Sin P-Delta

T=
STAAD. Pro sin P-Delta
MEMBER LOAD JT AXIAL SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z TORSION MOM-Y
123 SDX 57 63,064.06 18,304.73 0.07 0.00 0.15

T=
SAP2000 sin P-Delta
TABLE: Element Joint Forces - Frames
Frame OutputCase Joint F1 F2 F3 M1 M2
Text Text Text Kgf Kgf Kgf Kgf-m Kgf-m
123 SDX 57 18,295.51 0.00 63,033.63 0.01 85,217.31

T=
Story Load Case/Combo Station P V2 V3 T M2
m kgf kgf kgf kgf-m kgf-m
STORY1 SDX Max 0.00 62,944.71 18,270.06 0.00 0.00 0.01

Con P-Delta

T=
STAAD. Pro con P-Delta
MEMBER LOAD JT AXIAL SHEAR-Y SHEAR-Z TORSION MOM-Y
SDX 57 64,003.70 18,152.02 0.19 0.00 0.55

T=
SAP2000 con P-Delta
TABLE: Element Joint Forces - Frames
Frame OutputCase Joint F1 F2 F3 M1 M2
Text Text Text Kgf Kgf Kgf Kgf-m Kgf-m
SDX 57 18,118.09 0.00 64,021.96 0.01 86,447.87

T=
Story Load Case/Combo Station P V2 V3 T M2
m kgf kgf kgf kgf-m kgf-m
STORY1 SDX-PD Max 0.00 63,928.30 18,093.05 0.00 0.00 0.01
 3.336

MOM-Z
85,253.83

3.332

M3
Kgf-m
0.00

3.328
M3
kgf-m
85,101.42

3.839

MOM-Z
86,545.76

3.831

M3
Kgf-m
0.00

3.826
M3
kgf-m
86,325.95
Sin P-Delta
Variación respecto a STAAD.Pro
Programa P (Kg) M (kg.m) T (s) P (Kg) M (kg.m)
STAAD.PRO 63,064.06 85,253.83 3.336 0.00% 0.00%
SAP2000 63,033.63 85,217.31 3.332 -0.05% -0.04%
ETABS 62,944.71 85,101.42 3.328 -0.19% -0.18%

Con P-Delta
Variación respecto a STAAD.Pro
Programa P (Kg) M (kg.m) T (s) P (Kg) M (kg.m)
STAAD.PRO 64,003.70 86,545.76 3.839 0.00% 0.00%
SAP2000 64,021.96 86,447.87 3.831 0.03% -0.11%
ETABS 63,928.30 86,325.95 3.826 -0.12% -0.25%

Variación por efecto P-Delta

Programa P (Kg) M (kg.m) T (s)
STAAD.PRO 1.49% 1.52% 15.08%
SAP2000 1.57% 1.44% 14.98%
ETABS 1.56% 1.44% 14.96%
specto a STAAD.Pro
T (s)
0.00%
-0.12%
-0.24%

specto a STAAD.Pro
T (s)
0.00%
-0.21%
-0.34%