Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Category - Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology: Abstracts
Category - Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology: Abstracts
ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG 7
Abstracts
8 ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG
Abstracts
350 494
Vaginal microbiome molecular assay for diagnosis Prevalence and management of CIN by colposcopy
of vaginitis, vaginosis and risk of acquisition and among VIA-positive cases in a tertiary-level
persistence of HPV hospital of Bangladesh
Andrews, J Biswas, R1; Parvin, Z1; Biswas, R2
1
BD, Sparks, USA Faridpur Medical College, Dhaka, Bangladesh; 2International Centre
for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh
Objective The vaginal microbiome plays a significant role in the
maintenance of health and occurrence of disease in the female Background Cervical cancer is the second most common cancer
lower genital tract. Human papillomavirus (HPV) causes cervical among women in Bangladesh where CIN is the forerunner. Visual
intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and cervical and vaginal cancer. inspection of cervix with acetic acid (VIA) is adopted as national
This secondary research study provides an analysis of the current cervical cancer screening programme in this country. All positive
state of the evidence regarding role of vaginal microbiome in VIA cases are evaluated by colposcopy.
vaginitis, in bacterial vaginosis, and in acquisition and persistence Objective This study was conducted to evaluate the prevalence of
of HPV. CIN among the VIA-positive cases and to audit the performance
Design Systematic review. of a tertiary-level hospital in the colposcopic management of CIN
Methods We searched the Database of Abstracts of Reviews of to prevent invasive cancer.
Effects, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, PubMed, and Methods This population-based retrospective study was
the Health Technology Assessment database from January 2001 conducted in Faridpur Medical College Hospital of Bangladesh.
through January 2018 for relevant controlled trials and Study period was 06 (six) years from 2013 to 2018. All VIA-
observational studies. We supplemented by hand-searching of positive cases were evaluated by colposcopy. A total of 2102 VIA-
retrieved article reference lists. Eligible studies included positive cases were evaluated and were documented in
prospective studies of women and retrospective studies of residual ‘Colposcopy register’ supplied by the Government. International
specimens from women who were tested using molecular assays of Federation of Cervical Pathology and Colposcopy (IFCPC) 2011
healthy and pathogenic bacteria of the vagina and human nomenclature was used for diagnosis. Modified Reid Colposcopic
papillomavirus DNA assays. Index (RCI) was followed for management. ‘See and treat’
Results A PRISMA flow diagram is presented for this systematic protocol was mostly followed. Histopathological correlations were
review. The complete analysis of results of the systematic review, done. Data were screened, grouped, and analysed by SPSS version
with tables, is presented. Past cross-sectional studies relying on 23. Frequency and percentage were determined for comparative
Nugent’s score have been superceded by molecular next- purpose.
generation sequencing. Molecular assessment of the vaginal Results In this study, prevalence of CIN in VIA-positive cases is
microbiome assists with diagnosis of vaginitis and bacterial 26.1%. Among them, 65.5% were low-grade squamous
vaginosis. Dysbiosis of the vaginal microbiome, bacterial vaginosis, intraepithelial lesion (CIN-I) and 32.5% were high-grade
and vaginitis is associated with increased risk of acquisition of squamous intraepithelial lesion (CIN-II and III). Colposcopically
HPV infection. Dysbiosis of the vaginal microbiome and bacterial diagnosed 64.1% cases of low-grade squamous intraepithelial
vaginosis is associated with increased risk of persistence of the lesion (LSIL) and 74.2% of high-grade squamous intraepithelial
same HPV genotype. Persistence of HPV is associated with lesion (HSIL) cases received treatment and histopathological
increased risk of high-grade CIN. confirmation. Demographically, most of the patients were between
Conclusion The vaginal microbiome plays a substantial role in the 30 and 45 years (66.7%), had their primary or secondary
persistence or clearance of HPV, and in the progression or education (56.5%), and belonged to middle-class family (60.6%).
regression of CIN. The challenge to date has been that most Important finding is that 27.4% of the CIN cases are below
studies were observational, limiting conclusions to associations, 30 years.
rather than causation. Future research should target longitudinal Conclusion From this study, we got information about the
risk assessment. demography and prevalence of CIN among VIA-positive cases at
Note: The author/presenter is a former associate professor of Ob/ the same time management of CIN to prevent invasive cervical
Gyn, Editor-in-Chief of a peer-reviewed journal; Cochrane cancer. In developing countries like Bangladesh, adequate coverage
reviewer; Senior Scientist in an Evidence-based Practice Center; of the total female population by cervical cytology is not feasible
and current member of GRADE. at present. Also, women are not complaint for follow-up visits. In
such situation, VIA is suitable for primary screening and all VIA-
positive cases should have secondary screening by colposcopy and
biopsy. Colposcopy is the gold standard for diagnosis of CIN, and
colposcopy-based management can reduce the incidence of
carcinoma cervix. We should extend our screening programme
and that should be population-based.
ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG 9
Abstracts
947 582
Primary HPV testing with cytology versus cytology A comparative analysis of estrogen receptor alpha
alone in cervical screening – a prospective and beta expression in normal cervix and cervical
randomised controlled trial (RCT) with 2 rounds of cancer: a case–control pilot study
screening in a Chinese population Priyadarshini, V; Singh, A
Chan, KKL1; Ngu, SF1; Chu, MY1; Tse, KY1; UCMS & GTB hospital, New Delhi, India
Wei, N1; Liu, SS1; Lau, L1; Cheung, AN2;
Ngan, HYS1 Introduction Estrogen receptors (ER) were categorised into two
1
subgroups (alpha and beta) after the discovery of estrogen
Department of O&G, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, Hong
receptor beta in the mid-nineties. Studies show that ER alpha and
Kong; 2Department of Pathology, University of Hong Kong, Hong
beta have their own unique cell-specific expression patterns and
Kong, Hong Kong
actions and may also have mutual antagonistic roles if present in
Objective To evaluate the effectiveness of primary human the same tissue.
papillomavirus (HPV) testing combined with cytology in cervical Aim and objectives The aim of the research was to study and
cancer screening in a Chinese population. compare the expression of ER alpha and beta in ectocervix of
Design Prospective randomised controlled trial with 2 screening healthy women and cervical cancer patients.
rounds about 3 years apart in a Chinese population, comparing Design Case–control study.
high-risk HPV testing combined with liquid-based cytology (LBC) Methods One gram of cervical tissue was taken from 30 cervical
versus LBC alone. cancer patients (cases) and 20 healthy women (controls) and
Methods Women aged 30–60 attending health clinics for routine subjected to immunohistochemical analysis. The expression
cervical screening were recruited and randomised with 1:1 ratio pattern of ER alpha and beta was studied in terms of number of
into an intervention group (HPV testing with LBC) and a control women expressing the receptor and their respective
group (LBC alone). Digene HC 2 High-risk HPV DNA test was immunoreactivity scores and compared between healthy and
used for HPV testing. Women in the intervention group would be cancerous cervix.
referred to colposcopy and biopsy immediately if they were found Results Ectocervical cells of normal and cancerous cervix
to have high-risk HPV regardless of the cytology result. Women expressed both ER alpha and beta in their nuclei and only ER
in the control group would be managed according to standard beta in their cytoplasm. 90% of controls expressed ER alpha in
cervical screening protocol. Women were scheduled for second the ectocervix compared to only 6.67% of cases (P = 0.000) while
round of screening with LBC alone 36 months after the baseline there was comparable expression of ER beta between the 2 groups
round. The primary outcome was the detection rate of high-grade (80% versus 90%). The mean immunoreactivity scores for ER
cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). Results were analysed by alpha expression was also lower in cervical cancer patients
intention to treat. (0.167 0.75) compared to healthy women (2.60 2.01)
Results Over a 4-year period, a total of 15955 women were (P = 0.000). The mean score of ER beta was higher in cases
recruited into the study and were randomised into intervention (5.4 4.21) than controls (4.65 3.28), and the difference was
group (n = 7979) and control group (n = 7976). Majority of the not significant.
women had been attending regular screening prior to entry to the Conclusion ER alpha and beta have different expression patterns
study. At baseline screen, high-grade cytology was found in 0.13% in ectocervical cells. ER alpha is significantly downexpressed, while
of all women. The detection of CIN3+ lesions was significantly ER beta expression is retained or slightly increased in cervical
higher in the intervention group compared to the control (0.62% cancer cells when compared to normal cervix.
versus 0.2%, OR 3.06, 95% CI 1.78–5.58). At the subsequent
round of screening, however, CIN3+ detection was significantly
lower in the intervention group (0.07% versus 0.24%, OR 0.27, CI 2171
0.08–0.76). Over 2 rounds of screening, the total detection of
The low risk of CIN2+ in triage-negative HPV-
CIN3+ was higher in the intervention group (0.67% versus 0.39%,
positive women 5 years after primary screening
OR 1.71, CI 1.1–2.69). The no. of colposcopies done was four-
fold (10.6% versus 2.4%) higher in the intervention arm. Stanczuk, G1; Currie, H2; Forson, W2; Palmer, T3;
Conclusion Our results confirmed that the addition of a HPV test Cuschieri, K4
to cytology in primary cervical screening led to earlier detection of 1
Western Isles Hospital, Stornoway, UK; 2Dumfries and Galloway
clinically significant pre-invasive lesions resulting in a fall in the Royal Infirmary, Dumfries, UK; 3NHS Highlands, Inverness, UK;
4
incidence of high-grade lesions in the subsequent rounds. Triage Scottish HPV Reference Laboratory, Edinburgh, UK
for HPV-positive women is necessary to reduce colposcopy
referrals. (ClinicalTrials.gov NCT01058460) Objective The optimal triage of screen-positive women is one
of the most important considerations when introducing primary
human papillomavirus (HPV) testing. Performing liquid-based
cytology (LBC) on HPV-positive (HPV+) women and/or limited
genotyping has been recommended as a triage strategy in
several settings including the UK. Additionally p16/ki-67 dual-
10 ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG
Abstracts
stained cytology is a credible triage approach. We previously Design We conducted a comparison between two cross-sectional
reported an evaluation of triage strategies in a cross-sectional surveys done in 2013 and 2019.
study where disease was ascertained at the time of the positive Methods A total of 639 women aged 21 years and above
triage. The aim of this study was to evaluate the cumulative attending the general gynaecology clinic in KK Women’s and
incidence rate (CIR) of high-grade cervical intraepithelial Children’s Hospital in March to July 2013 and January 2019 were
neoplasia (CIN2+) within 5 years of primary triage strategies of recruited by simple random sampling. Three hundred and
HPV+ women. nineteen women were surveyed in 2013, whereas 320 were
Design Population-based longitudinal study. surveyed in 2019. Participants were made to answer a
Methods The study population (n = 385) was nested in the questionnaire made available in English, Chinese, and Malay.
Papillomavirus Dumfries and Galloway (PaVDaG) study and Analyses were carried out using SPSS version 21.0.
comprised of HPV+ women, who all had HPV 16/18 typing, LBC, Results There is no significant difference in the awareness of
and p16/ki-67 dual-stained cytology at the first screening round. cervical cancer 88.4% (2019) versus 88% (2013) (P = 0.576).
The aim of PaVDaG study was to evaluate effectiveness of HPV However, there is a significant increase in understanding of risk
testing using LBC and self-collected vaginal and urine samples in factors and association of HPV infection with cervical cancer from
a Scottish population-based screening cohort. All participants 33.7% to 69.4% (P ≤ 0.001). Women are more aware of HPV
were re-called for the second screening round, which was based infection and vaccination from 43.7% (2013) to 56.3% (2019)
on LBC only as per current screening practice in Scotland. We (P = 0.002) and from 38.6% to 50.3% (P = 0.004), respectively.
used the second round screening results to describe CIR of CIN2+ This has resulted in a nonsignificant increase in acceptance of
within 5 years of primary HPV+ testing stratified by the various HPV vaccination from 44% to 49.5% (P = 0.470). Among
triage strategies with proportions reflected within 95% confidence participants who declined HPV vaccination, 91.6% attributed to
intervals. namely two reasons – cost and lack of knowledge. Major sources
Results The length of follow up was up to 5.5 years. Overall of information were from the internet and healthcare
compliance to screening was 90%. During the first and second professionals.
round of screening, 66 and 8 CIN2+ lesions were detected, Conclusion Our study demonstrates that awareness of the HPV
respectively. The HPV+ women with an LBC-negative triage had vaccine is directly related to the acceptability of the vaccine.
5-year CIR of CIN2+ of 9.4% (6.5–13.3%) compared with 7.2% Despite nationwide efforts to increase the public’s awareness of
(4.6–11.1%) in women who were p16/ki-67dual-stained cytology- cervical cancer and HPV vaccination, the level of awareness and
negative and 10.6% (7.5–15.0%) in women who were HPV 16/18- the acceptability of the HPV vaccine in Singapore is still below the
negative. Regarding combination approaches, HPV 16/18-negative/ reported level among developed countries. Also, uptake is low due
LBC-negative women had 5-year CIR of CIN2+ of 3.9% (2.0– to cost. In order to improve our HPV acceptance rates, our study
7.6%). Furthermore, women who were ‘triple’ triage-negative suggests that more intensive campaigns may need to be
(HPV16/18, LBC, and p16/ki-67 dual-stained) had the lowest CIR undertaken, including schools and in healthcare institutions. In
of CIN2+ of 2.4% (0.9–6.0%). addition, subsidies to reduce costs of the nanovalent vaccine and a
Conclusion Full analysis will be presented however; our initial school-based vaccination programme could also improve the
data indicate that multistep triage options may offer the greatest uptake rate.
longitudinal protection for concurrent and subsequent disease
compared to individual approaches. Cost-utility analyses that
incorporate the additional improvement in sensitivity/detection
2072
gained alongside additional cost and implications for colposcopy
are thus warranted. Developing trends in referrals to colposcopy unit
at GSTT
Majeed, G
Guys and St Thomas NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK
1283
A comparison of awareness and attitudes on Background Guys and St Thomas NHS foundation Trust has the
human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination in largest colposcopy unit in London and third largest in England.
Singapore: now versus 6 years before As young women who had HPV immunisation reach screening
Kwek, M; Ang, J; Kho, L age, there are changing trends in colposcopy referrals for both
KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital, Singapore, Singapore direct and clinical indications.
Objective To look at the trends of change in referrals and
Objective There have been nationwide education campaigns on underlying pathology.
HPV vaccination and the inclusion of HPV vaccine in the Aim Plan and deliver high-quality colposcopy service efficiently.
National Childhood and Adult Immunisation Schedule over the Methods Referrals to colposcopy unit both direct and clinical
years. The bivalent and quadrivalent vaccines were made claimable indications were identified using colposcopy database Viewpoint,
via Medisave since 2017. We assess changes in the awareness and colposcopy scorecard, and Cyres over four years (2014–2018).
attitudes in our population and evaluate the effectiveness of these Histology with subsequent treatment was reviewed.
campaigns.
ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG 11
Abstracts
Results Total referrals increased from (2015) n = 2852 to Results Only 48% of patients with abnormal glandular cells
n = 2950 in 2018. However, abnormal cytology reduced from originating from the cervix were seen within 2 weeks. Nine of
n = 1657 (2015) to n = 1537 in 2018, and at the same time, these patients had cancer. In contrast, 100% of patients with
clinical indications including others increased from n = 1195 in abnormal glandular cells of nonendocervical type were seen in
(2015) to n = 1413 in 2018. CINIII reduced from n = 172 (2015) gynaecology clinic. Thirteen out of 128 cases had an endometrial
to n = 121 (2018), and LLETZ procedures reduced from n = 479 biopsy, 5 of which showed malignancy (4 of endometrial type and
(2015) to n = 266 (2018). There were 38 cancers, and over four- one from the Fallopian tube). Eleven of these cases also had either
year period, only one was detected via clinical indication. Number an ultrasound of hysteroscopy. Ninety-five patients were less than
of cancers was n = 8 in 2018 and n = 11 in 2017. or equal to 40 years of age. The average depth of excision was
Conclusion Colposcopy referrals have increased over the last four 11 mm with a range of (4–30 mm). In those less than 1 cm
years. Main increase is in the clinical indications, and only 1 excised, there were 12 patients and 4 needed repeat excision. Two
cancer was detected. Prevalence of precancer is decreasing which of these patients had cancer but were known from the initial
may be due to primary prevention by HPV immunisation as these excision. Thirty-two patients were over 40 years of age. The
vaccinated young women are screened. Excisional treatment has average depth of excision was 15 mm (range 4–25 mm). twenty-
almost halved as more young women with CINII are managed six patients had specimens less than 20 mm in depth. Of those, 5
conservatively, n = 197 in 2015 versus n = 81 in 2018. had adenocarcinoma. All had repeat excisions, 4 of which showed
Recommendations GSTT colposcopy Unit is holding educational no residual disease.
meetings for GPs advising about appropriate referrals for women Conclusion These data were all largely representative of the pre-
with clinical indication especially through electronic referral 2016 guideline, and so a prospective audit is needed to analyse
system. VTS trainees are exposed to colposcopy clinics during adherence to the current guideline and standards.
their training to identify changes in cervix and pathology. An
audit of clinical indications is being undertaken via Pan London
Colposcopy group. With introduction of primary HPV screening,
three trainees are currently under training to meet the challenges.
2211
Each gynae oncologists conduct one clinic a month, and a unit Outcomes of referrals with glandular neoplasia
lead will conduct a clinic per week. Chiu, S1,2; Lyons, D2
1
Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London,
UK; 2Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, London, UK
12 ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG
Abstracts
Results The total number of referrals received over 18 years was bleeding, but no dyspareunia. She was up-to-date with negative
24 000, and glandular neoplasia accounted for 0.95%. The smear test. On clinical examination, multiple, smooth, polypoid
majority of patients had the site or origin delineated, the last masses were seen arising around the vaginal fornices; cervix was
10 years being 100% identified. Pre-invasive disease accounted for healthy. A biopsy was taken, and the histology report revealed
52.6%, of which HGCGIN accounted 26.3%, HGCIN 16.2%, and endometriosis within the vaginal wall.
mixed 10.1%. Invasive disease represented 21% with 18.4% being Discussion Endometriosis is characterised by the presence of
adenocarcinoma (cervical and noncervical), and the remaining histologically functioning endometrial glands and stroma outside
2.6% was SCC. LGCIN/benign was identified in 26.4%. Overall, the uterine cavity.
pre-invasive and invasive disease in this population accounted for The prevalence of endometriosis in the general population is
73.6%. In 2000–2009, 12.4% had nonendocervical disease, whereas difficult to estimate as some women are asymptomatic while those
4% were identified between 2010 and 2017. HGCGIN was also with symptoms can have varied and nonspecific presentations.
found to be increased in the last 8 years. This would have been However, endometriosis has been reported in up to 50% of
expected as nonendocervical disease was investigated using the women with infertility and up to 70% of women with pelvic pain.
rapid access pathway. Patients <36 y.o. only had cervical disease Abdominopelvic pain, dysmenorrhoea, dyspareunia, heavy
and were associated with an increased prevalence of HGCGIN in menstrual bleeding, and infertility are the commonest presenting
comparison with those >36 y.o, representing 48% and 27.4%, symptoms of women affected by endometriosis.
respectively. Endometriotic lesions predominantly locate in the pelvis, but
Conclusion Results are in keeping with literature, identifying a extra-pelvic locations have been described such as central nervous
high incidence of pre-invasive and invasive disease in referrals system, lungs, urinary and gastrointestinal tract, and surgical scars.
suggestive of glandular neoplasia. These patients therefore require The vagina, vulva, and perineum can also be affected usually
a rigorous investigative protocol to identify and treat pathology. secondary to surgical or obstetric trauma. Endometriosis of the
vagina following an uncomplicated vaginal delivery is a fairly rare
phenomenon.
This case report highlights the widespread locations in which
2395
endometrial tissue can be found and therefore the wide range of
Endometriosis presenting as a vaginal polyp: a case symptomatology.
report Conclusion Endometriosis should always be considered in women
Safioleas, P1; Mehr, M1; Liakou, C2 of reproductive age. The diagnosis might be challenging and
1
Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Kings Lynn, UK; 2Norfolk Norwich requires a high degree of clinical suspicion and histological
University Hospital, Norwich, UK confirmation. The clinical doctor should bear in mind that
endometriosis can be multifocal; thus, a thorough investigation is
Background A 33-year-old woman with a vaginal wall polyp was required in every case.
referred to gynaecology outpatient for evaluation and
management. Her past medical and surgical history were
unremarkable, she had a normal vaginal delivery four months ago,
and at the time of referral, she was on progesterone-only pill and
therefore amenorrhoeic. The patient reported mild post-coital
ª 2019 The Authors. BJOG An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology ª 2019 RCOG 13