Key Words —visual inspection, visual examination, AWS B1.11:2000
surface conditions, instruments, An American National Standard
eqqtipment, records, discontinuities,
vontdestructive examination, Approved by
American National Standards Institute
January 7, 2000
Guide for the Visual
Examination of Welds
‘Supersedes ANSUAWS B1.11-88
Prepared by
AWS Committee on Methods of Inspection
‘Under the Direction of
AWS Technical Activities Committee
Approved by
AWS Board of Directors
Abstract
This gwide contains information to assist in the visual examination of welds. Inchided sre sections on prerequi
fundamentals, surface conditions, and equipment. Sketches and full-color photographs ilustrae weld discontinuities
commonly Found in welds,
American Welding Society
:W, LeJeune Road, Miami, Florida‘Statement on Use of AWS ‘American National Standard Standards
All standards (codes, specifications, reco i 7 classifications, and guides) of the American
Welding Society are voluntary consensus maccordance with the rules of the Ameri-
ccan National Standards Institute. When AWS i standards are either incorporated in, or made
part of, documents that are included in fed lations, ofthe regulations of other governmental
bodies. their provisions carry the full legal au ‘such cases, any changes in those AWS standards
‘must be approved by the governmental b before they can become a part of those laws
and regulations. In all cases, these sta rly of the contract or other document that invokes
the AWS standards. Where this coat in or deviations from requirements of an AWS
standard must be by agreement between,
ational Standard Book Number. 0-87171-625-9
by American Welding Society. Allright reserved
Printed in the United States of America
AWS standards are developed thro
senting varied viewpoints and in ile AWS oministers the process and establishes niles
{to promo fairness in the developme nol independently test, evaluate, oF verify the accuracy of
formation or the scundness of itsstandars,
AWS disclaims liability for any injry to yo cher damages of any nature whatsoever, whether spe
ial, indirect, consequential OF 6 di ly resulting from the publication use of, or reliance on this
standard, AWS also makes no guartaty or warranty asto the accuracy cx completeness of any information published herein,
In issuing and making: alle, A uurdertaking o render professional or other services for oF on
‘behalf of any person or enlity. Noris AWS undertaking 10 perform any duty owned by any person or entity to someone
else Anyone using these dely ons or her own independent gre as appropiate, seck the
advice of x competent lle eerste of reasonable cae in any given cicrasances,
‘This standard may be superseded by theastance af new cdtons. Uses shoul ensue tha they hve the last eto,
Publication of this standard doesnot authorize infrigemest of any patent, AWS disslaims ability forthe infringement
‘of any patent resulting from the use or reliance on this stander.
Finally, AWS docs not monitor, police, oreaforee ccmplianc: with this standard, nor does ithave the power to dos.
(Oficial incepretations of any ofthe techni quirements of this standard may be obtained by sending a request, in wrt
‘ing, to the Managing Director Technical Services, American Welding Society, $50 N.W. LeJeune Road, Miami, FL 33126
(see Annex C). With regard to. wiries made concerning AWS standards, oral opinions on AWS standards may.
be rendered. However, such opinions teprésent only the personal cpinions ofthe particular individuals giving them, These
individuals do not speak on behalf of AWS, aor Cothese oral opinions constiue offical o unofficial options or intrpre-
tations of AWS. In ation, oral opinions informal and should notbe used asa subsite for an official intrptation,
‘This standard is subject to revision at any time by the AWS BI Committee oa Methods of Inspection. It must be reviewed
‘every 5 years and if not revised, it must be either regpproved or withérawa. Comments (recommendations, additions, oF
deletions) and any pertinent data that may be of use in improving this standard are requested and should be addressed 0
AWS Headquarters. Such comments will eceive careful consideration by the AWS BI Cormmitiee on Methods of Inspec-
‘ton and the author of the comments will ke informed of the Committee's response to the comments. Guests are invited t
‘aitend all meetings of the AWS B1 Commitee on Metieds of Inspection to express their comments verbally. Procedures
{for appeal of an adverse decision concerning all such comments are provided in the Rules of Operation of the Technical
Activities Committee. A copy of these Rules ean be obiained from the American Welding Society, 550 N.W. Leeune
Road, Miami, FL 33126,
ent process that brings together volunteers repre-
Photocopy Rights
Authorization to photocopy items for internal, perscnal or eucatonal classroom use onl, or the intemal personal or
‘educational classroom use only of specific cients, is granted by the American Welding Society (AWS) provided thatthe
appropriate fee is paid to the Copyright Cleerance Center, 222 Rovewean! Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, Tel: 978-730-8400;
‘online: hups/www.copyright.com,
iPersonnel
AWS Committee on Methods of Inspection
PA. Grin, Chaic
RD. McGuire, ist Vice Chair
FD. Levert, 2ad Vice Chir
1B Connor, Secretory
AW Borges, PE
"CR. Brosheart
R.Brosilow
WA, Bruce
EL Criscuelo
“RE Deeds, Ir
$C Meller
KL Holdren
“DL Isenhour
°t. Laine
*W.C Minton
4 W.Overy
M,N. Pfeifior
AG Ponz
*S.J. Walmsley
K Zerkle
‘Modern Welding Company, Incorporated
National Roard of Boiler and Pressure Vessel Inspectors
Loral Vought Systems
American Welding Society
Consultant
Alyesta Pipeline Service Company
Welding Design and Fabrication
Exlison Welding Institute
Consultant
Consolidated Faison Company of New York
Heller Assoxiates
Welding Consultants, Incorporated
Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Company
Consultant
Consultant
Pacific Gas and Electric Company
Consultant
Consuitant
S.J, Walmsley and Associates
Hobart Brothers Companyord
(This Foreword isnot a part of AWS I
formation purposes only.)
‘Visval ecamination (VT), as used in
‘and particular phases of welding may be
methods requite the use af eyesight to
‘The use of yauges and other tools ss
‘examination of weldmeats
The Guide for the Visual.
to serve as a simple tutorial source o
document to present the only app
this document. tis intended that
‘welding personnel who need
for a particular process. Inch
performing visual exeminatin
ites and conditions,
‘the Visual Examination of Welds, bu i included for in-
ive method whereby a weldment, the related base metal,
with applicable requirements. All visual examination
ans which are present; hence, the term viswal examination,
-main method, and these are treated only as adjuncts to visual
n prepared by the AWS Committee on Methods of Inspection
ing visual examination of welds I isnot the intent of tis
ecamination attributes, which would be essential, or desirable,
tol prerequisites for performing visual examination, steps
and also typical examples of visual examination, disconti
records. and other reference sourees which may be helpful. Termi.
im AWS A3.0, Standard Welding Terms und Definitions.
2, The codes oF specifications applicable to any particular weldment
| material contained hersin, should any conflict arise between the two. The
does not inclad: all the conditions applicable toa specific instance, Examples
given ure general and are used only for the purpose of illustration.
“This material can be ning fext for inspectors. Although the information generally relates tothe are weld-
ing processes, most of it applies to weldments fabricated by other fusion welding processes, for which these methods
may be required.
For the examination of resistance welded assemblies, refer to AWS C1.1, Recommended Practices for Resistance
Welding, AWS Ci.3, Recommended Praciices for Resistence Welding Coated Low Carbon Steels, and AWS D8.1. Recom-
imerided Practices for Automotive Weld Quality-Resistance Spor Welding, published by the American Welding Society
Tor the examination of brazed assembles, refer to tie Brazing Handbook, also published by the American Welding,
Society.
Forthose who need more detiled information than this guide provides, bibliographies or complete books on the sub-
jects covered in each chapter may be found in ond technics} libraries. The many specifications and codes that ae listed,
and have been uscd as illustrative examples, may aso te consuked for more detailed information.
Basie information on other nondestructive examinstion metheds is contained in AWS BI.10, Guide for Nondestructive
Examination of Welds, and inthe AWS book, Welding Inspection,
‘Comments and inquiries concerning this standard are welcome. They should he sent tothe Secretary, BI Commitee
‘9n Methods of Inspection, American Welding Society, $50 NW, Leleune Roa, Miami, FL 33126.Personnel,
Foreword.
List of Figures
1
Table of Contents
Gener. .
LA Application... osname
Prerequisites
21 Genera.
22 Visual Acuity
23. Equipment oor
24 Experience and Training
25 Procedures...
26 Certification Programs
27 Safety
Fandamentals of Visual Examination.
31. General
32. Priorto Weiding..
33. During Welding...
34. After Welding.
Weld Surface Condi
4.1 General
42 Pomsity.
43° Incomplete Fusion... ce
44 Incomplete Joint Penetration.
45 Undereut
46 Underfill
47 Overlap,
48° Lamination oes
49° Seams and Laps a
4.10 Cracks...
4.11 Slag Inclusions...
4.12 Excessive Reinforcement...
4.13 Convexity and Concavity
414 Ave Strikes
41S Spotter =
4.16 Melt-Through..
4.17 Weld Size
4.18 Surface Oxitation,
‘Examination Equipment.
5.1 Introduction, <
5.2 Calibration and Handling of Examination Equipmert.Linear Measuring Devices.
‘Temperature Measuring DeviceSc.nn
Weld Gauges... i
Fiberscopes and Borescope
Ferrite Ganges...
Light Source
59° Ammeters..
6. Reconls...
Annex A—List of Standards Commonly
Annex Supplementary Reading Ma
‘Annex C—Guidelines for Preparation
AWS Document List,
“List of Figures
Scattered Porosity.
‘Surface Appearance of Piping Porosity
Aligned Porosity with Cragk.
Elongated POMS! enon
Various Locations of Incomplete Fusion
Incomplete Fusion,
Incomplete Fusion at the Groove Face.
Incomplete Fusion Between Weld Beads
Incomplete Fusion Between the Weld and Buse Meta
Incomplete Joint Penetration...
Incomplete Joint Penetration with Consumable Insert.
Incomplete Joint Penetration.
Examples of Undereut.
Undercat at Fillet Weld Toe
Underhill es enen
Lede Ung Fx Cand Ate Walle Stee.
Overlap.
Overlap.
Laminations...
‘Types of Cracks,
Longitudinal ys, Transverse Cracks
Longitudinal Crack and Linear Por
“Transverse Cracks ose
‘Threat Crack
Crater Crack. zi
Longitudinal Cracks. rooming from Crater Crack
‘Toe Cracks,
‘Toe Cracks.
Underbead Cracks.
Slag Inclusion...
Weld Reinforcement.
Convex Fillet Weld...
Convexity .
Concave Fillet Weld
Surface Oxidation (Sugaring) in a Sta
‘Temperature-Sensitive Crayon,
Surface Contact Thermomet
Pyromecr.
Evaluating a Convex Fillet Weld.
Evaluating a Concave Fillet Weld
A Maltipurpose Gauge
‘A Taper Gauge ..
Hi-Lo Mismatch Gauge
A Fiberscope in Use...
Femite Indicator (errtescope)..
‘Tong Test Ammeeer...
RBRRRERERBE‘AWS B1.11-2000
Guide for the
Visual Examination of Welds
1. General
1.1 Application Information contained inthis guide ap-
to the general duties and responsibilis of visual
inspectors of weldments and is useful to them in carying,
out their duties and responsibilities defined in particular
odes or specificstions. This document is primarily in-
tended for those who are responsible for the final accep
lance of weldments. However all welders, supervisors,
technicians, and engineers who are required to routinely
inspost work performed by them or under ther authority
Vill benefit from the ase of this document, Tis doeu-
‘ment wll provide general guidelines forthe vgual ena
ination of weldments
‘The inspector should be knowledgeable conceming
‘ach ofthe principles and methods of examination 1e-
‘ited om a particular weldment.It isthe responsibility
Cf those charged with the administration and supervision
Cf inspection to make certain thar the principtes and
‘methods set forth are properly undersiod and uniformly
apliah This sesponsibilty also includes the qualiica-
tton nd certification of inspectors, where such certiica-
tion is required by codes, specifications, or civil laws
AWS QC1, Standard jor AWS Cerifcaiion of Welding
Inspectors, indicates the importnsce AWS assigns 10
visual examination,
Contract docaments should specify the requisements
for visual examination, In the abseace of such requite-
ments, the manufacturer shouldbe requested to exis,
{in woting the extent and the methods of examination to
be required
Acceptance standards should be cleaily uidets¥od by
both the manufacturer and the buyer before any welding
is ane. This isnot only to make mor effective use of
the examination methods but 10 prevent disagreement
‘over whether 1 weldment is satisfactory and in accor-