Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ENCV600101
Perancangan Struktur Beton 1
Concrete Design 1
Dr., Dipl.‐Ing., Nuraziz Handika, S.T., M.T., M.Sc.
1
2017/2018
Outline of presentation
Introduction
Safety and Design
Material Properties
1
04/09/2019
Introduction
Safety and Design
Material Properties
Topics
• Basic concept, characteristic of stress‐strain in concrete and steel
concrete compressive strength and its evolution.
• Limit states design concept, Whitney’s stress block, single
reinforcement
• ratio of max and min reinforcement
• Double reinforcement
• T‐shaped beam, ratio of max and min reinforcement
2
04/09/2019
Expected Learning Outcomes Kurikulum 2016
Course Learning Outcomes WA2 WA3 WA10 WA9
Bobot
Pantau Pantau Pantau Peng. Bel.
Mampu menganalisis kekuatan dan merancang balok
1 beton bertulang dengan mempertimbangkan C4 C5 30%
serviceability
Mampu menganalisis kekuatan dan merancang pelat
2 beton bertulang dengan mempertimbangkan C4 C5 10%
serviceability
Mampu menganalisis kekuatan dan merancang
3 C4 C5 25%
kolom beton bertulang
Mampu menganalisis kekuatan dan merancang
4 C4 C5 15%
Pondasi Setempat beton bertulang
Mampu mengaplikasikan konsep disain pada beton
bertulang dalam mendisain bangunan sederhana 2
5 C4 C5 C3 C3 20%
lantai dan menyajikan hasil disain dalam laporan
disertai gambar kerja
Total = 100%
References
No Penulis Tahun Judul Penerbit
Reinforced Concrete: Mechanics and
1 MacGregor, J.G, 2012 Prentice‐Hall, 2012.
Design, 6th .edition
Beban minimum untuk perancangan Badan Standarisai
2 SNI 1727 : 2013 2013
gedung dan struktur lainnya nasional
Persyaratan beton struktural untuk Badan Standarisai
3 SNI 2847 : 2013 2013
bangunan gedung nasional
Tata Cara Perencanaan Ketahanan
Badan Standarisai
4 SNI 1726 : 2013 2013 Gempa untuk Struktur Bangunan
nasional
Gedung dan Non Gedung
5 Wahyudi & Syahril A.R 1997 Struktur Beton Bertulang Gramedia
Hard Copy Ujian
3
04/09/2019
Scoring
Nomor
Jenis Assessment Total
1 2 3
1 UTS 27% 27%
2 UAS 40% 40%
3 Quiz Sumatif 8% 8%
4 Tugas Desain 25% 25%
5 Tugas Gambar
Total = 100%
Books:
• James MacGregor: ‘Reinforced Concrete, Mechanics and Design’, Third Edition,
Prentice‐Hall International, 1997
• Constantin Avram, et al: Concrete Strength and Strains, Development in Civil
Engineering,3 Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, 1981
• SNI 2847:2013 Persyaratan Beton Struktural untuk Bangunan Gedung. Badan Standar
Nasional: 2013.
• SNI 1727:2013 Beban Minimum untuk Perencanaan Bangunan Gedung dan Struktur
Lain. Badan Standar Nasional: 2013.
• SNI 1726:2012 Tata Cara Perencanaan Ketahanan Gempa untuk Struktur Bangunan
Gedung dan Non Gedung. Badan Standar Nasional: 2013. 7
Introduction
Safety and Design
Material Properties
4
04/09/2019
Intro – Concrete Structure Design
• Reinforced concrete structures, availability :
Steel bar
ingredients: gravel, sand, and cement
Simple skill to produce concrete
• Reinforced Concrete Structures:
Bridges Radio TV Tower
Buildings Offshore Structure Oil and Gas
Basement Dams
Water tank
9
Bridges
10
5
04/09/2019
Buildings
11
Buildings
Brunswick Building
Transfer Girder
12
6
04/09/2019
Concrete Truss Tube:
13
Shell Roof
14
7
04/09/2019
Shell Roof
15
Tower: TV/Radio
16
8
04/09/2019
Offshore
17
RC structures elements
18
9
04/09/2019
RC structures elements
Flat plate and Flat slab
19
• Each structure respond in
different manner as it is
subjected to different load.
• Geometrically from its
structure, the responses of
structure can be linear or
non‐linear.
• Material properties,
structure can be either
elastic or inelastic.
• The response of structure
depends on time,
temperature and
environment condition.
20
10
04/09/2019
21
22
11
04/09/2019
Mechanical properties of Reinforced Concrete (RC)
Concrete strong in compression but weak in tension
Plain concrete beam, fails very suddenly and completely when the first crack
forms
Reinforced concrete beams
Pre‐stressed concrete beams
• Responses of structures due to external load, can be seen from the behavior of
structure.
• By understanding structure’s behavior, we can predict:
• Deformation due to external load
• Collapse mode
• Load capacity before collapse
• Safety factor that can be used so the collapse can be prevented.
23
Example for some RC structure
C
(b) Stresses in a plain concrete
T
C
(c) Stresses in a RC beam
T
Reinforcing bars
(d) PC beam
F
C
12
04/09/2019
Advantages of RC
Economical
Suitability of material for architectural and
structural function
Fire resistance
Rigidity
Low maintenance
Availability of materials
25
Disadvantages of RC
Low tensile strength
Necessity to use forms and shoring
Relatively low strength per unit weight or
volume
Time dependent volume change
26
13
04/09/2019
Formwork and Shoring
27
Introduction
Safety and Design
Material Properties
28
14
04/09/2019
Limit States in Concrete Structure Design
Limit States:
When element of structures are changing under some circumstances
and it becomes less than before (deflected, cracked, change.. ) it can be
said that it reaches its limit states.
Three groups:
1. Ultimate limit states
2. Serviceability limit states
3. Special limit states
29
30
15
04/09/2019
31
32
16
04/09/2019
Limit States Design
Limit States Design Process:
1. Identify all potential failure modes
2. Penentuan tingkat safety yang dapat diterima terhadap
setiap limit states: Building code, Load Factor,
Loading combination, Resistance factor
3. Pertimbangan perancang terhadap limit state yang
significant:
(a) Proporsi member terhadap Ultimate limit states
(b) Pengecekan terhadap Serviceability limit states
33
Limit States Design
Basic Design Relation ship
17
04/09/2019
Limit States Design
w
Wl l
w
Wdd
BendingMoment
Bending Moment
35
Safety of structure
Three reasons why safety factor (e.g. load and resistance) is a must in
structural design.
• Variability in resistance
(a) Variability in concrete and reinforcement resistance
(b) Difference in dimension in as‐built drawing
(c) the effect of simplification in decreasing structure’s resistance
• Variability in loading application
• Failure consequences
a) The cost of cleaning and rebuilding the structures and its contents
b) Potential loss of life
c) The social cost of loss of time, revenue and loss indirectly
36
18
04/09/2019
Beam failure moment calculation and experimental
results (fc’ > 2000 psi)
x = 1.05
50
= 0.105
of test
Number of test
Number 40
30
112 Tests
20
10
37
Frequency distribution of sustained component of
live loads in offices
0,80 0,80
0,60 0,60
Frequency
Frequency
Frequency
Frequency
0,40 0,40
0,20 0,20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Load intensity (psf) Load intensity (psf)
Load intensify (psf) Load intensify (psf)
19
04/09/2019
Probabilistic calculation of safety factors
• R, distribution of resistance population
• S, max distribution of load effect
• 45º line correlates the load effect
• Combination of S & R, exactly beyond the 45º line, results
in failure
• S1 & R1 causing the failure
• S2 & R2 safety combinations
• Probability of failure can be decreased by increasing the
resistance, translate the R to the right or decrease the
dispersion.
39
Safe and unsafe combinations of loads and
resistances
R
re
S=
ilu
: Fa
R
S>
afe
1 R:S
S1S1 S<
Load Effect, S
Load effects, S
S2S2 2
RR2
2
R1R1
Resistance, R
Resistance, R
40
20
04/09/2019
Safety margin, probability of failure, safety index
• Y=R‐S, Safety margin
• Failure = ‐ value
• Probability of failure, Pf =
probability [Y <0]
• Mean value of Y, Ÿ and standard
y
deviation σy
• Ÿ=0+βσy, where: β=Ÿ/σy =safety
Frequency
y
Frequency
index
0 Y= R- S
P[(R- S) <0 ] = shaded area = Pf Safety margin
Safety margin
41
Ultimate limit states design based on SKSNI
SKSNI pasal 11.1.1 & 11.1.2 regulates limit states design:
• 11.1.1 Struktur dan komponen struktur harus direncanakan hingga
semua penampang mempunyai kuat rencana minimum sama
dengan kuat perlu, yang dihitung berdasarkan kombinasi beban
dan gaya terfaktor yang sesuai dengan ketentuan tata cara ini.
• 11.1.2 Komponen struktur juga harus memenuhi ketentuan lain
yang tercantum dalam tata cara ini untuk menjamin tercapainya
perilaku struktur yang cukup baik pada beban kerja.
42
21
04/09/2019
Factored load (SNI‐2847:2014) new
U=1,4 D (9‐1)
U=1,2D+1,6L+0,5(Lr or R) (9‐2)
U=1,2D+1,6(Lr or R)+(1,0L or 0,5W) (9‐3)
U=1,2D+1,0W+1,0L+0,5(Lr atau R) (9‐4)
U=1,2D+1,0E+1,0L (9‐5)
U=0,9D+1,6W (9‐6)
U=0,9D+1,0E (9‐7)
Note:
(a) Faktor beban hidup L dalam Pers. (9‐3) sampai (9‐5) diizinkan direduksi sampai 0,5
kecuali untuk garasi, ruang publik, dan semua luasan dimana L > 4,8 kN/m2;
(b) Bila W beban angin tingkat layan, 1,6W harus digunakan sebagai pengganti dari 1,0W
dalam Pers. (9‐4) dan (9‐6), dan 0,8W harus digunakan sebagai pengganti dari 0,5W
dalam Pers. (9‐3)
43
Gaya jacking gaya prategang:
Untuk desain daerah angkur pasca tarik, faktor beban sebesar 1,2 harus
diterapkan pada gaya jacking, gaya prategang maksimum.
44
22
04/09/2019
Load (Beban, SNI 2847:2013)
• D = Dead Load
• L = Live load
• Lr = (Live) roof load
• R = rain load
• W = wind load
• E = earthquake load
• H = soil pressure
• F = fluids pressure
• T = foundation settlement, creep, concrete expansion,
delta temperature.
45
46
23
04/09/2019
Spiral
0,75 ϕ=0,65+(εt-0,002)(250/3)
Lainnya
0,65
Terkontrol Transisi Terkontr
tekan tarik
εt=0,002 εt=0,005
c/dt=0,600 c/dt=0,375
Interpolasi pada c/di : Spiral ϕ=0,75+0,15[(1/(c/dt)-(5/3)]
Lainnya ϕ=0,65+0,25[(1/(c/dt)-(5/3)] 47
Shear and Torsion φ=0,75
Support on concrete 0,65
Daerah angkur pasca tarik 0,85
Model strat dan pengikat, da strat, pengikat, daerah pertemuan (nodal), dan daerah
tumpuan dalam model tersebut 0,75
Penampang lentur daam komponen struktur pratarik dimana penanaman strand
kurang dari panjang penyaluran (12.9.1.1)
(a) Dari ujung komponen struktur ke ujung transfer 0,75
(b) Dari ujung panjang transfer ke ujung panjang penyaluran phi boleh ditingkatkan
dari 0,75 sampai 0,9
48
24
04/09/2019
49
new
50
25
04/09/2019
new
Untuk struktur yang tergantung pada dinding struktur pracetak menengah dalam KDS
D, E, atau F, rangka momen khusus, atau dinding struktur khusus untuk menahan
pengaruh gempa, E, ϕ harus dimodifikasi sebagaimana yang diberikan dalam (a)
sampai (c):
(a) =0.60 untuk geser pada komponen struktur penahan E gempa yg kuat geser
nominalnya < gaya geser yg timbul sehubungan dgn pengembangan kuat lenturnya
nominalnya;
(b) Untuk diafragma, ϕ untuk geser harus tidak melebihi ϕ minimum untuk geser
yang digunakan untuk komponen vertikal sistem penahan gaya gempa utama;
(c) =0.85 untuk penghubung (joint) dan balok kopel bertulang diagonal
51
Steel reinforcement bar new
26
04/09/2019
Earthquake structure design new
53
Analytical Procedure Start
and Design Architectural
Lay out
Investigasi
Material
Seleksi Preliminary Height, Story
Selection Structural Systems Span, Loading, Soil Cond.
Alternatives
Design Criteria
Appropriatness Selected Structural
Economy System
Maintainability
Preliminary size
2
54
1
27
04/09/2019
2
Structural Analysis
Static
Analytical Procedure Dynamic
and Design Loading
Combinations
Aesthetics
Design Criteria Members
Construcability
Code design
Maintainability
Strong-Column-weak-Beam Capasity
Ductile Design
Tender Documents:
Drawing
Specifications
BQ, List, Cost
55
Construction
References
1. James MacGregor: ‘Reinforced Concrete, Mechanics and Design’,
Third Edition, Prentice‐Hall International, 1997
2. Syahril A. Rahim: ‘Perancangan Struktur Gedung’, 2003, Jurusan Sipil FTUI
3. __________, ‘Tata Cara Perencanaan Struktur Beton Bertulang untuk
Bangunan Gedung’, SK‐SNI‐03‐ 2847‐2002, BSN
56
28
04/09/2019
Introduction
Safety and Design
Material Properties
57
Material : Concrete
• Concrete is a composite composed of aggregate, generally
sand and gravel, chemically bound together by hydrated
Portland cement
58
29
04/09/2019
Strength of Concrete
Mechanism of Cracking and Failure in Concrete Loaded in
Compression
Effect of Sustained Loads
60
30
04/09/2019
Effect of Sustained Loads
61
Effect of Sustained Loads
62
31
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
• Uniaxial compressive strength as measured by a
compression test of a standard test cylinder this test is
used to monitor the concrete strength for QC or
acceptance purposes
• Standard compressive strength tests:
Cylinder 150 mm in diameter by 300 mm high, cured, and
tested in accordance with ASTM Standards C31 and C39
• Statistical Variations in Concrete Strength
63
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Statistical variations in concrete strength
n
Mean value: x i
x i 1
n
n
(x x) i
2
Standard deviation s i 1
n 1
s
Coefficient of variation V
x
64
32
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Distribution of Concrete Strength
n=176 tests
Mean values=3940 psi
Standard deviation s=615
psi
Coefficient of variation:
V=615/3940=0.156 or
15.5%
65
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Normal frequency curves for coefficient of variation of 10, 15, and 20 percent
66
33
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Building code definition of Compressive Strength
•The specified compressive strength, fc’, is
measured by compression tests on 150 mm
x 300 mm, cylinder tested after 28 days of
moist curing
•The required mean strength of concrete, fcr’
must be at least (SNI)
or
f cr' f c' 1,34 s
f cr' f c' 2,33s 3,5 MPa
67
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Tabel 4 SNI Faktor modifikasi untuk deviasi standar jika jumlah pengujian kurang dari 30 contoh
15 contoh 1,16
20 contoh 1,08
25 contoh 1,03
Catatan:
Interpolasi untuk jumlah pengujian yang berada di antara nilai-
nilai di atas 68
34
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Tabel 5 SNI Kuat tekan rata‐rata perlu jika data tidak tersedia untuk
menetapkan deviasi standar
69
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Factor affecting concrete compressive strength
• Water‐cement ratio
• Type of cement
• Aggregate
• Moisture conditions during curing
• Temperature conditions during curing
• Age of concrete
• Maturity of concrete
• Rate of loading
70
35
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Effect of type of cement on strength gain of concrete
71
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Effect of moist‐curing condition
72
36
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Effect of temperature during the first 28 days on the strength of
concrete
73
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Age of concrete
t
f c'(t ) f c'( 28)
a bt
74
37
04/09/2019
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Maturity
n
maturity M Ti 10ti
i 1
75
Compressive Strength of Concrete
Normalized compressive strength versus maturity
(Referensi1)
76
38
04/09/2019
Tensile strength of Concrete
Modulus of rupture:
Standard a beam of plain concrete 150 x150 x 750 mm
is loaded in flexure at the third point of 600 mm span until it
fails due to crack
6M
fr
bh 2
where: M= moment
b = width of specimen
h= overall depth of specimen
77
Tensile strength of Concrete
Split cylinder test:
2P
f ct
ld
where: P=maximum applied load
in the test
l=length of specimen
d=diameter of specimen
78
39
04/09/2019
Relationship between:
compressive & tensile strength of concrete
79
Relationship between :
compressive & tensile strength of concrete
The mean split cylinder test: f ct 6.4 f c' (psi)
(psi)
The mean modulus of rupture: f r 8.3 f c'
ACI sec 9.5.2.3 (SNI 11.5.3) defines the modulus of rupture for
use in calculating deflection as
40
04/09/2019
Strength under biaxial loadings
Biaxial stresses
81
Strength under biaxial loadings
Strength and modes of failure of concrete subjected to biaxial stresses
82
41
04/09/2019
Strength under triaxial loadings
83
Mech. Properties of Concrete:
Typical concrete stress‐strain curves in compression
(Referensi1)
84
42
04/09/2019
Stress‐strain curves for normal‐weight concrete in
compression
The initial slope of the curves increase with in increase in compressive
strength:
Ec wc 0,043 f c
1, 5 '
(MPa)
Ec 4700 f c
' Untuk beton normal
The rising portion of the stress‐strain curves resembles a parabola with
its vertex at the maximum stress
Strain, ε0, at maximum stress increase as the concrete strength
increases: 0.0015‐0.003
The slope of the descending branch tend to be less than that of the
ascending branch for moderate strength concrete. This slope increases
with an increase in compression strength
The maximum strain reached, εcu, decreases with an increase in
compressive strength
85
Mech. Properties of Concrete:
Analytical approximation to the compressive stress‐strain curve for concrete
(Referensi1)
86
43
04/09/2019
Compressive stress‐strain curves for cyclic loads
87
Mech. Properties of Concrete: Poisson’s Ratio
At stresses below the critical stress: varies
from about 0,11 to 0,21 and usually falls in
the range 0,15 t0 0,20
88
44
04/09/2019
Time‐dependant volume change
Shrinkage
Creep
Thermal expansion
89
Shrinkage of an unloaded specimen
90
45
04/09/2019
Elastic and creep strains due to loading at time, t0
and unloading at time t
91
Behavior of concrete exposed to high temperature
Compressive strength of concrete at high temperatures
92
46
04/09/2019
Reinforcement
• Concrete strong in compression but weak in
tension
• Steel bars or wires that resist the tensile stresses
• Type of steel reinforcement:
‐ Hot‐rolled deformed bars
‐ Hot‐rolled un‐deform bars
‐ Wire fabrics
• Es=200000 MPa Es=29 x 106 psi
93
Reinforcement: Hot‐rolled deformed bars
94
47
04/09/2019
Reinforcement: Stress‐strain curves for reinforcement
95
Reinforcement:
Distribution of mill test yield strength for grade 60 steel
(Referensi1)
96
48
04/09/2019
Strength of reinforcing steels at high temperatures
97
References:
1. James MacGregor: ‘Reinforced Concrete, Mechanics and Design’,
Third Edition, Prentice‐Hall International, 1997
2. Constantin Avram, et al: Concrete Strength and Strains, Development in
Civil Engineering,3 Elsevier Scientific Publishing Company, 1981
3. ________________, Persyaratan beton struktural untuk bangunan gedung,
SNI 2847:2013, Badan Standarisai nasional
98
49