You are on page 1of 80

JGAAP-IFRS

comparison
English version 3.0
[equivalent of Japanese version 4.0]
Contents

Contents ............................................................................ 2
Introduction ....................................................................... 3
Presentation of Financial Statements, Accounting Policies,
Changes in Accounting Estimates and Errors, Assets Held for
Sale and Discontinued Operations ......................................... 4
Consolidation ...................................................................... 7
Equity Method ................................................................... 14
Joint Ventures/Arrangements ............................................. 17
Business Combinations ....................................................... 18
Inventory .......................................................................... 21
Intangible Assets a nd Research and Development Costs ......... 23
Fixed Assets ..................................................................... 26
Investment Property .......................................................... 29
Impairment of assets .......................................................... 31
Leases .............................................................................. 33
Financial Instruments ......................................................... 36
Foreign Currency ............................................................... 56
Income Tax ........................................................................ 60
Provisions and Contingencies .............................................. 64
Construction Contracts ...................................................... 67
Revenue Recognition .......................................................... 68
Share-Based Payments ....................................................... 71
Employee Benefits, excluding Share-Ba sed Pa yments ............. 74
Appendix 1 - The Adoption of IFRS in Japan .......................... 78
Appendix 2 - IFRS Related Resources ................................... 79

2
Introduction

Today, in a move towards improving the comparability of financial statements and to reducing
the costs of raising capital in international markets and so on, countries around the world are
converging their national accounting standards with International Financial Reporting
Standards (“IFRS”) or are adopting IFRS itself.

In Japan too, The Accounting Standards Board of Japan (“ASBJ”) and the International
Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”) concluded the “Tokyo Agreement” in August 2007 and
agreed to the acceleration of convergence. Specifically, it outlined that the significant
differences between Japanese generally accepted accounting principles (“JGAAP”) and IFRS
would be eliminated by the end of 2008 and that the remaining differences would be
eliminated by 30 June 2011. Through the convergence project consistent with that
agreement, the differences between IFRS and JGAAP are eliminated considerably.

Furthermore, in February 2009 the Financial Services Agency of Japan issued a proposed road
map for adopting IFRS, and serious consideration of adoption of IFRS in Japan commenced.

There are still a number of differences between JGAAP and IFRS because convergence based
on the “Tokyo Agreement” is ongoing and as revisions continue to be made and new standards
issued in IFRS.

In this booklet, we outline the differences between the two sets of standards by accounting
topic. It is not possible to describe comprehensively every difference which could arise in
accounting for all transactions, and we have focused as much as possible on those differences
which are considered to be most common in current practice.

We have taken care in preparing this booklet. However as the information is summarised, this
booklet is intended to be used as general guidance only and is not intended to be used as
detailed advice or in place of professional judgment. Please refer to the original texts for the
detailed guidance. Also, we recommend that you consult with specialists about particular
transactions.

Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC, Ernst & Young Global and any member firm thereof, will not be
responsible should any damages or losses arise as a result of the use of this booklet. The
information contained herein is based on accounting standards effective as at 30 June 2011.

3
Presentation of Financial Statements, Accounting
Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates and
Errors, Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued
Operations

► Significant Differences
JGAAP IFRS
Accounting (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS1.38, 39)
periods required and Preparation of Consolidated Comparative information, at a
to be presented Financial Statements: Presentation) minimum for one previous period,
The prior period and the current shall be disclosed for all amounts
period consolidated financial reported in the financial statements.
statements must be presented
comparatively.

Components of (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS1.10)


financial and Preparation of Consolidated The following statements must be
statements Financial Statements: Presentation) prepared ※1 :, 2
The following statements (※1)must
be prepared: ► Statement of Financial Position
► Consolidated Balance Sheet ► Statement of Comprehensive
► Statement of Consolidated Income (a single statement
Comprehensive Income (a single approach) ※4 or an Income
statement approach) or an Statement and a Statement of
Income Statement and a Other Comprehensive Income (a
Statement of Other two statement approach) ※3
Comprehensive Income (a two ► Statement of Changes in Equity
statement approach) (※2) ► Statement of Cash Flows
► Consolidated Statement of ► Accounting Policies and Other
Changes in Shareholders’ Explanatory Information
Equity
► Consolidated Cash Flow ※1 Titles other than those listed
Statements above may be used for these
► Consolidated Supplementary statements.
Information ※2 If an entity applies an accounting
※1 Even if an entity applies an policy retrospectively, makes a
accounting policy retrospectively, retrospective restatement of items in
makes a retrospective restatement of its financial statements or reclassifies
items in its financial statements or items in its financial statements, it
reclassifies items in its financial must prepare an opening balance
statements, it does not need to sheet for the earliest period
prepare an opening balance sheet for presented in addition to the above.
the earliest period presented. ※3 Both a single statement approach
※2 Both a single statement approach and a separate (two) statement
and a separate (two) statement approach are permitted.
approach are permitted. (Revised standard: IAS1.10A(b))
※4 A statement of profit or loss and
other comprehensive income (a
single statement)

4
JGAAP IFRS
Presentation of (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS1.87)
extraordinary and Preparation of Financial No profit or loss items are allowed to
gains and losses Statements 62,63) be presented as extraordinary items
Items related to extraordinary gains in the statement of comprehensive
and losses are presented by category income, the income statement (when
in accordance with their nature. presented) or in the notes.

Other In principle, it is not expected that ( IAS 1.95,96)


comprehensive there will be items of comprehensive Certain items are recognised in other
income not income that, as in IFRS, will not be comprehensive income and are not
reclassified to reclassified to profit and loss reclassified to profit or loss in
profit or loss subsequently. subsequent periods.

(Revised standard IAS 1.82A)


Within other comprehensive income
items which will not be reclassified
subsequently to profit or loss; and
items which will be reclassified
subsequently to profit or loss when
specific conditions are met shall be
separately presented.

Presentation of (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS1.83)


the total of and Preparation of Consolidated (revised standard IAS 1.81B)
profit/loss and Financial Statements 65.3 69 7.2) Profit (or loss) and total
comprehensive Profit (or loss) attributable to comprehensive income for the period
income minority interests is presented in the attributable to non-controlling
attributable to consolidated profit and loss interests shall be presented.
minority statement.
interests for the The amount of comprehensive
reporting period income attributable to owners of the
( comprehensive parent and to minority interests will
income) be disclosed as allocations in the
consolidated financial statements.
Departure from No such rule exists. (IAS1.19)
a requirement of In the extremely rare circumstances
a standard to in which compliance with a
give a fairer requirement in an IFRS would be so
presentation misleading that it would conflict with
or be contrary to the Framework for
the Preparation and Presentation of
Financial Statements, it is necessary
to depart from that requirement (the
‘true and fair override’).

Non-current There are no specific rules. (IFRS5.6,15)


assets classified However, under the Standard for the If the carrying value of assets will be
as held for sale Impairment of Fixed Assets, note 2, recovered principally through a sale
(and disposal as examples of indicators of transaction rather than through
groups) impairment, disposal of a business continuing use, the asset (or disposal
operation and restructurings, group) shall be classified as held for
disposal earlier than initially planned, sale and shall be measured at the
changes in purpose of use etc. are lower of carrying amount and fair
given. value less costs to sell.
5
JGAAP IFRS
Depreciation of There are no specific rules. (IFRS5.25)
non-current However, impaired assets must be Non-current assets (or disposal
assets (or depreciated from the book value from groups) classified as held for sale are
disposal groups) which the amount of impairment loss not depreciated.
classified as held is already deducted (Standard for the
for sale Impairment of Fixed Assets 3.1).

Presentation of There are no specific rules. (IFRS 5.38)


non-current Non-current assets and liabilities
assets classified classified as held for sale (or disposal
as held for sale groups), and any cumulative income
or expense recognised in other
comprehensive income or loss
relating to a non-current asset (or
disposal group) classified as held for
sale, shall be separately presented
within assets, liabilities and equity in
the statement of financial position
and within the statement of
comprehensive income, respectively.

※The major classes of items within


assets and liabilities described above,
except for certain items, shall be
disclosed in the statement of financial
position or notes (IFRS 5.38,39)

Presentation of There are no specific rules. (IFRS5.30,33)


discontinued The following total amounts must be
operations separated as a single item from the
amounts arising from continuing
operations in the statement of
comprehensive income (profit and
loss statement):
► the post-tax profit or loss of
discontinued operations;
► the post-tax gain or loss
recognised on the measurement
to fair value less costs to sell or
on disposal of the assets (or
disposal group).
※ An analysis of post–tax profit and
loss except for certain items shall
be disclosed in the statement of
comprehensive income ( or
income statement ) or notes.

6
Consolidation
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Scope of (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.4,12,13,14)
consolidation Consolidated Financial Statements The scope of consolidation is based on
6, 7, 13) the concept of control.
The scope of consolidation is based Control exists when the parent entity
on the concept of control. is able to govern the financial and
A parent company controls another operating policies of an entity so as
company when it has control over the to obtain benefits from that entity’s
body which makes the financial, activities.
operating and business decisions (the When assessing whether an entity has
decision making body) of that other control over another entity,
company. potentially exercisable or convertible
instruments with voting rights are
There are no specific rules about the considered.
effect of potential voting power or
whether the decision maker is a (New standard IFRS10.7)
principal or an agent when judging The scope of consolidation is based on
the existence of control. the concept of control.

On the other hand, similar to ‘de facto An investor controls an investee if and
control’ in IFRS10, even if less than only if the investor has all the
half of the voting rights are held, following:
there are rules that require an entity (a) power over the investee;
to make the judgment as to whether (b) exposure, or rights, to variable
control exists by also including the returns from its involvement with the
voting rights held by closely related investee; and
parties or parties with the same (c) the ability to use its power over the
intention after considering the investee to affect the amount of the
structure of the Boards of Directors, investor’s returns.
the financial position, and the
existence of any contracts which (New standard IFRS10.B, B47)
control policy making ability etc. of When assessing control, an investor
such parties. considers its potential voting rights as
well as potential voting rights held by
other parties, to determine whether it
has power.
(New standard IFRS10.B41, B42)
It is possible, that an investor with less
than a majority of the voting rights
has rights that are sufficient to give it
power, the so-called ‘de facto control’.
(New standard IFRS10.18, B58)
When an investor with
decision-making rights (a decision
maker) assesses whether it controls
an investee, it shall determine
whether it is a principal or an agent.

7
JGAAP IFRS
Scope of (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.4, 12)
consolidation Consolidated Financial Statements All entities, which are in substance
(exception) 14) controlled must be consolidated, there
The following entities are excluded are no exceptions similar to the
from the scope of consolidation: JGAAP exceptions.
► subsidiaries where control is
temporary; (New standard IFRS10 Appendix A,
► subsidiaries which, if IFRS9.3.2.1)
consolidated, would give rise to In accordance with IFRS10, all
the risk of substantially subsidiaries must be consolidated.
misleading the judgment of There are no exemptions as in JGAAP.
interested parties

Special purpose (Treatment of the revision of the (SIC12.8)


entities (SPEs) scope of consolidation of subsidiaries SPEs shall be consolidated when the
and structured and affiliated companies) substance of the relationship between
entities (SE) (Treatment in practice regarding the an entity and the SPE indicates that
control and the influence standards in the SPE is controlled by the entity.
relation to investment vehicles)
Certain SPEs which meet certain (New standard IFRS10)
conditions are presumed not to meet As set out in IFRS10.7, structured
the definition of subsidiaries. entities (SEs) that an investor controls
The scope of consolidation of must also be consolidated.
investment vehicles is in principle
judged based on the existence of
control over operations.

Uniform (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.24, 25)


accounting Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS10.19, B87)
policies of 17) Consolidated financial statements
consolidated (Practical Interim Solution on shall be prepared using uniform
subsidiaries Unification of Accounting Policies accounting policies for like
Applied to Foreign Subsidiaries for transactions and other events in
Consolidated Financial Statements) similar circumstances.
Accounting policies and procedures If a member of the group uses
for like transactions in similar accounting policies other than those
circumstances applied by the parent adopted in the consolidated financial
and the subsidiary, in principle, shall statements for like transactions and
be unified. events in similar circumstances,
However, if the financial statements appropriate adjustments are made to
of the foreign subsidiary are prepared its financial statements in preparing
in accordance with IFRS or USGAAP, the consolidated statements.
as an interim measure, these can be
used after adjustment of five specific
items.

8
JGAAP IFRS
Non-cotermino (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.22, 23, 41(c))
us reporting Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS 10.B92, B93)
periods Note 4) The financial statements of the parent
When the difference between the end and its subsidiaries used in the
of the reporting period of the preparation of the consolidated
subsidiary and that of the parent is financial statements shall be prepared
less than three months, the financial as of the same date.
statements of the subsidiary can be When the end of the reporting period
used as they are for consolidation of the parent is different from that of
purposes. In that case, adjustments a subsidiary, the subsidiary prepares,
shall be made for the effects of for consolidation purposes, additional
significant intragroup transactions. financial statements as of the same
date as the financial statements of the
parent unless it is impracticable to do
so (after making every reasonable
effort).
In the case that it is impracticable to
align the reporting period ends, ,
adjustments shall be made for the
effects of significant transactions or
events that occur between that date
and the date of the parent’s financial
statements (the gap period is limited
to no more than three months).

Presentation of (Accounting Standard for (IAS1.82, 83)


profit or loss Consolidated Financial Statements (Revised IAS1.81B)
attributable to 39) Profit or loss and total comprehensive
non-controlling In the Consolidated Profit and Loss income for the period are presented
interests (two statement approach) and the including non-controlling interests
(minority Consolidated Profit and Loss and (minority interests), and amounts
interests) Comprehensive Income (single attributable to non-controlling
statement approach), after deducting interests and to the parent company
or adding income tax to profit before are disclosed as allocations in the
incomes taxes and similar, the profit financial statements.
before minority interests is
presented, then minority interests are
deducted or added to present the
profit and loss for the period.

In the two statement approach,


Consolidated comprehensive Income,
and in the single statement approach,
Consolidated Profit and Loss and
Comprehensive Income, as part of
presenting comprehensive income,
both amounts attributed to the
owners of the parent and amounts
attributed to minority interests are
shown.

9
JGAAP IFRS
Allocation of (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.28)
losses of a Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS10, B94)
subsidiary to 27) Even when non-controlling interests
non-controlling If the proportionate losses of result in a deficit balance, total
interests subsidiaries relating to the minority comprehensive income is attributed to
interests’ share exceed the amount both non-controlling interests and the
that the minority interests are obliged parent company.
to bear, any such excess amount is
charged to the parent company.

Loss of control (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.34)


of a subsidiary Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS10.25, B97-99)
29 ) The parent company recognises any
(Accounting Standard for Business remaining interest at fair value at the
Separations 38, 48(1)①) date that control is lost.
(Application Guidance on Accounting
Standards for Business Combinations
and Business Separations 275, 276,
288(2))
As the result of a disposal etc, when
the remaining investment represents
an investment in an associate, the
investment is accounted for using the
equity method. When the remaining
investment does not meet the
definition of an associate, it is valued
based on its carrying value in the
separate financial statements of the
parent.

10
JGAAP IFRS
Change in a (Accounting Standard for (IAS 27. 30)
parent’s Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS10.23)
ownership 28-30) Changes in a parent’s ownership
interest in a (Accounting Standard for Business interest in a subsidiary that do not
subsidiary that Separations 48, 38,17-19, 39) result in a loss of control are
does not result For purchases of an additional share accounted for as equity transactions.
in a loss of in a subsidiary, any difference
control between the value of the interest
acquired and the amount invested is
recognised as goodwill (or negative
goodwill). For disposals, any
difference between the reduction in
the interest sold and the reduction in
the investment amount is recorded as
a profit or loss on disposal of the
shares in the subsidiary.
For increases or decreases in
interests in a subsidiary as a result of
stock issues etc. or business
combinations and such like, the
difference between the increase in
the interest and increase in the
investment are treated as goodwill (or
negative goodwill) and the difference
between the decrease in the interest
and the decrease in the investment
are treated as differences arising on
change in interest (i.e. within equity).

Separate
financial (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS 27.38)
statements Instruments 17 ) (Revised IAS27.10)
In the separate financial statements, Investments in associates and
investments in subsidiaries and interests in joint ventures must be
associates are accounted for at accounted for by either:
historical cost. ► cost, or
► in accordance with IFRS9/ IAS39

However, when investments


accounted for at cost are classified as
“held for sale” in accordance with
IFRS5, such investments are
accounted for in accordance with
IFRS5.

11
JGAAP IFRS
Loss of control (Accounting Standard for (IAS27.34)
of a subsidiary Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS10.25, B97-99)
29 ) The parent company recognises any
(Accounting Standard for Business remaining interest at fair value at the
Separations 38, 48(1)①) date that control is lost.
(Application Guidance on Accounting
Standards for Business Combinations
and Business Separations 275, 276,
288(2))
As the result of a disposal etc, when
the remaining investment represents
an investment in an associate, the
investment is accounted for using the
equity method. When the remaining
investment does not meet the
definition of an associate, it is valued
based on its carrying value in the
separate financial statements of the
parent.

Change in a (Accounting Standard for (IAS 27. 30)


parent’s Consolidated Financial Statements (New standard IFRS10.23)
ownership 28-30) Changes in a parent’s ownership
interest in a (Accounting Standard for Business interest in a subsidiary that do not
subsidiary that Separations 48, 38,17-19, 39) result in a loss of control are
does not result For purchases of an additional share accounted for as equity transactions.
in a loss of in a subsidiary, any difference
control between the value of the interest
acquired and the amount invested is
recognised as goodwill (or negative
goodwill). For disposals, any
difference between the reduction in
the interest sold and the reduction in
the investment amount is recorded as
a profit or loss on disposal of the
shares in the subsidiary.
For increases or decreases in
interests in a subsidiary as a result of
stock issues etc. or business
combinations and such like, the
difference between the increase in
the interest and increase in the
investment are treated as goodwill (or
negative goodwill) and the difference
between the decrease in the interest
and the decrease in the investment
are treated as differences arising on
change in interest (i.e. within equity).

12
JGAAP IFRS
Separate
financial (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS 27.38)
statements Instruments 17 ) (Revised IAS27.10)
In the separate financial statements, Investments in associates and
investments in subsidiaries and interests in joint ventures must be
associates are accounted for at accounted for by either:
historical cost. ► cost, or
► in accordance with IFRS9/ IAS39

However, when investments


accounted for at cost are classified as
“held for sale” in accordance with
IFRS5, such investments are
accounted for in accordance with
IFRS5.

Separate
financial (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS 27.38)
statements Instruments 17 ) (Revised IAS27.10)
In the separate financial statements, Investments in associates and
investments in subsidiaries and interests in joint ventures must be
associates are accounted for at accounted for by either:
historical cost. ► cost, or
► in accordance with IFRS9/ IAS39

However, when investments


accounted for at cost are classified as
“held for sale” in accordance with
IFRS5, such investments are
accounted for in accordance with
IFRS5.

13
Equity Method
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Equity method- (Accounting Standards for (IAS28.1,13)
scope Investments, Using the Equity Method (Revised standard IAS28.16)
6) In principle, all investments in
Non-consolidated subsidiaries and associates are accounted for using
investments in associates are, in the equity method.
principle, accounted for using the
equity method.

Equity method- (Application Guideline on determining (IAS28.13,14)


scope the scope of consolidation for All entities over which an entity has
(exception) subsidiaries and associates 25, 26) significant influence are accounted
The following investments are for using the equity method.
excluded from the application of the However, investments which are
equity method: classified as held for sale in
► associates where control is accordance with IFRS5 are accounted
temporary; for in accordance with IFRS5.
► associates, which, if the equity (Revised standard IAS28.20)
method were to be applied, would An entity shall apply IFRS 5 to an
give rise to the risk of investment, or a portion of an
substantially misleading the investment, in an associate that
judgment of interested parties meets the criteria to be classified as
held for sale. Any retained portion of
an investment in an associate that has
not been classified as held for sale
shall be accounted for using the
equity method until disposal of the
portion that is classified as held for
sale takes place.

Uniform (Accounting Standards for (IAS 28.26, 27)


accounting Investments, Using the Equity Method (Revised IAS28.35,36)
policies of 9) The investor’s financial statements
associates (Practical Interim Solution on shall be prepared using uniform
Unification of Accounting Policies accounting policies for like
Applied to Foreign Affiliates for transactions and events in similar
Consolidated Financial Statements) circumstances.
Accounting policies and procedures If an associate uses accounting
for like transactions in similar policies other than those of the
circumstances used by the investor investor for like transactions and
and the associate (including its events in similar circumstances,
subsidiaries), in principle, shall be adjustments shall be made to conform
unified. the associate’s accounting policies to
those of the investor when the
Also, the “Practical Interim Solution associate’s financial statements are
on Unification of Accounting Policies used by the investor in applying the
Applied to Foreign Affiliates for equity method.
Consolidated Financial Statements”

14
JGAAP IFRS
may be applied to foreign associates
as an interim measure.
If it is extremely difficult to obtain
information for unification of
accounting policies, this is considered
to be a rational reason for not using
uniform accounting policies as
outlined in the Audit Guidance on the
Practical Interim Solution on
Unification of Accounting Policies
Applied to Foreign Subsidiaries for
Consolidated Financial Statements.

Non-cotermino (Accounting Standards for (IAS28. 24. 25)


us reporting Investments, Using the Equity Method (Revised IAS28.33, 34)
periods 10) The most recent available financial
The most recent available financial statements of the associate are used
statements of the associate are used by the investor in applying the equity
by the investor in applying the equity method. When the end of the
method. reporting period of the investor is
When the end of the reporting period different from that of the associate,
of the investor is different from that the associate prepares, for the use of
of the associate, necessary the investor, financial statements as
adjustments are made or notes given of the same date as the financial
for the effects of significant statements of the investor unless it is
transactions or events. impracticable to do so.
When it is impractical to align the
period ends, adjustments shall be
made for the effects of significant
transactions or events that occur
between that date and the date of the
investor’s financial statements
(limited to a gap of no more than
three months).

15
JGAAP IFRS
Impairment of (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS28.31-33)
associates (and Standards for Investments Using the (Revised IAS28.40-42)
joint ventures Equity Method 9) Goodwill forms part of the carrying
accounted for (Practical Guidance on Consolidation amount of an investment in an
using the equity Procedures 32) associate and is not separately
method) Where an investor recognises an recognised. Therefore it is not
impairment loss in respect of an tested for impairment separately.
associate in its separate financial Instead, the entire carrying amount of
statements, and the resulting book the investment is tested for
value after the recognition of the impairment as a single asset,
impairment loss is below the book whenever application of the
value in the consolidated financial requirements in IAS 39 indicates that
statements, any goodwill is the investment may be impaired.
immediately depreciated to the extent The impairment test itself shall be
of that difference. carried out in accordance with IAS 36.
Any reversal of that impairment loss
is recognised to the extent that the
recoverable amount of the investment
subsequently increases.

Discontinuance (Accounting Standards for (IAS28.19)


of equity Investments, Using the Equity Method (Revised standard IAS 28.22)
method 15) When equity accounting is
(Accounting Standard for Business discontinued, the investment is
Separations 41(2), 48(1)①) accounted for as a financial asset in
(Application Guidance on Accounting accordance with IFRS 9 and the fair
Standards for Business Combinations value of the investment at the date it
and Business Separations 278(2), ceases to be an associate is its fair
290(2)) value on initial recognition.
When an entity ceases to be an
associate as the result of a sale or
another event, any remaining
investment in shares is valued at the
carrying value of the investment in
the separate financial statements of
the investor.
When an entity ceases to be an
associate or jointly controlled
operation as the result of a business
combination, the shares of the
acquirer or acquiree are valued at the
carrying value in the separate
financial statements of the investor
(in principle at the market value of the
shares of the combined entity after
the business combination).

16
Joint Ventures/Arrangements
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Joint ventures/ (Accounting Standard for Business (IAS31.30,38)
arrangements Combinations 39 (2)) Within joint ventures, jointly
Jointly controlled entities are controlled entities are accounted for
accounted for using the equity by either of the following methods:
method. ► proportionate consolidation; or
► equity method.

(New standard IFRS11.20, 24)


Of joint arrangements, for a joint
operation an investor accounts for
his own assets, liabilities, and
revenue and expenses as well as/ or
his share of the jointly controlled
assets, liabilities, and revenue and
expenses of the joint operation. For
joint ventures, the equity method is
applied.

Separate (Accounting Standard for Business (IAS27.38)


financial Combinations 301) (Revised standard IAS 27.10)
statements: Investments in jointly controlled In the separate financial statements
jointly controlled entities are presented in the of the investing entity, investments
entities separate financial statements in the in subsidiaries, associates and jointly
appropriate classification such as controlled entities are accounted for
affiliates etc. either:
► at cost; or
(Accounting Standard for Financial ► in accordance with IFRS 9/IAS39.
Instruments 17) However, when investments are
Investments in subsidiaries and classified as held for sale in
associates are recorded at cost in accordance with IFRS5, they are
the balance sheet of the separate accounted for in accordance with
(non-consolidated) financial IFRS5.
statements.

17
Business Combinations

► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Definition of a (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3R Appendix A)
business Combinations 5) A business combination is a
combination A business combination is when an transaction or other event in which
entity (company or similar entity) or an acquirer obtains control of one or
a business operation, which forms an more businesses.
entity, combines with another entity
or business operation, which forms
an entity, to become one reporting
unit.
Accounting for (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.4)
business Combinations 17) The acquisition method is applied,
combinations The purchase method is applied for the pooling method is not permitted.
business combinations other than
jointly controlled entities and (IFRS3.2)
transactions with entities under IFRS 3 does not apply to the
common control. formation joint ventures or the
combination of entities or
businesses under common control.
Acquisition-relat (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.53)
ed costs Combinations 26) Expensed when the services are
(expenses Included in the cost of the business received, with the exception of debt
directly related combination (as a result form part of or equity issue costs which are offset
to the business goodwill). against the carrying amount of such
combination debt or equity on initial recognition.
which form part
of the purchase
cost)
Contingent (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.39, 58 BC349)
consideration Combinations 27) The acquirer shall recognise the
and subsequent The acquirer recognises the acquisition-date fair value of
adjustments to consideration and adjusts goodwill contingent consideration as part of
goodwill after delivery or exchange is fixed the consideration transferred in
and market value is reasonably exchange for the acquiree,
determinable. Adjustment is not regardless of the probability of
limited to a tentative reporting economic benefit arising (it is
period (such as one year). considered that fair value can be
reliably measured).
Aside from changes as a result of
additional information that the
acquirer obtains after the acquisition
date about facts and circumstances
that existed at the acquisition date
within the measurement period, no
change is made to consideration or
to goodwill.

18
JGAAP IFRS
Recognition of (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.232)
contingent Combinations 30) Contingent liabilities, which are
liabilities Contingent liabilities are recognised present obligations arising from past
when they are expenses or losses for events, are recognised regardless of
certain conditions estimated to the probability likelihood of
occur after acquisition, and the occurrence an outflow of economic
likelihood of occurrence is reflected resources arising when fair value can
in the measurement of be measured reliably.
consideration.

Intangible assets (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.B31, IAS38.33)


acquired in a Combinations 28, 29) Identifiable intangible assets must be
business (Application Guideline for Business recognised separately from goodwill.
combination Combinations 59, 370) In business combinations, the
Intangible assets must be recognised reliable measurement criterion is
outside of goodwill when they can be always considered to be satisfied.
separately identified and can be
measured rationally.

Rights There is no specific guidance. (IFRS3.29)


reacquired Where the rights meet the criteria
through a for recognition as intangible assets,
business they are recognised as such
combination (for separately from goodwill based on
example, the remaining contractual term.
trademarks
previously sold
by the acquirer)
Initial (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.19,32)
recognition of Combinations 31) One of the following methods may
goodwill and Goodwill is the amount by which the be selected on an acquisition by
measurement of acquisition cost of the entity or the acquisition basis:
non-controlling business acquired exceeds the net 1) the fair value of the entire entity
interests amount which is allocated to the acquired is measured including
(minority assets acquired or the liabilities the non-controlling interests’
interests) assumed (the so-called “purchased share, and goodwill is recognised
goodwill approach”). including that relating to the
non-controlling interests’ share
(the so-called “full goodwill
approach”); or
(Accounting Standard for
Consolidated Financial Statements 2) non-controlling interests (NCI)
20) are measured as the NCI’s share
All assets and liabilities of a of the fair value of the net assets
subsidiary are measured at their fair of the acquiree, and goodwill is
values on acquisition date (the recognised only in respect of the
so-called “full market value acquirer’s share (the so-called
method”). “purchased goodwill approach”) .

*There is no option, as in IFRS, to


measure the entire minority
interests at fair value.

19
JGAAP IFRS
Treatment of (Accounting Standard for Business (IFRS3.B63, IAS36.90)
goodwill Combinations 32) Goodwill is not amortised but is
(Accounting Standard for subject to an impairment review
Consolidated Financial Statements each reporting period. Reversals of
24) previous impairments of goodwill are
In principle, goodwill must be prohibited.
amortised within 20 years using the
straight line method or any other
rational method. However, when the
amount is insignificant, it is possible
to expense goodwill in the period in
which it arises.

(Accounting Standard for the


impairment of fixed assets 2.8)
When there is an indicator that
goodwill is impaired, the need to
recognise an impairment loss must
be considered.

20
Inventory
► Significant Differences
JGAAP IFRS
Cost of (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS2.11)
inventories and Preparation of Financial Trade discounts, rebates and other
Statements 90, and related guideline similar items are deducted in
90) determining the costs of purchase.
Purchase discounts are treated as
non-operating income.

Cost methods (Accounting Standard for (IAS2.21-27)


Measurement of Inventories 6-2, The following methods of assigning
34-4) the costs of inventories are
The following methods are permitted permitted; the specific identification
for determining balance sheets method, FIFO, and the weighted
values; the specific identification average method.
method, FIFO, the average cost
method and the retail cost method. The following guidance on cost
In certain situations, the latest measurement techniques is given in
purchase price method is allowed. the standard.
In principle, the actual cost method
should be used, however the standard
cost method and the retail cost
methods are also given as examples
of cost measurement techniques in
IAS2.
The standard cost method and retail
cost method may be used for
convenience if the results
approximate cost.

Allocation of (Cost Accounting Standard 4(1)2, (IAS2.13)


fixed 47(1)3) The allocation of fixed production
production The allocation of fixed production overheads is based on the normal
overheads overheads is based on the scheduled capacity of production facilities.
(normal capacity or normal capacity of
The allocation of fixed production
capacity) production facilities etc.
overheads is not increased in periods
Relatively large cost variances, of low production, but such
arising due to differences between unallocated overheads (unfavourable
actual prices and expected prices, are variances) are recognised as an
allocated to cost of sales and to expense in the period in which they
inventories at the end of period. are incurred (i.e. they are not
included in period end inventory).
On the other hand, in periods of
abnormally high production, the
amount of fixed overhead allocated to
each unit of production is decreased
(i.e. favourable variances are
allocated to period end inventory).

21
JGAAP IFRS
Inclusion of ( Statement of Position 130, Industry (IAS23.7-8)
borrowing costs Specific Audit Research Group 460) For those inventories which meet the
in cost Interest costs, which meet certain conditions in IAS23, in principle,
criteria, may be included in the cost of borrowing costs must be included in
inventories in respect of property the cost of inventories.
development businesses.

Measurement (Accounting Standard for (IAS2.6,9,34)


of inventories Measurement of Inventories 7, 15, Inventories shall be measured at the
16) lower of cost and net realisable value
At the period end, if the net sales (NRV). NRV is the estimated selling
value is below acquisition cost, then price less the estimated costs of
the difference between the two values completion and the estimated costs
shall be recognised as a current necessary to make the sale.
period expense.
If a write-down is required, the
Inventories held for trading are difference between cost and NRV is
carried on the balance sheet at an recognised as an expense in the
amount based on market price, and period when the write-down occurs.
any movements in this price are
recognised as current period (IAS2.4)
expenses. Note, the specific guidance Commodity broker-traders, who
for inventories held for trading is measure their inventories at fair value
similar to the treatment of financial less costs to sell, are excluded from
instruments held for trading in the only the measurement requirements
Accounting Standard for Financial of IAS2.
Instruments.

Reversals of (Accounting Standard for (IAS2.33)


write-downs Measurement of Inventories 14, 17) When the circumstances that
It is possible to select either a policy previously caused inventories to be
allowing the reversal of previous write written down no longer exist, or when
downs or a policy of non-reversal of there is clear evidence of an increase
such write downs. in net realisable value caused by
changed economic circumstances, the
However, in extraordinary
amount of the previous write-down is
circumstances, even if a policy
reversed (i.e. the reversal is limited to
allowing reversal has been selected,
the amount of the original
reversals are not allowed.
write-down).

22
Intangible Assets and Research and
Development Costs
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Accounting There is no one comprehensive (IAS38)
standard accounting standard which deals with The basis of recognition and
intangible fixed assets. measurement of intangible assets
differs depending on whether such
assets are purchased separately or
are acquired through a business
combination, or whether they are
internally generated. IAS38 covers
all these situations.

Definition (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS38.8,13,17)


and Preparation of Financial The definition of an intangible asset
Statements 28) includes all of the following
There is no separate definition for conditions:
intangible assets, however the ► an asset controlled by the entity
following are given as examples: as a result of past events;
► goodwill ► an asset from which future
► patents economic benefits are expected
► land lease rights (including to be received; and
surface rights) ► an identifiable non-monetary
► trademarks asset without physical substance.
► utility model rights
► design rights
► mining rights
► fishing rights (including common
of piscary)
► software
► leased intangible assets
and similar

Initial There is no clear guidance in respect (IAS38.18,21)


recognition and of the recognition of intangible Intangible assets shall be recognised
measurement assets. if they meet the definition of an
(recognition intangible and if, and only if:
rules) ► it is probable that the expected
future economic benefits from
the asset will flow to the entity;
and
► the cost of the asset can be
measured reliably.

23
JGAAP IFRS
In-process (Accounting Standard for Business (IAS38.33,34,42,43)
research and Combinations 28, 29) An acquirer recognises the
development (Guidance on Application of in-process research and development
acquired in a Accounting Standard for Business costs of the acquiree as an asset,
business Combinations 59, 367) separately from goodwill, when the
combination In a business combination, definition of an intangible asset is
acquisition costs are allocated to met. The definition of an intangible
such assets, where they are asset is met when:
separately identifiable and where ► the item meets the definition of
individual project costs can be an asset; and
calculated reasonably, at the date of ► the item is separately identifiable.
acquisition based on market price on
the date of the acquisition. Intangible For separately identifiable intangible
assets such as transferable legal assets, it is generally considered that
rights are considered to be their fair values can be reliably
identifiable assets. measured.

Subsequent expenditure on the Subsequent expenditure on the


above items is treated in the same above items is treated in the same
way as expenditure on internally way as expenditure on internally
generated research and development generated intangible assets (below).
costs (in other words, it is expensed
when incurred).

Internally (Accounting Standard for research (IAS38.52-62)


generated and development costs 3 and Note 3) Expenditure on research shall be
intangible assets: Expenditure on research and recognised as an expense when
research and development shall be recognised as incurred.
development an expense when incurred.
Development costs are recognised as
expenses
If there are components of software intangible assets only if the technical
development costs and production feasibility of the asset, the intention
costs that relate to research and to use or sell the asset and a number
development, these are also of other conditions can all be
recognised as an expense when demonstrated. If these conditions
incurred. cannot be demonstrated, the related
development costs must be
expensed.
There is no separate guidance
relating to the development of
computer software.

24
JGAAP IFRS
Subsequent (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS38.72,75)
measurement 3 ,4(1)B, 5) Either the cost model or the
The acquisition cost of the intangible revaluation model must be selected
asset must be allocated to the profit as an accounting policy for the
and loss each fiscal year over its subsequent measurement of
useful life, using a depreciation intangible assets.
method. The unamortised balance
The revalued amount of an intangible
shall be disclosed (revaluation is not
asset is its fair value at the date of
allowed).
revaluation less any subsequent
accumulated amortisation and any
subsequent accumulated impairment
losses. To apply the revaluation
model, fair values can only be
determined by reference to an active
market.

Amortisation In practice, intangible assets are (IAS38.88,89,102,104,108)


(useful lives) generally amortised on a straight line The useful life of an intangible asset
basis in accordance with the tax is determined as finite or indefinite.
regulations.
(However, there is a specific rule for An asset with a finite useful life is
the amortisation of software in the amortised over its useful life.
standard relating to research and The amortisation period and the
development costs (4,5).) amortisation method for an
intangible asset with a finite useful
life, along with its residual value,
shall be reviewed at least at each
financial year-end.

An intangible asset shall be regarded


as having an indefinite useful life
when, based on an analysis of all of
the relevant factors, there is no
foreseeable limit to the period over
which the asset is expected to
generate net cash flows for the
entity.
An asset with an indefinite useful life
is not amortised but is subject to an
impairment test each period.

Advertising costs There are no specific rules for (IAS38.67,69,69A,70)


advertising costs. Advertising costs shall be recognised
as an expense when incurred. An
asset can only be recognised for
prepaid advertising costs if payment
is made before advertising goods and
materials can be used or before
advertising services are received.

25
Fixed Assets
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Measurement (Guidance on auditing advanced (IAS16.24)
of cost of asset depreciation by reduction of book Assets acquired in exchange for
acquired by value of assets) another asset are measured at fair
exchange In exchanges of dissimilar assets, in value unless:
principle, either the asset given up or a) the exchange transaction lacks
the asset received is measured at fair commercial substance; or
market value. This fair value becomes the fair value of neither the asset
the acquisition cost of the received received nor the asset given up is
asset. reliably measurable.
In exchanges of assets of a similar b) If the acquired item is not
nature or for similar purposes, the measured at fair value, its cost is
asset received is measured at the measured at the carrying amount
book value of the asset given up. of the asset given up.

Capitalisation (Statement of Position 3 (IAS23.5)


of borrowing Depreciation if Fixed assets 1,4,2) A qualifying asset is an asset that
costs (Self-constructed property) necessarily takes a substantial period
When an entity constructs its own of time to get ready for its intended
property, it calculates the use or sale.
manufacturing cost based on the Cost
Accounting Standard, and acquisition (IAS23.8)
cost is based on that manufacturing Borrowing costs directly attributable
cost. to the acquisition, construction or
Interest on borrowings required for production of a qualifying asset shall
construction and for the period before be included in the acquisition cost of
operation may be included in the asset. Other borrowing costs
acquisition cost. shall be expensed when incurred.

Dismantling, (Accounting Standard for Asset (IAS16.16(c), 18, IAS37.10, 14, 19,
disposal and Retirement Obligations 3, 6, 7, 11, 45, 47, IFRIC1.3, 8)
restoration 14) The costs of dismantling and
costs etc. (Guidance on Application of Asset removing an item and restoring the
Retirement Obligations 9) site of that asset, etc. which meet the
Asset retirement obligations are recognition criteria for provisions, are
added to the carrying amount of the included in the acquisition cost of an
related fixed assets. item of fixed assets in accordance
A legal obligation (or similar) is with IAS37. A provision in IAS 37
recorded as an asset retirement includes both legal and constructive
obligation based on relevant laws obligations.
relating to the retirement of fixed
assets or contractual requirements.

The discount rate is determined at the When a fixed asset is measured using
time the liability is recorded and is not the cost model and the discount rate
subsequently changed (note that is subsequently changed, any related
where there is an increase in the provision shall be re-estimated and

26
JGAAP IFRS
estimated future cash flows, the the acquisition cost shall be adjusted
discount rate is changed at that time, for the change.
but where there is a decrease in the
estimated cash flows, the discount
rate is not changed i.e. the original
rate is used).
The expense related to the periodic
The periodic adjustment to the unwinding of the discount shall be
obligation (the unwinding of the recognised as a finance cost during
discount) is classified in the profit and the period in which the unwinding
loss account in the same way as the occurs.
depreciation of the fixed asset to
which the asset retirement obligation
relates.
The exceptional treatment of rental
Where a rental deposit (shikikin) is deposits in JGAAP is not permitted
recorded as an asset, the amount that under IFRS.
is not expected to be refunded may be
reasonably estimated using a
“short-cut” method, and that portion
is allocated to the current period and
charged to the profit and loss
account.

Subsequent There are no specific rules. (IAS16.7, 12, 13)


costs Normally, expenditure which extends Subsequent costs are capitalised if it
the useful life of an asset or which is probable that they will give rise to
improves its operating capacity is future economic benefits for the
capitalised, and expenditure which entity and if they can be measured
maintains an asset’s current level of reliably. In all other cases they are
operation is treated as maintenance expensed as incurred.
costs.

Government (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS20.24)


grants related Note 24) Government grants related to assets
to assets Government subsidies and are presented either as deferred
construction cost sharing proceeds income or are deducted from the book
can be deducted from the cost of the value of the related asset.
related assets.

(Guidance on auditing advanced


depreciation by reduction of book
value of assets)
When a company records advanced
depreciation as an appropriation of
profit through a transfer to a reserve,
this accounting method can also be
considered to be appropriate by
auditors.

27
JGAAP IFRS
Subsequent Assets are carried at cost less any (IAS16.29, 31)
measurement accumulated depreciation and any Either the cost model or the
accumulated impairment losses (the revaluation model must be selected as
revaluation model is not permitted). an accounting policy and that policy
must be applied to an entire class of
assets.
When the revaluation method is used,
revaluations shall be made regularly
to ensure that the carrying amount
does not differ materially from the
fair value at the end of the reporting
period.

Unit of There are no specific rules. (IAS16.43)


depreciation Each part of an item of property,
(components plant and equipment with a cost that
approach) is significant in relation to the total
cost of the item shall be depreciated
separately.

Review of (Audit and assurance committee (IAS16.56, 61)


residual values, report No. 81 2) The residual values, useful lives and
useful lives and Depreciation shall be determined on a depreciation methods shall be
depreciation rational basis, and as such reviewed at least each financial
methods depreciation must be carried out each year-end.
period in a planned and systematic
way.

Changes of (Guidance on change in accounting (IAS16.61)


depreciation and correction of errors 11, 18, 19, Changes in the method of
method 20) depreciation are treated as changes in
The depreciation method of fixed accounting estimates.
assets is regarded as an accounting
policy. Since a change of depreciation
method is difficult to distinguish from
a change in accounting estimate, it is
treated the same way as a change in
the accounting estimate.
However the nature of change, a valid
reason for the change and the current
effect from the change should be
stated in the notes. Where it is
difficult to reasonably estimate the
future effect of the change, this fact
should also be stated.

28
Investment Property
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Property used (Accounting Standard for Disclosures (IAS40.10)
for more than about Fair Value of Investment and If the relevant portions of a property
one purpose Rental Property 7 and related with more than one use could be sold
Implementation Guidance and separately or leased out separately
Practical Solution 7, 17) under a finance lease, an entity
A property is normally expected to be accounts for the portions separately.
separated into rental property
If the portions could not be sold
portions and other portions using cost
separately, the property is classified
accounting and other reasonable
as an investment property only if an
methods.
insignificant portion is held for the
When the proportion of the property
entity’s own use.
used for rental purposes is high, the
property can be split for presentation If the portions could not be sold
purposes between rental property and separately, the property is classified
others. as other than investment property if
When the proportion of the property the portion held for the entity’s own
used for rental purposes is low, the use is other than insignificant.
property as a whole can be booked as
"fixed assets except rental
properties" and is outside of the
scope of rental property disclosures.

Properties (Accounting Standard for Disclosures (IAS40.8(e))


under about Fair Value of Investment and Property which is being constructed
development Rental Property 6) or developed to earn rentals (i.e. for
Rental property (investment future use as investment property) is
property) includes property under accounted for as investment
development, which is intended to be property.
used as rental property in the future,
and property under redevelopment,
which is intended for continued use as
rental property in the future.
Ancillary (Accounting Standard for Disclosures (IAS40.11, 12, 14)
services about Fair Value of Investment and When the ancillary services are
associated with Rental Property 28) insignificant to the arrangement as a
a property When it is difficult to judge the whole, the related property is treated
significance of any ancillary services as an investment property. When the
offered to tenants, the classification services are significant, the property
of the property may be judged on the is treated as an owner-occupied
basis of form alone. Investment property.
property which is rented out is subject When the above determination is
to the required disclosures of a rental difficult, disclosure must be made of
property. However, property which is the criteria used in making the
rented as part of a business operation judgment.
is outside the scope of rental property
disclosures (e.g. hotels etc).

29
JGAAP IFRS
Measurement The cost model is the only method (IAS40.30)
on initial allowed (there are no specific rules The cost or the fair value model may
recognition for fair value accounting as fair values be selected.
are disclosure items only).

Fair value There are no specific rules. (IAS40.33, 35, 53, 53A, 53B, 54)
measurement If the fair value model is chosen, all
investment properties must be fair
valued, except in specific situations
where fair value cannot be reliably
determined.
Changes in fair values are recorded in
the profit and loss in the period in
which they arise.
The same principles apply to
investment property under
construction however there is a
rebuttable presumption to support
application of this in practice.

Determination (Guidance on Accounting Standard for (IAS40. 32, 36)


of fair value Disclosures about Fair Value of The fair value of an investment
Investment and Rental Property 11) property is the price at which the
The market value of rental properties property could be exchanged between
at year end is usually measured by knowledgeable, willing parties in an
observable market prices, but if arm's length transaction.
market prices are not observable, It is recommended, but not required,
calculated prices using reasonable that a valuation by an independent
assumptions are used. These valuer with a certain level of
calculated prices for rental properties experience is used.
are calculated using the method
described in the Real Estate Appraisal
Standards (Ministry of Land,
Infrastructure, Transport and
Tourism) or a similar method.

30
Impairment of assets
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Indicators of (Guidance for the application of the (IAS36.12)
impairment – standard on the impairment of fixed As the indicators of impairment are
long lived assets assets 11-17) of a broad nature, there is tendency
More precise, numerical indicators for an indication of impairment to be
are used in JGAAP than in IFRS (for judged to exist earlier than would be
example an indicator would be: if the the case under JGAAP.
market value falls below 50% of book Further, one of the examples of an
value). indicator of impairment given is if the
carrying value of net assets is more
than an entity's market capitalisation.

Impairment (Accounting Standard for the (IAS36.59)


review process impairment of fixed assets 2 2,3) 1 step approach:
2 step approach: When there is an indicator of
1. Complete a recoverability test impairment, an impairment loss is
(the carrying value of the asset is determined as the amount by which
compared to the undiscounted the carrying value of an asset
cash flows to be generated exceeds its recoverable amount.
through the use of the asset and Recoverable amount is the higher of
on its final disposal). (i) fair value less costs to dispose and
2. As a result, if the carrying value (ii) value in use (the present value of
is higher than the undiscounted future cash flows derived from using
cash flows, the carrying value is the asset, including its residual
considered to be not recoverable. value).
An impairment loss is then
recognised for the difference
between the carrying value and
the amount of the discounted
cash flows.

Reversal of (Accounting Standard for the (IAS36.110,117, 124)


impairment impairment of fixed assets 3 2) Reversals relating to goodwill are
losses Reversals of impairment losses are prohibited however, for other assets,
prohibited for all fixed assets. at the end of each period an
assessment must be made as to
whether there is any indication that a
previously recognised impairment no
longer exists.
When appropriate, the impairment
loss is reversed to the extent that it
does not exceed the carrying amount
that would have been determined
(net of amortisation or depreciation)
had an impairment not been
recognised previously.

31
JGAAP IFRS
Allocation of (Accounting Standard for the (IAS36.80,84)
goodwill impairment of fixed assets 2 8) Goodwill shall be allocated to each of
When determining the recognition of the acquirer's cash generating units,
an impairment loss, goodwill shall be or groups of cash-generating units.
allocated across the asset groups of
the business to which the goodwill Each unit or group of units to which
relates, generally at a higher level. the goodwill is allocated shall:
If the carrying amount of goodwill can ► Represent the lowest level within
be allocated to individual asset the entity at which the goodwill is
groups of the related business, based monitored for internal
on reasonable criteria, then the management purposes, and
recognition of an impairment loss can ► Not be larger than an operating
be determined after the goodwill has segment as defined by paragraph
been allocated to each asset group. 5 of IFRS 8 Operating Segments
before aggregation.

If the initial allocation of goodwill


cannot be completed before the end
of the annual period in which the
business combination is effected,
that initial allocation shall be
completed before the end of the first
annual period after the acquisition
date.

32
Leases
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Definition of a (Accounting Standard for Lease (IAS17.4,8,10)
finance lease Transactions 5, Implementation Finance leases are leases which
Guidance on Accounting Standard for transfer substantially all the risks and
Lease Transactions 9) rewards of ownership of an asset
Finance leases are defined to be regardless of whether or not title is
non-cancellable and requiring full transferred.
payout, which means meeting the Whether a lease is a finance lease or
following conditions: an operating lease depends on the
► the present value of the total substance of the transaction rather
lease payments over the term of than the form of the contract.
the non-cancellable lease is 90%
or more of the estimated cash
purchase price of the asset; or
► the lease term is approximately
75% or more of the economic
useful life of the related asset.

33
JGAAP IFRS
Lessee (Implementation Guidance on (IAS17.20)
accounting for Accounting Standard for Lease At the commencement date of the
finance leases – Transactions 22,34,35,37,45,46) lease term, the lease assets and
convenient Lease assets and lease liabilities are liabilities are recorded at the lower of
method (kanben measured as follows: the fair value of the leased assets
hou) and the present value of the
<If the lessor’s purchase price is minimum lease payments, each
clear> determined at the inception of the
Transfer of ownership: lessor’s lease.
purchase price There is no “convenient method” as
No transfer of ownership: the lower in the Japanese standards.
of the lessor’s purchase price and the
present value of the minimum lease
payments (including the residual
value of the asset)

<If the lessor’s purchase price is


unclear>
The lower of the present value of
lease payments (including the value
of any rights to purchase the asset at
a discount) and the lessee’s
estimated cash purchase price.

If any of the conditions below are


met, the convenient method may be
used, which allows accounting for the
lease as an operating lease:
► leases for depreciable assets,
which are insignificant; where the
cost of the lease is expensed
when the assets are acquired and
the total lease payments are
below a set amount;
► leases with a lease term of less
than 1 year; or
► leases where the total lease
payments are less than JPY 3
million and it is clear from the
business’s operations that they
are not significant (excluding
those leases which transfer
ownership).

Lessor (Implementation Guidance on (IAS17.39)


accounting for Accounting Standard for Lease The recognition of finance income
finance leases – Transactions 59,60) shall be based on a pattern reflecting
– insignificant Where a lease does not transfer a constant periodic rate of return on
transactions ownership and is insignificant to the the lessor’s net investment in the
lessor, it is possible to allocate the finance lease.
interest receivable on a straight line There is no “convenient method” as
basis over the lease term. in the Japanese standards.

34
JGAAP IFRS
Depreciation of (Accounting Standard for Lease (IAS17.27)
finance leases Transactions 39) The leased asset is depreciated by
It is possible to select a different the lessee over the lease term on a
depreciation policy for a leased asset basis consistent with the
than for an entity’s own fixed assets, depreciation policy adopted for its
depending on the circumstances. own depreciable assets.

Operating There are no specific rules. (SIC15)


lease-incentives In principle, incentives shall be
recognised by lessors and lessees as
part of the net consideration for the
use of the leased asset over the lease
term, on a straight-line basis. If
there is another systematic basis of
allocation which is more appropriate
than the straight line method, then it
should be used.

35
Financial Instruments
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Initial (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS 39.AG76A)
Measurement Standard for Financial Instruments No gain or loss is recognised on the
102) initial recognition of a
JGAAP does not make the same non-marketable financial asset or
assumptions as IFRS regarding financial liability.
non-listed derivatives. This allows an
entity to measure a non-listed
derivative at a valuation amount, so
long as a reasonable price estimate
can be calculated or observed.

Inclusion of (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS39.43)


transaction costs Standard for Financial Instruments For financial assets and liabilities not
in acquisition 29,56) at fair value through profit or loss,
cost The related costs of the acquisition transaction costs that are directly
of a financial asset are, in principle, attributable are included in the
included in the acquisition cost. acquisition cost.
However, costs that arise regularly Transaction costs are not included in
and which are not clearly related to the acquisition cost of financial
the cost of the acquisition may be assets and liabilities at fair value
excluded. through profit or loss.

Subsequent (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS 39. 46,55)


measurement Instruments 14, 15-18) All of the entity's financial
Receivables shall be separately instruments shall be classified into
recognised from securities. one of 5 categories.
In principle, only securities shall be (these are described further below)
classified into the financial
instrument categories.

36
JGAAP IFRS
Held-to-Maturity (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS 39. 46(b))
(HTM) Standard for Financial Instruments When measuring HTM financial
investments 274, Q&A Q22) instruments at amortised cost, the
Only securities with no excessive effective interest rate is determined
credit risk can be reclassified as HTM based on estimated future cash flows
investments. reflecting any discount due to
incurred credit losses.
(Practical Guidance on Accounting
Standard for Financial Instruments (IAS 39.11)
86) For a compound financial instrument,
A structured bond cannot satisfy the where the host financial instrument
criteria for classification as an HTM and the embedded derivatives are
investment, because of the risk separated, the host instrument itself
exposure of the principal even if the can be accounted for as HTM
embedded derivative is separated. investments.

(IAS 39.9)
(Practical Guidance on Accounting An entity shall not classify any
Standard for Financial Instruments financial assets as HTM if the entity
83) has, during the current financial year
If an entity changes its purpose for or during the two preceding financial
holding securities, it cannot classify years, sold or reclassified more than
any financial assets as HTM for 2 an insignificant amount of
years (the 2 years includes the held-to-maturity investments before
period when the purpose of maturity (more than insignificant in
possession is changed). relation to the total amount of
held-to-maturity investments), other
than sales or reclassifications
meeting certain conditions.
(Practical Guidance on Accounting
Standard for Financial Instruments (IAS 39.54)
82) After the lapse of a"penalty period"
An entity cannot reclassify securities as a result of the above, available for
as HTM investments even after the sale financial instruments can be
lapse of the “penalty period” above. reclassified to HTM investments.

(Accounting Standard for Financial


Instruments 20, Practical Guidance (IAS 39.63)
on Accounting Standard for Financial The amount of any impairment loss
Instruments 91) on HTM investments is measured as
For HTM investments with a market the difference between the asset's
value, the amount of any impairment carrying amount and the present
loss is measured as the difference value of estimated future cash flows.
between the asset's carrying amount
and its fair value.

37
JGAAP IFRS
Loans and There is no separate category for (IAS 39.46(a))
receivables loans and receivables as part of the The amortised cost method, based on
classification of securities. an effective interest method, shall be
applied to all loans and receivables
(Accounting Standard for Financial except for those that are short term.
Instruments 14)
Receivables are subsequently
measured after initial recognition by
deducting any applicable allowance
for bad debts from the receivables.

Low or non- There are no specific rules. (IFRS9.B5.1.1, B5.1.2 /


interest bearing In practice, normally these are IAS39.AG64, AG65)
loans or recognised at the loan value Loans with no interest or with a lower
receivables (amortised cost). than market interest rate are
originally measured at fair value,
which may be based on a discounted
cash flow calculation using the
prevailing market interest rate of a
similar instrument, and then
measured after recognition using the
effective interest rate method. If
the fair value of the financial asset or
financial liability at initial recognition
differs from the transaction price,
the entity shall account for that
difference according to its nature.

Scope of fair (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS 39.AG80, AG81)


value Standard for Financial Instruments Investments in equity instruments
measurement 63 provisory clause) and derivatives linked to them that
Securities that do not have a quoted do not have a quoted market price in
market price in an active market are an active market can be measured at
measured making the assumption cost if their fair value cannot be
that there is no fair value. measured reliably. However such
cases are presumed to be rare.
(Practical Guidance on Accounting
Standard for Financial Instruments
104)
Where a mature market has not yet
developed for a particular type of
derivative (for example weather
derivatives etc.), the fair value is
quite difficult to measure. In this
case, such derivatives are measured
at acquisition cost and recorded on
the balance sheet.

38
JGAAP IFRS
Loan (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IFRS9.2.1, 4.2.1 / IAS39.4, 47)
commitments Standard for Financial Instruments Certain loan commitments are
139) recognised as financial liabilities at
A financial institution that acts as a fair value when the commitment is
lender should provide disclosures in made.
the notes to the accounts for its bank
overdraft contracts (or similar) and
lending commitments. These
disclosures should cover the fact that
such items exist, the credit line
amount or the loan commitment,
after deducting the amount already
loaned.

A regular way (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IFRS9.3.1.2/IAS39.38)


purchase or sale Standard for Financial Instruments Regular way purchases or sales of
of financial 22,26) financial assets shall be recognised
assets For contracts to buy and sell and derecognised, as applicable,
securities, if the period between using trade date accounting or
trade date and settlement date is settlement date accounting.
normal in accordance with the
market rules or practices, the buyer
recognises the marketable securities
and the seller derecognises the
marketable securities on the trade
date.
However, for each category of
investment (based on the purpose of
possession), it is permitted for the
buyer to recognise only the market
movement between the trade date
and settlement date, and for the
seller only to recognise the gain or
loss on sale at the trade date.
Loans receivable and loans payable
are recognised when the loan is
made, and are derecognised when
repayment is made.

Derecognition of (Accounting Standard for Financial (IFRS9.3.2.6/IAS39.20)


financial assets Instruments12) Financial assets are derecognised
Financial assets are derecognised based on a risk and rewards
based on the "financial component" approach.
approach. If an entity has neither transferred
nor retained substantially all the risks
and rewards of ownership, then it
must determine whether it has
retained control.
If control has been retained, then the
entity continues to recognise the
asset to the extent of its continuing
involvement.

39
JGAAP IFRS
Obtaining a new (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IFRS9.3.2.11/IAS39.25)
asset or liability Standard for Financial Instruments If as a result of transfer, a financial
as a result of 37,38,39) asset is derecognised in its entirety
transferring a Any new asset or liability arising but the transfer results in the entity
financial asset when a financial asset is obtaining a new financial asset or
derecognised is recorded at market assuming a new financial liability, or
value at the date of transfer. a servicing liability, the entity shall
If the market value of the remaining recognise the new financial asset,
interest or any new asset (derivative) financial liability or servicing liability
arising on the derecognition of at fair value.
another financial asset cannot be
reasonably measured, the remaining
interest or new asset should be
measured at zero and any gain or
loss on the transfer should be
calculated as if the market value is
zero.

Accounting for (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.16,19,21)


loan Instruments 42, Practical Guidance There are no specific rules, so the
participations on Accounting Standard for Financial derecognition of loan participations
Instruments 41) is assessed based on the general
Derecognition of a receivable is requirements for derecognition.
allowed only when certain conditions
are met, such as when almost all the
risks and economic rewards of that
receivable are transferred.

Accounting for (Accounting Standard for Financial (IFRS9.B3.3.3/IAS39.AG59)


debt Instruments 42, Practical Guidance Payment to a third party, including a
assumptions on Accounting Standard for Financial trust does not, by itself, relieve the
(in-substance Instruments 46) debtor of its primary obligation to the
defeasance) The related bonds may be creditor, in the absence of legal
derecognised only when the release, and does not meet the
likelihood of a retrospective claim to criteria for derecognition.
the issuer is extremely low.

Exchange of There are no specific rules. (IFRS9.3.3.2


financial B3.3.6/IAS39.40,AG62)
liabilities and An exchange between an existing
alteration of borrower and lender of debt
conditions instruments with substantially
different terms, or a substantial
modification of the terms of an
existing financial liability (or a part of
it), shall be accounted for as an
extinguishment of the original
financial liability and the recognition
of a new financial liability.

40
JGAAP IFRS
Other financial (Accounting Standard for Financial (IFRS 9.4.2.1, IAS 39.47)
liabilities Instruments 26) After initial recognition, an entity
In principle, financial instruments are shall measure all financial liabilities
recognised on the balance sheet at at amortised cost using the effective
the amount of the debt. interest method except for financial
If an entity issues a bond at a price liabilities at fair value through profit
that is lower or higher than its or loss.
denomination, then an entity can use
amortised cost. In this case, in
addition to an effective interest
method, a straight line method is
allowed.

Classification of (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.2(a),9,45)


financial assets Instruments 15-18) Financial assets are classified into
Marketable securities are classified four categories:
as follows: ► financial assets at fair value
► securities held for trading; through the profit or loss;
► debt securities held to maturity; ► held-to-maturity investments;
► shares in subsidiaries and ► loans and receivables; and
associates; and ► available for sale financial assets.
► other marketable securities. In principle, investments in
subsidiaries, associates and joint
ventures are outside the scope of
IAS39.

(New standard IFRS9.4.1-4.4,5.2.1)


Financial assets are divided into debt
instruments and equity instruments.
► Debt instruments (bonds,・loans
receivable etc.)
Debt instruments are measured at
amortised cost only if the
“business model” test and the
“characteristics of the financial
asset test” are met and the fair
value option is not applied.
(hereinafter referred to as
FVTPL)
► Equity instruments
On acquisition an equity
instrument, which is not held for
trading, can be designated as
measured at fair value through
other comprehensive income. In
all other cases, equity
instruments are measured at fair
value through profit and loss.

41
JGAAP IFRS
Concept of fair (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS 39.AG71)
value Standard for Financial Instruments An entity determines the price at
49) which a transaction would occur at
If a financial instrument is listed on the end of the reporting period in
more than one market, then an entity that instrument in the most
determines the price in the most advantageous active market to which
active market. the entity has immediate access.

Except for some unlisted derivatives, (IAS 39,AG70)


the 'mid price' is generally used as For assets held the current bid price
the quoted market price. is used, and for assets to be acquired
(short positions) the current asking
price is normally used.

In May 2011, IFRS 13 was published.


IFRS 13 does not preclude the use of
mid-market pricing or other pricing
conventions that are used by market
participants as a practical expedient
for fair value measurements within a
bid-ask spread.

Financial There are no specific rules. (IAS 39.9)


liabilities held for
the purpose of (Accounting Standard for Financial Only if certain conditions are met,
trading and the instrument 15) can financial liabilities be designated
fair value option Securities held for trading are not as at fair value through the profit or
included in financial liabilities. loss ‘the fair value option’.
Financial instruments held for the
purpose of trading and financial
instruments for which the fair value
option has been elected, are
classified and measured at fair value
with valuation differences recognised
in net profit (FVTPL).

42
JGAAP IFRS
Fair value option There are no specific rules. (IAS39.9,11A-13)
If certain criteria are met, financial
assets and liabilities, which are not
held for trading purposes, can be
measured at fair value (the fair value
option). Such financial assets and
liabilities must then be fair valued
every period, and a valuation gain or
loss recognised.

(IFRS9.4.1.5)
An entity may, at initial recognition,
irrevocably designate a financial
asset as measured at fair value
through profit or loss if doing so
eliminates or significantly reduces a
measurement or recognition
inconsistency (sometimes referred to
as an ‘accounting mismatch’) that
would otherwise arise from
measuring assets or liabilities or
recognising the gains and losses on
them on different bases.

(IFRS 9.4.2.2)
An entity may, at initial recognition,
irrevocably designate a financial
liability as measured at fair value
through profit or loss under certain
conditions.
However, the change in the fair value
of the financial liability that is
attributable to the change in an
entity’s own credit risk shall be
accounted for as other
comprehensive income, unless doing
so creates or enlarges a
measurement or recognition
inconsistency (sometimes referred to
as ‘an accounting mismatch’). This
OCI is prohibited from being
reclassified to profit or loss.

43
JGAAP IFRS
Classification (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS 39.50)
change of Standard for Financial Instruments An entity shall not reclassify any
financial 80) financial instrument as held at fair
instruments The classification of securities (by value through profit or loss after
the purpose of possession) cannot be initial recognition just because it
changed without a rational reason. changes its operating policy. A
For example, a change of operating financial asset may be reclassified
policy or a similar specific out of that “fair value through profit
circumstance would allow an entity or loss” category only in rare
to change its purpose of possession circumstances. Even the recent
of a security. financial crisis allows only certain
reclassifications.

(IFRS 9.4.4.1)
When, and only when, an entity
changes its business model for
managing financial assets it shall
reclassify all affected financial assets
(debt instruments). Equity
instruments held and financial
liabilities cannot be reclassified.

Available-for-sale Only securities can be accounted for (IAS 39.9)


financial assets as ‘other marketable securities’. As long as they are not held as
FVTPL, any financial assets can be
(Accounting Standard for Financial accounted for as available for sale.
Instruments 18) Receivables can be accounted for as
‘Other marketable securities’ are available for sale financial assets.
presented when no other categories
are appropriate.

(Accounting Standard for Financial The method of separate presentation


Instruments 18 (2)) given under Accounting Standard for
With regard to ‘other marketable Financial Instruments 18(2) is not
securities’, unrecognised gains are allowed.
presented within equity, while
unrecognised losses are presented as
a current loss.

(Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS 39.46)


Instruments Note 7) A fair value at the end of reporting
The average market price over a one period must always be used without
month period can be used as the fair any exceptions.
value measurement base at the end
of the reporting period for ‘other
marketable securities’.

44
JGAAP IFRS
Valuation of (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.55(b),AG83)
available-for-sale Instruments 18, 20-21) For available-for-sale financial
financial assets The carrying values of securities are assets, fair value adjustments (after
Gains and losses determined using market values, and considering deferred tax) are taken
related to the valuation differences are to other comprehensive income until
FVTOCI/other recognised (after considering derecognition. This excludes,
marketable deferred tax) by one of the following however, interest charges arising
securities methods: from the effective interest method,
(equities) ► the total amount is directly impairment losses and foreign
recorded as part of net assets exchange differences
(not through P&L); For non-monetary securities (such as
► valuation gains, where the equity instruments) foreign exchange
market value exceeds acquisition differences are recognised in other
cost, are recognised as a part of comprehensive income.
net assets. Valuation losses,
where the market value is below (New standard IFRS9.4.2, 5.7.5)
acquisition cost, are recognised The classification “available-for-sale
as a loss in the current period. financial assets” is abolished. If the
entity makes the election at initial
When fair value is decreases recognition to measure equity
dramatically, and there is no instruments at fair value through
possibility of a recovery or the other comprehensive income, only
decrease is significant, an dividend income is recorded in profit
impairment loss should be recognised and loss. All other changes are
and the difference between the recorded in equity and are not
carrying value and fair value shall be subsequently reclassified to profit or
reclassified to profit or loss. loss.
Reversal of impairment losses is
prohibited.

Foreign (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS39.AG83,IAS21.28)


exchange gains Standard for Financial Instruments If the available–for-sale financial
and losses on 16) assets are foreign currency
foreign currency For foreign currency denominated denominated monetary items (i.e.
denominated “other marketable securities”, any bonds), any foreign exchange gains
available-for-sale foreign currency translation and losses are recognised in profit or
financial assets differences arising on the cost or loss.
and other amortised amount are treated in the
marketable same way as valuation differences. (new standard IFRS 9. B5.7.2-B5.7.4
securities However, for foreign currency / IAS 21.28)
denominated bonds, foreign currency Foreign exchange gains and losses on
differences arising from changes in monetary assets and monetary
the foreign currency denominated liabilities are to be recognised in
market value can be treated as profit or loss.
valuation differences, and any other
differences can be treated as foreign Exchange differences arising on an
exchange gains or losses. equity instrument classified as FVOCI
and denominated in a foreign
currency are recognised through
OCI.

45
JGAAP IFRS
Amortisation and (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS39.9,46,47)
the effective Standard for Financial Instruments Normally, the effective interest rate
interest rate 70) (EIR) method is applied.
method Amortisation is based on the
effective interest rate method in
principle, however the straight line (IAS 39.9)
method is also allowed for EIR includes all fees and points paid
convenience, providing it is applied or received between parties to the
consistently. contract that are an integral part of
the effective interest rate,
An effective interest rate method transaction costs, as well as all other
takes into account the interest premiums or discounts and incurred
amount only. losses. It does not consider future
credit losses.

Investments in (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.AG80,AG81)


unlisted equities Instruments19, Practical Guidance Except in cases where appropriate
(shares with no on Accounting Standard for Financial models are not available,
market value) Instruments 63) investments in unlisted equity
For shares which are not traded or instruments are measured at fair
for which there is no market value value.
based on that trading, if market value
is extremely difficult to measure, (New standard
then measurement at cost is allowed. IFRS9.5.2.1,B5.5-B5.8)
The above exemption is abolished
and all investments in equity
instruments must be measured at fair
value. However, in limited
circumstances, cost may be an
appropriate estimate of fair value.
There is guidance in the standard as
to when that would not be
appropriate.

Separation of (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.63-65, 66,67-70)


bad debts Instruments 20-21, 27-28) Impairment is considered for each of
allowances and Impairment of financial instruments the following categories: impairment
impairment is considered separately by the of financial assets carried at
following categories: bad debts on amortised cost; impairment of
receivables; and impairments of financial assets carried at cost; and
securities. impairment of available-for-sale
assets.
(Accounting Standard for Financial
Instruments 27, Practical Guidance
on Accounting Standard for Financial
Instruments 106)
Based on the financial condition of
the creditor and its operating results
etc., impairments are considered by
each of the following categories:
general receivables; receivables with
risk of default; and bankrupt,
delinquent, and doubtful receivables.

46
JGAAP IFRS
Bad debt (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.63-65, 66,67-70)
allowances and Instruments 20-21) Impairment of financial instruments
impairment For securities, where the fair value is considered using the model
(equities) decreases dramatically (unless there appropriate for each of the following
is a possibility of recovery), the categories: impairment of financial
carrying value of those financial assets carried at amortised cost;
assets is reduced to fair value impairment of financial assets
(market value), and the related loss is carried at cost; and impairment of
recognised in profit or loss. available-for-sale assets.

For shares whose market value is Where there is objective evidence of


extremely difficult to measure, if the impairment, regardless of
value in substance decreases recoverability, an impairment loss is
dramatically, the carrying amount recognised.
shall be reduced to the in substance
value and the loss shall be accounted Securities are assumed to have
for through profit or loss. market value.

(Practical guidance on Accounting


Standard for Financial Instruments
93) (IAS39.63,66)
It is assumed that the market value For financial instruments accounted
of a security is extremely difficult to for at amortised cost, where there is
measure. objective evidence of impairment,
regardless of recoverability, the
carrying value of those financial
assets is reduced to the estimated
present value of future cash flows,
and the related loss is recognised in
profit or loss.

For equity instruments, both a


significant decrease in fair value and
a long term decrease in fair value can
be objective evidence of impairment.

47
JGAAP IFRS
Impairment of ( Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.58,59,63,66,67)
loans and Instruments 27, 28) Where there is objective evidence of
receivables Bad debt allowances are estimated impairment, regardless of
differently depending on the recoverability, the carrying value of
category of financial asset as follows: financial assets is reduced to the
► General receivables: Calculated estimated present value of future
based on the historical rates of cash flows and the related loss is
doubtful debts and reasonable recognised in profit or loss. For
assumptions. available-for-sale financial assets,
► Receivables with risk of default: the reduction in fair value recognised
Depending on the situation of the in other comprehensive income is
receivable, either of the reclassified to profit or loss when the
following methods are applied asset is impaired.
consistently:
► calculation of the doubtful (IFRS9.5.2.1-5.2.2,5.4.1,
debt amount, based on the B5.12-B5.15)
irrecoverable balance The separate classification of loans
remaining after reducing it and receivables is abolished, but for
by the amount expected to those items which are measured at
be collected from collateral amortised cost, the assessment of
and similar items. impairment is carried out in
► estimation of the amount of accordance with IAS39.
doubtful debts as the
difference between the
present value of future cash
flows and book value.

Bankrupt, delinquent, and doubtful


receivables: The estimated doubtful
debt amount is the irrecoverable
amount remaining after deduction of
amounts expected to be collected
through realisation of collateral.

48
JGAAP IFRS
Impairment Marketable securities held for trading (IAS39.65,66,69,70)
reversals continue to be measured at market If, in a subsequent period, the
value after impairment, however amount of the impairment loss
impairments of debt securities held decreases and the decrease can be
to maturity and other marketable related objectively to an event
securities must not be reversed. occurring after the impairment was
recognised, the previously
recognised impairment loss shall be
reversed.

However, for equity instruments


where fair value cannot be reliably
measured, for derivative assets
linked to such equity instruments,
and for equity instruments classified
as available-for-sale, impairment
losses shall not be reversed.

(New standard IFRS9.5.4.1,


B5.12-B5.15)
For equity instruments there will be
no further issue concerning
impairment (or reversal thereof) as
fair value measurement will be used.
For debt instruments measured at
amortised cost, there is no change to
IAS39 regarding the reversal of
impairment.

For investments classified at FVTOCI,


only dividend income is accounted
for in profit or loss, and cumulative
other comprehensive income shall
not be reclassified to profit or loss
subsequently. Therefore,
impairment and impairment loss
issues do not arise.

(IAS 39.65)
For financial assets carried at
amortised cost, if in a subsequent
period, the amount of the impairment
loss decreases and the decrease can
be related objectively to an event
occurring after the impairment was
recognised, the previously
recognised impairment loss shall be
reversed.

49
JGAAP IFRS
Valuation of (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.47)
financial Instruments 26) With the exception of those financial
liabilities Balance sheet amounts are based on liabilities valued at fair value through
the amount of the liability at profit or loss, an entity shall measure
maturity. However, the amortised all financial liabilities at amortised
cost method should be used where cost using the effective interest
the proceeds and the amount of the method.
liability due on maturity differ.

Classification of There is no comprehensive standard (IAS32.11,16A-16D,15,18)


financial dealing with the classification of debt IAS32 deals comprehensively with
liabilities and and equity, however normally the classification of equity and
equity classification is based on legal form. liabilities. Classification is determined
instruments based on the substance of the
contract and definitions of financial
liability (asset) and equity.

Convertible (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS32.15,28)


bonds – Instruments 36, Implementation After evaluating the terms of the
accounting by Guidance on Corporate Accounting contract, the financial instrument is
the issuer Standards No. 18) classified as debt or equity according
Either of two methods may be used: to the substance of the contract.
record the bond as a single amount
without separation, or separate the
bond and the share rights portion.

Financial liability (Interim Treatment relating to the (IAS32.35, IAS39.9)


issue costs Accounting for Deferred Tax Assets 3 Bond issue costs are recognised by
(2)) including them in the effective rate of
► Principle: account for issue costs interest, and as such they are
as non-operating expenses amortised as interest.
► However, such costs can be
accounted for as deferred assets
and may be amortised throughout
the bond redemption period using
the interest method, or using a
straight-line method provided
that method is applied
consistently.

50
JGAAP IFRS
Costs related to (Accounting Standard Treasury (IAS32.35,37)
equity Shares and Reversals of Legal Transaction costs of equity
transactions Reserves 14) transactions shall be accounted for
(Tentative Treatment relating to the as a deduction from equity, net of
Accounting for Deferred Tax Assets 3 any related income tax benefit.
(1))
► Costs related to the acquisition,
disposal, or extinguishment of
treasury stock are accounted for
as non-operating expenses.
► Costs related to share exchanges
as part of financial activities to
enlarge the business (including
share exchanges as part of a
reorganisation) should be
accounted as deferred assets,
and amortised using the
straight-line method within three
years from the day of the
exchange.

Transaction There are no standards regarding the (IAS32.38)


costs related to allocation of transaction costs to a Transaction costs that relate to the
compound liability component and an equity issue of compound financial
financial component. instruments are allocated to the
instruments liability and equity components of the
instrument in proportion to the
allocation of proceeds.

51
JGAAP IFRS
Derivatives- (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IFRS 9. Appendix A/IAS39.9)
definition Standard for Financial Instruments 6) A derivative is a financial instrument
A derivative is a financial instrument or other contract with all three of the
with the following characteristics: following characteristics:
► The value of the rights or a) its value changes in response to
obligations respond to changes changes in an underlying
in an underlying variable and the variable (i.e. specified interest
contract has 1) an underlying rate, financial instrument price,
variable and 2) either a fixed commodity price, foreign
nominal amount or determinable exchange rate, index of prices or
settlement amount, or both a rates, credit rating or credit
fixed nominal amount and a index, or another variable),
determinable settlement provided, in the case of a
amount. non-financial variable, that the
variable is not specific to a party
► There is no initial net investment
to the contract;
or no significant net investment
compared to that which would be b) it requires no initial net
required for other similar types investment or an initial net
of contracts that would have a investment that is smaller than
similar response to changes in would be required for other
market conditions. types of contracts that would be
expected to have a similar
► Net settlement (payment of the
response to changes in market
difference) of the contract is
factors; and
required or accepted; net
settlement can be easily carried c) it is settled at a future date.
out separately to the contract, or
even if physical settlement
occurs, in substance it leaves the
counterparty in no different
position than if net settlement
had occurred.

52
JGAAP IFRS
Embedded (Accounting Standards for Other (IAS39.11)
derivatives Compound Instruments) An embedded derivative shall be
It is necessary to separate embedded separated from the host contract if
derivatives if all of the following all of the below are met:
conditions are met: ► the economic characteristics and
► it is possible that the underlying risks of the embedded derivative
asset or liability could be are not closely related to those
affected by the risks arising from of the host contract;
the embedded derivative; ► a separate instrument with the
► a separate instrument with the same terms as the embedded
same terms as the embedded derivative would meet the
derivative would meet the definition of a derivative; and
definition of a derivative; and ► the hybrid (combined)
► the impact of changes in fair instrument is not measured at
value are not reflected in profit fair value with changes in fair
and loss. value recognised in profit or loss.
However, where embedded
derivatives are separated for (IFRS9 4.3.1-4.3.3)
management purposes and certain An embedded derivative with a host
conditions are met, they may be contract that is a financial asset shall
separated. not be separated. The derivative is to
be included with the host contract
and shall be measured at amortised
cost or fair value through profit and
loss depending on the characteristics
of the cash flows of the entire
contract.
Note: for contracts with non-financial
asset hosts, the separation criteria of
IAS39 continue to apply.

Hedge (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.86,89,95)


accounting Instruments 32) There are three types of hedge
As a general rule, profits, losses or accounting as follows:
valuation differences related to the ► Fair value hedges: changes in
hedging instrument are deferred as a fair value arising from exposures
part of net assets (equity). relating to the hedged item and
However, where “other marketable changes in the fair value of the
securities” are the hedged item, fair hedging item are both
value hedges are permitted, where recognised in the profit and loss.
the market fluctuations of the ► Cash flow hedges: the effective
hedged item are recorded in profit or portion of the changes in fair
loss. value of the hedging instrument
is recognised in other
comprehensive income.
► Hedges of a net investment in a
foreign operation.

53
JGAAP IFRS
Ineffective (Implementation Guidance on (IAS39.95(b))
portions of Financial Instruments 172) The ineffective portion of the gain or
hedges The ineffective portion of the gain or loss on the hedging instrument shall
loss can be deferred where the be recognised in profit or loss (this is
hedging instrument as a whole is particularly notable for cash flow
judged to be effective and the hedges).
requirements for hedge accounting
are fulfilled.
Where the ineffective portion of the
hedge can be separately identified in
a rational manner, it may be
recognised in profit or loss in the
current year.

Accounting for (Implementation Guidance on (IAS39.97,98)


forecast Financial Instruments 170,338) When an asset or liability is
transactions Deferred profits or losses from cash subsequently acquired and the gain
flow hedges relating to forecast or loss on the cash flow hedge of the
transactions are recognised as an forecast transaction has been
adjustment to the book value of the recognised in OCI:
asset acquired, and are reflected in ► for non-monetary items, that gain
profit and loss when the cost of the or loss is reclassified to profit or
related asset affects profit or loss. loss as the non-monetary item
However, if the asset acquired is an affects profit and loss, or is
interest accruing financial asset like a reclassified to adjust the carrying
loan, the profits or losses arising on amount of the non-monetary
the hedge may be treated as a item;
deferred hedge with profits or losses ► for monetary items, that gain or
recorded in net assets (equity). loss is reclassified to profit or loss
as the monetary item affects
profit and loss.

Using the foreign (Accounting Standard for Financial There are no such rules, and this
currency Instruments 43) method is not allowed.
contract rate
(furiate shori) When the requirements of hedge
accounting are met, foreign currency
denominated receivables and
payables may be translated using the
rate in the forward currency
contract.

Interest rate (Accounting Standard for Financial There are no such rules, and this
swap special Instruments 107) method is not allowed.
method Where certain conditions are met, an
interest swap contract is not
recognised at market value, but
rather the swap interest is directly
adjusted to increase or decrease the
interest on the relevant financial
assets or liabilities.

54
JGAAP IFRS
Documentation (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS39.88(a) and others)
requirements Instruments 31) Hedge documentation shall not be
(Practical Guidance on Accounting abbreviated.
Standard for Financial Instruments
144,145)
Hedge documentation may be
abbreviated if certain conditions are
met.

Assessment of (Implementation Guidance on (IAS39.88(e),F.4.2,F.4.7,F.5.5 and


hedge Financial Instruments others)
effectiveness 143(2),146,156,158)
If the main provisions of the hedging The assessment of hedge
instrument and the hedged item are effectiveness cannot be cut short as
the same and changes in market in JGAAP.
rates or cash flows are expected to
perfectly offset, the hedge Expected hedge effectiveness may be
effectiveness assessment may be assessed on a cumulative basis if the
abbreviated. hedge is so designated, and that
condition is incorporated into the
If an initial test shows that the hedge
appropriate hedging documentation.
is highly effective and even if a
Therefore, even if a hedge is not
subsequent test shows it to be
expected to be highly effective in a
ineffective, if the range of
particular period, hedge accounting
fluctuations is small and are expected
is not precluded if effectiveness is
to be temporary, hedge accounting
expected to remain sufficiently high
may be continued.
over the life of the hedging
For hedges which fix cash flows, if relationship.
the cumulative change in the cash
flows of the hedging instrument and Further, in the ongoing assessment
the hedged item are highly of the effectiveness of a cash flow
correlated, they are accepted as hedge, it is necessary to compare the
effective. changes in the fair value of the cash
flows of the hedging instrument with
the changes in the discounted
expected cash flows arising from the
hedged item.

55
Foreign Currency
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Determination of Functional currency is not clearly (IAS21.8-12,21)
functional defined. Management must determine the
currency functional currency by considering
the primary economic environment
in which the entity operates.
A foreign currency transaction shall
be recorded, on initial recognition in
the functional currency, by
translating the foreign currency
amount at the spot exchange rate
between the functional currency and
the foreign currency at the date of
the transaction.

Foreign currency (Accounting Standard for Foreign (IAS21.8,20)


transactions Currency Transactions Note 1) A transaction that is denominated or
A foreign currency transaction is requires settlement in a currency
defined as a transaction for which other than the functional currency
the trading price or other transaction
price is denominated in a foreign
currency (that is, a transaction
denominated in a currency other
than Japanese yen).

Classification of (Accounting Standard for Foreign (IAS21.8)


foreign Currency Transactions 2,3) A foreign operation is an entity that
operations Foreign operations are classified as is a subsidiary, associate, joint
foreign branches or as foreign venture or branch of a reporting
subsidiaries and similar. entity, the activities of which are
based or conducted in a country or
currency other than those of the
reporting entity.
A foreign operation is not further
classified as a foreign branch or as a
foreign subsidiary as in JGAAP.

56
JGAAP IFRS
Translation of (Accounting Standard for Foreign (IAS21.39,40,44)
foreign currency transactions 2,3) The results and financial position of
operations Branches foreign operations shall be translated
The foreign currency transactions of into the presentation currency of the
foreign branches are accounted for reporting entity (after their
in the same way as the transactions recognition in functional currency)
of the head office, in principle, with using the following method, provided
the following exceptions: that the functional currency is not
► Income and expenses can be the currency of a hyperinflationary
translated at average rates for economy.
the period. ► Assets and liabilities for each
balance sheet presented shall be
► Under certain conditions, the
translated at the closing rate at
closing rate at the date of the
the date of that balance sheet.
balance sheet can be used to
translate all balance sheet items. ► Income and expenses for each
In this case, income and expenses statement of comprehensive
can also be translated at the income (income statement) shall
same rate. be translated at the exchange
rates at the dates of the
► The exchange differences arising
transactions. Average rates for
from the use of a translation
the period are often used if the
method other than that used by
exchange rates do not fluctuate
head office are recognised as
significantly.
exchange gains or losses in the
income statement. ► All resulting exchange
differences arising from the
above translations shall be
Subsidiaries
recognised as a separate
Assets and liabilities in foreign
component of equity.
subsidiaries and similar entities are
translated into yen at the exchange
rates at the date of the balance
sheet.
► Equity related items acquired by
the parent are translated at the
exchange rate at the time of the
acquisition and subsequently
acquired items are translated at
the date of each transaction.
► Revenue and expenses are
translated at average rates in
the period in principle, however
the closing rate at the date of
the balance sheet can also be
used. Transactions with the
parent are translated using the
parent’s exchange rate, any
differences which arise are
recognised as exchange gains or
losses in the income statement.
► Exchange differences are
recognised as a separate
component of equity.

57
JGAAP IFRS
Disposal or (Accounting Standard for Foreign (IAS21. 48A)
partial disposal of Currency Transactions and related On the disposal of an entity’s entire
a foreign Implementation Guidance and interest in a foreign operation, the
operation Practical Solution 42) cumulative amount of the exchange
When the parent's proportion of differences relating to that foreign
ownership interest decreases as a operation shall be reclassified from
result of a change in equity, the equity to profit or loss (as a
related decreased portion of foreign reclassification adjustment) only if
currency translation adjustments one of the following conditions is
shall be recognised as a profit or loss met:
on sale of investments in the ► The loss of control of a
consolidated Income Statement. subsidiary
► The loss of significant influence
over an associate
► The loss of joint control over a
jointly controlled entity

(IAS 21. 48C)


On the partial disposal of a subsidiary
that includes a foreign operation, the
entity shall re-attribute the
proportionate share of the
cumulative amount of the exchange
differences recognised in other
comprehensive income to the
non-controlling interests in that
foreign operation (when control
continues).
In any other partial disposal of a
foreign operation the entity shall
reclassify to profit or loss only the
proportionate share of the
cumulative amount of the exchange
differences recognised in other
comprehensive income.

Net investment in There are no specific rules relating to (IAS21.32)


a foreign the exchange differences arising Exchange differences arising on a
operation from a net investment in a foreign monetary item that forms part of a
operation. reporting entity’s net investment in a
Accordingly, foreign exchange foreign operation are recognised in
differences arising on such monetary profit or loss in the separate financial
items are recognised in profit or loss statements of the reporting entity.
in the separate and consolidated However, in the consolidated
financial statements of the reporting financial statements, such exchange
entity. differences are recognised initially in
other comprehensive income and are
reclassified to profit or loss on
disposal of the net investment.

58
JGAAP IFRS
Forward foreign (Accounting Standard for Foreign (IAS39)
exchange currency transactions Notes 6 and 7) When hedge accounting is applied,
contracts Foreign currency receivables and the JGAAP method described on the
payables may be translated on the left is not permitted.
basis of rates in the related forward
contract (furiate shori), as a
temporarily allowed treatment.

Financial There is no standard relating to (IAS21.42)


reporting in financial reporting in The results and financial position of
hyperinflationary hyperinflationary economies. an entity whose functional currency
economies is the currency of a hyperinflationary
economy shall be translated into a
different presentation currency using
the following procedures:
► All amounts (i.e. assets,
liabilities, equity items, revenue
and expenses, including
comparatives) shall be translated
at the closing rate at the date of
the most recent balance sheet.

59
Income Tax
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Tax effect on (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS12.15)
goodwill Standard for Tax effect accounting A deferred tax liability arising from
for consolidated financial statements the initial recognition of goodwill shall
27) not be recognised.
Deferred tax assets or deferred tax
liabilities are not recognised in (IAS12.21B)
relation to goodwill. However, in some countries the
amortisation of goodwill is allowed for
tax purposes. A deferred tax liability,
for taxable temporary differences
which arise after the initial
recognition of goodwill as a result of
the amortisation of goodwill for tax
purposes, is recognised.

(IAS12.32A)
If the carrying amount of goodwill
arising in a business combination is
less than its tax base, a deferred tax
asset shall be recognised as part of
the accounting for that business
combination, to the extent that it is
probable that taxable profit will be
available against which the deductible
temporary difference could be
utilised.

60
JGAAP IFRS
Assessment of (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS12.24,27-31)
the Standard for Tax effect accounting A deferred tax asset shall be
recoverability for separate financial statements 21, recognised for all deductible
of deferred tax Audit committee report No66,3) temporary differences to the extent
assets The recoverability of deferred tax that it is probable that taxable profit
assets relating to deductable will be available against which the
temporary differences, and any deductible temporary difference can
necessary valuation allowance, should be utilised.
be thoroughly and prudently A two step approach under which a
determined considering the following valuation allowance is recognised is
items: not adopted, rather a deferred tax
► sufficiency of taxable income asset is recognised directly for the
based on earning power; amount of recoverable deferred tax
► existence of tax planning; after considering the following items:
► sufficiency of taxable temporary ► sufficiency of taxable income
differences based on earning ability;
When judging recoverability, detailed ► existence of tax planning;
guidance, which includes numerical ► sufficiency of taxable temporary
criteria (within five years, or within a differences
year etc.), for each category of entity Certain guidance is provided for
are stipulated. judging the recoverability of deferred
tax assets (however, the categories of
(Practical Guidance on Accounting the assets or numerical criteria are
Standard for Tax effect accounting not stipulated as in JGAAP).
for consolidated financial statements
16) When considering the recoverability
The criteria in “Practical Guidance on of deferred tax assets arising from the
Accounting Standard for tax effect elimination of unrealised profits on
accounting for separate financial consolidation, a determination is
statements 21" are not applied when made based on the general principles
considering the recoverability of above (there is no exceptional rule as
deferred tax assets arising from the in JGAAP).
elimination of unrealised profits on
consolidation. Such deferred tax
assets are considered to be
recoverable.

Tax effect of (Practical Guidance on Accounting (IAS12.47)


the elimination Standard for Tax effect accounting There is no exception as in JGAAP
of unrealised for consolidated financial statements (above). Therefore, in principle,
profit 13,14) deferred tax assets and liabilities shall
The carrying amount of this type of be measured at the rate which is
deferred tax asset is measured by expected to apply to company which
multiplying the unrealised profit by holds the asset (the purchaser).
the effective tax rate, which is
calculated using the seller’s rate on its
taxable income for the year.

61
JGAAP IFRS
Recognition of (Accounting Standard for (IAS12.58,61A)
current and Presentation of Comprehensive Current and deferred tax shall be
deferred tax Income and amendment to a related recognised as income or expense and
Accounting Standard 8) included in profit or loss for the
There are no specific rules with period, except for:
regard to the presentation of current ► tax arising from a transaction or
tax and deferred tax, but they are event recorded either in other
generally considered to be included in comprehensive income or directly
profit or loss for the period (except in equity;
for as below). tax arising from a business
combination.
However, tax effects on items
recorded in other comprehensive Current tax and deferred tax that
income (i.e. unrealised gains or losses relates to items that are recognised
on securities, gains or losses on outside of the profit or loss, in the
hedges and foreign currency same or a different period, shall be
translation adjustments) are not accounted for as follows:
included in profit or loss for the period ► If related to transactions in other
but are also included in other comprehensive income, then the
comprehensive income. tax shall be recognised in other
comprehensive income.
► If related to transactions that are
recognised directly in equity, then
the tax shall be recognised
directly in equity.

Classification of (Accounting Standard for tax effect (IAS1.56)


deferred tax accounting 3,1) When an entity presents current and
assets Deferred tax assets and liabilities are non-current assets as separate
(liabilities) in classified into current or non-current classifications on the face of its
the statement items as appropriate. balance sheet, it shall not classify
of financial deferred tax assets (liabilities) as
position current assets (liabilities).
(balance sheet) Deferred tax assets (liabilities) are
classified as non-current assets
(liabilities).

Presentation in (Accounting Standard for Tax effect (IAS12.6,77,77A,80)


the statement accounting 3 3) The current tax expense (current tax
of The amounts that shall be paid as income) and deferred tax expense
comprehensive corporate tax for the period along (deferred tax income) relating to net
income (income with deferred tax expenses (or income and loss from ordinary
statement) deferred tax income) are presented activities shall be presented as a tax
on the face of the income statement expense (tax income) in the statement
separately. of comprehensive income. The major
components of that tax expense (tax
income) shall be disclosed separately
in the notes.

62
JGAAP IFRS
Offsetting (Accounting Standard for Tax effect (IAS12.74-76)
deferred tax accounting 3 2) In rare circumstances and not limited
assets and Deferred tax assets (liabilities) to the same taxable entity, if certain
liabilities classified as current assets (liabilities) conditions are met (for example, the
and non-current assets (liabilities) are entity has a legally enforceable right),
offset within each of these categories. deferred tax assets and deferred tax
liabilities of different taxable entities
(Practical Guidance on Accounting are offset.
Standard for Tax effect accounting
for consolidated financial statements *In JGAAP, deferred tax assets
42) (liabilities) are classified as current
Deferred tax assets and deferred tax assets (liabilities) and non-current
liabilities shall be offset if they relate assets (liabilities), and are offset
to the income taxes of the same within those current/non-current
taxable entity. categories. However, in IFRS, all
deferred tax assets (liabilities) are
classified as non-current assets
(liabilities) and therefore there is no
restriction of offset for current or
non-current classifications as in
JGAAP.

63
Provisions and Contingencies
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Criteria for (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS37.14)
recognition of a Explanatory Notes18) A provision shall be recognised when
provision A provision shall be recognised when all of the following conditions are met:
all of the conditions below are met: ► an entity has a present obligation
► it relates to a specific future cost (legal or constructive) as a result
or loss; of a past event;
► it arises from a past event; ► it is probable that an outflow of
► it has a high probability of resources embodying economic
occurrence; and benefits will be required to settle
► the amount can be estimated the obligation; and
reasonably. ► a reliable estimate can be made
of the amount of the obligation.

Constructive There are no specific rules. (IAS37.10)


obligations Liabilities include both legal and
constructive obligations.
A constructive obligation is an
obligation that derives from an
entity’s actions where:
(a) by an established pattern of past
practice, published policies or a
sufficiently specific current
statement, the entity has indicated to
other parties that it will accept certain
responsibilities; and
(b) as a result, the entity has created
a valid expectation on the part of
those other parties that it will
discharge those responsibilities.

Present Even if it is not a present obligation, a (IAS 37.14(a))


obligation of provision shall be recognised when it It is not acceptable to recognise
provisions satisfies the above conditions. provisions unless they represent
present obligations.

Major (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS16.14)


inspections or Explanatory Notes 18) Future costs of major inspections of
repair costs Special repair provisions are given as items of PPE, which have not yet been
an example of non-current liabilities. carried out, are not permitted to be
The amount of the provision which recognised as provisions. When the
relates to the current period is recognition criteria are fulfilled, such
recognised as a current period profit costs are recognised in the carrying
or loss. amount of the item of PPE and are
included in the depreciation charge.

64
JGAAP IFRS
Discounting the There are no specific rules. (IAS37.45-47)
provision Where the effect of the time value of
(Accounting Standard for Asset money is material, the amount of a
Retirement Obligations 6) provision shall be the present value of
An asset retirement obligation is the expenditures expected to be
calculated based on its discounted required to settle the obligation.
value. The discount rate used is the The discount rate (or rates) shall be a
risk free pre-tax interest rate which pre-tax rate (or rates) that reflect(s)
reflects the time value of money. current market assessments of the
time value of money and the risks
specific to the liability. The discount
rate(s) shall not reflect risks for which
the future cash flow estimates have
been adjusted.

Environmental (Accounting Standard for Asset (IAS37.19.21)


clean-up and Retirement Obligations 4) The general principles of IAS37 are
decommissioni Recognition of asset retirement applied to provisions for
ng costs obligations is required for legal or environmental clean-up and
equivalent obligations. decommissioning costs etc. In other
words, if a legal obligation or a
constructive obligation exists, a
provision shall be recognised.

Onerous There are no specific rules. (IAS37.10,66-69)


contracts An onerous contract is a contract in
which the unavoidable costs of
meeting the obligations under the
contract exceed the economic
benefits expected to be received
under it.
If an entity has a contract that is
onerous, the present obligation under
the contract shall be recognised and
measured as a provision.

Restructuring There are no specific rules. (IAS37.70-83)


costs These are provided for based on the A provision for a constructive
general requirements for provisions. obligation to restructure is recognised
under the general recognition criteria
of IAS37 when an entity:
a) has a detailed formal plan for the
restructuring and
b) has raised a valid expectation in
those affected that it will carry
out the restructuring by starting
to implement that plan or by
announcing its main features to
those affected by it.

65
JGAAP IFRS
Contingent There are no specific rules. (IAS37.10,89)
assets: A contingent asset is a possible asset
definition and that arises from past events and
disclosure whose existence will be confirmed
only by the occurrence or
non-occurrence of one or more
uncertain future events not wholly
within the control of the entity.
Where an inflow of economic benefits
is probable, an entity shall disclose a
brief description of the nature of the
contingent assets at the end of the
reporting period, and, where
practicable, an estimate of their
financial effect should be disclosed.

Measurement (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS37.39,40)


of a provision Explanatory Notes 18) Where the provision being measured
within a range Only a rational basis is accepted for involves a large population of items,
of expected the estimation of a provision, and so the best estimate is the expected
outcomes there is no requirement to give an value (if all possible outcomes in the
explanation of the details of the range have the same probability of
measurement method. occurrence, the mid-point can be
used).
(Accounting Standard for Asset Where a single obligation is being
Retirement Obligations 6) measured, the individual most likely
An asset retirement obligation is outcome may be the best estimate of
calculated by discounting future cash the liability.
flows, using either the most likely
outcome or the expected value
method.

66
Construction Contracts
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
When the (Accounting Standard for (IAS11.32)
outcome of a Construction Contracts 9) A method based on the recoverability
construction The contract completion method is of construction costs is applied (that
contract cannot applied. is, revenue shall be recognised only to
be measured the extent of contract costs incurred
reliably for which recovery is probable).

Resolution of (Implementation Guidance on (IAS11.35)


the uncertainty Accounting Standard for Construction From the point when the uncertainties
of the outcome Contracts 3,14) over the outcome of the construction
Changing from the use of the work are resolved, the stage of
percentage of completion method completion method is applied.
should not be made only because of
certainty derived from subsequent
events. However, this does not apply
to subsequent determinations which
should have been made at the
commencement of the contract.

67
Revenue Recognition
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Basic concept (Corporate Accounting Principles 2 (IAS18.7)
3B) Revenue is defined as the gross
Revenue related to the sale of goods inflow of economic benefits during
or rendering of services should be the period arising in the course of the
recognised in accordance with the
ordinary activities of an entity when
realisation principle.
those inflows result in increases in
equity, other than increases relating
to contributions from equity
participants.
The standard specifies requirements
for recognising revenue from the sale
of goods, the rendering of services,
and from interest, royalties and
dividends. In addition, practical
examples of applying the general
principles of IAS 18 are given in the
Appendix.
Identification of Aside from the "Practical Guidance (IAS18.13)
the transaction for Software Transactions and the It is necessary to apply the revenue
Standard on Accounting for recognition criteria to the separately
Construction Contracts", there are identifiable components of a single
no general rules regarding the transaction in order to reflect the
identification of transactions, or substance of that transaction.
whether those transactions require On the other hand, more than one
separation or combination. transition should be treated as a
single transaction when the
commercial effect cannot be
understood otherwise.

Presentation of Aside from the "Practical Guidance (IAS18.8, Appendix21)


revenue for Software Transactions", there are Amounts collected as an agent on
no general rules regarding the behalf of a principal, which do not
presentation of revenue. bring economic benefits to the entity,
do not result in increases in equity
and therefore only commission
income is recognised.

Contracts with (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS18.11,IE8)


deferred Note 6) Revenue is measured at the fair value
payment terms Even if the difference between the of the consideration received.
(e.g. instalment fair value and the nominal amount of For transactions with a financial
sales contracts) consideration is, in substance, element, like instalment sales
interest income, the interest element contracts, consideration is
does not have to be accounted for determined using an imputed rate of
separately. interest and the interest element is
In addition to the normal sales separately recognised.
method, accepted methods of The due date method and recognition
accounting for such sales are the due on a cash basis are not allowed.
date method and the cash basis.

68
JGAAP IFRS
Sales Incentives (Regulation for Terminology, Forms (IAS 18.9,10)
and Preparation of Financial The amount of revenue is measured
Statements 93) at the fair value of the consideration
A cash discount on sales is expensed received or receivable taking into
as non-operating expenses. account the amount of any trade
A sales incentive is either deducted discounts and volume rebates
from sales or recorded as selling and allowed by the entity.
administrative expenses for practical
purposes.

Sales of goods (Corporate Accounting Principles (IAS18.14)


2,3B,Note 6) Revenue from the sale of goods shall
There is no specific definition of be recognised only if:
realisation nor are there standard ► the entity has transferred to the
requirements for revenue buyer the significant risks and
recognition. In general, realisation
rewards of ownership of the
refers to economic transactions
conducted with third parties, in other goods;
words when the goods or services are ► the buyer of the goods controls
converted to a form of monetary those goods;
asset. The realisation principle is ► the amount of revenue can be
applied as guidance for the measured reliably;
recognition of sales. However, in ► it is probable that there will be an
practice, a delivery basis and a inflow of economic benefits to
shipping basis for revenue the entity; and
recognition are also applied, and so ► the costs incurred can be
the timing of recognition depends on
measured reliably.
established commercial practice.

Rendering of There are no specific rules. (IAS18.20)


services When the following conditions are
met:
► the amount of revenue and costs
can be measured reliably,
► it is probable that the economic
benefits associated with the
transaction will flow to the entity
► the stage of completion of the
transaction can be measured
reliably,
Then the revenue associated with the
transaction shall be recognised by
reference to the stage of completion
of the transaction.

Rendering of There are no specific rules. (IAS18.26)


services: where Revenue shall be recognised only to
the outcome the extent of the expenses
cannot be recognised that are recoverable.
reliably
measured

69
JGAAP IFRS
Dividends (Accounting Standard for Financial (IAS 18.30 (c) )
received Instruments and related Dividends shall be recognised when
Implementation Guidance and the shareholder's right to receive
Practical Solution 94) payment is established.
In terms of marketable securities,
dividends are recognised based on
the expected declared amount per
share on the ex-dividend date, for
each class of security.
For non-marketable securities,
dividends are recognised on the date
when the declaration of dividends is
approved by a shareholder's meeting
or another authorised board meeting.
However, dividends are allowed to be
recognised on the date received
provided that the recording entity
uses the same accounting method
consistently for all securities.

Separate There are no clear rules. (IFRIC13.3, 5-7)


identification of In practice it seems that in many When customer loyalty credits are
transactions cases the full amount of revenue is awarded at time a sale is made, the
(customer recorded at the time of sale and a fair value of consideration is divided
loyalty provision for the expected cost of with reference to the relative fair
programmes) fulfilling the customer loyalty values of the goods sold and the
obligation is recorded. credits awarded. The portion of
revenue for the goods sold is
recognised at the time of the sale and
the portion of revenue in respect of
the credits awarded is recognised
when the points are utilised.

70
Share-Based Payments
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
In scope (Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.53,54,58)
transactions and Share-based Payment 17) For equity settled share-based
effective date The guidance in this standard is to be payments, IFRS2 shall be applied to
applied to stock options, options such grants of shares, share options or
as rights relating to the company’s other equity instruments that were
stock and payments made through granted after 7 November 2002 and
stock transfers from the date of the had not yet vested as at the effective
implementation of the Companies Act date of IFRS2. The entity is
(1 May 2006). encouraged, but not required, to
apply IFRS2 to other grants of equity
instruments if the entity has
disclosed publicly the fair value of
those equity instruments,
determined at the measurement
date.

Classes of (Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.2)


share-based Share-based Payment 28) IFRS2 is applied to equity-settled and
payment Applies to stock options and cash-settled share-based payment
transactions situations where consideration for transactions, and transactions which
goods or services is given through provide a choice of cash or equity
equity-settled share-based payments. settlement.

Equity-settled (Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.11-13)


share based Share-based Payment 6,14,15) ► Transactions with employees:
payments – ► Transactions with employees: grant date
measurement Stock options granted as
date consideration for goods or ► Transactions with parties other
services: grant date than employees: date goods are
obtained or services rendered
► Transactions with parties other
than employees:
Stock options granted as
consideration for goods or
services: contract date
Stock delivered as consideration
for goods or services: contract
date

71
JGAAP IFRS
Equity settled (Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.10-13)
share based Share-based Payment 6,14,15) ► Transactions with employees:
payments – ► Transactions with employees: measure at the fair value of the
measurement Stock options at grant date: equity instruments granted
method measure using a widely accepted
measurement technique that ► Transactions with parties other
gives a reasonable estimated than employees: measure at the
value. fair value of the goods or
services received. Only where
► Transactions with parties other
the fair value of the goods or
than employees: calculate using
services received cannot be
whichever of the two methods
estimated reliably, measure at
below gives the most reliable
the fair value of the equity
valuation:
instruments granted.
► fair value of the stock option (or
stock) used as consideration;
► fair value of the goods or
services received.
(whichever gives the most
reliable valuation is judged
based on The Application
Guidance 23)

(Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.24)


If the fair value
Share-based Payment 13) In rare cases, if the fair value of the
of the equity
There are no specific rules. equity instruments cannot be
instruments
However, for unlisted companies, it is estimated reliably at the
granted cannot
possible to account for stock options measurement date, the equity
be estimated
based on the estimated intrinsic instruments are measured at their
reliably
value per option, as a substitute for intrinsic value. This is measured
fair value. In this case, the intrinsic initially at the date the entity obtains
value per option at the grant date is the goods or the counterparty
estimated, and is not revised later. renders service, and subsequently at
each reporting date and at the date
of final settlement, with any change
in intrinsic value recognised in profit
or loss.
The goods or services received are
recognised based on the number of
equity instruments that ultimately
vest or (where applicable) are
exercised.

Equity There are no specific rules. (IFRS2.22)


instruments with For options with a reload feature, the
reload feature reload feature shall not be taken into
account when estimating the fair
value of options granted at the
measurement date. Instead, a reload
option shall be accounted for as a
new option grant, if and when a
reload option is subsequently
granted.

72
JGAAP IFRS
Treatment after (Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.23)
vesting date Share-based Payment 8) The entity shall make no subsequent
If an option is exercised and new adjustment to total equity after
stock is issued, the portion of the vesting date. However, this
amount recorded as share warrants requirement does not preclude the
that relates to the exercise of the entity from recognising a transfer
option is transferred to paid-in within equity, i.e. a transfer from one
capital. component of equity to another.

Cancellation or There are no specific rules. (IFRS2.28)


settlement of ► Account for the cancellation or
grant settlement as an acceleration of
vesting;
► Any payment made on the
cancellation or settlement of the
grant shall be accounted for as
the repurchase of an equity
interest. However, to the extent
that the payment exceeds the fair
value of the equity instruments
(measured at the repurchase
date), the recording entity shall
recognise an expense for that
excess.

Lapse due to non (Accounting Standard for (IFRS2.23)


exercise of Share-based Payment 9) No adjustment is made to the existing
options When options lapse because they are equity balance. However, an entity
not exercised, the portion of the is not precluded from recognising a
amount recorded as share warrants transfer within equity.
(or options) that relates to those
options is transferred as a gain in the
profit and loss account.

73
Employee Benefits, excluding
Share-Based Payments
► Significant differences
JGAAP IFRS
Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (IAS19.64,67)
Pension Plans – Benefits 2, 2 (Revised standard IAS 19.67,70)
Benefit Practical Guidance on Accounting for In principle, the Projected Unit Credit
Obligations Retirement Benefits 2) Method (accrued benefit valuation
In principle, the value of accrued method) shall be used. However, the
benefit obligations is calculated using straight-line method is required if
the straight line method. Other employee service in later years leads
methods such as a payroll basis, a to a materially higher level of benefit
percentage of salary method and a than in earlier years.
points basis may be used by way of
exception.

Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (IAS19.58)


Pension Plans – Benefits Note 1) Where there is a surplus of pension
Plan Assets When pension plan assets exceed plan assets over obligations, an asset
retirement benefit obligations, the is recognised up to the limit of the
difference is recognised as a prepaid total of:
pension expense. a) any unrecognised net actuarial
losses and past service costs; and
b) the present value of any
economic benefits available as
refunds from the plan or
reductions in future contributions
to the plan (the asset ceiling).

(Revised standard IAS19.64)


When an entity has a surplus in a
defined benefit plan, it shall measure
the net defined benefit asset at the
lower of the surplus in the defined
benefit plan and the asset ceiling

74
JGAAP IFRS
Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (IAS19.78)
Pension Plans - Benefits partial revision (3) 2, Notes (Revised standard IAS 19.83)
Discount rate to the same standard 6) The following procedure is followed.
There is no hierarchy with which to
consider the discount rate. The rate used to discount
The discount rate is determined post-employment benefit obligations
based on the interest rates of highly (both funded and unfunded) shall be
stable long term bonds. This is the determined by reference to market
interest rate at period end available yields at the end of the reporting
on long term government, period on high quality corporate
governmental institution and high bonds in a currency and with a
quality corporate bonds. maturity consistent to the benefit
obligations. In countries where there
is no deep market in such bonds, the
market yields (at the end of the
reporting period) on government
bonds shall be used.

Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (Revised standard IAS 19.123)
Pension Plans – Benefits 3. 2(3)) The net interest on the net defined
Expected Return The expected return on plan assets is benefit liability (asset) shall be
Rate calculated per individual pension plan determined by multiplying the net
asset at the beginning of the period defined benefit liability (asset) by the
using a reasonable expected return discount rate stated above.
rate.

Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (IAS19.96)


Pension Plans – Benefits 3,2) In cases where benefits have already
Past Service In principle, past service costs are vested, an entity shall recognise the
Cost recognised as expenses, and are related past service cost immediately.
amortised over a fixed period (within In cases where vesting is not
the period of the remaining average immediate, an entity shall recognise
service lives). the related past service cost as an
The amortisation periods for past expense on a straight-line basis over
service costs and for actuarial gains the average period until the benefits
and losses may be determined become vested.
separately.
For actuarial gains and losses, (Revised standard IAS 19. 103)
amortisation may commence from An entity shall recognise past service
the period following the period in cost as an expense at the earlier of
which they arose, however this is not the following dates:
allowed for past service costs. a) when the plan amendment or
curtailment occurs; and
(Accounting Standard for Retirement b) when the entity recognises
Benefits Note 11) related restructuring costs
Past service costs relating to retired termination benefits.
employees can be distinguished from
other past service costs and can be
expensed in full when they arise.

75
JGAAP IFRS
Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (IAS19.92,93A,93B,93D)
Pension Plans – Benefits 3, 2) It is possible to chose any of the
Actuarial Gains (Accounting Standard for Retirement follow accounting policies:
and Losses Benefits Note 9) ► The corridor method: actuarial
In principle, actuarial gains and losses differences within a certain
are recognised as expenses and “corridor” are not recognised.
amortised over a fixed period (within ► However an entity may recognise
the period of the remaining average these differences in profit and
service lives). loss faster than over the
As per the above, the amortisation expected average remaining
periods for past service costs and for working lives of the employees,
actuarial gains and losses may be provided that it consistently uses
determined separately. a systematic method.
For actuarial gains and losses, ► An entity which selects an
amortisation may commence from accounting policy to recognise
the period following the period in the actuarial differences in the
which they arose. period in which they occur, may
recognise the differences outside
the profit and loss account, in
other comprehensive income.

(Revised standard IAS 19.8, 57,63)


An entity shall recognise the net
defined benefit liability (asset) in the
statement of financial position.
Remeasurements of the net defined
liability (asset) are to be recognised in
other comprehensive income,
including actuarial gains and losses.
(Actuarial gains and losses must not
be recognised as profit or loss in
subsequent years)

Defined Benefit (Accounting Standard for Retirement (Revised standard IAS 19.120)
Pension Plans – Benefit 3,1) An entity shall recognise the
Expense Current service cost and interest cost components of defined benefit cost,
are expensed as the components of except to the extent that another
defined benefit cost and if the IFRS requires or permits their
pension plan is funded, the current inclusion in the cost of an asset, as
expected return on the plan assets follows:
shall be deducted. a) service cost in profit or loss;
b) net interest on the net defined
benefit liability (asset) in profit or
loss; and
c) remeasurements of the net
defined benefit liability (asset) in
other comprehensive income

76
JGAAP IFRS
Minimum There are no specific rules. (IFRIC14.18-26)
funding In some cases, to protect employees,
requirement a minimum level of funding is
required by the plan or the law.
Such funding requirements are called
minimum funding requirements. If the
minimum funding requirement is
larger than the actual plan assets, the
deficiency should be recognised as an
additional liability.

Defined benefit (Implementation Guidance on There is no short-cut method.


pension- Financial Instruments 34)
convenient Small sized entities are permitted to
method account for retirement benefit
obligations using the convenient
method or the short-cut method.

Retirement There are no specific rules. (IAS19.1,3,6)


benefits other (Revised standard IAS19,2,4,7)
than pensions With the exception of those benefits
covered by IFRS2 (Share Based
Payment), all employee retirement
benefits other than pensions are also
within the scope of IAS19.
Note: the post-employment benefits
of directors are also included.

Paid vacation There are no specific rules. (IAS19.11-16)


accrual Provisions for accumulating
compensated absences must be
recognised.

77
Appendix 1 - The Adoption of IFRS in
Japan
Since 2001, there has been a tremendous increase in the adoption of IFRS around the world. The
precise way in which this has happened has varied among jurisdictions. This appendix
summarises how Japan is approaching the adoption of IFRS.

In 2007, an agreement between the Accounting Standards Board of Japan (ASBJ), and the IASB,
known as ‘The Tokyo Agreement’, was announced. The Tokyo Agreement advanced the gradual
convergence of Japanese GAAP and IFRS, which had been taking place for a number of years.
Following the initial convergence projects under this agreement, in 2008 the European
Commission accepted Japanese GAAP in its markets as part of its process to accept certain
GAAP as equivalent to IFRS for listing non-EU companies in a European ‘regulated market’ (as
defined by the European Commission). Further convergence of Japanese GAAP has continued as
new standards are issued or expected to be issued. Since adoption of IFRS is being considered
for consolidated financial statements only, this convergence process is expected to continue as
Japanese GAAP is used by Japanese companies in their standalone financial statements.

In June 2009, the Business Advisory Council (BAC) a key advisory body to the Financial Services
Agency approved a roadmap for the adoption of IFRS in Japan and the relevant related matters
have subsequently been incorporated into the regulation for consolidated financial statements.
The key points of this roadmap are:

► Option of voluntary adoption of IFRS from fiscal years ended after 31 March 2010 for
companies with global financial or operating activities; and
► Decision on the mandatory adoption of IFRS to be made in 2012.

In June 2011, the BAC announced that if mandatory application of IFRS were to be decided, a
period of five to seven years would be given for preparing for adoption. This is a longer period than
proposed in the June 2009 roadmap. A number of Japanese companies have already taken, or are
planning to take, the option to apply IFRS voluntarily.

78
Appendix 2 - IFRS Related Resources
Please use our knowledge fully.
Ernst & Young Online
Ernst & Young Shinnihon LLC website
Ernst & Young’s information site for clients, that gathers
the latest news from around the world, provides
We offer a variety of online resources that provide more
detail about IFRS as well as things to consider as you web-based learning, model financial statements a
research the potential impact of IFRS on your company. variety of other knowledge.

http://www.shinnihon.or.jp/services/ifrs/index.html http://www.ey.com/IFRS

A variety of Japanese language tools and publications: IFRS Web-based learning – includes a number of
web-based modules that address the basic
► IFRS Outlook and Supplements to IFRS
accounting concepts and knowledge of IFRS.
Outlook- These include a variety of
publications focused on specific standards and
Global Accounting & Auditing Information Tool
industries. (English versions in GAAIT)
(GAAIT)
► Jouhou sensor – our magazine combining
English only. Subscription fee based.
accounting and tax information. In this
A multinational GAAP research tool that allows
magazine the IFRS section ‘IFRS jitsumu kouza’
continuous access to important International GAAP®
includes articles by EYSN’s IFRS professionals
information:
on the interpretation of IFRS for specific topics
and in a practical way. ► Example option
International GAAP® online- includes Ernst &
International GAAP® Young’s International GAAP® book, illustrative
This comprehensive book from Ernst & Young is updated financial statements and disclosure checklists, all
annually and provides practical guidance for of the official IASB standards, exposure drafts and
understanding and interpreting IFRS on a globally discussion papers, and full sets of IFRS reporting
consistent basis. entities’ annual reports and accounts.

International GAAP® - Japanese language


Japanese language version of the above.

Please send enquiries about our IFRS services to:


A Complete Comparison: Japanese GAAP and IFRS
- Japanese language only Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC
Detailed explanation by topic with many examples of the Hibiya Kokusai Bldg.
differences between the fundamental concepts of 2-2-3 Uchisaiwaicho, Chiyoda-ku
Japanese accounting standards and IFRS, the resulting Tokyo, Japan 100-0011
differences in accounting treatments, and related practical Tel: 03 3503 3508 (IFRS Department)
points. This book also includes differences in presentation Email: IFRS@shinnihon.or.jp
and disclosure rules.

79
Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC

About Ernst & Young


Ernst & Young is a global leader in assurance,
tax, transaction and advisory services.
Worldwide, our 152,000 people are united
by our shared values and an unwavering
commitment to quality. We make a difference
by helping our people, our clients and
our wider communities achieve their potential.

Ernst & Young refers to the global organization


of member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited,
each of which is a separate legal entity.
Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company
limited by guarantee, does not provide services
to clients. For more information about our
organization, please visit www.ey.com

About Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC


Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC is a member firm of
Ernst & Young. We are the leading audit firm in
Japan, with the largest number of people, and with
offices throughout the country. We are committed
to providing the highest quality audit and
assurance services, and to offering a range of
other financial advisory services. Together with
the Ernst & Young global network, we strive to
ensure trust in our capital markets and improve
their functioning to achieve the potential of the
global economy and our wider communities, which
surround Japan.For more information, please visit
www.shinnihon.or.jp

© 2011 Ernst & Young ShinNihon LLC


All Rights Reserved.

This publication and the materials referred to therein


contain edited information in summary form and are,
therefore, intended for general reference purposes only.
They should not be used for specific purposes, or as a
substitute for detailed research or the exercise of
professional judgment. Neither Ernst & Young
ShinNihon LLC nor any other member of the global Ernst
& Young organization can take responsibility for the
accuracy, completeness, applicability for purpose or any
other aspect of the contents and nor shall they bear any
responsibility whatsoever for loss occasioned to any
person acting or refraining from action as a result of any
material in this publication or the materials referred to
therein.

You might also like