Professional Documents
Culture Documents
To cite this article: Sadako Kai, Hiroyuki Kai, Osamu Tabata & Hideo Tashiro (1993)
The Significance of Posterior Open Bite After Anterior Repositioning Splint Therapy for
Anteriorly Displaced Disk of the Temporomandibular Joint, CRANIO®, 11:2, 146-152, DOI:
10.1080/08869634.1993.11677956
Download by: [Australian Catholic University] Date: 27 September 2017, At: 15:29
• CASE REPORTS
0886-9634/1102- ABSTRACT: Spontaneous posterior open bite was observed in 15 patients after the application of ante-
Downloaded by [Australian Catholic University] at 15:29 27 September 2017
0146$03.00/0, THE
JOURNAL OF rior repositioning splints in the treatment of anterior1y displaced disk. Recapture of the disk after treat-
CRANIOMANDIBULAR ment was clinically diagnosed in five patients. Arthrography performed on 10 patients with open bite
PRACTICE,
Copyright© 1993 revealed a completely recaptured disk in four patients, an anterior1y displaced disk without reduction in
by CHROMA, Inc. four patients, and an anterior1y displaced disk with reduction in two patients. This suggests that recap-
Manuscript received ture of the disk in the correct position at mouth closing should be a major cause of the posterior open bite
March 3, 1992; revised
manuscript received in patients who have a relatively short duration of locking and successful mandibular manipulation.
August 11, 1992; accepted Although the cause of posterior open bite with the persistently displaced disk is still unclear, an increase
October 9, 1992
in the posterosuperior joint space by the posterior open bite appears to eventually produce favorable
Address for reprint requests:
Dr. Sadako Kai, D.D.S. effects to joints with anterior1y displaced disks.
First Department of
Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
Faculty of Dentistry
T
Kyushu University he recognition of the concept of internal derange-
3-1-1 Maidashi, Higashiku, ments of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ)I. 2
Fukuoka, 812 Japan
has directed clinical attention toward the spatial
Dr. Sadako Kai received her D.D.S. relationship between the disk and the condyle. Thus, the
degree from Kyushu University in 1977
and her D.D.Sc. degree from the same anterior repositioning splint has recently become a
institution in 1982. She has been working common therapeutic appliance for internal derangements.
as an oral surgeon and an instructor in It is generally applied to patients with anteriorly dis-
the First Department of Oral and
Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of placed disks with reduction in order to maintain a correct
Dentistry, Kyushu University since 1981, disk-condylar relationship during all phases of mouth
and has actively treated and researched movement. In patients with closed lock (anterior disk dis-
TMJ disorders since /987. Dr. Kai has
focused her professional interest on the placement without reduction), it is applied after success-
relationship between occlusal problems ful mandibular manipulation. 3 In the course of treatment
and TMJ disorders. with the anterior repositioning splint, we observed 15
patients whose posterior open bite persisted after removal
of the splint. This report describes these cases and dis-
cusses the mechanical causes of the posterior open bite.
Case Reports
Dr. Hiroyuki Kai received his D.D.S.
degree from Kyushu University in 1983.
He has been at First Department of Oral Case I: A 31-year-old Woman
and Maxillofacial Surgery, Faculty of
Dentistry, Kyushu University since 1983
and has actively treated and researched The patient visited our clinic complaining of limited
oral maxillofacial lesions. Dr. Kai is a mouth opening with pain in the left TMJ and the masseter
member of the Japanese Society of Oral muscles. She had reciprocal clicking in the left TMJ for
Maxillofacial Surgeons and the Japanese
Society ofTMJ. three months, followed by a sudden limitation of her
mouth opening for 10 days.
At the first visit, maximal interincisal distance was
20 mm and the mandible at mouth opening was remark-
146
KAI ET AL POSTERIOR OPEN BITE
Figure3
Arthrotomograms of Case I with a posterior open bite shows the
complete recapture of the disk, even after removal of the splint:
A. At mouth closing; B. At mouth opening.
Figure 1
Posterior open bite of Case I after three days of anterior repositioning
splint therapy. A. The mandibular arch was located about 1.5 mm Figure4
anterior to that before treatment. B. There was intermaxillary contact Left lateral view of a silver splint cemented on the bicuspid and molar
at the second molars bilaterally. region to fill the space of the open bite.
APRIL 1993, VOL. 11, NO. 2 THE JOURNAL OF CRANIOMANDIBULAR PRACTICE 147
POSTERIOR OPEN BITE KAI ET AL.
FigureS
Downloaded by [Australian Catholic University] at 15:29 27 September 2017
Occlusion after the final prosthetic treatment. The patient was able to
open her mouth smoothly up to 45 mm without pain or deviation of the
mandible.
148 APRIL 1993, VOL 11, NO. 2 THE JOURNAL OF CRANIOMANDIBULAR PRACTICE
KAI ET AL. POSTERIOR OPEN BITE
APRIL 1993, VOL. 11, NO. 2 THE JOURNAL OF CRANIOMANDIBULAR PRACTICE 149
POSTERIOR OPEN BITE KAI ET AL.
Table 1
Fifteen patients with posterior open bite
after anterior repositioning splint therapy
before treatment after development of posterior open bite
case age sex duration until postenor
diagnosis* duration of maximal interincisal diagnosis* maximal interincisal open bite was posterior
locking distance (mm) distance (mm) confirmed (days) contact
I 31 F AD 10 days 20 Nt 46 7 +
2 15 F AD(intermittent) - 40 N 58 +
3 25 F AD 14 days 22 ADt 36 10 +
4 26 F ADR 45 Nt 45 I
5 24 M AD 3 days 28 Nt 55 0 +
6 30 F ADR 43 Nt 43 30 +
7 16 F ADt 10 days 30 ADRt 46 7 +
8 21 F AD 8 days 29 ADRt 51 8 +
Downloaded by [Australian Catholic University] at 15:29 27 September 2017
open bite after the manipulation, ranging from immedi- loose organized connective tissue which is not designed
ately after the manipulation to 30 days after. However, for loading. The posterior attachment is compressed
the exact time of onset of the open bite was unclear in the between the condyle and the fossa when the disk is dis-
majority of patients. While open bite was bilaterally placed anteriorly. If the disk is recaptured correctly, the
observed in some cases, all of the cases had the unilateral posterior band is at the 12 o'clock position of the condyle
displaced disk. at mouth closing. This change results in increased joint
space dimension between the condyle and the fossa,
Discussion especially in the posterosuperior portion of the joint. In
150 APRIL 1993, VOL. 11, NO. 2 THE JOURNAL OF CRANIOMANDIBULAR PRACTICE
KAI ET AL. POSTERIOR OPEN BITE
other words, replacement of the posterior attachment space in which the posterior attachment tissue might
with the posterior band should reposition the mandible functionally adapt to the altered intracupsular conditions.
anteroinferiorly. Excellent results were obtained in 94% of the patients
There has been no report of posterior open bite after concerning the range of maximal mouth opening and pain
surgical correction of disk position (disk plication in the TMJ and masticatory muscles: excluding the fact
surgery). On the other hand, the postoperative arthro- that crepitation gradually occurred during the treatment.
graphy or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) shows fre- The development of an open bite may depend on the
quent recurrence of anteriorly displaced disk after duration of splint wear. This is because a posterior open
plication surgery. 9· 10 It seems that the recurrence depends bite frequently occurred in patients with anteriorly dis-
on insufficiency in the joint space to maintain the recap- placed disks without reduction before treatment, who had
tured disk in the correct position. Thus, the necessity of to wear the splint at all times to stay unlocked and to
occlusal rehabilitation is suggested. avoid recurrent locking. The explanation for this may be
Most patients did not recognize the onset of the poste- that the continuous anterior position of the condyle may
rior open bite because we instructed them to not attempt to surpass the volumetric expanding capacity of the poste-
Downloaded by [Australian Catholic University] at 15:29 27 September 2017
place the posterior teeth in contact after the removal of the rior disk attachment, 15 and the deficit so created increases
splint. However, it is believed that the open bite occurred the volume of joint fluid in the upper joint cavity. There
immediately after complete recapture of the disk in such is also a possibility that long-standing application of the
cases. This conjecture was evidently demonstrated in splint decreases or eliminates hyperactivity or hyper-
Case 2 (a 15-year-old woman who had intermittent closed tonicity of the elevator muscles, such as the masseter or
lock with two different occlusions). Accordingly, a poste- temporal muscles resuspending the mandible beneath the
rior open bite is definitely not an undesirable side effect of cranial base, thereby causing the posterior open bite.
splint therapy, but shows the occlusal disorders which These alterations may even enhance the degree of open
causes the disk to slip from the condyle. bite in patients with completely recaptured disks and
Lundh et al. 11 stated that a favorable effect of the ante- occurrence of open bite in the contralateral side.
rior repositioning splint is short duration. The majority of The possibility that the open bite was due to intrusion
patients reported pain and clicking and demonstrated ten- of the posterior teeth was excluded in this study by com-
derness following removal of the splint after six weeks of paring the models before and after treatment, and because
treatment. More permanent devices were needed to stabi- the patients had such a short duration of splint therapy
lize the mandible in an anterior position, thereby main- until the presence of a posterior open bite was confirmed.
taining the recaptured disk in a normal relation to the Additionally, when the occlusion with posterior open
condyle. Generally, the tedious walk back procedure 12· 13 bite had one or more intermaxillary contacts in the molar
requires much time to select a position as far posteriorly region, the stability appeared to be obtained more easily
as possible without displacing the disk anteriorly. The than when occlusion without contacts resulted. The sta-
presence of the posterior open bite shortens the procedure bility resulting from this posterior contact may influence
because occlusion with an open bite closely represents development of the posterior open bite on the contralat-
the final anteroposterior position of the mandible after the eral side in which the disk has not been displaced. Indeed,
occlusion is restored. most of the patients had unilateral or bilateral contacts at
A correct disk-condylar relationship failed to be main- the second molar. It goes without saying that these con-
tained in patients with anteriorly displaced disks after the tacts should not be equilibrated, as their removal may
occurrence of posterior open bite. However, the open bite induce recurrent displacement of the disk or pain due to
does not appear to be an undesirable condition, because it loss of the occlusal stability they provide.
increases the joint space; especially in the postero-
superior portion, where the stretched posterior attach- Conclusion
ment tissue exists under excessive loading from occlusal
forces. Increased joint space may be favorable to prevent This study indicates that complete recapture of an ante-
destructive changes of the disk and posterior attachment. riorly displaced disk changes the maxillomandibular rela-
We followed the course of symptoms in 35 patients tionship between the jaws, resulting in a posterior open
with persistent anteriorly displaced disks which failed to bite in patients with a short duration of locking. This
be ultimately recaptured by mandibular manipulation. 14 change shows the occlusal compensations causing or
These patients received conservative therapy with flat contributing to the displacement of the disk. The occlu-
occlusal splints in order to: (a) eliminate hyperactivity of sion change occasionally occurs when the disk is not
the masticatory muscles, and (b) achieve sufficient joint recaptured because the maxillomandibular relationship
APRIL 1993, VOL 11, NO. 2 THE JOURNAL OF CRANIOMANDIBULAR PRACTICE 151
POSTERIOR OPEN BITE KAI ET AL.
has been made more normal. Clinicians should pay atten- 9. Bronstain SL: Postsurgical TMJ arthrography. J Craniomandib Pract 1984;
2:165-171
tion to this resulting change in occlusion and symptoms 10. Conway WF. Hayes CW. Campbell RL. Laskin DM. Swanson KS:
of TMJ disorder in the course of treatment with the ante- Temporomandibular joint after meniscoplasty: Appearance at MR imag-
ing. Radiology 1991; 180:749-753
rior repositioning splint in order to select the most II. Lundh H. Westesson P-L. Kopp S. Tillstrom B: Anterior repositioning
suitable mandibular position (maxillomandibular splint in the treatment of temporomandibular joint with reciprocal click-
ings: Comparison with a flat splint and untreated control group. Oral
relationship). Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol1985; 60:131-136
12. Clark GT: The TMJ repositioning appliance: A technique for reconstruct-
ing. insertion. and adjustment. J Craniomandib Pract 1986; 4:37-46
Acknowledgements 13. Owen AH: Orthodontic/orthopedic therapy for craniomandibular pain dys-
function. Part A. Anterior disk displacement. Review of literature. J
Craniomandib Pract 1987; 5:357-366
The authors wish to thank Dr. Y. Yamasaki. Department of
14. Kai S. Kai H. Hamasaki A. Shirastuchi Y. Tashiro H: Clinical course of the
Pediatric Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, Kyushu University, for conservative treatment in patients with persistent anterior disk displace-
performing the orthodontic treatment in Case 2. The authors also ment without reduction. J lap Soc TMJ 1990; 2:34-46
acknowledge Dr. S. Nakashima, Second Department of Prosthetic 15. Westesson P-L. Kurita K. Eriksson L. Katzberg RW: Cryosectional obser-
vations of functional anatomy of the temporomandibular joint. Oral Surg
Dentistry, Faculty of Dentistry, Kyushu University, for performing Oral Med Oral Patholl989; 68:247-251
the final prosthetic treatment in Case I.
Downloaded by [Australian Catholic University] at 15:29 27 September 2017
References Dr. Osamu Tabata recei1•ed his D.D.S. degree from Kyushu University
in 198/. He has been an instructor in the Department of Oral and
I. Wilkes CH: Arthrography of the temporomandibular joints in patients with Maxillofacial Radiology. Faculty of Dentistry. Kyushu University since
the TMJ pain-dysfunction syndrome. Mimr Med 1978; 61 :645-652 /98/. He is a member of the Japanese Society of Oral Maxillofacial
2. Farrar WB. McCarty WL: Inferior joint space arthrography and characteris- Radiology and the Japanese Society ofTMJ. Dr. Tabata has focused his
tics of condylar paths in internal derangement of the TMJ. J Prosthet
professional interest on TMJ disorders.
Dent 1919; 41:548-555
3. Farrar WB. McCarty WL: A Clinical Outline of Joint Diagnosis and
Treatment. 7th Ed. Montgomery: Walker Printing Co. 1982:115-142
4. Murakami K. Matsui M. Iizuka T. Ono T: Recapturing the persistent ante-
riorly displaced disk by mandibular manipulation after pumping and Dr. Hideo Tashiro graduated from the Medical Faculty of Kyushu
hydraulic pressure to the upper joint cavity of the temporomandibular University in 1955. He then recei1•ed training in general surgery. neuro-
joint. J Craniomandib Pract 1987; 5:17-24 surgery. dentistry. and oral maxillofacial surgery at Kyushu University.
5. Kai H. Yamasaki Y. Kai S. Tashiro H: Evaluation of the treatments in plastic surgery at Tokyo Metropolitan Police Hospital, and oral and
young people with anteriorly displaced disc of the TMJ. Jap J Oral maxillofacial surgery at Dusseldorf University, Germany. Dr. Tashiro
MaxillofacSurg 1992; 38:127-137 was a professor and chairman of the Department of Oral and Maxillo-
6. Manzione JV. Tallents RH. Katzberg RW. Oster C. Miller TL: facial Surgery, Faculty of Dentistry at Kyushu University in 1974 and
Arthrographically guided splint therapy for recapturing the temporo- served as the Director of the University Dental Hospital from /979 to
mandibular joint meniscus. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Patlwl 1984;
1982. From 1985 to /989, he was the Dean of the Dental Faculty at
57:235-240
7. Tallents RH. Katzberg RW. Miller TL. et al.: Arthrographically assisted Kyushu University. Dr. Tashiro sen•ed as President of the Japan Society
splint therapy: Painful clicking with a nonreducing meniscus. Oral Surg of Head and Neck Cancer in 1977, the Japanese Stomatological Society
Oral Med Oral Pathol 1986; 61 :2-4 in 1986, and the Japanese Cleft Palate Association in /988.
8. Manco LG. Messing SG: Splint therapy evaluation with direct sagittal com-
puted tomography. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol1986; 61:5-11