Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reduced integration
Only quadrilateral and hexahedral elements can use a reduced-integration scheme; all wedge, tetrahedral, and triangular
solid elements use full integration, although they can be used in the same mesh with reduced-integration hexahedral or
quadrilateral elements.
Reduced-integration elements use one fewer integration point in each direction than the fully integrated elements. Reduced-
integration, linear elements have just a single integration point located at the element's centroid. (Actually, these first-order
elements in Abaqus use the more accurate “uniform strain” formulation, where average values of the strain components are
computed for the element. This distinction is not important for this discussion.) The locations of the integration points for
reduced-integration, quadrilateral elements are shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Integration points in two-dimensional elements with reduced integration.
Abaqus simulations of the cantilever beam problem were performed using the reduced-integration versions of the same four
elements utilized previously and using the four finite element meshes shown in Figure 2. The results from these simulations are
presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Normalized tip displacements with reduced-integration
elements.
Linear reduced-integration elements tend to be too flexible because they suffer from their own numerical problem called
hourglassing. Again, consider a single reduced-integration element modeling a small piece of material subjected to pure bending
(see Figure 2).
Figure 2. Deformation of a linear element with reduced integration subjected to bending moment M.
Neither of the dotted visualization lines has changed in length, and the angle between them is also unchanged, which means
that all components of stress at the element's single integration point are zero. This bending mode of deformation is thus a
zero-energy mode because no strain energy is generated by this element distortion. The element is unable to resist this type of
deformation since it has no stiffness in this mode. In coarse meshes this zero-energy mode can propagate through the mesh,
producing meaningless results.
In Abaqus a small amount of artificial “hourglass stiffness” is introduced in first-order reduced-integration elements to limit the
propagation of hourglass modes. This stiffness is more effective at limiting the hourglass modes when more elements are used
in the model, which means that linear reduced-integration elements can give acceptable results as long as a reasonably fine
mesh is used. The errors seen with the finer meshes of linear reduced-integration elements (see Table 1) are within an
acceptable range for many applications. The results suggest that at least four elements should be used through the thickness
when modeling any structures carrying bending loads with this type of element. When a single linear reduced-integration