Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Accounting2017 - Cornelius Rautenbach
Accounting2017 - Cornelius Rautenbach
Accounting often perceived as extremely precise activity with rigid rules, but there are areas where
judgement has to be applied e.g. choice of the depreciation rate
Types of companies
● Sole trader / Unlimited liability
○ Creditors can pursue owner beyond limit of business
○ Don’t have to make P/L and balance sheet public
○ Annual tax returns is a must
● Partnership
○ Partnership agreement sets out inter alia, how the annual profit will be shared
○ Rules the same as for Unlimited liability as the partners personal assets are at risk
● Company
○ Limited liability of the shareholders amount of equity (share capital)
○ Companies must make public their annual accounts which must be audited by a
registered auditor, to protect creditors against abuse of the limited liability
Measurement of Accomplishment
Accomplishment = No. of products shipped and invoiced
Accounting Conventions
1. The realisation convention
a. Only products that have been sold are measured as sales
2. The accruals convention
a. An obligation made from creditworthy customer is good enough to act as sale
b. Also covers situation where customer pays invoice which covers a period beyond date
of financial statements
Measurement of Effort
Effort = direct costs + indirect costs
Accounting Conventions
1. Matching convention
a. All expenses must be matched in same accounting period as the revenues they helped
to earn
2. Allocation convention
a. Step 1: Determine how much of each component of production (in money terms) was
consumed in the accounting period.
i. Use of raw materials (Start + purchases) - End
ii. Labour - Use pay records
iii. Depreciation of fixed assets
b. Step 2: Decide how many of costs should be allocated to products unsold or unfinished
at the end of period
i. Cost of sales = (Beginning inventory + Purchases) - Ending inventory
3. Cost convention
a. Use the historical cost of means of production
i. Difficult if prices fluctuate during the accounting period
Depreciation methods
1. Straight-line depreciation
a. Appropriate where:
i. Use of asset same each year
ii. Asset has equal decline in economic usefulness each period
3. Consumption method
b. The greater the machine hours run, the greater is the wear and tear
It is possible to lower profit and minimise tax by switching between LIFO when prices are rising and
FIFO when prices are going down
Module 3: The balance sheet
Illustrates the financial position (valuation of assets & liabilities) o
f the company at given point
Comparing owner’s equity between two points will show how much profit / loss has been made.
Non-current Assets
● The Intention of Use that defines an asset as fixed or current.
○ E.g. Cars: Current asset for a car dealer, fixed asset for a driving instructor
1. Land
a. Not depreciated
b. Recorded at acquisition cost, together with legal fees and cost of preparing the land
c. Expenditure is written off u nless it is clearly related to the acquisition of asset and
the asset could not be made operational without incurring the cost
d. Alternative treatment to acquisition cost:
i. Record acquisition cost and publish market value in parenthesis
ii. Revalue the asset from time to time, change book value and change the
shareholders’ equity (revaluation reserve) with the same value
2. Buildings
a. Often combined with land and shown as one amount in the balance sheet
3. Plant and Equipment
a. The faster the depreciation rate, the lower the profit in the P&L sheet (and book
value in balance sheet become)
4. Intangible assets
a. e.g. expanding IP and writing software
b. Companies are allowed to capitalise these expenditures ( treat them as non-current
assets in the balance sheet)
c. Should be capable of being sold + have power to obtain future economic benefits,
otherwise it can be considered as routine expenditure
d. If the cost of the software had been significant in relation to the company (say £500),
then it would have been capitalised within non-current assets.
5. Lease
a. Why Lease?
i. Avoid substantial outflow of cash + spread the outflow into relatively small
amounts over the asset’s life.
ii. Maintenance costs are covered by the lease agreement.
iii. Lease payments can be charged against profits before tax.
b. Recording The Lease Activity
i. Operating leases (where ownership remains with the lessor) - record as
expense
ii. However recommended that leased assets are recorded under the terms of a
finance lease:
1. Asset appears under fixed assets.
2. Future lease payments appears under creditors in the Liability section.
Current assets
1. Inventories
a. Value at whatever is lower between cost and realisable value (what it can be sold at)
2. Debtors
a. Conservatism: Some Debtors won’t pay.
b. Solution: Record an initial provision (based on previous experience). For following
periods, adjust the provision incrementally (managers decide the size of provision).
c. Matching: Ensure that costs and sales are recorded in the relevant period.
i. Debt is written off against profits in the period which debt is considered
irrecoverable
3. Cash
4. Prepayments
a. Paying for something that only needs to be paid next year is a current asset
Sources of Cash
1. Profit from Operations
2. Capital Introduction
a. Injection of cash from owners normally at start of org.
b. Usually once off except if high growth and not enough cash
3. Creditors increase ( owing the money, but can use it for other business purposes)
4. Debtors decrease (paying their bills)
5. Sale of Fixed Assets (total amount realised - costs of disposal used in Cash Flow Stmt)
6. Loans
7. Inventories decrease (realises the money tied up in them)
Prevented by:
● Framework within which companies must operate in financial reporting
● Additional info that must be disclosed other than 3 familiar statements
Disclosing info
★ Companies often disclose the minimum information required, because of:
○ Potentially sensitive information.
○ Can cost money to prepare disclosure reports
Groups of Companies
- Holding company owning more than 50% in subsidiary companies must publish the
group P&L and Balance Sheet, plus it’s own Balance Sheet.
- No need to publish own P&L Sheet.
- Subsidiary companies continue to publish their own financial statements
- Subsidiaries whole assets and liabilities included in the group asset sheet (even if the
holding company doesn’t own 100% of the subsidiary).
Goodwill
❖ The excess paid for a share in a company, over the asking price
❖ Reflects the intangible asset not in the balance sheet (good brand name, patents etc)
❖ Goodwill = Purchase Price – Company’s Net Assets.
❖ Add it to balance sheet e.g. pay 100 for company but assets is 50. Assign extra 50 to
goodwill under assets
Impairment Test
❖ Each cash generating unit to be tested for impairment (decrease) on annual basis
➢ Compare the carrying value (CV) of fixed assets and their recoverable amounts
➢ If the recoverable amount < CV, then impairment charge should be taken to the income
statement
❖ If goodwill figure not possible to allocate, explanation must be provided in notes
Share Capital
● The portion of a company’s equity obtained by trading stock to a shareholder
○ Authorised Share Capital: Total the organisation is allowed to issue.
○ Issued Share Capital: Total Share Capital allocated to Shareholders:
■ Treasury Shares - Held by the company itself (buyback).
Rounding
● Can round up to the nearest 100, 1000 or even 1000000!
○ Needs to be true and fair – not misleading + consistent in financial statement
Contingent asset
- A contingent asset is a potential asset associated with a contingent gain
- Contingent assets should not be recognised – but should be disclosed where an inflow of
economic benefits is probable.
Disclosure Requirements
Depreciation
● IAS-16 mentions basic methods (straight line, reducing balance + sum of units) as possibilities
○ Two overriding requirements for method selection:
■ Reflects pattern of consumption over the assets life.
■ Applied consistently from year to year.
● If the depreciation speeds up due to e.g. tech changes, management must adjust
depreciation equation accordingly and raise the depreciation charges.
Inventories
● IAS-2:
○ Inventories = Deferred cost in one reporting period carried forward to the next,
incurred on raw materials, WIP and finished goods
○ The more cost carried forward to next year = higher profits this year, hence regulated
● Valuation methods allowed include FIFO and weighted average (not LIFO).
○ Inventories must be measured at lowest of cost or realisable value
● Other potential inventory costs:
○ Storage and distribution (added if part of production process (think whisky).
○ Admin costs NOT normally included.
○ Fixed production overheads is allowed if based on normal levels of activity.
Management commentary
Companies must publish MC both on:
- Financial statements in the annual report
- Discussion of strategic challenges faced by company in future
Qualified report = Auditor found problems & provides reasons. Unqualified report = No problems.
Module 6: Interpretation of Financial Statements
Why Ratio Analysis
1. Easy comparison - Use industry average stats for benchmarking
2. Good for spotting trends - Not so good taken in isolation
● > 2 sound financial situation. Companies with ratio of less than 2 may well be able to pay their
bills - especially if large proportion of assets = cash
● > 1 Quick Ratio means no matter how great the losses incurred on sales of inventories,
company will still have enough money to pay obligations
● If quick ratio bad but current ratio matches avg, the amount of inventory may be the problem
● Large diff btwn gross profit margin and profit margin indicates heavy overhead structure
a. A high ratio often indicates that business has been aggressive in financing via debt.
This can be an issue due to interest expenses, especially in volatile economic times.
b. High gearing (higher debt): Less risk of loss when market goes into recession, but lower
returns when things take off.
c. Low gearing (higher equity): More risk of loss when market goes into recession, but
higher returns when things take off.
d. Example:
i. If debt is 52% of owners’ equity, debt = £1484m (52% of £2854m).
ii. If owners’ equity increases to £3354m as a result of the rights issue, then the
revised debt/equity gearing ratio is £1484m/£3354m, or 44%
❖ If Cost of Sales not available, use raw material and labour components.
❖ Higher the better
❖ Tip – 52 / times to get the number of weeks holding
Window dressing
● Attempt to make results look better than they really are
● Fraudulent agreement between parties e.g.
○ Company sells £200and then buyer returns it after the end of the financial year.
○ Can lead to auditor marking the accounts as not being “true and fair”.
○ Ratio analysis can be carried out throughout the year to identify window dressing
❏ High PE shows that market thinks there is potential - willing to pay more
❏ What if management pay out too high dividends to keep shareholders happy
❏ This ratio will draw attention to such practices.
❏ Higher = generally better.
❏ Sharp increase – pulling money out?
Module 7: How to understand a bank’s annual financial statements
Income statement
● Dividend income - income the bank receives from various equity stakes it has taken in
customers
● Net trading income - foreign exchange; currency, derivatives; government and
non-government fixed income and money market instruments;
● Other operating income - comprises rental income on the leasing of assets; gains on disposal
of property, plant and equipment; and valuation gains on investment properties
● Loan impairments and other credit risk provisions - equivalent to bad debt provision.
Balance sheet
Other info
Risk-weighted assets
Ratio Analysis
Profitability
➔ Upward trend over a number of years == the bank has improved its bottom-line profit (e.g. less
competition in pricing loans or an improved bad debt experience)
Gearing
➔ Below a certain minimum, supervisors insist that either no further borrowing is done by the bank
or that it raises more Tier 1 capital to support growth in the lending book. We use the
risk-weighted assets because this figure represents the total view of risk the bank is running.
➔ A rising trend in this figure should raise questions about the bank’s continuing ability to take on
new lending business without injecting more equity capital.
➔ A falling trend would suggest that the bank is becoming more and more successful in attracting
customer deposits, traditionally seen as a cheap form of funding, as opposed to raising money
from more expensive and riskier sources.
➔ The stock market likes to see a rising trend in absolute dividends paid, but if this is achieved
only by distributing a higher and higher percentage of a shrinking earnings figure = not good
Operations
➔ A rising trend in this ratio would indicate the increasing reliance on non-core banking activities.
= 0.335%
➔ A rising trend in this ratio, however, would cause analysts to question the risk profile of the loan
book being taken on.
Mgt accounting is based on current and future trends, which does not allow for exact numbers.
Financial accounting is precise and must adhere to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP),
but mgt accounting is often more of a guess or estimate, since most managers do not have time for
exact numbers when a decision needs to be made.
Variable Cost
➔ Costs varies with volume produced
E.g. labour costs / material
Fixed Cost
➔ Does NOT change when amount of items change
E.g. admin costs / depreciation
The way company classifies costs into product and period costs affect profit figure:
The more product costs, the higher inventory valuation and higher reported profit.
Of course all costs are theoretically controllable but generally uncontrollable costs can be defined by
those that cannot easily be changed. For example building rent is a fixed cost that the owner/manager
has little control over on a monthly basis.
The higher the result, the higher the contribution the sale of a unit makes.
Example:
0.4 = $4 profit / $10 sales (For each $1 of sales, we earn a contribution of 40 cents).
0.5 = $5 / $10 (For each $1 of sales, we earn a contribution of 50 cents). Preferable to the above.
Doesn’t consider the interrelationships between service departments. Recognised by step method
Joint Products
- Product that appears during process of producing the main product
- e.g. aircraft fuel, then also sell raw chemicals
- If there’s an option of whether or not to create 2nd product then the 2 products aren’t joint
By-products
● Differ from joint products in terms of motive and commercial value
● Has a low sales value relative to the main product e.g. Ends and trimmings.
● Emerges from a production process that is designed to produce another product. e.g. afval
● Only the revenue from the actual by-products sold can be deducted
● Unsold are carried forward in inventory at zero cost
Record keeping More required since time & Less record keeping because of
materials charged to specific aggregated costs
job.
The difference between the two is simply a question of the timing of fixed costs.
Note that at the end of the day the profit profiles will be identical for both methods.
Cons
1. Time
a. Budget process often starts too early > Start as late as possible.
b. Time consuming
2. Lack of mgt commitment
a. Budget holders get frustrated when they see senior mgt wasting money
3. Form of punishment
a. Often all discretionary expenditure such as entertaining and travel are stripped out
4. Responsibilities are blurred
a. Mgt get annoyed when they have to manage costs that they have no control over (i.e.
corporate level).
5. Moving goalposts
a. Implement a rolling budget – 12 months view of the future
6. Budgeting towards inefficiency
a. Blanket budgeting (expenditures that are authorized on a blanket basis, without
specifying individual projects, allowing for slackness) can unfair to those who are good
at holding budgets
Cash Budgets
- Variances should be calculated where they arise and passed on to the next department at std cost
- Consistent variances may indicate that the standard / budget needs to be recalculated.
Sales Variances
Mgt need insight into consequences of not achieving the sales volume & mix planned for the budget.
Contribution = Selling price - variable costs per unit
Volume variance
➢ (Actual sold - planned sold) * planned price
Types of Divisions
❖ Cost Centres - Responsible for costs only (not revenues)
e.g. a division that is bottom part of a production chain
❖ Revenue Centres - Responsible for generating revenues (without reference to costs)
e.g. the seat reservation system of an airline.
➢ Focus on revenue generation regardless of associated costs (which are mostly fixed)
❖ Profit Centres - Cost & revenues matched (Traditional)
➢ Performance assessed via bottom line profit
❖ Investment Centres - Consider net assets when evaluating profit performance
If ROI needs to be e.g. 16% and the extra profit on a project is 100K, then the amount acceptable to
invest is 100K/16% = 625K
Residual Income
Alternative, better view than ROI
Residual Income = Profit - (investment in net assets * imputed interest)
● 58m = 100m - (350m * 0.12)
Requirements:
1. Imputed interest/ cost of capital must be constant, otherwise it will lead to friction
2. Valuation of the asset base is key
The current profit level is 320K. Interest is 6%. Investment is 2M. Residual income is 200K.
- If an asset is scrapped for 100K, then the imputed interest charge falls to 114K from 120K (6%
of 1.9M), altering residual income to 206K. The difference between 206 K and a target of 182 K
is 24 K of ‘extra interest’. At a 6% cost of capital, this equates to an extra investment of 400K
(24K/0.06).
Asset Base Valuation
1. Net Book Value = Acquisition cost - accumulated depreciation
a. Results in a growing ROI over time.
Transfer pricing
Divisions may wish / require to trade with one another:
- Danger of political games My division sells at an inflated cost = my figures look better, even
though the company doesn’t earn money on the sale
- Market Prices
★ Best alternative for transferring goods & service btwn divisions, because it can be
objectively tested by both parties.
Use suppliers price lists, market observations in a truly competitive market etc.
- Cost Based Prices
❖ Full costs: B ased on variable costs plus fixed costs. But then the buying division are
contributing to the fixed costs of the selling division!
❖ Variable Costs: Just using the variable costs means that the buying division are
getting the product cheap and are being subsidised by the selling division!
❖ Negotiated Costs: O ften used when managers can’t agree and upper management
force them to propose a solution that will not harm the company! I.e. Dual Pricing.
Also, by adjusting transfer prices one can ensure that profits are repatriated e.g.
- Country 1 restricts division from sending it’s funds (through cash transfer or dividends) back to
the country of the main company
- The division located in the Country 1 pays high transfer prices to a division located in the
country of the main company.
Module 15: Investment Decisions
Capex: Investment decision: Impact extends beyond the current operating period (i.e. Year).
Opex: Operating decision: Impact within the current operating period.
Investment Decisions
● Investment = Increases Capital employed
● Return on Capital Ratio will decrease, requiring higher profit targets
● Also consider the opportunity cost of investment in one project over another
● The further we go into the future, the more uncertain business becomes.
Present Value
Considers time value of money
- Known as discounted cash flow approach to evaluate investment opportunities
NPV
● Take project cash flows and reduce them to a common denominator (PV) by using an
appropriate interest rate (i.e. cost of capital)
NPV = absolute, IRR = relative. Perhaps both analyses should be performed to get real picture!
Not-for-Profit Situations
❖ Use NPV and apply cost minimisation (i.e. choose option where the NPV is lowest negative).
Risk and Uncertainty
1. Do no further analysis
a. Mgt looks at figures & makes decision, taking account of all other factors felt relevant
2. Mgt groups projects into risk categories
a. Use higher rate of return on more risky projects
3. Payback answer the question ‘When will we get our money back?’
a. Disadvantage: It ignores relevant cash inflows after the point of payback
b. Also ignores the opportunity cost of capital invested
c. Better method is to reduce the cash flows to their present value b efore deducting
them from the original investment
Sensitivity Analysis
➢ Analysis on what happens if things change
➢ Involves c
hanging critical key variables to assess how this affects the final result
○ i.e.: selling prices, sale quantities, or adjust cash inflow
➢ Doesn’t take into account probability of taking place. Risk analysis caters for this!
Risk Analysis
● Subjective probability for deviations from an estimate.
● Take range of outcomes + probability of occurring & find the mean
Capital investment
● It is not only the amount that is important, of course, but also the timing
○ Fixed Capital
■ Cash outflows to cost of new buildings and equipment.
■ Cash inflows from government tax allowances and grants.
○ Working Capital
■ Cash outflows as debtors build up
■ Cash inflows from debtors pay back
Operating cash flows
❏ Cash flows generated in operating period
❏ Inflows arise from sales vs outflows from operating expenses
❏ Non-cash expenses like depreciation have no part in the calculations
❏ Looks at profitability of a project over its lifetime, not only the accounting year
Investment life
❖ Factors determining the lifetime of the investment
➢ Physical – wear and tear or fatigue may cause the asset to collapse
➢ Technical – asset is obsolete because of new technology
➢ Market – product may no longer be demanded
❖ Don’t use depreciation calculations for deciding the investment life of a specific project.
Cost of capital
➢ Key factor in assessing the profitability of a project
How a business might determine its cost of capital:
Inflation
➔ Real value of money (purchasing power) changes over time because of inflation
➔ Independant from time value of money.
➔ Inflation difficult to predict and is rarely straight line.
◆ Use sensitivity analysis to help analyse this variable.
Module 16: Techniques under Development in Management Accounting
Shortcomings of current Management Accounting
1. Driven by financial accounting (focus on inventory valuation and profit measurement).
2. Direct labor still a popular method of overhead allocation, even though it’s use is shrinking
3. Automation is challenging established boundaries fixed and variable costs
4. Complexity of business has increased – more product lines, shorter life cycles, more
product support needed.
5. Globalization accentuates many of the above problems.
Target Costing
The leader’s price sets the benchmark beyond which imitators dare not go. Most suited in
fast-moving technology-based goods markets, where there are innovative competitors and where market
sizes and selling prices are known.
Innovation and Learning: Be better at acquiring, storing, transmitting knowledge in the workforce.