Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ZHAO Suying (䎫㍖㤧)1,**, HUANG Jingzhao (哺䮒䫀)1, WANG Liang’en (⧁㢥)1 and
HUANG Guoqiang (哺ളᕰ)2
1
College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou 350002, China
2
National Engineering Research Center for Distillation Technology (NERCDT), Tianjin 300072, China
Abstract A process composed of a fixed-bed and a distillation column with a side withdraw, mainly methanol, is
developed to hydrolyze methyl acetate (MA) as a typical byproduct in polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) and pure
terephthalic acid (PTA) factory. The process is simulated by employing the equilibrium stage model RadFrac and
plug flow model Rplug in Aspen Plus. Experiments are also carried out in a lab-scale to evaluate the process. The
results show that at the molar ratio of water to methyl acetate about 4.05.0 in the feed stream and the volume ratio
of distillate to feed MA above a critical value, the side product contains more than 80% (by mass) (MeOH) and less
than 2% (by mass) MA, while the bottom contains more than 46% (by mass) acetic acid (HAc) and less than 0.5%
(by mass) methanol with almost complete conversion of MA. Compared with the old catalytic distillation process
we proposed before, this process can cut down 47.6% energy consumption and a distillation column.
Keywords methyl acetate, hydrolysis, simulation
Table 1 Summary of NRTL binary interaction parameters used in the prediction of equilibrium data
Component i Component j Temperature units aij aji bij bji cij
MA MeOH K –1.14353 0.509837 536.8947 31.74408 0.3
MA H2 O K –2.43297 –0.12096 1311.373 805.9797 0.419742
MeOH H2 O K –2.626 4.8241 828.3871 –1329.54 0.3
MeOH HAc K –3.8591 7.4858 975.377 –2151.88 0.3
MA HAc K 0 0 415.2702 –239.246 0.3
H2O HAc K 3.3293 –1.9763 –723.888 609.8886 0.3
3.2 Reaction kinetics the column, thus the stage is 11. In order to meet de-
mands of MeOH mass concentration of less than 0.5%
The hydrolysis of methyl acetate is a reversible in bottom product in the PTA and PVA plants, we set a
reaction with the following expression: design value of 0.4%. RL/F of 4.5 and RW/MA of 5.0 are
ZZX HAc MeOH
MA H 2 O YZZ (1) feasible parameters obtained by several simulations.
Other parameters are the same as the experimental
The equilibrium constant of this reaction is 0.15 at data. All the parameters for the base case simulation
55°C. According to the reaction mechanism the pseudo- are given in Table 3. All feed streams enter at 25°C.
homogeneous reaction kinetics can be expressed as: The mass basis distribution in the hydrolysate
c k CMA CH 2 O k CMEOH CHAC
r Ccat (2) distillation column is shown in Figs. 2 and 3. Fig. 2
indicates the methanol concentrations in vapor phase
A detailed study of this reaction has been done in at 6th14th stages are more than 0.8 with less than 0.15
our previous work [17] and the forward and reverse water, 0.03HAc and rare MA. That means 6th14th
reaction rate constant ( k and k , respectively ) can stages are the feasible locations for side withdrawal
be expressed by following equations. and the side product is readily to be refined by simple
Forward:
k0 3.181 u 104 m6·mol–1·s–1·g–1,
Table 5 The energy consumptions of the main equipments of the old process (kW)
Catalytic distillation Hydrolysate distillation MA-MeOH separation MeOH distillation Total energy
column (CD) column (HD) column (MMSD) column (MD) consumption
675.70 546.61 100.02 262.84 1585.17
Table 6 The energy consumptions of the main equipments of the new process (kW)
Fixed-bed(F-BED) Hydrolysate distillation column (C1) MeOH distillation column(C2) Total energy consumption
25.59 722.22 87.23 835.03
760 Chin. J. Chem. Eng., Vol. 18, No. 5, October 2010
of the two processes are summarized in Tables 5 and 6, xW-HAc mass concentration of acetate acid in the bottom product
respectively. xW-MeOH mass concentration of methanol in the bottom product
Obviously the new process have saved a main Superscripts
+ forward reaction
equipment by comparing Figs. 7 and 8. The MA-MeOH – reverse reaction
separation column is not needed in which the Subscripts
side-withdraw of the hydrolysate distillation column az azeotrope
can solve the separation problem of the azeotrope cat catalyst
MA-MeOH. Table 5 shows that the sum of energy
consumptions of fixed-bed and hydrolysate distillation REFERENCES
column in the new process is 747.81 kW. It is much
smaller than that of CD column and hydrolysate dis- 1 Ma, Y.G., Mou, C.G., Wu, S.H., Technology of PVA Production, Tex-
tillation column of 1222.31 kW in the old process. As tile Industry Press, Beijing (1986). (in Chinese)
2 Wang, C.X., “Study on hydrolysis of methyl acetate in a catalytic
known, MA hydrolyzes with water in liquid phase [21]. distillation column”, Chin. J. Chem. Eng., 9, 382387 (2001).
But MA is vaporized in the reactive distillation zone 3 Pan, Y.B., Li, W.X., Shen, P.D., Wan, H., Han, M.J., Guan, G.F.,
of the CD column. Thus, the reflux quantity on the top “Study on hydrolysis of methyl acetate from production of purified
of the CD column needs to be increased to promote terephthalic acid by catalytic distillation”, Chem. Reac. Eng. & Tech.,
reaction. More reflux quantity, more energy consump- 25, 132136 (2009). (in Chinese)
4 Wang, J.F., Ge, X.D., Wang, Z.W, Jin, Y., “Experimental studies on
tion. The energy consumption of MeOH distillation the catalytic distillation for hydrolysis of methyl acetate”, Chem.
column are also reduced greatly as shown in Table 6. Eng. Technol., 24, 155159 (2001).
In the old process, extra water enters on the top of the 5 Sander, S., Flisch, C., “Methyl acetate hydrolysis in a reactive di-
MA-MeOH distillation column to extract MeOH from vided wall column”, Chem. Eng. Res. Des., 85,149154 (2007).
6 Yuan, P.Q., Chen, Z.M., Liu, T., Yuan, W.K., “Hydrolysis of methyl
MA, so methanol concentration is much lower than acetate under near or supercritical condition”, Chem. J. Chinese U.,
that of the side product in the new process. The vapor 24, 12411245 (2003). (in Chinese)
feeding used in the new process also saves a lot of 7 Fuchigami, Y., “Hydrolysis of methyl acetate in distillation column
energy. The energy consumption gap between the new packed with reactive packing of ion exchange resin”, J. Chem. Eng.
and the old is up to 47.6%. Therefore, no matter in the Jpn., 23, 354359 (1990).
8 Xiao, J., Liu, J.Q., Li, J.T., Jiang, X.H., Zhang, Z.B., “Increase MeOAc
capital investment or in the operation cost, the new conversion in PVA production by replacing the fixed bed reactor with a
process takes every superiority. catalytic distillation column”, Chem. Eng. Sci., 56, 65536562 (2001).
9 Wang, L.E., Su, W.R., Zhao, Z.S., Liu, J.Q., Wu, Y.X., Shen, J.N., Qiu, T.,
“Industrial application of the catalytic distillation technique in hydrolysis
6 CONCLUSIONS of methyl acetate”, Viny. Commu., 21, 1012 (2001). (in Chinese)
10 Wu, Y.X., Wang, L.E., Zhao, Z.S., Tan, T.E., “Mass transfer model
for catalyst capsule in catalyst distillation (I) mathematical model”,
Both simulation and experiment have proven that CIESC J., 53, 503507 (2002). (in Chinese)
MA can be hydrolyzed completely in the coupled sys- 11 Wu, Y.X., Wang, L.E., Zhao, Z.S., Tan, T.E., “Mass transfer model for
tem of fix-bed reactor and distillation column with catalyst capsule in catalyst distillation (II) measurement and calculation
vapor side product. However, RW/MA should be greater of effectiveness factor”, CIESC J., 53, 508512 (2002). (in Chinese)
12 Kim, K., Roh, H.D., “Reactive distillation process and equipment for
than 3.0 and RL/F above the critical value at every the production of acetic acid and methanol from methyl acetate hy-
RW/MA. Under the conditions that RW/MA 4.05.0 and drolysis”, U.S. Pat., .5970770 (1998).
RL/F above the critical value the side product will con- 13 Moritz, P., Hasse, H., “Fluid dynamics in reactive distillation pack-
tain more than 80% (by mass) MeOH and less than ing Katapak®-S”, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54, 136713741 (1999).
14 Dirk-Faitakis, C.B., An, W.Z., Lin, T.B., Chuang, K.T., “Catalytic
2% (by mass) MA, while the bottom will contain distillation for simultaneous hydrolysis of methyl acetate and etheri-
more than 46% (by mass) HAc. Only a simple column fication of methanol”, Chem. Eng. Process., 48, 10801087 (2009).
is needed to attain MeOH with high purity. Compared 15 Gmehling, J., Bölts, R., “Azeotropic data for binary and ternary sys-
with the catalytic distillation process we proposed tems at moderate pressures”, J. Chem. Eng. Data., 41, 202209 (1996).
before, this process can save 47.6% of energy con- 16 Bessling, B., Löning, J.M., Ohligschläger, A., Schembecker, G.,
Sundmacher, K., “Investigations on the synthesis of methyl acetate
sumption and a distillation column. in a heterogeneous reactive distillation process”, Chem. Eng. Technol.,
21, 393400 (1998).
17 Wu, Y.X., Zhao, Z.S., Wang, L.E., Zhao, S.Y., “Kinetics of hydroly-
NOMENCLATURE sis of methyl acetate and the effectiveness factor of catalyst capsule”,
Eng. Chem. Meta., 20, 241246 (1999). (in Chinese)
18 Wang, L.E., Liu, J.Q., Su, W.R., Zhao, Z.S., Zheng, W.H., Zhang,
Cccat density of the catalyst, g·m–3
J.L., “Catalytic distillation process for methyl acetate hydrolysis and
–3
Ci concentration of component i, mol·m its equipments”, China Pat., 97101306.3 (1997).
Ea apparent activation energy, kJ·mol–1 19 Wang, L.E., Zhao, Z.S., Qiu, T., Zhao, S.Y., Zheng, H.D., Qiu, T.R.,
k rate constant, m6·mol–1·s–1·g–1 Su, W.R., Xie, Y.H., Luo, D.H., “Byproduct methyl acetate hydroly-
k0 pre-exponential factor, m6·mol–1·s–1·g–1 sis process and its equipments in the industry of PTA”, China Pat.,
R universal gas constant, J·mol–1·K–1 200610124556.7 (2006).
RL/F distillate to feed MA volume ratio, m3·m–3 20 Wu, Y.X., Tan, T.E., Wang, L.E., Zhao. Z.S., “Simulation of the
RSP/F volume ratio of side product to feed MA, m3·m–3 catalytic distillation process for hydrolysis of methyl acetate”, Eng.
RW/MA molar feed ratio of water to methyl acetate, mol·mol–1 Chem. Meta., 21, 2429 (2000). (in Chinese)
r reaction rate, mol·s–1·m–3 21 Pöpken, T., Götze, L., Gmehling, J., “Reaction kinetics and chemical
xSP-HAc mass concentration of acetate acid in the side product equilibrium of homogeneously and heterogeneously catalyzed acetic
xSP-MA mass concentration of methyl acetate in the side product acid esterification with methanol and methyl acetate hydrolysis”, Ind.
xSP-MeOH mass concentration of methanol in the side product Eng. Chem. Res., 39, 26012611 (2000).