Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4. "Of all things the measure is man, of the things that are, that they are, and of
things that are not, that they are not," said Protagoras. Although the phrase
seems to imply total relativism (as it is almost always interpreted), there is no
way of knowing if this is what Protagoras intended. Just a few fragments of
Protagoras' work have been preserved. Protagoras is not saying that the gods do
not exist in this passage; rather, he is claiming that based on his subjective
experience, he cannot determine if they do. The passage could just as easily be
interpreted as him saying, "I don't know enough about this issue to make an
educated opinion on it," as it could be interpreted as a suggestion about the
presence or non-existence of deities.
5. He concluded that not all pleasures are beneficial to everyone. There are certain
situations that may offer people joy, but they were carried out in an extremely
unpleasant manner, such as rape. The victim may have felt joy, but she also felt
pain and disgust. As a result, he was opposed, and for Christians, happiness is
not the most important aspect of life.