91-2
s.l33 117
s.l45 244, 248
s.322A 45
Companies and Business Names Regulations 1981 18-19
Companies (Single Member Private Limited Companies)
Regulations 1992, SI 1992/1699 6, 304, 332
Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986 Ill, 148, 185, 187,
188, 258
s.2 205
s.3 205, 206
xxx Table of Statutes and Directives
s.3(2) 206
s.3(3) 206
s.4 205, 206
s.4(1)(a) 206
s.4(1 )(b) 206
s.5 205, 206
s.6 41, 187, 199, 205, 207, 208, 215, 216
s.6(2) 207
s.6(4) 187, 205
s.8 196, 217
Company Securities (Insider Dealing) Act 1985 218
s.2 220
s.3 223
s.9 220
Criminal Justice Act 1993 218, 347
Part V 218
s.lO 219
s.52 221
s.52(2) 223
s.52(2)(a) 221
s.52(2)(b) 222
s.52(3) 222
s.53 222
s.53(3) 222
s.53(b) 222
s.54(2) 218-19
s.55 221
s.56 219
s.57 219, 220, 221
s.57(1)(b) 219
s.58 219
s.62 223
s.63 223
Regulation 4(1) 94
Schedule 12 292
s.l 98
s.1(2) 99
s.l (3) 100
s.3 97-9, 99, 101
s.4 101
s.5 101
s.35 101
s.42 101
s.43 101
s.47 91, 101-2
s.48 223
s.60 102
s.61 102, 103
s.62 102, 103
s.62A 102
s.146 87, 88, 89, 91
s.l46(2) 89
s.l46(3) 89
s.147 87, 89
s.l50 87, 88
s.150(1) 89
s.l51 89,90
s.l51(2) 89, 90
s.l51(4) 90
s.l52 90
s.l59 93
s.160 93
S.l68(8) 91
Schedule 1 98-100
Part I 99
Part II 99
Part III 99
Part IV 100, 101
Schedule 2 101
Schedule 3 101
Ch. V 101-2
Ch. IX 102
Financial Services Act 1999 97
s.2 207
s.2(2) 303
s.3 207
s.4 207
s.5 207
s.6 207
s.6(1) 303
s.7 207
s.8 207
s.8(1) 297
s.9(1) 298
s.9(2) 299
s.9(3) 300
s.9(4) 299
s.10 300
s.11(1) 300
s.14(1 )(b) 301
s.14(4) 300
s.17 301
s.l8 302
s.21 300
s.23 301
s.24 302
s.24(5) 301
s.27 302
s.42(1) 304
s.84 137, 305
s.89 305
s.94 312
s.95 306
s.96 306
s.107 305, 306
s.110 125, 294, 295
s.111 294, 295
s.122(1 )(g) 249
s.l23 297, 298
s.l24 302
s.l24A 305
s.125(2) 249, 250
s.129(1A) 306
s.143 306
s.l65 137
s.l75 306
s.201 312
s.205 312
s.212 186, 310, 312
s.213 309
s.214 41, 186, 308
Table of Statutes and Directives xxxv
s.214(2) 310
s.214(5) 311
s.216 14
s.238 111, 306, 307
s.239(4)(B) 307
s.239 307, 308
s.241 307
s.241(1A) 307
s.244 308
s.245 309
s.249 309
s.251 283, 309
s.386 306, 315-18
s.390(1) 306
s.423 308
s.435 309, 318-19
s.651 312
s.642 312
Insolvency (No. 2) Act 1994 307
Insolvency Rules 1986
r.1.20(1) 303
r.2.1(2) 298
r.2.1 (3) 298
r.2.28(1) 302
r.2.4(2) 299
r.2.9 299
r.2.10 300
Stock Exchange (Listing) Regulations 1984 (SI 1984 No. 716) 87, 88, 95
s.5 88