Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 16-Computer Applications
Chapter 16-Computer Applications
Chapter 16
Key words: Computer Applications, Earthquake Engineering, Earthquake Ground Motion, Engineering Judgment,
General-Purpose Software, Loss Estimation, Instrumented Building Response, Seismic Design, Special-
Purpose Software
Abstract: This chapter surveys the state-of-the-art in computer applications in seismic design. The field of computer
applications is rapidly changing. Therefore, a general overview of contemporary applications is provided
with references to the relevant worldwide web site addresses. The ever-increasing reliance on computer
applications requires a re-doubling of emphasis on sound engineering judgment by practicing professionals.
Computers can enable us to perform engineering tasks we did not dream to be possible just a few years ago.
Blind faith in computers, however, may produce results that are far less reliable than back of the envelope
calculations by a seasoned engineer.
794 Chapter 16
16. Computer Applications in Seismic Design 795
The computer revolution that started in the Instrumental Intensity maps for significant
last quarter of the 20th century and is still earthquakes in the southern California region
accelerating today, has the potential of are automatically produced by the Trinet and
impacting human civilization more than the Cube networks. The Cube maps are
advent of printing by Gutenberg(16-2). As will be instantaneously sent via e-mail to subscribers.
noticed from reading this chapter, earthquake Trinet shake maps may be viewed on the
engineers are now achieving objectives that Internet (http://www. Trinet.org) within a few
could not have been even imagined a short few minutes after earthquakes (Figure 16-2). A
years ago. A few examples would be click-able map for Southern California faults
illustrative. The probabilistic seismic hazard available at a web site
map of the entire United States for default site (http://www.scecdc.scec.org/faultmap.html)
soil conditions is now readily available on the permits users to point to any fault and obtain all
Internet and distributed as a part of the 2000 relevant information (Figure 16-3).
International Building Code (IBC-2000)(16-3) as In the field of loss estimation, emergency
well as FEMA Guidelines for Seismic management and post-earthquake response, the
Rehabilitation of Existing Buildings(16-4, 16-5). A GIS based HAZUS-99 software system(16-6)
companion CD-ROM to these documents developed under a grant from the Federal
allows the user to identify design spectral Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has
ordinates of any site by providing its latitude provided a new horizon to various casualty loss
and longitude. For more approximate scenario and probabilistic analysis (Figures 16-
applications, providing a postal zip code also 4 and 16-5).
suffices! (Figure 16-1).
16. Computer Applications in Seismic Design 797
In seismic analysis and design of very Detailed nonlinear finite element analysis
complex structures, automotive and airplane techniques have been successfully utilized to
proportioning and design software have been predict the experimental behavior of proposed
utilized to accommodate the sophisticated structural connections (Figures 16-7 and 16-
curvatures in the architectural and structural 8)(16-8).
systems (Figure 16-6)(16-7).
10
1
Cummulative Number of Events (N)/ Year
Acceleration (g)
.1 .1
.01
.01
.001
3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5 9.0 .001
Magnitude (M)
.1 1 10 100
Distance (mi)
Figure 16-14. An earthquake recurrence curve generated
by application of EQSEARCH
Figure 16-16. A site acceleration versus distance chart
generated by EQFAULT
7.75
7.50
7.25
Magnitude (M)
7.00
6.75
6.50
Figure 16-17. A typical input screen for the FRISKSP
computer program
.1 1 10 100
Distance (mi)
Framing the earthquake loss estimation The modular nature of the HAZUS-99
methodology as a collection of modules permits methodology permits a logical evolution of the
adding new modules (or improving models/data methodology as research progresses and the
of existing modules) without reworking the state-of-the-art advances.
entire methodology. Improvements may be HAZUS-99 incorporates state-of-the-art
made to adapt modules to local or regional models in the earthquake loss estimation
needs or to incorporate new models and data. methodology. For example, ground shaking
Direct Physical
Damage
9. Inundation 10. Fire 1 1 . H a z M a t 12. Debris 13. Casualities 14. Shelter 15. Economic
16. Indirect
Economic
Losses
W Θ∗
Ws Wf
R
(R -r)
kR −Θ∗
E le va tio n P la n
808 Chapter 16
Analytical
1.5
Experiment
1
FORCE (KIPS)
0.5
16.9 CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
16-1 Pearce, P. (1980), Structure in Nature Is a Strategy
for Design, The MIT Press, Massachusetts Institute
of Technology, Cambridge, MA.
16-2 Naeim, F. (1998), “Internet Frontiers for
Earthquake Engineering Design and Education”,
Proceedings of the 6th National Conference on
Earthquake Engineering, Earthquake Engineering
Research Institute, Seattle, WA.
16-3 International Code Council (2000), International
Building Code, March.
16-4 Federal Emergency Management Agency (1997),
NEHRP Guidelines for the Seismic Rehabilitation
of Buildings, FEMA-273, Washington, D.C.
16-5 Federal Emergency Management Agency (1997),
NEHRP Commentary on the Guidelines for the
Seismic Rehabilitation of Buildings, FEMA-274,
Washington, D.C.
16-6 Federal Emergency Management Agency (1999),
HAZUS – FEMA’s Tool for Estimating Potential
Figure 16-36. Comparison of Analytical Responses with Losses from Natural Disasters, CD-ROM set,
Experiment for model shown in Fig. 16-33(16-38). Washington, DC.
16-7 Naeim, F., Martin, J.A., Jr., Gong, V., Norton, G,
The correlation among the analytical Schindler, B.S., Scambelurri, M. and Rahman,
predictions and observed performance has been M.A. (1999), “ Structural Analysis and Design of
the Walt Disney Concert Hall, Los Angeles,”
continuously improving. For example, Figure
Proceedings of the 1999 SEOAC Annual
16-35 shows the model of a three story building Convention, Santa Barbara, CA.
tested at the University at Buffalo. Diagonal 16-8 Naeim, F., Patel, K., Tu, K.C., Saiidi, M., Itani, A.,
brace dampers were added between floors as a and Anderson, J.C. (2000), “A New Rigid
retrofit alternative. As indicated by Figure 16- Connection for Heavy Beams and Columns in Steel
812 Chapter 16
Moment Resisting Frames,” Proceedings of the 5th 16-22 MSC Software Corporation (2000), The
Conference on Tall Buildings in Seismic Regions, MSC/NASTRAN Software System,
Los Angeles, CA. (http://www.mscsoftware.com).
16-9 Naeim, F. and Anderson, J.C. (1996), Design 16-23 ALGOR Corporation (2000), ALGOR Virtual
Classification of Horizontal and Vertical Prototyping Solutions for Mechanical Engineers,
Earthquake Ground Motion (1933-1994), Report (http://www.algor.com).
No. 7738-96, John A. Martin & Associates, Inc., 16-24 Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc. (2000), The
Los Angeles, CA. ABACUS Software System, (http://www.hks.com).
16-10 Blake, T.F. (2000), EQSEARCH: A Computer 16-25 Structural Analysis and Research Corporation
Program for the Estimation of Peak Acceleration (2000), The COSMOS/M Software System,
from California Historical Earthquake Catalogs, (http://www.srac.com).
Version 3.0, Thomas F. Blake Computer Services 16-26 ANSYS Inc. (2000), The ANSYS/Structural
and Software, Thousand Oaks, CA. Software System, (http://www.ansys.com).
(http://www.thomasfblake.com) 16-27 Bathe, K.J., E.L. Wilson and R.H. Iding (1974),
16-11 Blake, T.F. (2000), EQFAULT: A Computer NONSAP – A Structural Analysis Program for
Program for the Deterministic Estimation of Peak Static and Dynamic Response of Nonlinear Systems,
Acceleration using Three-Dimensional California Structural Engineering Lab, Report No.
Faults as Earthquake Sources, Version 3.0, Thomas UCB/SESM-74/3, Department of Civil
F. Blake Computer Services and Software, Engineering, University of California, Berkeley,
Thousand Oaks, CA. California.
16-12 Blake, T.F. (2000), FRISKSP: A Computer 16-28 Mondkar, D.P. and Powell, G.H., (1975), ANSR-I
Program for the Probabilistic Estimation of Peak General Purpose Program for Analysis of
Acceleration and Uniform Hazard Spectra using Nonlinear Structural Response, EERC report No.
Three-Dimensional California Faults as 75-37.
Earthquake Sources, Version 4.0, Thomas F. Blake 16-29 Computers and Structures, Inc. (2000), ETABS
Computer Services and Software, Thousand Oaks, Linear & Nonlinear Static & Dynamic Analysis &
CA. Design of Building Systems,
16-13 Naeim, F. (1997), Performance of Instrumented (http://www.csiberkeley.com)
Buildings During the January 17, 1994 Northridge 16-30 Prakash, V., Powell, G.H., and Filippou, F.C.
Earthquake -- An Interactive Information System -- (1992), DRAIN-2DX: Base Program User Guide,
, Report No. 97-7530.68, John A. Martin & Report NO. UCB/SEMM-92/29 Department of
Associates, Inc., Los Angeles. Civil Engineering, University of California,
16-14 Naeim, F. (1991), “Interactive Finite Element Berkeley.
Analysis on a Pocket Calculator," Computers and 16-31 Prakash, V., Powell G.H., Campbell S.D., and
Structures, Pergamon Press, Vol. 41, No. 2, Oxford. Filippou F.C. (1992), DRAIN-3DX Preliminary
16-15 Bhatia, H. (1997), Seismic Analysis and Retrofit of Element User Guide, Report, Department of Civil
Cylindrical Liquid Storage Tanks, Ph.D. Engineering, University of California, Berkeley,
Dissertation, University of California, Irvine. CA. December.
16-16 MARC Analysis Research Corporation (2000), The 16-32 Prakash, V., Powell G.H., and Filippou F.C. (1992)
MSC/MARC Software System, DRAIN-BUILDING Base Program User Guide,
(http://www.marc.com) Report No. UCB/SEMM-92/31.
16-17 Martin, J.A., Jr. and Naeim, F. (2000), Structural 16-33 Takeda, T., Sozen, M.A., and Nielsen, N.N.,
analysis and Design of the Staples Center, ASG- (1970), “Reinforced Concrete Response to
ASCE 6th Annual Symposium, University of Simulated Earthquakes,” Proceedings, ASCE, Vol.
Southern California, Los Angeles, January. 96, No. ST12.
16-18 Naeim, F. (2000), Eiffel Tower II: Re-engineering a 16-34 Park, Y.J., Reinhorn, A.M., and Kunnath, S.K.,
Landmark, Invited Lecture, North American Steel (1987), IDARC: Inelastic damage analysis of
Construction Conference, Las Vegas, February. reinforced concrete frame -- shear-wall structures,
16-19 Naeim, F. (1997), UCLA Royce Hall: Anatomy of Tech. Report NCEER-87-0008, State Univ. of New
An Award Winning Seismic Correction, Annual York at Buffalo, N.Y.
Convention, American Concrete Institute, April. 16-35 Valles, R.E., Reinhorn, A.M., Kunnath, S.K., Li, C.,
16-20 Computers and Structures, Inc. (2000), SAP2000 and Madan, A. (1996), IDARC2D: A Computer
Integrated Finite Element Analysis and Design of Program for the Inelastic Damage Analysis of
Structures, Berkeley, CA. Buildings, Tech. Report NCEER-96-0010, State
(http://www.csiberkeley.com) Univ. of New York at Buffalo.
16-21 ADINA R&D, Inc. (2000), The ADINA System, (http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/idarc2d50/)
(http://www.adina.com)
16. Computer Applications in Seismic Design 813