Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s10722-005-1304-y
Diqiu Liu , Xiaoping Guo , Zhongxu Lin, Yichun Nie and Xianlong Zhang*
National Key Laboratory of Crop Genetic Improvement, Huazhong Agricultural University, Wuhan, Hubei
430070, China; *Author for correspondence (e-mail: xlzhang@mail.hzau.edu.cn; phone: +86-27-87283955;
fax: +86-27-87280016)
Key words: Cotton, Genetic diversity, Gossypium arboreum, Microsatellite, Simple sequence repeats, SSR
Abstract
Asian cotton (Gossypium arboreum L.) was once widely cultivated in China. It has also been a valuable
source of genetic variation in modern cotton improvement. In this study, the genetic diversity of selected
G. arboreum accessions collected from different regions of China was evaluated by microsatellite (simple
sequence repeats, SSRs) analysis. Of the 358 microsatellite markers analyzed, 74 primer pairs detected 165
polymorphic DNA fragments among 39 G. arboreum accessions examined. Twelve accessions could be
fingerprinted with one or more SSR markers. With the exception of two accessions, DaZiJie and
DaZiMian, genetic similarity coefficients among all accessions ranged from 0.58 to 0.87 suggesting high
level of genetic variation in the G. arboreum collections. The UPGMA dendrogram constructed from
genetic similarity coefficients revealed positive correlation between cluster groupings and geographic dis-
tances. In addition, comparison of the microsatellite amplification profiles of the diploid G. arboreum and
tetraploid Gossypium hirsutum L. found that size distribution of amplified products in G. arboreum was
dispersive and that of G. hirsutum was relatively concentrated. The information on the genetic diversity and
SSR fingerprinting from this study is useful for developing mapping populations for constructing diploid
cotton genetic linkage map and tagging economically important traits.
Gossypium arboreum has been domesticated and The objectives of this study are to (1) evaluate the
cultivated for almost 2000 years in China since it genetic diversity among selected G. arboreum
was first introduced from India (Xiang and Shen accessions; and (2) identify G. arboreum accessions
1989). G. arboreum possesses many favorable traits with high genetic diversity that will be used to
for cotton production, which the upland cotton develop mapping populations for constructing
cultivars lack. For example, the drought tolerance, diploid cotton linkage maps and marker-assisted
resistance to diseases like root rot, and insect pests molecular tagging of economically important traits.
like bollworms and aphids (Mehetre et al. 2003)
make G. arboreum well adapted to dry land con-
ditions and low input cultivation practices. Natu-
Materials and methods
ral G. arboreum fibers display various colors (e.g.,
white, milky, beige and brown). Many Chinese
Germplasm collection
G. arboreum accessions produce fibers with high
strength and seeds with high oil content and seed
The 39 G. arboreum accessions used in this study
index. Over 300 G. arboreum accessions have been
were randomly selected from the more than 300
collected and conserved in the Cotton Germplasm
G. arboreum accessions preserved in the Cotton
Center located in the Chinese Academy of Agri-
Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Agricul-
cultural Science. These G. arboreum collections are
tural Sciences (CRI, CAAS), which were kindly
invaluable gene pool for cotton improvement.
provided by Dr X.M. Du of CRI, CAAS. With the
However, they have not been well characterized at
exception of two accessions that were originated
the molecular level. Understanding of the genetic
from Japan and the USA, respectively, all others
relationships of G. arboreum would facilitate effi-
were collected from different provinces of China.
cient use of these resources in developing superior
The additional materials from the authors’ labo-
cotton cultivars with favorable agronomic traits.
ratory, G. hirsutum cv. ‘Jinmian6’ (JM6), one
Molecular markers, especially PCR-based
G. herbaceum accession and G. raimondii were also
markers such as RAPD (random amplified poly-
used. Relevant information of the 39 G. arboreum
morphic DNA), AFLP (amplified fragment length
accessions and the G. herbaceum accession was
polymorphism) and SSRs (simple sequence
presented in Table 1 and Figure 1.
repeats) have been extensively used to study
genetic diversity, genetic relationships and molec-
ular phylogeny in Gossypium species (Tatineni et
al. 1996; Khan et al. 2000; Abdalla et al. 2001; Microsatellite analysis
Iqbal et al. 2001; Xu et al. 2001; Gutiérrez et al.
2002; Lu and Myers 2002; Zhu et al. 2003). Total genomic DNA was isolated from leaf tissue
Recently, the SSR marker has received much more of each material according to Paterson et al.
attention in phylogenetic studies in cotton. The (1993). Totally 358 SSR primer pairs were used for
PCR-based, co-dominant microsatellite markers the present study. All primer sequences were
are highly polymorphic and preferentially associ- downloaded from the UK CropNet website
ated with non-repetitive DNA in plant genomes (http://ukcrop.net/perl/ace/search/CottonDB) and
(Morgante et al. 2002). These features make it were synthesized commercially. Procedure of SSR
ideal to use microsatellite markers for genetic analysis followed Mei et al. (2004).
diversity studies and marker-assisted selection in
cotton breeding.
In this study, the genetic diversity within 37 Data analysis
representative G. arboreum accessions from differ-
ent regions of China was analyzed using microsat- After silver staining, all major DNA band sizes
ellite markers. In addition, two G. arboreum were recorded using 100 bp DNA ladder as the
accessions, one from Japan and the other from the reference. The amplified DNA fragments were
United States of America, as well as a G. herbaceum scored as either 1 or 0, respectively, representing
accession were also included in this study for presence or absence of the band. Each polymorphic
comparison of genetic variation of these materials. SSR fragment was considered a different locus as it
1147
Table 1. Description of 39 Gossypium arboreum accessions and one G. herbaceum sample used in this study.
1 G. herbaceum L. Unknown
2 Pingdongxiaohua PDXH Guizhou (GZ)
3 Changfengheizi CFHZ Jiangsu (JS)
4 Qingjinghuanghuayouhongxin QJHHYHX Unknown
5 Wuanzhongmian WAZM Hebei (HeB)
6 Dazijie DZJ Hebei (HeB)
7 Zijingzihuazhongmian ZJZHZM Unknown
8 Dazimian DZM Hebei (HeB)
9 Shanghaizhongmian SHZM Shanghai (SH)
10 Jiangxixiushuizhongmiamaozi JXXSZMMZ Jiangxi (JX)
11 Wanxianxiaobaihua WXXBH Hebei (HeB)
12 Shanxianxiaozihua SXXZH Shandong (SD)
13 Shiyaxi1 SYX1 Hebei (HeB)
14 Nonglin6 NL6 Japan
15 Huazhongziganzhongmian HZZGZM Hubei (HuB)
16 Jiadingzhongmian JDZM Shanghai (SH)
17 Baoshangzihua BSZH Shanghai (SH)
18 Zhejianghuangdidabu ZJHDDB Zhejiang (ZJ)
19 Meiguozhongmian971 MGZM971 USA
20 Tiemuchi TMC Liaonin (LN)
21 Hexianzizhumianhua HXZZMH Anhui (AH)
22 Changshudabaizi CSDBZ Jiangsu (JS)
23 Xiazhaixiaohua 3 XZXH3 Guizhou (GZ)
24 Chaoxianzihuaxiaozi CXZHXZ Anhui (AH)
25 Sangjiangguandongzongxuzhongmian SJGDZXZM Guangxi (GX)
26 Jinxianzhongmian JXZM Hebei (HeB)
27 Dingyuanxiaohuamian DYXHM Anhui (AH)
28 Qingyangdazihuamaozi QYDZHMZ Anhui (AH)
29 Rudongjijiaoyaguo RDJJYG Jiangsu (JS)
30 Anhuifuyangxinjidahua AHFYXJDH Anhui (AH)
31 Luodianguantianxiaomianhua LDGTXMH Guizhou (GZ)
32 Shulubaihuabai SLBHB Hebei (HeB)
33 Guizhouzhongmian GZZM Guizhou (GZ)
34 Yuxi 3–3 YX3-3 Hebei (HeB)
35 Changshundaihuaxiaohua CSDHXH Guizhou (GZ)
36 Changrongzhongmian CRZM Hubei (HuB)
37 Wangmosanglangdamianhua WMSLDMH Guizhou (GZ)
38 Wuzhaixiaohua WZXH Guizhou (GZ)
39 Xiabaxiaohua2 XBXH2 Guizhou (GZ)
40 Dongtaixiaobaihua DTXBH Jiangsu (JS)
a
Code number = designated sample number for accessions in SSR analysis.
Figure 1. Geographic origin of 37 Gossypium arboreum accessions collected from China. For germplasm name and province name in
brackets, see Table 1. The remaining two accessions were from Japan and the USA, respectively, which were not shown here.
generated by each primer pair ranged from 1 to 8, four, both QYDZHMZ and HXZZMH had two.
with an average of 2.33. For example, the micro- The other eight accessions, WAZM, WXXBH,
satellite markers BNL2634 and BNL2569 detected MGZM971, CSDBZ, XZXH3, GZZM,
eight and six polymorphic loci respectively, among CSDHXH and CRZM had one each.
the 40 accessions.
Accession-specific microsatellite markers were
identified based on the SSR band patterns. There Genetic diversity analysis
were twelve accessions possessing one or more
specific SSR markers (here referred to SSR prim- Genetic similarity coefficients among all 39
ers) to distinguish each of them from other 38 G. arboreum accessions and one G. herbaceum
accessions (Table 2). Remarkably, NL6 had eight ranged from 0.58 to 0.99, and the maximum 0.99
accession-specific SSR markers. LDGTXMH had was between two G. arboreum, DZJ and DZM,
NL 6 BNL 347 BNL 852 BNL 1317 BNL 2634 BNL 2884 BNL 3264
LDGTXMH BNL 269 BNL 1395 BNL 1897 BNL 2440
HXZZMH BNL 116 BNL 2569
QYDZHMZ BNL 2967 BNL 4094
WAZM BNL 1395
WXXBH BNL 3971
MGZM971 BNL 256
CSDBZ BNL 2569
XZXH3 BNL 1897
GZZM BNL 2440
CSDHXH BNL 116
CRZM BNL 2569
which might mean they were closely related. With lower Yangtze Valley such as Hubei, Anhui,
the exception of DZJ and DZM, pairwise genetic Jiangsu and Shanghai. The US introduction,
similarity coefficients ranged from 0.58 to 0.87, MGZM971 was also in group C. Group D was
indicating that a vast genetic base is present in composed of five G. arboreum accessions. Basal
Chinese G. arboreum. The least similarity coeffi- position of the phylogenic tree was occupied by
cient of 0.58 was generated between NL6 and three accessions, QYDZHMZ, LDGTXMH and
WXXBH, the former was introduced from Japan NL6, which made up groups E, F and G, respec-
and the latter from Hebei province of China. NL6 tively. As shown above, the three accessions hap-
was outstanding because its average similarity to pened to have the highest polymorphism as
other accessions was 0.66, showing large variabil- revealed by microsatellite analysis in this study.
ity in genomic constitution. PDXH and WZXH, Not all accessions from the same regions were
MGZM971 and DYXHM were included in the clustered in the same group. For example, the
accessions with maximum similarity index of 0.87. eight accessions originated from the Guizhou
The first two were both collected from Guizhou province of southwestern China dispersed in
province of China while the latter two were from groups B, D and F indicating high local genetic
far away regions, the USA and Anhui province of diversity within this region.
China, respectively.
The UPGMA dendrogram generated from
genetic similarity coefficients is shown in Figure 2. Comparison of microsatellite performance
Cluster analysis resulted in seven groups between G. arboreum and G. hirsutum
(A through G). Group A consisted of four
G. arboreum accessions and the G. herbaceum In this study, 84 SSR primer pairs failed to amplify
accession. There were nine members in group B. decipherable products among the 40 G. arboreum
Accessions in groups A and B were mainly from or G. herbaceum accessions listed in Table 1.
northern and northeastern regions of China, such However, when the PCR profiles of these micro-
as Hebei and Shandong provinces (Figure 1). satellite markers were compared among three
Eighteen members constituted group C, and most Gossypium species: G. arboreum (A2), G. raimondii
of them were from provinces in the middle and (D) and G. hirsutum cv. ‘Jinmian 6’ (AD), 17 SSR
Figure 2. An UPGMA dendrogram of 39 Gossypium arboreum accessions and one G. herbaceum sample based on SSR data. For
abbreviations of germplasm names, see Table 1.
1150
groups A and B whereas the four accessions, SYX1, polyploids, and through contraction or expansion,
DZJ, DZM and JXZM from Hebei Province fell the imperfect dinucleotide repeats converted to the
into group B. The majority of group C accessions perfect repeats. Jiang et al. (1998) concluded that
were collected from provinces in the middle and during polyploidization, 52 chromosomes in tet-
lower Yangtze Valley. Similar results were found by raploids have diverged further from their ancestral
Monte et al. (1993) and Sharma et al. (2000). genomes, especially D subgenome. The same
Vergara and Bughrara (2003) also found that phenomenon was observed in the present study
bentgrass accessions from geographically adjacent (Figure 3), but more detailed studies seem neces-
countries commonly clustered together, but those sary for making any conclusion.
from distant locations were clustered into different So far all SSR markers (BNL series) were
groups with low similarity coefficients. The developed from tetraploid cotton genome. Liu
G. arboreum had been cultivated in China for over et al. (2000) estimated that annealing between
2000 years. It is likely that the widely different primers and templates would be affected when
environment of China had contributed significantly tetraploid cotton-derived primers were used to
to the diversity of G. arboreum. Nonetheless, eight amplify templates from diploid A or D genome
accessions from Guizhou were dispersed in groups species. If this is true, it is not surprising that 84
B, D, and F, indicating that they possess large ge- SSR primer pairs out of 358 did not yield unam-
netic diversity. The G. arboreum spread into China biguous and characteristic DNA fragments among
from ancient India along the line of Punjab, Indian the 40 Gossypium diploid species in this assay.
peninsula, Burma and Vietnam and firstly culti- Through farther validation, 67 SSR primer pairs
vated in Chinese southern and southwestern re- might relate to D genome with 17 primer pairs
gions, subsequently spread to the drainage areas of previously reported to be located in D genome
Yangtze and Yellow Rivers. Hence, the southern (Liu et al. 2000; Lacape et al. 2003; Mei et al.
and southwestern regions of China including 2004). Abdalla et al. (2001) detected 84 D-related
Yunnan and Guizhou provinces may be the sub- DNA bands using AFLP. It is more possible that
biodiversity centre of G. arboreum. Several peren- D-related markers were derived from the D-gen-
nial G. arboreum were found in Yunnan Province ome progenitor. The next objective of our work is
(Xiang and Shen 1989) which may well explain the to make sure that the other 50 SSR primer pairs
high-level genetic diversity of G. arboreum acces- (excluding 17 SSR primer pairs reported to be
sions from Guizhou that borders Yunnan Province. located in D genome) are specific markers of D
In the present study, 74 SSR primer pairs yiel- genome.
ded a total of 165 polymorphic loci with each
marker detecting 1–8 polymorphic fragments
among the 40 accessions. It seems that microsat-
ellite analysis is a method of choice to study Acknowledgements
genetic diversity, varietal relationships and gen-
ome evolution in Gossypium. However, little is We thank the Cotton Research Institute, Chinese
known about the origin and evolution of them in Academy of Agricultural Sciences for providing
the Gossypium genomes. Syed et al. (2001) ana- the 39 G. arboreum accessions used in this study.
lyzed differences among dinucleotide microsatellite We also thank Drs L.F. Zhu, D.H. He and Y.X.
repeats in diploid A or D genome and polyploid Zhang for technical help. Financial support of this
AD genome of cotton, and concluded that among research from the National High Technology
107 SSR loci examined, 30–50% had similar allele Project (2004AA211171) and National Basic
sizes in all three genomes, but over half of the loci Research Program of China (2004CB117301) was
had either longer or shorter sequences in the tet- appreciated.
raploids. They analyzed sequences of SSR loci and
discovered that not only the number of dinucleo-
tide repeats but also sequences flanking the repeats References
caused the variation in allele sizes. Therefore, Syed
et al. (2001) speculated that after polyploidization, Abdalla A.M., Reddy O.U.K., El-Zik K.M. and Pepper A.E.
the microsatellite alleles might evolve rapidly in 2001. Genetic diversity and relationships of diploid and tet-
1152
raploid cottons revealed using AFLP. Theor. Appl. Genet. Monte J.V., McIntyre C.L. and Gustafson J.P. 1993. Analysis
102: 222–229. of phylogenetic relationships in the Triticeae tribe using
Beasley J.O. 1940. The origin of American tetraploid Gossypium RFLPs. Theor. Appl. Genet. 86: 649–655.
species. Am. Nat. 74: 285–286. Morgante M., Hanafey M. and Powell W. 2002. Microsatellites
Beasley J.O. 1942. Meiotic chromosome behavior in species, are preferentially associated with nonrepetitive DNA in plant
species hybrids, haploids and induced polyploids of Gossy- genomes. Nat. Genet. 30: 194–200.
pium. Genetics 27: 25–54. Nei M. and Li W.H. 1979. Mathematical model for studying
Gerstel D.U. 1953. Chromosomal translocations in interspecific genetic variation in terms of restriction endonucleases. Proc.
hybrids of the genus Gossypium. Evolution 7: 234–244. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 76: 5269–5273.
Gutiérrez O.A., Basu S., Saha S., Jenkins J.N., Shoemaker Paterson A.H., Brubaker C.L. and Wendel J.F. 1993. A rapid
D.B., Cheatham C.L. and McCarty Jr. J.C. 2002. Genetic method for extraction of cotton (Gossypium spp.) genome
distance among selected cotton genotypes and its relationship DNA suitable for RFLP or PCR analysis. Plant Mol. Biol.
with F2 performance. Crop Sci. 42: 1841–1847. Rep. 11: 122–127.
Iqbal M.J., Reddy O.U.K., El-Zik K.M. and Pepper A.E. Rohlf F.J. 2000. NTSYS-pc: Numerical Taxonomy and Mul-
2001. A genetic bottleneck in the ‘evolution under domes- tivariate Analysis System, Version 2.1, User Guide. Exeter
tication’ of upland cotton Gossypium hirsutum L. examined Software, New York.
using DNA fingerprinting. Theor. Appl. Genet. 103: 547– Seelanan T., Schnabel A. and Wendel J.F. 1997. Congruence
554. and consensus in the cotton tribe. Syst. Bot. 22: 259–290.
Jiang C.X., Wright R.J., El-Zik K.M. and Paterson A.H. 1998. Sharma A., Sharma R. and Machii H. 2000. Assessment of
Polyploid formation created unique avenues for response to genetic diversity in a Morus germplasm collection using flu-
selection in Gossypium (cotton). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA orescence-based AFLP markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 101:
95: 4419–4424. 1049–1055.
Khan S.A., Hussain D., Askari E., Stewart J.McD., Malik K.A. Sokal R.R. and Michener C.D. 1958. A statistical method for
and Zafar Y. 2000. Molecular phylogeny of Gossypium spe- evaluating systematic relationships. Univ. Kansas Sci. Bull.
cies by DNA fingerprinting. Theor. Appl. Genet. 101: 931– 28: 1409–1438.
938. Syed N.H., Lee H.S., Mei M., Thaxton P., Stelly D.M. and
Lacape J.M., Nguyen T.B., Thibivilliers S., Bojinov B., Cour- Chen Z.J. 2001. Variability and evolution of microsatellite
tois B., Cantrell R.G., Burr B. and Hau B. 2003. A combined loci in cotton (Gossypium) diploid and polyploidy genomes.
RFLP-SSR-AFLP map of tetraploid cotton based on a Plant & Animal Genome IX Conference. Town & Country
Gossypium hirsutum · Gossypium barbadense backcross pop- Hotel, San Diego, CA, January 13–17, 2001.
ulation. Genome 46: 612–626. Tatineni V., Cantrell R.G. and Davis D.D. 1996. Genetic
Liu S., Saha S., Stelly D., Burr B. and Cantrell R.G. 2000. diversity in elite cotton germplasm determined by morpho-
Chromosomal assignment of microsatellite loci in cotton. logical characteristics and RAPDs. Crop Sci. 36: 186–192.
J. Hered. 91(4): 326–332. Vergara G.V. and Bughrara S.S. 2003. AFLP analyses of ge-
Lu H.J. and Myers G.O. 2002. Genetic relationships and dis- netic diversity in Bentgrass. Crop Sci. 43: 2162–2171.
crimination of ten influential Upland cotton varieties using Xiang X.L. and Shen D.Z. 1989. Chinese Asian Cotton
RAPD markers. Theor. Appl. Genet. 105: 325–331. (Gossypium arboreum). China Agricultural Press, Beijing,
Mehetre S.S., Aher A.R., Gawande V.L., Patil V.R. and China.
Mokate A.S. 2003. Induced polyploidy in Gossypium: a Xu Q.H., Zhang X.L. and Nie Y.C. 2001. Genetic diversity
tool to overcome interspecific incompatibility of cultivated evaluation of cultivars (G. hirsutum L.) from the Changjiang
tetraploid and diploid cottons. Curr. Sci. 84(12): 1510– River valley and Yellow River valley by RAPD markers.
1512. Acta Genet. Sin. 28: 683–690.
Mei M., Syed N.H., Gao W., Thaxton P.M., Smith C.W., Stelly Zhu L.F., Zhang X.L. and Nie Y.C. 2003. Analysis of genetic
D.M. and Chen Z.J. 2004. Genetic mapping and QTL anal- diversity in upland cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) cultivars
ysis of fiber–related traits in cotton (Gossypium). Theor. from China and foreign countries by RAPDs and SSRs.
Appl. Genet. 108: 280–291. J. Agric. Biotechnol. 11: 450–455.