Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a f t e r t h e B u d d h a’ s E n l i g h t e n m e n t
Seven Weeks
after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Osmund Bopearachchi
MANOHAR
Manohar
2016
First published 2016
© Osmund Bopearachchi, 2016
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be
reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means,
without prior permission of the author and the publisher.
ISBN 978-93-5098-137-5
Published by
Ajay Kumar Jain for
Manohar Publishers & Distributors
4753/23 Ansari Road, Daryaganj
New Delhi 110 002
Printed at
Salasar Imaging Systems
Delhi 110 035
Contents
List of Illustrations 7
Preface 11
Introduction 13
Pāli, Sanskrit and Chinese Sources 16
First Week 17
Second Week 19
Third Week 20
Fourth Week 21
Fifth and Sixth Weeks 23
Seventh Week 24
Iconography 26
Gandhāran Art 26
Great Sāñcī Stūpa 34
Nāgārjunakoṇḍa Stūpa 42
Frieze from Kumbukwewa (Sri Lanka) 45
Mural Paintings from Sri Lanka 48
Mural Paintings from Myanmar 63
Conclusions 70
Bibliography 73
Illustrations
The focal point of the present study is the unique and unpublished
relief of late Andhra style sculpted in Sri Lanka by an artist from
Nāgārjunakoṇḍa using a hard lime slab imported from Andhra
(Fig. 1). Unfortunately, the relief was found broken into two pieces.
In spite of the bad state of its preservation, the scenes in question can
be identified without any problem.
Archaeological evidence, along with epigraphic and literary sources
attest the intense interactions between the Buddhists of Sri Lanka and
those of the same faith in the Krishna Valley in Andhra during the
early centuries of the Common Era. The earliest Buddha images in
the round known in Sri Lanka were carved out of Andhra hard
limestone and were brought to the island by traders, pilgrims and
monks using maritime routes.1
It is also well-known that Buddhist art in Sri Lanka, apart from
rare exceptions, is deprived of bas-reliefs or rock cut images depicting
the life of the historical Buddha. Most of the portable slabs found in
the island were executed in the Krishna Valley in Andhra Pradesh and
were imported to Sri Lanka. The two panels found in 1894, in the
Bodhighara, in a paddy field about a mile from Anuradhapura depicting
the dream of Mahāmāyā and the interpretation of the dream, now
exhibited in the Colombo National Museum were certainly executed
in India, as their prototypes in Andhra art prove. Many fragments and
intact slabs found in the Bodhighara south of the Jetavana Stūpa in
Anuradhapura, unearthed during excavations conducted by the Cultural
Triangle, in November 1986, are made of Andhra hard limestone, and
stylistically they belong to the Nāgārjunakoṇḍa School. The slab
depicting the renunciation of Prince Siddhartha, now in the Gririhandu-
Vihara in Ambalantota executed in the Andhra lime stone is of the
later Nāgārjunakoṇḍa style.2 As we have pointed out elsewhere, two
out of four railing pillars found in the Bodhighara of the Jetavanarama
1
For a general introduction of these discoveries, see Bopearachchi, 2008a,
2012 & 2015, vol. II, pp. 201-45.
2
For a detailed discussion about these slabs, see Bopearachchi, 2008a.
14 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
3
Bopearachchi, 2015, vol. II, pp. 210-11, also see the colour illustrations,
p. 220; plate 14.
4
Paranavitana, 1971, p. 13.
5
According to an inscription found at the site, the monastery was inhabited
by the Mahāvihāravasin from Sri Lanka, see Sircar and Lahiri, 1970.
6
Stone, 1994, pp. 18-19.
introduction 15
7
For a summary of these trade networks, see Bopearachchi, 2008b.
8
Bopearachchi et al., 2016.
16 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
The frieze depicting the seven weeks after the Sambodhi that the
Blessed One spent in the vicinity of the Bodhi tree, that we wish to
examine follows the Pāli tradition very closely, much more than it
does the Sanskrit one, and it is quite possible the sculptor who was
from Andhra, judging by its Andhra style, executed it, inspired by the
Pāli texts in vogue at the time in Sri Lanka, on a hard lime stone
imported from Andhra.
The way the Buddha spent the weeks immediately after his
Enlightenment varies from one source to the other. For example,
according to the Mahāvagga, the second book of the Vinaya-Piṭaka,
the Buddha fasted only for four weeks, but the Mahāvastu,9 the
Lalitavistara,10 the Nidānakathā11 and the Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa,12 say
that Blessed One fasted for seven weeks or forty-nine days. It is
important to underline that in the Sanskrit text of the Buddhacarita
the last chapters of the second half of Canto 14 are missing, so the
9
The Mahāvastu is a text of the Lokottaravāda school of Early Buddhism
composed of Jātaka stories, Avadāna tales and the biography of the Gautama
Buddha. It is believed to have been composed between the second century bce
and fourth century ce. The Mahāvastu, translated by J.J. Jones, The Pali Text
Society, 1949, rpt. 2007, Lancaster (abbreviated hereafter Mahāvastu).
10
The Lalitavistara is a Sanskrit Buddhist text usually dated to the third
century ce. It narrates biography of Gautama Buddha from his descent from the
Tuṣita heaven up to his Great Awakening and preaching of the first sermon. We
use the French Translation: Le Lalitavistara. L’histoire traditionnelle de la vie
du Bouddha Cakyamuni, (traduit du sanskrit), translated by P.E. de Foucaux,
Paris, Les Deux Océans, 1884 (abbreviated hereafter Lalitavistara) and the
translated from the French: The Lalitavistara Sūtra. The Voice of the Buddha.
The beauty of Compassion, translated from the French G. Bays, Berkeley, Dharma
Publishing, 1983 (abbreviated hereafter Lalitavistara Sūtra).
11
The Nidānakathā was composed in the fifth century ce by Buddhaghoṣa in
Sri Lanka. Buddhist Birth Stories (Jataka Tales). The Commentarial Introductions
Entitled Nidanā-Kathā. The Story of the Lineage, transl. Rhys Davids, new and
revised edition by C.A.F. Rhys Davids, London, George Routledge and Sons
Ltd., 1880 (abbreviated hereafter Buddhist Birth Stories).
12
The Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa, is a prose poem composed by Upatissa in the reign
of Mahinda IV of Sri Lanka around 980 ce which carries some valuable information
about the seven weeks that the Blessed One spent around the bodhimaṇḍa
(abbreviated hereafter Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa).
introduction 17
events that took place after the Enlightenment are not known. They
are, however, preserved in the Chinese and Tibetan translations.13
First Week
13
Buddhacarita. In praise of Buddha’s Acts, Translated from Chinese by
Charles Willemen (Berkeley, Numata Centre for Buddhist Translation and
Research, 2009); also see the note by Patrick Olivelle, in Life of the Buddha by
Aśvaghoṣa, translated by Patrick Olivelle, New York University Press, New York,
2009, 417. Katsumi Tanabe (2012) examines these contradictions to a certain
extent in his recent article, but he does not take the Pāli texts into consideration,
because his study is mainly based on the Gandhāran iconography.
14
Lalitavistara Sūtra, p. 515. For the French translation: “… le Bôdhisattva
ayant surmonté l’opposition du démon, dompte l’ennemi et complètement triomphé
en tête du combat ; entouré de parasols, d’étendards et de bannières déployés,
après avoir atteint la première contemplation, détachée des désirs, détachée des
lois du péché et du vice, accompagnée de raisonnement et de jugement, née du
discernement, douée de joie et de bien-être, il y demeure.”, Lalitavistara, p. 287.
15
Lalitavistara Sūtra, p. 559. “Ainsi, Religieux, devenu Bouddha parfait et
accompli, le Tathāgata bien loué par les dieux, sans cesser d’avoir des jambes
croisées, regardait le roi des arbres sans cligner l’œil. Nourri de la joie de la
18 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Second Week
20
Translation by Stanley Insler (Yale University). The translation by J.J. Jones
(Mahāvastu, pp. 268-9) is as follows: “Then at the end of the seven days the
Exalted One rose up from his throne, surveyed the bodhi tree with a Nāga’s look
and a steady gaze. In joy and ease he stood for the second seven days fasting and
gazing steadily at the bodhi tree.”
21
This is an allusion to the twin miracle that the Blessed One performed,
during the first week: “Now certain of the devas began to doubt, thinking: ‘This
day also there must be something more Siddhartha has to do, for he still lingers
seated there.’ The master knowing their thoughts, and to appease their doubts,
rose into the air and performed the twin-miracle (Yamak-paṭihāriyaṇ).” Buddhist
Birth Stories, p. 200.
22
Buddhist Birth Stories, pp. 200-1.
23
Lalitavistara Sūtra, p. 559. “Ainsi, Religieux, devenu Bouddha parfait et
accompli, le Tathāgata bien loué par les dieux, sans cesser d’avoir des jambes
croisées, regardait le roi des arbres sans cligner l’œil. Nourri de la joie de la
contemplation, goûtant en lui-même le bonheur, il passe une semaine au pied de
l’arbre de l’Intelligence.” Lalitavistara, p. 308.
20 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
remained seated looking at the Bodhi tree with unblinking eyes. The
same information can be gathered from the Fó bìnxíng jíjīng
(Abiniṣkramaṇa Sūtra): “At that time, the World-honoured One rose
from his lion’s seat and not far from the Bodhi tree sat down in
meditation again. For seven days, he did not move, and he used the
conduct of liberation as his peace. For seven days he carefully
contemplated the Bodhi tree, and did not divert his eyes for a moment.
Repeatedly he produced the following thought: ‘At this place I
exhausted the limitless suffering, in order to get rid of the heavy
burden.’ At that time the World-honoured One passed seven days [in]
right thought and right wisdom, he awoke from his samādhi. After
that there was a person who erected a stūpa at the place where the
Tathâgata had contemplated the Bodhi tree, and called it the ‘Stūpa
of the Not-blinking Eye’.”24 So, this Chinese version as well as the
Lalitavistara say that the Buddha kept sitting, not standing, con
templating the Bodhi tree.
Third Week
Concerning the third seven days, the Mahāvastu says quite explicitly:
“… he (The Buddha) spent in walking up and down a long way in
joy and ease”.25 Owing to the confusion of weeks, the Lalitavistara,
presents the same activity, for the second week, saying that the
Tathāgata spent the second week in walking up and down a long way.26
As far as the early Buddhist iconography is concerned, the Nidānakathā
carries the most pertinent description of the third seven days: “Then
he created between the seat and the spot where he stood a cloistered
walk, and he spent seven days walking up and down, in that treasure-
cloister which stretched from east to west. And that spot became
known as the Dāgaba of the Treasure-Cloister.”27
24
Translation by Christoph Ander, Fó bìnxíng jíjīng (Abiniṣkramaṇa Sūtra),
T. 3, no. 190: 799c 21-6.
25
Mahāvastu, p. 269.
26
Lalitavistara, p. 314: “La seconde semaine, le Tathāgata fit une longue
promenade comprenant les régions des trois milles grands milliers de mondes.”
27
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
introduction 21
Fourth Week
The confusion reaches its apogee when the Lalitavistara says that
during the third week – which is in reality the fourth week – the
Tathāgata looked at the bodhimaṇḍa, without blinking his eyes. The
Fāngguǎng dà zhuāngyán jīng, one of the Chinese translations of the
Lalitavistara, repeats, in a way, what has been recorded in the original
Sanskrit text: “When the third seven-day period had arrived, he
contemplated the place of enlightenment, never taking his eyes off
for a single moment” 28 (see the chart).
The Mahāvastu gives a clear picture of the activities of the Buddha
during the fourth seven days: “Now While the Exalted One was taking
his long walk up and down, Kāla, the Nāga king, came to him. He
bowed his head at the feet of the Exalted One, arranged his robe over
one shoulder, raised his joined hands, and said, ‘Lord, former perfect
Buddhas, the exalted Krakucchanda, Konākamuni and Kāśyapa, lodged
in my abode. Well would it be if thou, Lord, would take pity on me
and also lodge in my abode.’ And so the Exalted One spent the fourth
week in joy and ease at the abode of Nāga king Kāla. Then at the end
of the fourth week the Exalted One left abode of Kāla the Nāga king.”29
According to the Nidānakathā, it was gods who created the jewelled
house: “But for the fourth week the devas created to the north-west
of the Bo-tree a Treasure-house, and he spent the week seated there
cross-legged, and thinking out the Abhidamma Piṭaka and here
especially the entire Paṭṭhāna with its infinite methods.”30
28
Translation by Christoph Ander, Fāngguǎng dà zhuāngyán jīng,
(*Lalitavistara), T. 3, no. 187: 601a 1-2.
29
Mahāvastu, p. 287.
30
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201. The Nidānakathā furher says that the
sattaratanaghara is not made of actual jewels but is called, because it is where
the Buddha meditated on the seven chapters of the abhidhamma: “Catutthe pana
sattāhe bodhito pacchimuttaradisābhāge devatā ratanagharaṃ māpayiṃsu, tattha
pallaṅkena nisīditvā abhidhammapiṭakaṃ visesato cettha anantanayaṃ
samantapaṭṭhānaṃ vicinanto sattāhaṃ vītināmesi. Ābhidhammikā panāhu
‘’ratanagharaṃ nāma na sattaratanamayaṃ gehaṃ, sattannaṃ pana pakaraṇānaṃ
sammasitaṭṭhānaṃ ‘ratanaghara’nti vuccatī’’ti. Yasmā panettha ubhopete
pariyāyā yujjanti, tasmā ubhayampetaṃ gahetabbameva. Tato paṭṭhāya pana taṃ
ṭhānaṃ ratanagharacetiyaṃ nāma jātaṃ. Evaṃ bodhisamīpeyeva cattāri sattāhāni
vītināmetvā pañcame sattāhe bodhirukkhamūlā yena ajapālanigrodho
Weeks Mahāvastu Nidānakathā Lalitavistara Fāngguǎng dà zhuāngyán
jīng
1st Week Buddha sat on the bed of Buddha sat motionless for Buddha kept sitting at the Buddha watched the
straw at the foot of the seven days, realizing the bliss root of the Bodhi tree. Bodhi tree; the eyes did
Bodhi tree with his legs of Nirvāna. * * * * * * * not divert for a moment.
crossed. He remained seated gazing
steadily at the Bodhi tree.
2nd Week Buddha stood fasting and Buddha stood gazing Buddha spent the second Buddha remained seated
gazing steadily at the Bodhi steadfastly at the spot where he week in walking up and looking at the Bodhi tree
tree. had gained the results of the down a long way with unblinking eyes.
deeds.
3rd Week Buddha spent in walking up Buddha spent seven days He looked at the Buddha contemplated the
and down a long way in joy walking up and down, in the bodhimaṇḍa, without place of enlightenment,
and ease. treasure-cloister. blinking his eyes. never taking his eyes off
for a single moment
4th Week Buddha spent in joy and Devas created a Treasure-
ease at the abode of Nāga house, and Buddha spent the
king Kāla week seated there cross-
legged.
5th Week Buddha spent fasting in joy Buddha spent under the Buddha was in the house of
and ease at the abode of Shepherd’s Nigrodha-Tree and the king of the Nāgas,
Mucilinda the Nāga king. Māra’s daughters attempt to Mucilinda.
distract Buddha
6th Week Buddha spent fasting in joy Buddha went on to the Buddha was under the
at the foot of the Goatherd’s Muchalinda-tree and spent a Goatherd’s Banyan-tree
Banyan-tree week.
7th Week Buddha spent the seventh Buddha spent the seventh week
week fasting in joy and ease sat under the Rajāyātana tree
at a shrine of many devas in enjoying the bliss of
a thicket of kṣīrika tees. deliverance.
End of the 7th Trapuṣa and Bhallika came Tapassu and Bhalluka came
Week with five hundred chariots with five hundred carts
Chart summarizing the literary sources on seven weeks after the enlightenment of the Buddha.
introduction 23
The Mahāvastu tells us how the Buddha spent his fifth week: “The
Nāga king Mucilinda who also had shown respect to former Buddhas
came to the Exalted One. Having bowed his head at his feet, he
stood to one side with his joined hands raised and appealed to the
Exalted One. “Lord”, said he, “former perfect Buddhas, the exalted
Krakucchanda, Konākamuni and Kāśyapa, lodged in my abode. Well
would it be thou, too, Lord, would take pity on me and lodge in my
abode.” And so the Exalted One spent the fifth week fasting in joy
and ease at the abode of Mucilinda the Nāga king. Now in that week
unreasonable rainy weather came on. For the whole week it rained
night and day. But Mucilinda the Nāga king threw his coils seven fold
around the Exalted One to form an envelope of half a yojana and
covered him above with his broad hood.”31 “After he had left the
abode of Mucilinda the Nāga king, the Exalted One spent the sixth
week fasting in joy at the foot of the Goatherd’s Banyan-tree” says
the Mahāvastu.32 The Lalitavistara gives a similar description regarding
the sixth week.33
The Nidānakathā and the Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa record that the
encounter with the Nāga king, Mucilinda, took place in the sixth week.
More precisely, the Nidānakathā says: “Having thus spent four weeks
close to the Bo-tree; he went, in the fifth week, to the Shepherd’s
Nigrodha-tree: and sat there meditating on Doctrine, and experiencing
the happiness of deliverance.”34 It further says that at that time, when
Seventh Week
The Mahāvastu thus records the activities of the Buddha: “When this
sixth week at the foot of the Goatherd’s Banyan-tree was over, he
spent the seventh week fasting in joy and ease at a shrine of many
devas in a thicket of kṣīrika tees. Thus the Exalted One fasted for
seven weeks or forty-nine days.”37 The story narrated in the
Laitavistara38 (p. 317) is quite similar to the one given in the
Mahāvastu. The Nidānakathā is not in contradiction either with the
two Sanskrit texts: “Thence he went away to the Kingstead-tree
(Rajāyātana tree) and there also sat down enjoying the bliss of
deliverance. And so seven weeks passed away, during which he
35
Buddhist Birth Stories, pp. 202-4.
36
Ibid., p. 204.
37
Mahāvastu, p. 290.
38
Lalitavistara, 317: “La sixième semaine, le Tathāgata, de la demeure de
Moutchilinda alla au pied du figuier du berger des chèvres.”
introduction 25
39
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 204.
40
Mahāvastu, pp. 290-1.
41
Lalitavistara, pp. 317-18.
42
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 205. This episode is discussed at length by André
Bareau (1963, pp. 106-23) in the light of Pāli sūtras. Phyllis Granoff (2005,
pp. 129-38), places this story in a Jain context in which fasting and breaking fast
are major themes. Likewise, she rectifies some of Bareau’s hesitations in accepting
supernatural interventions in this story.
43
Buddhacarita, pp. 73-4.
26 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Iconography
Gandhāran Art
44
For the events quoted here, see Mahāvagga, pp. 1-6.
45
Kurita, 2003, Fig. 236, p. 121.
introduction 27
The upper register depicts the veneration of the Buddha and his turban most
47
probably by the gods, each of them being shown inside a voluted raised arch.
This piece is now conserved in the Asian Art Museum, San Francisco.
28 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Māra’s attack and the Enlightenment of the Blessed One and on the
left, the first sermon delivered to the five monks (only four are shown
here) at the Deer Park are sculpted. In the middle panel, the Awakened
One, wrapped in a saṃghāṭi with both shoulders, feet and hands in
dhyāna mudrā covered, sits in the middle under a tree, while Trapuṣa
and Bhallika offer him rice cakes and honey. The merchant to the
right may hold the pouch with the rice cake and the one to the left a
container with a long spout with honey or water. Contrary to their
Sāñcī and Andhra counterparts, these Gandhāran sculptures do not
depict in a theatrical manner the episode which is vividly narrated in
the Mahāvastu,48 the Laitavistara49 or in the Nidānakathā.50 If there
is one which does justice to these narrations it is the depiction on the
base of the ‘Fasting Siddhārtha’ from Takht-i-Bāhī now in the Peshawar
Museum (Fig. 4).51 The scenes portrayed on this base closely follow
the narration in the Laitavistara.52 To the extreme right, it is shown
how a cart driven by two humped bulls got stuck under the divine
intervention. It is reported that the wheels of the carts sunk into the
48
Mahāvastu, pp. 290-1.
49
Lalitavistara, pp. 317-18.
50
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 205.
51
Foucher, 1918, p. 273, Fig. 440; Ingholt, 1957, p. 62, no. 53, and pl. 53.
52
Lalitavistara, pp. 317-18.
introduction 29
53
Lalitavistara, p. 317.
30 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
stands behind the bulls, next to a tree, throwing flowers from the curve
of the uttarīya, hung across the body. The realistic depiction of the
four humped bulls or zebu, also known as Brahman (Bos taurus
indicus) is noteworthy. This Indian species has a fatty hump on their
shoulders, drooping ears and a large dewlap, and these characteristics
are all skilfully portrayed in this sculpture.
Although I have no intention to examine this aspect in detail in the
present study, it could be argued, based on the chronological sequence
depicted in some reliefs with several well-preserved scenes, that the
Gandhāran artists followed the sequence starting with the descent of
the Bodhisattva from the Tuṣita heaven up to his Great Awakening as
narrated in the Lalitavistara rather than the alternatives given in the
Mahāvastu or in the Buddhacarita.54 Let us, however, rapidly examine
the false-niche of the Greater-Gandhāran style related to our discussion
that I have briefly published elsewhere (Figs. 6 A & B).55 On this
54
This will be discussed in detail in my forthcoming book: When East met
West: Gandhāran Art Revisted.
55
Bopearachchi, 2008c, see the Fig. 16 in p. 37, for the commentary, see
pp. 35-7.
Figures 6 A & B: False-niche of the Greater-Gandhāran style. Private collection, London. The Buddha looking at the
Bodhi tree with unblinking eyes, and six events related to the great Awakening. Photograph O.B.
32 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
56
These events are depicted following the chronological sequence given in
the Lalitavistara, see chapters 17 to 19.
57
This position, with the left leg horizontal, the right leg vertical, but turned
outwards, is quite rare in Gandhāran sculptures. The closest resemblance is the
sculpture in the Lahore Museum (Ingholt, 1957, no. 177) where the Buddha is
seated in the middle of the scene. The sculpture from Butkara I, now in the Swat
Museum, Siadu Sharif, where the Buddha is seated under a tree, in a pensive
mood, surrounded by gods and monks pleading him to teach, Buddhist Heritage
of Pakistan, cat. no. 165, p. 226; in the sculpture in the Freer Gallery of Art
visualizing the first sermon, the monk seated to the left hand side of the Buddha,
Kurita, 2003, no. 280, p. 149 and the Buddha or a monk, from Fondukistan seated
in a similar position, Hackin, and al.1959, fig. 150; Tissot, 2006, p. 125, a. & b.
34 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
from the middle of the tree. A luxuriantly dressed god or a tree spirit,
holding a bag or the curve of the uttarīya across his body, full of
flowers and raising a hand to throw them. The young Vajrapāṇi looks
to the right holding the vajra vertically at the right hand side of the
seated Buddha. The Blessed One is not definitely seated on the
bodhimaṇḍa, but looking at the tree from a distance. Following the
description in the Lalitavistara, the sculptor depicts the Buddha in
the centre, seated at royal ease next to the Bodhi tree inhabited by a
vriksha-devata, spending the second week during which he looked at
the Bodhi tree with unblinking eyes, gratifying the tree.58 He is not
standing as stated in the Mahavastu, but as described in the Lalitavistara,
he is shown seated gazing steadily at the king of the trees. This is
indeed the result of the confusion made in the Lalitavistara, combining
the first week with the second.
58
Lalitavistara Sūtra, p. 559; Le Lalitavistara, p. 308.
59
This information is provided by Mitra, 2003, pp. 49-51.
60
Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19.
61
Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. c1.
Figure 7: Southern gateway (toraṇa) of the Great Sāñcī Stūpa.
With courtesy of the Archaeological Survey of India. Photograph O.B.
36 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
62
See the middle panel, Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 65. a2.
introduction 37
Figure 10: ‘Mucilinda, the Nāga king’ panel on the front face of east
pillar of the southern gateway of the Great Sāñcī Stūpa, drawing by F.O.
after Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. c1.
Mahāvagga, 4: “The Mucalinda, the serpent king, at the end of those seven
63
days, having known that the sky was clear and without a cloud, having unwound
his coils from the Lord’s body, having given up his own form and assumed a
youth’s form stood in front of the Lord honouring the Lord with joined palms.”
38 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Figure 11: ‘Mucilinda, the Nāga king’, panel on the inner face of the
north pillar of the west gateway of the Great Sāñcī Stūpa. With the
courtesy of the Archaeological Survey of India, Photograph O.B.
front of the Lord honouring the Lord with joined palms.” The panel
on the inner face of the north pillar of the west gateway (Fig. 11),64
Nāga Rājā is accompanied by his two queens, seated on stools with
lattice-work made of rattan, and an escort of nine nāgiṇīs, each with
a single cobra-hood behind the head, drinking, dancing and playing
music. On the top of the front face of the east pillar of the southern
gateway, we see Mucilinda, accompanied by his two queens, but each
64
See the middle panel, Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 65. a2.
introduction 39
65
On the panel on the inner face of the north pillar of the west gateway, both
queens are seated to the right of their husband.
66
Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. c3.
40 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Figure 13: ‘Jewelled House’ panel on west face of the east pillar,
drawing by F.O. after Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. D1.
67
Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. d1; Mitra, 2003, p. 40.
68
Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. d1; Mitra, 2003, p. 40.
69
Mahāvastu, p. 287.
introduction 41
70
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
71
Marshall and Foucher, 1949, vol. II, pl. 19. d3. The woman to the left,
according to these two authors, is Sujātā offering milk-rice to Bodhisattva
Siddhārtha who is represented by the throne placed under the Bodhi tree.
72
Mitra, 2003, p. 40. Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 19. d4) consider
this scene as an “ordinary stereotype of the Sambodhi”.
73
Mahāvastu, p. 269.
74
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
75
Marshall and Foucher, 1940, vol. II, pl. 34. a3) identify this as ‘the Great
Prodigy at Śrāvastī”. Mitra (2003, p. 40) as the ‘Arial promenade’.
76
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
77
This scene is identified by Marshall and Foucher (1940, vol. II, pl. 19. d1);
Mitra (2003, p. 40) as the Enlightenment of the Buddha Vipaśin.
42 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Figure 14: ‘Cloistered walk’, panel on the front face of the east pillar
of the north gateway of the Great Sāñcī Stūpa, with the courtesy
of the Archaeological Survey of India, Photograph by O.B.
are depicted in the panels of the Great Sāñcī Stūpa (Figs. 8-14). It
goes without saying, that when the Blessed One is not shown
anthropomorphically, it is especially difficult to depict in a theatrical
manner the first and the second weeks during which the Exalted One
regarded the Bodhi tree with an unblinking gaze. This obstacle was
easily overcome by the sculptors of the Nāgārjunakoṇḍa Stūpa by the
anthropomorphic image of the Buddha.
Nāgārjunako]n]da Stūpa
81
The Bodhi tree under which the Buddha is usually depicted seated is
mutilated.
82
The bad state of preservation makes it difficult to identify the arms or
symbols Māra holds in both hands.
83
See for example, Stone, 1994, nos. 193 and 203. As in Ganhāran art, both
the attack and the defeat of the Māra are often shown in the same panel in Andhra
School of Art.
84
O. Monod, 1966, p. 57, no. 7; and also C. Sivaramamurti, 1942, pl. 1X.
46 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
85
A.H. Longhurst, 1938, pl. XXII, b.
introduction 47
right hand corner, shows the Blessed One seated in samādhi, inside
the jewelled house, created by the devas, thus the fourth week.89 In
the top panel of the left frame, Mucilinda, the Nāga king with his
seven hoods protects the Exalted One, thus the fifth week according
to the Mahāvastu or in this context the sixth week according to the
Nidānakathā.90 As discussed earlier, the Nidānakathā states very
clearly, that the Buddha went in the fifth week, to the Shepherd’s
Nigrodha-tree: and sat there meditating on Doctrine, and experiencing
the happiness of deliverance.91 It is also at this moment that the three
daughters of Māra made another attempt to dissuade the Enlightened
One. However, as we shall see later, when depicting the seven weeks
after the Buddha’s sambodhi, Kandyian period painters follow the
order given in the Nidānakathā. If the relief from Kumbukwewa also
follows this sequence, the missing frame at the top of the panel, may
have represented the fifth week. Likewise, the scene at the top left
hand corner, represents the sixth week during which the Nāgarāja
protected the Blessed One from the heavy rain. Like the slab from
the Nāgārjunakoṇḍa Site that we have examined earlier (Fig. 15), the
Nāga is not coiled around the Blessed One, instead, the latter sits on
the coils of the former. Two Gods, probably Indra and Brahmā stand
on either side venerating the Buddha. As one would expect, the middle
panel of the left vertical frame, shows Trapuṣa and Bhallika offering
the refreshment of honey to the Exalted One, in consequence this is
the seventh week. The Buddha holds a bowl already offered by the
four Lokapālas standing behind the two merchants. With this panel
we have the complete set of seven weeks, making this sculpture the
most ancient document ever attested where the artist has favoured the
narration of seven weeks in Nidānakathā and the Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa.
92
Marie Gatellier (1991, vol. 1, pp. 182-4) has discussed some of these paint
ings in her book dedicated to Kandyan period mural paintings, but without analys
ing the relationship between the texts and visual art.
93
Bandaranayake, 1986, p. 117 and Gatellier, 1991, vol. 1, p. 68. All the seven
weeks are depicted from left to right in the same register, the last week continues
to the next wall.
94
Gatellier, 1991, vol. 1, pp. 77-8, vol. 2, Figs. 157, 159 & 160. The seven
weeks run from right to left in the same row, but first five weeks are in one wall
and the rest in the next.
95
Gatellier, 1991, vol. 1, pp. 82-6. The seven weeks are shown in two registers,
the above with first three weeks continue from left to right and the remaining
four weeks in the lower register from right to left.
50 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
96
Gatellier, 1983, for an exhaustive study of the paintings of Kelaniya Vihāra;
also see Gatellier, 1991, vol. 1, pp. 75-7, vol. 2, Fig. 156 and Jayasinghe, 2006,
p. 31. All the seven weeks are depicted in a single row from right to left.
97
Gatellier, 1991, vol. 1, pp. 82-6. The seven weeks are shown in two registers,
all the scenes run from left to right, the upper register depicting the first three
weeks. Every week is labelled in Sinhalese. The first scene on the far left corner
of the upper register has no relationship with the seven weeks.
98
The Blessed One is shown greeted by four gods whose divine nature is
indicated by a hallo.
99
See the paintings of the Medawala Tampita Vihāra, Hiṅdagala Vihāra and
Ridi Vihāra. Curiously, the artist of the Medawala Tampita Vihāra has taken the
liberty to show the Bodhi tree in a pot (Fig. 19).
100
See the paintings of the Kelaniya Vihāra and Mugirigala Vihāra.
101
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
Figure 18: ‘First Week’, Medawala Tampita Vihāra.With the courtesy
of the Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 25: Uḍa Vihāra in the Ridi Vihāra complex dated to the
eighteenth century. With the courtesy of the Department of
Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 26: ‘First five weeks’ Uḍa Vihāra in the Ridi Vihāra complex. With the courtesy of the
Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 27: ‘Sixth and Seventh weeks’ Uḍa Vihāra in the Ridi Vihāra complex. With the courtesy of the
Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 28: ‘Fifth Week: three daughters of Māra’, Uḍa Vihāra
in the Ridi Vihāra complex. With the courtesy of the
Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
102
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
103
Mahāvastu, p. 287.
104
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 201.
105
Ibid., p. 202.
106
Ibid., p. 204.
Figure 30: Hiṅdagala Vihāra probably built in 1775 by
Rajadi Rajasimha. With the courtesy of the
Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 33: ‘Sixth and seventh weeks’, Hiṅdagala Vihāra. With the
courtesy of the Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 34: Kelaniya Vihāra, mural paintings following the Kandyan style of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries.
With the courtesy of the Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
Figure 35: Mugirigala Vihāra, near Tangalla with early twentieth century paintings. With the courtesy of the
Department of Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph R.B.
62 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
snake-king is shown with a single huge head, over the house where
the Blessed One is seated in mediation (Fig. 27).107
As discussed earlier, according to the Nidānakathā, the two
merchants, Trapuṣa and Bhallika reached the Rajāyātana tree at the
end of the seventh week. The artist of the Kelaniya Vihāra alone is
content to show the Buddha seated in dhyāna mudra under the
Rajāyātana tree without the presence of the merchants (Fig. 34). The
artist of the Ridi Vihāra, on the contrary, gives a vivid picture of the
events taking place at the end of the seventh week (Fig. 29). Here, as
the two merchants approach the Blessed One with refreshments from
the left, four Lokapālas shown above emerging from the clouds each
holding an alms bowl. The four-armed Viṣṇu holding the śaṅkha and
a water pot, is a pure invention of the painter. In Mugirigala Vihāra,
the Blessed one is shown already holding a bowl, while three out of
the four Lokapālas appear on the top right hand corner of the image
(Fig. 35). The two merchants enter the scene from the right holding
rice cakes and honey to offer to the Buddha to break his fast. This
depiction follows the narration in the Chinese translation of Aśvaghoṣa’s
Buddhacarita according to which four kings offered their alms bowls,
before the arrival of the merchants.108 The seventh week in the
Medawala Tampita Vihāra depicts the Buddha seated under the
Rajāyātana tree in abhaya mudrā being approached by the two brothers
with refreshments (Fig. 24). In the Hiṅdagala Vihāra painting, Trapuṣa
and Bhallika are shown to the left and three out of four Lokapālas to
the right: two emerging from the clouds while the third in añjali
mudrā kneeling in front of the Buddha with an alms bowl already
placed on a stand (Fig. 33). Perhaps the most striking and vivid painting
of the seventh week is to be found in the Mahāraja Vihāra of the
Dambulla Raja Mahāvihāra in Dambulla (Fig. 36).109 The Buddha, in
dhyāna mudra is seated on a higher seat under the Rajāyātana tree,
while four Lokapālas, each holding a bowl, appear to the right and
the two merchants from Orissa are shown to the left. One holds a
bowl filled with refreshments while the other holds a reliquary stūpa
107
The absence of the Mucilinda-tree is noteworthy.
108
Buddhacarita, p. 105. 72.
109
Gatellier, 1991, vol. 2, p. 97, Fig. 162. The paintings of this cave were
ancient, but their present state goes back to the eighteenth century when they
were completely restored and repainted, see Bandaranayake, 1986, p. 154.
introduction 63
110
The presence of four-armed Brahmā holding a water pot, emerging from
the clouds above the two merchants is also to be noted.
111
Buddhist Birth Stories, p. 205.
64 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
112
See the studies of Stadtner (1991); Bautze-Picron (2003), Raymond (2010).
113
Stadtner, 2005, p. 12.
114
Gunawardana, 1979, pp. 271-7.
115
Gunawardana (1979, p. 272) here refers to the article by Duroiselle in the
Annual Reports of the Archaeological Survey of India, 1928-9, pp. 105-7).
116
For a depiction of the Buddha gazing at the Bodhi tree with unblinking
eyes during the second week from the Hapya-thon-zu (Bagan), see Bautze-Picron,
2003, pl. 36, p. 41; for an image of the Buddha walking up and down, in the
treasure-cloister during the third week from Tayok-pyi-hpaya-gyi (Bagan), see
see Bautze-Picron, 2003, pl. 37, p. 42; for a depiction of the Buddha seated in
the jewelled-house during the fourth week from Kubyauk-gyi, see Bautze-Picron,
2003, pl. 38, p. 42 and for an image of the Buddha protected by the Mucilinda
the Nāga king during the sixth week, see Bautze-Picron, 2003, pl. 40, p. 44.
117
Stadtner, 1991, pp. 39-52 and also in Buddhist Art of Myanmar, Fig. 26.
introduction 65
sequence from left to right, we see: Mucilinda the Nāga king (6th
week); the Buddha paying homage to the Bodhi-tree with unblinking
eyes (2nd week); the Buddha under the Ajapala Nigrodha tree (5th
week); the Enlightenment under the Bodhi tree (1st week); The Buddha
in the Jewelled house (4th week); the Buddha walking up and down
a long way or caṅkram (3rd week) and the Buddha under the
Rājāyatana tree (7th week). This plaque is dated to the eleventh and
twelfth centuries and this was precicely the period when Myanmar
was in close relationship with Sri Lanka.
Among many paintings in Bagan, we may draw the attention of
the reader to the paintings of the deep chamber in the East corridor
of the Sulamani Temple which was built in 1183, and it is considered
as an important landmark in Bagan’s architecture (Fig. 37). However,
the paintings depicting the seven weeks are dated the eighteenth
century based on the inscription in the north entrance hall dated to
1779. It is also important to underline here that the deep chamber
with the paintings originally faced the main entrance of the shrine.118
The seated Buddha in the bhūmisparśa mudrā symbolizes the
Figure 37: Sulamani Temple in Bagan, Myanmar built 1183. With the
courtesy of the Department of Archaeology, Myanmar. Photograph O.B.
118
Stadtner, 2005, p. 256.
66 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Enlightenment and the first week the Blessed One spent under the
Bodhi tree (Fig. 38). On either side of the main image, the right and
left walls bear the images of the six other weeks. The narration begins
on the right wall; reading from right to left, the second week is
illustrated by the Buddha in front of the bodhimaṇḍa (Fig. 39). The
Buddha then walks in the cloistered path, thus evoking the third week
(Fig. 39). Following the narration of the Nidānakathā, the Tathāgata
is shown seated inside the jewelled house created by the gods (Fig.
39). As the Pāli text tells us the Blessed One went, in the fifth week,
to the Shepherd’s Nigrodha tree: and sat there meditating on Doctrine.
This week is clearly depicted on the left wall (Figs. 40 and 41). Under
the seated Buddha, goats are shown playing, indicating it is indeed
the Goatherd’s Banyan tree (Fig. 41). The three daughters of Māra
are not depicted, however, in this scene in Burma. They begin to
appear in some Bagan paintings as early as the eleventh century.119
Brahmā, identified in the Burmese inscription below the divinity, as
‘Thahanpati’ in another words ‘Brahmā Sahampathi’ is quite
exceptional.120 While examining the paintings of the Medawala
Tampita Vihāra, we have observed that Brahmā makes a sudden
appearance during the fourth week (Fig. 21). We know it was only
quite a long time after the events related to Trapuṣa and Bhallika,
when the Buddha had decided not to preach to the humans that Indra
and Brahmā intervened begging the Blessed One to reconsider his
decision. The Chinese version of the Buddhacarita reduces the seven
weeks to one: “The Buddha meditated seven days, and his mind was
pure. He observed the bodhi tree, gazing without blinking.” Then
Brahmā intervened to persuade the Buddha to teach so as to rescue
the suffering beings. The Buddha was pleased in his heart at Brahmā’s
invitation and expresses his intention to expound the Law. The presence
of Brahmā during the fourth week in the Medawala Tampita Vihāra
painting (Fig. 21) or in the fifth week at the East corridor of the
Sulamani shrine painting (Fig. 41) has no relevance with any of the
Buddhist texts. In both occasions, we believe, Brahmā appears out of
119
For an interesting survey on over all depictions of the three daughters, see
Stadtner, 2015.
120
Stadtner, 2005, pp. 256 and 259. It is difficult to accept the hypothesis put
forward by Stadtner (2005, p. 256) according to which Brahmā is depicted here
appealing to the Buddha to preach.
Figure 38: Deep chamber at the East corridor, Sulamani Temple in
Bagan, Myanmar. Photograph O.B.
Figure 39: Right wall with the paintings of the second, third and fourth weeks,
deep chamber at the East corridor, Sulamani Temple in Bagan,
Myanmar. Photograph O.B.
Figure 40: Left wall with the paintings of the fifth, sixth and
seventh weeks, deep chamber at the East corridor,
Sulamani Temple in Bagan, Myanmar. Photograph O.B.
Figure 41: Left wall with the paintings of the fifth and sixth weeks,
deep chamber at the East corridor, Sulamani Temple in
Bagan, Myanmar. Photograph O.B.
introduction 69
Figure 42: Left wall with the painting of the seventh week,
deep chamber at the East corridor, Sulamani Temple in Bagan,
Myanmar. Photograph O.B.
context. Mucilinda who protects the Buddha from the heavy rain was
very popular in Southeast Asia, and the depiction of the snake-king
in the next painting is quite exquisite (Fig. 41). It is not necessary to
emphasize that in this series of paintings, the episode of Mucilinda
corresponds to the sixth week narrated in the Pāli tradition, but certainly
not the fifth week of the Sanskrit accounts. Finally, as in the Kandyan
paitings, the seventh week is characterized by the presence of the two
merchant brothers offering refreshments and four World Guardians
proposing alms bowls to the Blessed One (Fig. 42). The continuation
of the story is then depicted by the seated Buddha eating the food
offered by Trapuṣa and Bhallika. We thus have a complete set of
episodes related to the narration of the Nidānakathā revealing it was
the Pāli tradition which was in vogue in Burma.121
Apart from Bagan, seven weeks following the enlightenment of the Buddha
121
were amply depicted on the murals of Powin Taung caves of the Nyaungyan
(1599-1752) and early Konbaung (eighteenth century) periods. See Munier and
Aung, 2007, pp. 15, 77-8. See the illustrations in the book: cave 111, pl. 40 from
the fifth to the seventh weeks; cave 473, pl. 79, all the seven weeks; cave 585,
pl. 85, from the second to the seventh weeks; temple A, pl. 152, pp. 77-8, all the
70 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
Conclusions
seven weeks; cave 93, pls. 234, 236, p. 151, all the seven weeks; cave 462, pls.
334-6, pp. 269-71, all the seven weeks; cave 472, pl. 347, p. 472, from the third
to the seventh weeks; cave 568, pls. 385-6, p. 568, all the seven weeks. Needless
to say all these paintings follow the narration of the Nidānakathā.
122
Mahāvaṃsa, p. 208, XXX, 78: “The events during the seven weeks he
commanded them to depict duly here and there in the relic chamber.…”
introduction 71
Figure 43: ‘The Buddha under the Bodhi tree’, painting from the relic
chamber, Mahiyangana Stūpa. With the courtesy of the Department of
Archaeology, Sri Lanka. Photograph O.B.
underline once again that in almost all the paintings of the Kandyan
period in Sri Lanka that we have examined, and many others which
were not discussed in the present study, the seven weeks are depicted
according to the chronological order given in the Nidānakathā.
The relief from Kumbukwewa that we date to the fourth century
ce, because of its closeness to the later Nāgārjunakoṇḍa style, was no
doubt one of the earliest documents which existed at least thirteen
centuries prior to the Kandyan paintings. This means that the tradition
of painting the seven weeks inside relic chambers was in vogue around
the fourth and fifth centuries as mentioned in the Pāli chronicles.
Unfortunately, only two painted relic chambers have been found so
far in Sri Lanka: one in the Mahā Seya at Mihintale and the other in
the Mahiyangana Stūpa at Mahiyangana. The paintings of the Mahā
Seya at Mihintale which could be dated to the fifth or sixth century ce
depict gods and apsararas venerating the relics.123 Many fragmentary
paintings of the Mahiyangana Stūpa relic chamber are usually dated
123
Paranavitana, 1971, no 105.
72 Seven Weeks after the Buddha’s Enlightenment
124
Paranavitana, 1971, nos 108-10. The Buddha seated venerated by gods,
among which, the presence of Brahmā holding the kamaṇḍalu, Viṣṇu, the śaṅkha
and Śiva, the triśūla is to be noted, since the Polonnaruwa period is characterized
by the impact of Hinduism over Buddhism.
125
This is also the opinion of Bandaranayake, 1986, p. 62.
Bibliography
Literary Sources
Life of the Buddha = Life of the Buddha by Aśvaghoṣa, translated by Patrick
Olivelle (New York University Press, New York, 2009).
Buddhacarita = Buddhacarita. In Praise of Buddha’s Acts, translated from Chinese
Charles Willemen (Berkeley, Numata Centre for Buddhist Translation and
Research, 2009).
Dhammapada = The Dhammapada. A Collection of Verses. Being One of the
Canonical Books of the Buddhists, translated by F.M. Müller, Oxford
University Press, Oxford, 1881, rpt. 1988.
Lalitavistara = Le Lalitavistara. L’histoire traditionnelle de la vie du Bouddha
Cakyamuni, translated by P.E. de Foucaux (Paris, Les Deux Océans, 1884).
Lalitavistara Sūtra = The Lalitavistara Sūtra. The Voice of the Buddha. The
beauty of Compassion, translated from the French G. Bays (Berkeley, Dharma
Publishing, 1983).
Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa = The Mahābodhi-Vaṁsa, edited by S. Arthur Strong (London,
Pali Text Society, Oxford University Press, 1891).
Mahāvagga = The Mahāvagga (Vinaya-Piṭaka), translated by I.B. Horner,
(Lancaster, The Pali Text Society, 1951, rpt. 2007).
Mahāvaṃsa = The Mahāvaṃsa or, The Great Chronicle of Ceylon, translated by
Wilhelm Geiger (London, Pali Text Society, 1912).
Mahāvastu = The Mahāvastu, translated by J.J. Jones (Lancaster, The Pali Text
Society, 1949, rpt. 2007).
Buddhist Birth Stories = Buddhist Birth Stories (Jataka Tales). The Commentarial
Introductions Entitled Nidanā-Kathā. The Story of the Lineage, translated by
Rhys Davids, new and revised edition by C.A.F. Rhys Davids (London,
George Routledge and Sons Ltd., 1880).
Exhibition Catalogues
Buddhist Heritage of Pakistan = Gandhara – The Buddhist Heritage of Pakistan.
Legends, Monasteries, and Paradise, Kust und Ausstelungshalle der
Budesrepublik Deutschland, Bonn, Berlin, Zürich, 2009/10.
Buddhist Art of Myanmar = Buddhist Art of Myanmar, edited by Sylvia Fraser-Lu
and Doland Stadtner, Asia Society Museum, Yale University Press, New
Haven and London, 2015.
74 bibliography
Secondary Sources
Bautze-Picron, Claudine (2003), The Buddhist Murals of Pagan: Timeless Vistas
of the Cosmos, Weatherhill, Trumbull.
Bandaranayake, Senake (1986), The Rock and Wall Paintings of Sri Lanka, Lake
House Bookshop, Colombo.
Bareau, André (1963), Recherches sur la biographie du Buddha dans les
Sūtrapiṭaka et les Vinayapiṭaka anciens : de la quête de l’éveil à la conversion
de Śāriputra et de Maudgayāna, Le Bulletin de l’École française d’Extrême-
Orient, vol. LII, Paris.
Bopearachchi, Osmund (2008a), “Sculptures of Amaravati Tradition in Sri Lanka”,
Journal of the Asiatic Society, pp. 1-26.
——— (2008b), Tamil Traders in Sri Lanka and Sinhalese Traders in Tamil
Nadu, International Centre for Ethnic Studies, Colombo.
——— (2008c), “Les premiers souverains kouchans : Chronologie et iconographie
monétaire”, Jounal des Savants, January-June, pp. 3-56.
——— (2012), “Andhra-Tamilnadu and Sri Lanka: Early Buddhist Sculptures
of Sri Lanka”, in New Dimensions of Tamil Epigraphy, edited by A.
Murugaiyan, Cre-A, pp. 49-68.
——— (2015), From Bactria to Taprobane: Selected Works of Osmund
Bopearachchi, vol. I: Central Asian and Indian Numismatics; vol. II: Art
History and Maritime Trade, Manohar, New Delhi.
Bopearachchi, Osmund, Senarath Disanayaka and Nimal Perera (2016), “The
Oldest Shipwreck in the Indian Ocean”, in Ports of the Ancient Indian Ocean,
edited by Marie-Françoise Boussac, Jean-François Salles, Jean-Baptiste Yon,
Primus Books, Delhi, pp. 411-34.
Gatellier, Marie (1991), Peintures murales du Sri Lanka, école Kandyenne XVIIIe-
XIXe siècles, 2 vols, Paris, EFEO.
Gatellier, Marie (1983), “Les peintures du temple de Kelaniya à Sri Lanka”, Arts
Asiatiques, XXXVIII, pp. 49-70.
Gunawardane, R.A.L.H. (1979), Robe and Plough. Monasticism and Economic
Interest in Early Medieval Sri Lanka, University of Arizona Press, Tucson.
Granoff, Phyllis (2005), “The Gift of the Two Merchants: Defining the Buddhist
Community through Story”, East and West, vol. 55, pp. 129-38.
Hackin, Joseph, Jean Carl & Jacques Meunié (1959), Diverses recherches
archéologiques en Afghnaistan (1933-1940), MDAFA, VIII, Paris.
Ingholt, Harold (1957), Gandhāran Art in Pakistan, Pantheon Books, New York.
Jayasinghe, Gamini (2006), The Glory of Kelaniya Murals, Uni Graphics,
Colombo.
Kurita, Isao (2003), Gandhāran Art, vol. I: The Buddha’s Life Story, vol. II: The
World of the Buddha, 1st edn. 1988-90, revd. and enlgd. edn. 2003, Nigensha,
Tokyo.
Longhurst, Albert Henry (1938), The Buddhist Antiquities of Nāgārjunakoṇḍa,
bibliography 75