Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Parking Lecture
Parking Lecture
site
program
dimension
function
type
material
idea
site
program
dimension
function
type
material
idea
parking garage
one additional
function
etymology
“park“ the placing of gun carriages parallel to one onother in both battle
and parade formations
T H E P A R K I N G G A R A G E P H E N O M E N O N
WHERE
the phenomenon was born mainly in America and in Europe (Paris)
Europe → just few buildings, that had to carry the meaning of being the example and the paradox of
the “new” architecture, of the modernity
• history
WHEN
• history
Parking garages are relative newcomers to the urban scene
obviously was born after the car invention
↓ ↓
↓ ↓
↓
new constructions
and materials → stout interior pillars of reinforced concrete were necessary
for bearing the great loads combining upper floors plus vehicles
- columns and walls between every second parking stall
- the width of a parking stall was typically 2.15 m
- facade echoed impressive apartments, emporiums buildings
or mainly civil buildings
The Automobile club of America
3 buildings, New York, 1908-1915
Parking in La Salle street
Chicago, 1918
Holabird e Root
1920s-1940s → the Great Depression, World war II
1920s-1940s → the Great Depression, World war II
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
↓
“the bigger is better” syndrome became popular and many cars increased in size.
1945-1965 → big boom in garage construction
↓
“the bigger is better” syndrome became popular and many cars increased in size.
↓
the capacity of early garage having columns every three parking spaces was
not appropriate anymore
1945-1965 → big boom in garage construction
↓
“the bigger is better” syndrome became popular and many cars increased in size.
↓
the capacity of early garage having columns every three parking spaces was
not appropriate anymore
↓
construction innovations
- clear-span system (no columns within parking bays)
- pre-stressed concrete
- lower ceiling heights → lower ramp grades
- steel skeleton structures
- open deck construction rendered unnecessary some elements :
windows, ventilation, 10% costs of fire encasement and much artificial lightning
1945-1965 → big boom in garage construction
↓
“the bigger is better” syndrome became popular and many cars increased in size.
↓
the capacity of early garage having columns every three parking spaces was
not appropriate anymore
↓
construction innovations
- clear-span system (no columns within parking bays)
- pre-stressed concrete
- lower ceiling heights → lower ramp grades
- steel skeleton structures
- open deck construction rendered unnecessary some elements :
windows, ventilation, 10% costs of fire encasement and much artificial lightning
greater attention to internal traffic flow, to design of ramps and to rapid handling
of both entering and exiting traffic
- enclosing walls were eliminated to save cost and to provide better ventilation and
visibility - it was possible also because car batteries improved
↓
construction
- concept of long clear-span without cumbersome interior columns
- pre-stressed concrete and cast-in-place post tensioning became
as common as precast system
- clear span of 18.30 m became the standard for parking bays
from the middle of 1960 → 4 principal components:
- open deck
- sloped floors
- self parking
- clear-span construction
construction
- concept of long clear-span without cumbersome interior columns
- pre-stressed concrete and cast-in-place post tensioning became
as common as precast system
- clear span of 18.30 m became the standard for parking bays
construction
- concept of long clear-span without cumbersome interior columns
- pre-stressed concrete and cast-in-place post tensioning became
as common as precast system
- clear span of 18.30 m became the standard for parking bays
↓
parking designed specifically for small cars can reach a gain in capacity of 15%-25%
WHY
reasons of the parking introduction
1920s - when car became available for the masses across all class barriers
↓
the increase of cars caused a general caos situation
• widing streets
• land costs increase because of the Great Depression and of the World War II
→ only one level parking started to be too expensive
multilevel parking building as a solution
• parking categories
• parking categories
• suburban
parking categories
• self parking
• attendant parking
parking categories
• parking categories
• traditional parking
• mechanical parking
parking garage typologies
• mechanical parking
parking garage typologies
- horizontal system
- vertical system
- horizontal + vertical
system
Autotower, Wolfsburg 1994
Henn Architekten
parking garage, New Haven, 1960
Paul Rudolph
underground parking, Place Vendome, Paris
1991
HOW
• parking categories
↓
↓
↓
- some activities were not anymore a downtown domain, but they started to move to suburbia.
(like department stores, movie theaters, hotels, medical services, middle class residential)
- most of the new garages were positioned close to wealthy residential districts or new quartiers
with the event of car culture city were decentralizing
↓
↓
- some activities were not anymore a downtown domain, but they started to move to suburbia.
(like department stores, movie theaters, hotels, medical services, middle class residential)
- most of the new garages were positioned close to wealthy residential districts or new quartiers
↓
they made to sprawl outward at city margins, in part through accommodation of parking need
special use parking facilities
special use parking facilities → operating 24 hours a day, 365 days a year
hospitals, hotels, airports…
special use parking facilities → operating 24 hours a day, 365 days a year
hospitals, hotels, airports…
↓
shopping center
- regulate continuous in and out traffic
- much daily turnover
Towers for people and cars, Chicago 1964
Bertrand Goldberg
New Haven 1965
Roche Dinkeloo
PARKING GARAGE ORGANIZATION
PARKING GARAGE ORGANIZATION
• circulation
• construction
• capacity
PARKING GARAGE ORGANIZATION
• circulation
• construction
• capacity
• entrances - larger parking facilities sholud have more than one entarnce and exit
- is generally more convenient to enter from one-way street or
by turning right from a two way street
- entrances must be designed to be obvious and not to be confused with the exits.
- where a parking facilities is adjacent to a high-velocity street a deceleration lane can help
• stairs - one stairway located adjacent to elevator tower, in case the elevator is not operating
- at least 2 fire exit stairs, depending on maximum travel distance
(in open-deck parking structure a travel distance is 60 m)
• economical efficiency
• comfort
- two-bay split-level provides poor traffic circulation and higher structural costs because its
geometry required special ramps
- ramps system used by infrequent parker (convention centers, hospitals) should be kept as simple as
possible
Parking in 60 East Lake Street, Chicago
Tigermann, Fugmann, Mc Curry
circular or spiral ramps
• most common type: double threaded, each complete turn → two parking levels
• circulation
• construction
• capacity
construction methods to produce the most economic solutions
construction methods to produce the most economic solutions
later
construction methods to produce the most economic solutions
1950-1960
construction methods to produce the most economic solutions
→ slab-beam-girder system
→ slab-beam-girder system
• single “T”
cast-in-place concrete with post-tensioning
structural steel system
coloumn location and spacing
coloumn location and spacing → to realize the greatest parking efficiency
Azéma Architectes
Costs: 4,3 M€
Levels: 4
Acciaio
Acciaio
Acciaio
secondary beams L = 15 m
distance 3.3 m
main beams L = 10 m
Acciaio Gravità
Parking molinette hospital, Tourin 2006
main beams
concrete coloumns
Acciaio Gravità
maximum level of efficiency
(design, structure, material, economy) → angle parking layout with one way can be more
efficient than 90-degree layout, because is more easy to park
→ short spans
beams → flat soffit construction → the same depth as the joists
→ short spans
→ short spans
→ dropped beam construction → as spans increase, the beam soffit must make bigger
ist depth
• flat soffit construction
→ broken beam
beams → haunched beam → reducing the beam depth in the center,
the weight of the beam is redused
→ broken beam → costant cross section, but ist soffit is not level
• broken beam
• post-tensioned slab and beam
long-span prestressed concrete construction
PARKING GARAGE ORGANIZATION
• circulation
• construction
• capacity
capacity → to estimate the number of parking spots, different parameters:
• jump of scale
• utopia
• future signs
parking’ s social effects
parking’ s social effects
• car became a status symbol, the central to who people think they are.
for example through having an assigned parking space at work , it can be an important form of territoriality
• inhospitable place
sometimes is a scene of violent and opportunistic crimes
driving automobile is a physical experience → represents an unaittanable idea
↓
↓
• jump of scale
• utopia
• future signs
jump of scale
• streets
• traditional city
Gateshead, in the mid 1960s
Owen Luder and Partners
parking or driving brought a new dimension to architecture, or rather to the city;
↓
at the biginning people and medieval centres of cities were not ready for this changement
freeway or expressway construction made a dramatic impact
↓
↓
↓
this argoument was also inherent in art avantgards movement as Russian Constructivism and Italian Futurism
↓
at the biginning people and medieval centres of cities were not ready for this changement
freeway or expressway construction made a dramatic impact
↓
↓
↓
this argoument was also inherent in art avantgards movement as Russian Constructivism and Italian Futurism
↓
• jump of scale
• utopia
• future signs
utopia
utopia → car and parking phenomenon were always subjects looking to the future
Philadelphia, 1947 - 62
Louis Kahn
“Urban Future"
E.M. Khoury
“Motopia”, 1961
G.A. Jellicoe
utopia → car and parking phenomenon were always subjects looking to the future
utopia → car and parking phenomenon were always subjects looking to the future
↓
• jump of scale
• utopia
• future signs
future sign or individual events?
Park and ride
Park and ride → increased after the mid-twentieth century
- generally located in the suburbs of metropolitan areas or on the edges of large cities
↓
↓
contrsucting parking garage with tighter dimensions can reduce the overall construction cost
zoning → parking area for small cars that is separeted from the large-car area
zoning → parking area for small cars that is separeted from the large-car area
↓
↓
↓
a more realistic approach would be to fix an average dimension, one size fits to all
zoning → parking area for small cars that is separeted from the large-car area
↓
↓
a more realistic approach would be to fix an average dimension, one size fits to all
↓
In any case, more efficient, cost-effective parking facilities can be designed by considering the type of use
and the actual mix of vehicles
CONSIDERATIONS
new input for the future?
INTERACTION WITH PEDESTRIAN AND OTHER TRANSPORT VEHICLES
INTERNET → NEW WAY OF WORKING → DIFFERENT WORKERS TRAFFIC? → ?
TRAVELLING WITH EASY → APTITUDE TO FLY → PARKING IMPLICATIONS ?
the house or apartment, as home excites affection and attention,
yards and gardens declare one’s personal tastes,
but parking space even at home usually remains a contrasting place, an almost alien world.
is independent from the context, the parking garage is a model of pure functionality :
economy of space, forms, structure, material, and cost
did not need to be anythin other than a container for its function.
its idea is based on programmatic concept, the risult is the creation of typologies
idea
Parking garage
+
Offices
Parking garage
+
Housing
Parking garage
+
Hotel
Parking garage
+
Sport facilities
Parking garage
+
Shopping mall
Parking garage
+
Transportation
Parking garage
+
Airport
size
for parking spots
S 100
M 100 - 1000
L 1000 - 5000
XL > 5000
site
groups → materiale_per_studenti → AA 10-11 → MAS_1 → Olgiati_Progettazione