The paper entitled: "Multiple time-frequency curve extraction Matlab code and its application

to automatic bearing fault diagnosis under time-varying speed conditions". Using Time-
Frequency Curve Extraction (MTFCE) a derivatives of TFR methode to automatic diagnosis
of bearing fault under time-varying speed conditions. TFR methode is a scanner for faults
diagnosis;

Traditional time-frequency domain analyzes are not feasible to achieve these results; is really
an interesting work. The diagnosis methodology is well presented and explained, the results
are proven and evaluation criteria were taken meticulously. I did not find just to wish to
authors more wonderful researches. Really is good work and it shows that the authors are
experts in the diagnosis of machines.

An interesting work however the authors need to take into account the following small
remarks:

 The literature review is too weak. Just a small deep comparison between the previous
works and the current one;
 What happen if we used MTFCE to detect other faults,
 If we extract the exact features of bearing fault, we may not need to take extra steps or
compare this study;
 Have different loads been used?
 Your search contains several variables it will be better if you place it in Nomenclature,
 The article is suitable for publication ..;
 In conclusion, the work seems suitable for industrial application;
 In favor not use references for more than five years…;
 Missing schema of the test bench;
 Missing parameters of the machines;
 Enhance your references by adding other works.