Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
The MIT Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to TDR (1988-
)
Laura Edmondson
1.
1. In
In February
February2012,
2012,the
the
bill
bill
was
was
reintroduced
reintroduced
although
although
Bahati
Bahati
says that
says the
thatdeath
the death
penaltypenalty
provision
provision
will be dropped
will be dropped
(Chongaile2012).
(Chongaile 2012).
2.
2. Evidently
Evidentlydetermining
determiningthat
that
Joseph
Joseph
Kony's
Kony's
name
name
did not
did lend
not lend
itselfitself
to comic
to comic
effect,effect,
writerswriters
Matt Stone
Mattand
Stone
Treyand Trey
Parker
Parker turned
turnedtotorecent
recentLiberian
Liberian
history
history
andand
named
named
the character
the character
after after
General
General
Butt Naked,
Butt Naked,
the nickname
the nickname
of of
Roosevelt
RooseveltJohnson,
Johnson,a amilitia
militialeader
leader
in the
in the
First
First
Liberian
Liberian
CivilCivil
War of
War
1989—1996.
of 1989—1996.
Laura Edmondson is Associate Professor of Theater at Dartmouth College. For the 2012/13 academic
year; she will be based at Makerere University in Uganda as a Fulbright Scholar. Her publications on
East African performance include Performance and Politics in Tanzania: The Nation on Stage (Indiana
(j University Press, 2007). Her current book project explores transnational narratives of violence in
& Uganda, Rwanda, and the DRC. laura.edmondson@dartmouth.edu
P
TDR: The Drama Review 56:3 (T215) Fall 2012. ©2012
10 New York University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
As if Uganda's place in the international limelight wasn't already assured, Kony 2012 hit
the YouTubesphere on 5 March 2012 and went on to become "the most viral video in his
tory" (Wasserman 2012). The video, which was created by Invisible Children, Inc., calls for
the continued presence of 100 US troops in Uganda, who arrived in October 2011 to assist
the Ugandan army in tracking down Kony. Like many of Invisible Children's advocacy tech
niques, the video was familiar in its self-aggrandizing, sensationalist, and oversimplified rep
resentations of the complexities of conflict and post-conflict Uganda. Decidedly less familiar
was the sustained and rigorous critique of the video that permeated the media, which primar
ily attacked Invisible Children but also touched upon the realities of present day Uganda.4
Although the organization's stated aim was to make Kony famous, I would argue that Uganda
played a costarring role in the film and that its cup of symbolic capital overflowed. From aban
doned baby to Tony-award winning Broadway musical to the most viewed viral video in history:
You go, Uganda!
Of course, it's an easy jump from the "The Black Baby" to The Book of Mormon and Kony
2012. In all three representations, Uganda serves as a convenient terrain for formations of the
white Christian male self. In an especially incisive critique of Kony 2012, Elliot Ross argues
that Invisible Children "comes directly out of a missionary tradition of American evangeli
cism that has been growing more and more obsessed with Uganda for years." He explains that
in a historical moment when Africans themselves are increasingly calling the shots in an inter
national evangelical movement, "any would-be American missionaries who fancy themselves
as adventurers need to find new kinds of mission work, new ways of making themselves rele
vant to African societies like Uganda when converting people no longer makes sense as a pri
mary goal" (Ross 2012). The overtly Christian rhetoric of Kevin Russell, a founder of Invisible
Children and director of Kony 2012, as well as the substantial funding that the organization
receives from evangelical Christian organizations, resonate with what Charles Piot (2010) terms
a post-postcolonial society in which religious institutions and NGOs are filling the gaps left in
African states weakened by neoliberal reform. We move from the bowlegged John Bull to nerdy
missionaries to virile Californians carrying out a new version of the scramble for Africa. In each
incarnation Uganda is infantilized, and whatTeju Cole (2012) calls the "White Savior Industrial
Complex" runs amuck.
But why Uganda, when so many other enticing traumas in the region beckon for White
Saviors of their own? I could analyze Invisible Children's representations of Uganda through
the lens of what Didier Fassin and Richard Rechtman have called the empire of trauma (2009),
4. Some of the most useful critiques that I found include Tavia Nyong'o's posting, "Inaudible Children" (2012);
Jack Bratich's "The Rise of the Flashpublics: My Little Kony" (2012); and Mahmood Mamdani's "What Jason H
Didn't Tell Gavin and Other Critiques of Invisible Children" (2012). As this article was going to press, Amanda a
»
Taub launched a new ebook, Beyond #Kony2012: Atrocity, Awareness, and Activism in the Internet Age (2012), r>
o
which includes a range of academic and journalistic critiques of the Kony 2012 phenomenon. I refer to other use 3
ful critiques (such as Cole 2012) in the body of the essay itself. 3
11
We just wanted it to be that place that you always read about [...] where it's just that place
you go, can this place get a break? You know, they have earthquakes and then cholera
and then a warlord, you know, and then a famine and then, you know, no water. And you
know, it was just supposed to be that place. And we settled on Uganda honestly because
they speak English there. So that seemed one, like, less leap to make. And we setded on
Northern Uganda, which has had a humanitarian crisis of its own, and it borders Congo
and the Sudan. So really it was kind of a bunch of different things that brought us to that.
We didn't start with Uganda. It's supposed to be just [that] generic, war-torn worst-place
on-Earth that where, if you are from Utah, nothing [...] makes any sense when you get
there. (Stone and Parker 2011)
The inarticulateness of his response speaks to Uganda's ambiguous position in the empire
of trauma. Uganda is often characterized as a semi-authoritarian state; that is, President Yoweri
Museveni's government allows certain civil and political liberties but arbitrarily, and capri
ciously, cracks down on those same liberties. In an analogous light, could Uganda be consid
ered a semi-traumatized state? In Museveni's Uganda: Paradoxes of Power in a Hybrid Regime, Aili
Mari Tripp (2010) argues that Uganda should be understood as a hybrid state that embraces
the contradictory impulses of authoritarianism and democracy. Taking a cue from Tripp, I've
begun to think of Uganda as a hybrid state poised between "traumatized" and "tame": as semi
traumatized, tainted with just enough trauma to make it tantalizing but not so much to make it
disturbing. The "epistemic murk" (Taussig 1987) of the turmoil in bordering South Sudan and
the DRC is too extreme, whereas Tanzania and Kenya are too tame. Even better—Ugandans
speak English, making it all the easier to understand their (post-conflict) tales of woe. And all
the easier for the Euroamerican Christian male to indulge in his navel-gazing formations of self.
5. See Blaatman and Annan (2010) for a detailed analysis of LRA tactics that helps to clarify the extent of abduc
tion in northern Uganda as well as the experiences of the abductees during captivity. Although the statistics that
they provide are extremely disturbing—for example, they state that "55 percent of abducted youth report that
abductees were often or sometimes forced to beat or kill new arrivals" (140) — their findings also serve as a much
needed corrective to the sensationalist and exaggerated portrayals of the LRA in the international media.
s
E 6. The FDLR, the French acronym for the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda, is based in the eastern
o
U DRC; the CNDP, another French acronym for the National Congress for the Defense of the People, is also based
04 in the eastern DRC; SSDM stands for the South Sudan Democratic Movement.
Q
H
12
This dynamic is vividly at play in another widely publicized Ugandan response to Kony 2012
that was documented by A1 Jazeera. Journalist Malcolm Webb attended a public screening of
the film in Lira, a town in one of the districts that was directly affected by the LRA conflict.
As depicted in a video posted on the A1 Jazeera blog on 14 March 2012, the screening was shut
down due to the angry response of the northern Ugandan spectators, some of whom threw
stones at the screen. The A1 Jazeera video also includes brief clips of Lira residents responding
to the film. "It celebrates our suffering," explains one former LRA abductee with the last name
of Odongo.7 An unidentified spectator at the screening expresses anger against "some kind of
NGO [that is] trying to mobilize funds using the atrocities committed in northern Uganda!"
Both of these responses indicate an awareness of how their suffering has been appropriated
for Invisible Children's gain. The last individual to speak in the video expresses a more blunt
desire to see the representation of Lira's violent past; he exclaims that "we wanted to see how
our local people were killed but these are all white men in the film, they are different from
northern Ugandans!" In a broadcast of the A1 Jazeera footage on the Ugandan network NTV,
Victor Ochen of the Lira-based NGO African Youth Initiative Network, which organized the
screening of Kony 2012, seems to dismiss the complexity and range of these responses when he
explains that the organization is withdrawing the video from public screenings "in order not to
keep retraumatizing [the victims]" (NTV Uganda 2012).8 It is startlingly clear that the Lira res
idents were not "retraumatized," they were simply and defiantly angry about a current world
13
9. See Marlies Glasius (2009) for a more detailed discussion of the atrocities suffered by the civilian population of
the CAR during the 2002-2003 conflict between President Ange-Felix Patasse's forces and an insurgency led by
Francois Bozize. She writes, "Rape of both women and men was particularly prevalent on the Patasse side, while
killings, maltreatment, and pillage were committed by both sides" (51). Another spate of violence occurred from
2005—2007 in the wake of two new rebellions in the northeast and northwest. In tandem with my own observa
tion about CAR's invisibility in the eyes of empire, Glasius notes that the CAR remains "an extraordinarily iso
lated country, relatively small and neglected by international agencies and international NGOs alike" (65).
10. See enoughproject.org for an introduction to the advocacy work of Prendergrast and Clooney. See also wronging
rights.com and africasacountry.com for critiques of their approaches.
14
References
Blaatman, Chris, and Jeannie Annan. 2010. "On the Nature and Causes of LRA Abduction: What the
Abductees Say." In The Lord's Resistance Army. Myth and Reality, eds. Tim Allen and Koen Vlassenroot,
132-55. London: Zed Books.
Boswell, Alan. 2012. "Joseph Kony: 2 Rare, Firsthand Views." The Seattle Times, 8 March. http://seattletimes
.nwsource.com/html/nationworld/2017703 762_konyprofile09.html (20 April).
Bratich, Jack. 2012. "The Rise of the Flashpublics: My Little Kony." Counterpunch, 13 March, www
.counterpunch.org/2012/03/13/my-little-kony/ (20 April).
Chongaile, Clar Ni. 2012. "Uganda Anti-Gay Bill Resurrected in Parliament." The Guardian, 8 February.
www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/feb/08/uganda-gay-death-sentence-bill (18 April).
11. Zoungagbe is identified as the founder of Radio Zereda, which I searched in order to learn that it is based in the
town of Obo in eastern CAR, which was especially hard hit by LRA raids in 2008. Kony's former "wife" (briefly
identified in an easily missed voiceover as being from the CAR) was also identified through quick additional
u
searching as Guinikpara Germaine, who was abducted from Obo in 2008. It is possible that Invisible Children w
n
chose not to identify her on the film because of concerns over her safety; however, Germaine's story and photo o
graph had already been published on 5 March 2012 through McClatchy Newspapers and widely publicized; see, 3
3
for example, Boswell (2012).
15
Copnall, James. 2012. "Joseph Kony Victims Back Online Campaign." BBC News, 19 March, www.bbc
.co.uk/news/world-africa-17432481 (25 May).
Fassin, Didier, and Richard Rechtman. 2009. The Empire of Trauma: An Inquiry into the Condition of
Victimhood. Trans. Rachel Gomme. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Glasius, Marlies. 2009. "'We Ourselves, We Are Part of the Functioning': The ICC, Victims, and Civil
Society in the Central African RepublicAfrican Affairs 108, 430:49-67. www.afraf.oxfordjournals.org
(2 April 2012).
Human Rights Watch. 2003. "Uganda: Idi Amin Dies Without Facing Justice." HRW.org, 19 August.
(31 March 2012).
Human Rights Watch. 2010. Trail of Death: LRA Atrocities in Northeastern Congo. HRW.org (24 March 2012).
Invisible Children. 2012a. KONY2012. YouTube video, 29:59, posted by invisiblechildreninc, 5 March.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y4MnpzG5Sqc (28 March).
Invisible Children. 2012b. Kony 2012, Part II: Beyond Famous. YouTube video, 19:48, posted by
invisiblechildreninc, 5 April. www.youtube.com/watch?v=c_Ue6RekeTA (20 April).
Kagumire, Rosebell. 2012. "My Response to Kony 2012." Rosebellkagimiire.com, 8 March. (29 March).
Kagumire, Rosebell, and David Smith. 2012. "Kony 2012 Video Screening Met With Anger in Northern
Uganda." The Guardian 14 March, www.guardian.co.uk/world/2012/mar/14/kony-2012-screening
anger-northern-uganda (20 April).
LonelyPlanet.com. 2011. "Lonely Planet's Best in Travel: Top 10 Countries for 2012." Lonely Planet Tips &
Articles, 27 October, www.lonelyplanet.com/europe/travel-tips-and-articles/76856 (20 April 2012).
"This Magnificent African Cake." 1997. VHS, 57 mins. Written and presented by Basil Davidson. Chicago,
IL: Home Vision Select.
Mamdani, Mahmood. 2012. "What Jason Didn't Tell Gavin and Other Critiques of Invisible Children." The
Monitor, 13 March. www.monitor.co.ug/artsculture/Reviews/-/691232/1365090/-/c8108/-/index
.html (20 April).
Mukisa, Brian. 2007. "Is Uganda Suffering from Brand Deficit?" The Monitor, 28 September, www.monitor
.co.ug/Business/Commodities/-/688610/788208/-/gyhriw/-/index.html (1 April 2012).
NTV Uganda. 2012. "Kony 2012: Screening Angers Lira Locals." YouTube video, 1:41, posted by
ntvuganda, 14 March. www.youtube.com/watch?v=PJYisE8vjv4 (30 March).
Phelan, Peggy. 2003. "Performance, Live Culture, and Things of the Heart." An interview with Marquard
Smith. Journal of Visual Culture 2, 3:291-302. www.vcu.sagepub.com (19 April 2012).
Piot, Charles. 2010. Nostalgia for the Future: West Africa After the Cold War. Chicago, IL: University of
Chicago Press.
Smith, David. 2012. "Kony 2012 Campaigners Announce Sequel Video." Guardian, 2 April, www.guardian
.co.uk/world/2012/apr/02/kony-2012-campaigners-sequel-video (20 April).
Stone, Matt, and Trey Parker. 2011. "'Book Of Mormon' Creators On Their Broadway Smash." National
Public Radio, Fresh Air hosted by Terry Gross, 19 May. www.npr.org/templates/transcript/transcript
,php?storyId=13614232 (27 March 2012).
e
Taub, Amanda, ed. Beyond #Kony2012: Atrocity, Awareness, and Activism in the Internet Age. Leanpub, 2012.
s
o
Ieanpub.com/beyondkony2012 (24 April).
U
Pi
Q
h
16
Tripp, Aili Mari. 2010. Museveni's Uganda: Paradoxes of Power in a Hybrid Regime. Boulder, CO: Lynn Rienner
Publishers.
YouTuhe.com. 2011. "The Book of Mormon—Hasa Diga Eebowai." YouTube video, 4:24, posted by
MrSwiket, 10 May. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IjBileEaAA (28 March 2012).
YouTube.com. 2012. "Kony 2012 'Invisible Children' viral video response from Ugandan PM Amama
Mbabazi." YouTube video, 7:56, posted by WMTVofficial, 17 March, www.youtube.com/watch
?v=ye5X9Xdg2CE (29 March).
Wasserman, Todd. 2012. '"Kony 2012' Tops 100 Million Views, Becomes the Most Viral Video in History."
Mashable, 12 March, http://mashable.com/2012/03/12/kony-most-viral/ (19 April).
Wikia. 2011. "Michael Potts: Hasa Diga Eebowai." Lyric Wiki. 31 May. http://lyrics.wikia.com/Michael_
Potts:Hasa_Diga_Eebowai (19 April 2012).