Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.amca.org
THE ONLY MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO THE AIR MOVEMENT & CONTROL INDUSTRY
FEI 0.9
IN THIS ISSUE
AMCA at 100: A Century of Inclusion Louver Requirements in Hurricane-Prone Regions
How to Specify AMCA-Certified Products Fire, Smoke and Combination Fire/Smoke Dampers
AMCA inmotion is also celebrating our association’s 100-year anniversary of industry service.
In this issue, we reminisce about how much AMCA has grown in size and stature. We’ve gone
from 11 U.S.-based member companies in 1917 to over 137 companies located all over the
world. And while AMCA is turning 100, the AMCA Certified Ratings Program (CRP) is turning
AMCA International 75. It now represents more than 3,600 product lines manufactured globally by more than 200
companies.
Board of Directors
At this turning point in AMCA’s history, we encourage you to read the article on how to specify
Tim O’Hare, President
Vice President, Sales & Marketing AMCA-certified products in construction documents. Our research shows that although the
The New York Blower Company CRP has been around for 75 years, the new talent currently designing and specifying systems
could use some mentoring!
Tim Kilgore, Chairman of the Board
President, Sales & Marketing Because AMCA inmotion’s technical articles are developed to provide lasting value to engineers
Greenheck involved in commercial and industrial air systems, we invite you to peruse every issue of AMCA
Doug Yamashita, Vice President inmotion going back to 2006, available on AMCA’s website under “Resources.” These issues
Executive Vice President, Sales & Marketing are free — and they’re chock full of detailed guidance on sizing, selecting and installing the
ACME Engineering and Manufacturing Corporation gamut of products manufactured by AMCA members. Codes and standards are covered as
David Johnson, Treasurer well, and you’ll find plenty of information on indoor air quality, energy efficiency and cost
Director of Engineering effectiveness.
Berner International Corporation
Thanks in advance for taking the time to read AMCA inmotion, and thank you for your own
Amit Ahuja, Director industry service. Feel free to drop me a note with your suggestions for improving the magazine,
General Manager and best of luck and health to you and your teams.
Maico Gulf
Frank Cuaderno, Director
Vice President of Engineering
Mars Air Systems LLC Michael Ivanovich
Keith Glasch, Director Editor in Chief, AMCA inmotion
President Senior Director, Industry Relations, AMCA International
Ruskin
Tom Gustafson, Director
Chief Technology Officer/Quality Manager
Hartzell Air Movement Feature Articles Departments
John Magill, Director
Vice President, Engineering 2 New Efficiency Metric for Fans Enables 1 From the Editor in Chief
Howden North America Inc.
New Approaches for Regulations and
26 European AMCA Update
Jim Meats, Director Incentives
Director of Marketing
Loren Cook Company 10 AMCA at 100: A Century of Inclusion 28 Asia AMCA Update
Mats Sándor, Director 12 How to Specify AMCA-Certified Products 30 Middle East AMCA Update
Technical Director
Systemair AB 18 Louver Requirements For Hurricane- 32 CRP Update & Event
Prone Regions
Chee Keong So, Director Calendar
Head of Department 22 Fire Dampers, Smoke Dampers and
GTG Industries Sdn Bhd Combination Fire/Smoke Dampers: The 34 Publications & Standards
Mark Stevens, Executive Director Difference is Important Library
AMCA International Inc.
AMCA International Inc. is a not-for-profit association of the world’s manufacturers of air system
equipment. Since 1917, AMCA has led industry education and training, provisions for codes and
Published by ASHRAE JOURNAL
regulations and the development of product test standards and certification.
on behalf of AMCA INTERNATIONAL
Editorial content for this supplement was provided by the Air Movement and Control Association International Inc. The
Greg Martin, Associate Publisher, appearance of any technical data, editorial material or advertisement in this publication does not constitute endorsement,
ASHRAE Media Advertising warranty or guarantee by either ASHRAE or AMCA International of any product, service, process, procedure, design or the like.
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 1
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
in buildings at a reasonable cost and minimal burden to industry for any program, code or regulation need only check the FEI
and customers. rating on the label.1
In the absence of a DOE test procedure, the FEI metric is
INTRODUCTION currently being formalized in an AMCA rating standard and
Over the past six years, the DOE fan initiative has helped the ISO standard for fan efficiency. The harmonized AMCA
AMCA develop and nurture relationships with advocacy and ISO FEI rating standards will prescribe how an FEI
organizations, regulators and other associations. The result rating is calculated from data taken during the two organiza-
is that AMCA and its members developed FEI with many tions’ performance-rating tests.
perspectives in mind. When finalized by the DOE, FEI will
replace existing fan efficiency metrics in U.S. model energy FEI, THE METRIC OF FUTURE REGULATIONS
codes and standards, and it is already being considered for The Appliance Standards and Rulemaking Federal Advisory
utility incentive programs.1 Committee (ASRAC) created a term sheet that describes FEI
FEI is a wire-to-air metric consistent with the regulatory as a metric calculated as the ratio of the actual fan efficiency
approaches being taken for other motor driven loads, such as to a baseline fan efficiency (Equation 1), both at a given airflow
pumps and air compressors. It also has a “sizing and selection” and pressure point. Since these efficiencies are each calculated
clause baked into the metric, in a manner acceptable to the at the same airflow and pressure, FEI is also defined as the
DOE.2 With these basic conditions in place, FEI stands to ratio of the baseline electrical power to the actual electrical
revolutionize how fans are sized, selected and specified by power of a fan (Equation 2).
practitioners. In fact, the rationale behind the development of
FEI is consistent with the European Commission regulation’s
“extended product” approach for regulating motor driven
Fan Efficiency
equipment. FEI takes this further by adding application-based Equation 1: FEI =
Baseline Fan Efficiency
parameters to the energy savings opportunity, which may
introduce new regulatory approaches to other equipment as
well. Baseline Fan Electrical Input Power
Equation 2: FEI =
With much of the low-hanging fruit having been picked Electrical Input Power
from the product-efficiency-savings tree over decades of
regulation, FEI grafts a new and exciting variety of energy
savings to the tree.
This breakthrough has occurred because fans differ from Equation 2 is equivalent to Equation 1, but because the goal
other appliances; their operating efficiency varies significantly of mandatory and voluntary programs is to reduce wasted
based on how they are applied and where they are selected energy, Equation 2 is preferred. Its specific mention of reduc-
within their operating envelope. Fan application and selec- ing electrical power consumption has more relevancy to
tion is therefore far more influential than peak fan efficiency regulatory goals than increasing energy efficiency. Equation
in determining the actual energy consumed by a fan. Unlike, 2 also is easier to apply and has the added benefit of working
for example, an incandescent light bulb, a fan that is least along the entire fan curve.
efficient in some applications may be the most efficient in Equation 2 suggests that there is an intermediary calcula-
others. tion leading to FEI, and there is: the measurement or calculation
Instead of specifying a minimum peak efficiency level for of FEP. FEP is obtained either by directly measuring fan
each of the various fan types, FEI establishes a baseline effi- electrical input power during rating tests or by measuring
ciency and resulting baseline power that varies with both fan shaft power and incorporating default values for motors
airflow and pressure, universally applied to all fan categories. and drives.3 The default values are defined in AMCA Standard
This establishes a range of compliant operations rather than 207,4 which is currently being approved for publication. Fan
a single-point pass/fail efficiency threshold. Instead of elimi- rating tests can be conducted using AMCA Standard 210,5
nating inefficient models, the FEI metric seeks to eliminate which the ASRAC fan working group adopted as the basis
inefficient selections.1 FEI also has the operating point char- of the DOE test standard.3
acteristics built into the calculation, so compliance officials Once the FEP rating of a fan is known, it is compared against
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 3
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
the baseline FEP (FEPstd ), as shown in Equation 3. Note that APPLYING FEI
FEP has engineering units of kW, which cancel out when FEI Instead of specifying a minimum peak efficiency level for
is calculated. each of the various fan types, the FEI establishes a baseline
efficiency and resulting baseline power that varies with both
airflow and pressure, universally applied to all fan categories.2
FEI defines a “compliant range of operation” instead of a
FEPstd single compliant efficiency threshold. For a single-speed fan
Equation 3: FEI = FEP rating
curve, the compliant range is a subsection of the total fan
curve (Figure 1).6
On multiple-speed fan curves, as would be used with a
variable frequency drive, these compliant zones look like
Table 1 shows how FEI can be used for regulations and bubbles. Bubble sizes are proportional to fan efficiency. Gen-
voluntary incentive programs.2 erally, the more efficient the fan, the larger the compliance
A useful characteristic of this metric is that for FEI ratings bubble (Figure 2, Figure 3).1 In some cases, however, fans
greater than one, the amount of energy savings over the baseline can be very efficient over a small operating range. The shaded
is FEI minus 1.0 on a percentage basis. So a fan rated FEI = regions in the figures indicate compliance FEI 1.0. Bubbles
1.1 uses 10 percent less energy than the baseline requirement. are defined within the compliance zone to indicate higher FEI
This makes FEI useful for calculating relative energy savings levels where applicable and outside the compliance zone where
between any two fans or between a fan and the FEI threshold FEI is less than zero. In Figure 3, a label indicates the maxi-
in a fan code, standard or regulation provision. mum speed at which the fan can be operated to have compliance.
This gives operators and engineers an opportunity to set up
Fan Regulatory or Possible variable speed drives and belts to restrict fan speed.
Voluntary Program Body FEI Requirement Manufacturers will include such diagrams, or their tabular
U.S. Department of Energy FEI ≥ 1.0 at design point equivalents, in product literature and sizing/selection software
to help consumers make good purchasing decisions for their
ASHRAE Standard 90.1 or
applications.
International Energy FEI ≥ 1.0 at design point
Conservation Code
THE SUPERIORITY OF FEI AS A METRIC
ASHRAE Standard 189.1 FEI ≥ 1.1 at design point
The ratio of fan power to baseline power at design conditions
Utility Incentive Programs FEI ≥ 1.1 at design point makes FEI easy to use for customers, owners, regulatory bod-
ies and creators of utility rebate programs. The baseline
Table 1: How FEI can be applied in regulatory and
voluntary programs. represents a reasonable efficiency level that is common to all
fan types as they are normally applied.
2.0 Also, there is much potential for
Pressure Compliant Range of Fan an upcoming DOE regulation based
on FEI. Regulations can be written
Fan Energy Index - FEI
dling, could also have FEI requirements of less than 1.0. in any manner they choose. A fan user can utilize any com-
As shown in Table 1, high-performance-building standards bination of fan, transmission, motor and speed control if the
(such as ASHRAE Standard 189.1) or utility rebate programs combined FEI level meets the minimum requirement.3
would set FEI requirements to be greater than the baseline Even though FEI was developed to focus on fan energy as
requirement. In the current fan efficiency provision in ASHRAE applied, it can also be used as an application-independent
Standard 189.1, additional stringency is added to the corre- metric when the design operating point is not known.2 This
sponding ASHRAE Standard 90.1 provision by making the would be true for fans sold off the shelf without a motor. In
sizing/selection window smaller — from 15 percentage points this case, FEI is evaluated at the best efficiency point at the
to 10. This is because more energy is saved by further restrict- maximum published fan speed. If the fan on the shelf has a
ing fan selections to larger sizes rather than increasing the fan motor and drive, the distributor will have the FEI bubble. By
efficiency grade (FEG) rating from 67 to
FEG 71, the next level up.7, 8 High Efficiency Fan
The FEI metric can also stand up to
Peak Efficiency
the expected increased stringency in
codes and regulations over time as fan
technology improves. The baseline FEI
Static Pressure
considering this single point, the metric establishes a restricted regulatory framework will soon show itself in standards,
speed range while remaining consistent with its use at the codes and regulations.
design point of operation. As shown in Figure 3, the restricted FEI is a metric that allows many different types of fans to
speed size is the maximum speed at which the fan can be be compared on equal footing, and it does so by concentrating
operated to remain at FEI = 1.0 or greater. on the energy consumed by a fan as it is applied. It can be
While driving significant energy savings and technological
used by regulators and purchasers alike to make a price-sensitive
improvements, the FEI will also teach proper fan selection.
market favor true efficiency, helping consumers see how a fan
Every detail that helps a consumer make a fan selection decision
can be affordable and efficient at the same time. Additionally,
will show the value of FEI for that selection. Consumers will
know immediately how their fan selection compares to the the FEI can provide manufacturers with concrete assurance
maximum baseline fan electrical input power. They will know they are creating energy saving products that will appeal to
how the energy consumption of one product compares to another, their customers. It is an all-encompassing, high-level solution
regardless of product type, category, size or drive method.1 to a complex problem.
CONCLUSION REFERENCES
FEI was selected by the DOE, AMCA and other industry 1. AMCA International. “Introducing the Fan Energy Index.”
stakeholders to be the metric around which a federal effi- Arlington Hts., IL: AMCA, 2017. www.amca.org/
whitepapers.
ciency standard would be developed, and it can be applied
in rebate programs for commercial and industrial fans. The 2. Persful T., M. Ivanovich, G. Wickes, and E. Rogers. “A
long, hard work that has gone into the development of this Look at the Extended Product Motor Labeling Initiatives
sophisticated and effective metric and the supporting for Fans.” 2016 Proceedings of the ACEEE Summer
Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings. Pacific Grove,
CA, 2016. http://aceee.org/files/proceedings/2016/data/
papers/6_587.pdf.
3. U.S. Department of Energy. Term Sheet of the Commercial
and Industrial Fans and Blowers Working Group. Sep-
tember 3, 2015 (edited September 24, 2015). Washington
D.C.: U.S. Department of Energy Appliance and Equip-
ment Standards Program, 2015. http://tinyurl.com/
TermSheet2015.
4. AMCA International. BSR/AMCA Standard 207 (Draft).
Arlington Hts., IL: AMCA, 2017.
5. ANSI/AMCA Standard 210–ANSI/ASHRAE 51. Labora-
tory Methods of Testing Fans for Aerodynamic
Performance Rating. Arlington Hts., IL: AMCA, 2010.
www.amca.org/store.
6. Mathson T. “Update on the Impending U.S. Fan Efficiency
Regulation.” Presented at the International Symposium
on Fan Efficiency Regulation. Bejing, April 6, 2016.
7. Ivanovich M. and N. Jones. “A Comparison of U.S. and
European Approaches to Regulating Fan Efficiency.”
Proc. of the CIBSE/ASHRAE Technical Symposium.
Dublin, April 3–4, 2014. http://tinyurl.com/
ComparisonIvanovichJones.
8. ANSI/ASHRAE/IES Standard 189.1. Standard for the
Design of High-Performance, Green Buildings Except
Low-Rise Residential Buildings. Atlanta: ASHRAE,
2010. www.ashrae.org.
www.info.hotims.com/65142-48
AMANDA MULEDY
EDITOR
AMCA at 100:
A Century of Inclusion
Association marks milestone as themselves the National Association of Fan Manufacturers,
international authority on system or NAFM. One of NAFM’s earliest efforts to advance the
components. industry was the development of Bulletin 110, Standard Test
Code for Disc and Propeller Fans, Centrifugal Fans and Blow-
A
ers. That document is better known today as ANSI/AMCA
s AMCA looks back on 100 years of service, a Standard 210, Laboratory Methods of Testing Fans for Certified
common thread runs through its history: a dedica- Aerodynamic Performance, and it is one of the association’s
tion to inclusion. AMCA is the association it is today because, key technical standards.
in 1917, competing U.S. fan manufacturers During the 1930s, NAFM began distribut-
decided to engage each other in conversa- ing “Certified Ratings” stickers to members
tion rather than shut each other out. This who tested in accordance with standard test
put the industry’s long-term well-being codes. The NAFM Publicity Committee
ahead of these companies’ own short-term hoped the stickers would stir conversation,
victories, setting a precedent for integrity. bringing more companies into the fold and
Since then, AMCA has never stopped encouraging testing and verification in
finding ways to be inclusive — inclusive of more regions, harmony with peer-vetted standards.
inclusive of more products and inclusive of more people. In 1955, NAFM invited a number of manufacturer trade
It all started when 11 fan manufacturers met in Detroit in associations to consolidate and form the Air Moving and Con-
1917 to discuss a new venture: an association allowing member ditioning Association, or AMCA. In 1970, AMCA added dampers
companies to determine the industry’s path. They called and louvers to its list of products. With this change in scope
NAFM Bulletin 110, the predecessor to AMCA Standard 210, Laboratory Methods of Testing Fans for Certified Aerodynamic
Performance. It was first published in 1923. All images courtesy of AMCA International.
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 11
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
T
for industrial products, cannot be certified. In these cases,
he CRP not only verifies manufacturer data; it also having language specifying that the product be rated in accor-
ensures that data conform with formatting requirements, dance with an AMCA standard’s tests is appropriate.
enabling the comparison of like products from different
manufacturers. The scope of the CRP includes series-produced STEP 1: SELECT AN AMCA-CERTIFIED PRODUCT TYPE
fans, dampers, louvers, air curtains, air To ensure an AMCA-certified product is
monitoring stations and other air system installed, you must first verify that the product
products commonly found in commercial type is one that AMCA certifies. For example,
and industrial facilities. many of the components within an air handling
To enjoy the benefits and peace of mind unit can be AMCA certified, but air handling
that comes from specifying AMCA-certified units themselves are not in the scope of
products, building industry professionals products AMCA certifies. For a complete list
need to know how to first properly specify of products covered by the program, download
them and then ensure they get installed. the free white paper entitled “An Introduction
Before showing you how to correctly to the AMCA Certified Ratings Program”
specify, it is worth pointing out that engineers from AMCA’s website.1
often require that products be tested in
accordance with an AMCA test standard, STEP 2: FIND AMCA-CERTIFIED
such as AMCA Standard 210 for fans or PRODUCTS
AMCA Standard 500-D for dampers. This AMCA Publication 11 outlines the The most reliable way to find AMCA-certified
can lead to trouble. A product that was tested fundamentals of the CRP. products is to use the association’s online
Images courtesy of AMCA International.
in accordance with an AMCA standard is certified products database,2 which has PDFs
not necessarily an AMCA-certified product. If you include this of approved catalogs for certified products.
language without referencing compliance with AMCA-11-series Manufacturers also identify AMCA-certified products in
publications, you open the door for a possible uncertified their catalogs, which are approved by AMCA for following
product substitution. CRP requirements. But if you select products based on manu-
Another common mistake is specifying that a product be facturer literature, it is good practice to verify certifications
tested in an AMCA/AMCA-accredited laboratory. Again, this are current by checking AMCA’s online database.
Application of a CRP
seal.
STEP 3: VERIFY SPECIFIC For a tight specification, mention the appropriate test standard
CERTIFIED PERFORMANCE PARAMETERS and the appropriate CRP publication by name. Below are
A product certified for a general license type, such as sound examples for a fan, damper and louver specification. Brackets
performance, may only be certified for specific parameters. are used to indicate where options are available.
For example, a fan may be certified to display the AMCA sound Fans shall be tested in accordance with ANSI/AMCA
and air performance seal. But note that this seal covers a number Standard 210 and licensed to bear the AMCA Certified
of performance types, and not all those performance types need Ratings Program seal for [air performance] [efficiency]
[sound] in accordance with AMCA Publication 211.
to be certified in order to earn the right to bear the sound and
air seal. That fan may only be certified for inlet LwA sound Fans shall be tested in accordance with ANSI/AMCA
Standard 300, be licensed to bear the AMCA Certified
and air performance, not hemispherical sones or octave bands.
Ratings Program seal for sound performance in accor-
Or a louver may be certified to display the AMCA water pen- dance with AMCA Publication 311 and shall comply
etration and air performance seal but only be certified for intake with ANSI/AMCA Standard 301 for calculating fan
pressure drop and water penetration, not exhaust pressure drop. sound ratings from laboratory test data.
To verify specific certified parameters, view approved manu-
facturer literature or reference AMCA’s online database. Also, Because AMCA has test standards specific to different fan
check the test configurations for how your product will be types, be sure to name the test standard appropriate for each
applied. For example, fan tests in accordance with AMCA fan type.
Standard 210 can be done in four different combinations Dampers shall be tested in accordance with ANSI/
involving ducted inlets and ducted outlets. For this reason, you AMCA Standard 500-D and licensed to bear the AMCA
should be sure to check that your fan options are tested and certified ratings program seal for air performance
[and leakage, etc.] in accordance with AMCA Publica-
certified in the appropriate configuration.
tion 511.
Louvers shall be tested in accordance with ANSI/AMCA
STEP 4: WRITE A TIGHT SPECIFICATION
Standard 500-L and licensed to bear the AMCA Certi-
FOR AMCA-CERTIFIED PRODUCTS
fied Ratings Program seal for air performance [and
After you have selected your AMCA-certified product and water, wind-driven sand, etc.] in accordance with
verified the performance parameters you need certified, the AMCA Publication 511.
next step is to write a product specification that will hold For more information about writing a specification for AMCA-
throughout the challenges of plan review, value engineering certified products, see the white paper entitled “How to Specify
process and possible contractor substitutions. AMCA-Certified Products,” available on AMCA’s website.1
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 13
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
Authentic AMCA seal Counterfeit seal Authentic AMCA seal Counterfeit seal
This seal on the right is too wide, and the text alignment The seal on the right should say “water penetration,”
and colors are incorrect. not “water performance.” Also, the design, width,
text alignment and colors are incorrect.
Authentic AMCA seal Counterfeit seal Authentic AMCA seal Counterfeit seal
AMCA-certified seals will always be in English. The seal on the right has the wrong font, text
alignment and colors. It is also missing elements.
STEP 5: VERIFY CERTIFICATION AUTHENTICITY • Verify the actual product against the specified
The building design and construction process is long and product
complex. Things change along the way. Products get pack- At submittal, installation and commissioning, verify that
aged with other products. Substitutions happen. From the the selected product matches the product specification.
time when products are specified to when they are procured, • Verify certification in the online database
installed and commissioned, building Go to AMCA’s online database and
industry professionals need to ensure that search by product, company, country or
The AMCA store has the
there are no eliminations of AMCA’s cer- license type to verify certification.
most recent versions of
tification requirements or substitutions with • Check online for violations
standards and publica-
uncertified products. Visit AMCA’s violations database online4
tions, and it can be
The goal of the AMCA certification pro- found on AMCA’s to see lists of unlicensed products,
gram is simply to ensure that air movement website under program violation notices and products
and control products perform as stated in 3
“Resources.” The with licenses withdrawn.
manufacturer literature. Because displaying publications associated • Verify the product has the correct
an AMCA seal is optional, it is not always with the CRP are AMCA seal
clear whether a product is certified or not available at no cost, and AMCA-certified products are not required to
just by looking at it. Below are items to there is a nominal have a seal on them. But if there is a seal, you
check to verify that a product is, indeed, charge for standards. should verify that it matches the certification
AMCA certified. requirement identified in the product
specification. You can contact AMCA staff if you While this product The ratings shown are based on tests
and procedures made in accordance with
may have been tested in AMCA standard 500-L. The actual test
need help matching seals to requirements. Also, know accordance with AMCA
results of water penetration and air
performance may vary (+/-10%)
depending on the actual application. Free
that printed seals on product packaging are not standards, this is not area calculations are (+/-5%)
www.info.hotims.com/65142-69 www.info.hotims.com/65142-65
CONCLUSION
There is significant value to specifying a
building product that has independently-
verified product performance data and that
meets formatting requirements that facili-
tate comparisons of like products. Given
that this benefit is available for many air
movement and control products, it makes
sense to not only gain the advantage of
specifying a certified product but to also
ensure that the specified certified product
actually gets installed. Specifying AMCA-
certified air movement and control products
and then carefully verifying product selec-
tion throughout the design and construction
process will ensure products perform as
described and expected.
www.info.hotims.com/65142-49
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 17
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
Louver Requirements
For Hurricane-Prone Regions
A look at the very specific requirements HURRICANE-PRONE REGION AND WIND-BORNE
within the hurricane-prone and DEBRIS REGION DEFINITION AND REQUIREMENTS
The International Building Code specifies hurricane-prone
wind-borne debris regions.
T
regions to be any location along the U.S. Atlantic Ocean or
he International Building Code and International Gulf of Mexico coasts where the ultimate design wind speed
Mechanical Code only permit exclusive, high perfor- for Risk Category II buildings is greater than 51.4 m/s (115 mph).
mance louver products within the hurricane-prone and Additionally, the International Building Code classifies Hawaii,
wind-borne debris regions — and for good reason. The damage Puerto Rico, Guam, the Virgin Islands and American Samoa
caused by wind driven rain intrusion and airborne debris as hurricane-prone regions.
resulting from hurricanes and tropical storms can prove cata- According to the same International Building Code, wind-
strophic. In order to keep people safe, manufacturers should borne debris regions are areas within hurricane-prone regions.
be familiar with the codes governing these regions, and they An area is a wind-borne debris region if it is located within
should understand how to ensure that louvers meet the require- 1.61 km (1 mile) of the coastal mean high water line, where
ments laid out in the codes. the ultimate design wind speed is 58 m/s (130 mph) or greater.
115
120
130
140
150
Wind-Borne
Debris Region
140
150
Hawaii: 130
Guam: 195
Virgin Islands: 165
American Samoa: 160
Wind-Borne Debris Region 140 Puerto Rico: 150-170
160 170
Building Risk Category II & III 150
160
(Non-Healthcare), Figure 1609A in 115 170 180
IBC 2012/Figure 1609.3(1) in IBC
120 150
2015 (Risk Cat II). Image adapted from IBC. 130 140 180
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 19
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
Figure 2: Typical fire damper installation, based on AMCA Figure 3: Example of a combination fire/smoke damper
Publication 503.1 Image courtesy of Ruskin. with electric heat response device. Image courtesy of Ruskin.
in the airstream. Multi-blade fire dampers generally offer to create pressure differences. Pressurizing the areas surround-
greater restriction to airflow than a curtain-type fire damper ing the fire prevents the spread of smoke into other areas.
for the same size duct. However, multi-blade fire dampers can
be applied in situations when the system air velocities exceed COMBINATION FIRE/SMOKE DAMPERS
the curtain-type fire damper closure ratings. Multi-blade fire The codes have recognized — and most engineers agree
dampers have been UL tested and are “dynamic” rated for — that the best method of compartmentalization is through
closure at a minimum 2,000 fpm and 4.0 in. w.g. the use of smoke and combination fire/smoke dampers.
Combination fire/smoke dampers close not only upon the
SMOKE DAMPERS detection of high duct temperature but also upon the detec-
The definition for smoke dampers is similar to that of fire tion of smoke. They can be factory-supplied with override
dampers, with the difference being that these devices prevent controls to pressurize individual spaces. These dampers
the passage of smoke through an HVAC system or from one are UL-leakage rated to stop smoke in its tracks, which is
side of a leakage-rated separation to the other. Smoke dampers their main difference from fire dampers. Only combination
are controlled by a smoke detection system and open or close fire/smoke dampers or stand-alone smoke dampers are
automatically. They can also be opened or closed from a leakage-rated devices (Table 1).
remote fire command station. Combination fire/smoke dampers (Figure 3) meet the
Smoke dampers are operated by a factory-installed electric requirements of both UL standards for safety, UL 5553 and
or pneumatic actuator. They are controlled by smoke detectors
and/or fire alarms. Smoke dampers are qualified under UL Leakage Leakage, cfm/sq-ft
Classification at Standard Air Conditions
Standard 555S, Standard for Smoke Dampers,2 and have two
general applications: 4.5 in. wg. 8.5 in. wg. 12.5 in. wg.
1. As part of a passive smoke control system, where they I 8 11 14
close upon detection of smoke and prevent the circulation of
II 20 28 35
air and smoke through a duct, transfer or ventilation
opening. III 80 112 140
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 23
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
e u r o p e a n a m c a u p d at e
AMCA continues to represent its members and their interests in companies, with 11 AMCA Certified Ratings Program (CRP) par-
the European market. Membership remains stable and saw a ticipants. AMCA is anticipating continued steady growth in
slight increase in 2017. Regional membership has grown to 29 membership and CRP participation in 2017.
• Consulting engineers
• Equipment manufacturers
• Applications engineers
• Research scientists and technicians
• Code officials
• Designers
• Specifiers
• Engineering students
a s i a a m c a u p d at e
region was assembled November 16, The steering committee’s first meeting
2016, replacing the now-dissolved Asia was held on April 12, 2017, in Shanghai.
discuss and develop a strategic plan for The committee will meet twice a year,
Alex Zhang, Asokdas Damodaran, CK So (Chairman), the Asia region and to present its annual once during a trade show and once at the
David Lau, Louis Shum. Images courtesy of AMCA International. report to the AMCA International board annual Asia AMCA regional meeting.
Meetings
2016 VIETNAM TECHNICAL SEMINAR ASIA AMCA 2016 ANNUAL REGION MEETING
Together with AMCA members, Kruger Ventilation
Industries, Nicotra Gebhardt and Systemair, Asia AMCA
facilitated its first technical seminar in Vietnam. The event
took place in Ho Chi Minh City on November 9, 2016.
Turnout was good, with more than 100 attendees that ranged
from consultants to engineers to end users. Presentations
included “EC Technology — Demand Control Applications
in Ventilation Systems,” “Fan Type Selection and Fan
Sizing” and “System Effect and Energy Savings for Air
Curtains.” Attendees gather for the Asia AMCA’s 2016 annual region
meeting.
Attendees took advantage of a coffee break to network and
visit booths set up by Kruger Ventilation Industries, Nicotra Asia AMCA’s sixth annual region meeting was held in Bangkok.
Gebhardt and Systemair, seeking to understand their products It was supported by the Air Conditioning Engineering
and services. The seminar concluded with a lunch for all Association of Thailand (ACAT) and ASHRAE Thailand
attendees. Chapter.
Topics presented at the morning technical seminar session
included “Ventilation Designed & Built in Thailand’s Market,”
“UVC and HVAC Performance,” “Draft of Fan Regulation
for Energy Efficiency Labeling in Thailand” and “The Basics
of Sound.”
After lunch, AMCA members reassembled to hear news
and updates from the executive directors of AMCA International
and Asia AMCA. The Federation of Thai Industries also shared
information on the economy of Thailand. This year, Asia
AMCA staff invited the marketing and engineering committees
to meet together, and a productive discussion ensued. Members
were generous with feedback, and this sparked ideas for future
AMCA International Executive Director Mark Stevens content. The meeting ended with a buffet dinner, with plentiful
presents at the technical seminar in Ho Chi Minh City. opportunities for networking.
Asia AMCA’s booth at ACREX India. Asia AMCA’s booth at China Refrigeration Show.
ACREX SHOW 2017 China Refrigeration Show was specially designed to showcase
Asia AMCA participated in ACREX India 2017, which was the history of AMCA, tunnelling through the years that shaped
held at the India Exposition Mart in Delhi, India. This show is AMCA into what it is today. The booth educated members
focused not only on HVACR but also on more diverse building and other visitors about the different phases AMCA passed
engineering services, including electrical and plumbing, build- through as it progressed over the years.
ing automation and the ever-growing cold chain industry. As
always, Asia AMCA was glad to host the large number of AMCA 100-Year Anniversary
members who visited the booth for discussions and feedback. Celebration Dinner
To celebrate AMCA’s 100-year anniversary, Asia AMCA orga-
HVACR VIETNAM 2017 nized a dinner in Shanghai, China, at the Grand Mercure
Shanghai Century Park Hotel. Members from China, Taiwan,
India, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore attended the dinner
on April 13, 2017. AMCA’s executive director Mark Stevens
presented an update and a brief history of AMCA, discussing
how various milestones shaped AMCA into what it is today.
Goh Swee Lee, Asia AMCA’s executive director, then gave an
update on the Asia region specifically and presented a brief
history of Asia AMCA.
The anniversary dinner was informal, and it included a quiz
game to test members on how well they know AMCA. Results
showed that AMCA members know the association well, with
two tables tying for first place. Mark Stevens posed a final ques-
tion to determine the quiz winner. Overall, it was a night for
members and staff to socialize and enjoy one another’s company
Asia AMCA’s booth at HVACR/PS.
as they revisited the history of the association that brought them
Asia AMCA participated in the 11th HVACR/PS Vietnam together.
2017 exhibition this year. The event was held at the Saigon
Exhibition and Convention Center in Ho Chi Minh City on
March 29–31, 2017. Members in Vietnam and Southeast Asia
visited the Asia AMCA booth to converse with staff, and
manufacturers interested in joining AMCA also stopped by
for information.
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 29
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
BY AMIT AHUJA, GENERAL MANAGER, MAICO GULF
CHAIR, AMCA MIDDLE EAST REGION
MEMBER, AMCA BOARD OF DIRECTORS
m i d d l e e a s t a m c a u p d at e
The AMCA Middle East region continues to be a place of That increases the total number of certified products to 101.
growth in membership and participation in the AMCA Certified Between its initiatives, committees, conferences and
Ratings Program (CRP). The region has 27 members, 21 of marketing, the region’s activity increases month by month.
which participate in the CRP. The CRP in this region in par- AMCA looks forward to a continued uptick in participation
ticular is thriving, with a 15 percent growth over the past year. from manufacturers in the Middle East.
W W W. A M C A . O R G A M C A I N T E R NAT I O NA L inmotion Fa l l 2 0 1 7 31
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
BY NAZME MOHSINA
ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR OF CERTIFICATION PROGRAMS,
AMCA INTERNATIONAL
a m c a c r p u p d at e
The CRP continued its steady growth this year. As of June 30, product lines procured their wind-driven-sand certification — and
there was a total of 3,690 product lines certified, compared with there are many more of these certifications in the pipeline.
3,500 at the end of the last fiscal year. This shows a growth of 5.4 AMCA’s CRP department is continuing to improve in-house
percent over the last year. The total number of companies with processes. Staff members are now posting the catalog checklists
certified products is 270, which is a 12 percent gain since last for air movement and control products on the AMCA website for
year. The louver listing program also showed steady growth. The members, and they are modifying the CRP application forms to
number of louvers listed reached 76, up from 26. And seven louver auto-populate fields in the database.
AMCA Publication 11-16 standard will rely on the calculation methods in AMCA Standard
The main CRP document was revised this past year. Changes 207. In anticipation of the completion of AMCA Standard 208,
in this revision to AMCA Publication 11 includes an expanded the AMCA Publication 211 Committee will be working on
purpose, an updated definitions section, a simplified viola- requirements needed to add FEI to the CRP documents.
tions table and new rules regarding DBAs. AMCA Standard 210 Software
ANSI/AMCA Standards 207 and 208 The AMCA-Standard-210-based software used in the AMCA
AMCA Standard 207, Fan System Efficiency and Fan System lab is now available to AMCA-accredited laboratories. Test
Input Power Calculation, was completed and approved in the reports generated in XML will drastically reduce the time
last quarter. A committee is currently working on a new stan- spent checking catalog data.
dard: AMCA Standard 208, Calculation of the Fan Energy AMCA Publication 211
Index (FEI). Since FEI is a wire-to-air efficiency metric, this Changes are being made to AMCA Publication 211 to allow
certification of single-room air handlers and axial impellers.
Advertisers Index/Reader Service Information Included are the reporting requirements, as well as specific
ADVERTISING SALES ASHRAE JOURNAL rating statements and catalog requirements.
1791 Tullie Circle NE | Atlanta, GA 30329 | P: 404-636-8400 | F: 404321-5478 | www.ashrae.org
Publisher, W. Stephen Comstock | E-Mail: comstock@ashrae.org Large Diameter Ceiling Fan
Associate Publisher, ASHRAE Media Advertising | Greg Martin | E-Mail: gmartin@ashrae.org
Advertising Production Coordinator | Vanessa Johnson | E-Mail: vjohnson@ashrae.org
The DOE proposed to test all ceiling fans with blade spans
Company ..........................................................Page Company ..........................................................Page
less than or equal to seven feet (2 meters) using a test proce-
Web Page Web Page dure based on version 1.1 of the ENERGY STAR® test method.
2018 AMCA ASET Conference ......................... 27 Loren Cook...................................................... Cvr 2 Meanwhile, all high-volume ceiling fans with blade spans
info.hotims.com/65142-67 info.hotims.com/65142-45
greater than seven feet (2 meters) would be tested using a
Acme Engineering ................................................ 9 Loren Cook........................................................... 15 modified version of the AMCA Standard 230 test procedure.
info.hotims.com/65142-70 info.hotims.com/65142-46
AMCA Publication 211 was modified to account for this.
AHR Expo-Chicago 2018 ................................... 36 Mars Air Systems, Inc ....................................... 16 AMCA Publication 511
info.hotims.com/65142-71 info.hotims.com/65142-65 A revision of AMCA Publication 511 includes changes to the
backdraft damper leakage section, which allows manufacturers
AMCA Store......................................................... 34 Multi-Wing .......................................................... 16
info.hotims.com/65142-66 info.hotims.com/65142-69 to show compliance with the new code and regulation leakage
requirements for non-motorized dampers. This revision changes
Berner International ............................................ 8 New York Blower ........................................... Cvr 3
info.hotims.com/65142-48 info.hotims.com/65142-47
the testing requirements to obtain certification for backdraft
dampers. The backdraft damper leakage program now requires
ebm-papst, Inc ................................................... 25 Pottorff ................................................................. 21 three to five different sizes of dampers to be tested. Previously,
info.hotims.com/65142-55 info.hotims.com/65142-64
only one size backdraft damper had to be tested.
Foam Supplies Inc ............................................. 17 Ruskin Mfg Co ...................................................... 5 Database Rewrite
info.hotims.com/65142-49 info.hotims.com/65142-50
The CRP department is in the process of rewriting the database
Greenheck....................................................... Cvr 4 SystemAir............................................................. 35 in order to operate the program more efficiently. It will inter-
info.hotims.com/65142-51 info.hotims.com/65142-54 face with AMCA laboratories worldwide, as well as AMCA
Greenheck.............................................................. 7
independent laboratories, to follow up with members regarding
Ziehl-Abegg ......................................................... 33
info.hotims.com/65142-52 info.hotims.com/65142-73 contract tests, precertification tests and check tests.
a m c a p u b li c at i o n s and standards
PUBLI CATIO N
N
ICATIO
PU BL
AMCA 222-16
Application Manu
al for Air Curta
Air Movement
ins
and Control
Is your AMCA library up to date?
Association
2-17
International
A 20
AMC oting
lesho rol
Troub d Cont
ent anrnational
ovem
Air M ciation Inte
AsAso
USA
quarters -1893, amca.org
Head ts, IL 60004150 n
www.
orate on Heigh
Corp Arlingt Ph: +1-847-394-0
AMC sity Drive, rg n tional
Univer mca.o tion Interna
30 W. ions@a l Associa
unicat & Contro
comm ent
Air Movem
© 2017
AMCA 311-16
Certified Ratings Program Product Rating Manual for Fan
Sound Performance
AMCA 501-17
Louver Application Manual and Design Guide
AMCA 503-08
Fire, Ceiling (Radiation), Smoke and Fire/Smoke Dampers
Application Manual
AMCA 512-09
AMCA Listing Label Program
AMCA 513-14
Economizer Damper and Return Air Damper Secondary
Labeling Program
AMCA 600-16
Application Manual for Airflow Measurement Stations
AMCA 611-15
Certified Ratings Program - Product Rating Manual for
Airflow Measurement Stations
www.info.hotims.com/65142-66
Congratulations AMCA
We are honored to play a part in your history
and we look forward to the next century.
systemair.net | fantech.net
www.info.hotims.com/65142-54
2 in. wg 3 in. wg
BHP FEI RPM BHP F
RD
STA NDA
CA
ANSI/AM 210-16/
rd
Standa
ASHR AE 51-16
nda rd
Sta
Testing
thods of
tor y Me mic
Labora Aerodyna
STANDARDS
Certified
Fans for ance Ra
ting
Control
ent and al
Air Movem n Internation
ociatio
AssCorpor
AMCA
ate Headq
30 W. Universit
commun
uarters
y Drive,
ications@
AMCA 204-05 (R2012)
Arlington
amca.or
Heights,
IL 60004-1
g n Ph: +1-847-3
94-0150
893, USA
n www.am
ca.org
AMCA 207-17
AMCA 220-05
ASHRAE
l and
Internationa
© 2016 AMCA
AMCA 230-15
Laboratory Methods of Testing Air
Circulating Fans for Rating and
Certification
AMCA 240-15
Laboratory Methods of Testing
Positive Pressure Ventilators for
Aerodynamic Performance Rating
AMCA 250-12
Laboratory Methods of Testing Jet
Tunnel Fans for Performance
AMCA 260-13
Laboratory Methods of Testing
Induced Flow Fans for Rating
AMCA 300-14
Reverberant Room Method for
Sound Testing of Fans
AMCA 301-14
Methods for Calculating Fan Sound
Ratings from Laboratory Test Data
AMCA 500-D-12
Laboratory Methods of Testing
Dampers for Rating
AMCA 550-15
Test Method for High Velocity Wind
Driven Rain Resistant Louvers
AMCA 540-13
Test Method for Louvers Impacted
by Wind Borne Debris
© 2017 Greenheck