Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tradition history forces interpreters to consider the possibility that some texts may have
had an oral prehistory. It also notes that past traditions were retold and used for a
present purpose; that it was made real, vital, or relevant for each successive generation.
The method also has weaknesses. Tradition history creates highly speculative
reconstructions, often built on the speculative deductions from source criticism.
Moreover, tradition history may exaggerate the role of oral tradition. If texts were
written soon after they were spoken so that there was not a long oral prehistory, then
the assumptions of tradition history fall to the ground. The use of Olrik's laws is also
dubious: It may be a false analogy to compare Icelandic folklore with Hebrew
folklore since they are very different cultures. Some folklorists question whether Olrik's
laws apply even to Scandinavian literature much less any other (Gunkel admitted they did
not apply to all stories in Genesis).