Professional Documents
Culture Documents
html
1
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF FOOD
AND NUTRITIONAL SCIENCES
Annie Kuruvilla*
Department of Foods & Nutrition, Faculty of Family & Community Sciences, M. S .University of Baroda, Vadodara,
Gujarat, India.
*
Corresponding Author: apnaatul@hotmail.com
Received on: 18th December 2013 Accepted on: 10th July 2014
ABSTRACT
A formative research was carried out to assess the life-style related health and nutritional problems of
women prisoners and need based health promotion initiatives were conducted and the impact assessed. The present
study was undertaken with a central aim to promote health among the women prisoners of the Vadodara Central Jail,
Gujarat. Vadodara Central Jail was chosen as the site for the study, and 120 women prisoners who were willing to
participate were enrolled. Majority of the women belonged to the age group of 31-50 years (43.4%). 68.3% were
illiterate and 96.7% were married. The women were from socio-economically under privileged sections of the
society. The prevalence of bone disorders was 78% and malnutrition was 61%. Mild mood disturbances (43.3%) and
borderline clinical depression (11.7%) was observed. 20% of the inmates were hypertensive. Nutrition health
education (NHE) on the topics related to diseases and its management, exercises & yoga were provided to them
thrice a week for a period of 3 months. A significant increase in knowledge was seen after the NHE sessions (p <
0.001). A kitchen garden concept was successfully implemented in the prison and vegetables grown in the garden
were harvested and incorporated in the jail menu. The current jail menu and jail ration followed since 1955, needed
modification and revision since it was deficient in important micronutrients like calcium and β carotene. Plain roti
was replaced by paushtik (nutritious) roti made by incorporating green leafy vegetables like spinach leaves,
fenugreek leaves, radish leaves and drumstick leaves and instead of single dal preparation, recipes containing
combination of different variety of dals were implemented. As a ready reckoner a health and wellness manual was
designed and published by the investigators which would serve as a reference for health promotion initiatives in all
the prisons of Gujarat. Funding: This study was partly funded by UGC (DSA SAP II). Acknowledgements: This
work was carried out by my research students Miss Priyanka Joshi and Miss Jemima Chauhan under my guidance
and supervision.
Keywords:- formative research, kitchen garden, jail menu, physical activity, health promotion, Nutrition health
education (NHE), lifestyle, calcium, β carotene, manual.
2 specials jails in Gujarat and no women jail and borstal Vadodara Central Jail which was further extended till
school as per Indian Prison Statistics 2011. May 2013.
Out of two central jails in Gujarat one is located in The present study was carried out on women
Vadodara i.e. Vadodara Central Jail and the other one is prisoners in an institutionalized setting of the Central Jail,
located in Ahmedabad i.e. Sabarmati central Jail. Vadodara. Initially there were around 150 female
The total numbers of jail inmates in Gujarat prisoners in Vadodara Central Jail, out of which 120
recorded at the end of the year 2011 are 11601out of subjects (convicts, under-trials and detained) were
which 11051are male inmates and 550are female inmates. enrolled in the study.
In Gujarat the total number of female inmates are 550 out The study was divided into four phases –
of which 176 are convicts, 328 are under trials and 46 are
detunes recorded at the end of the year 2010 (Source – COLLECTION OF BASELINE DATA OF FEMALE
Indian Prison Statistics 2011, National Crime Records PRISONERS OF VADODARA CENTRAL JAIL
Bureau). This phase included collection of information on the
In India very minimal research has been done in following aspects –
the area of prison health and also there is paucity of Socio-demographic profile
published data regarding the prison studies particularly Reproductive status & morbidity profile
related to women prisoners‟ health needs and effective Mental health
prison health intervention studies. Anthropometric measurements
Women in prison tend to place a greater demand Bone health (Bone mineral density)
on the prison health services than men do. This is the case Semi-structured questionnaire was designed and
right from the start of their imprisonment, as so many was divided into different sections to collect
women prisoners have had no contact with health services information on various parameters like age,
during the period before admission to prison. As a religion, education, marital status, income level
consequence, most women in prison have little idea of and its source, type and length of imprisonment,
their own health status and may be less aware than most types of crimes committed, regarding money
people of healthy lifestyles. Moreover, women in prison order and work done by prisoners in jail,
have specific health issues; the most prominent are substance use pattern and reproductive status.
related to reproductive health such as menstruation,
The morbidity profile of women prisoners was
menopause, pregnancy and breastfeeding, and mental
assessed using checklist of major and minor
health & substance abuse issues. Considering the above health problems.
the present study was undertaken with a broad objective
to promote health among the women prisoners of the
HEALTH PROMOTION INITIATIVES
Vadodara Central Jail through nutrition health
Kitchen garden
intervention and health promotion initiatives.
A kitchen garden was made in an area of 7500
sq feet around the female barracks in the new
METHODOLOGY women‟s jail. In the kitchen garden various
The research design was reviewed by the panel
fruits trees (70 to 80 tree saplings) like chickoo,
of members of the Institutional Ethics Committee for
mango, guava and seasonal vegetables like
Human Research and it was passed under the no.
brinjal, cabbage, cauliflower, fenugreek, radish
IECHR/2016/6.
leaves, drumstick etc. were planted with the help
The „No Objection Certificate‟ was first
of a professional gardener assisted by jail
obtained from the Inspector General of Prisons,
authorities who were experts in farming and
Ahmedabad and the Superintendent of the Vadodara
allied activities. The purpose behind the idea of
Central Jail. Unlike general population, prison population
the kitchen garden was to engage the prisoners
has peculiar characteristics regarding exertion of their
to help them divert their minds from stress and
rights, thus the following ethical considerations were
depression.
taken:
Modifications in the jail Menu
All participants were clearly explained that they
The current jail menu and existing jail ration was
had free choice to participate or refuse participation in
analysed and the nutritive value was calculated
study or drop out at any point in the duration of the study.
with the help of food composition tables.
Informed consent form was taken prior to survey. They
were given individual codes and information was Promoting physical activity and Yoga
obtained in a secure way to ensure confidentiality. The Along with educational sessions on physical activity and
permission was granted for a time period from July to health, they were also trained with some exercises and
November 2012 to carry out the research work in the yoga techniques for the purpose of management of non-
communicable diseases, bone and joint related disorders
like osteoporosis and osteoarthritis and also for relieving group of 51 – 65 years (30%). Table 2 shows the data
mental stress. regarding the socio economic characteristics of the
subjects.
NUTRITION HEALTH INTERVENTION
Female inmates were given need based Nutrition Table 1 - Age wise Distribution of Female Inmates
Health Education (NHE) with the help of slide show Age Group N= 120 %
presentations and verbal explanation of the topics. The 18-30 years 13 10.8
following topics were designed on the basis of the needs 31-50 years 52 43.4
assessment done –
Topics of NHE 51-65 years 36 30.0
Anemia, Menopause, Bone health and >65 years 19 15.8
osteoporosis Osteoarthritis, Diabetes, Physical Mean age 49.75 ± 15.09
activity, Healthy eating tips, Substance Abuse,
HIV/AIDS Table 2 - Socio Demographic profile of Female
Pictorial presentations were made on the above Inmates
mentioned topics to the female prisoners with the help of Sr. no. N = 120 %
a LCD projector provided by the jail authorities. The 1. Religion
NHE was given for 2 months and sessions were held
Hindu 96 80.0
thrice a week.
To assess their knowledge regarding various aspects of Muslim 24 20.0
nutrition and common health problems, a structured 2 Education
questionnaire was used pre and post intervention. Literate 38 31.7
Practices regarding the hygiene were assessed using a Illiterate 82 68.3
checklist. 3 Marital Status
Single 4 3.3
IMPACT ASSESSMENT Married 78 65.0
This phase included impact evaluation on Widowed 38 31.7
knowledge retention of NHE sessions provided to female 4 Have Children
prisoners. Impact assessment of health promotion Yes 114 98.3
initiatives was done by exit interview.
No 2 1.7
The data collected was entered in the excel sheet under
5. Employed
different sections and was analyzed using SPSS
(Statistical Package for Social Sciences) version 20. Yes 75 62.5
Frequency and percent responses were No 45 37.5
calculated for the data regarding socio-demographic 6. Occupation
profile, health profile, mental health, bone health and Unemployed 45 37.5
nutritional status. Government 2 1.7
Percent responses were calculated to assess the employee
knowledge retention. Pre and post scores were calculated Private 14 11.7
and appropriate statistical test was applied. organization
Qualitative data i.e. responses obtained from employee
interview were compiled and categorized. Percent Labourer 19 15.8
responses were calculated for the same. Housemaid 7 5.8
Agricultural work 26 21.7
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Small scale 7 5.8
business
BASELINE DATA OF FEMALE PRISONERS OF 7. Domicile
VADODARA CENTRAL JAIL Rural 84 70.0
Table 1 shows the age-wise distribution of the
Urban 36 30.0
female inmates of Vadodara Central Jail. The mean age
of female prisoners under study was 49.75 years ± 15.09. 8. Household monthly income
10.8% of the women were of 18-30 years, 43.4% were in <3000 53 44.2
the age group of 31 – 50 years, 30% were in 51-65 years 3000 – 6000 52 43.3
and 15.8% were above 65 years of age. It was observed >6000 15 12.5
that majority of female inmates belonged to age group of
31 – 50 years (43.4%) followed by women in the age
Majority of the female inmates (80%) were 10. Problems related to 4 3.3
Hindus. 68.3% of them were illiterate. 96.7% of women Endocrine system
were married, and of them 31.7% were widowed and only 11. Skin disorders 9 7.5
3.3% were single. Majority (98.3%) of the inmates had 12. Eye problems 6 5.0
children. 62.5% were employed in different types of 13. Miscellaneous 72 60
occupation before coming to prison. Among those who problems
were employed most of them were engaged in agriculture
(21.7%) and labour work (15.8%) prior to incarceration. Till date many mega medical camps had been
70% of the inmates were from rural areas. Majority of done in the prison, but only preliminary investigations
them had household monthly income either <Rs 3000 or like BP, weight, height and few basic check-ups were
between Rs 3000 to 6000. done. The data regarding the same was not documented
The socio demographic profile suggests that and even follow up was not done. Mental health of the
majority of the women were from socio-economically female inmates was assessed using Beck Depression
under privileged sections of the society. Out of the literate Inventory (BDI). Percent prevalence and degree of
population (31.7%), most of the inmates (57.9%) had depression among subjects obtained are presented in
primary education, 13.2% had secondary education, Table 4.
10.5% had higher secondary and 18.4% were graduates
and above. Table 4 - Degrees of depression among female inmates
Miscellaneous problems (60%) were the highest as per Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)
that were reported among the female inmates. List of Grades of Depression N = 120 %
miscellaneous problems reported were as follows: fever, Normal 52 43.3
breathlessness, neck pain, lower back pain, pain in hand Mild mood disturbance 52 43.3
legs, weakness etc. In a study conducted by (1) in Borderline clinical 14 11.7
Bangalore prison, it was found that the commonest depression
problems reported by prisoners were back or neck
Moderate depression 2 1.7
problems. Similar problems were also reported by the
Severe depression 0 0
female inmates in the present study.
45% of the inmates reported problems related to
gastrointestinal tract. Heartburn and acidity were the Almost half of the female prisoners reported
highest reported problems by the inmates. Other mild mood disturbances (43.3%), 11.7% were found to
gastrointestinal problems were flatulence, nausea, have borderline clinical depression and only 1.7%
vomiting, gastritis, diarrhoea and constipation. showed moderate depression. No severe depression was
35% of the inmates reported problems related to found among the female inmates according to Beck
central nervous system. Tension headache was the highest Depression Inventory (BDI).
reported problem under central nervous system. Other In prevalence study conducted by ² among
problems reported were migraine, sleep disturbances, women prisoners in Pakistan, it was found that 43.8% had
peripheral neuropathy (table 3). mild depression, 12.5% had moderate depression, and
3.1% had severe depression.
Table 3- Morbidity profile of the prisoners Mental health in prison frequently remains
undiagnosed or under diagnosed. Depression can cause
Sr. no. List of problems N %
mental impairment. Untreated depression can have
1. Problems of Oral cavity 20 16.7
serious effects. It diminishes the pleasure of living,
2. Problems of Gastro- 54 45
including appetite; it can exacerbate other medical
intestinal tract
conditions and can compromise immune function ³. Thus
3. Problems of 0 - initiatives were taken in this study to promote mental
Hepatobiliary tract health among the prisoners through physical activity,
4. Problems of Pancreas 0 - yoga and gardening activities.
5. Problems related to 28 23.3 Data on physical parameters (height and weight)
Respiratory tract was collected using standard anthropometric techniques.
6. Problems related to 23 19.2 The percent prevalence of underweight, overweight and
Cardiovascular system obesity was calculated.
7. Problems related to 15 12.5 Table 5 shows the prevalence of malnutrition
Genito-urinary system among female inmates as per Asia pacific cut offs.
8. Problems pertaining to 25 20.8 It was found that 61% of the female inmates were
Locomotor system malnourished and out of them 14% were found to be
9. Problems related to 42 35.0 under weight and 37% were obese and 10% were at risk
Central nervous system of obesity.
Table 5 - BMI classification of the female prisoners as Prevalence of under nutrition was found more
per Asia pacific cut offs among the age group of 18 to 30 years. Inmates who
Grade of malnutrition N=100 % belonged to the age group of 51 – 65 years were found to
Normal (BMI 18.5 – 22.5) 39 39% be more obese as compared to others (shown in table 6).
Underweight (BMI< 18.5 ) 14 14% Women prisoners face problems of both under and over
Overweight (BMI 23 – 24.5) 10 10% nutrition, with high number of obese and overweight
women especially in the age group 51 years and above.
Obese (BMI ≥ 25) 37 37%
This is of grave and serious concern, since gardener, assisted by men prisoners (10 to 15 of them).
hypertension, mental depression and menopause were Since the men prisoners were agricultural farmers and
also most prevalent in this age group, thereby increasing labourers, they had good skill for planting, watering and
the risk of non-communicable diseases. Thus it was all nurturing the plants. A professional gardener was
the more appropriate to conduct a Nutrition health employed on a daily basis for 3 months immediately after
intervention program suggesting life style modifications. the monsoon season (July to September 2012). Seasonal
vegetables which were suitable for Gujarat climate
HEALTH PROMOTION INITIATIVES (brinjal, cabbage, fenugreek, tomato, spring onion,
Health promotion initiatives were planned looking cauliflower etc.) were grown and even harvested by
into the needs assessment, the availability and scope for December the same year. A garden lawn with carpet grass
intervention. Since the majorities of the women were in and landscaping was made towards one part of the wall
the middle age (31 – 55 years) and were having which could serve as a place for recreation and relaxation
osteopenia, moderate levels of depression and life-style for the women prisoners when not in the barracks
related health problems, a practical strategy was devised.
To improve mental and physical health, prevent
deterioration in health during imprisonment and to
encourage them to adopt a positive attitude, the following
health promotion initiatives were undertaken:
KITCHEN GARDEN
Contact with nature (gardens and parks)
positively impacts blood pressure, cholesterol, outlook on
life and stress reduction (4-6). From empirical, theoretical
and anecdotal evidence it was suggested that contact with
nature (gardens and parks) was an effective strategy in the
prevention of mental ill health (7) Exposure to nature Figure 1- A Prison inmate nurturing the plant
enhances the ability to cope with and recover from stress,
illness and injury (8). People have a more positive outlook
on life and higher life satisfaction when in proximity to
nature (9).
The women‟s jail had lot of open spaces between the
barracks which could be utilized effectively. A layout of a
kitchen garden in a area of 7500 sq. feet with fruit trees
and seasonal vegetables was designed and was given for
approval to the jail authorities.
Nearly 70 to 80 fruit tree-saplings each 5 feet
high (guava, sapota, drumstick, mango) were planted on
the boundaries and sidewalks of an area of 7500 sq feet
land in the center of two barracks by a professional Figure 2 - Brinjal plant
inmates to improve their knowledge levels for better were done for the prison inmates. The impact of health
control and management of such diseases. promotion initiatives can be clearly observed from the
responses. The purpose of kitchen garden was served as
DEVELOPMENT OF IEC MATERIALS inmates felt relieved of stress when they sat around the
Nutrition books, research reports and some authentic garden or did gardening activity. Modified recipes were
websites were referred and relevant information was accepted by both prison officials and prisoners and these
collected from these sources on the following topics: are still being followed in the jail menu till date. The
Anemia purpose of NHE sessions and physical activity sessions
Menopause had brought a positive change in the habits of the inmates.
Bone health and osteoporosis As a ready reckoner a health and wellness manual was
Osteoarthritis designed and published by the investigators which would
Diabetes serve as a reference for health promotion initiatives in all
Physical activity the prisons of Gujarat.
Healthy eating tips.
HIV ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
My profound gratitude to UGC and the M.S.
Substance abuse
University for the grant sanctioned for the publication of
Power point presentations were prepared in local
the Health and Wellness Manual which would benefit the
language including pictures and graphics so that it could
prison staff and prisoners of all the prisons in Gujarat.
be easily understood by the female inmates as most of
The study was partly sponsored by UGC-DSA
them were illiterate.
SAP Programme of the Department. The data
collection and intervention was done by Miss. Priyanka
IMPARTING NUTRITION HEALTH EDUCATION
Joshi and Miss. Jemmima Chauhan who were pursuing
Health and nutrition education is a key tool to
their post graduate degree in the department.
bring about behaviour change in prevention and
management of nutritional disorders. A study conducted
by (18) assessed the impact of nutrition program on the REFERENCES
health benefits of prisoners and showed that health Math SB, Murthy P, Parthasarathy R, Naveen
education and proper diet improved anthropometric and Kumar C, Madhusudhan S Mental health and
biochemical parameters in the patients with substance use problems in prisons: Local lessons
cardiovascular risk factors. Thus need based Nutrition for national action. Publication National Institute
health education was imparted to the women prisoners. of Mental Health Neuro Sciences, Bangalore.
Hygiene practices were found to be excellent among 2011.
female inmates and so topics on hygiene were not much
emphasized. Sessions on the relevant topics were Khan at el 2012., Clarke J., Hofeldt R. M., Lihs
scheduled in the afternoon 4 to 5 pm, three times a week P., Loo R. K., Prabhu M. et al. 2007. A Captive
for two months. They were held in the computer room of Audience: Bringing the WISEWOMAN
the prison and pictorial presentations with the help of Program to South Dakota Prisoners. Women‟s
projector were shown to them and were explained Health Issues, 17, 193–201.
verbally. Sessions for under trials and convicts were held Mahan L.K. and Stump S.E. Krause‟s Food and
separately as they were not allowed to interact with each Nutrition Therapy. 2008, 12th edition
other.
Moore, E. O, A prison environment effects on
IMPACT ASSESSMENT health care service demands. Journal of
The post data on knowledge retention was environmental systems. 1981; 11, 17-34
collected using the same questionnaire after all the NHE
Parsons, R, Tassinary L. G, Ulrich, R. S, Hebl,
sessions were over after 2 months. The overall picture
N. R and Grossman- Alexander, M. The view
shows that there was improvement in the knowledge of
from the road; Implications for stress recovery
the inmates regarding health and nutrition aspects, which
and immunization. Journal of environmental
would help them to improve lifestyle in prison and adapt
psychology, 1998; 18, 113 -140
healthy choices within the confined environment of the
prison. Kaplan, R and Kaplan, S, The experience of
nature; a psychological perspective. Cambridge
CONCLUSION University Press, Cambridge, New York. 1989.
The responses showed that the prison authorities
were pleased with the health promotion activities that Cecily. M, Mardie. T, Anita. P, Peter. B and
Lawrence. S., Healthy nature, healthy people;