Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This content has been downloaded from IOPscience. Please scroll down to see the full text.
(http://iopscience.iop.org/0957-0233/27/2/025009)
View the table of contents for this issue, or go to the journal homepage for more
Download details:
IP Address: 198.91.37.2
This content was downloaded on 26/06/2016 at 12:29
E-mail: tanggang@mail.buct.edu.cn
Abstract
Roller bearings are essential components of rotating machinery and are often exposed
to complex operating conditions, which can easily lead to their failures. Thus, to ensure
normal production and the safety of machine operators, it is essential to detect the failures as
soon as possible. However, it is a major challenge to maintain a balance between detection
efficiency and big data acquisition given the limitations of sampling theory. To overcome these
limitations, we try to preserve the information pertaining to roller bearing failures using a
sampling rate far below the Nyquist sampling rate, which can ease the pressure generated by
the large-scale data. The big data of a faulty roller bearing’s vibration signals is firstly reduced
by a down-sample strategy while preserving the fault features by selecting peaks to represent
the data segments in time domain. However, a problem arises in that the fault features may
be weaker than before, since the noise may be mistaken for the peaks when the noise is
stronger than the vibration signals, which makes the fault features unable to be extracted by
commonly-used envelope analysis. Here we employ compressive sensing theory to overcome
this problem, which can make a signal enhancement and reduce the sample sizes further.
Moreover, it is capable of detecting fault features from a small number of samples based on
orthogonal matching pursuit approach, which can overcome the shortcomings of the multiple
down-sample algorithm. Experimental results validate the effectiveness of the proposed
technique in detecting roller bearing faults.
status of a roller bearing by highlighting the fault character- samples under the Nyquist sampling rate. Moreover, a fault
istic frequency in the frequency spectra [5]. However, when can be diagnosed during the recovery procedure without com-
the vibration signals measured by sensors are polluted by plete reconstruction.
noise, the fault characteristic frequency will be drawn out, The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2
especially for weak fault signals at the early stage. To over- introduces the basic concept of the multiple down-sample
come this shortcoming of frequency domain analysis, some method. The fault feature detection strategy for a roller bearing
methods of time-frequency domain analysis have been devel- is presented in section 3. Section 4 introduces the applications
oped, such as short time Fourier transform [6], wavelet anal- of the multiple down-sample method for the fault detection of
ysis [7], empirical mode decomposition [8, 9].Nevertheless, roller bearings. Conclusions are drawn in section 5.
most of the approaches mentioned above involve satisfying
the requirement of Nyquist sampling theory, which means
2. Basic concept of the multiple down-sample
that a large number of vibration signals must be acquired for
strategy
fault diagnosis. Thus, collection and analysis at the Nyquist
sampling rate undoubtedly impose immense pressure on fault As a central principle of signal processing, the Nyquist sam-
diagnosis. Therefore, balancing the detection efficiency and pling theory, which states that the number of samples required
the big data acquisition has been a challenge for the fault diag- to the signal capture depends on its bandwidth, underlies
nosis of roller bearings. most sensing and signal processing methods. Under the con-
To ease the pressure on fault diagnosis caused by the straints of the Shannon/Nyquist sampling theory, the number
large-scale data, Lin et al [10] proposed a simple and effec- of vibration signals increases, imposing immense pressure
tive down-sample method called Peak-Hold-Down-Sample on the fault diagnosis process. Therefore, it is necessary to
(PHDS) algorithm, which can be used to shrink vibration reduce the number of samples required for fault diagnosis, but
signals generated from a faulty roller bearing. It selects the reducing the samples while preserving the fault features is a
peaks to represent entire data segments and remaining the great challenge.
information pertaining to roller bearing faults. However, a Among the various fault features of a roller bearing, the
problem arises in that noise might be mistakenly considered peak feature is of great importance because the vibration
as peaks if the noise is stronger than the faulty vibration signal generated by a roller bearing failure contains many
signal. Consequently, the fault characteristic frequency ulti- impulses. Thus, a simple and effective down-sample algorithm
mately becomes weaker than before and cannot be extracted called PHDS algorithm applied in time domain has been pro-
by commonly-used envelope analysis. Owing to a developed posed to preliminarily reduce the number of samples by using
compressive sensing (CS) theory, the problem caused by peaks to represent data segments, while preserving the impor-
the PHDS algorithm may be solved. CS makes it possible tant information closely related to fault features. As roller
to reconstruct signals from a small number of samples far bearing fault monitoring often contains large-scale vibration
below the Nyquist sampling rate [11–13]. Therefore, it has signals with impulses, this kind of algorithm is suitable for
been applied to image processing [14, 15], medical fields their dimensions reduction in time-domain processing. A brief
[16], etc. However, its applications in the field of fault diag- introduction of the PHDS algorithm is given below. For more
nosis are relatively few. Zhu et al [17] summarized several information, please refer to a previous study [10].
applications of CS in the mechanical field, but no practical The first step of the PHDS algorithm involves division
applications were reported. Wang et al [18] proposed a time- of the original time-domain signal into several segments
frequency method for sparse representation via CS, which according to a pre-defined down-sample ratio. Assuming that
has been successfully applied to fault diagnosis. However, s(t) is the original signal. Then, the first step can be described
this method requires complete reconstruction of original sig- as follows.
nals. Chen et al [19] proposed a method for fault diagnosis
via impulse components extraction based on a learned dic- (t ) = [s(t0 ), s(t1), s(t2 ), , s(ti ), ] , 0 ⩽ i ⩽ N − 1
s(1)
tionary through CS, but the samples required for fault diag-
nosis are still large. (T ) = [S (T0 ), S (T1), S (T2 ), , S (Tj ), ], 0 ⩽ j ⩽ M − 1
S(2)
In order to reduce the dimensions of monitoring vibration Where M = int(N/r) is the number of data segments and r
signals while preserving the fault features and make them pos- represents the pre-defined down-sample ratio.
sibly detected, in the present paper, we develop a compressed The data segments can be written as
detection strategy of roller bearing fault based on multiple
X (Tj ) = [s(ti ), s(ti + 1), s(ti + 2 ), , s(ti + r )]
(3)
down-sampling method. The dimensions of monitoring
vibration signals are firstly reduced by a down-sampling pro- Where ti ⩾ Tj and ti + r < Tj + 1.
cessing, then we use a compressive sensing strategy to solve The second step of the PHDS algorithm involves finding
the detection problem caused by inadequate samples without peaks with a maximum absolute value in each segment to rep-
complete reconstruction. Finally the bearing fault features can resent the data segment. The selection of the peaks depends
be identified from under-sampled noisy signals by orthogonal on the sign of the preceding and the sign change between the
matching pursuit strategy. This novel method is proposed for maximum and minimum values within each signal segment.
the fault feature detection of roller bearings, which can extract To simplify the description, a denotes the maximum value and
the fault characteristic frequency from a small number of b represents the minimum value in a data segment. If a and b
2
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
y = φψα
(6)
Divide s(t) into m segments
Where x is a N×1 column vector, which can be viewed
Finding the maximum value ai and the as the signal measured by sensors. It can be expressed
minimum value bi in ith segment by a group of N×1 basis vectors, which are denoted as
ϕ = {ϕ1, ϕ2, , ϕN − 1, ϕN } ∈ R N × N . The representation vector
It is the first YES The one selected as
peak has the maximum
α can be said to be K-sparse, if it contains only K non-zeros
segment?
absolute value coefficients (K N). And Φ is a M × N measurement matrix.
NO Due to equation (5), it can get M linear observations, which
contain the enough information for reconstruction.
The one selected as
When ai is positive, the YES The sign of ai is NO peak has opposite sign Let
peak is ai, otherwise the
same to bi ? to the preceding peak in
peak is bi
(i-1)th segment A = φψ
(7)
So
Figure 1. Flow chart of peak selection in ith segment.
y = Aα
(8)
have opposite signs, whether a or b is the peak depends on
Thus, the model can be viewed as a set of linear equa-
the preceding element in the down-sample data segment. For
tions that need to be solved. However, according to equa-
example, if the sigh of the preceding selected peak is nega-
tion (8), a solution seems impossible, because it is an ill-posed
tive, the selected peak should be positive and the maximum
equation. The solution can be expressed as
of a and b will be the selected peak. However, if the sigh
of the preceding selected peak is positive, the selected peak min α 0
(9) s.t . y = Aα = φψα
is the opposite of the maximum between a and b . In other
Owing to the sparsity of α, the solution becomes possible
words, the sign of the selected peak must be opposite to that
because the unknowns reduce. Therefore, it is possible to
of the preceding element, which is more suitable to represent
reconstruct the signal from a small number of samples if the
the vibration signals. However, if a and b have the same sign,
following requirements can be met.
the selection of peaks relies on the sign of a. When a is nega-
tive, the peak is b, otherwise the peak is a. Therefore, it can be (1) The signal should be sparse or can be compressible,
ensured that the selected peaks have the maximum absolute which means it should meet the requirement of sparsity
value. However, the selection of the peak in the first data seg- [22];
ment is an exception, because it has no preceding element to (2) The basic matrix and measurement matrix should be
compare with. Therefore, the peak in the first signal segment irrelevant. That is it should satisfy the restricted isometry
depends on the absolute value of a and b. If a > b , the peak property (RIP) [23].
is a, otherwise the peak is b. The flow chart for peak selected
The CS theory enables signal sampling to be converted into
in the ith segment is shown in figure 1.
information sampling. Thus, signal expression and reconstruc-
The number of vibration signals is first reduced by the
tion become the key elements [24].In this way, the sampling
application of the PHDS algorithm, which ensures that the
frequency no longer relies on the maximum frequency of the
fault features of the roller bearing are preserved. However,
signal but on the structure and contents of the signal. In addi-
because of the influence of noise, the selected peaks are not all
tion, the theory brings new insight into fault diagnosis, which
fault features. Consequently, the fault features become weaker
is used to extract the fault characteristic frequency. According
than before and may be drowned out in the envelope spec-
to the theory, the vibration signals of faulty roller bearings can
trum. However, with the help of the CS theory, the number of
be reconstructed from a small number of samples with a good
vibration signals can be further reduced. Furthermore, a fault
desired measurement matrix and a sparse representation.
can be detected during the reconstruction procedure without
complete reconstruction.
It is not an overstatement to say that the Nyquist sam- 3. Compressed detection strategy of roller bearing
pling theory underlies most signal acquisition and processing fault
methods in use. However, the CS theory breaks the limitations
of the Nyquist sampling theory and provides great responses. Once there is a local defect in a roller bearing, a force impulse,
Therefore, it has a promising future. Furthermore, it provides a which is a broadband signal in frequency domain covering the
new technique for data acquisition and signal processing, thus natural frequency of the bearing system, is generated when
giving new insight into the fault diagnosis of roller bearings. the surface with the fault strikes to another surface [25]. As a
The core idea of the CS theory is to reconstruct a signal from result, resonance occurs. Hence, the vibration signal energies
a small number of samples. The CS theory can be expressed in at the resonance frequency are enhanced. Whether or not a
terms of a mathematical model as follows [11–21]. fault exists is judged depending on the resonance frequency.
In addition, each time the ball go through the fault, a periodic
x = ψα
(4) impulse is produced, which is called the fault characteristic
3
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
Envelope demodulation
Detecting through CS
Figure 3. Fault test rig of roller bearing.
4
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
0.5
Amplitude/V
0
-0.5
-1
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Data No. 4
x 10
0.01
Amplitude/V
0.005
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Frequency/Hz
0.5
Amplitude/V
-0.5
-1
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000
Data No.
0.03
Amplitude/V
0.02
0.01
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Frequency/Hz
5
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
10
Amplitude/V
0
-5
-10
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Data No.
0.04 0.02
Amplitude/V
Y: 0.01702
0 0.01
-0.02 0.005
-0.04 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 0 100 200 300 400 500
Data No. Frequency/Hz
0.02 0.02
0.01 0.015
Amplitude/V
Amplitude/V
X: 112.3
Y: 0.01554
0 0.01
-0.01 0.005
-0.02 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 0 100 200 300 400 500
Data No. Frequency/Hz
10
5
Amplitude/V
-5
-10
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Data No. 4
x 10
the detection method based on CoSaMP is used to extract the results of the incomplete reconstruction in time domain,
fault characteristic frequency; here, the sparsity K is set to 2. which has same dimension as that of the original signal in
Moreover, the number of samples can be further compressed figure 6, the different is the waveform due to the incomplete
to 600 as presented in figure 8, which is the compressed result reconstruction. Thus all the dimensions in these mentioned
of CS. The frequency of the first detected harmonic compo- figures are 2000.
nent is 55.66 Hz shown in figure 9, which is almost equal
to the theoretical value. Figure 10 indicates that the value 4.2.2. Detection of bearing fault in the inner race at a shaft
twice of the fault characteristic frequency can be determined. speed of 900 rpm. The roller bearing fault in an inner race
Therefore, it can be concluded that a fault exists on the inner fixed on a shaft rotating at a speed of 900 rpm is also detected
race. In addition, the left parts in figures 9 and 10 are the to validate the effectiveness of the proposed detection
6
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
0.06
Amplitude/V
0.04
0.02
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Frequency/Hz
10
5
Amplitude/V
-5
-10
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000
Data No.
0.4
0.3
Amplitude/V
0.2
0.1
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Frequency/Hz
100
50
Amplitude/V
-50
-100
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Data No.
strategy. The time domain waveform shown in figure 11 con- characteristic frequency and twice that value are extracted by
tains 100 000 samples, which will impose immense pressure the proposed method as presented in figures 16 and 17, which
on fault diagnosis. The frequency spectrum of the signals in indicate that a fault exists on the inner race.
figure 11 is shown in figure 12, from which the fault charac-
teristic frequency cannot easily found. However, through the 4.2.3. Detection of bearing fault in the inner race at a shaft
application of the PHDS algorithm, the number of samples is speed of 1300 rpm. Finally, the proposed detection strategy
reduced to 2000 samples shown in figure 13, which is 1/50 is implemented to extract the fault features of a roller bearing
of the number of samples in the original signal. However, with a fault on the inner race at a shaft speed of 1300 rpm. The
the fault characteristic frequency is flooded in the envelope parameter settings are the same as those for the faults men-
spectrum as shown in figure 14. Assisted by CoSaMP, the tioned above. The results are all similar to the applications
samples can be further reduced to 600 as shown in figure 15. mentioned above, which can detect the fault features success-
With sparsity K = 2, the fault features concluding the fault fully through the proposed method.
7
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
0.4 0.2
X: 100.6
0.2 0.15 Y: 0.192
Amplitude/V
Amplitude/V
0 0.1
-0.2 0.05
-0.4 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 0 100 200 300 400 500
Data No. Frequency/Hz
0.2 0.2
0.1 0.15
Amplitude/V
Amplitude/V
X: 202.1
Y: 0.1534
0 0.1
-0.1 0.05
-0.2 0
0 500 1000 1500 2000 0 100 200 300 400 500
Data No. Frequency/Hz
8
Meas. Sci. Technol. 27 (2016) 025009 H Wang et al
[14] Harish S, Hemalatha R and Radha S 2013 Image recovery [21] Zhu S, Zeng B and Gabbouj M 2015 Adaptive sampling
from reduced sparse measurements by compressed sensing for compressed sensing based image compression J. Vis.
based on wavelet transform 2013 Int. Conf. on Recent Commun. Image Represent. 30 94–105
Trends in Information Technology pp 244–9 [22] Baraniuk R G, Candès E, Nowak R and Vetterli M 2008
[15] Hu D, Wang J, Fang E, Zhou W and Zhou Y 2014 Compressive sampling Signal Process. 25 12–3
The application of compressed sensing method in [23] Dragotti P L and Lu Y M 2014 On sparse representation in
photoacoustic image reconstruction 2014 4th IEEE Int. fourier and local bases Trans. Inf. Theory 60 7888–99
Conf. on Information Science and Technology [24] Li B, Li H, Li J, Zhang Y, Wang X, Zhang J, Dong L and
pp 256–9 Fang J 2015 Relaxation enhanced compressed sensing 3D
[16] Milles J, Versluis M J, Webb A G and Reiber J H C 2010 black-blood vessel wall MR imaging: preliminary studies
Quantitative evaluation of compressed sensing in MRI: Magn. Reson. Imaging 33 932–8
application to 7T time-of-flight angiography 2010 [25] Ho D and Randall R B 2000 Optimisation of bearing
10th IEEE Int. Conf. on Information Technology and diagnostic techniques using simulated and actual bearing
Applications in Biomedicine pp 1–4 fault signals Mech. Syst. Signal Process. 14 763–88
[17] Zhu K, Lin X, Li K and Jiang L 2015 Compressive sensing [26] Needell D and Tropp J A 2009 CoSaMP: Iterative signal
and sparse decomposition in precision machining process recovery from incomplete and inaccurate samples Appl.
monitoring: from theory to applications Mechatronics Comput. Harmon. Anal. 26 301–21
31 3–15 [27] Davenport M A, Needell D and Wakin M B 2013 Signal space
[18] Wang Y, Xiang J, Mo Q and He S 2015 Compressed sparse CoSaMP for sparse recovery with redundant dictionaries
time–frequency feature representation via compressive Trans. Inf. Theory 59 6820–9
sensing and its applications in fault diagnosis Measurement [28] Li M, Wang H, Tang G, Yuan H and Yang Y 2014 An
68 70–81 improved method based on ceemd for fault diagnosis of
[19] Chen X, Du Z, Li J, Li X and Zhang H 2014 Compressed rolling bearing Adv. Mech. Eng. 6 676205
sensing based on dictionary learning for extracting impulse [29] Wang H, Li R, Tang G, Yuan H, Zhao Q and Cao X A
components Signal Process. 96 94–109 Compound fault diagnosis for rolling bearings method
[20] Duarte M F and Baraniuk R G 2013 Spectral compressive based on bind source separation and ensemble emprical
sensing Appl. Comput. Harmon. Anal. 35 111–29 mode decomposition Plos One 9 e109166