Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Benchimarking Study of Ginning Factory' Edited
Benchimarking Study of Ginning Factory' Edited
DEVELOPMENT INSTITUTE
Addis Ababa
Jan – 2015
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
List of Tables....................................................................................................................................................2
Executive Summary .........................................................................................................................................3
I. Introduction ...........................................................................................................................................5
II. Methodology .........................................................................................................................................7
III. Objective............................................................................................................................................7
IV. The Scope of the Study ......................................................................................................................8
CHAPTER ONE .............................................................................................................................................8
1. Overview of Ethiopian Ginning sub sector ....................................................................................8
1.1. History of ginning factory in Ethiopia ............................................................................................8
2. Installed Capacity ..........................................................................................................................9
3. Production Capacity ......................................................................................................................9
4. Raw Material Supply................................................................................................................... 10
5. Geographical location................................................................................................................. 10
CHAPTER TWO.............................................................................................................................................. 11
2. Benchmarking the Competitiveness of the Ginning Industry..................................................... 11
2.1. Technology Type and Status ....................................................................................................... 11
2.2. Infrastructural layout.................................................................................................................. 14
2.3. Production and Productivity ....................................................................................................... 15
2.3.1. Ginning Out Turn (GOT) .................................................................................................... 16
2.3.2. Cotton seed /oil .................................................................................................................. 16
2.4. Seed and lint cotton quality management ................................................................................. 17
2.4.1. Major causes of quality deterioration ........................................................................................ 17
2.4.2. Access to cotton testing lab ........................................................................................................ 19
2.5. Maintenance............................................................................................................................... 20
2.6. Labor productivity and Skill ........................................................................................................ 20
2.7. Waste management ................................................................................................................... 21
CHAPTER THREE...................................................................................................................................... 21
3. Issues and Challenges of ginning industry ................................................................................. 21
4. Conclusion and Recommendation.................................................................................................0
4.1. Conclusion .................................................................................................................................0
4.2. Recommendation ......................................................................................................................0
1
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
List of Tables
Table: - 1 the region wise distributions of ginning units
Table:-3 the production capacity of Ethiopian ginning industries one bale average wt. = 227
kg
Table -4 the annual production of raw cotton and ginning capacity utilization
Table:-5 Geographical location of cotton Ginning
Table: -10 Quality checking practice of ginning factory compared with standard practice
Table: - 12 Detail of Benchmarking standards, gap identified and comments to fulfill the
gaps regarding Quality parameters of cotton, Ginning Production, maintenance, and it’s
Human Resource
Table 13: - Detail comments to fulfill the gaps against the standards
2
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Executive Summary
Ginning factories are placed at pivotal position in the cotton value chain. They are the major
clients of the cotton growers and provide raw material to the textile and clothing industry and
the oil mills, so thousands of people in Ethiopia have their source of revenue dependent upon
performance of this sector. However, this sector has tremendous potential for improvement
and value enhancement as the ginning factories lack trained staff, poor infrastructure and
continue to use outdated technology. Improvement in the knowledge and skills of the people
associated with the ginning sector will not only benefit the sector, but will also create value
enhancement in both forward and backward linkages.
Keeping in view the importance of the ginning sector, in the cotton value chain, a study was
conducted with the objective of determining gaps in quality, production, Maintenance,
techniques, skill of man power and work methods against the international standards within
the ginning sub-sector. This study found several issues related with determined gaps of
quality parameter of seed cotton, production, maintenance, work methods of the ginners.
Most of the ginners faced shortage of seed cotton, obsolete technology (cost of production
and maintenance increase, quality of lint and seed deteriorate, working condition harsh etc),
spare parts and power interruption as the top most problem.
The ginners pointed out that seed cotton usually contained high concentration of trash and
other contaminant. Contamination of cotton has adversely affected the performance of higher
value added sectors along the cotton value chain, more particularly the export of cotton
products. Local buyer acting as agent of middleman purchased cotton from different farmers
and mix this different varieties and transports to ginning factories which have high
contribution in quality problems. In most ginning factories, seed cotton is stocked in open
places where it is fully exposed to sun light, dust, dew and other contaminations till ginned.
The seed cotton produced was also usually packed in jute/polypropylene bags and
transported to the ginning factories through open trucks. These jute/polypropylene bags are
used more than two years and proved that it is the source of contamination in the lint cotton.
Furthermore, small scale farmers did not bother to keep cotton of different varieties
separately, eventually; individualistic characteristics of different cotton varieties are lost.
Thus farmers need proper skills in picking, stocking, packing and transporting cotton and
3
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
ginning factories need proper storage, feeding, processing of seed cotton, packing and
transporting. According to survey most of ginning factories were stop their post cleaner to
increase their ginning out turn (GOT) which is wrong practice. There is no any recorded data
of GOT, lint loss and trash value of cotton occurs during the process of ginning. However,
the ginners orally told us that their GOT is 37%, 38% and 39% and trash from 5-12% and
invisible loss is not known. There was no evidence of any study on the productivity of human
resource in the ginning sector of Ethiopia. Low productivity was attributed to lack of skills,
knowledge and attitude of the workers. Secondly, the culture of management was also
responsible for this phenomenon.
In the study, the identified major problems related with their production chain are: - the
quality of cotton (As discussed earlier, cotton contains high amount of trashes and dust), lack
of spare parts (saw- gin saws), lack of skilled manpower and no accurate practice of technical
and production data recording, shortage of seed cotton that makes them idle, lack of
programmed maintenance, using outdated Technology and poor work practice, poor bale
management and packing system and infrastructural layout. Problem of the quality of cotton
was attributed to the poor knowledge, skills and attitudes of the farmers, traders and ginners.
Lack of skills of the labour, programmed maintenance and recorded data were due to the
non-availability of any proper arrangements for their training schedule and lack of skill
respectively. The problem of lack of spare parts inside country is due to obsolete
technologies of the existing machineries.
Value addition at the ginning stage will not only lead to improvement in the livelihood of all
those who are associated with ginning industry, but will also have yield benefits in both
forward and backward linkages. Improvement in quality of the lint cotton would mean
provision of higher quality raw material to the textile and clothing industry, which will
translate into increasing competitiveness of the higher value added textile and clothing
products. As a result, the industry will create more job opportunities and higher income for
those associated with industry. But the market does not give premium price for good quality
cotton, so the farmers, merchants and ginners do not afford additional cost for improving
quality.
Ginning sector improvement in term of skill and technology can create improvement of lint
cotton quality and cotton products, job opportunities, and offer active involvement of cotton
4
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
producers. The aim of the study is to determine gaps including production management,
maintenance management, quality management, human resources management and
infrastructure layout of ginning factories in Ethiopia.
I. Introduction
Ethiopia has a long history of traditional cottage textile industry. Traditionally yarn from
cotton fiber supplied by small hold cotton farmers is home spun using age old spinning drop
wheel. The yarn is then converted into fabrics using handlooms. This traditional cottage
industry continues to grow even today’s making an important contribution to satisfying
people’s requirement for textile and providing large scale employment to rural and urban
households. The introduction of modern integrated textile mills in Ethiopia is a recent
phenomenon initiated by Italian during the Second World War. Dire Dawa Textile Mill was
the first integrated textile mill established by foreign capital in 1930 E.C. This has marked
the starting point of textile sub-sector in Ethiopia. During 1960’s 5 large- scale integrated
textile enterprises were established mainly by private capital. The socialist regime, which
reigned from 1974 to 1991, nationalized private textile and apparel firms and at the same
time established 4 more integrated textile mills (Awasa, Kombolcha, Arbaminch and Adey
Abeba) to expand the sector to satisfy the domestic demand for regular textile and
substituting imported products.
On the pace of these textile factories, the first ginning factory, Tendaho, was established in
1953 E.c at Afar region to provide lint cotton and during 1960’s five ginning factories
(Abacot, Ediget, Yerekesem, Shewa and Gonder) were installed. At the end of 1970’s and
beginning of 1980’s the ginning factories established in Addis Ababa (especially from
Yerekesem and Abacot) were taken to cotton farming areas such as Middle Awash,
Arbaminch, and Abobo. Eventually, due to lack of support and outdated technology the
sector gradually became out of competition and could not meet international market
standards. As the result, the cotton farming, ginning, textile and apparel sectors were
producing below capacity.
5
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
However, in recent few years, since the formulation of the Industry development strategy has
been developed by the Democratic republic of Ethiopian, priority is given to the sector. In
such a case the Ethiopian Textile Industry Development Institute (ETIDI) was established to
give direct support for the sectors. At the same time the foreign currency obtained from the
sector is planned to increase from 23 million USD to 1 billion USD in a growth and
transformation plan (GTP) (2003-2007 E.C) period. The number of ginning factories was
increased from 11 to 21 which have the installed capacity of 1284 ton lint cotton production
per day of which only 49 % of it is achieved. Among these factories 35% were installed
around cotton framings and 65% are in remote areas from farming. To expand and facilitate
the rapid growth of ginning and textile sector the production of domestic cotton as an input is
very essential. For this around 3 million hectare of the potential areas which are suitable for
the production of cotton is identified region wise in the Country. However, from the potential
areas maximum 112 000 hectare is cultivated and 79,000 ton lint cotton was produced in
2003/2004 E.C. This indicates that there is still much work remains on development of
cotton, ginning as well as textile sector to achieve the agricultural led industrial development
principle. In the value chain, increasing of cotton production directly has an effect on
increasing either the number of ginning factories or effectively and efficiently using the
existing once is the most important.
Therefore performance of the textile sector will determine the demand for ginning factories’
lint cotton. The ginning is an important transfer point in the cotton value chain. After picking
of seed cotton by the farmers, it is transported directly or indirectly to the ginning factories
for further processing. Therefore ginning sector acts as bridge between the farmer field and
textile industry. Ginning stage of cotton plays a significant role in determining the quality of
raw material for textile and clothing industry. Process of ginning converts cotton into cotton
lint and seed. Ginning is a seasonal industry like sugar, operating during only certain period
in a year. Ginning process often are also combined with pressing units i.e. pressing cotton
fibers and making a 'bale' ready for transportation to cotton textile industries. There are eight
major cotton growing regions from which the seed cotton is transported to ginning factories
in Ethiopia e.g., Afar, Tigiray, Amahara, SNNPR, Gambella, Benshangul, Oromia and
Somalia.
6
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Therefore, this study report consists of three chapters of which chapter one deals about
overview of the Ethiopian ginning factories, chapter two states about the benchmark
competitiveness of ginning factories in Ethiopia and chapter three about the Issues,
challenges and finally includes the conclusion and recommendation.
II. Methodology
At the first stage, Term of reference including detail check list of benchmark standards’, and
structured questionnaire were prepared to collect data from 13 selected ginning factories.
Based upon designed and pre-tested term of reference and questionnaire data, three experts
were engaged in the study. Therefore primary and secondary data were collected from each
factory through observation, interview and questionnaires’. These data were analyzed against
the benchmark standards to identify the gaps and give the final conclusion and
recommendation.
III. Objective
7
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
CHAPTER ONE
As mentioned in the introduction, the ginning sector existed in Ethiopia during the regime of
emperor H/Silassie starting from 1950’s and at the beginning of 1960’s before that the
traditional separation of seed from lint was done manually. Thus, on the pace of the gradually
establishment of textile industries, cotton ginning industries were established in the country.
In such a way that the first cotton ginning factory, Tendaho, that has 8 gins stands was
established in 1953 E.C. in Afar region, which is today closed. This enterprise was
established to provide lint cotton for Dire Dawa Textile factory. During 1960’s other cotton
ginning factories in Addis Ababa (especially Abacot, Yerekesem, Shewa and Ediget) and in
Amahara region at Gonder Town, Gonder ginning factory were established.
It would be advisable to install the ginning machine at the neighborhood of cotton farms, for
this case, at the end of 1970’s and beginning of 1980’s the ginning factories established in
Addis Ababa (Yerekesem and Abacot) were taken to cotton farming areas such as Middle
Awash, Arbaminch, and Abobo. Later, since the articulated Industrial development strategy
has given priority to the cotton and textile sectors some of the existing outdated ginning
technologies were gradually replaced to increase their production capacity and other modern
technology (3 double roller ginning factories and 10 modern high capacity saw gin) were
established. Therefore, in fact the number of gins operating in Ethiopian has increased from,
8
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
5 in 1982, to 21 in 2007 E.C. and the installed lint production capacity increased from 282
bales to 5656 bales per day.
2. Installed Capacity
Installed capacity is the capacity of the ginning machines that the manufacturer has designed
for production. Therefore the designed seed cotton production capacity of all factories has
been shown as below. But the existing ginning factories are not even using more than 50% of
this capacity due to four major problems such as difficult of obtaining spare part, seed cotton
shortage, working methods and 86 % are old aged technology.
3. Production Capacity
Lint Cotton is a major input for the textile industry. The demand for the product is therefore
derived from the demand for textile products. Thus, Cotton ginning is the process of
separating cotton seed from the lint so that the lint will be baled and goes to textile industries
for further processing whereas the cotton seed is milled by oil mills to produce edible oil and
also used for further seed preparation. Cotton ginning, therefore, requires the unprocessed
raw cotton, and then is applied on the cotton ginner in order to produce baled cotton and
cottonseed. During the survey time only three ginning factories are running and other are
stopped due to shortage of seed cotton. And the yearly production capacity of the factories
are depends on the availability of cotton production in the country i.e. when the production of
cotton is high the factories use their maximum capacity to gin it and would be idle when no
cotton production or less production.
9
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Table :-3 The production capacity of Ethiopian ginning industries one bale average
wt. = 227 kg
Number of bale can Current Number of bale
Number and type of be produced at can be produced in kg per
S/n
Ginning factories Installed production day
capacity in kg per day
1 Saw ginning 4525 2016
2 Roller ginning 1131 504
The capacity utilization difference from year to year is due to raw material production
difference, three ginning factories out of function and some new ginning are added to the
sector.
5. Geographical location
In terms of geographical location, the ginning mills are spread over seven regions in the
country as shown below. The geographical distribution of ginning factories is not economical
especially factories that are far away from farm areas exposes the cotton producers for extra
transport cost.
10
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
* Ginneries located at Addis Ababa and Oromia region are not strategically near to the cotton
farming areas where as the ginneries located in the other regions are relatively in strategic area
to the cotton farms.
CHAPTER TWO
11
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
In Ethiopia both saw and roller ginning Technology systems are present. The Saw gins which
are available in the county are old technology and less productive as compared to latest
technology saw gin and the number of gin stands in a factory is from one to maximum four
which are not economical. The number of roller gin is relatively better in number which is
from 18 to 80 double rollers. Out of these two types of technologies, 86 % (18) of the
industries are saw type and the remaining 14% (3) is roller ginning technology industry
(second handle machineries). The detail type of technology is show in table below.
12
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Gins typically use two types of lint cleaners, air jet and saw. The air-jet lint cleaners are
directly behind the gin stand and use centrifugal force to remove trash from the lint as it
makes a sharp turn in the duct work. Most of the Ethiopian lint cleaners are saw type. In saw
type lint cleaner, a condenser removes the fiber from the conveying air stream and forms it
into a batt. The batt is fed to a saw cylinder which normally rotates at approximately 1,000
revolutions per minute. The saws carry cotton over grid bars, which, aided by centrifugal
13
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
force, remove immature seeds (motes) and foreign matter. The cleaned lint is removed from
the saw by a rotating brush which also provides air to convey it to the next machine. The
importance of Lint cleaners is to improve the grade of cotton by removing foreign matter if
the cotton has the necessary color and preparation characteristics. Lint cleaners may also
blend light spotted cotton so that it becomes a white grade. These lint cleaners are by-passed
in most ginning factories in the country.
In all ginning factors of Ethiopia the feeding system is manual. In feeding room workers are
assigned to feed the seed cotton but not for contaminant sorting. The feeding system are
through pipe or holes underground.
In most of the cotton Ginning Factories in in Ethiopia, the cotton is stored in open area with
surroundings full of dust and other contaminants such as dry leaf bits, plastic materials and
other materials thrown up by human beings or blown by winds. The storage should be done
in fully covered concrete godowns having neat and clean surroundings. Else Addis have
since realized the need for making covered paved warehouses which will save cotton from
contaminations rains and dew etc.
At present majority of the cotton Ginning Factories are handling raw cotton as well as lint
cotton and cotton seeds manually. The clean conditions in the Ginning Factories haven much
to be desired, the cleaning of gin house is not done properly, dirty cotton lint, oil and grease
stains, nut bolts, metal pieces, broken wooden pieces, broom pieces, wire, raw cotton and
seed entangled in gin or other places etc. find its way to lint. The majority of the Ginning
Factories are not having efficient / adequate supervision which leads to negligence or
carelessness on the part of the laborers working in Ginning & Pressing. Factories and
consequential increase in the presence of foreign materials such as human hair, cloth pieces,
jute threads, wood pieces, pieces of cigarettes, tobacco pouches, dusts and stone extra
14
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Some factories have no cyclone due to these absence the waste generated from the factories
disturb the surroundings.
Table: - 8 The Existing situation of ginning factories’ Infrastructures verses the standards
s.no Ginnery name Feeding Seed store Gin house Bale store Cotton Cyclone
room house seed store
good poor good poor good poor good poor good poor good poor
1 Omo valley
2 Haji Turie
3 Geberselam
4 Dorry(Lucy)
5 Agricot
6 Studio 3D
7 Else Addis
8 Awash(Mohammed
Amiru)
9 Lucy international
10 Middle awash
11 Haji Nur Hussein
12 Des
13 Loyal tiret
% 92 8 31 69 38 62 38 62 31 69 23 77
15
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Production of cotton requires several inputs like land, labour, seed, water, fertilizer,
pesticides, finances, etc. Second transfer point in the cotton value chain is the ginning.
2.3.1. Ginning Out Turn (GOT)
Ginning out-turn is a useful indicator of the performance of ginning factories. It can be
described as the percentage of lint obtained from seed cotton. Ginning factories with high
ginning out-turn values are preferable; because they yield more lint thus most of the ginning
factories in the country are not using lint cleaner to increase or maintain their GOT which is
bad practice. And most of them have no systematic recorded ginning out turn whereas the
average ginning out turn of the country is estimated to 37%.
2.3.2. Cotton seed /oil
The cotton seed share in ginning mill is 2/3 of the seed cotton. Most of the ginning factories
or the seed cotton owners sell the cotton seed to Oil mills but only two factories Middle
awash which have delinter machine and Hiwot with sulphuric acid to prepare seed for
plantation.
The trash percentage is ranges from 5% to 12% which is at higher side.
16
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Quality Cotton is the best raw material that has cleanliness and meets the needs and
expectations of customers (Textile industries and End-users). It is Fitness for Use or Fitness
for purpose or user based or Customer satisfaction or Meeting specification.
The quality of cotton fiber depends upon a variety of factors ranging from seeds and sowing
season to picking and other agro-climatic conditions of growth, in addition to post harvest
technology employed. The work practices at ginning, storage and transportation before and
after ginning also influence the quality of cotton. Hence the quality of bale cotton is not the
same even if the variety is same.
The existing ginning factory quality management system is poor and almost all ginning
factories are not performing auditing of cotton quality before and after ginning. The workers
of the ginning factory have low awareness about quality of cotton and even some of the
workers have good awareness about quality they don’t care about quality because the market
does not give premium for better quality.
In the existing situation harvesting method, packing method, grade mixing, storage,
transportation and ginning practice attribute quality deterioration.
Ginning is handled differently in different parts of the world. In places like the United States,
the cotton remains the property of the farmer unless it is purchased by a merchant, most
ginners usually playing the role of service provider. However, in countries like India and
Pakistan, ginning is an operational industry known for its production and employment role in
17
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
the agro-sector of the country’s economy. In Ethiopian, where most of ginneries are owned
by private and provide service, so many ginners prefer to focus on higher
quantities/production/ rather than better quality. Generally, profit maximization leads to less
concern about quality, depending on market behavior.
Seed cotton packaging: - All farmers, merchants and even ginneries have their own farm
uses jute and pp. bags for transporting seed cotton to ginning factories which has high
contribution for contamination of lint cotton.
Lot mixing: - cotton merchants buy seed cotton from different farmers and process
cottons having different quality (seed cotton with different color, fineness and staple
length) together which leads to poor quality.
Seed cotton transportation to ginneries:-During transporting of seed cotton bags are not
properly packed and most trucks are opened (not covered). In this situation seed cotton
dropped on the road and dust and smokes of the truck are deteriorate color and grade of
the cotton by increasing its trash content.
Storage and bale packing: - Most of the ginning factories have no adequate storage and
even some has enough storage which is not clean and the floor is not cemented. In most
ginning factories, the seed cotton is accumulated outside in soil, uncovered and dusty
ground in which dusts and contaminants are simply mixed with seed cotton and also
colors of cotton is deteriorated due to moisture in air and sunlight.
Ginning practice: -
A). Most of the ginning machineries are very old and most of them are not containing
the essential machineries such as, lint cleaner, dryer and moisturizer. Important quality
parameters (staple length and strength) of cotton are damaged and impossible to
produce clean and good quality lint cotton.
B). There is lack of skilled man power and workers of the factory are not conscious of
the quality of cotton.
C). the market does not give premium price for good quality cotton, so the merchants
and farmers does not afford additional ginning cost for improving quality of lint cotton.
Best Practices to bridge the gaps
18
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Seed cotton packing:- Jute and pp. bag should not be used for packaging of seed cotton
because if a thread of jute or pp. bag is mixed with seed cotton it will multiplied on ginning
process and make a difficulty during spinning process and affect end product quality. So the
seed cotton should packed by cotton made bags.
Lot mixing: - To avoid grade/lot mixing awareness should be created to merchants and
farmers about categorizing of cotton in lots through workshops, trainings and other
mechanisms by concerned body.
Seed cotton transportation to ginneries: - seed cotton should be transported with covered
and clean truck and also the bags should be properly packed.
Storage: - The seed cotton should be stored in cemented, covered & clean floor and
conditioned, so all factories should have cemented, clean and adequately conditioned store.
Ginning practice: - The old parts of the ginning machineries retooled or changed and the
necessary machineries such as, lint cleaner, dryer and moisturizer should be full field to
perform the ginning process without damaging the important parameters of the lint cotton.
The market should give premium for good quality cotton and price should be based on
quality, so that all the stack holders (Farmers and Ginneries) will conscious about cotton
quality.
2.4.2. Access to cotton testing lab
Except 15.4% (Omo valley and Middle Awash) the remaining 84.6% of the factories have no
testing lab rooms and equipment. Even those who have labs are not equipped with necessary
instruments only they have fineness tester, moisture tester and color board.
Table: 9 Access to cotton testing lab
19
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Table: -10 Quality checking practice of ginning factory compared with standard practice
Factory 2.5 % Fineness Matu Moisture Trash Color Neps GOT Seed % Contam
S.L
rity content (%) / gm (%) ination
(%)
2.5. Maintenance
The ginning factories under this investigation have no scheduled maintenance program
except the routine cleaning shift wise during processing and overhauling of off- season
maintenance schedule and all of them only performs on consumable preventive maintenance
such as greasing, oiling and belt change. Since there is no saw grinding machine in all
ginneries, the ginning saws are not reused. These indicate that there is less maintenance skill
in performing preventive and scheduled program which needs to be improved. The factories
should have workshop, spare parts stock management, scheduled maintenance program and
maintenance audit to have health machinery operation and to produce quality lint cotton.
2.6. Labor productivity and Skill
The major problem of all ginning factories is low labor productivity since untrained and
unskilled labors are employed to the factories. Skill of the workers should be improved by
training and the factories should employ skilled man power (engineers and technical school
graduates) to improve ginning practice. The major constrain of the availability of skilled man
power in the sub sector is the lack of formal training in TVET as well as in higher
educational institutions. So focus has to be given by learning institution to provide formal
training on the ginning technology to improve ginning productivity and work practices.
20
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
CHAPTER THREE
3. Issues and Challenges of ginning industry
There are several challenges that ginning industry are currently facing. These are identified
during the survey of 13 ginning industries as listed below:
High trash content of seed cotton was brought to ginning factories especially by trader.
Ginning provides foundation to the whole textile sector in the country by supplying the
lint cotton but this sector has been seriously neglected by the researchers and learning
institutions.
Ginning sector seriously lacks in technology and skills for classification of the cotton
lint.
There are quite inadequate regulations for the ginning process.
Ginneries rely on old machinery and outdated methods of ginning.
Ginning sector lacks any standards for ensuring the health and safety of the people
working in the ginning factories. Ginning workers remain exposed to cotton dust, which
21
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
may cause respiratory symptoms and there is a positive relationship between the
exposure to cotton dust and symptoms of cough.
Low ginning outturn
Ginners and cotton traders mostly concern on quantity than quality.
Low capacity Utilization.
Poor maintenance practice.
Lack of spare parts and workshop.
Lack of skilled manpower.
Different lot seed cotton mixed and delivered to ginners especially by traders.
Almost all ginners are serves providers.
Most factories infrastructures are not follow best arrangement and not full fill all
facilities and managed by non-technical people.
Lack of quality standard and price premium for lint cotton.
Almost all ginneries have no properly conditioned raw material (seed cotton) and
finished goods (lint cotton) storage facilities.
High Contamination problem
22
Table: - 12 Detail of Benchmarking standards, gap identified and comments to fulfill the gaps regarding Quality parameters of
cotton, Ginning Production, maintenance, and it’s Human Resource.
Parameters Standards Existing situation Remark
Staple length millimeters
Extra-long staple 34 & above Almost all ginning factories have Since there is no any instrumental
Long staple 28 up to 34 no equipment to check quality checking of seed cotton quality
Medium staple 24 up to 28 parameters of lint and seed parameters, fiber rupture, trash and
Short staple Less than 24 cotton. Except Omo valley moisture content before, on processing
Strength grams/Tex which has fineness tester. and auditing practice after process in
Weak Below 23 Almost in all factories hand and order to adjust processing machine
Medium 23-25 visual quality checking are setting and maintenance. It is impossible
Average 26-28 practiced which gives subjective to know whether the process is affecting
Strong 29-30 result. the quality of output (lint cotton) or not
Very Strong Above 31 hence, difficult to produce good quality
Micronaire lint cotton.
(µg/inch) The factories must be have skilled cotton
Very Coarse 5.5 and above The ginning factories should have
Coarse 4.8 – 5.4 skilled cotton classifiers and quality
Medium 3.7 – 4.7 checking rooms with at least low cost
Fine 3.0 – 3.6 laboratory equipment’s (such trash
Color Code analyzer, fineness tester, hygrometer
White 11,21,31,41,51,61,71 etc.). And also it is better to create
Light spotted 12,22,32,42,52,62,72,82 awareness on basic quality concept,
advantage of auditing cotton quality
Spotted 13,23,43,53,63,73, 83
before and after ginning process.
In other way producers and ginners can
Tinged 24,34,44,54,64,74,84
use ETIDI and other textile factories
Yellow 25,35, 85 which have well equipped laboratories.
Trash content %
Trash amount 1–7%
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
1
Table process parameters
Production
No record and Hp Since the factory has no humidification
plant the room temperature and RH% is the
Temperature & RH%
27 -30 D C surrounding atmosphere. It is advisable to
of ginning section
use psychro-meter for recording
temperature and RH% for process control.
Moisture content in No checking Storing highly moisture of the seed cotton
seed Cotton during for Long period can fade its color, lose
storage Below 10 % strength and vice versa. So it should be
checked.
cotton seed Feeding Manual/ Automatic Manual feeding For uniform flow of material automatic feeding
system First in first out (FIFO) First in first out is preferable.
(FIFO)
Almost all of the Adequate storage should be available in the
factories seed cotton factory to avoid mixing of contaminants,
Storage facility & Store should be covered
storage is not enough dusts, over drying, deterioration of cotton
systems of storage of /roofed/ cemented and clean.
and good except color, etc.
seed cotton
ELSE. Training on seed cotton handling and
kaizen to the factories.
9 kg The lint cotton in kg per saw /hrs. is less
Lint cotton kg /saw/ hrs. 10 - 21 than the standard. It needs improvement.
invisible waste % harvesting mechanism (but 63% no actual data that show the exact amount.
mostly 58 to 63 %) It is advised to organize its data of
Seed cotton cleaning No means of incoming and outgoing cotton fiber, trash,
Cleaning efficiency of efficiency 55-83% checking seed weight, to know the exact value.
ginning Lint cleaning Cleaning and realization is measured by
13 -62% improvement of lint grade.
37 to 42%( depends upon
Lint Cotton realization
trash% in seed cotton & trash 37%
%
removed from lint cotton)
Actual 60 ton/shift, The production efficiency of the factory is
Bales production / shift
13-15 bales 18% This shows that there is a lot to
(8 hrs.)
improve.
No checking It is required to check moisture of bale so
Bale moisture content 6 to 7% that the factory’s has to practice by using
hygrometer at least.
Bale Dimension
Bale length On some factories the bale size is very big
No uniform due to tying wire is only 5. So that the
Bale height dimension L= 135, factory is advised to decrease the bale size
H=70 and w= 53 to load even on trucks as many bale as
Bale width
possible.
Bale pressing
Hydraulic The bale press is Hydraulic pressing of
Bale press type &
Pneumatic/hydraulic double box up packing type and down
system of pressing
packing
Jute cloth and weight It jute cloth is used for bale packing which
Average Wt of bale &
Avr. 218kg ranges from 90 kg to very harm for color variation during dying
type of packing by jute
By cotton cloth cover 227 kg so that the factory is advised to stop it and
or cotton cover
use 100% cotton cloth.
1
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Completely covered Only It is required to cover the bale all the six
with cotton cloth Recommended Square (level) 2/6 -6/6 is covered face to avoid any contaminant mixing and
Wire knots on ball of heads Permanent Bale attract customers.
bale Identification (PBI) tag on
All ties recessed into bale
flat side of bale
specified number of 5 circular wires It is below standard so that the factory is
Rectangular (6 to 10)
ties advised to use minimum 6 ties on a bale.
Storage facility of good There is no well-ventilated room for bale
Descent.
cotton bales/internal store
Good.
condition of stores &
Bales lot wise.
type of storing
Manual system The seed cotton unloading from truck is by
System of
Mechanised forklift or labor but des use forklift and
handling/bales/ seeds
feeding to pipe is by labor.
Bale is arranged by bale is arranged by It better relatively
Best arrangement
forklift forklift
Meeting with all No meeting with The factory is advised to take feedback
harvesters once in a farmers from both customers.
year for giving
feedback to produce Once in a year must
good quality of cotton
looking to the need of
the spinning industry
3 Maintenance
Every shift cleaning by No scheduled but
Routine cleaning of all compressed air opening the shift wise and weekly
ginning machines doors of the individual cleaning
machine
Preventive maintenance Once in15 days No scheduled The factory only performs on consumable
2
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
3
2. Infrastructural layout of Ginning & Pressing
Table 13: - Detail comments to fulfill the gaps against the standards
1 Transportation of covered truck No their own trucks. Transportation of cotton seed to the
cotton seed to Clean the hand cart/bullock cart/ tractor ginning factory is by pp.bags and jute
ginneries trolley before loading seed cotton No proper packing of seed bags that are used more than a year.
Different varieties must be segregated cotton, high contamination These bags are stayed in the ginning
while transporting cotton from the field during packaging and factor till the next season seed cotton
to the ginning factory transportation. harvesting is coming which is very
Cotton should be kept protected from bad practice. So it is bad practice that
cotton pieces, hair, rope, toffee has to be Improved.
wrappers, plastics etc at any spot of
Mostly open trucks are used for
transportation
transportation from farm to ginning
During transportation Cotton should be
that simply exposes the seed cotton to
properly packed
Packing with old jute bags. any adulterous things.
Cotton is transported with 100% cotton
bags and covered.
Not Transporting with worn out jute
bags The seed cotton delivered to the
factory is by trucks of other people.
for most
2 cotton Seed Stack seed cotton on clean, paved and The store floor is not fully The cemented floor and roofed houses
storage house preferably roofed platforms or in well- cemented, ventilated, cleaned are used but the cleaning habit of the
and its floor ventilated ware house with area 400- and well arranged. factories should have to be improved
2000sq.m
Storage space for cotton should clean The siner workers have
and dry. if cemented floor is not uniforms and caps.
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
4 cotton seed Three stage cotton seed conveyor system Pneumatic feed. The transportation of seed cotton
pneumatic comprising from manual feeding to next machine
Conveyor Pneumatic from heap to pre-cleaner or Hopper feeding to each (stone catcher) is through pipe which
vehicular cotton seed conveyance gin stands. Only seed and is pneumatic and always though
without manual handling trash are transported by machine mechanical and from air
Pneumatic / Mechanical from pre- screw conveyor separator or recliner to extractor is by
cleaner to Gin Hall screw conveyor. The pneumatic
Pneumatic / Mechanical to each Gin transport has its own disadvantage
through sensor control droppers when long pipe with many bent
Note: Two stage system will do if pre- junctions are used which can create
cleaner is inside the Gin Hall rolling of material and create neps.
5 Pre cleaner Off-line –by pass / On-line cleaner with No well disposal of waste since Here
3 - 6 beaters (inclined) the factory is not using cyclone which
5 -10 beaters (horizontal) 4- 7 beaters all inclined needs improvement. And there is no
pneumatic trash transporting pipe -Air transporting of seed
adjustment and checking of its
Air transporting pipe cotton and trash.
cleaning efficiency so that it is better
to check it
6. Gin stands and Gin Number of Saw gin or Roller stand 2- 4 saw gin stands and 80 Two saw gin stand which is below
House - 127 saws each standard.
1
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
7. Lint Cleaner Lint cleaner with 3-6 beaters No lint clear The post cleaner is installed by
modification to clean when the high
trashed used in this factory. And
patented for the modifier since it is a
new investigation
8. Conveyor Only pneumatic conveyor from gins to Pneumatic transportation from Pneumatic transportation from gin
System for Lint lint cleaner, from lint cleaner to pala gin stands to press box. stands to lint cleaner and then to
halls and from pala halls to press box / condenser and press box
on-line bale press
9. Bale Press Two / single stage manual loading & Up and down packing circular All factories are integrated ginning
manual tramping press. auto loading and auto and pressing system.
Two / single stage auto loading & auto tramping press.
tramping press
10 Other Contamination detector & eliminator Except some mobile The factory must have to check the
Equipment / HVI / MVI /LVI instruments no any lab quality of material processed
Laboratory Workshop instruments
Lab. gin
Grooving machine
Nep Counting facility
Moisture Meter
11 Seed Conveyor Automatic seed conveyor -screw conveyor There is no safety system so needs
& Platform from gin house to improvement.
- Roofed CC seed platform 8x (40x50)
1000 sq. ft., with direct
collection into transport
containers [or]
- Seed godown 1500 sq.
ft.
12 Factory Layout Cotton seed platform ,Gin house ,Pala house, Eight Many seed cotton store There are three main balance used in
Press house, Bale go down / Roofed bale the ginning factory, gate Weigh
storage Bridge, bale balance and seed
balance. The advantages of all
balances are to measure and give the
2
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
information.
10. Adequate Cotton seed platform ,Gin house ,Pala house, Poor lighting system. The lighting system is used for
Lighting Press house, Bale godown / Roofed bale control of waste in the room and
storage clearly observes the processing
machines during processing. But the
factory use it.
11. Safety Motor guard, Machine guard, Ventilation, Poor safety and regulation There is no safety system so needs
Masks and First aid kit system improvement
12 Weigh Bridge 20 tons weigh bridge available within 30 tone functional. There are three main balance used in
1km the ginning factory, gate Weigh
20 tons weigh bridge within factory Bridge, bale balance and seed
premises balance. The advantages of all
30 tons mechanical weigh bridge within balances are to measure and give the
factory premises information.
30 tons electronic weigh bridge within
factory premises
30 tons electronic weigh bridge with
display & print out facility within
factory premises
13 Humidifier / Nozzle system for cotton seed & steam No Nozzle spray for lint. The nozzle spray is used when very
Moisturizer system for lint dry cotton is processed.
Benson fans for cotton seed and lint
14 Electrical Wiring In-coming power cable Under ground and well The electric boards must be protected
(underground Gin house protected
or protected) Press hall
Other machinery
15 Fire Fighting small/ large Units Having/ not having Small units. powder Since fire preventions are small units
System water well extinguisher
5- 10 hydrants or above + OHT / Sump
Closed 65 KL or OHT / Sump Open 75
KL + standby diesel pump besides
3
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
electric pump
16 Boundary Wall Partially walled / fenced, Wire fenced all Thin Fenced. Not Well protected by wire fence.
/ fence around, Partly walled & partly fenced all
around , Boundary wall all around,
Boundary wall all-around of height 6
feet or above
17 Machine Satisfactory Poor The maintenance system must be
maintenance Good improved
very good
18 Gin Settings Proper grooving The setting is try and error. The setting must not be try and error.
Overlap setting It has to be done with the
Appropriate seed grid commitment
19 Off-loading of On cloth / tarpaulin On floor (not cemented) Except cleaning the floor is good
cotton seed On brick floor
On cemented floor
20 Engaging labour to Up to 5 laborers No assignment The labors are assigned but not
remove 6 - 10 e laborers properly monitored
contaminants Abov10 laborers
21 Covering of cotton One heap covered Having roofed storage facility Not covering and arrangement of seed
seed heaps Two heaps covered but no proper handling. cotton in heaps.
Having roofed storage facility and / or
covering all the heaps.
22 Training of Trained fitters Not available Training of factory workers about
personnel, Quality awareness boards quality is required
quality awareness Gum / Velcro board for hair
boards
23 Segregation in Only grade-wise Both variety-wise. but Sorting is best identification grade
heaping & Only variety-wise different varieties are mixed wise
processing (Benefit Both variety-wise and grade-wise together when traders bring
of for ginning
doubt for job work
units)
4
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
25 Uniforms, caps / Uniform Glass, working cloth, caps, Working cloth can create suitable
head Cap / Head covering helmet, for mechanic and working condition. Even workers
covering & shoes Shoes operator need suitable working condition
beside the cloth. Therefore this has to
be improved.
26 Supervision Fitter in Gin house No any supervisor One supervisor can be controlling the
Fitter in Press house whole factory
Seed cotton off–loading & storage
27 Covering of cotton Few vehicles with cover no any vehicles with Needs Improvement
seed in Many vehicles with cover cover.
incoming vehicle All vehicles with cover
28 Housekeeping & Satisfactory poor Training on housekeeping
Cleanliness Good
very Good
29 Contaminant Type high impact contaminants White plastic fabric Contaminants can be manmade or
White plastic fabric Hair Natural. But whatever it is, it has to
White plastic string Feather be controlled.
White / transparent plastic film Coloured cotton fibres
Training on Contaminant types
Hair Coloured plastic fibre
Feather
Coloured cotton fibres
Coir fibre
Coloured plastic fibre
Others (Specify)
5
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
6
4. Conclusion and Recommendation
4.1. Conclusion
From the above it may be observed that since the improvements in ginning will benefit the entire
supply chain, Ethiopian ginning Industries have to be improved in its productivity, infrastructure,
technology status, spare part stock management, maintenance practice, data recording system ,
material handling, skill of manpower, electrical power consumption, reduction in contamination
and improvement of cotton quality in supply of quality lint cotton to domestic as well as
international textile mills.
4.2. Recommendation
Using good quality seed which results in better quality lint cotton.
Establish separate storage of each variety,
Improve the practices of harvest and post-harvest to produce clean cotton.
Labor assigned on the task of picking should be properly trained.
Proper storage and transportation.
Buyers from different small scale should avoid mixing of different lots.
Adopt proper cleaning process like using pre and post - cleaning machineries.
Upgrading machinery of ginning.
Implement ESA-lint cotton standards in purchasing the cotton.
Delivering comprehensive program for the capacity building of the management and staff
of the ginning factories in areas like standards of cotton, quality management, management
of the ginning processes.
Encourage competition among the ginners and ginning professionals by giving awards to
the best performers.
Premium for the quality of the cotton and discount for poor quality
Selecting a gin site that is economical for cotton transport. So that ginneries has to be near to the
farm areas.
Ethiopian Ginning factories Gap Analysis study Report Jan- 2015
Establish good waste management system inside and outside the ginnery to provide a safe working
environment in and around the ginnery. Be friendly to the environment and utilize all cotton
byproducts wisely.
Ensuring that farmers are aware of the best variety selection, production, harvesting and storage
practices so that high quality cotton with minimal foreign matter and damage can be delivered to
the gin. If this is done, minimal drying and cleaning will be required, and thus less fiber damage,
higher quality fiber, and greater gin turnout will result
Developing and implementing a comprehensive ginning maintenance program that is continually
documented and communicated. The maintenance program must include off-season repair, in-
season preventive maintenance, and breakdown repair and documentation.
Developing contamination prevention program to ensure contaminant free bales. Avoid use of
synthetic materials in and around the ginnery and cotton fields. Or installing contaminant sorters.
Developing specific job description for each employee, and make sure that it is available in the
appropriate language.
Using feedback from farmer, marketing, textile and other customers to refine and improve ginning
operations.
Maintaining uniform flow of cotton through all machines.