Huna AnekcaHoposHa Cudoposa HAPOAHbIE EPETMVYECKME ABUYKEHMA Bo ®PAHLIMM B XII—XIII Bekax @panuy3cknn erkerogHnk 1961 M.: Hayka. 1962. C.429-433 Be6-ny6nnkauna: Vive Liberta, 2011 CcbiikKi Ha MaTepManbi K Teme AaHbI HAMM Noce CTaTbU a MOCHELHMe TOAbI HOUATHE KcpeyHeBeKOBAA epechy upeTepmenaer onpenencHnyio Moyuwpuxan, OO oroM sCHO CBUAeTeENBCTBYeT O- kay, Meropuka HepKonnoro Mpava FX. Te Bpaca (Dpamsens) «Mpo- Gaema uncTHTyTOS cpeyHeBeKoLOrO XpucTUANcTBay, uperCTanreMnetik uM Ha XI Mesxpynapogustit Kourpece ucropmKoR, cocrosBumitca B CrokroabMe B anrycre 1960 p. O6mei Tengein@el compemenxoii Koudbeccnonassno Hacrpoeu- Holl sanaguoi ucropuorpadun ABneTCH CTpeMaeHMe BeATECKH crxagHTh Upo- THBOPCIMA, KOTOPbIe CYMecTBORAIU B CPCAHMe BeEKA MOAAY WepKOBLO U BCOMH UHAKOMMICLINAM, 1 OOBACHUTH PH TPoTHBOPeMUT pAylOM eslyUaiABEX OGcTON- reabers (pasminmuem B-THMAX yMa, CKBEPHLIM XapakTepom Toro HoT WHOTO aH Wa, CTO OCOOHIM UCHXIUCCKIM CKIAOM, UZTHUTHEI TOPAYHOCTHWO MmpeycTaBuTe- neit oprosoKent 17. J.) . Cuegya otoii reugentmu, JIe Bpac yrsepaqaer, 1ro uceneqORAaNMA ocse,- HHX eT «OOHOBMINY TOMUMAaHne CpeyqHeBeKOBEIX epeceli, 60 TO, YTO HCTOpHKR JepKBU paccMATPURATN palee Kak «MATERNY M «CeKTHY, HOCHBIMHE aHTUTEp- KOBEBUI Xapanrep, WANE CHMTaeTes! XOTH H OCODLIME TeNeMMAMM, HO TeNeHMsMN B Mpegesax PUMCKO-KaTOMTMecKolt HepKBU, KOTOPolt «OHM HoAparasn m9 hop- Me, ompegzeceHuam u AucHMMInHe». B yoxuage Jie Bpaca epecu sierynawr Kak sMICIMHe, TOROpAMee oO BapomAeRUM noBitX MpercTanrenwit Geonexa Oo HOTYCTOPOHHEM MMpe, ¢ KOTOPHIMIT WepKOBb He Beerfa XoTera MMpHTECsT. Dra TouKka apeHUA KaKeTcA HAM coRepmeHHo HeyOemuTENBHOl mM Hero He OSEACHAONIeH, TAK AL KAK M TOUKA SpeHI TeX 8AlagNBX HCTOPUKOR, KOTOpLE uByIAWT cpeAHEBEKORME epec ¢ MosMpi sHCTO MyeatucruYeCKOi cXewE uma ugeit. Yrsepayas, wro oOPACHeHMe JaHHoro UAeoOTHUeCKOrO sBIe- Hs ChoyNTes K TOMY, TTOGH HaiiTH ero UCTOKM B APYTOM useosorIMEcKOM 3Ke ABNCHINI, DTH METOPUKM YHessHOT OCHOBHOe RUMMAIHe MOMCKAM HeKOed «mpa- epecu» (wanpraep, Manmxeiickoil) a rex nyreii, KoTOpsIMT ona mponmKama c Bocroxa ra Saray m oKaastnasia BanAAHe Ha epeTHTecKHe yuerins » Enpore. IIpn prom ncropmn aderparmpytorest of Toi coumarnnolt qelierBITremBMacTH, KOTOpad MOpoAada KOHKpeTHbIe epech B AanHoit crpaHe HB AauiI0c BpeMa, H conepmrento o6xogAT BoMpoc 0 TOM, KARIM MCI oSpasom m TOveMy yYAMIcrHMecKoo, 7. €. RORCe HE XpuCTMANCKOO, MaNMuKelicKoe Yuee corso * Jlonxay, npowtrarnnii ma sacesamnm cone puxon 8 Mocktne 2 oxraps 1961 r. o-PpaunyacKoll Koubepesuan weronaiirn nouny Ha Banayze » XL[—XIII x. 9 Ooo neromns0Rano hpaunyacnt- MH epeTukamy B Ux SopBbe c KaTOMMHeCKON HepKOBHIO. O6nAcHeHHe aTOMY sBACHITIO jaloT CoBeTCKMe NeTOpHKH, KOTOpEIe o6po- MWaloT BHUMaHHe He TONBKO ua SorocaoBckyw OGoAOUKYy epeceii, HO MW Ha Wx CoNMatbHoe cofepanHe u paccMaTPHBaIOT epech Kak OWN M3 APKUX MposB- renuit anrnpeogannol u auruyepKosHoit onmosnnMM Co CTOPOHBI yrHETeHHDIN cnocn deotaspnoro o6mectBa, [pu stom coBnerckHe meTOpHKU HexOAT Ns CHEAYIOMUX UpUAWHAbAHIX UOLOMeHMi, B onoxy eopamama uwepKowr ABIATACh HanOoree oOOMUM cuuTes0M mM Han6olec oOmfeH canKuMeit cymject- Bylomero deoxanHoro crpos. Tloaromy wee Burpaxkermie » oomeii dopre HavagKM wa eoxaansm W WEPROBL, T. e. BCe COMMAIBUBIE W MOMUTHECKUE PenoAONMONABIE yuenn, HeMaderRIO UpuuuvamM B oTy 9TOxy opmy Goro- cHOBCKHX epeceit. [laa To10 “roGst Crasto BO3MO*KHO HaNajarb Ha CymecTBy- Tome OOMECTREHUEIC OTHOMeHHA, ¢ HUX HY+K0 ObLIO COpBaT Opeost cBsITOCII. Pesomionionnand onmo3snunA (eotatu3My Co CTOPONbI KpecTbAHCTBA HM TOpoyKan BbIPAAATACh B PABIMINbIX (POpMax, BRICTYIAA TO B BAe MUCTHKA, TO B BATE orKkppiToii epecit, To BIA BOOpy7KeIIOTO BoccTaIMUs. OcrannM 8 cTopone Tepsoc HM WocuexNee HM OpaTHMcA K pacewoTpenwo epecn. HanGomnuntit murepec, ¢ amet TowkH spenuA, npescTaRasaT te epert- MOCK RBBICTYIMeHAM, KOTOPHe NocHAM Macconsiii, Hapomustit xapakrep 1 KenocpesCTBeHHO OTparanu UNTepeckI m NpeOoRaHMA TpyAMMUXcA Mace dco gatbuoro o6mectha. DrH ABWKeKUA MHTepecHBI He TOADKO cRoeit macco- BOCTBIO, HO H TeM, 4TO OHM Gp Hanbonec paguKaspnpr. Oxnako Haq BUMETIT, ITO HByVeHMe WapomHHIX epeTHYecKUX ABIKeHUIt HMceT oCoOEIE Tpyqnoctn. 7lo Hae gon counenns o6pazoRaNHBtx epernkKoB-ofWHOYeR M Orpomiroe KOTHYECTBO BCCBOSMOAMHBIX KATOMMICCKUX HCTOYHMKOR, COBPEMeHHBIX epecsi (TpakrTaTpI, OMpoReprainyte epeTH4eCKMo YYOHUA, MocTAHOBLeHMA WepKOBIEA\ cobopos; Xpomnn; arncToxapubtit Marepwas Ww, Haxowen, Matepmacts moKBN- anim). JO wac He LOULIN AOKYMeNTEL, KoTOpHE Gur UexosHAN aeMocpe”cT- BeHHO OT MpeycraBnteneit Hapogtbrx Macc. HM oro OOBACHAETEH He TOIbKO TEM, ‘To YuaCTHHKN HapORMHIX epeTHuECKNX jUAOKeHM B HOAaBOMeM osm eTBo OULIM JOM MeoSpasonanune, KO ¥ TEM, YTO TepKoBR CTapaTesHo YHMATORATA MoTO6HOre powa pykorucn, Cyf{HTh O MaCCOBLIX epeTITecKUX jamKennsx so Mpampm XIT—XII ae. mpuxognter roaKo wa ocHoBaHnt BBICKAasbIBalHit HX Bparos —caymUTCTei KaTOMMMecKOi NepKB, SosBmeiica STUX AbIDKeHMIE I sKeCTOKO ¢ HMM pacupasunemelicn. Jump B penkux caysa AX TePKOBABe HCTOUHUKM aloT Gomee Man MeHee OObeKTHBHOe MaTOReNHe epetuteckux yuennii m creserm# 06 Ux MocHeqoBarerax. B OonnmunctBe ae CHYYAaeR OTT Meow coxepAAT BeeROsMONDIHIe M MeRepoATAHI OOBIMTETNs To aypecy epeTMkoB, rogpobwoe onpowepatenne UX BSTIAAOR CG TepKOBION TOUKH BPOUMA 1 CTONS 7Ke TOApoOHOe oNNCAaANe MponaBeeHHOil Hay epeTuKaMIt pacrpaset. Meusime scero ronopat KaToaieckme ucTOMMMKA 0 commarbHoli UpMHAMIeKHOCTH epeTUKoR, KoTOpad MOUTH We IpUDTeKaTA RIMMANIA cpesHe- BeKonnlx apropos. Padora c oTHMM MCTOYHUKAMM TpedyeT WCKMOVUTeTBHOIL TuATeBHOCTH. Hayasto XII B. Osi0 oTMeveHO BosHMKHOBeHUeM Macconoro eperHuecKorn suurxermt na TOre Pparnmn, rae xelicrBonarn Herp xe Bpton 1 ero mocste0- narein LempHux, YUNBUME CBOUX UpMBepaONNEs (raaBNEIM OOpasow us MNeEAA peMecxeMMIKOA-TKaveH) He BepTh B TepRowmne TauneTma, we uoceMaAry KAPOTMMECKHX XpaMOR H WOBCEMCCTHO AOU M YUNITOAATS KpecrBT KAK CIM- RO HOsopa u TITOK, AnruepKOBHOe ABIDKeHMe Ha CeBepe B aTO 2Ke BPEMT posramict Tan\ensM DOnautperuit, worps0nanmmiica Goapmoit Tonyasip HocThO Y peMecsextoro Hacexenun Daanypim mn oTKpsITO BoreTyMaBumtit ¢ NpouonorMo, oThepraumeli MepKOBD, eo TanHCTRA H ee Hepapxmo. B 1113 x.epoTmueckoe YBKeHAC pacupocrpanaxoch B oOracT Gyaccona, a B cepexnne XILB. soanmksa gyaaucTuyeckaa epecb Jona Creamer gs Bperann. Bo sropoit rorosune XI. Hapopios operuueckoe ABHAKeHMe He UpeKpa- muxoce. B 1157 r. nepxonssrit co6op 8 Pelco oeyqus nyaauctuyecnyio epecr Spomnwix TKate!, OXBaTHBUTyIO BeIO peiimcnyio Mpopmmmmo. B 60-x roxax XII b, craxo nanectHo, ITO TaKOTO 2Ke Pofa epecio sapaxKeno SoraToe KyTe- veerso Ouarapuse Me peMecseunple WexH Tkavei uw cyKoNMMMKOR HémpneKoit o6aactu. B ato we BpemMa BO3HUKAM epecs B BypryHAuu (ue pysiazapmast Tit HepKOBHEIX TANNCTR, HM RATOMTVECKOI MepapxsiM, HH AecATHND) mM Epecs Hepiro, noesegonarea KoTOpoli cuMTaIN, YTO OOMKTO He jOrREM MATTE. asaqerho. B 1165 rf. eperMnn BKICTYMICH ¢ OTNpBITEIMN wastomenmeM chow partuyom Ha wepkoruom co6ope B JomGepe, az 4467 r. coanaan cnoii epern- yecnsit co6op » Cex-Demnce. B 1170 r. B JIrone w % obnactu Pownt 1 Amit wayan CROW MpoMOBED Gexocrn Terp Baayyo. nosomumuntit navan0 jmMKeC- Hito WMONCKHX GeANAKOR, WH BamBZeNcos. MU, waKonen, ¢ wavana XUIL 3. camoe wiupoxoe pacupocrpaneuue Ha TOre Dpanumn HostywHIa epeck KaTapos. Karapast 1 baxrnyenerso, AOCTHTINME B DTO BPeMsr MaKcMMaANDNOI eNIKI, BIN TaN B Ce6s BCe ANTHLEPKOBUBIe TeYeHUA, CyNeCTROBABLINE AO TOTO BpeMeH 3 lOmnoi Pparmme. Xapanrepways o6mecrsextoe cogeprarne Beex arAx epeceii (xesaB¥eHMo or ux GorocaozcKoli hopMel), weoGxoM M0 MpusNATS, YTO OH WocHAM mpe- UMY[ecTBeHHO TOpomCKoi xapanrep. HanGouee akTwBHoe yuacTue B MUX MPAAIMASO TOPOACKGe HaceteHHe, PeMecteHNAKH M KYINEL, pie HMer tO nepawre (perme BCeTO TRAM) ABILUINGH TAARAON RUA MEH Cusoli HapoANDLX epeceli. Mexogs 13 cnoux untepecos (crpemaemie a cexyuspusasyun mepKos- HBIX 3eMeTb B YCAOBUAX POCTA TOPOAOB if TORAPHO-TeHeARHEIX OTHOMEHIM), RK eperiteckomy amokermo wa TOre Pparignt upinrorasn repemKo m-pEApT, M fake Kpynabre eomaant (TaaBuAM oGpasom 13-38 wAeAAaHUA COXPAHUTh CROW nomntnyecky%o camoctontebuocts). Ho sce ari mpepcrasirean rocrogcrBy- WHEL KHACCA GEM HecTOIKIAMN NomyrunKamM eperHeenoro —jMWKeIMN, TOTOBLIMM ITPEATh CTO IPH MepBOM Ke YKOOHOM eydae, ecaMt 9TO IIpeABeNTAAO UM Vary1o BEIrOTy. JIpowmymecrseno ropoxexoli xapanrep epermvecknx aBweennii XI1— XUC on. so Opammun wopaxkaarcn 1 B TOM, “TO OM GHIA TecHO cBABANBT € KOMMYIUIGABOT OCROOOMMTEIHISIE ABIGKERMEN ropogos, Bopnéa ropoman ¢ UX NEpKOBREMN CeHHOpAMN ecrecrREHNO coTeTarach ¢ GopEOoit roporman npo THB LYNOBNOrS aBTOpuTeTA WepPKRH. Camas Tecnad cpagb cyimecTRonaNa MexKAY epeTIMecKHMM jBWAKeHUEAT B ropoplax sc auTHdeogasbuoit GopROoit Kpectauerea, Buepammue Kpenoctute, 6enannmo » ropona, HenaGerno unocnm tyRA anTndeogaxUBIe HacTpoenus, UpUcyUpLe KpectTasMICKIM MaccaM, H OKASHIBAN TEM caMBIM wOryuCe BOBzTCII orpite Ha pasMax U OCTPOTY aNTUPeoMaLUBIX BCTYNAeHMIL ropoman. Co cuo- eit CTOPONs TopopCKHe epect, MpOHNKaT B Hepenmo, oKasMBarH Goabutve RIMM Na KpecrssM BUX aHrueorassuoit GopbSe W RaBarw wWeosrormaeexe opyxue B nx pyxn. ocrato4o RenOMUNTS Boccranne «nactynTKoB> B 4254 r. Oranvasch of ocTambuMIx vacrei KopomencTBa Gosee BHCOKMM ypoRneM DKOHOMIMECKOTO PAaBATHA, CBASAHOFO C PAHHUM PAcKBeTOM peMecna HW TOp- ToRIM, a CHeqoRaredeuo, ue Gonbuteit ocrporoli commasieMsIx mpoTHBOpeNnii, fOmnasx @parnna crasa B navane XIII n. ecroernemmim menrpom anrmyep. KOBMOTO ARITKEHUM, CKpIRABMIero HOY Gorocaoneroit OGO-IO4KOS BUOTHE peas foie aNTHpcofamHHEe THe6oBaHMA HapoOAHHIX Macc. Iro coorHomenne, cyme- ersoBasnice Memzy popMoit u coxepmanUeM epeci, MbI LOMbITAeMes packpLITE 4a UpuMepe epeTHyecKoro yyenun Kavapon. OctoRuEMt MoxOAeHMEM KaTapW3MA, KAK UBBeCTHO, ABIsIOcK MpHsnanie HEUHOLO COCYMICCTROBAKMIA ABYX HATAT, paBHLIX HO cHOeMY MoryilecTRY, T. &.Gora o6pa w Gora sca. Coornerernenno aToMy, yrRepAast KaTApEL, cyTect ByeT i Wha Mupa — onmt neSecuatit, coszamnit Gorom xobpa, a Apyroit 3ex- Holt, MaTepuaabustit, vyzerBeHHEIi, coaqanEti Gorom asa. Takum o6paaom, fyaiueTw4ecKoe Mpencranstenne 0 WBYX BeuHKIX WayaTax HOSsROAAIO KATApAM PaccMATpURATS 2eMuOi MMP Kak TROpeHMe WM Naperao Hoapora. Caeyonarensso, woe 30, cymecrBylomee ma seme (deoqabubtii THOT M eoqasHNan aKCIIIyaTAIpAA, eokaasyoe recyqapeTRo, WepKOBD HW BCe eoaannsre nopsTKH), oKAssMatoes THOpeRNEM ABABOsTA. H eos ¢ HEpKOBHOIt TOURM BpeuA GoppOa TopoaaH H KPECTAH NPOTHB ceHbOpMatbuoro THETA, TocyAapcTBa HM WepKBN paccMarpHRayach Kak rpeXoBHoe BoccTanMe mpoTuE TOpHAKOB, yevanoBeHMBIX caMuM OoroM, ¢ TOUKM speHA KaTapos raKast GoppOa cuuranach camMenHolt M BaccryAMBaOMell BCAKUX MoxRaT, w6o ona Beslach ¢ 3eMHBIM NapeTROM AHAROLTA. Kak ppipasuresm Hactpoennit TpyAAuyNxXcA Mace KaTapHt OTKpEITO IpoTe- “eropai mpotus Bcex Bolin m ycoOuu, KoTOpHe pa3squpail crpaxy Ha YacTIt u Beeit choeii TAMeCTHIO AOMMAMCD Ha teu Hapora. OHM oTBepramn sense BAACTH, UX Upano CyMPITH H HAKAsHHATS Mo;el. He Menee penomonnonustit xapaxtep, vem yuerme Katapon o wByX Maya- wax, Hocna HX XpHCTONOrNA, KOTOpad OTpHNAAa Mm KpaeyrossHBti YorMaT KaTorTMaMa 0 ComectREHNOM TPHEMMHCTRE, 1 HCKYIMTeMHHYW weprBy Xpuc~ Ta H paccMarpnnasa eRaHreaBCKHe PAaccKassI O CTO RUBINT M CMepTH Kak BBI- uatcer, Corsacno ysenuio xatapos, Aucyc rompKo mamMemM o6pa3om Romie B VeMOBETOCKYIO WAOTH 1 HMKOTAA Te Gsia pore pono Mapueii. He Gro M HUKAKMX eTpaganuit pacusrore Xpucra, Oo Bee D1 sBAsOCh TOKO BUIU- MocTHIO, a Ha camom jexe Wnecye Xpucroc umxorga we YMUpast, He BocKpecast He BOsHOcHACA Ha HeOo. CeqoBarenbHO, He OLWIO MU MCKYIMTeIbNOI »epTBEL Xpuera, u karommeckas WepKosb ue oGtaqaer Tooromy MmNKaKoii Gomecruen- uoit GraToRaTEIO WM He MomeT coobMaTE, ee TOAAM, MITyUpOM cnacenmaA. Vucye 6m nocsan Gorom joSpa na seMaw ch ANH Toro, HTOGHE Npody- AUTH B YENOBEYOCKUX LYMAX, NEKOPAA UOXVIMEHUBIX jLbFBOGOM C¢ HeGA, BOC- ToMMHaMMe 06 ux HeOCcHOM UpoucxomjeHuu. BaxepuuB CBO MponloReAb Ha semac, Mncye Xpneroc nepegaa ce mpoqoxKeHue amocTomaM, a OT HMX aTa Mpowowes, Mepemma upsMo B PyKM NCTHHHOi YepKN, T. e. B pyKt KaTapoR. [ostomy m yocTurnyTs eiacenna MoryT JM Te JOAN, KoTOpsIE RocmpMAAH YueHne KaTapoR M MOAYHIM oT MX «Kpemenne AyXoM», sun «yTemTeHne». Ho xavaper ne orpariusmasncs orpunaniem KaroanuecKoi porn. Orr KaMAA Ha KaMHe He OCTABAsM HOT caMOrO HUCTHTYTa HepKen. Oun orBepraan Bee ee TAHHCTBA KAK 3HakM [EABOMA MU BCIO ee HepapXxHio, HaWNHam oT Mar HO UpocToro KiOpe, KA HABOALOKNX cayr. B cpoem erpemaenun coKpyIUNTD AO KOWMA «xpaM caTalyy KaTappl WOOL elle AaHMe, ocymAyan m Bee cpexeTRa DMONMONANEIOLO BoaHelicTRUA Ha BepYIOUIUX, BAIPAGOTAHHBLe HePROBBW 3a MITO- Tie Beka ee rocrogerna. Natapst BEICTyHaJIM MpoOTHR Mecebt H KyabTAa CRATHIX, porn Moujeli uM XpecroR, npoTHE MomTE (KpoMe MosuTHM «Orde wan) H LepKORNBIX 8{aHMi, MPOTHB MKOU M WepKoBHOll YrBapM, UpoTMB KoWOKOTOR w KiagGum, Ou ormepram ECO MMIIHOCTK KaTOMMYECKOrO GorocayAentst, ¢ HOMOME1 KoTOpot UEpKoBD cTpemmaacy BosseiicrBORATH Wa YyBeTBA Bepy- ronUrx. Haxonen, ronops 0 Katapax, Nexpan Ne OTMeTHTH HY ropTHMX mporecron Mporis GecKonewm1x woSopos co cropomm yepKu, uG0, Baayen oOmmupueill- TMMM 3eMenbNEIM SoratcTRaMH WM OO1aJaA 01pOMITEIM NowuTMYecKMM Mory- I[CCTBOM, KATOMM4ECKAA WePKOBb, B TUTE WpexcTarnreseit cRoeli nepapxun, BEeTYHata HOBCIOLY KaK YacTh TocmopeTRyIoMe10 Kaacca, SecmomasO OK TulyaTMpoBaBIeTO HapomHBIe MACCEI. B camom peakom ocyoxqeHum GorareTR mepkeH K KaTapam pwn BAILLCHCH, II WMONCKHe SeAHAKH, BbIAPHTABINe CROUM THaBHBIM TpeGon -HHeM aGcoOTHYIO Ge_HOCTL HW BoOsRpAT kK WOpAAKAaM PauNexpucTHAHcKoH COMM ant, XoTs# YUOHME BAABACHCOR sMIKexoCe Ha CORCEM APYTUX eTOWMAX, YeM yueHne KaTapos (BanbyeHChl OOOCHOBLIBATI CBOM WOMOKEHUA, CCbLIAACh Ha cBATeMHOoe UcaHMe), B cBoeit MpakTM4ecKoil AeaTeAbUOCTH M KaTApEI, 1 BANL- Aenest 7o6uBasuce, opuoro u Toro axe. WM re u ~Apyrue cxpemusuch K yHuUTo- MCHMIO KATOMMMCCKOI NepKBM ee MepapxI, YTO H AaBato UX COBpeMeRHU- KAM OCHOBAHMe HasbipaTh UX OAHMM OOMMM aMeHeM auDOuroiines. Hs atoro MoHo, YTO GorocaoncKas OGoOURA epeceit HMea jaseKO He MepnocrenerHoe guavenne. OcroniaMt 1m pemarongnt S110 WX ConarHNOe coxepaanne, oOye- WOBLeHHOe TO CpefOli, B KOTOPO! OHM BOSHMRATH, 1 CONMAAbHBIMIL CItmaMut, wirepechl KOTOPBIX OHM OTpaAaInt. Yuenne karapow Bo Bex cro yaeTax (meraduamveckolt Kocmoromnr uw Teo- HOLM, THRE Me CONMATEHO-MOAUTHYCCKNX BOLPOCAX) OTAUTATOCH He TOKO HMCKUOWNTCALHOM WOCTYUHOCTLIO WAM BOCIPMATUA, HO M OrpoOMHOIi peRouiOUN- ouMOi cusOi CROUX UpaKnecnux BsBoAoB. B arom u saKmoyaereH paaraqna toro, MOYeMY OHO NOwYYNNO WMpovalimee pacupocrpakeHue cpe BApOMHEIX mace IOnxoli Dpannun. Orne yuNTEIBaH DTO, epKoBb Besa ¢ KaTApUsMOM H Bab eHCTBOM camy1o ynopry1 Gopsby. HpnGeruyn x nowonur cenepodpanuyacknx cevsopon, ona opramgz0Rana KpecToBETit mOXo” MpoTUR amDOurosines; ona cosqana TAK HAsIBACMELC CHIMEHCTBYIOIINey OpeHa Ww BReTAa UAKBNaNWWO. OHaKO HMKA- Kuve penpeccum Co CTOpons! NepKBH 1 BCerO rocHoOeTByOMerO Kacca B WEIOM He MOTIM 3aLYUIBTE PeROAMNMOHHOTO MpoTecTa HapoAHIX Macc HpoTHR eo- Tawbubix WopATKos wm Heofatbuoit sxcrayarannm. Ha cmeny XI u XII pe. ¢ 3X HapOAHEIME eperITTeCKAMH jpwXeNKAMN eH nek XIV, vex Haxepuw s To- posexux noceranuit. : CcbiikKi Ha MaTepHasibl K Teme B.Pymen6yp2. Hapogubie ABMKeHA B ropogax Utannn. XIV - Hay. XV BB. http://www. diary.ru/-vive-liberta/p97316681.htm B.Camapkun. BocctaHne AonbunHo (y4e6HO-meTogMYeckoe Nocobue ANA cTyAeHTOB MCTOpHYeCKHX aky/bTeETOB FocyfapCTBeHHbIX YHHBEPCHTeTOB, C NPHOXKEHHEM AOKYMEHTAsIbHbIX MCTOUHHKOB) http://enlightment2005.narod.ru/arc/dol1.pdf C.Cka3kuH. Uctopuyeckne ycnosna BoccTaHna Jonbunuo. AoKnagbi copetcow Aeneraynn Ha 10 MexkAyHap.KOHTpecce UCTOPHKOB B Pume http://enlightment2005.narod. ru/arc/dol2. pdf T.Mei. Ovepk uctopnn cpeAHeBeKoBoro MaTepnann3ma / Tlepepog c Hem. http://www. diary.ru/~vive-liberta/p141001160.htm