Professional Documents
Culture Documents
($ in Thousands)
Concept: Now, we have a great idea to expand our business: we're going to add a monthly subscription service to the site
Idea is to offer interviews with experts and case studies each month to help students (you!) get more practice.
And although it's a monthly service, we have another brilliant idea: you'll only be able to pay for it with an ANNUAL or QUA
that you purchase upfront…
So you pay us upfront for 3 months or 12 months of membership to this new service… great for us, not as great for you.
This is another very common scenario: customers pay upfront for a product or service that gets delivered later on.
Think about: Your smartphone (if it's locked to a contract and subsidized by the carrier), insurance, annual subscriptions,
cable bills, gym memberships, and the list goes on.
And it's yet another "hole" in our assumption that Net Income = Cash Generated.
Now, we're collecting CASH from customers… but we can't record it as revenue! No product/service delivered yet!
Question: How does this affect the cash generated from this business? How does Net Income differ from cash generated n
If we're collecting cash payments from customers but can't recognize them as revenue, we get an account called "Deferred
that we also have to track over time.
If this "Deferred Revenue" goes UP, our cash also goes UP because we're getting cash money! It's just that we can't exactly
it as revenue yet… but our bank account is still going up.
So if this keeps going up and up over time, cash generated will be *higher* than Net Income on the IS…
On the other hand, if we HAVE a Deferred Revenue balance and then stop collecting cash payments, waiting to recognize t
the balance falls and cash generated will be LESS than Net Income…
Because we've *already* collected it in cash - revenue we recognize now doesn't actually arrive in cash form!
Let's say we really do start this subscription business… but we decide to be nice and only ask for quarterly payments for ea
We get a good number of customers, and around $5,000 per month in subscription revenue coming in…
Deferred Revenue for Subscription Services: Paying for Subscription Services Each Month i
Month 1 Month 2 Month 3
Cash Received: $ 15 $ - $ - Cash Paid:
Revenue Recognized: 5 5 5 Expense Recorded:
Big difference! Better for us, not as good for our new subscription customers…
Subscription Revenue Paid Upfront in Cash: $ 15 <--- This represents the amount of quarterly paym
Operating Expenses Paid in Cash Later On: $ 15 that have NOT yet been recognized as revenue at
Prepaid Operating Expenses: $ 30
Revenue NOT Received in Cash Upfront: $ 50
Pre-Tax Income (EBT): 325 360 It decreases when the company records it a
Income Taxes: (130) (144) It's always going up and down, but there wi
balance as long as the business continues to
Net Income (Profit After Taxes): $ 195 $ 216 revenue at different times. The balance at t
Net Income Margin: 30.0% 30.9% what the company will record as revenue in
In a very simple business, Net Income really DOES mean "How much cash did this business generate in this period?"…
But that stops being true once the business gets more complex. Common "holes" include customers NOT paying upfron
company PREPAYS for expenses upfront, and when the company *delays* payment of expenses for products/services t
have already been delivered… and when the company COLLECTS cash but does not record it as revenue (the scenario h
Examples: Customers paying for a monthly subscription a year in advance… or paying for a product or service even a fe
weeks, or days in advance and then getting it delivered later on.
When this happens, we create a "Deferred Revenue" line item - and it's common for companies in almost all industries.
Here, we've assumed that we're getting cash upfront from customers who sign up for our monthly subscription service
work and products that we deliver in the future.
End Result: Our cash balance goes up by MORE than the Net Income in this period.
If this keeps happening over time, it's going to create an ongoing difference between our profits and how much cash we
And that is going to impact how we run the business, how much it's worth, and how we plan for the future.
subscription service to the site!
e on the IS…
e coming in…
ed Revenue" balance goes up each time the company Therefore, we need to adjust up to reflect how much cash we
h from customers but cannot record it as revenue on actually generated in this period.
an Net Income
t change either).