Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Review Article
Citaon: Zeng Z, Tay WC, Saito T, Thinn KK, Liu EH (2018) Dicult Airway Management during Anesthesia: A Review of the Incidence and Soluons.
J Anaesthesiol Crit Care. Vol 1 No.1:5
Introducon
Abstract Predicon of dicult airway management and the
preparaon of advanced equipment and the skill to use them
Objecve: We determined the incidence and predicve can prevent poor outcomes when dicules are encountered.
factors of dicult airway problems, and the devices used to
solve the problems, in paents having general anesthesia. Hence we use a standardized preoperave airway assessment
of all paents, comprising Mallampa view, neck movement,
Methods: We reviewed reported dicult airway cases in thyromental distance, mouth opening and presence of loose
37,805 paents who underwent general anesthesia from teeth or gaps in denon, to enable adequate preparaon.
May 2011 to October 2013. Data were obtained from a Failure to intubate the trachea is not in itself life threatening,
procedural audit system implemented in our instute.
but repeated aempts may traumaze the airway, make airway
rescue more dicult, leading to failed oxygenaon, and even
Results and conclusion: There were 885 (2.3%) paents
with dicult airway problems. The incidence of diculty mortality [1,2]. We emphasized oxygenaon, avoiding mulple
encounter with tracheal intubaon, supragloc airways and aempts at device inseron, and changing to an alternave
mask venlaon were 4.7%, 0.4% and 1.0%, respecvely. Of airway management method early.
ear ly.
the 805 paents with dicult tracheal intubaon, tracheal
intubaon failed in 11 (0.1%) paents and 3 of these While the range of available devices is wide, we had idened
paents needed tracheotomy. The main risk factors of a in our department four core devices to train our sta with, for
© Under License of Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License | This article is available from: http://www.imedpub.com/journal-anaesthesiology-critical-care/ 1
surgical speciales. The Domain Specic Review Board was extension, short thyromental distance, limited mouth opening,
informed of our audit work and advised that consent from poor denon and Mallampa IV oropharyngeal view. We
paents was not required for such audit work. The audit system calculated the sensivity and specicity of these factors in
recorded the paent’s characteriscs, anesthesia techniques, predicng diculty and also the posive and negave predicve
problems and dicules encountered and crical and adverse values of the presence of these factors.
incidents.
the need
We notedforthe methods
addional devices to achieve tracheal intubaon.
used to solve the dicult airway
Mask Ventilation 1708 17 1 0 0
a dicult “me
inducon airway is ancipated
out”, is the
during which checked again
identy at the
of the pre-
paent, Bronchospasm 15 1.7
history of allergies, funconing of monitors, and ancipaon of
Laryngospasm 10 1.1
blood loss are also checked. Subsequent preparaon of a
bougie, videolaryngoscope or other device for dicult airway Dental trauma 6 0.7
Table 3 Success rates of rescue devices aer failed inial intubaon aempts using a Macintosh laryngoscope.
In 605 cases where the rst aempt with direct laryngoscopy paents. Failed SGA placement occurred in 34 (0.2%) paents,
was unsuccessful, bougies were the rst addional device used. where further aempts were stopped, and the paents’ airways
In these paents, some poron of the laryngeal inlet could be were managed with mask venlaon or tracheal intubaon.
seen and there was successful intubaon in 600 cases (99.2%). There was concurrent dicult tracheal intubaon in 9 of these
Bougies were also used with other laryngoscopes, and overall, paents. When faced with a dicult SGA placement, a dierent
enabled successful intubaon in 686 (85.2%) of cases when used SGA type was aempted in 21 of these paents and only 11
with a Macintosh laryngoscope, McCoy laryngoscope or (52.4%) were successful.
videolarnygoscope. Videolaryngoscopes were the next most
common technique used aer diculty with the Macintosh Difcult mask venlaon
laryngoscope and intubaon was successful in 76.9%.
Videolaryngoscopes were used as the rst device, instead of the Among paents for whom mask venlaon was the planned
Macintosh laryngoscope, for tracheal intubaon in 37 paents method of airway management, there was dicult mask
and was successful in 29 paents (78.4%). venlaon in 17 (1.0%) paents, requiring the assistant to help
and the use of addional devices. While there were no paents
The LMA Fastrach was used for tracheal intubaon in seven with impossible mask venlaon, the anesthesiologists did not
paents, all successfully. Flexible bronchoscopy was used in six connue struggling with dicult mask venlaon. SGAs were
paents as a planned awake procedure prior to inducon of used to overcome the diculty in 9 paents, tracheal intubaon
anesthesia. In two paents, exible bronchoscopy was used in 6 paents and exible bronchoscopic intubaon in 2 paents.
aer failure with direct
di rect laryngoscopy and videolaryngoscopy
videolar yngoscopy..
Among the 885 paents, dicult airway management had
In 11 paents (0.06%), failed intubaon was diagnosed aer
aempts with addional devices failed, and further aempts at been ancipated in 524 (59.2%) paents aer pre anesthesia
evaluaon. These 524 paents were 5.1% of the 9684 paents
tracheal intubaon were stopped. Three of these 11 paents in whom diculty had been ancipated. This incidence was four
required urgent tracheotomy,
tracheotomy, during which mask venlaon was fold higher than in paents for whom diculty was not
maintained. In eight paents, SGAs were successfully used to ancipated.
maintain oxygenaon. In one of these 11 paents, the airway
was maintained with mask venlaon throughout anesthesia, The sensivity, specicity and predicve values of the
aer intubaon aempts failed. In 2 paents, decisions were indicators used in pre-anesthesia evaluaon are noted in Table
subsequently made to stop anesthesia, awaken the paents, and 4. The posive predicve values were low, while the negave
postpone surgery. Transient hypoxia had occurred aer dicult predicve values were high. All the indicators: high Mallampa
intubaon in four paents, but no paents had severe hypoxia class, short thyromental distance, limited neck movement,
that resulted in neurological injury.
i njury. limited mouth opening, poor denon, high BMI, increased the
risk of dicult airway management. The magnitude of increased
risk was greatest with short thyromental distance and limited
Difcult supragloc airway placement
neck movement.
Among paents for whom SGAs were the planned method of
Negative
Non difficult Positive Predictive Predictive Value
Difficult airway (n) airway (n) Odds Ratio (95% CI) S ensitivity (%) Specificity (%) Value (%) (%)
No 361 27236 - - - - -
No 784 34456 - - - - -
No 841 36240 - - - - -
Mallampati classification
Thyromental distance
Normal 67
672 35915 - - - - -
Mouth opening
Normal 80
809 36143 - - - - -
Neck extension
Normal 79
793 36314 - - - - -
Teeth
videolaryngoscope should be used early and that bougies be unancipated dicult airways, and being prepared. There was
used together with the videolaryngoscope in “can see cannot low sensivity and specicity, and very low posive predicve
intubate situaons”. In our audit, there was no airway trauma value of the airway evaluaon and individual risk factors in our
caused by the videolaryngoscopes, but we should also avoid paents. This is similar to other more extensive and complicated
mulple aempts with videolaryngoscopes, to prevent swelling airway evaluaon systems, which all also had limited sensivity
and bleeding in the airway [14]. and specicity [9,19,20]. Many paents in whom diculty was
ancipated eventually had easy airway management, with only
In our paents, the rate of dicult SGA inseron was much
lower than that of dicult tracheal intubaon. It is possible that 5.1% having dicult airways. Conversely, in paents evaluated
as not having a dicult airway, the negave predicve value was
many dicult intubaon situaons were avoided by using SGAs
very high and 98.7% did not have any problems. The residual
instead. SGAs now feature in all dicult airway algorithms, to
1.3% had unancipated diculty.
enable oxygenaon and venlaon [15,16]. While SGAs may not
provide the same level of protecon against aspiraon of We suggest that tests not only be directed at dicult
regurgitated stomach contents, SGAs such as the LMA Proseal laryngoscopy and intubaon, but also for dicult mask
and Igel have channels for inseron of gastric tubes that enable venlaon, dicult SGA, dicult surgical airway. In our paents,
drainage and reducon of the volume of stomach contents. short thyromental distance was the strongest predictor of a
However, we cauon against over reliance on SGAs, as dicult dicult airway. Thyromental distance is considered to be an
SGA inseron can also occur in paents in whom intubaon is indicator of mandibular space [21] and reects whether
dicult. An earlier review found the rate of dicult venlaon displacement of the tongue by the laryngoscope blade will be
with an SGA to be 0.5% [17]. The failed SGA inseron cases in easy or dicult. We included checking for limited neck
our review mostly involved inadequate venlaon due to gas movement, limited mouth opening and poor denon to
leaks. SGA inseron was abandoned and tracheal intubaon prevent unancipated diculty due to these factors. In
used instead, but a substanal proporon of these also had parcular, severely limited mouth opening would require
dicult tracheal intubaon requiring the use of bougies and alternave methods such as bronchoscopic nasal intubaon or
videolaryngoscopes. We suggest that it is also important to subgloc surgical airways. Despite the limitaons of this simple
avoid mulple aempts at SGA inseron, as these aempts can evaluaon, our results suggest that it prevents unancipated
traumaze the airway, making subsequent mask venlaon, diculty with inseron of a laryngoscope or SGA. The paents
tracheal intubaon or exible bronchoscosopy dicult or who did have unancipated dicult airways had anatomical
impossible. variaons that could be managed with bougies and
videolaryngoscopes.
In our study, there were no paents in whom failed mask
venlaon, failed SGA placement and failed tracheal intubaon There are a few limitaons of our study. As a teaching
all occurred and had not been ancipated. Only a very small hospital, we have a wide range of clinical experience and
number of paents required a subgloc surgical airway. In all competency and it is possible that some airways diagnosed as
three paents, the diculty had been ancipated and the dicult by more junior anaesthests may not be dicult in
surgical team was present to carry out emergency surgical more experienced hands. Secondly, although diculty was
tracheotomy. None of the paents had cricothyrotomy by the ancipated in many paents, only a small proporon was
anesthesiologists, suggesng that it is very unlikely that the eventually reported as being dicult, as SGAs were used
anesthesiologists will ever gain adequate personal experience instead. Thirdly, the wide use of SGA will result in lower rates of
with cricothyrotomy.
are the only pragmacTraining
methodsintosimulators
gain skill. and animal models
dicult intubaon, but this reects contemporary pracce.
2. Caplan RA, Benumof JL, Berry FA, Bli CD, Bode RH, et al. (2003) 12. Asai T, Liu EH, Matsumoto S, Hirabayashi Y, Seo N, et al. (2009) Use
Pracce guidelines for management of the dicult airway: an of the Pentax-AWS in 293 paents with dicult airways.
updated report by the American Society of Anesthesiologists task Anesthesiol 110: 898-904.
force on management of the dicult airway. Anesthesiology 98:
13. Griesdale DE, Liu D, McKinney J, Choi PT (2012) Glidescope(R)
1269-1277.
video-laryngoscopy versus direct laryngoscopy for endotracheal
3. Benumof JL (1991) Management of the dicult adult airway. With intubaon: A systemac review and meta-analysis. Can J Anaesth
special emphasis on awake tracheal intubaon. Anesthesiology 59: 41-52.
75: 1087-1110.
14. Asai T (2013) Strategies for dicult airway management-the
4. Tachibana N, Niiyama Y, Yamakage M (2015) Incidence of cannot current state is not ideal. J Anesth 27: 157-160.
intubate-cannot venlate (CICV): Results of a 3 year retrospecve
15. Apfelbaum JL, Hagberg CA, Caplan RA, Bli CD, Connis RT, et al.
mulcenter clinical study in a network of university hospitals. J
(2013) Pracce guidelines for management of the dicult airway:
Anesth 29: 326-330.
an updated report by the American Society of Anesthesiologists
5. Combes X, Jabre P, Margenet A, Merle JC, Leroux B, et al. (2011) task force on management of the dicult airway. Anesthesiol 118:
Unancipated dicult airway management in the prehospital 251-270.
emergency seng: Prospecve validaon of an algorithm.
16. Henderson JJ, Popat MT, Lao IP, Pearce AC (2004) Dicult Airway
Anesthesiol 114: 105-110.
Society guidelines for management of the unancipated dicult
6. Davies S, Ananthanarayan C, Castro C (2001) Asymptomac lingual intubaon. Anesthesia 59: 675-694.
tonsillar hypertrophy and dicult airway management: A report
17. Saito T, Liu W, Chew STH, Ti LK (2015) Incidence of and risk factors
of three cases. Can J Anaesth 48: 1020-1024.
for dicult venlaon via a supragloc airway device in a
7. Cook TM, Woodall N, Frerk C (2011) Major complicaons of populaon of 14 480 paents from south-east Asia. Anesthesia
airway management in the UK: Results of the Fourth Naonal 70: 1079-1083.
Audit Project of the Royal College of Anaesthests and the
18. Liu EH, Asai T (2015) Cannot intubate cannot venlate—focus on
Dicult Airway Society. Part 1: Anesthesia. Br J Anaesth 106:
the 'venlate'. J Anesth 29: 323-325.
617-631.
19. Adnet F (2000) Dicult mask venlaon: an underesmated
8. Asai T (2012) Videolaryngoscopes: Do they truly have roles in
aspect of the problem of the dicult airway? Anesthesiol 92:
dicult airways? Anesthesiol 116: 515-517.
1217-1218.
9. Shiga T, Wajima Z, Inoue T, Sakamoto A (2005) Predicng dicult
20. Ramachandran SK, Mathis MR, Tremper KK, Shanks AM, Kheterpal
intubaon in apparently normal paents: A meta-analysis of
S (2012) Predictors and clinical outcomes from failed Laryngeal
bedside screening test performance. Anesthesiol 103: 429-437.
Mask Airway Unique: a study of 15,795 paents. Anesthesiol 116:
10. Samsoon GL, Young JR (1987) Dicult tracheal intubaon: A 1217-1226.
retrospecve study. Anesth 42: 487-490.
21. Randell T (1996) Predicon of dicult intubaon. Acta
11. Cook TM, Woodall N, Harper J, Benger J (2011) Major Anaesthesiol Scand 40: 1016-1023.
complicaons of airway management in the UK: Results of the
Fourth Naonal Audit Project of the Royal College of Anaesthests
and the Dicult Airway Society. Part 2: Intensive Care and
Emergency Department. Br J Anaesth 106: 632-642.