20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth?

ion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

 8   Has a… Close

Posted by u/deftius 2 years ago 

Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes
sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in
depth?
i was comparing the Richter account with the Gardiner one.
Gardiner rushes it through like any of the other chorus bits in the
passion. Richter on the other hand recognises this 2 bar phrase for
the grand chorale that it actually is. He spreads it out for a good 30
seconds. And there you notice the immensity of it all, a canon in the
beginning, the three imitative sequences in the end, and the 7+
cadences that occupy that space. I was just wondering if somebody
like schweitzer ever analysed it. Because i feel they could do a much
better job than i could

 2 Comments  Share  73% Upvoted

This thread is archived

 New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast

SORT
BEST
BY

[deleted] · 2y

Homework assignment?

 1  Share 

deftius OP · 2y

Nope. I dont study music. But i was comparing the Richter

account with the Gardiner one. Gardiner rushes it through
like any of the other chorus bits in the passion. Richter on
the other hand recognises this 2 bar phrase for the grand
chorale that it actually is. He spreads it out for a good 30
seconds. And there you notice the immensity of it all, a
canon in the beginning, the three imitative sequences in
the end, and the 7+ cadences that occupy that space. I
was just wondering if somebody like schweitzer ever
analysed it. Because i feel they could do a much better job
than i could

 5  Share 

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 1/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

More posts from the classicalmusic community

Search
Posted by u/Hadi_Karimi 4 days ago 2 2 2

Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky (3D Sculpture) Artwork/Painting

 1.8k   48 Comments  Share 

PROMOTED • Posted by u/Macrosentiment 3 months ago 7 14 14 13

AI-based weekly indicators for stocks, the S&P 500, and

Forex — with 70% win rate

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 2/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://macrosentiments.com View More

 Vote   369 Comments  Share

Posted by u/DimFakJimKK 3 days ago

Happy birthday to Erik Satie, born 17th May, 1866,

Normandy

 1.1k   21 Comments  Share 

Posted by u/gustavmahler273 3 days ago 2

I was searching for a Photography of Mahler and Strauss

forever and finally found one!Details in comments.
https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 3/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Photograph
Search

 576   22 Comments  Share 

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 4/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 5/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 6/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 7/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 8/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 9/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 10/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 11/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 12/13
20/5/2021 Has anybody analyzed 'Wahrlich dieser ist gottes sohn gewesen' from Bachs Matthew Passion in depth? : classicalmusic

Search

Continue browsing in r/classicalmusic

https://www.reddit.com/r/classicalmusic/comments/990b79/has_anybody_analyzed_wahrlich_dieser_ist_gottes/ 13/13