You are on page 1of 9

FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY

ACT of 2010
Financial Rehabilitation and Insolvency Act (FRIA):
 Governs all petitions filed after it has taken
effect.
 Governs all further proceedings in insolvency, Fair Valuation – means what a willing owner, not
suspension of payments and rehabilitation cases compelled to sell, would take, and a willing purchaser
pending at the time it became effective (except if would pay, when not compelled to buy.
the application of FRIA would not be feasible or
would work injustice) *In determining whether the debtor’s liabilities are
greater than his assets, reference must be made to the fair
Policy of the State: Encourage debtors, both natural valuation of his assets. The debtor’s assets must not, at fair
valuation, be sufficient to pay his debts.
and juridical persons, and their creditors to collectively
and realistically resolve and adjust competing claims and
Insolvency Law vs. Bankruptcy Law
property rights.
Insolvency laws operated on the petition of an
Specifically:
insolvent debtor to discharge him from his debts.
1. Ensure a timely, fair, transparent, effective, and
Bankruptcy laws operated on petition of a debtor’s
efficient rehabilitation or liquidation of debtors;
creditors for the purpose of applying his property to the
2. Ensure or maintain certainty and predictability in
payment of his debts.
commercial affairs;
3. Preserve and maximize the value of the assets
*Both bankruptcy and insolvency statures may be
of debtors; initiated by either creditor or debtor, and may be used for either
4. Recognize creditor rights; purpose.
5. Respect priority of claims;
6. Ensure equitable treatment of creditors who are Debtors covered by FRIA
similarly situated; and 1. Sole proprietorship duly registered with Dept. of
7. Facilitate a speedy and orderly liquidation of Trade and Industry
these debtors’ assets and the settlement of their 2. Partnership duly registered with the Securities
obligations. and Exchange Commission
3. Corporation duly organized and existing under
Insolvency – refers to the financial condition of a debtor Philippine laws
that is generally unable to pay its or his liabilities as they 4. Individual debtor who has become insolvent as
fall due in the ordinary course of business or has defined in the law (FRIA).
liabilities that are greater than its or his assets.
Debtors not covered by FRIA
 Balance Sheet Test – denotes the state of a 1. Banks
person whose liabilities are more than his 2. Insurance companies
assets. It is that relative condition of a man’s 3. Pre-need companies
assets and liabilities that the former if all made 4. National and Local government agencies or
immediately available, would not be sufficient to units
discharge the latter. 5. Unincorporated company
*In this sense, insolvency is similar to 6. Joint venture (not registered as partnership with
bankruptcy. the SEC)
7. Estate of deceased person
 Equity Test – the inability of a person to pay his 8. Trust
debts as they become due in the ordinary course
of his business. The person may be insolvent Claim – refers to all claims or demands of whatever
although he may be able to pay his debts at nature or character against the debtor or its property,
some future time on a settlement and winding up whether for money or otherwise, liquidated or
of his affairs. unliquidated, fixed or contingent, matured or unmatured,
*In this sense, the debtor is said to be illiquid
disputed or undisputed, including but not limited to:
not bankrupt.

1|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021


FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
 All claims of the government (whether national and Suspension of Payment Rules of Procedures for
or local) including taxes, tariffs and custom Insolvent Debtors (FLSP Rules).
duties
 Claims against directors and officers of the Involuntary Liquidation Proceedings – for juridical
debtor arising from the acts done in the debtors, jurisdiction over all persons affected by the
discharge of their functions falling within the proceedings is acquired upon publication of the petition
scope of their authority or motion under Section &, Rule 2(B) of the FLSP Rules.

*The claim must be against the debtor or its property.


Rehabilitation Court has no jurisdiction over claims of a debtor
against his own debtors or against third parties. - for individual debtors, jurisdiction over the
person of the debtor is acquired upon service of
*FRIA covers both monetary and non-monetary claims.
summons in accordance with Section 15, Rule 3(C).
Remedies of Insolvent Debtor:
Suspension of Payment Proceedings – jurisdiction over
1. Judicial (e.g., rehabilitation and suspension of
all persons affected by the proceedings is acquired upon
payment under FRIA)
the publication of Suspension of Payments Order.
2. Extrajudicial (e.g., dacion en pago)
*Any order issued by the court is under the procedural
Remedies under FRIA rules is immediately executory.
 Rehabilitation
o Voluntary Advantages of Judicial Remedies (FRIA)
o Involuntary 1. Retention of Management
o Pre-negotiated 2. Non-withholding of Supply
 Out-of-Court restructuring 3. Protection from certain actions and processes
 Liquidation 4. Exemption from taxes
o Voluntary 5. Compromise binding
o Involuntary 6. Cram-down Power
 Petition for suspension of payment (for individual 7. Binding effect of Rehabilitation Plan
debtors)
SUSPENSION OF PAYMENT – a petition for
Nature of Proceedings under FRIA suspension of payment is a remedy available to an
The proceedings under FRIA are proceedings in individual debtor who seeks to suspend the payments
rem. In rem actions are against the thing itself and they outside of the necessary or legitimate expenses of his
are binding upon the whole world. business while the proceedings are pending.
The court need not acquire jurisdiction over the
person of the defendant in actions in rem because they Who Can File: Only individual debtors can file a
are not directed against any person. The court need only petition for suspension of payment.
to acquire jurisdiction over the res.
*An individual debtor is a natural person who
Acquisition of Jurisdiction (FRIA) is a resident and a citizen of the Philippines who has
Rehabilitation Proceedings – the court acquires become insolvent.
jurisdiction over all persons affected by the proceedings
upon publication of the notice of the commencement of Who Cannot File:
the proceedings and the Commencement Order in any o Creditors cannot file a petition for
newspaper of general circulation in the Philippines for suspension of payment against the
two (2) consecutive weeks. debtor
o Corporations and other juridical persons
Voluntary Liquidation Proceedings – both juridical and o Non-Philippine citizen
individual debtors, jurisdiction over all persons affected
by the proceedings is acquired upon publication of the Venue – the petition is filed in the court having
Liquidation Order as provided in the Financial Liquidation jurisdiction over the province or city where the
2|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021
FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
debtor has resided for six (6) months before the *To form a majority, it is necessary that (i)
filing of the petition. 2/3 of the creditors voting unite upon the
same proposition and (ii) claims represented
by the majority vote amount at least 3/5 of
BASIC PROCEDURE: the total liabilities of the debtor mentioned in
the petition.
 Filing of Petition
o The debtor files his verified petition for *A creditor who incurred his credit within 90
suspension of payment and must attach days prior to the filing of the petition is not
the following: entitled to vote.
 Schedule of debts and liabilities
 Objections to Proposal
 Inventory of assets
o If any creditor has dissented from and
 Proposed agreement with the
creditors protested against the vote of the
majority (proposal and amendments
*The petition must indicate the names of approved by majority of the creditors
at least three (3) nominees to the during the
position of commissioner.
creditors’ meeting), may file an objection
GENERAL RULE: From the time of filing the petition with the court within 10 days from the
and for as long as proceedings remain pending, no date of the last creditors’ meeting.
creditor can sue or institute proceedings to collect his
claim.
o GROUNDS:
EXCEPTION:
 Creditors having claims for personal labor,  Defects in the call for the
maintenance, expense of last illness, etc., meeting, in the holding thereof
incurred within 60 days immediately before and in the deliberations had
filing. which prejudiced the rights of
 Secured creditors the creditors;
 Fraudulent connivance between
 Action on Petition one or more creditors and the
o If the court finds the petition sufficient in individual debtor to vote in favor
form and substance, it will, within five (5) of the proposed agreement;
working days from the filing the petition,  Fraudulent conveyance of
issue the Suspension Order. claims for the purpose of
obtaining a majority.
 Notification through Publication and Notices 
o The Order is published in a newspaper  Hearing and Issuance of Order
of general circulation in the province or o The court must hear and pass upon
city in which the petition is filed once a such objection within 30 days from the
week for two (2) consecutive weeks. date of filing and in a summary manner.
o The first publication should be made
within seven (7) days from the time of IF APPROVED PROPOSED AGREEMENT IS
the issuance of the Order. ANNULLED BY THE COURT: The court will declare the
proceedings terminated and the creditors will be at
 Creditors’ Meeting and Voting by Creditors liberality to exercise their rights which may correspond to
o The creditors will meet on the time, date them.
and place designated by the court in the
Order. IF APPROVED PROPOSED AGREEMENT IS UPHELD
*The presence of creditors holding claims at OR NO OPPOSITION: The court will order that the
least 3/5 of the liabilities is necessary in agreement be carried out and all parties bound thereby
holding the meeting. to comply with its terms.
o The creditors and the individual debtor
will discuss the propositions in the Commissioner – will preside the creditors’ meeting in
proposed agreement and put them to a connection with the proceedings.
vote.
3|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021
FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
1. Debtor has assets that can generate more cash
Qualifications: if used in its daily operations than if sold
1. Must be a natural person 2. Liquidity issues can be addressed by a
2. Citizen of the Philippines or a resident in practicable business plan that will generate
the Philippines for six (6) months enough cash to sustain daily operations
immediately preceding his appointment 3. Debtor has a definite source of financing for the
3. Of good moral character and with proper and full implementation of the
acknowledged integrity, impartiality and Rehabilitation Plan that is anchored on realistic
independence assumptions and goals.
4. Has the requisite knowledge of
insolvency laws, rules and procedures Infeasible Rehabiliation Plan:
5. Has no conflict of interest 1. Absence of a sound workable business plan
2. Baseless and unexplained assumptions, targets
Prohibited Transactions and goals
The following are prohibited upon the issuance 3. Speculative capital infusion or complete lack
of the Order and while the so long as the proceedings thereof for the execution of the business plan
relative to the suspension of payments are pending: 4. Cash flow cannot sustain daily operations
5. Negative net worth and the assets are near full
depreciation or fully depreciated.
1. Sale, transfer, encumbrance or disposition by
the individual debtor of his property
a. EXCEPT: Those used in the ordinary Court-supervised Rehabilitation
operations of commerce or industry in  Voluntary – if an insolvent debtor initiates the
which the petitioning individual debtor is rehabilitation proceedings
engaged.
2. Individual debtor is prohibited from making any To file the petition, there must be
payments outside of the necessary or legitimate approval from:
expenses of his business or industry. (i) Owner in case of single
proprietorship
REHABILITATION – refers to the restoration of the (ii) Majority of the partners in
debtor to a condition of successful operation and case of partnership
solvency, if it is shown that its continuance of operation (iii) Majority of vote of the board
is economically feasible and its creditors can recover by and vote of stockholders
way of the present value of payments projected in the representing at least 2/3 of
Rehabilitation Plan. capital stock in case of
corporations
Types:
 Court-supervised: Voluntary  Involuntary – if a creditor or group of creditors
 Court-supervised: Involuntary (with aggregate claims of at least P1 million or at
 Pre-negotiated least 25% of subscribed capital or partners’
 Out-of-court of Informal contribution) initiates the rehabilitation
proceedings
Purpose:
1. To efficiently and equitably distribute the Venue for Petition
assets of the insolvent debtor to its  Sole Proprietorship
creditors o the petition must be filed in the RTC
2. To provide the debtor with a fresh start which has jurisdiction over the principal
office of the debtor
*If rehabilitation is not feasible, the appropriate  Corporation, Partnership or Association
proceeding would be a liquidation proceeding instead of a
(principal office in Metro Manila)
rehabilitation proceeding.
o the petition must be filed in the RTC of
Economically Feasible Rehabilitation Plan the city or municipality where the hear
(Characteristics): office is located

4|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021


FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
* If petition involves a group of debtors, the same g. Exact address at which documents
must be filed in the RTC which has jurisdiction regarding the debtor and the
over the principal office of any of the debtors proceedings may be reviewed and
alleged to be insolvent
copied
h. Documents showing that there is
Requirements and Contents
substantial likelihood that the debtor
 By the debtor/s:
may be rehabilitated
1. Petition must be verified
2. Must set forth with sufficient particularity
all of the following material facts:
a. Name, business, and principal BASIC PROCEDURE:
address and other addresses of
the debtor;  Filing of Petition
b. Nature of the business and o Insolvent Debtor: By filing a petition with
principal activities of the debtor, the court on the grounds provided in the
and the addresses where these FRIA. The petition must be verified to
activities are conducted; establish the insolvency of the debtor
c. History of the debtor and the viability of its rehabilitation.
d. Fact and cause of debtor’s o Creditor/s: By filing a petition for
insolvency rehabilitation with the court on the
e. Specific relief sought grounds provided in the FRIA. The
petition must be verified to establish the
substantial likelihood that the debtor
f. Grounds upon which the petition may be rehabilitated.
is based

g. All pending actions or


 Action for Petition
proceedings by or against the
If the court finds the petition for
debtor and the courts or tribunal
rehabilitation sufficient in form and in
where such are pending;
substance, it will, within five (5) working
h. Threats or demands to enforce
days from filing the petition, issue a
claims or liens against the
Commencement Order.
debtor
i. Manner by which the debtor
If the court finds the petition deficient in
may be rehabilitated
substance and in form, it may, in its
j. Exact address at which
discretion, give the petitioner/s a
documents regarding the debtor
reasonable period of time within which
and the proceedings may be
to:
reviewed and copied
 amend or supplement the
petition
 By the creditor/s:
a. Name, business, and principal address  submit such documents as may
and other addresses of the debtor; be necessary
b. Nature of the business and principal  put the petition in proper order
activities of the debtor;
*In this case, the five (5) working
c. Circumstances sufficient to support the
days shall be reckoned from the
petition to initiate involuntary
date of the filing of the amended or
rehabilitation proceedings; supplemental petition or the
d. Specific relief sought; submission or the submission of
e. Rehabilitation Plan; such documents.
f. Names of at least three (3) nominees to
the position of rehabilitation receiver *If the deficiency is not complied
(with qualifications, office and email within the extended five-day period,
addresses); the court will DISMISS the petition.

5|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021


FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
When COMMENCEMENT ORDER is issued: be entitled to receive distributions arising
The order will set the case for initial hearing, from the proceedings although he is not
which will not be more than 40 days from the entitled to participate.
date of filing of the petition.
 Challenge of Claims
 Publication of Commencement Order and o Within 30 days from the expiration of the
Delivery of Notices period to inspect the registry of claims,
o The Order is published in a newspaper the debtors, creditors and stakeholders
of general circulation in the province or may submit their challenge to claim/s to
city in which the petition is filed once a the court.
week for two (2) consecutive weeks. o Upon the expiration of the 30-day
o The first publication should be made period, the rehabilitation receiver must
within seven (7) days from the time of submit to the court the registry of claims.
the issuance of the Order.
*The aggrieved party may seek the review of
HOW NOTICES DELIVERD: the decision of the rehabilitation receiver by
filing a motion with the rehabilitation court
 If petitioner is the debtor: There
within five (5) days from receipt of
will be service by personal rehabilitation receiver’s decision.
delivery of a copy of the petition
on each creditor holding at least  Initial Hearing and Subsequent Hearings
10% of the total liabilities of the o At the initial hearing, the court will:
debtor within five (5) days.  Determine the creditors who
 If petitioner is the creditor: Direct have made timely and proper
the service by personal delivery filing of their notice of claims;
of a copy of the petition on the  Hear and determine any
debtor within five (5) days. objection to the qualifications or
the appointment of the
rehabilitation receiver (and if
 Establishment of Registry of Claims necessary, appoint one);
o Within 20 days from rehabilitation
receiver’s assumption of office, he must
establish a preliminary registry of claims.
o Rehabilitation receiver must make
 Direct the creditors to comment
registry available for public inspection on the petition and
and provide publication notice by Rehabilitation Plan;
publishing the place and date of  Direct the rehabilitation receiver
inspection in a newspaper of general to evaluate the financial
circulation once every week for two (2) condition of the debtor and to
consecutive weeks. prepare and submit to the court
within 40 days from the initial
* The period of inspection cannot exceed 15
hearing a report (provided in
days from the last publication.
Sec. 24 of the FRIA).
 Filing of Creditor’s Claim  Determine the reasonableness
o The creditors must file their claim at of the rehabilitation receiver’s
fees stated in the Rehabilitation
least five (5) days before the initial
Plan (which will be presumed
hearing.
reasonable unless the creditors
*If a creditor fails to file their claim in object on it)
accordance with the Commencement Order
and such is not listed in the schedule of *The court may hold additionall
debts and liabilities will not be entitled to hearing as may be necessary to
participate in the rehabilitation proceedings. continue the initial hearing process
However, if he files a belated claim, he will but these hearings must be
concluded not later than 90 days
6|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021
FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
from the first hearing date fixed in o If the petition is given due course, the
the Commencement Order. court will issue an order directing the
rehabilitation receiver to call a meeting
 Creditor’s Comment on the Petition and with the debtor and all classes of
Rehabilitation Plan creditors.
o The creditors will submit their comments
to the court and rehabilitation receiver *The meeting will take place in not less than
within 20 days from the initial hearing. 2 weeks nor more than 4 weeks from the
date of the order to consider the organization
 Submission of Report of Rehabilitation of a creditors’ committee.
Receiver
o The rehabilitation receiver will submit its o A creditors’ committee may be
report to the court within 40 days from organized if the creditors, representing
the initial hearing stating his preliminary at least a majority of all the claims as
findings and recommendation, whether: reflected in the registry of claims, cast
 The debtor is insolvent; their votes for its creation.
 The underlying assumptions,
financial goals and procedures CREDITORS’ COMMITTEE: Will be
to accomplish in the composed of a representative from each of
Rehabilitation Plan are realistic, the following classes:
feasible and reasonable;  Secured Creditors
 There is substantial likelihood  Unsecured Creditors
for the debtor to be successfully  Trade Creditors and Suppliers
rehabilitated;  Employees of the debtor
 The petition should be
dismissed;  Creditors’ Meeting to Approve Rehabilitation
 The debtor should be dissolved Plan
or liquidated o After the rehabilitation receiver reviews
and revises the Rehabilitation Plan, he
will notify the creditors and stakeholders
that the plan is ready for their
examination.
o Within 20 days from the notification, he
will convene the creditors for the
 Grant or Dismissal of Petition or Conversion
of Proceedings
o Within 10 days from receipt of the report purposes of voting on the approval of
of the rehabilitation receiver, the court the plan.
may: o The rehabilitation receiver will notify the
 Give due course to the petition court, the creditors or the creditors’
 Dismiss the petition committee and the stakeholders of the
 Convert the proceedings into approval or the rejection of the Plan
one for the liquidation of the within five (5) days from such voting.
debtor
 Submission of Rehabilitation Plan to the
 Consultation with Debtors and Creditors Court
o If the court gives due course to the o Within five (5) days from the receipt of
petition, the rehabilitation receiver must the Plan submitted by the rehabilitation
confer with the debtor and all of the receiver, the court will notify the
creditors, and may consider their views creditors that the Rehabilitation Plan has
and proposals in the review, revision or been submitted for confirmation.
preparation of a new Rehabilitation Plan. o Creditors may either obtain copy of the
plan or file an objection thereto.
 Formation of Creditors’ Committee
7|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021
FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
 Filing of Objections IF MOTION IS GRANTED: The court will
o The creditors may file their objection set the proposed amendments for
within 20 days from receipt of notice hearing not later than 15 days from the
from the court. date of the order.

Objections to the Rehabilitation Plan are  Termination of Proceedings


limited to the following grounds: o The rehabilitation proceedings are, upon
 Creditors’ support was induced motion by any stockholder or the
by fraud rehabilitation receiver, terminated by
 Documents or data relied upon order of the court either declaring a
in the Rehabilitation Plan are successful implementation of the Plan or
materially false and misleading a failure of rehabilitation.
 Rehabilitation Plan is in fact not
supported by the voting THERE IS FAILURE OF REHABILITATION
creditors IN THE FF CASES:
 Court dismisses the petition
 Hearing on Objections  Debtor fails to submit a
o The court will issue an order setting the Rehabilitation Plan
time and date for the hearing/s on the  No substantial likelihood that the
objections. debtor can be rehabilitated within a
o If it finds merit in the objection, it will reasonable period
order the rehabilitation receiver or other  Commission of fraud in securing
party to cure the defect, whenever approval of the Plan or its
feasible. amendments
o If it finds that the debtor acted in bad  Court does not confirm the Plan
faith or that it is not feasible to cure the  Failure of the debtor to comply with
defect, it will convert the proceedings the FLSP Rules, Rules of Court, or
into one for the liquidation of the debtor. any order of the Court.

 Court Action
o If no objections were filed within the COMMENCEMENT ORDER
period of 20 days, or if objections lack in Contents:
merit, the court will issue an order  Declare that the debtor is under rehabilitation.
confirming the Rehabilitation Plan.  Appoint rehabilitation receiver who may or may
not be from among the nominees of the
*The court has a maximum period of one (1) petitioners
year from the date of filing of the petition to  Prohibit the debtor’s suppliers of goods or
confirm a Rehabilitation Plan. services from withholding the supply of goods
and services in the ordinary course of business
(as long as debtor pays after the issuance of the
 Amendments to the Approved Rehabilitation Commencement Order)
Plan 
o After the confirmation of the
Rehabilitation Plan, the debtor,  Authorize the payment of administrative
rehabilitation receiver or any creditor expenses as they become due
may file a verified motion for leave to  Set the case for initial hearing
amend the Plan.
Effects:
*The motion must state the reasons  Vest the rehabilitation receiver with all the powers and
warranting the amendment of the Plan and functions provided for in the FRIA
the proposed amendments, with a copy  Prohibit or otherwise serve as the legal basis for
given to the rehabilitation receiver. rendering null and void the results of any extrajudicial
activity or process to seize property or attempt to

8|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021


FINANCIAL REHABILITATION and INSOLVENCY
ACT of 2010
collect on or enforce a claim against the debtor after  Criminal action against the individual debtor or
the commencement date owner, partner, director or officer of a debtor
 Serve as the legal basis for rendering null and void
any set-off after the commencement date of any debt
owed to the debtor by any of the creditors
 Serve as the legal basis for rendering null and void
the perfection of any lien against the debtor’s property
after the commencement date
 Consolidate the resolution of all legal proceedings by
and against the debtor to the court

Effectivity and Duration


The Order is effective for the duration of the
rehabilitation proceedings, unless:
 earlier lifted by the Court
 Rehabilitation Plan is seasonably confirmed or
approved
 Rehabilitation proceedings are ordered
terminated by the Court

SUSPENSION ORDER
Effects:
 Suspend all actions or proceedings, in court or
otherwise, for enforcement of claims against the
debtor
 Suspends all actions to enforce any judgment,
attachment or other provisional remedies against
the debtor
 Prohibit the debtor from selling, encumbering,
transferring or disposing in any manner any of its
properties (except in the ordinary course of
business)
 Prohibits the debtor from making any payments
of its liabilities outstanding as of the
commencement date (except as may be
provided)

Does not apply to:


 Cases already pending appeal in the Supreme
Court as of commencement date.
 Cases pending or filed at a specialized court or
quasi-judicial agency which, upon determination
by the court, is capable of resolving the claim
more quickly, fairly and efficiently than the
rehabilitation court.
 Enforcement of claims against sureties and other
persons solidarily liable with the debtor, and

accommodation mortgagors or issues of letters


of credit
 Any form of action of customers or clients of a
securities market participant to recover or
otherwise claim moneys and securities entrusted
to the latter in the ordinary course of business

9|Page Lovely Balagon Orais|2021

You might also like