Professional Documents
Culture Documents
rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com
On
12/01/2020
.I
I*'
I- I-
.,
,' ..
-*
1 , :
1 .- * -
3'
I -
.#
c
Y
A design guide for vacuum drainage systems, for use in conjunction with
*'-
..a
\
* ;"bx
%- L, 2 i
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
Contents
1 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................... 3
1.1 Scope .......................................................................................................................................... 3
1.2 Background ................................................................................................................................ 3
1.3 Vacuum drainage systems compared to gravity drainage.......................................................... 3
1.4 Applications ................................................................................................................................ 3
4 DESIGN .................................................................................................................................. 12
4.1 Design requirements ................................................................................................................ 12
4.2 Design criteria ................................... :...................................................................................... 12
4.3 Maintainability ........................................................................................................................ 15
4.4 Noise control ............................................................................................................................ 15
BIBLIOGRAPHY .................................................................................................................................... 16
DESIGN EXAMPLES
In the course of producing this guidance. the following sites in the UK have been studied:
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
I
~~
Loading of sewerage system Dependant upon appliances Dependant on pumping rate Discharge from forwarding
installed pumps can be times to coincide
with low flow periods
Table 1 - differences between different types of drainage systems
(3
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
1 Advantages I Disadvantages
Low installation costs High component costs
Environmentally safe Mechanical components- possibly for failure
, Electrical power only required at vaciiiim station Skilled design, installation and maintenance required
Always self cleansing Regular maintenance required
No possibility of vermin in pipelines Standby facilities required
Possible water saving technique if vaciiiim toilets are used Require area for situation of vacuum tanks and vaciiiim
generation equipment
I High water velocities prevent deposits in pipework I High velocity water may cause transient plumbing noise I
Minimise risk of leakage
Can use small diameter lightweight pipes that can be installed
without a continuous fall
I Vertical lifts are possible I I
I Ability to easily separate grey and black water I I
High turn around time - no need for cistern to refill for
subsequent flushes I
Table 2 - Advantages arid disadvantages of vacirirni drainage systenis
Buffer volume The storage volume of the admitted air continues to expand. Eventually, friction
interface unit which balances and gravity bring to rest the wastewater at the low
the incoming flow of points of the pipework system; such as reforming
wastewater to the output pockets and at the bottom of pipeline lifts.
capacity of the discharge
The vacuum drainage system transports wastewater by
valve.
means of atmospheric pressure acting against vacuum.
Controller The device which, when The operation of the system is described below.
activated by its level sensor,
opens the interface valve and, 2.3 Operation of system
after the passage of When an interface valve is opened, the difference in
wastewater and normally air, pressure between the main pipeline and the interface
closes the valve. unit drives the water out of the buffer volume and
into the pipeline. A quantity of air, several times the
Interface valve A valve which admits the
volume of water, follows the water into the pipework
flow of wastewater only, or
before the valve closes. This creates a large local
wastewater and air, into the
pressure differential that accelerates the water
vacuum drainage system
vigorously in the service connection. This movement
pipeline.
of water takes place in the direction of lower pressure,
Lift Section of vacuum pipeline so initially the flow is both upstream and
with an increase in invert downstream, but the connection angle and gradient
level in the direction of flow. have directional effects on the water flow. Within
any low points, or pockets, in the pipework slugs of
Reforming pocket A low point in the piping
water will form.
profile installed intentionally
to produce a controlled After a number of repeated accelerations of slugs of
slug flow. water, the air has lost most of its kinetic energy and
cannot create any more pumping action. This is
Service connection The section of vacuum
called the Reach of the Interface unit. The reach
pipeline connecting an
depends upon many things, e.g. buffer volume, valve
individual interface unit to
timing, aidwater ratio, pipe diameter and length.
the vacuum main.
For many systems, the transportation distance is
Slug An isolated quantity of normally within the reach of every interface unit.
wastewater flowing full bore However, for longer systems (i.e. greater than lOOm
through the vacuum pipeline. pipe length), and for further transport, several
interface units may be required to operate in
Vacuum Any pressure below
sequence to supply the necessary volume of air.
atmospheric.
At low flow conditions, for example in the middle
Vacuum station An installation comprising of the night, sequential operation might not occur.
vacuum generator(s), a means Some vertical lifts may then become full, or almost
of discharge and control full, of water. To restore the required dynamic flow
equipment, that may also regime necessary for vacuum transport, one or more
incorporate vacuum adjacent interface units have to operate to supply
vessel/holding tank(s). the air, or a separate valve unit that will supply air
on demand only must be installed.
2.2 The vacuum transport process
When designing systems greater than lOOm in
An understanding of the vacuum transport process is
length (from the valve to the vacuum station), a
helpful to the system designer. As long as n o interface
series of reforming pockets must be used. These
unit is operating, little wastewater transport takes
minimise the break-up of the wastewater slug and
place. All wastewater remaining in the vacuum
reform that portion of the slug that remains in the
pipework will drain, by gravity, into the reforming
piping between interface valve discharges. The
pockets when all upstream interface valves are closed.
reformed slug is then propelled by the air admitted
When an interface valve opens, the differential
during the next discharge.
pressure between the vacuum in the system and
atmosphere forces the wastewater into the vacuum Once the interface valves have operated, the
pipework. Whilst accelerating, the wastewater is discharge travels to the vacuum station, normally
transformed into foam and soon occupies only part of located at ground or basement level. Air is
the vacuum pipe cross section so that the momentum discharged to atmosphere only from the vacuum
transfer from air to water takes place largely through station. From the vacuum station, the wastewater is
the action of shear stresses. The magnitude of the pumped automatically to the building outfall
propulsive forces starts to decline noticeably when the connection, to discharge into the external drainage
interface valve closes, but remains important as the system by gravity.
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
To design a reliable and economic vacuum drainage 0 this opens the interface valve and activates a
system, it is necessary to generate sequentially high timer in the controller
acceleration and self-cleansing velocities with the 0 after the set time period has expired, the buffer
least amount of energy. volume will have been drained and sufficient
NOTE: A vacuum drainage system is NOT a reversed air to transport the wastewater will have been
pressure system where all the water would be admitted
accelerated simultaneously. 0 the controller/sensor unit operates the pilot
valve to close the vacuum supply line to the
interface valve and to admit air to the valve
3 BASIC COMPONENTS operating mechanism
The vacuum drainage standard considers the 0 the interface valve closes.
Vacuum Drainage System in four system elements: The arrangement of the components may vary
0 the automatic interface units (AIU) according to the design of the installation. In
0 the vacuum toilets general terms, the buffer volume gets larger as the
0 the pipework, and inflow rate increases. The buffer volume can be a
0 the vacuum station. separate tank of various materials suitable for the
application. It may also be possible to use part of
3.1 Interface units the gravity drainage system that feeds the interface
valve as a buffer volume.
3.1.1 Description There are several types of interface valves suitable
The valves that form the interface between the for vacuum drainage, e.g. piston valves, pinch valves
vacuum drainage lines and the appliances can be and diaphragm valves. All interface valves are
used directly with some appliances and with buffer normally closed and require vacuum to be applied
volumes for others. When used with buffer volumes, to open the valves.
level sensors and controllers the valves are termed
interface units. Most interface units operate 3.1.3 Pinch (See Figure 3)
automatically and are known as automatic interface The pinch valve comprises a flexible tube running
units (AIUs). Although AlUs are operated by air, between the inlet and outlet of the valve body, a
non-automatic units may use electricity to control spring-loaded closing mechanism that requires
their operation. compression to release the tube, an airtight body
with flexible sleeved ends that are attached to the
There are various sizes of interface valve up to about ends of the closing mechanism.
100mm bore. The larger valves are used in vacuum
sewerage systems.
Typically a complete interface unit is composed of a
buffer volume of varying size, a sensor to sense the Rubber Sleeve
wastewater level in the buffer volume, a controller
which operates a pilot valve to open and close a
vacuum supply line to the interface valve. In many Vacuum
Side
designs of interface unit, level sensors and
controllers are combined into one device.
~ ' Rubber Sleeve'
INTERFACE VALVE
3.1.2 Operation
Normally, interface valves would be operated by Figure 3 - Pirich valve
vacuum but may be operated by electricity if
appropriate. Although the operation of all automatic 3.1.3.1 Operation
interface valves is similar, vacuum toilets operate The valve is opened when the controller applies
differently (see section 3.2). A typical sequence of vacuum to the inside of the valve body. The external
operation for an automatic unit, with an air tube air pressure then compresses the closing mechanism
level sensor and combined controller/sensor unit, is: which allows the tube to return to its natural open
0 liquid enters the holding tank by gravity, as the state and connect the appliance to the vacuum
liquid level rises in the sump it pressurises air in system. Air at atmospheric pressure then forces the
the sensor pipe wastewater through the open pinch valve and into
0 this air pressure is transmitted through a tube the piping.
to the controller/sensor unit When the controller disconnects the vacuum from
0 the air pressure operates the controller/sensor the inside of the body, it allows air to enter the body
unit, which operates a pilot valve to open the which assists the spring to return the ends of the
vacuum supply line to the interface valve's mechanism to their rest positions and pinch the
operating mechanism flexible tube closed.
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
-
curved state.
1. Controller
3.1.6.1 Operation
2. P a l under vacuum
3. Pal at atmospheric wwsure Wastewater wm In the closed position, the diaphragm is held against
4. Suction pipe
5. sensorpipe Air 0 the vacuum seating by the spring and atmospheric
5 Depth signal
Q Vacuum I
7. Wfstewater inlet pressure. When the controller applies vacuum to the
chamber over the diaphragm, the diaphragm seating
face retracts into the top chamber. This creates a
clear passage opening the valve. Air at atmospheric
pressure then forces the wastewater through the
open diaphragm valve and into the piping.
The controller has an adjustable timer that controls
Figure 5 - Automatic interface unit with piston valve
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
the valve’s rate of closing by slowly admitting air to emptied by a 50mm or 75mm valve into the
-
the chamber. This allows the spring to return the vacuum collection tank. An isolation valve may be
diaphragm to its closed position. fitted between the vacuum tank and the interface
valve.
3.2 Vacuum toilets
3.3.2 Standby generator
A vacuum toilet uses air instead of water to remove
Unlike most gravity drainage systems, vacuum
the contents of the bowl, and is a form of interface
drainage systems require electrical power for
valve. Usually, it includes a rinse rim and the toilet’s
operation. Hence, there may be a requirement to
controller may have a memory function so that it
provide an alternative power supply to operate the
will operate as soon as there is sufficient vacuum
system in case of a primary power supply failure.
available. A typical vacuum toilet is shown
diagramatically in Figure 7. A vacuum drainage system should require only one
air inlsf liner source of power located at the vacuum generation
plant room. The standby generator is usually rated
to provide 100%)standby power for discharge
pumping and vacuum generation. The generator
nnse ring should be arranged for automatic start upon failure
1177
\ / of the main power supply.
loilef bowl
3.4 Ejector unit (See Figures 8 and 9)
Ejector units are used on small systems, which
vacuum hose require approximately 40m3 of air an hour at peak
vacuum pipe
flow. They have the advantage of having a lower
capital cost, being small in physical size and with
Figure 7 - Vacuum toilet controls and operation fewer working parts than vacuum pumps, and are
easy to maintain and operate. However, they are less
3.2.1 Operation of dry vacuum toilet power efficient than a vacuum station and, therefore,
Where minimal water use is required, a dry vacuum are more expensive to run. The control of this kind of
toilet may be used. The water consumption of this vacuum station is similar to a conventional pumping
type of toilet is typically 0.2 to 0.4 litre per flush. station. These units can also receive discharges from
The dry vacuum toilet retains n o water in its bowl, gravity drainage systems directly into the tank.
as the flush valve closes before the discharge valve However, wastewater containing high levels of
closes. The cleansing of the bowl is usually inferior detergents may cause foaming problems.
to that of a wet vacuum toilet.
3.4.1 Operation (The ntiinhers refer to Figure 9)
The ejector unit creates a vacuum in the pipework
3.2.2 Operation of wet vacuum toilet
-
by means of an ejector (2) and pump (3).
Typically, when operating a flush button, pressurised
Wastewater is pumped from the tank (1) through
water is introduced into the bowl through a water
valve and a rinse ring with holes to clean the bowl. the nozzle of the ejector creating a venturi effect,
whereby air and waste are inducted from the
Simultaneously the discharge valve opens and the
pressure differential in the piping forces the ,, Vacuum drainage pipeline
contents through the valve. Before the discharge
Check Valve
valve closes, air is drawn into the pipe. The flush
water valve stays open for about two seconds to
re-establish the water pool in the bowl. The typical
water consumption for this timing sequence would
be 0.8-1.5 litre per flush. Vacuum toilets may be re- B
flushed in less than a quarter of the time taken for a Figure 8 - Schematic of ejector
conventional WC to refill, on average, a vacuum
toilet will take 3 seconds to complete a flush cycle.
vacuum drainage pipework, mixed with the alarms, and where required a standby generator.
wastewater jet and passed to the collecting tank. Vacuum stations may be built from a package of
The induction of air from the drainage pipework
equipment provided by the manufacturer of the
creates the vacuum within the pipework. When the
system. Package vacuum stations may be pre-
level of water in the tank reaches the high level
fabricated on a skid at the manufacturer's plant and
switch (8), the collected wastewater is transferred to delivered to site fully assembled and tested.
the sewer by using the same pump(s), and by
diverting the flow through a discharge valve (7). The vacuum receiver tank size and/or number of
When the water level in the tank has dropped to the tanks depends on the number of appliances
level of the low-level switch, the discharge valve will connected to the system and the excepted frequency
close. When the set vacuum has been developed in of discharge. Each tank incorporates level indicator
the pipework, the vacuum switch (4) will cause the switches that control the discharge pumps
pump(s)(3) to stop. The vacuum will be maintained automatically, vacuum regulator switches which
in the pipework by the check valve at the end of the control the vacuum pumps and level alarms which
vacuum drainage pipeline, within the ejector. As the can be audible or connected to the building
tank is vented to atmosphere, wastewater from a management system.
conventional gravity system can be introduced into
the tank and then pumped to the sewer during the 3.6 Vacuum generating and forwarding pumps
normal discharge cycle.
3.6.1 Vacuum generating pumps
3.5 Vacuum station (See Figures 10 and 1 1 ) Vacuum pumps of the liquid ring and sliding vane
types are both suitable for use in vacuum drainage
systems. Vane-type vacuum pumps are
recommended for most projects, as they are more
efficient, i.e. they have a greater throughput of air
and are less temperature sensitive than similarly
powerful liquid ring pumps.
The maximum vacuum provided by a liquid ring
pump often will not exceed -0.8 bar gauge, whilst
the maximum vacuum of a vane pump will typically
be closer to -1 bar gauge. This will affect the choice
of pumps where vacuum levels of a greater
magnitude than the normal -0.5 to -0.7 bar gauge
operating range will be required, or for projects at
high elevations where atmospheric pressure is lower.
Figure 10 - Vacuum station
A vacuum switch attached to the pipework and
Although vacuum stations may be used with simjlar adjustable timer are used to control the vacuum
systems as the ejector unit, they are used mainly for pumps. A second vacuum switch may control a low
larger systems, i.e. greater than 40mRof air. They are vacuum alarm signal. These switches are fitted with
large units with a higher capital cost but typically stainless steel bellows to protect against corrosion
are cheaper to run than ejectors. from any gases evolving from the wastewater.
The machinery installed is similar to that of a
3.6.2 Forwarding pumps (See Figure 12)
conventional wastewater pumping station or lift
Forwarding pumps are required to discharge the
station, and consists of a collection tank, wastewater
collected wastewater to the external gravity sewerage
forwarding pumps, vacuum pumps, controls and
system. These pumps are designed to operate with a In systems where only black water is being collected,
large pressure differential across them with their it is prudent to use the second forwarding pump as
inlets under vacuum. The size of the forwarding a circulation pump. This circulates sewage within
pump is a function of the following: design peak the collection tank and breaks up any solids which
flow, volume to be discharged, and the permissible may have formed on the surface of the wastewater.
discharge rate for the receiving sewer. This operation should be programmed into the logic
system as the first step in the discharge cycle.
To enable some forwarding pumps to work, a vacuum
balance line may be required downstream o f the 3.7.3 Collection tank level controls
discharge pump to reduce the pressure difference Level detectors are available in various forms, some
across the pump (a balance line is not required with are float switches, others are fixed probes that may
an ejector systems). To prevent loss of vacuum when be conductive, inductive or capacitative. Where a lot
the pump is not discharging, a check valve is required of condensate is being collected, for example in
in the discharge pipework downstream of the supermarkets with chiller cabinets, the mineral
connection of the balance line see Figures 11 and 12. content of the water may affect the operation of the
system and conduction probes may need to be used.
3.7 Controls
Level detectors, of some form, are fitted to all
3.7.1 System controls collection tanks. The signals from the six common
I
The vacuum drainage system control panel contains detectors control the discharge pumps and alarms as
follows, in ascending order of height from the base
the main power switch and the pump operating
of the tank:
system, which includes magnetic starters, overload
protection, control circuitry and hours run meters for 1. earthing probe, or sensor float switch or similar
each vacuum and forwarding pump. A data recorder 2. both forwarding pumps stop
may be built into this panel, as well as the collection 3. lead forwarding pump start
tank level control relays. 4. assist forwarding pump start
Alarm and telemetry systems may be included if 5. high-level alarm
also required. 6. high-level cut-off - stop vacuum pumps.
generated
0 if level reaches the high level alarm sensor,
then an alarm is given and the vacuum system
is shut down Water column
0 when the water level has fallen to a low-level Trap sump wlumn
sensor or after a pre-set time period, the To sewer
controller will stop the forwarding pump(s)
Column Tank
and open the automatic balance line valve,
if fitted.
Figure 13 - Column tank installation
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
from the operating position of the isolation valves. The combined vacuum generator and forwarding
3.8 Column tank (See Figure 13) pump:
Wastewater may be forwarded by other means than U generates vacuum
forwarding pumps, e.g. by gravity if a sufficiently 0 macerates solids, and
high water column can be arranged to prevent 0 pumps wastewater in the same operation.
backflow of air into the vessel. This is the principal
employed in the column tank. For example, if the A combined vacuum generator and forwarding
system is operating at -0.5 bar, the height of the pump can generate vacuum directly on the pipeline
column needed to balance the vacuum would be to an appliance and discharge to a gravity system in
5m. The volume of the sump of the trap would the same operation. Vacuum tanks or collecting
need to be 5 x 7Lrz m3, where r is the internal radius tanks are not required normally. Combined vacuum
of the column pipe. generators and forwarding pumps can be used for all
size of systems. The size and number of combined
At the top of the column is an air water separator, and at
vacuum generator and forwarding pumps to be used
the bottom a water trap sump of sufficient capacity to
depends upon the required capacity. Combined
balance the volume of the water column created by the
vacuum generators and forwarding pumps have a
negative pressure (vacuum). The wastewater is forwarded
small footprint compared to conventional vacuum
to the gravity sewer continuously. This system is useful
stations and can be located in small ducts. A
particularly when the negative pressure is below 0.6 bar.
combined vacuum generator and forwarding pump
Column tanks of about 2m may be used in apartment
buildings when using small vacuum generators such as a is more power efficient than an ejector system, but a
combined vacuum generator and forwarding pump and large number of combined vacuum generator and
discharging into gravity drainage stacks. forwarding pumps would be more expensive to
purchase and run than a comparable vacuum-
3.8.1 Vacuum reservoir/moisture removal station-based system.
It is important to prevent moisture entering the
vacuum generating pumps to protect their 3.9.1 Operation
mechanisms and prolong their service life. This is When the combined vacuum generator and
particularly a problem with vane-type vacuum pumps forwarding pump is filled with liquid and started, a
which often have a low tolerance of any moisture liquid ring is created around the rotor. The depth of
carried over into them. Moisture carryover from the the liquid ring is governed by the size of the
collection tank can be prevented by using a moisture opening in the end plate on the pressure side. This
removal tank or an automatic condensate trap. opening is arranged such that the created liquid ring
touches the rotor hub on one side and the rotor tips
I 3.9 Combined vacuum generator and forwarding on the other. This arrangement creates a series of
p u m p (See Figure 14) progressive crescent-shaped cavities travelling from
, the vacuum to the pressure side. Air and wastewater
are drawn into these cavities and transported
through the vacuumarator. Any solids within the
wastewater are macerated by the integral macerator
before it enters the pump body.
0 number of people the system is to serve wastewater and lowers its bulk density. These factors
0 types, number and location of appliances to be enable the wastewater to behave more like a gas
connected than a liquid and in particular flow uphill.
0 wastewater temperature range (high The strength of thermoplastics is affected by
temperature grey water discharges shall be temperature. In industrial installations where high
specified concerning temperature, flow, batch wastewater temperatures are anticipated, care must
volume and frequency) be taken in the selection of pipe materials. Wastewater
0 ambient temperature range within which the temperatures greater than 70°C should be notified to
system shall operate the designer, so that the design can limit, by pipework
[7 minimum vacuum level required to operate the design and buffer volume sizing, possible boiling due
interface units and vacuum toilets to pressures lower than atmosphere.
0 air to water ratios required for the interface units Installation of vacuum pipes and fittings follow
0 air consumption of vacuum toilets, and current water system practices. Isolation valves are
0 permissible leakage factors. installed in branches and mains to allow portions
of the main to be isolated for repairs or
The following parameters are required to calculate
troubleshooting.
the pipe sizes and system layout. They should be
determined by the designer and equipment supplier Although most drainage systems only have
for each system: relatively short distances between the appliances
0 total wastewater flow and vacuum station, long vacuiim pipelines are laid
0 vacuum toilet flush frequency with a series of reforming pockets (see Figure 18).
[7 dynamic losses between the vacuum station
When the propulsion effect of the air has
and the furthest appliance on each pipeline diminished, the wastewater remaining within the
pipework will drain under gravity into the reforming
0 static losses between the vacuum station and pockets. When the next interface valve opens, the
the furthest appliance on each pipeline
movement of the air will remove the water from the
0 required operational value of vacuum pocket and transport it as a slug further towards the
0 required vacuum generator capacity vacuum station. This enables the wastewater to be
0 required forwarding pump capacity, if utilised transported to the vacuum station in a series of
0 required collecting tank capacity, if utilised interface valve operations.
0 pipe sizes, and
0 vacuum recovery time.
I Wash hand
basins Vacuum ww
60 m m
vucuum line
Pocket line
Vent from
65 mrn
vacuum
header
Vecuum
discharge
line
T L
Figure 16 - Typical short system pipework layout
Licensed copy from CIS: rennes.desamparado@arcadis.com, Hyder Consulting Middle East Ltd, 12/01/2020, Uncontrolled
klxiKL
slop 0 5%
cast integrally with the concrete floor slab or floor >.?Qm
Vacuum toilets
Annually - inspect, clean and check the function of the toilet and carry out maintenance if necessary.
Remove and replace the rinse ring.
Five yearly - remove and replace the components of the water inlet valve and the discharge valve. Inspect the
functional control flushing mechanism and carry out maintenance if necessary.
Vacuum station
Weekly - visual inspections; record hours run by vacuum generators and forwarding pumps (inspect data on
chart recorder).
Monthly - routine operational maintenance.
Annually - mechanical and electrical maintenance.
BIBLIOGRAPHY