TUGAS

REVIEW JURNAL METODE PICO

Oleh :
Shendy Wira Putra
(183310822)

Dosen Pembimbing:
Ns. Nova Yanti, M.Kep., Sp. Kep. MB

PRODI SARJANA TERAPAN KEPERAWATAN

POLTEKKES KEMENKES RI PADANG
TAHUN 2020
 A. Analisis Jurnal Evidence Based Practice (EBP) dengan PICO
Judul : Comparing The Effect Of Colactive Plus Ag Dressing Versus
Nitrofurazone And Vaseline Gauze Dressing In The Treatment Of Second-Degree
Burns.
Penulis : Salehi H., Momeni M., Ebrahimi M., Fatemi M.J., Rahbar H., Ranjpoor
F., Salehi A., Moosavizadeh F.
Tempat : Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Tahun : 2018

P Problem, patient, population

1. Problem : The Effect Of Colactive Plus Ag Dressing Versus Nitrofurazone And

Vaseline Gauze Dressing In The Treatment Of Second-Degree Burns.
2. Patient : Burn Patients at Shahid Motahari Burn Hospital in Tehran, Iran.
3. Population : 25 patients with superficial second-degree burns were evaluated.
Nineteen patients (76%) were male and 6 patients (24%) were female. Mean age
was 14.2±31 years.
I Intervention, prognosting, factor atau exposure.
This was a randomized clinical trial study involving 25 cases. A superficial second-
degree burn area was divided into two parts in each patient; randomly, traditional
dressing was used on one area, and ColActive plus Ag dressing on the other. Every 3
days, after removing the dressings and washing the wounds, wound surface area was
evaluated by medical photographic records and J image software. Wound surface area in
the two groups was compared before dressing and on the 3rd, 6th, 9th and 12th day
afterwards. The difference was not significant before dressing, but significant on the 3rd,
6th, 9th and 12th post-operative day. The difference was significant in both groups, but it
was more prominent in the ColActive group.

C Comparison /Perbandingan
Shokoh Varaei , Tehran University of Medical Sciences School of Nursing and
Midwifery : There is a signicant difference in epithelialization parameter and (BWAT)
scores between intervention and control area. Based on this study it looks like that aloe
vera gel could promoted epithelialization and wound closure more effectively than 2%
Nitrofurazone ointment
O Outcome yang ingin diukur /ingin dicapai
 Considering the results of this study and good results in previous case reports, ColActive
may be more effective than traditional dressing. We suggest a more comprehensive study
for a longer period with a larger number of cases to compare other important variables
such as scar quality, cost, and pain in the two dressings.
Link jurnal : https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6367865/pdf/Ann-Burns-and-
Fire-Disasters-31-204.pdf

Link Jurnal Pembanding : https://assets.researchsquare.com/files/rs-16854/v2/d1eff602-e898-

4d74-8e60-60de599e66b4.pdf