Exchange for aid: World tells Pakistan to

shape up
BRUSSELS: World powers told Pakistan that post-flood aid was part of a "two-way" deal on reform
Friday, as Islamabad also offered to lend a hand to regional peace by facilitating Afghan-Taliban talks.
After US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton demanded Pakistan's "affluent and elite" be made to pay
through tax changes, ministers attending a major aid meeting on Pakistan also insisted there would be
no gain without some pain. For Pakistan to "become more stable," German Foreign Minister Guido
Westerwelle said, "you can harvest as much money as you want, it won't be enough at the end of the
day if there is no reform." "An adjustment in the equilibrium between rich and poor in Pakistan" was
fundamental, he said.
The meeting of the Friends of Democratic Pakistan came as the World Bank and Asian Development
Bank estimated damages for Pakistan's devastating floods since July at 9.7 billion dollars - almost twice
the amount of its 2005 earthquake. British Foreign Secretary William Hague, who said London had
already ploughed some 134 million pounds (215 million dollars) of aid into its former colonial territory,
also underlined that "there are necessary reforms in Pakistan and they should include a widening of the
tax base."
But he said Pakistan Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi had "stressed in the meeting that the
government of Pakistan is fully cognisant of what they need to do." Stepping into the Brussels talks,
gathering 26 countries and international groups, Qureshi said "there are more reforms in the pipeline."
He also offered Islamabad's services for "reconciliation" in Afghanistan, saying a peaceful neighbour was
in his country's interests. Reconciliation was "an Afghan initiative," he said. "They have to own it, they
have to lead it. We are there to help, we are there to facilitate." An EU source had warned before the
talks concluded that backers were "not signing any blank cheques." "It's a two-way street," the source
added, indicating EU foreign affairs chief Catherine Ashton's view that "unprecedented support cannot
be expected without profound changes" in the way Pakistan runs its economy.
"We must make sure where the money goes," said one diplomat. "We expect clear commitments." The
floods affected 21 million people - with 12 million in need of emergency help by UN estimates. To date
the United States and the EU have provided around 450 million dollars each in aid to Pakistan. Europe
has also offered a major trade boost, proposing to lift duties on 75 imports as part of an aid-linked
package. But the three-year suspension of duties still requires a waiver from the World Trade
Organisation.
And Italy's Foreign Minister Franco Frattini warned that his country retains reservations, hinting that
Rome's backing would be conditional on India failing to obtain similar concessions in the WTO. "Under
certain limitations we can go ahead," Frattini said. "I am ready but on condition." Qureshi on Thursday
told the European parliament that Islamabad's fledgling democracy was on the march after ending a
decade of military rule in 2008. "Obviously it takes time. Old habits die hard," he said. "You have to be
patient."