Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • A Predictive Model For Automatic Detection of Social Isolation

    Uploaded by

    Qirtas Malik
    8 views8 pages

    Original Title

    A Predictive Model for Automatic Detection of Social Isolation

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    8 views8 pages

    A Predictive Model For Automatic Detection of Social Isolation

    Uploaded by

    Qirtas Malik

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 8

    2017 13th International Conference on Intelligent Environments

    CE87<6G<I8@B78?9BE4HGB@4G<678G86G<BAB9FB6<4?
    <FB?4G<BA<AB?78E47H?GF
    

    ?<6<4$4EG<A8M-<E:<A<4&EG<M H:BFGE474 $<:H8?BAM4?8M


    8C4EG@8AGB9B@CHG8E*6<8A68 %&+ 8C4EG@8AGB9B@CHG8E*6<8A68
    % + $8K<6B<GL$8K<6B +*$$8K<6B
    H8EA4I464$8K<6B ;H:B 8FGE474<A9BG86 @K @:BAM4<G8F@ @K
    N4@4EG<A8MI<6>L BEG<MO68A<78G 87H 
    @K
    
    
                  <AFGEH@8AGF4E84E<8A7F;<CF64?8G;<F6BAF<FGFB9F<K#<>8EG
        "   DH8FG<BAF 45BHG C8E68<I87 FB6<4? FHCCBEG 9EB@ 94@<?L 4A7
     "     9E<8A7F 23 5 +;8 *B6<4? *HCCBEG (H8FG<BAA4<E8 G;<F F64?8
                 <78AG<9<8F G;8 FB6<4? FHCCBEG F4G<F946G<BA FB6<4? C4EG<6<C4G<BA
              4A7 @4G8E<4? 4<7 23 6 AI8AGBEL B9 *B6<4??L *HCCBEG<I8
           "  8;4I<BEFG;<F<AFGEH@8AG4FF8FF8F<AFGEH@8AG4?<A9BE@4G<BA4?
     "     "   4A7 FB6<4? FHCCBEG 23 4A7 9<A4??L 7 +;8 #H558A *B6<4?
             %8GJBE> F64?8 G;<F F64?8 @84FHE8F FB6<4? FHCCBEG 98?G 9EB@
                 
    9E<8A7F4A794@<?L<AB?78E47H?GF +;8F8<AFGEH@8AGFF;4E8G;8
              
    6B@@BA B5=86G<I8 B9 4FF8FF<A: G;8 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA
               
       !  
    J<G; 7<4:ABF<F 54F87 BA F8GF B9 DH8FG<BAF 9EB@ FB6<4? FHCCBEG
    98?G23 
    #"$     !  +;84<@B9G;<FC4C8E<FGBCE8F8AGG;8<@C?8@8AG4G<BAB94
     CE87<6G<I8 @B78? G;4G C8E@<G G;8 4HGB@4G<6 78G86G<BA B9 G;8
     %+)&,+ &%
    ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA <A B?78E 47H?GF 2 3  +B 46;<8I8 G;<F
    B5=86G<I84FB9GJ4E84CC?<64G<BAJ4F78I8?BC87G;4GC8E@<GG;8
    GCE8F8AGG<@84?@BFG @<??<BAC8BC?8<AG;8JBE?74E8 @BA<GBE<A:B9 G;874<?L 46G<I<G<8FB9 4AB?78E47H?G J;<6; 4E8
    BI8E  L84EFB?7 +;8 FB6<4?FG4G<FG<6F <A7<64G87 G;4G <A   @4CC87 J<G; G;8 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? 789<A87 <A G;<F E8F84E6;
    C8BC?8 4:87   4A7 BI8E J<?? 58  5<??<BA G;4G <F @BE8 G;4A JBE> +;8FB9GJ4E84CC?<64G<BA4??BJF94@<?L@8@58EF9E<8A7F
    B9G;8JBE?7FCBCH?4G<BA +;8:EBJG;B9G;<FF8:@8AGB9 BE64E8:<I8EFB9G;88?78E?LGB58<A9BE@87J;8AG;8B?78E47H?G
    FB6<8GL;4F?87GB:E84G8E4GG8AG<BA58<A:C4<7GBG;8C4EG<6H?4E CE8F8AG 4A <FB?4G87 C4GG8EAF 466BE7<A: J<G; G;8 CE87<6G<I8
    A887FB9G;88?78E?L4A7G;8CEB5?8@F946875L@4ALB9G;8@ @B78? 
    2 3  66BE7<A: GB G;8 .BE?7 84?G; &E:4A<M4G<BA .& 4??
    <A7<I<7H4?FBI8E  L84EF4E86BAF<78E87 GB588?78E?LC8BC?8  +;8 C4C8E <F FGEH6GHE87 4F 9B??BJF *86G<BA  78F6E<58F
    $8K<6B <F 6HEE8AG?L HA78E:B<A: 4 78@B:E4C;<6 GE4AF<G<BA 546>:EBHA7 4A7 E8?4G87 JBE>F B9 G;<F E8F84E6;  A *86G<BA 
    J;<6;FH::8FGFG;4G5L  BA8<A9BHEC8BC?8J<??58BI8E  CE8F8AGF BHE CE87<6G<I8 @B78? CEBCBF87 9BE 78G86G<A:
    L84EFB?722 33  4HGB@4G<64??L FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA  *86G<BA  CE8F8AGF E8FH?GF
    B5G4<A87 B9 G8FGF 4CC?L<A: GB 8KC8E<@8AG4? :EBHC  <A4??L
    +;8 4:<A: B9 FB6<8GL ;4F 4EBHF87 G;8 <AG8E8FG B9 ;84?G; *86G<BACE8F8AGFG;86BA6?HF<BAF4A79HGHE8JBE> 
    <AFG<GHG<BAF 4A7E8?4G87 4E84F GB <@CEBI8 G;8 J8??58<A:B9 G;8
    B?78E47H?GF  AG;<F6BAG8KG9<A7<A:89986G<I8J4LFGBCEBI<78  ")&,%%)#+.&)"
    64E8 9BE G;8 B?78E 47H?GF ;4F 586B@8 BA8 B9 G;8 :E84G8FG +;<F F86G<BACE8F8AGF JBE>FG;4G4E8 6?BF8E8?4G87 J<G; G;8
    6;4??8A:8F9BEF6<8AG<9<66B@@HA<GL23  E8F84E6;CE8F8AG87<AG;<FC4C8E  A234FG4G<FG<64?4A4?LF<FJ4F
    *B6<4? <FB?4G<BA <F 789<A87 4F G;8 ?46> B9 6BAG46G 4A7 C8E9BE@87 GB <78AG<9L FB6<4? <AG8E46G<BA 46G<I<G<8F G;4G ;4I8 4
    <AG8E46G<BAJ<G;BG;8EF23 *B6<4?<FB?4G<BA<FBA8B9G;8<FFH8F FG4G<FG<64??L F<:A<9<64AG 6BEE8?4G<BA J<G; G;8 78:E88 B9 FB6<4?
    G;4G4E88K468E54G87<AB?78E47H?G7H8GB946GBEFFH6;4F?45BE <FB?4G<BA B9 4A B?78E 47H?G  +;8 @4<A 7<998E8A68 58GJ88A G;<F
    E8G<E8@8AG 6;<?7E8A ?<I<A: <A 7<998E8AG C?468F BE ?BFF B9 4 CE8I<BHF JBE> 4A7G;8 E8F84E6; CE8F8AG87 <A G;<FC4C8E <FG;4G
    FCBHF8  A 84E?L 7<4:ABF<F B9 G;<F 6BA7<G<BA F<:A<9<64AG?L 9<EFG BA?L 9B6HF87 <AGB G;8 FG4G<FG<64? 4A4?LF<F 4A7 G;8 ?4GG8E
    E87H68FG;8E<F>B978CE8FF<BA6B:A<G<I8<@C4<E@8AG786E84F87 477E8FF8F G;8 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? <GF <@C?8@8AG4G<BA 4A7
    9BB7 <AG4>8 E87H687 C;LF<64? 8K8E6<F8 BE <@CBI8E<F;@8AG B9 8I4?H4G<BA B9 G;8 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? CEBCBF87 <A 4 FB9GJ4E8
    G;8FB6<4?A8GJBE>23  4CC?<64G<BAJ;<6;4HGB@4G<64??L6B??86GFG;8E8?8I4AG4GGE<5HG8F
    9BEG;8CE87<6G<I8@B78? 
    G CE8F8AG G<@8 G;8E8 4E8 F8I8E4? CFL6;B?B:<64?
    <AFGEH@8AGF 78AB@<A4G87 F64?8F GB 4FF8FF G;8 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? +;8 9E4@8JBE> 2 3 <AGEB7H68F 4 ;H@4A9E<8A7?L C4EGA8E
    <FB?4G<BA <A B?78E 47H?GF  *B@8 B9 G;8F8 CFL6;B?B:<64? G;4G<F45?8GB;4I84A4GHE4?6B@@HA<64G<BAJ<G;8?78EC8BC?8

    2472-7571/17
    2472-7571 /17 $31.00 © 2017 IEEE 68
    DOI 10.1109/IE.2017.35

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    HF<A: E8?8I4A68 G;8BEL  66BE7<A: G;8 E8FH?GF B9 G;8 E8F84E6; &HE CE87<6G<I8 @B78? 9BE 78G86G<A: FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA J4F
    JBE>G;88?78E?LC8BC?864A6;86>G;8<E?<I<A:6BA7<G<BAFHF<A: B5G4<A875L4A8KC?BE4GBEL4A4?LF<FB94F8GB9I4E<45?8FE8?4G87
    I<FH4?<M4G<BAFFLFG8@5H<?G5LHF<A:?<98?B:74G4<A<A9BE@4G<BA GBG;874<?L46G<I<G<8FC8E9BE@875L4AB?78E47H?G +;8E8FH?GB9
    FGEH6GHE87FC468 +;<F<A9BE@4G<BA64A4?FB58F;4E874A7HF87 G;<F 4A4?LF<F J4F 4 F8G B9 E8?8I4AG I4E<45?8F GB 78G86G FB6<4?
    5L G;8 8?78E?L C8BC?8VF 94@<?L 4A7 64E8:<I8EF 4F 4 E8@BG8 <FB?4G<BA 
    @BA<GBE  +;8 B5=86G<I8 B9 G;8 FLFG8@ <F GB 78G8E@<A8 HAHFH4?
    ?<98 C4GG8EAF BE HAHFH4? 58;4I<BE B9 8?78E C8BC?8 GB 46DH<E8 +;878G86G87E8?8I4AGI4E<45?8F J8E8:EBHC87<A:EBHCF
    <@@87<4G8?L 4FF<FG4A68  +;<F E8F84E6; JBE> <F G;8E89BE8 6B@@HA<64G<BA@B5<?<GL4A778@B:E4C;<6I4E<45?8F+45?8  
    9B6HF87<AGBG;878G8E@<A4G<BAB9:8A8E4?74<?L46G<I<G<8FJ;<?8 +;8 9<EFG :EBHC 6B@@HA<64G8F I4E<45?8F B5G4<A87 9EB@ G;8
    BHEE8F84E6;JBE><F68AG8E87<AGBFB6<4?<FB?4G<BA  B?78E 47H?GVF 6B@@HA<64G<BA HF<A: ;8E
    ;<F @B5<?8 C;BA8
    %H@58E B9 <A6B@<A: 94@<?L 64??F 4I8E4:8 7HE4G<BA B9
    +;8 E8F84E6; JBE> 2 3 CEBCBF8F 4 :8EBAG86;AB?B:<64? <A6B@<A: 94@<?L 64??F $<A  AH@58E B9 <A6B@<A: 64??F 9EB@
    9E4@8JBE>J;<6;8A45?8FE84?G<@84A76BAG<AHBHF@BA<GBE<A: 9E<8A7F4I8E4:87HE4G<BAB9BHG:B<A:64??FGBG;894@<?L$<A 
    B9 8@BG<BA4? FG4G8F B9 G;8 B?78E 47H?G 4A7 466BE7<A: GB G;8 AH@58E B9 @8FF4:8F F8AG GB G;8 E<8A7F 4A7 AH@58E B9
    78G86G878@BG<BA4A46G<BA<FC8E9BE@87GB5845?8GB6;4A:8 @8FF4:8F E868<I87 9EB@ G;8 94@<?L  +;8 F86BA7 :EBHC B9 G;8
    G;8 8@BG<BA4? FG4G8 B9 G;8 B?78E 47H?G  +;8 9E4@8JBE> $B5<?<GL <F BE<8AG87 GB G;8 @B5<?<GL B9 B?78E 47H?GF <AF<78 4A7
    E86B:A<M8F 8@BG<BAF G;EBH:; C;LF<B?B:<64? F<:A4?F 946<4? BHGF<78G;8<E;B@8AH@58EB9C?468FJ;8E8B?78E47H?GFG4L<A
    8KCE8FF<BA4A7IB<68 G7<998E8A68B9BHECEBCBF874CCEB46; G;874L4A7G;87HE4G<BAB9FG4LG<@8<A846;4E84B9G;8;B@8 
    G;4G 4A4?LM8F 6B@@HA<64G<BA @B5<?<GL 4A7 78@B:E4C;<6 <A4??L <A G;8 G;<E7 :EBHC J8 HF8 :8A78E 4F 4 78@B:E4C;<6
    I4E<45?8FG;<FE8F84E6;JBE><F9B6HF87BA?LBA6B@@HA<64G<BA  I4E<45?8 E8?8I4AG GB 78G8E@<A8 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA  G <F <@CBEG4AG
    CB<AG87 BHG G;4G 8I8A BG;8E 78@B:E4C;<6 I4E<45?8F J4F
    A2 34FLFG8@54F87BA@B5<?8G86;AB?B:L<FCE8F8AG87 6BAF<78E87 BA?L :8A78E J4F 6BAF<78E 5L G;8 4?:BE<G;@F 4F 4
    J;<6;<F9B6HF87BAFHCCBEG<A:G;8E8?4G<BAF;<C58GJ88AB?78E E8?8I4AGI4E<45?8 
    47H?GF?<I<A:4?BA8<A$8K<6B4A7G;8<EE8?4G<I8F?<I<A:45EB47 
    +;8 FLFG8@ CEBCBF8F 4 6B@@HA<64G<BAF FLFG8@ G;4G 4??BJF 'E8I<BHF FGH7<8F ;4I8 78@BAFGE4G87 G;4G G;8F8 :EBHCF B9
    8?78E?L C8BC?8 @4<AG4<A 6?BF8 FB6<4? G<8F 5L F;4E<A: 46G<I<G<8F 4E8 ;<:;?L 6BEE8?4G87 J<G; FH5=86G<I8 FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA
    <A9BE@4G<BAC8EFBA4?E8@<A<F68A68F4A7FGBE<8F +;<FJBE>64A ?BA8?<A8FF 9BE <AFG4A68 G<@8 FC8AG <AF<78 ;B@8 2 3 G<@8
    58 6B@C?8@8AG4EL J<G; BHE CEBCBF87 4CCEB46; GB FHCCBEG FC8AG BHG B9 ;B@8 2 3 4A7 6B@@HA<64G<BA G;EBH:; @B5<?8
    8?78E?LG;4G<F78G86G87J<G;FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA  C;BA8F2 3 BEG;<FE84FBAFH6;46G<I<G<8FJ8E86BAF<78E874F
    G;84GGE<5HG8F8G9BEG;8CE87<6G<I8@B78?78I8?BC@8AG 
    A2 34@B5<?8C?4G9BE@9BE8?78E64E8J4F78I8?BC87G;4G
    C8E@<GF 74<?L 46G<I<GL GE46>8E 4A7 FHCCBEG GB 74<?L 46G<I<G<8F +#  )#-%+-) #*
    FH6;4FFB6<4?8A:4:8@8AG4A7@87<64G<BAF6;87H?<A:  A2 3
    4A<A7BBE@BA<GBE<A:FLFG8@9BE8?78E?LJ4F78I8?BC87G;4GHF8 "    
    4 <G5<G ?8K JE<FG54A7 4A7 46G<I8 )  GB 78G8E@<A8 4E84F  
     I8E4:8<A6B@<A:64??F9EB@94@<?L$<A 
    J<G; 46G<I<GL  A G;4G E8F84E6; JBE> G;8 46G<I<GL ?8I8? B9 G;8 B@@HA<64G8F I8E4:87HE4G<BAB9<A6B@<A:64??F9EB@94@<?L
    8?78E?L <F 8I4?H4G87 I<4 7<FF<@<?4E<GL @84FHE8@8AG 5L I4E<45?8F $<A 
    8@C?BL<A: 4A 46G<I<GL 78AF<GL @4C J<G; 4 ;<:; ?8I8? B9 I8E4:8<A6B@<A:64??F9EB@9E<8A7F
    466HE46L  <A4??L <A 2 3 4 9E4@8JBE> 9BE 4FF<FG<A: ?<I<A: 9BE I8E4:87HE4G<BAB9BHG:B<A:64??FGB94@<?L
    8?78E?L C8BC?8 G;4G 6BAF<78E 9B??BJ<A: 6B@CBA8AGF 4 4 94?? $<A  
    78G86G<BA @B5<?8 4CC?<64G<BA 5 4 5<B9887546> @BA<GBE<A: I8E4:8BHG:B<A:@8FF4:8FF8AGGB9E<8A7F 
    FLFG8@GEBH:;J84E45?8F8AFBEF64ABHG7BBE?B64G<BAF8EI<68 I8E4:8<A6B@<A:@8FF4:8FE868<I879EB@94@<?L 
    $B5<?<GL I8E4:8G<@8<AG;8587EBB@EF  
    G;EBH:; 4 F;B8 8DH<CC87 J<G; ?B54? 'BF<G<BA<A: *LFG8@ I4E<45?8F I8E4:8G<@8<AG;8?<I<A:EBB@EF  
    '*4A774@B5<?84CC?<64G<BA9BE64E8:<I8EFG;4GG4>864E8  I8E4:8G<@8<AG;87<AA<A:EBB@EF  
    B9F8I8E4?8?78EF6BA9<A87GB4;B@88AI<EBA@8AG  I8E4:8G<@8<AG;8:4E78AEF  
    I8E4:8G<@8<ABG;8E4E84<AG;8;B@8EF  
    A4??FGH7<8FCE8F8AG87<AE8?4G87JBE>F86G<BAG;84HG;BEF %H@58EB9C?468FI<F<G87
    8@C;4F<M8 G;8 <@CBEG4A68 B9 477E8FF<A: G;8 @4A4:8@8AG B9 8@B:E4C;<6 8A78E
    6;EBA<6 7<F84F8F G;8 @4<AG8A4A68 B9 C;LF<64? 4A7 @8AG4? I4E<45?8
    ;84?G;G;4G49986GG;88?78E?L +;87<998E8A68<ABHE4CCEB46;<F 
    G;8GLC8B9I4E<45?8FG;4G4E8HF87GB@BA<GBEG;846G<I<GLB9G;8
    B?78E 47H?G G;8 4HGB@4G<6 4CCEB46; GB B5G4<A 46G<I<GL 74G4 B9 +;8 GE4<A<A: 74G4 9BE G;8 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? J8E8 B5G4<A87
    G;8 B?78E 47H?G HF<A: F@4EGC;BA8F4A7 F8AFBEF 4A7 G;8 HF8 B9 9EB@ 4 ABACEB545<?<FG<6 F4@C?<A:  5BHG  B?78E 47H?GF
    @87<64?F64?8FGB54F87G;8CE87<6G<BAB9G;8<FB?4G<BA?8I8?  J8E8 FHEI8L87 45BHG G;8<E FB6<4? <AG8E46G<BAF BI8E G;8 ?4FG  
    74LF +;8<A9BE@4G<BA64A58E8GE<8I87<Ahttp://goo.gl/2p3G2o.
     +')&'&*') + -$&#&)++ % +;8 74G4 B5G4<A87 <A G;8 FHEI8LF J8E8 6?4FF<9<87 5L G;8
    *& # *&#+ &% 4?:BE<G;@!2 3 +;8E8FH?GFB5G4<A87J8E8G;E88@4<A?8I8?F
    B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA J<G;BHG E<F> ?BJ E<F> 4A7 ;<:; E<F> B9
    A G;<F E8F84E6; JBE> 4 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? 8K4@<A8F G;8
    FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA 
    58;4I<BEB94F8GB9<A7<I<7H4?F4A7<G78G8E@<A8FG;858;4I<BE
    C4GG8EA J<G; 4 @B78? G;4G 6?4FF<9L G;8 <A7<I<7H4?F <A 6?4FF8F +;8 74G4 CEBI<787 5L G;8 FHEI8LF A887 GB 58 54?4A687
    J<G; G;8 B5=86G<I8 B9 CE87<6G<A: G;8 6?4FF 4 A8J <A7<I<7H4? G;8E89BE8 G;8 *$&+ E8F4@C?<A: G86;A<DH8 <A6?H787 <A
    58?BA:54F87BA<GF58;4I<BEC4GG8EA  ."74G4@<A<A:GBB?J4F4CC?<87GB54?4A68G;874G4B9

    69

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    64G8:BE<8F   F8G B9 74G4 <F HA54?4A687 <9 G;8 6?4FF<9<64G<BA
    64G8:BE<8F4E8ABGE8CE8F8AG878DH4??L +;8HA54?4A6858GJ88A
    64G8:BE<8F 6BH?7 ;4I8 4A <@C46G BA G;8 6?4FF<9<64G<BA
    :8A8E4G<A: 4?:BE<G;@F G;4G 58GG8E CE87<6G G;8 6?4FF8F J<G; 4
    ?4E:8AH@58EB974G4 
    *$&+ <F 4 FG4G<FG<64? G86;A<DH8 HF87 GB <A6E84F8 G;8
    AH@58E B9 64F8F <A G;8 74G4 F8G <A 4 54?4A687 @4AA8E
    :8A8E4G<A:A8J<AFG4A68F9EB@8K<FG<A:64F8FG;4G4E8CEBI<787
    4F <ACHG  +;8 A8J <AFG4A68F 4E8 6E84G87 5L G4><A: F4@C?8F B9
    G;86;4E46G8E<FG<6FC4689BE846;?4FFB978FG<A4G<BA4A7G;8<E
    6?BF8FG A8<:;5BEF 4A7 :8A8E4G<A: A8J 8K4@C?8F G;4G 6B@5<A8
    6;4E46G8E<FG<6FB9G;878FG<A4G<BA64F8J<G;6;4E46G8E<FG<6FB9<GF
    A8<:;5BEF 2 3   +45?8   F;BJF G;8 74G4F8G 589BE8 4A7 49G8E
    4CC?L<A:*$&+ 

    +#  )#-%+-) #*

            

    89BE8 4CC?L<A:    


    *$&+
    9G8E4CC?L<A:*$&+      

    
    %8KG FG8C BA68 J8 B5G4<A87 4A 8DH<?<5E4G87 F8G B9 74G4
    F8I8E4?6?4FF<9<64G<BA4?:BE<G;@F2 3J8E88I4?H4G87<ABE78EGB
    78I8?BCG;8@BFGFH<G45?8@B78?9BECE87<6G<A:FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA 
    +;<F CEB68FF J4F 64EE<87 BHG HF<A: ." 4CC?<64G<BA 2 3 
    18EB) 1) 4?:BE<G;@ J4F HF87 4F 4 54F8?<A8  +;8 BG;8E
    6?4FF<9<8E 4?:BE<G;@F HF87 J8E8 %4<I84L8F % *<@C?8
    #B:<FG<6 *# *HCCBEG -86GBE $46;<A8 *-$ > %84E8FG
    %8<:;5BE >%% 74BBFG  &A8) &) ! 4A7
    *<@C?84EG *  +;8 FGE4G<9<87 G8A G<@8F G8A9B?7 6EBFF
    I4?<74G<BA G86;A<DH8 J4F HF87 5864HF8 <G <F G;8 FG4A74E7
    8I4?H4G<BA G86;A<DH8 <A F<GH4G<BAF J;8E8 BA?L ?<@<G87 74G4 <F
    4I4<?45?82 3 
    +;8 8I4?H4G<BA B9 6?4FF<9<64G<BA 4?:BE<G;@F J4F HF89H? GB
    78I8?BCBHECE87<6G<I8@B78?54F87BAG;84?:BE<G;@6 G;4G
    CEB7H68F 4 5<A4EL GE88  G <F <@CBEG4AG G;4G 5<A4EL GE88 <F G;8
    E8CE8F8AG4G<BA:8A8E4G875LG;8."4CC?<64G<BAGB58HF87
    GB :H<78 G;8 4HGB@4G<6 78G86G<BA B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA  .8 ;4I8
    9BHA74@4G6;58GJ88AG;84I8E4:8I4?H8FB9G;874G49EB@G;8
    FHEI8L 4A7 G;8 4I8E4:8 I4?H8F B5G4<A87 9EB@ G;8 4?:BE<G;@
    J<G;G;8GE4<A<A:74G4 
    +;8 4I8E4:8 B9 G;8 I4?H8F 9BE 846; B9 G;8 4GGE<5HG8F <F
    B5G4<A87 9EB@ G;8 GE4<A<A: 74G4   E86BE7F B9 FHEI8LF G;4G
    4E8 <AGEB7H687 4F <ACHG B9 ."  L 8K4@C?8    <F G;8
    4I8E4:8I4?H8B9G;8AH@58EB9<A6B@<A:64??9EB@94@<?L4A7
    G;<F I4?H8F <A7<64G8 J;<6; 5E4A6; B9 G;8 GE88 @HFG 58 9B??BJ
    466BE7<A:G;8E84?74G4B5G4<A879BE@B5<?84CC?<64G<BA 
    
    
    
    
    
    <:  'F8H7B6B78B9CE87<6G<I8@B78?

    70

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
     ! F4@8 F6E88A G8??F LBH <9 <G <F 4 94@<?L @8@58E BE
    +;8 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? GB 78G86G FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA <A B?78E 9E<8A7 BA9<:HE4G<BAG4>8F4CCEBK<@4G8?L@<AHG8F 
    47H?GFCEBCBF87<AG;<FE8F84E6;J4F<@C?8@8AG87<A4FB9GJ4E8 5 $8FF4:8 E8GE<8I4? @B7H?8 G;<F @B7H?8 E8GE<8I8F G;8
    4CC?<64G<BA G;4G 6BAF<78EF G;8 74G4 6B??86G<BA 9EB@ 8?78E <A9BE@4G<BA B9 @8FF4:8F 9EB@ G;8 F@4EGC;BA8 B9 G;8
    46G<I<G<8F 4A7 G;8 @BA<GBE<A: B9 G;8 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA B?78E47H?G +;8E8?8I4AGI4E<45?8FG;4G4E88KGE46G87<A
    466BE7<A:J<G;G;8CE87<6G<I8@B78?  G;<F @B7H?8 4E8 &HG:B<A: @8FF4:8F F8AG GB 9E<8A7F
    .8<@C?8@8AG87G;8CE87<6G<I8@B78?<A4F@4EGC;BA8G;4G 4A7<A6B@<A:@8FF4:8FE868<I879EB@94@<?L 
    4??BJF 6B??86G<A: G;8 I4?H8F B9 G;8 E8?8I4AG I4E<45?8F B9 B?78E 6 4?? '<6>HC $B7H?8 +;<F @B7H?8 E8GE<8I8F
    47H?G 8F<78FBG;8E@B5<?84CC?<64G<BAJ4F<@C?8@8AG87G;4G <A9BE@4G<BAB964??F9EB@G;8B?78E47H?GFF@4EGC;BA8 
    J<??F8EI8G;864E8:<I8EGB@BA<GBEG;8?8I8?B9FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA  +;8E8?8I4AGI4E<45?8FG;4G4E8B5G4<A87<AG;<F@B7H?8
    BG; FLFG8@F J8E8 78I8?BC87 HF<A: G;8 6?<8AGF8EI8E 4E8 4I8E4:8 <A6B@<A: 64??F 9EB@ 94@<?L 4I8E4:8
    4E6;<G86GHE8  7HE4G<BA B9 <A6B@<A: 64??F 9EB@ 94@<?L $<A 
    +;8 @B5<?8 4CC B9 G;8 B?78E 47H?G <F G;8 E8FCBAF<5?8 GB 4I8E4:8<A6B@<A:64??F9EB@9E<8A7F4I8E4:87HE4G<BA
    B5G4<A G;8 E8FBHE68F B9 G;8 F@4EGC;BA8 4A7 G;8 F8AFBEF B9BHG:B<A:64??FGB94@<?L$<A  
    8@587787 <A ;B@8 4E8 G;8E8FCBAF<5?8 GB 64CGHE8 G;8E8?8I4AG 7 B@8 @BA<GBE<A: @B7H?8 G;<F @B7H?8 64CGHE8F
    I4E<45?8F FH6; 4F 6B@@HA<64G<BA C4GG8EAF 4I8E4:8 G<@8F <A <A9BE@4G<BABAG;84@BHAGB9G<@8@84FHE87<A;BHEF
    7<998E8AG4E84F<A;BHF8
    BHG;BHF88G6 +45?8  FE8FH?GG;8 G;4GG;8B?78E47H?GFG4L<A846;4E84B9;<F
    ;8E;BHF8 
    4CC 78G8E@<A8F G;8 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA 8FG45?<F;<A: G;8 +;8 E8?8I4AG I4E<45?8F G;4G 4E8 B5G4<A87 9EB@ G;<F
    E8?4G<BA B9 74G4 64CGHE87 9EB@ F@4EGC;BA8 4A7 G;8 C4GG8EAF @B7H?8 4E8 I8E4:8 G<@8 <A G;8 587EBB@ EF 
    78G8E@<A87 <A G;8 CE87<6G<I8 @B78?  +;8 4CC J<?? 58 HF87 GB 4I8E4:8G<@8 <A G;8 ?<I<A:EBB@ EF  I8E4:8 G<@8
    ;8?C G;8 8?78E 64E8:<I8E GB CEBI<78 FHCCBEG G;8 B?78E 47H?G <A <AG;87<AA<A:EBB@EF 4I8E4:8G<@8<AG;8:4E78A
    E<F>F<GH4G<BAF  EF 4I8E4:8G<@8<ABG;8E4E84<AG;8;B@8EF  
    BHE@4<A@B7H?8F6B@CBF8G;8F@4EGC;BA84CC?<64G<BA ?H8GBBG; 78I<68F 64??87 846BAF J8E8 HF87 <A BHE
    JBE> GB B5G4<A G;<F <A9BE@4G<BA <A 4A 4HGB@4G<6
    4 )8:<FGE4G<BA @B7H?8 +;<F @B7H?8 E8DH8FG @4AA8E 
    78@B:E4C;<6<A9BE@4G<BA9EB@G;8B?78E47H?GFH6;4F
    4:8 :8A78E 4A7 A4@8 GB F88 <:   <A6<F8 4  +;8 B??BJ<A: G;8 9HA6G<BA4?<G<8F B9 4CC?<64G<BA B9 G;8 B?78E
    6BA9<:HE4G<BA @B7H?8 4??BJF G;8 HF8E GB @4AH4??L 47H?G 4E8 CE8F8AG87 <A <:   A6<F8 5  +;8 HF8EF 64A F88 G;8
    <A7<64G8 G;8 C;BA8 AH@58E B9 94@<?L @8@58EF 4A7 ?8I8?B9FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA;<FGBE<64?74G44A74@BAG;?LFG4G<FG<6F 
    9E<8A7FG;4GHF8EHF87GB6BAG46GHF<A:G;8F@4EGC;BA8  AG;8BG;8EF<78G;84CCCEBI<78F4FC86<9<6<AG8E9468<:  
    +;8F@4EGC;BA84CC6BAG4<AF4J<A7BJF<AJ;<6;G;8 A6<F8 6 GB E8:<FG8E G;8 C8EFBA4? 74G4 B9 G;8 8?78E 64E8:<I8EF
    C8BC?8J<G;J;B@G;8B?78E47H?G<F@BFG?<>8?LGB58 4A7 4?FB 4 FC86<9<6 <AG8E9468 GB CE8F8AG G;8 E8FH?GF B9 G;8
    47787 @4AH4??L BE F8?86G87 9EB@ G;8 6BAG46G ?<FG G;8 @BA<GBE<A:46G<I<GL<:   

    
    

      
    456
    <:   *6E88AF;BGB94E8:<FG8E4A7H?GB?78E54CCB?78E47H?GF6E8:<FG8E64E8:<I8E

     

    71

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    F8AFBE J4F GB 78G8E@<A8 G;8 4@BHAG B9 G<@8 G;4G B?78E 47H?GF
    FC8AG<A846;;B@84E84J;<6;<F<A9BE@4G<BAI8ELE8?8I4AGB9
    G;8 CE87<6G<BA @B78?  G <F <@CBEG4AG GB CB<AG BHG G;4G 8?78EF
    J8E8 ABG<9<87 G;4G G;8 HF87 F8AFBEF 7B ABG E8:<FG8E 4H7<B BE
    I<78B 
    +JB 6B@C?8@8AG4EL CEB68FF8F 6B@CBF8 G;8 8I4?H4G<BA B9
    G;8 CEBCBF87 4CCEB46;  +;8 9<EFG C;4F8 <F E8?4G87 GB G;8
    6B??86G<BAB9<A9BE@4G<BA9EB@F@4EGC;BA84A7F8AFBE4A7G;8
    F86BA7C;4F8<FE8?4G87GBG;878G8E@<A4G<BAB9FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA
    54F87BAG;874G46B??86G87 
    A 9<EFG C;4F8 B9 74G4 6B??86G<BA 4 F8G B9 6;86>CB<AGF J4F
    G4>8A <AGB 466BHAG 5L G;8 C8EFBA E8FCBAF<5?8 GB 64EEL BHG G;8
    8I4?H4G<BA
    − +;8 F8AFBEF 846BAF J8E8 <AFG4??87 <A G;8
    9B??BJ<A: EBB@F 87EBB@ ?<I<A: EBB@ 7<A<A:
    EBB@ :4E78A 4A7 BG;8E ;B@8 4E84F FH6; 4F G;8
    FGH7<B :4E4:8 ><G6;8A 68??4E  46; F8AFBE J4F
    ?458?87 J<G; G;8 A4@8 B9 G;8 EBB@ <A J;<6; G;8
    F8AFBEJ4F<AFG4??87 
    
    − A GB 4IB<7 G;8 F<:A4? <AG8E98E8A68 9EB@ G;8
    <:   K4@C?8B9?8I8?FB9FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA78G86G87-<8JB964E8:<8E 846BAF G;8 F8AFBEF J8E8 C?4687 J<G; @BE8 G;4G
    GJB@8G8EFB97<FG4A684@BA:G;8@ 
     "
    A BE78E GB 8I4?H4G8 BHE CEBCBF87 CE87<6G<I8 @B78? 4A +;8 B?78E 47H?G J4F ABG<9<87 J<G; E86B@@8A74G<BAF 45BHG
    8KC8E<@8AG J4F 6BA7H6G87 J<G; E84? 74G4 9EB@ 8?78E?L C8BC?8 G;8HF8B9G;8F@4EGC;BA8 +;89<EFGE86B@@8A74G<BA9BE8?78EF
    <A $8K<6B   6B@C4E<FBAB9 G;8 @B78?]FE8FH?GF J<G; G;8 E84? J4FG;8LA887FGBHF8G;8F@4EGC;BA8<A4??74<?L46G<I<G<8F4A7
    6BA7<G<BAB9G;8B?78E47H?GFJ4F64EE<87BHG  4GG;88A7B974LG;88?78EA88787GB6BAA86GG;8F@4EGC;BA8
    GB8A8E:LGB;4I8E847LG;878I<68GB6B??86G<A9BE@4G<BAA8KG
    "   B?78E 47H?GF  JB@4A 4A7  74L 
    @8A 6B@CBF87 G;8 8KC8E<@8AG4? :EBHC  +;8 C4EG<6<C4AGF ;47
    G;89B??BJ<A:CEB9<?8< 4A7B?78E<<&?78E47H?GFJ<G;BHG  # 
    6B:A<G<I8 4A7 @BGBE <FFH8F 4A7 <<< &?78E 47H?GF HF<A: 4 #H558A *B6<4? %8GJBE> *64?8 23 J4F HF87 4F 4
    F@4EGC;BA8  +;8F8 B?78E 47H?GF ;4I8 4:8F 58GJ88A   4A7  CFL6;B?B:<64? <AFGEH@8AG BE78E GB B5G4<A G;8 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA
    L84EFB?7  ?8I8?GBB?78E47H?G 
      '4EG<6<C4AGF] @B5<?8 C;BA8F 5846BAF +;<FF64?8;4F?<>8EGGLC8DH8FG<BAFJ<G;4F6BE8E4A:8B9
    <A9BE@4G<BA 4A7 CE<AG87 9BE@F J8E8 HF87 GB 6B??86G G;8  GB   J;8E8   CB<AGF <A7<64G8 G;8 45F8A68 B9 FB6<4?
    <A9BE@4G<BA9BEG;88I4?H4G<BA  <FB?4G<BA  CB<AGF BE @BE8 <A7<64G8 4 ?BJ E<F> B9 FB6<4?
    <FB?4G<BA4A7?8FFG;4A CB<AGF4;<:;E<F>B9<FB?4G<BA*B6<4?
    "   <EFG G;8 8KC8E<@8AG C4EG<6<C4AGF 2 3  A477<G<BAG;<FF64?8;4F4*C4A<F;I8EF<BA478DH4G8GB
    J8E8 4F>87 GB F<:A G;8 <A9BE@87 6BAF8AG 9BE@ J;8E8 G;8L G;8CEB9<?8B9G;8FGH7L:EBHC 
    4:E887 GB C4EG<6<C4G8 <A G;8 8KC8E<@8AG  +;8 @BA<GBE<A: 4CCF
    J8E8<AFG4?87<AG;847H?GVFF@4EGC;BA8F +;8BA?L<AG8EI8AG<BA AG;8F86BA7C;4F849G8EG;8@BA<GBE<A:G;8#H558A*B6<4?
    B9 G;8 B?78E 47H?G J<G; FB9GJ4E8 4CC J4F @478 <A G;<F CB<AG %8GJBE> *64?8 J4F 4CC?<87 GB G;88KC8E<@8AG4? :EBHC 4A7 G;8
    J;8A G;8L HF8 G;8 4CC <AG8E9468 GB E8:<FGE4G8 ;8E
    ;<F 74G4 4A7 ?8I8?B9FB6<4?<FB?4G<BAJ4FB5G4<A875L8I4?H4G<A:G;<FF64?8 
    G;8<A9BE@4G<BA45BHGG;8F@4EGC;BA86BAG46GF4?FB<A7<64G<A:
    G;8 94@<?L 4A7 9E<8A7F 6BAG46GF  ,FH4??L G;8 HF8E FC8AG  -  )*,#+*
    @<AHG8FGB6B@C?8G8G;8E8:<FGE4G<BA  +;8G8FGF64EE<87BHGGB8KC8E<@8AG4?:EBHCB?78E47H?GF
    ?FB 4 F8G B9 CE868AF8 F8AFBE 5846BAF J4F <AFG4??87 <A 6BAF<FG87<AGJBC;4F8F GB@BA<GBEG;8B?78E47H?G46G<I<G<8F
    7<998E8AG4E84FB9G;88?78E;B@8  G;EBH:;4F@4EGC;BA84A7 GB4CC?LG;8#H558AF64?8GBG;8
    74G464CGHE85LF8AFBEF4A7F@4EGC;BA8 +;8E8FH?GFB9G;89<EFG
    #4G8E BA 846; C4EG<6<C4AG J4F @BA<GBE87 9BE BA8 J88> <A C;4F8 J8E8 6B@C4E87 J<G; G;8 E8FH?GF <A7<64G87 5L #H558A
    G;8<E 74L?L 46G<I<G<8F  A BE78E GB B5G4<A G;8 74G4 G;8 B?78E *B6<4? %8GJBE> *64?8 F86BA7 C;4F8  F FG4G87 589BE8 846;
    47H?GF A88787 GB 5E<A: G;8 F@4EGC;BA8 7HE<A: G;8<E ABE@4? C4EG<6<C4AGJ4F8I4?H4G877HE<A:4J88> 
    74<?L46G<I<G<8F<AG;88I4?H4G<BAC8E<B7 
    +45?8  F;BJF G;8 E86BE7F B9 G;8 8KC8E<@8AG4? :EBHC 9BE
    %B 9HEG;8E <AG8EI8AG<BAF J8E8 A88787 58GJ88A G;8 B?78E 78@B:E4C;<6 6B@@HA<64G<BA 4A7 @B5<?<GL I4E<45?8F  #4FG
    47H?G4A7G;8FB9GJ4E84CC586HF8G;846G<I<GL@BA<GBE<A:J4F 6B?H@A <A7<64G8F G;8 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA 78G86G87 5L G;8
    C8E9BE@87 4HGB@4G<64??L 5L G;8 4CC G4><A: G;8 <A9BE@G<BA @B5<?84CC?<64G<BA 
    7<E86G?L 9EB@ F@4EGC;BA8 E8FBHE68F  +;8 B5=86G<I8 B9 G;8

    72

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    

    +#  # *+&+ - + *&')+  '%+*


       
       "   
          
       
      

      ! ! ! !  


     ! ! ! ! ! 
                  
         !  !    !
    #             
      #    
    # #    
       

    8@                 #BJ


    4?8
    $4?8               #BJ
    8@            #BJ
    4?8
    8@                 #BJ
    4?8
    8@                 <:;
    4?8
    $4?8                  <:;
    8@                    #BJ
    4?8

    
    <:   F;BJF 4 ?<FG B9 46G<I<G<8F B9 846; C4EG<6<C4AG B9 <@C4<E@8AG  +;<F F<GH4G<BA @BG<I4G8F G;8 78I8?BC@8AG B9
    8KC8E<@8AG4?:EBHC  6B@CHG8E FLFG8@F 45?8 GB 4HGB@4G<64??L <78AG<9L F<GH4G<BAF B9
    E<F><AG;8FB6<4?<AG8E46G<BAFB9G;8B?78E47H?G 
     ?? G;8 ?8I8?F B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA 78G86G87 5L BHE
    @B5<?84CC?<64G<BA J8E8 G;8 F4@8 G;4G G;8 E8FH?GF B5G4<A87 5L A G;<F E8F84E6; 4 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA 78G86G<BA @B78? J4F
    #H558A *B6<4? %8GJBE> *64?8  +;HF G;8 CE86<F<BA B9 BHE <@C?8@8AG87  .8 78I8?BC87 4 @B5<?8 4CC?<64G<BA G;4G
    CE87<6G<I8 @B78? <A G;8F8 G8FGF J4F   +;<F @84AF G;4G 4HGB@4G<64??L 78G86GF G;8 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA B9 4A B?78E
    FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA 78G86G<BA @B78? <@C?8@8AG87 <A G;8 @B5<?8 47H?G  ?FB 4 @B5<?8 4CC?<64G<BA J4F 78I8?BC87 FB G;4G G;8
    4CC?<64G<BA6BEE86G?L6?4FF<9<87F8I8AB9G;8F8I8AC4EG<6<C4AGF 8?78E 64E8:<I8E 64A 58 <A9BE@87 B9 G;8 78:E88 B9 FB6<4?
    58?BA:<A:GBG;88KC8E<@8AG4?:EBHC*88<:   <FB?4G<BAG;4GB?78E47H?G<F;4I<A: +;8<A<G<4?8I4?H4G<BAB9G;8
    CEBCBF874CCEB46;J<G;F8I8AB?78E47H?GF4??BJF78G8E@<A<A:
    -  &%#,* &%* G;4G FLFG8@ <@C?8@8AG4G<BA ;4F 4  B9 466HE46L GB
    +;8CBCH?4G<BAB9B?78E47H?GF<F6BAFG4AG?L<A6E84F<A: +;8 78G8E@<A8FB6<4?<FB?4G<BA;BJ8I8E@BE88KG8AF<I88I4?H4G<BAF
    FG4G<FG<64? CE87<6G<BA <A7<64G8F G;4G <A   4CCEBK<@4G8?L 4 A887 GB 58 <@C?8@8AG87 GB >ABJA G;8 89986G<I8A8FF B9 G;8
    DH4EG8E B9 G;8 $8K<64A CBCH?4G<BA J<?? 58 B?78E 47H?GF 4CCEB46;J<G;CE86<F<BA 
    <A6E84F<A:G;878@4A79BE@87<64?F8EI<68FE8?4G87GBC;LF<64? G G;8 CE8F8AG G<@8 G;8 CEBCBF87 4CCEB46; <F <AGEHF<I8
    4A7 @8AG4? ;84?G;  +;<F 8@C;4F<M8F G;8 <@CBEG4A68 B9 FB6<4? 5864HF8 B5?<:4G8F G;8 8?78E 47H?G GB 5E<A: 4 F@4EGC;BA8 <A 4??
    94@<?L4A7;84?G;FHCCBEGFLFG8@F  74<?L46G<I<G<8FA8JABA<AGEHF<I8@86;4A<F@A887GB58HF87
     G<@8?L 7<4:ABF<F B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA <A G;8 8?78E?L 64A G;4GC8E@<G4@BE8<AI<F<5?8@BA<GBE<A:GBB? 
    F<:A<9<64AG?L E87H68 G;8 E<F> B9 78CE8FF<BA BE 6B:A<G<I8 

    73

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
     
    <:   #<FGB946G<I<G<8FB9846;C4EG<6<C4AG

     
    <:   B@C4E4G<I8G45?8B9E8FH?GF4@BA:74G4B5G4<A875L#H558A*B6<4?%8GJBE>*64?84A774G4B5G4<A875L@B5<?84CC?<64G<BA

    "%&.#$%+*
    ))%*
    +;<FE8F84E6;JBE>;4F588AC4EG<4??L9HA7875LHEBC84A
    2 3 AG8EA4G<BA4? 74L B9 &?78E 7H?GF  A FC4A<F; 2BA?<A83  I4<?45?8 <A
    B@@<FF<BA4A7&%0+G;EBH:;G;8*@4EG*"CEB=86G  ;GGC

    JJJ HA BE:
    8F
    8I8AGF
    B?78EC8EFBAF74L
     2668FF87 85
    3 
     2 3 BAMQ?8M    &  !   
         # $  !'  %"  
    87 $RK<6B AFG<GHGB788E<4GES4*86E8G4ES478*4?H7 
    

    74

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
    23   $4EG<A8M L .  4@CBF BEE8?4G<BA 58GJ88A FB6<4? <AG8E46G<BA 2 3 $  )B7ES:H8M -  BAM4?8M !  4I8?4 L '  *4AG4A4 XB@854F87
    46G<I<G<8F E8:<FG8E87 J<G;A8J G86;AB?B:<8F 4A7 ?8I8? B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA 6B@@HA<64G<BA FLFG8@ 9BE B?78E 47H?GF 4A7 G;8<E E8@BG8 94@<?LY
    <A B?78E 47H?GF <A *C4A<F;  <B@87<64? A:<A88E<A: $8K<64A !BHEA4?  
    !IB?  A BCC     
    CC        2 3  4F:HCG4" 8?7@4A .4:;E4L' .<??48EG  )4L5B?7L% 
    23 '  +BJAF8A7 +;8 94@<?L ?<98 B9 B?7 C8BC?8 4A <AI8FG<:4G<BA <A 84FG -;4J?4XA AG8:E4G874A7<:<G<M874E8E4@8JBE>9BE*H668FF9H?
    #BA7BA +;8*B6<B?B:<64?)8I<8J      :<A:YCC    
    23   E<A 0BE> ! .  #<A74 $84FHE<A: *B6<4? FB?4G<BA @BA: &?78E 2 3 0   +4AFH +4A  *8A<BE $8@58E $HA>;=4E:4? B6;BB "8
    7H?GF ,F<A: $H?G<C?8 A7<64GBEF EB@ G;8 %*' *GH7L  !BHEA4?F B9 4B ;8A H)BA: !84A L  4A7       ;8A H!<A *;<; X A7BBE
    8EBAGB?B:L*8E<8F    6G<I<GL $BA<GBE<A: *LFG8@ 9BE ?78E?L ,F<A: )  4A7 <G<G ?8K
    23   4JG;BEA8 $84FHE<A: *B6<4? FB?4G<BA <A &?78E 7H?GF .E<FG54A7Y 
    8I8?BC@8AG 4A7 A<G<4? -4?<74G<BA B9 G;8 E<8A7F;<C *64?8  *B6<4? 2 3 * * 4A7! # EHAB$  *<?I4!B8?! '  )B7E<:H8F+<4:B$  
    A7<64GBEF)8F84E6;     *<@B8F XA @5<8AG FF<FG87 #<I<A: E4@8JBE> 9BE $B5<?8
    23   *4E4FBA 8G 4?  FF8FF<A: *B6<4? *HCCBEG +;8 *B6<4? *HCCBEG AI<EBA@8AGFY  
    (H8FG<BAA4<E8  !BHEA4? B9 '8EFBA4?<GL  *B6<4? 'FL6;B?B:L    2 3 '8G8EF8A !  HFG<A   "4L8 !   '4I8? $   4L8F + #    
       ,AB5GEHF<I8 AB@8 8G86G<BA B9 +<@8 *C8AG &HGB9B@8 .<G;
    23 !  *GB>8F   .<?FBA +;8 <AI8AGBEL B9 FB6<4??L FHCCBEG<I8 58;4I<BEF CC?<64G<BAFGB#BA8?<A8FF4A7';LF<64?6G<I<GL  ! <B@87 84?
    <@8AF<BA4?<GLCE87<6G<BA4A7:8A78E7<998E8A68F @8E<64A!BHEA4?B9 A9BE@4G<6F -B?   %B   CC   Z   & 
    B@@HA<GL'FL6;B?B:L     
    !    
    23 !  #H558A $  <EBA74 *B6<4? %8GJBE>F 4A7 *B6<4? K6?HF<BA 2 3 +4A P  '4@H> $   UA78E      #BA8?<A8FF 4A7 $B5<?8
    *B6<B?B:<64? 4A7 'B?<6L '8EFC86G<I8F $84FHE<A: *B6<4? %8GJBE>F 4A7 ';BA8  'EB687<4 Z *B6<4? 4A7 8;4I<BE4? *6<8A68F -B?   CC   Z
    FF8FF<A: G;8<E 8A89<GF  F;:4G8 'H5?<F;<A: B@C4AL  &  
    = F5FCEB   
    HE?<A:GBA-+    2 3 [*$&+\   2&A?<A83  I4<?45?8 ;GGCF

    @F7A @<6EBFB9G 6B@


    8F
    2 3 .  4@CBF 8G86G<BA B9 FB6<4? <FB?4G<BA <A B?78E 47H?GF G;EBH:; 8F
    ?<5E4EL
    7A   4FCK 2668FF87 CE 3 
    8AI<EBA@8AG4? <AG8??<:8A68 4A7 BA?<A8 FB6<4? A8GJBE><A: F<G8F <A 2 3 2 3.H /  "H@4E -  )BFF (H<A<4A !  8G  4?     +BC 
    FC4A<F;';+;8F<FB9% +   4?:BE<G@F <A 74G4 @<A<:  "ABJ?87:8 4A7 AFBE@4G<BA *LFG8@ -B?  
    2 3   +4A:   0HFH9 !  BGM;8<@ %  "H5BG4 L   *  ;4A X ABI8? %B  CC   &  
    F    
    @H?G<@B74? 6B@@HA<64G<BA 9E4@8JBE> HF<A: EB5BG C4EGA8E 9BE 4:<A: 2 3 2 3$ 4?? E4A> B?@8F '94;E<A:8E' )8HG8@4AA4A7 
    CBCH?4G<BAY "#A !4AH4EL    .<GG8A[+;8."4G4$<A<A:*B9GJ4E8A,C74G8\* "
    2 3 !    4FG<??B   8EAQA78M454??8EB _  4FGEBBAMQ?8M $    KC?BE IB?  AB    
    *4?<6;F L $  +  #TC8M X 9E4@8JBE> 9BE E86B:A<M<A: 4A7 E8:H?4G<A: 2 3 2 3    .<GG8A   E4A> 4A7 $  4?? 4G4 $<A<A: 'E46G<64?
    8@BG<BAF<A8?78E?LYCC      $46;<A8 #84EA<A: +BB?F 4A7 +86;A<DH8F +;<E7 7<G  IB?    AB   
    C  
    

    75

    Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY COLLEGE CORK. Downloaded on August 25,2020 at 10:36:24 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

    You might also like