Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Music therapy is increasingly becoming an intervention used in palliative care settings around the globe.
Received 15 March 2015 While the specialty of palliative care music therapy is relatively young having emerged in the late 1980s,
Accepted 26 April 2015 there is a strong and growing body of evidence demonstrating its efficacy in assisting a variety of issues
common at end-of-life. There are multiple music therapy techniques that are implemented with clients
Keywords: in palliative care and they can be categorized in four broad areas: receptive, creative, recreative and
Efficacy
combined. These techniques will be presented with respect to their development by clinicians as sup-
Grief
ported by the descriptive and research literature. Information is also provided on the use of music
Music therapy
Palliative care
therapy in facilitating the grieving and bereavement process.
Techniques © 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ctcp.2015.04.004
1744-3881/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
126 A. Clements-Cortes / Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice 23 (2016) 125e129
(2) the bringing about of self-esteem through self-actualization, and Music (BMGIM). The BMGIM involves the use of a detailed
and protocol and specifically designed music programs to assist a client
(3) the utilization of the unique potential of rhythm to engage in reaching a deep relaxed state in order to access their unconscious
and bring order (p. v). and work through ‘material’ (issues, feelings) they may or may not
be acutely aware of. When this method is used at end-of-life it can
Similarly Sears [14], identified the following classification sys- produce powerful results quickly.
tem for processes occurring in music therapy as: “(1) experience Songwriting remains a highly effective and important technique
within structure, (2) experience in self-organization, and (3) in palliative care. Refs. [17e19] first described songwriting for
experience in relating to others” (p. 31). These principles and persons with emotional and psychiatric problems; and songwriting
classification systems shed light on how goals are accomplished in palliative care has its roots in these early writings. O'Callaghan
using music, and how they are exhibited and demonstrated in the [20] who has written extensively on songwriting in palliative care
techniques. provided early guidelines in the form of 10 therapeutic opportu-
Music is one modality that provides a large number of expres- nities associated with music and songwriting in palliative care,
sive and learning experiences ranging from singing, to moving to which are:
music, to discussing music, etcetera [12]. As with other clinical
populations, music therapy techniques in palliative care may be (1) Songwriting offers patients opportunities to express crea-
categorized in one of four categories: receptive, creative, recreative, tively through both the words and music.
and combined [15]. Receptive methods are common at end-of-life (2) Songwriting may be less threatening than other forms of
considering the patient may have decreased energy levels and creative writing.
involve more passive responses on the part of the client; typically (3) Songwriting offers varied opportunities to promote physical
involving the patient listening to music. Approaches that fit in the and social well-being.
creative category include things such as: music and lyric compo- (4) The music accompaniment may enhance one's learning of
sition, and other music creation on voice or instruments. Per- the lyrics.
forming previously composed music either on instruments or by (5) Songwriting allows people to make creative choices that
singing are considered recreative approaches, and combined ap- encompass both musical and verbal dimensions.
proaches involve various fusions of music with other modalities (6) Songwriting may offer opportunities for counseling.
such as movement, art or drama. (7) The song melodies may inadvertently offer comfort.
Clements-Cortes [16] categorized various techniques that were (8) Songwriting verbally and musically validates emotional
useful to her participants in examining relationship completion at expression.
end-of-life (see Table 1). (9) Helping patients to create new lyrics for well-known music
Brief definitions of the techniques, which require further may encourage their expression of thoughts and feelings.
description, are provided below. The receptive technique of song (10) When writing songs one may feel pride about both the lyrics
choice is where the therapist invites the client to select a piece of and musical setting (p. 13e15).
music based on certain criteria, or to freely choose any song that
might be important, present or preferred. Song choice which often Improvisation of music can either be done by the therapist and
involves verbal processing of the selections, may help uncover and the client individually or together. O' Kelly [21] acknowledges the
reveal various aspects of the patient such as their feelings, and importance of this technique in facilitating therapist support,
present or enduring thoughts. Lyric analysis is the choice of songs reflection and encouragement of patient expression in music rather
by either the patient or the therapist followed by listening to said than in verbal discussion and processing. Song dedications and the
song and the having a verbal discussion of the lyrics. creation of music or song legacies involve the patient selecting and/
Entrainment is another common technique in palliative care and or writing a song that expresses a thought, feeling or sentiment to
involves the therapist playing music to facilitate changing a pa- another person, and when these are recorded individually or as part
tient's heart rate, brain waves and breathing pattern. The therapist of a group of songs they are known as song legacies.
often includes this technique to help slow down rapid breathing or To conduct a music life review the therapist may help the pa-
to calm a racing heart rate. The therapist begins by matching the tient to identify music from various time periods in their life to
heart rate of the patient musically and gradually changes and slows stimulate discussion about their life story. However, assembling
the tempo so that the patient's heart rate and breathing will music that the patient identifies as representative of important life
resonate and change to the slower tempo. This is known as the iso- events or times is categorized as a musical autobiography.
principle.
Music and imagery involves the therapist providing either live, 3. The role of music therapists within palliative care
improvised or recorded music accompanied by descriptions of interdisciplinary health care teams
scenery, a journey, or other imagery. A specialized approach that
involves music and imagery implemented by a trained practitioner Around the world music therapists are increasingly being
in the approach is known as The Bonny Method of Guided Imagery included in palliative care interdisciplinary health care teams. This
Table 1
Music therapy techniques for relationship completion.a
growth in inclusion is primarily due to the increased research and also help clients express feelings that are challenging to discuss [29].
documented efficacy of music therapy as well an overall increase Gallagher et al. [36] implemented song choice to facilitate goal
and desire for holistic and comprehensive care. For example acquisition with respect to several concerns including: decreasing
Clements-Cortes [16], found music therapy was a valued inter- anxiety and depression, enhancing mood, decreasing pain percep-
vention in working towards common palliative care goals; and tion, providing enjoyment, distraction and support or coping skills.
others such as Refs. [22,23] describe its success in addressing a Song choice and lyric analysis often trigger reminiscence and Jones
variety of emotional, physical and spiritual issues in palliative care. [37] acknowledges that patient self-identity can be strengthened
Specifically, the literature has discussed: reducing emotional through music and reminiscence as specific songs might facilitate
suffering that includes anxiety, anger, depression and fear [24], discussion on stories from various time periods in a person's life such
reducing feelings of loneliness and social isolation [25], patient as early adult years, childhood, marriage and school days.
perceived improvements in physical comfort, reduced pain
perception and enhanced relaxation [4,26e28] and attending to 4.2. Creative techniques
spiritual distress [29].
Songwriting is a powerful technique at end-of-life. O'Callaghan's
4. Research efficacy evidence [38] early writings discussed how songwriting facilitates expres-
sion of suppressed feelings, instilling feelings of contributions to
Up until 2005 most studies on palliative care music therapy the world, providing the client pleasure and contributing to
were qualitative in nature. Hilliard [30] analyzed 11 published increased self-efficacy, all while helping the client to express
quantitative studies summarizing that results were promising but messages to important people in their lives. O'Callaghan [39]
lacked generalization to the broader palliative care population. One studied the themes of 39 palliative care patients' songs (64 songs
of the main issues with the quantitative studies to date surrounds total) concluding that songwriting provided diversion and a place
small sample sizes and an intensified need for studies with of refuge from their current illness, and it further provided a place
increased control and randomization of participants as well as of safety and helped with symptom management. In more current
meta-analyses. A Cochrane review of the literature that included research, songwriting continues to be helpful for clients’ expression
1891 participants and 30 trials was undertaken by Bradt et al. [31]. of feelings [16], and further enables the discussions between the
The authors concluded that music therapy may have benefits to- client and their family and friends regarding their feelings and
wards reducing anxiety, improving mood, reducing pain percep- experiences, with the song providing the framework within which
tion, enhancing quality of life, and reducing heart, respiratory and to share [40].
blood pressure rates in persons with cancer. This review highlights With respect to clinical improvisation common benefits noted
the importance of music therapy as an intervention with end-of-life were release and resolution of painful emotions [41]; helping the
cancer patients and also identifies areas for further research in client build a deep therapeutic relationship with the therapist and
palliative care music therapy. Here, I have organized important assisting the client to feel understood [25]; helping the client access
research contributions to palliative care music therapy under the unconscious issues and process them including anger, fear, exis-
headings of the four categories of techniques described earlier: tential loneliness and jealousy [25]; and increasing comfort and
receptive techniques, creative techniques, recreative techniques, reducing anxiety [42]. Specifically, with respect to vocal improvi-
and combined techniques. sation Batzner [43] noted that following music therapy sessions in-
patient hospice clients displayed decreased discomfort behaviors.
4.1. Receptive techniques
4.3. Recreative techniques
A number of studies have focused on the use of music listening
to reduce pain perception. For instance Curtis [27], found that Halstead and Roscoe [44] found that enhanced mood, increased
participants in her study had an increase in scores for pain relief, expression of feeling, alongside contributing to feelings of
physical comfort, relaxation and contentment after listening to enhanced quality of life were benefits gained through instrument
music. Clements-Corte s [26] found that both live and recorded playing; while Gauthier and Dallaire [45] found that it helped
music listening by palliative care patients resulted in statistically facilitate communication between the client, their family and
significant reduced pain perception with the magnitude of the ef- friends as well as staff members. Singing was shown to lead to a
fect being much greater for live music. Other case studies have also greater sense of self awareness and increased feelings of belonging
identified that listening to music helps reduce pain perception and [46], while also helping boost mood, confidence, assist with
increases feelings of relaxation [2,6,7,32]. More specifically Kemper emotional release, and stimulate reminiscence and overall in-
and Danhauer [33], found that classical music listening resulted in teractions with family [47]. Toning and chanting were of specific
patients experiencing reduced tension and prescribed music had benefit as they were linked with emotional and physical relief and
patients commenting on feelings of improved mental clarity, reduced stress [48].
increased relaxation, as well as reduced feelings of sadness, tension
and fatigue. 4.4. Combined techniques
With respect to persons receiving chemotherapy treatments
Troesch et al. [34], found guided imagery resulted in delayed Musical life review is a technique that allows clients to review
symptoms of the chemotherapy as compared to participants in the significant and unique aspects of their lives [49], while also
study control group. Further benefits included feelings of relaxation, providing an avenue to celebrate or acknowledge accomplish-
feeling more prepared and in control prior to chemotherapy then ments, process regrets, and raise self-esteem. Duffey [50]
participants in the control group. Similarly, patients who listened to acknowledged that this technique may help clients to gain under-
their own preferred choice of music experienced reduced or delayed standing on negative aspects of their life and even help the client to
symptoms of nausea following chemotherapy [35]. revise or re-author those occurrences. For clients suffering from a
Song choice has also been demonstrated in the efficacy literature fear of death or those having existential concerns about life and
and is a useful technique in helping clients regain self-esteem, death this technique can also be important to work through some
reconnect to identity, provide opportunities to make choices, and of those issues. Halstead and Roscoe [44] noted the importance of
128 A. Clements-Cortes / Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice 23 (2016) 125e129
Therapy. New York: Macmillan; 1968. p. 30e44. Behaviors of In-patient Hospice Clients (Unpublished master’s thesis). Law-
[15] Dileo C, Dneaster D. Introduction: state of the art. In: Dileo C, Loewy JV, ed- rence, KS: University of Kansas; 2003.
itors. Music therapy at the End of Life. Cherry Hill, NJ: Jeffrey Books; 2005. [44] Halstead MT, Roscoe ST. Restoring the spirit at the end-of-life: music as an
xixexxvii. intervention for oncology nurses. Clin J Oncol Nurs 2007;6(6):332e6.
[16] Clements-Corte s A. Episodes of Relationship Completion through Song in [45] Gauthier PA, Dallaire C. Music therapy. Can Nurse 1993;89(2):46e8.
Palliative Care (Doctoral thesis). Toronto, Canada: University of Toronto; 2009. [46] Clair AA. Therapeutic Uses of Music with Older Adults. Baltimore, MD: Health
[17] Castellano JA. Music composition in a music therapy program. J. Music Ther. Professions Press; 1996.
1969;6:12e4. [47] Aldridge D. Music Therapy in Palliative Care: New Voices. London: Jessica
[18] Crocker D. Techniques in the use of music as therapy for the emotionally Kingsley Publishers; 1999.
maladjusted child. Music Ther. 1952;2:175e80. [48] Dileo C. Music Therapy and Medicine: Theoretical and Clinical Approaches.
[19] Rupenthal W. Scribbling in music therapy. J. Music Ther. 1965;2:8e9. Silver Spring, MD: American Music Therapy Association; 1999.
[20] O'Callaghan C. Therapeutic opportunities associated with the music when [49] O'Callaghan C. Musical profiles of dying patients. Aust. Music. Ther. Assoc. Bull
using songwriting in palliative care. Music Ther. Perspect. 1997;15:32e8. 1984;7(2):5e11.
[21] O'Kelly J. Music therapy in palliative care: current perspectives. Int. J. Palliat. [50] Duffey T. Using music and a musical chronology as a life review with the
Nurs. 2002;8(3):130e6. aging. In: Rubin LC, editor. Popular Culture in Counseling, Psychotherapy, and
[22] Hilliard. The use of music therapy in meeting the multidimensional needs of Play-Based Interventions. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company, LLC;
hospice patients and families. J. Palliat. Care 2001a;17:161e6. 2008. p. 81e92.
[23] O'Callaghan C. Bringing music to life: a study of music therapy and palliative [51] Salmon D. Music therapy as psychospiritual process in palliative care. J. Palliat.
care experiences in a cancer hospital. J. Palliat. Care 2001;17(3):155e60. Care 2001;17(3):142e6.
[24] Hogan B. The experience of music therapy for terminally ill patients: a [52] Magill LM. The meaning of the music: the role of music in palliative care
phenomenological research project. In: Pratt RR, Grocke DE, editors. Music music therapy as perceived by bereaved caregivers of advanced cancer pa-
Medicine 3: Music Medicine and Music Therapy. Australia Expanding Hori- tients. Am. J. Hospice Palliat. Med. 2009a;26(1):33e9.
zons, Faculty of Music, University of Melbourne; 1999. p. 242e54. [53] Magill LM. The spiritual meaning of pre-loss music therapy to bereaved
[25] Lee CA. Music at the Edge. London: Routledge; 1996. caregivers of advanced cancer patients. Palliat Support. Care 2009b;7:97e108.
[26] Clements-Corte s A. The effect of live music vs. taped music on pain and [54] Baker F, Wigram T. Songwriting Methods, Techniques and Clinical Applica-
comfort in palliative care. Korean J. Music Ther. 2011;13(1):105e21. tions for Music Therapy Clinicians, Educators and Students. London: Jessica
[27] Curtis S. The effect of music on pain relief and relaxation of the terminally ill. Kingsley Publishers; 2005.
J. Music Ther. 1986;24(1):10e24. [55] Dalton TA, Krout RE. The grief song-writing process with bereaved adoles-
[28] Krout RE. The effects of single-session music therapy interventions on the cents: an integrated grief model and music therapy protocol. Music Ther.
observed and self-reported levels of pain control, physical comfort, and Perspec. 2005a;24:94e106.
relaxation of hospice patients. Am. J. Hospice Palliat. Care 2001;18:383e90. [56] Derrington P. Teenagers and songwriting: supporting students in a main-
[29] Clements-Corte s A. The use of music in facilitating emotional expression in stream secondary school. In: Baker F, Wigram T, editors. Songwriting:
the terminally ill. Am. J. Hospice Palliat. Med. 2004;21(4):255e60. Methods, Techniques and Clinical Applications for Music Therapy Clinicians,
[30] Hilliard RE. Music therapy in hospice and palliative care: a review of the Educators and Students. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers; 2005. p. 66e81.
empirical data. Evid. Base Comp. Altern. Med. 2005;2(2):173e8. [57] Hara AF. Continuity through song. In: Loewy JV, Hara AF, editors. Caring for
[31] Bradt J, Dileo C, Grocke D, Magill L. Music interventions for improving psy- the Caregiver: The Use of Music and Music Therapy in Grief and Trauma.
chological and physical outcomes in cancer patients. Cochrane Database Syst. Silver Spring, MD: American Music Therapy Association; 2002. p. 63e70.
Rev. 2011;2011(8). http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD006911.pub2. [58] Krout RE. The music therapist as singer/songwriter: applications with
Article. CD006911. bereaved teenagers. In: Baker F, Wigram T, editors. Songwriting Methods,
[32] Mandel SE. Music Therapy in the Hospice: “Musicalive.” Palliative Medicine. Techniques and Clinical Applications for Music Therapy Clinicians, Educators
5(2). 1991. p. 155e60. and Students. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers; 2005. p. 206e23.
[33] Kemper KJ, Danhauer SC. Music as therapy. South Med. J. 2005;98(3):282e8. [59] Schwantes M, Wigram T, McKinney C, Lipscomb A, Richards C. The Mexican
[34] Troesch LM, Rodehaver CB, Delaney EA, Yanes B. The influence of guided corrido and its use in a music therapy bereavement group. Aust. J. Music Ther.
imagery on chemotherapy-related nausea and vomiting. Oncol. Nurse Forum 2011;22:2e20.
1993;20(8):1179e85. [60] Lee CA. Architecture of Aesthetic Music Therapy. New Braunfels: Barcelona
[35] Standley JM. Clinical applications of music and chemotherapy: the effects of Publishers; 2003.
nausea and emesis'. Music Ther. Perspect. 1992;10(1):27e35. [61] Hilliard. The effects of music therapy based bereavement groups on mood and
[36] Gallagher LM, Lagman R, Walsh D, Davis MP, LeGrand SB. The clinical effects of behaviour of grieving children. J. Music Ther. 2001b;37:291e306.
music therapy in palliative medicine. Support Care Cancer 2006;14:859e66. [62] Mayhew J. A creative response to loss: developing a music therapy group for
[37] Jones JD. A comparison of songwriting and lyric analysis techniques to evoke bereaved siblings. In: Pavlicevic M, editor. Music Therapy in Children’s Hos-
emotional change in a single session with people who are chemically pices. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers; 2005. p. 62e80.
dependent. J. Music Ther. 2005;42:94e110. [63] Ryan KL. Access to music in pediatric bereavement support groups. In: Lee C,
[38] O'Callaghan C. Music therapy skills used in song-writing within a palliative editor. Lonely Waters. Oxford: Sobell Publications; 1995. p. 41e59.
care setting. Aust. J. Music Ther. 1990;1:15e22. [64] Roberts M. “I want to play and sing my story”: Home-based songwriting for
[39] O'Callaghan C. Songwriting in Palliative Care. Master’s thesis. Australia: Uni- bereaved children and adolescents. Aust. J. Music Ther. 2006;17:18e34.
versity of Melbourne; 1994. [65] Hilliard. The effects of orff-based music therapy and social work groups on
[40] Blyth L, Miles L. We’re all in this together: inpatient and community based childhood grief symptoms and behaviors. J. Music Ther. 2007;44(2):123e38.
music therapy for children and families experiencing terminal illness. Palliat. [66] Dalton TA, Krout RE. Development of the grief process scale through music
Care. Aust. 2012 Online PDF retrieved from, http://www.palliativecare.org.au/ therapy songwriting with bereaved adolescents. Arts Psychotherapy
Portals/46/Together%20conference/C4%20Louise%20Miles.pdf. 2005b;32(2):131e43.
[41] Bunt L. Music Therapy: An Art beyond Words. New York: Routledge; 1994. [67] Smeijters H, van den Hurk J. Music therapy helping to work through grief and
[42] Lee CA, Clements-Corte s A. Applications of clinical improvisation and finding a personal identity: qualitative single case research. J. Music Ther.
aesthetic music therapy in medical settings: an analysis of Debussy's ‘L’isle 1999;16(3):222e52.
joyeuse’. Music Med. 2014;6(2):61e9. [68] Rosner Kruse, Jagl. A meta analysis of interventions for bereaved children and
[43] Batzner KW. The Effects of Therapist Vocal Improvisation on Discomfort adolescents. Death Stud. 2010;34(2):99e136.