Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Knowledge Attitude and Practice in Emergency Manag
Knowledge Attitude and Practice in Emergency Manag
207]
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
242 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 |
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 188.24.116.207]
reported so far to evaluate the knowledge, attitude The second case depicted more serious scenario that
and practice of physical education teachers regarding involved avulsed tooth. This was to evaluate the
emergency management of dental injuries. Hence knowledge and practice of dental first-aid.
a study has been taken up to assess the knowledge,
attitude and practice of physical education teachers of Third case elicited a case of laxative injury.
Bangalore schools.
Part III: - consisted of 11 questions, which were on
All the available physical education teachers from luxations and avulsed injuries in their experience that
both government and private schools were considered evaluated their knowledge and attitude regarding
to the study. Among them a total of 700 teachers management of dental injuries.
were available during the study tenure out of which
580 have responded for the study. A prior permission All questions were given alternative choices to help the
was obtained from the Directorate of Physical respondents to make quick decisions.
Education Department, Bangalore, to conduct the study.
Permission regarding circulation of questionnaires Results
to physical education teachers in various schools was
obtained from Principals/School Head Masters of the Sex: A total of 580 physical education teachers were
respective schools. A multistage sampling was done available for the study. Among them 402 (69.3%) were
to obtain the sample. The Bangalore city was divided males and 178 (30.7%) were females.
into two parts namely North and South. A total of 100
Age: Among the 580 physical education teachers, 56
wards are present in the city. On random sampling a
(9.6%) were under 25 years of age, 185 (31.8%) were
total of 50 wards were taken for the study purpose
between 25 and 34 years, 244(42%) were between 35
(1st stage). From these wards, a total of 700 schools
and 44 years of age, 62 (10.6%) were between 45 and 54
selected were taken by random sampling. The data was
years and above age group.33 (5.6%) were above 55 years.
recorded by investigator personally from the physical
education teachers by going to their respective schools. Length of service: Physical education and first-aid
training: out of 580 study population 551 (95%) had
Inclusion criteria
formal physical education training and 527 (90.8%) had
• Physical education teachers from primary, middle
first-aid training, while 29 (5%) had no formal physical
and high schools in Bangalore city are included.
education training and 24 (4.11%) of them had no first-
• Teachers who agreed to participate in the study.
aid training [Figure 1].
• Physical education teachers were included
irrespective of specialized game, age, sex and Part II
religion.
Case 1
Questionnaires were distributed to all physical Dental trauma: - Among 580 study subjects, 228
education teachers who agreed to participate in the (39.3%) of them came across dental trauma, out of
study. The questionnaires were both in Kannada and these 96 (42.1%) found broken teeth without bleeding,
English language to ensure comprehension by all
physical teachers. The questionnaire was divided into First-Aid training
three parts
4%
Part I: - consisted of 11 questions on personal and
professional data that recorded sex, age, teaching
experience and first-aid training background.
J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 | 243
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 188.24.116.207]
56 (24.5%) saw broken teeth with bleeding. 22 (9.6 %) would sideline the injured boy and tell him to bite on
has found teeth that had fallen off, 44 (19.2%) found a handkerchief, while 8 (0.72%) would wash the child’s
mobile teeth (Extrusion), 9(3.9%) saw displaced teeth mouth and let him resume the game. 61 (10.5%) checked
(Intrusion) and others like soft tissue injuries was the degree of injury, and sent him away. About 341
(0.43%) [Figure 2] (58.7%) would take him to the nearest dentist [Table 5].
Among the 580 subjects; only 142 (24.4%) answered Part III
that the damaged teeth were permanent, 169 (29.1%) This section will deal with the questions that evaluate
of them as primary teeth, while 269 (46.5%) were not the physical education teachers’ personal life encounters
sure which teeth it was. Regarding the action taken 48 associated with their knowledge, attitude and practice
(8.2%) of them felt that they would contact the parents towards the management of dental injuries. Among 580
of the child and explain to them what happened after teachers, only 103 (17.7%) [Table 6] had come across
the class. About 57(9.8%) of the teachers would give luxated dental injuries among their spouse/children
the child warm drink and contact the parents, while or students, 51 (8.7%) of teachers had come across
177 (30.7%) would send the child to school nurse, 298 avulsion cases. Approximately 130 (22.4%) teachers
(51.3%) would contact the child’s parents and would felt that they would first refer the injured student to a
take her to the nearest dentist [Tables 1 and 2]. Medical practitioner, while 297 (51.2%) would refer to
a dental clinic, 73 (12.5%) to a General Hospital and 75
Case 2 (12.9%) to a dental hospital and 5 (0.8%) would refer
Out of 580 subjects, 334 (57.5%) felt that they would to a school nurse.
sideline the injured boy and tell him to bite on a
handkerchief, 24 (4.1%) felt that they would look for Regarding the urgency in seeking professional help
the teeth, wash it and give it to the boy to take it home. for an avulsed permanent tooth among the 580
About 9 (1.5%) would look for the tooth and put it back study subject, 288 (49.6%) thought they should seek
in the socket. While 202 (35.6%) of them felt they would professional help immediately, 205 (35.3%) felt that
put it in the water, 11 (1.8%) would keep the tooth in professional help has to be taken within 30 min, 60
milk [Tables 3 and 4]. (10.3%) within few hours and 27 (4.6%) thought
they could seek before next day. All the 580 teachers
Case 3 answered to seek professional help at least before
Among 580 study subjects, 170 (29.3%) felt that they next day; this shows they are not ignorant regarding
management of dental injuries like avulsion injury.
Experienced Dental trauma of students during service Out of 580 study subjects, 128 (22%) knew that an
avulsed tooth can be replanted, while 363 (62.5%) of
study population felt that the avulsed tooth should
be replanted, which shows a positive attitude among
39%
these population. While asking their involvement in the
procedure to replanted tooth, 162 (27.9%) of physical
education teachers agreed to do it by themselves. When
61% questioned regarding cleaning the soiled avulsed tooth,
89 (15.3%) would scrub the tooth gently with a tooth
Yes No brush, 262 (45.1%) would rinse the tooth under tap
water. Approximately 15(2.5%) felt that they would
Figure 2: Showing physical education teachers who have come across put the tooth straight back into the socket, while 214
dental trauma during their job (36.8%) did not know what to do. Some teachers have
Table 1: Depicting different types of dental injuries faced by the study population
Options Broken teeth Broken teeth Teeth that had Mobile teeth Displaced teeth Others
without bleeding with bleeding fallen off (d) (e) (f)
(a) (b) (c)
Total 96 56 22 44 9 1
Percentage 42.1053 24.5614 9.649123 19.298 3.947 0.438
244 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 |
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 188.24.116.207]
mentioned regarding other procedures as cleaning it extrusion injuries, 14 (2.4%) felt that would leave it as
in antiseptic solution, soap, warm water. it is, 381 (65.6%) of physical education teachers told
that they would take the child to a dentist, 16 (2.7%)
While answering for the management of intrusion and teachers told that they would correct it by themselves,
169 (29%) accepted that they did not know about the
Table 2: Represents the action taken by the study population management of luxated injuries. When asked about
with respect to Case I if they have received any advice regarding first-aid
Options a b c d e management of dental injuries, 107 (18.4%) answered
Total No 48 57 177 298 0 that they had received advice or information. Finally
Percentage 8.275862% 9.827586% 30.17241% 51.37931% 0 when asked regarding need for the dental first-aid
After class, contact her parents to explain what happened. Give her a warm drink and contact
her parents. Send her immediately to the school nurse. Contact her parents and take her to the
component in their course, 560 (96.55%) gave a positive
nearest dentist. Others please specify. answer and only 3.4% answered as negative.
Table 6: Showing the knowledge, attitude and practice of the study population regarding the various scenarios depicted in the cases
Knowledge Trained Untrained Overall
based Correct Incorrect Total Correct Incorrect Total Total
N % n % n % n % n % n %
Case 1 Q-1 140 25.4 411 74.6 551 05 17.2 24 82.8 29 580 100
Q-2 451 81.8 500 18.2 551 08 27.5 21 72.5 29 550 100
Case 3 Q-1 326 59.1 225 40.9 551 15 51.7 14 48.3 29 580 100
Part III Q-5 120 21.7 431 78.3 551 06 20.6 23 79.4 29 580 100
Attitude-based Q-3 435 79.1 116 20.9 551 16 55.1 13 44.9 29 580 100
Q-6 348 63.1 203 36.9 551 15 51.7 14 48.3 29 580 100
Q-9 363 65.8 188 34.2 551 17 58.6 12 41.4 29 580 100
Practice-based 280 50.8 271 49.2 551 17 58.6 12 41.4 29 580 100
Q-4
Q-7 155 28.1 396 11.9 551 17 58.6 12 41.4 29 580 100
Q-8 260 47.1 291 52.9 551 12 41.4 17 58.6 29 580 100
Q-9 363 65.8 188 34.2 551 17 58.6 12 41.4 29 580 100
P < 0.005 (Significant)
J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 | 245
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 188.24.116.207]
cases I and II were intentionally selected as 8 and 13 Only 1.5% of physical education teachers told that
years, respectively as children between this ages carry they would look for the tooth and put it back in the
great risk of sports-related dental injuries.[4-6,8-14] socket, but this figure was much lower when compared
to that obtained in Hong Kong,[16] where it is 17.5%.
Case-1, question 1 was regarding 8-year-old girl with However, there was a high statistical significance among
a broken upper front teeth less than half only; 24.4% the trained and untrained physical education teachers.
recognized that at the age of 8 years the upper front (p <0.005). Looking through the storage media, 21.5%
teeth will be permanent dentition. This indicates the chose milk, 15.6% chose water and surprisingly 58.3%
general knowledge of surveyed group regarding the population did not know about the storage media. This
time of eruption of permanent teeth was inadequate. highly significance difference is due to the fact that
No significant difference was noted between the trained knowledge, training and practice among the physical
and not trained physical education teachers (p = 0.055). education teachers in Hong Kong is higher than the
In similar survey carried out on physical education those in Bangalore. As no dental topics covered in
teachers in Hong Kong, 46.8% had identified the tooth the basic teaching and training of physical education
correctly.[16] A good result in Hong Kong may be due programs, physical education teachers in Bangalore
to a planned teachers training program focusing on have low knowledge and practice ability.
all required topics with regular program/workshops
conducted to update their healthcare knowledge. When It was revealed in Part III of the questionnaire that only
a question was posed about the action to be taken when 8.7% physical education teachers had experienced direct
a tooth was broken, only 51.3% answered correctly by or indirect avulsion injury among the children during
choosing option, ‘The parent should be contacted and the tenure. This was lower as compared to physical
asked to take the child to a dentist’. In some instances education teachers covered by Chan (28.3%).[16] The
this may not be immediately possible. In such cases reasons behind this may be due to the kind of sports
referral to the school nurse option was an acceptable that is played in Bangalore, as there is not much contact
alternative; 31% of teachers chose this option, and sport activity compared to Hong Kong.
this response is lower than the responses obtained in a
similar study by Chan,[16] where 70% of the teachers When confronted with an accident involving an avulsed
answered appropriately. A highly significant difference tooth, a higher proportion of the respondents (51.2%)
in the distribution of response between trained and said that they would go to a dental clinic and 12.9% to a
untrained physical education teachers (p < 0.000) dental hospital. The higher percentage of those seeking
was noticed. The reason for the difference in results help from a dental clinic could be related to accessibility
between the present study and the study conducted by and less knowledge regarding super-specialty dental
Chang is the presence of school nurse in every school hospitals, and also lack of interaction with the dental
in Hong Kong. This shows that there is a scarcity of hospitals. The preference of taking the child to a dentist
school nurses in Bangalore. For case II, presenting a by the physical education teachers may be attributed
13-year-old boy with avulsed upper front tooth, the to the increased availability of private healthcare
ideal treatment would be immediate replantation[3] facilities in Bangalore city. In the Hong Kong study,[16] a
failing when one should ensure minimizing further significantly higher proportion (48.8%) of the teachers
insult to the periodontal ligaments cells on the root said that they would take the child to a ‘dental clinic’;
surface of the avulsed tooth.[3,17] Approximately 57.5% this may illicit that the dental service being provided
population chose to answer ‘sideline the injured boy in Bangalore is better than Hong Kong.
asking him to bite on a handkerchief ’ suggesting that
they were concerned with controlling the bleeding first. Most teachers (49.6%) recognized the urgency in
This would be the most common instinctive reaction by seeking professional assistance for avulsive injuries.
most lay people in such cases, wherein the sight of blood None of the respondents thought that the treatment
sets off a panicky response focusing on controlling was not necessary. This shows that the attitude of
the bleeding first. Similar results were observed in the the physical education teacher in Bangalore has a
study done on physical education teachers by Chan.[16] good appreciable attitude in providing dental injury
Unfortunately, the child would not benefit from this treatment.
maneuver because undue delay in replanting the tooth
would jeopardize its prognosis.[3,17] Regarding the urgency in seeking professional help
246 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 |
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 188.24.116.207]
there was no significant difference of correct response study shows that all the physical education teachers
between the trained physical education teachers and have good attitude towards management of dental
untrained physical education teachers (p = 0.54). The injuries and lack of knowledge is leading to undesirable
general perception, the trained and untrained teacher practice regarding management of dental injuries.
showed a comparatively same level of awareness
regarding the urgency of seeking treatment in the case It is been noticed however that the physical education
of an avulsion. teachers have a great enthusiasm towards the need for
further training in emergency management of dental
Only 18.4% of teacher had received advice regarding injuries, but there is a need for incorporating emergency
the management of an avulsive injury. A higher management of dental injuries in the curriculum of
number of teachers (39.9%) had received advice on the the physical education teachers as most of them lacked
management of avulsive injury according to studies knowledge on management and practiced inappropriate
done by Chan[16] respectively. There seems to be an methods, which could lead to disability or loss of tooth.
urgent need to educate the physical education teachers
and correct these misconceptions. References
When the responses of the teachers to the questions 1. Andreasen JO. Challenges in clinical dental traumatology. Endod
regarding dental trauma were correlated with their Dent Traumatol 1985;1:45-55.
teaching experiences, unexpectedly it was found that 2. Andreasen JO, Andreasen FM. Textbook and colour atlas
of traumatic injuries to the teeth. 3 rd ed. Copenhagen:
there was no significant relationship between the Munksgaard.1994.
practice conducted and the teaching experience. But 3. Andreasen JO. Effects of extra- alveolar period and storage media
according to a study done by Sae-lim,[18] teaching upon periodontal and pulpal healing after replantation of mature
experience showed a direct correlation with the self- permanent incisors in monkeys. Int J Oral Surg 1981;10:43-53.
assessed knowledge of physical education teachers 4. Grimm S, Frazao P, Antunes JLF, Castellanos RA, Narvai PC.
Dental injury among Brazilian schoolchildren in the state of Sao
regarding the emergency management of dental Paulo. Dent Traumatol 2004;20:134-8.
trauma. In the above results, among trained and 5. Tovo MF, dos Santose PR, Karmer PF, Feldens CA, Sari GT.
untrained physical education teachers there is no Prevalence of crown fractures in 8- 10 years old school children
difference regarding the knowledge of dental trauma in Canoas , Brazil. Dent Traumatol 2004;20:251-4.
6. Zuhal K, Semara OE, Huseyin K. Traumatic injuries of
management and the qualification (trained physical the permanent incisors in children in southern Turkey: A
education teachers), as the trained teachers have not retrospective study. Dent Traumatol 2005;21:20-5.
undergone any special training to handle dental injuries. 7. Gracia Godoy FM Prevalence of distribution of traumatic dental
When the physical education teachers were asked if injuries in a sample of Dominican school children. J Am Dent
Assoc 1981;9:193-7.
they thought they needed further training to manage
8. Sarkar S, Basu PK. Incidence of anterior tooth fracture in
dental trauma cases, a majority of them (560, 96.5%) children. J Indian Dent Assoc 1981;53:371.
answered ‘yes’ and similar response was also observed 9. Saroglu I, Sonmez H. The prevalence of Traumatic injuries
in a study done by Chan (81.9).[16] treated in the pedodontic clinic of Ankara University, Turkey,
during 18 months. Dent Traumatol 2002;18:299-303.
10. Lalloo R Risk factors for major injuries to the face and teeth.
Conclusion Dent Traumatol 2003;19:12-4.
11. Traebert J, Peres MA, Blank V, Boell RS, Pietruza JA. Prevalence
Among the physical education teachers, it is clearly of traumatic dental injury and associated factors among 12 year
old school children in Florianopolis Brazil. Dent Traumatol
elicited that there was significantly very low knowledge 2003;19:15-8.
of dental trauma emergency management; no dental 12. Sandalli N, Cildir S. Clinical investigation of traumatic injuries
emergency management component was included in in Yeditepe University, Turkey during the last 3 years. Dent
their Physical Education curriculum. Traumatol 2005;21:188-94.
13. Tapias MA, Jimenez-Garcia R, Lamas F, Gil AA. Prevalence of
traumatic crown fractures to permanent incisors in a childhood
A lack of adequate knowledge was observed among population: Mostoles, Spain. Dent Traumatol 2003;19:119-22.
the physical education teachers regarding the suitable 14. Rai SB, Munshi AK. Traumatic injuries to the anterior teeth
medium for transport of an avulsed tooth. There among South Kanara school children: A prevalence study. J
should be more interaction between school teachers Indian Soc Pedod Prev Dent 1998;10:2:44-51.
15. Gabris K, Tarjan I, Rozs N. Dental trauma in children presenting
and dental professionals along with nearby dental for treatment at the Department of Dentistry for Children
hospitals to enable them to detect and proceed correctly and Orthodontics, Budapest, 1985-1999. Dent Traumatol
in rendering better treatment at the primary levels. This 2001;17:103-8.
J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 | 247
[Downloaded free from http://www.jisppd.com on Wednesday, September 28, 2016, IP: 188.24.116.207]
16. Chan AW, Wong TK. Lay knowledge of physical education 18. Sae-Lim V, Lim LP. Dental trauma management awareness of
teachers about the emergency management of dental trauma Singapore pre-school teachers. Dent Traumatol 2001;17:71-6.
in Hong Kong. Dent Traumatol 2001;17:77-85.
17. Martin MP, Pileggi R. A quantitative analysis of Propolis:
A promising new storage media following avulsion. Dent Source of Support: Nil, Conflict of Interest: Nil
Traumatol 2004;20:85-9.
248 J INDIAN SOC PEDOD PREVENT DENT | Oct - Dec 2009 | Issue 4 | Vol 27 |