Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sae 20tofhp10
Sae 20tofhp10
WE INNOVATE.
Imitation is easy.
Innovation is hard work.
Leighton Lee II was an innovator. He founded
our company on that spirit, and it’s how we
solve tough problems today. Every product
you see here—from miniature check and relief
valves to shuttle valves, flow controls, precision
orifices and plugs—was developed to solve a
customer’s fluid control challenge. Since 1948,
we’ve been delivering engineered solutions
for a wide variety of demanding applications.
We have the experience, product breadth, and
technical know-how to provide engineered
performance, with zero risk. Don’t let an imitator
ruin your day—or your design. Contact us
today to put our knowledge to work for you.
®
2 Pettipaug Rd, Westbrook CT 06498-0424
860-399-6281 | 1-800-LEE PLUG | www.leeimh.com
The Lee Company WESTBROOK•LONDON•PARIS•FRANKFURT•MILAN•STOCKHOLM
Hydrogen is hot!
Fuel cells ramp up
worldwide
COMVEC
Highlights:
• Startups inject speed
• UX design for cabs
• Ultra-low NOx challenges
Guided by the spirit of our founding brothers, we became one of the 20 largest mobility suppliers in the world. Times may have
changed but our company’s spirit is still the same. Today, we work to develop tomorrow’s sustainable mobility. Our innovative
solutions continue to set milestones in the field of alternative drive systems and in the optimization of combustion engines. Our
77,000 employees are happy to take on the great challenges of our time, always accompanied by a colleague with 100 years of
experience – our legendary Pioneering spirit.
us.mahle.com
ON THE COVER
General Motors will supply its Hydrotec fuel-cell system to Nikola
for Class-7/8 trucks, helping the automaker build scale to lower
costs and increase profitability. (GM)
12
follow us @SAEOHEMag
Truck & Off-Highway Engineering®, October 2020, Volume 28, Number 5. Truck & Off-Highway
Engineering (ISSN 2475-6148) is published in February, April, June, August, October, December
by Tech Briefs Media Group, An SAE International Company®, 261 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1901, New
York, NY 10016 and printed in Mechanicsburg, PA. Copyright © 2020 SAE International. Annual
print subscription for SAE International members: first subscription, $20 included in dues;
additional single copies, $30 each North America, $35 each overseas. Prices for nonmember
subscriptions are $100 North America, $150 overseas. Periodicals postage paid at New York,
NY and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Please send address changes to Truck &
Off-Highway Engineering, P. O. Box 3525, Northbrook, IL 60062. SAE International is not
responsible for the accuracy of information in the editorial, articles, and advertising sections of
this publication. Readers should independently evaluate the accuracy of any statement in the
editorial, articles, and advertising sections of this publication that are important to him/her and
rely on his/her independent evaluation. For permission to reproduce or use content in other
media, contact copyright@sae.org. To purchase reprints, contact advertising@sae.org. Claims
for missing issues of the magazine must be submitted within a six-month time frame of the
claimed issue’s publication date. The Truck & Off-Highway Engineering title is registered in the
U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, and feature articles are indexed and included in the SAE Dig-
ital Library. For additional information, free demos are available at www.saedigitallibrary.org.
ISSN 2475-6148 (print)
Audited by
EDITORIAL
Ryan Gehm
KS, KY, MO, NE, ND, SD, ON, MB
Editor-in-Chief
Bob Casey
Ryan.Gehm@sae.org
+1.847.223.5225
Lindsay Brooke bobc@techbriefs.com
Senior Editor
Southern CA, AZ, NM,
Lindsay.Brooke@sae.org
Rocky Mountain States:
Paul Seredynski Tim Powers
Senior Editor +1.424.247.9207
and strategy at Ricardo North America, takes a significant amount of time to go Associate Art Director Japan:
Shigenori Nagatomo
noted a culture shift is needed in engi- through and assess your internal capabili- +81.3.3661.6138
neering design. “We were trained in ties vs. some of the external options avail- SALES & Nagatomo-pbi@gol.com
engineering to be ingrained in tradi- able. It can be faster to actually acquire a MARKETING South Korea:
Eun-Tae Kim
+82-2-564-3971/2
tional thinking — ‘I need this design to company, and it can be less costly.” Joe Pramberger
ksae1@ksae.org
Publisher
last 20 years; it must not break; the Ford has pursued equity investments as joe@techbriefs.com
world can end and this will still be an R&D strategy. “We’ve found that there Kaitlyn Sommer Integrated Media
there,’” he told SAE COMVEC attendees. are great startups out there,” Pincock said,
Marketing Director
ksommer@techbriefs.com Consultants
Rather, what the industry needs are “and if we engage directly with them — Martha Tress Christian DeLalla
+1.973.841.6035
Recruitment Sales Manager
“engineering chefs,” with a mindset and not only on a commercial basis but also +1.724.772.7155 christiand@techbriefs.com
process more akin to a top chef that on an investment basis — that we’ve been Martha.Tress@sae.org Casey Hanson
+1.973.841.6040
changes his or her menu regularly. able to leverage those skills, those capa- chanson@techbriefs.com
“Design it, develop it, produce it, let peo- bilities and that technology, and then REGIONAL Patrick Harvey
ple enjoy it, let them appreciate it and bring it back into the company and edu- SALES +1.973.409.4686
pharvey@techbriefs.com
then move on,” Brockbank said of the cate the broader workforce.” North America Todd Holtz
+1.973.545.2566
new-look product lifecycle. “It must be Over the past four to five years, Ford New England/Eastern Canada: tholtz@techbriefs.com
ME, VT, NH, MA, RI, QC
consumable, it must be adaptable, and it has completed between 40 and 50 Ed Marecki Rick Rosenberg
+1.401.351.0274 +1.973.545.2565
must be upgradeable.” (See page 3.) transactions, ranging from full acquisi- emarecki@techbriefs.com rrosenberg@techbriefs.com
Electrohydraulic system develop- tions to minority investments — “All with CT: Scott Williams
Stan Greenfield +1.973.545.2464
ment, with its increasing emphasis on the idea of accelerating our strategy.” +1.203.938.2418 swilliams@techbriefs.com
software and programming tools, is a One notable success story, he said, has greenco@optonline.net
good example of an evolving technol- been working with VW and new-tech- Mid-Atlantic/Southeast/TX:
DC, VA, WV, TN, NC, SC, GA, FL,
ogy area that calls for unique skills. nology startup Argo AI in the autono- AL, MS, LA, AR, OK, TX
Ray Tompkins
“The combination of several factors mous-vehicle space. (See page 23.) +1.281.313.1004
rtompkins@techbriefs.com
— using object-oriented design (OOD) Whether hiring, reskilling or acquir-
NY, NJ, OH:
in the design and implementation pro- ing, one thing is clear: Companies must Ryan Beckman
cess, moving towards multithreaded evaluate and adapt skillsets and devel- +1.973.409.4687
rbeckman@techbriefs.com
applications via multi-core CPUs and opment processes to stay relevant in a PA/DE:
SUBSCRIPTIONS
+1.866.354.1125
embedded operating systems and a shifting technology landscape. Desiree Stygar
+1.908.300.2539 TOH@OMEDA.COM
transition to agile project management Ryan Gehm, Editor-in-Chief dstygar@techbriefs.com
models and tool chains — makes this
sector a very palatable field also for Editor’s Note: Check out TOHE’s 2020 REPRINTS
Jill Kaletha
many software engineers and computer Heavy-Duty Diesel Engines e-chart spon- +1.574.347.4211
jkaletha@mossbergco.com
scientists,” said Janosch Fauster, direc- sored by Mahle, which offers a compre-
tor, Application Development Center at hensive list of specifications for power
TTControl. (See page 8.) units available in North America. The
Technology impact on the develop- e-chart is now available for download at
ment process and workforce skills was techbriefs.com/2020_TOHEchart.
Michael Weinert
Vice President –
Commercial Vehicle
Andrew Jeffers
Treasurer
David L. Schutt, PhD Cabin interiors will continue to transform in the projected onto a head-up display (HUD) to
Chief Executive Officer
coming years, largely driven by the advanced provide at-a-glance information, enhancing
Gregory L. Bradley, Esq. UI/UX (user interface/user experience) devel- operator visibility and minimizing distractions.
Secretary opment taking place in companies’ innovation An integrated display on the right-hand win-
centers, said David Wilkie, director of the CNH dow allows operators to perform farm-man-
Landon Sproull Industrial Design Center, speaking at a 2020 agement “office” activities, and precision farm-
SAE COMVEC Digital Summit session on de- ing is supported by a drone that transmits real-
Jeff Varick sign’s role in product development. He believes time data back to the cab so parameters can
Rhonda Walthall a designer’s job is to foster a “human connec- be modified based on actual field conditions.
tion” between the machine and the operator Despite the sleek designs and high-tech fea-
that includes a focus on ergonomics and the tures, the CNH concepts still retain traditional
SAE International Sections details that make for a “more pleasurable” op- HMI elements, such as a steering wheel. Why
SAE International Sections are local
units comprised of 100 or more SAE erating environment. remain so operator-focused? “I believe that the
International Members in a defined “There’s a huge push towards improving the cab is still with us for a while,” Wilkie said. “Full
technical or geographic area. The purpose
of local Sections is to meet the technical, cabin, improving the way of life for the operator autonomous is actually easier for the designer.
developmental, and personal needs of the and really making things easy to use and a plea- I think we should be looking at both.”
SAE Members in a given area. For more
information, please visit sae.org/sections sure to use,” Wilkie said. “To do this, you don’t
or contact SAE Member Relations Specialist
Abby Hartman at abby.hartman@sae.org.
just need a designer or a stylist, what you need HMI standardization
is a team – an engineering team that works with Providing an automotive aftermarket perspec-
us, you need ergonomics, and you need the UX/ tive on consumer electronics, Chris Cook, presi-
SAE International UI team because it’s the complete package.” dent of the Mobile Electronics Association,
Collegiate Chapters
Collegiate Chapters are a way for SAE Wilkie presented several recent futuristic- stressed that nothing should break the 10-2-30
International Student Members to get looking concept vehicles by CNH brands that rule to ensure safe operation – meaning no
together on their campus and develop
skills in a student-run and -elected span the agricultural, construction and com- more than 10 two-second glances in a 30-sec-
environment. Student Members are vital
to the continued success and future of
mercial vehicle segments. A hybrid-electric ond period. This rule should apply whether
SAE. While your course work teaches tractor concept from Steyr and powertrain designing for the aftermarket or for original
you the engineering knowledge you
need, participation in your SAE Collegiate
partner FPT Industrial revealed in late 2019, the equipment, he said.
Chapter can develop or enhance other Steyr Konzept, won a 2020 MUSE Design Working against this goal is a lack of HMI
important skills, including leadership,
time management, project management, Award for Concept Design. This “future vision standardization, Cook said, noting that drivers
CNH INDUSTRIAL
communications, organization, planning, for agricultural machinery” features a minimal- must acclimate to varied interfaces as they
delegation, budgeting, and finance. For
more information, please visit students. ist design for the cab but maximizes advanced operate different vehicles. “HMIs from various
sae.org/chapters/collegiate/ or contact
SAE Member Relations Specialist Abby
human-machine interface (HMI) technology. automakers, as we’ve seen from the aftermar-
Hartman at abby.hartman@sae.org. For example, key operating parameters are ket side, become very complicated and almost
STANDARDS
ELECTRO-HYDRAULIC
PUMP FOR STEERING
Electric and hybrid commercial vehicles
are driving a path toward clean and effi-
cient transportation. Sonceboz’s compact
EHPS solutions for front and rear axle
steering are ideal for easy integration in
tight spaces.
PROPULSION
Electric actuators can benefit
heavy-duty diesels
Camcon’s iVT
technology
replaces the
camshaft
with electric
actuators to
deliver fuel
consumption
savings of up
to 5%.
CLOCKWISE FROM TOP LEFT: SAE/RYAN GEHM; CAMCON; CAMCON; SAE/RYAN GEHM
select regions in early 2020.
toward pure electric powertrains. Depending on country, fuel
costs over the lifetime of an average HDD truck could be some
while AEM and William Bernhard with AEM sponsored and 1 million euros, making a 5% cut very significant, Butler said.
facilitated the meetings. Harmon explained to Truck & Off- Camcon’s figures for annual running costs are based on a
Highway Engineering that vacuum excavation and sewer HDD truck operating in the U.K., averaging 9 mpg (imperial
cleaning were in a gray area, where it was not entirely clear unit), burning diesel fuel at a cost of £1.15/liter and covering
what standards applied to these applications.
“It is moving toward falling in the scope of earthmoving
machinery, so it will be a little clearer what standards apply to
this [equipment],” she shared. Camcon says iVT provides
The publication of SAE standards J3106 and J3107 (www. “infinite control” of an
sae.org/standards/content/j3107_202007/) has comple- engine’s valves and fills a
mented the efforts that the underground construction in- gap created by “increasingly
dustry has delivered to their workforce to improve safety. “I complex but essentially
mechanical” variable
am an advocate for having industry consensus on our best
valvetrains.
practices to develop safety requirements for earthmoving
machinery,” Harmon said. “What is really nice about this new
standard is that we were able to arrive at a consensus and
that we came together to define these requirements.”
Jennifer Shuttleworth
85,000 miles (137,000 km) per annum, “Technology such as digital control of when applied to HDD trucks. What’s
or about 230 miles (370 km) per day. valve timing – replacing camshafts with more, innovation such as this requires
electric motors to increase engine ef- no changes to existing infrastructure,
‘Infinite’ control of valves ficiency – can make a significant and saves operators money and lessens en-
By replacing the camshaft with electric almost immediate reduction in fuel con- vironmental impact.”
actuators, iVT can ensure an “infinite sumption and emissions, particularly Stuart Birch
variety” of valve events via changing TOHE Smalley Ad 1020.qxp_1/2 Page Island 9/29/20 11:27 AM Page 1
timing lift and shape, Butler explained.
This capability would contribute to re-
ducing weight and packaging require-
ments of current aftertreatment equip-
ment, he added, which can be extreme-
ly costly and may come near to equal-
ing or even exceeding the price of some
diesel truck engines. AdBlue consump-
tion also would be reduced.
Butler said that although most as-
pects of the combustion process of
HDDs utilize digital control, there is a
gap to be filled: “Breathing has been
stuck under the control of increasingly
complex but essentially mechanical
variable valvetrains (VVTs); iVT gives
infinite control over the valves, bring-
ing enormous benefits for HDD users,
from cold-start emissions performance
to exhaust gas recirculation (EGR),
plus on-demand cylinder activation
and management of harmful pollut-
ants, including NOx.”
A further asset of iVT concerns cata-
lyst performance. “Catalysts can be
maintained at their optimum operating
temperature over a greater proportion
of the drive cycle,” Butler explained. To
maximize efficiency, Camcon envisions
incorporation of a suite of software that
facilitates iVT being calibrated via ma- STAINLESS IS STANDARD
chine learning to combine hardware
and software into a single package. Our rings provide the same fit
At the U.K.’s University of and func tion as stamped rings,
but are easier to assemble and
Cambridge, David Cebon, director of
remove with no special tools.
the Center for Sustainable Road Freight Standard parts available in stainless
and professor of mechanical engineer- (302 & 316) and carbon steel.
ing, stated: “Changing the powertrain of
Standard or custom, we’ll provide
cars and trucks is inevitable. What tech-
you with the right ring, in the right
nologies will win in the new era are as material, for your application.
yet unknown. While the future emerges,
it has to be acknowledged that conven-
tional engines will be with us for at
FREE SAMPLES:
least the next decade, and probably a C all (866) 483 -9410, or visit
lot longer as part of hybrid powertrains. exper t .smalley.com/SAE /rings
“So, the industry’s responsibility is to
make them as low impact to the envi-
ronment as possible,” Cebon continued.
O
ff-highway vehicles are typically admired for
their power, but the driving force behind a
Software’s importance grows
growing number of performance improve- That focus on software should continue to grow. For years, electrohy-
ments are the invisible bits and bytes of draulic system development was strongly driven by mechanical, hy-
control software. Many of the improvements touted by draulics and electrical experts. Many rapidly evolving technologies
equipment makers are enabled by software that helps are helping empower software’s rising role in off-highway vehicles.
pumps, valves and other electrohydraulic parts oper- “The combination of several factors – using object-oriented design
ate more effectively. This shift follows a growing trend (OOD) in the design and implementation process, moving towards
in which digital controls and software are taking a big- multithreaded applications via multi-core CPUs and embedded oper-
ger role. This transition is expected to continue as rap- ating systems and a transition to agile project management models
id advances in semiconductors and software make it and tool chains – makes this sector a very palatable field also for
easier to add features and functions. many software engineers and computer scientists,” said Janosch
Caterpillar’s Next Generation Excavators highlight Fauster, director, Application Development Center at TTControl.
this transition to software. The machines use a new, Commercial-vehicle developers are rapidly establishing software
advanced electrohydraulic system that combines elec- partnerships so they can leverage the latest design tool advances. At
tronic intelligence with efficient hydraulic components. the same time, the software revolution ripples out to end users, giv-
Electronic joysticks in the cab control the electrohy- ing them more capabilities to operate more efficiently given the di-
draulic main control valve, directing hydraulic power verse needs of various industries.
to the different cylinders and motors on the excavator. “Our tools offer increased integration with third-party tools and
The pumps and engine work in unison to provide ef- products, including simulation programs,” said Kevin Faulds, director
ficient performance and fuel efficiency while meeting of software product, marketing and sales at Danfoss Power
emissions regulations. Software is a critical element. Solutions. “This allows customers to add an entire platform to build
“The intelligence of this hydraulic system is applied their own IoT services and solutions.”
through software,” said Brian Stellbrink, Caterpillar The focus on software is driving other changes in many companies’
senior market professional, hydraulic excavators. “The design processes. Engineers and programmers can use a range of
CATERPILLAR
software can be updated over-the-air via cellular sig- design tools to test out different strategies and techniques. Modular
nal. This ensures the most current software and latest development strategies let design teams utilize proven software
features for the end user.” components for different projects. This approach also makes it easier
“New ECU generations have now enough computational resources hardware expedites the development of the system
and memory to handle the overhead introduced by OOD languages,” solution. All these factors come together to improve
TTControl’s Fauster said. “MISRA C++ and Autosar guidelines com- the efficiency of software updates.”
bined with static analyzers provide a robust framework also for safe- Efficiency for OTA includes security, a factor that’s
ty-related code. OOD combined with C++ allows for a more natural soared in importance as software and connectivity
translation of software architectures and designs into code and en- moved into the mainstream. Design teams are utilizing
hance code abstraction, maintainability and reuse considerably.” the latest standards and best practices to ensure that
Developers are rapidly creating techniques for updating firmware security and piracy aren’t compromised.
HYDRAULIC
SYSTEM
CAPABILITIES
Electrohydraulic advances optimize cab experience
Microcontrollers and metal are being combined to improve the efficiency of
off-highway vehicles. While software has become a primary driver for ad-
vanced electrohydraulics, mechanical components and computing hardware
remain at the core of system designs.
Digital controls are making it possible to automate many tasks, allowing
companies to hire less-skilled operators while also improving the effectiveness of
veteran workers. Electronics are being paired with improved electrohydraulic
components to enhance operational efficiency, improve fuel and emissions pa-
rameters and even streamline vehicle designs. Flex-Steer from Danfoss address- Bosch systems can be
es streamlined design while also helping vehicle designers meet other goals. updated in the field
“The Flex-Steer solution consists of an electrohydraulic steering valve, a using over-the-air
steering input device such as a joystick or mini wheel, sensors and a complete communications.
software solution – reducing development time and streamlining implementa-
tion for OEMs,” explained Philipp Hermann, market segment director at Danfoss
Power Solutions. “Flex-Steer can help optimize the cabin experience by getting
rid of the need for a steering column, improving visibility or simplifying the
overall rotating cabin design in roadbuilding or forestry applications.”
The actuation systems on various machines also are being improved to let
operators work more efficiently. For example, advanced electrohydraulic systems
on Caterpillar’s Next Generation Excavators provide key benefits for contractors.
“The smart hydraulics combined with advanced sensors and software
logic enable significant efficiency gains through the use of standard tech-
nologies such as Cat Grade, Cat Grade with Assist, Payload, and Lift Assist,”
said Brian Stellbrink, Caterpillar senior market professional, Hydraulic
Excavators. “For example, both 2D and 3D integrated machine grade control
systems help contractors dig to grade more quickly and stay on grade with
a high degree of accuracy, while eliminating or greatly minimizing tradi-
tional ground labor around the machine.”
Many different components make these advances possible. Pumps,
valves, actuators and embedded sensors are all improving so complete sys-
tems can enhance operations. Powerful microcontrollers also help engineers The focus on
increase efficiency. Danfoss recently started shipping digital displacement software is changing
pumps (DDP) that sharply improve efficiency for excavators and other elec- the way TTControl
trohydraulic system architectures. develops products.
“The DDP is a radial piston machine that enables and disables cylinders
in real-time using ultra-fast mechatronic valves that are controlled by a ded-
“We use the latest wireless security standards and
icated computer,” said Christopher Williamson, senior systems engineer at
Danfoss. “The primary advantages of DDP when compared to traditional
continuously update as these standards evolve,”
swash-plate pumps are increased part-load efficiency, faster response (less Danfoss’ Faulds said. “This includes securing and con-
than 30 milliseconds) and intelligent digital control.” trolling the endpoints for access and OTA updates, as
Terry Costlow well as building in safety mechanisms to ensure up-
dates are managed from start to finish. OTA updates
Smart hydraulics require a safe and secure channel to thwart intentional FROM TOP: BOSCH REXROTH; TTCONTROL; CATERPILLAR
help operators or unintentional hacking.”
of Cat excavators The growing focus on software is changing the way
accomplish more. companies operate. A hierarchy of programmers often
team up to complete a project.
“The increase of complexity of the software in elec-
trohydraulic systems combined with the respective
increase in the size of the software teams allow for
more differentiated and specialized roles, also in many
mid-sized companies: from dedicated software archi-
tects to controls engineers, framework software engi-
neers and low-level software developers,” TTControl’s
Fauster said. “This higher specialization can result in
better design, better-performing solutions and higher
implementation efficiency.”
WHAT
ATEVER IS HAPPENING IN THE WORLD, CUMMINS IS WORKING
HARD TO SUPPORT YOU. OUR GLOBAL NETWORK IS THERE TO
KEEP YOUR BUSINESSES UP AND RUNNING.
THERE FOR YO
YOU, WHEREVER YOU ARE.
CUMMINS.TECH/MOREPOWER
TAKING
AUTONOMY
TO THE NEXT LEVEL
More work still needs done on AI, reaction strategies and assessing technology
readiness before L4 trucks are market ready.
by Ryan Gehm
D
espite a pandemic that continues to punish global econom- But Starsky Robotics, which shut down operations
ic markets, not to mention vehicle manufacturers’ and sup- in March 2020 after four years of developing autono-
pliers’ product plans, many heavy-duty truck makers are mous-truck technology, is a stark reminder that the
not relaxing on efforts to bring high-level (SAE Level 4 or path to fully autonomous commercial vehicles is not
5) autonomous trucks to market. Partnerships with self-driving tech an easy one.
startups can be a big part of the roadmap, the latest example coming Starsky co-founder and CEO Stefan Seltz-Axmacher
in mid-July as Navistar announced it will co-develop SAE L4 trucks, attempted to explain in a blog post how and why his
targeted for production by 2024, with San Diego-based TuSimple. company went from operating the first fully unmanned
The producer of International commercial trucks and IC Bus school truck on a “live” highway in 2019 to being defunct
and commercial buses also has taken a minority stake in TuSimple. within a year of doing so. Beyond lamenting that
These moves follow a two-year “technical relationship” with the trucking companies are not great technology custom-
startup, which operates a U.S. fleet of 40 self-driving trucks that ers and investors and others prefer “cool” features
move freight between Arizona and Texas for companies like UPS and over mundane safety – “We couldn’t figure out how to
McLane Company. TuSimple plans to demonstrate completely driver- make safety engineering sexy” – he believes artificial
less operations in 2021. intelligence (AI) not being truly ready for prime time is
“TuSimple and Navistar began joint development of pre-produc- the main problem facing the AV industry.
tion units in 2018, and now we are kicking-off a full go-to-market “Supervised machine learning (ML) doesn’t live up
production program,” said Cheng Lu, president of TuSimple. “With to the hype. It isn’t actual artificial intelligence akin to
[our] combined expertise, we have a clear path to commercialize C-3PO, it’s a sophisticated pattern-matching tool,”
DTNA
self-driving Class-8 trucks at scale.” Seltz-Axmacher wrote. “It’s widely understood that
the hardest part of building AI is how it deals with CVs already can be found. But for long-haul trucking, where there’s
situations that happen uncommonly, i.e. edge cases. perhaps the “biggest need and highest efficiency” potential for au-
In fact, the better your model, the harder it is to find tonomy, according to Wohltmann, the operating environment is any-
robust data sets of novel edge cases. Additionally, thing but predictable. Failure detection and the reaction strategy must
the better your model, the more accurate the data be robust and invariably reliable to instill confidence that unmanned
you need to improve it. Rather than seeing exponen- heavy trucks are safe for public roads.
tial improvements in the quality of AI performance (a “The system has to reliably detect gaps, sensor or other faults
la Moore’s Law), we’re instead seeing exponential and react accordingly,” he said. “With increasing autonomy, the sys-
increases in the cost to improve AI systems – super- tem needs to take over more and more the diagnostic and espe-
vised ML seems to follow an S-Curve.” cially the reaction.”
Despite such challenges, many automated-driving A well-defined redundant system architecture is necessary for this
technology experts continue to project commercial strategy, and the systems must be highly connected and centrally con-
vehicles as the most promising early-adoption sector trolled. “Each sensor, all communication lines, every controller and the
for high-level automation. related actuators need to have a backup to take over in case of single
individual faults,” Wohltmann said. Using already-available compo-
nents and actuators can help save weight and complexity compared to
Failure detection and reaction strategy incorporating additional actuators. For example, active steering can
“The autonomous self-driven commercial vehicle will carry a backup electronic control and actuator, or it could be taken
come – for sure,” asserted ZF’s Dirk Wohltmann, engi- over by the existing service brakes with “steer by brake.”
neering director, Americas, providing a Tier-1 supplier Incorporating the trailer into the failsafe and redundancy concept
perspective in a recent SAE technical webinar on the is vital to realizing the full potential of an autonomous-vehicle sys-
topic. But when and how it can be realized depends tem setup, according to Wohltmann. “If today the driver might only
heavily on the usage environment, or Operational apply the rear axle brake as a last resort in case of service brake
Design Domain (ODD), he added. failure, the automated system will integrate the front axle and trail-
In controlled environments that can limit or eliminate er brakes based on ‘knowledge’ of performance and status and
unexpected obstacles and other unpredictable vehi- loading setup,” he said. “Experience from EBS and brake balancing
cles/scenarios, such as mining sites, ports and indus- can be used for a safer and more efficient holistic braking setup
trial areas, highly automated or even fully autonomous and utilized as redundancy.”
ZF
AUTONOMY
TO THE NEXT LEVEL
“Rather than seeing exponential improvements in the quality of AI
performance, we’re instead seeing exponential increases in the cost
to improve AI systems.” - Stefan Seltz-Axmacher, Starsky co-founder
Releasing an L4 vehicle is a “monumental” challenge. Shown is a potential the readiness of automated technology. Narayanan
approach, applied by NASA, to systematically address a technology’s Readiness offered one possibility, a methodology long applied by
Level and avoid “release paralysis.” NASA that systematically addresses technology readi-
ness level (TRL), thoroughly assessing a technology’s
maturity before it can be safely deployed among the
Avoiding ‘release paralysis’ public (see chart).
“We must acknowledge that the release of a Level-4 truck is a dis- “The one thing that I find fascinating is the poten-
tinguished challenge, one that requires us to approach it with a tial ‘release paralysis’ that a chief engineer could face
combination of known methodologies and adopting new ones,” if they do not approach this in the most objective
said Suman Narayanan, director of engineering for the Autonomous way,” he said.
www.curtisinstruments.com
I N N OVAT I O N
& EXCELLEN CE
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/76533-705
Hydrogen
fuel cells –
FINALLY?
Cummins designed and developed many of the critical powertrain
components for its demonstrator, including the PEM fuel cell, system
controller, powertrain controls, wire harnesses and junction boxes.
M
ore than 20 years have passed since hydro- Advanced Clean Trucks rule in June, which basically begins the demise
gen-fuel-cell electric vehicles (HFCEVs) of diesel power for new medium- and heavy-duty trucks sold in the
looked to be the future zero-emission ve- Golden State. The rule requires a shift to zero-emission commercial ve-
hicle (ZEV) solution. About that time, this hicles – meaning battery-electric or fuel-cell electric — starting in 2024,
editor spoke with Prof. Dr. Ferdinand Piëch, then boss with every new truck sold there being zero-emission by 2045. Fifteen
of the Volkswagen Group, about the commercial po- other states and the District of Columbia followed suit just weeks later,
tential of fuel-cell cars in general and a possible future forming a coalition to “eradicate toxic diesel emissions” by 2050.
timeline. Piëch thought it unrealistic to see fleets es- Arizona-based startup Nikola Corp. is making headlines with its push
tablished in the near term (around 2003) and sug- for zero-emission heavy trucks. Initially the company announced its in-
gested it might be 2011 before they would be sold or tention to develop and manufacture HFC vehicles, but since has adopted
leased in any significant volume. It sounded cautious a strategy to pursue both battery and fuel cell power. “We’re definitely
at the time but has proven to be extremely optimistic. more well known for the fuel-cell side, [but] our launch vehicle will be a
Today, signs of an HFCEV commercial victory remain battery-electric,” said Elizabeth Fretheim, the startup’s head of business
low across the world. Despite its convincing technol- development. (Read more at www.sae.org/news/2020/06/nikola-accel-
ogy, hobbled by cost and lack of infrastructure, the erates-production-hydrogen-station-infrastructure)
fuel cell’s battle with the battery does not look win- On September 8, Nikola and General Motors announced a strategic
nable in the near future. Its savior, though, could be partnership that gives GM a $2 billion equity stake in the company, or
application in trucks and buses, eventually leading to 11% ownership, in exchange for the Detroit automaker’s know-how to
increased use in passenger vehicles. A snapshot of engineer, validate, homologate and manufacture both the battery-
some HFCEV projects, tests and trials from around the electric and fuel-cell-electric versions of the Nikola Badger pickup
world demonstrates that hydrogen technology is in- truck. Start of production is expected by late 2022.
deed making progress. The agreement extends beyond Badger to Nikola’s other vehicle
programs, including the Nikola One and Two semi-trucks. GM will be
the exclusive supplier of fuel cells globally (outside of Europe) to
North America Nikola for Class-7/8 trucks and also will supply its Ultium battery sys-
In the U.S., fuel-cell cars sold/leased since 2012 totaled a tem, development of which is ongoing. GM’s battery-technology
mere 8,363 by June 1 this year, according to the California roadmap includes silicon anodes and lithium metal anodes, which are
Fuel Cell Partnership via Baum and Associates. Some 41 already demonstrating automotive-grade durability and “significantly
refueling stations are presently available in California with higher” energy density, the companies claim.
a further 18 in development; HFC buses in operation in “This strategic partnership with Nikola continues the broader deploy-
California total 48. But there is now meaningful progress ment of General Motors’ all-new Ultium battery and Hydrotec fuel-cell
in the U.S. truck and bus sectors. systems,” GM chairman and CEO Mary Barra said in a statement. “We are
CUMMINS
Accelerating this progress are new rules like the growing our presence in multiple high-volume EV segments while build-
California Air Resources Board’s “first-of-its-kind” ing scale to lower battery and fuel-cell costs and increase profitability.”
Hydrogenics, a recent acquisition of Cummins. The truck was designed duction of ‘green’ or CO2-neutral hydrogen.”
for a 90-kW fuel cell and is scalable in 30- or 45-kW increments up to Certainly “green” hydrogen manufacturing is what
180 kW; it also has a 100-kWh lithium-ion battery capacity. Other fuel- environmentalists and HFCEV enthusiasts want. Yet,
cell activities for Cummins include a memorandum of understanding significant commercial momentum remains lacking,
with Hyundai Motor Co. to collaborate on HFC technology across com- with unfulfilled potential credibility particularly for its
mercial markets in North America and an investment in Loop Energy, a application to cars.
Canada-based provider of fuel-cell-electric range extenders.
Another Canadian company making headway in commercial heavy-
and medium-duty applications is Ballard Power Systems, which an-
Switzerland
nounced in August that its PEM fuel-cell technology and products have As in the U.S., many countries continue to at least
now accumulated more than 50 million km (31 million miles) on roads demonstrate the application of development HFC
in 15 countries, an increase of more than five times since 2017. This in- technology. In Switzerland, there is an active approach
cludes about 1,000 fuel-cell-electric buses and 2,200 commercial to hydrogen power with a focus on trucks. In July,
trucks. Ballard launched its 8th-generation power module in 2019. Hyundai shipped to the country the first 10 units of
The late Prof. Dr. Ferdinand Piëch usually kept details of The Mercedes-Benz GenH2 hydrogen fuel-cell concept truck, revealed in September,
Volkswagen Group’s advanced projects under his hat, but he covers a range of up to 1,000 km (620 miles). Customer trials are expected to begin
revealed a little about possible fuel-cell timing. in 2023, with series production coming in the second half of this decade.
Xcient Fuel Cell, what it claims is the world’s first not until the second half of this decade.
heavy-duty fuel-cell truck. Forty more trucks will be Audi, with its h-tron concept that’s linked to Hyundai technology,
delivered by yearend. is expected to continue HFC R&D, but Daimler has shifted away from
Developed independently by Hyundai Motor, the HFC cars (namely its GLC F-Cell), which cannot compete with BEVs
Xcient uses two 95-kW FC stacks and seven tanks that on cost. Newly formed Daimler Truck Fuel Cell is now consolidating
offer a combined storage capacity of around 32.09 kg Daimler AG’s fuel-cell activities and is planned to transition into a
of hydrogen. Slated initially to carry groceries in that scheduled joint venture with Volvo Group. Focused on developing,
country, Xcient can travel approximately 400 km (250 commercializing and producing long-distance, heavy-duty HFC
miles) on a single charge. Hyundai says it will develop trucks, the partnership looks to be a sensible financial investment
a tractor unit with a 1,000-km (620-mile) driving with production expected to start after 2025.
range. The company plans to roll out up to 1,600 By the middle of 2019, only 386 HFCEVs were registered in
Xcient Fuel Cell trucks (leased via Hyundai Hydrogen Germany. German Federal Transport and Digital Infrastructure
Mobility) by 2025. Minister Andreas Scheuer said recently: “Hydrogen, fuel cells and
Also in Switzerland, police in the Zurich canton are electricity move the future. We need them on the road now. We have
trialing a HFC Hyundai Nexo. Hyundai started FC de- to convince citizens that the technology works.”
velopment in 1998. It has been suggested that German supplier Bosch is working to do just that. The company
Switzerland could prove to be geographically conve- states that battery-electric powertrains are not the first choice for
nient as a base for the vehicle maker’s European heavy trucks, given the battery weight, long charging times, and lim-
FROM LEFT: VOLKSWAGEN; DAIMLER TRUCKS
HFCEV operations. ited range of today’s technology. It believes fuel cells are the key to
allowing 40-ton trucks to travel more than 1,000 km in all-electric
mode in the near future.
Germany “The advantages of the fuel cell really come into play in those ar-
In Germany, HFCEVs are being supported with some eas where battery-electric powertrains don’t shine,” said Dr. Uwe
84 refueling stations across the country. BMW has Gackstatter, president of Bosch Powertrain Solutions. “This means
dabbled with wasserstoff (hydrogen) projects for there’s no competition between fuel cells and batteries; instead, they
years, including its research applications for internal- complement each other perfectly.”
combustion engines. Now, working with Toyota, its Bosch is developing its fuel-cell powertrain with a primary focus on
iHydrogen Next project could see HFC versions of its trucks and plans to start production in 2022-2023. Once these sys-
X5, X6 and X7 in low-volume production but probably tems have become established in commercial vehicles, Bosch says its
fuel-cell powertrains “will then increasingly find their way into pas-
senger cars – rightly making them an integral part of tomorrow’s
Japan
powertrain portfolio.” In Japan, fuel-cell cars sold/leased up to November
last year totaled 3,521 and there are 22 fuel-cell buses
in operation, according to the Japan Ministry of
United Kingdom Economy, Trade and Industry. Honda offers the Clarity
A report called “Driving Change” from the U.K. think tank Center for and Toyota the Mirai in the international HFCEV mar-
Policy Studies sees bus fleets being used as test beds for HFC tech- ket. Japan’s Kyoto Institute for Integrated Cell Material
nology. The U.K. government has recently confirmed plans for a Sciences is working on HFCs using coordination poly-
“hydrogen bus town.” Jo Bamford — described as the JCB organi- mer glass membranes designed to demonstrate as
zation heir — owns Ryse Hydrogen and the Wrightbus companies. much energy as liquid systems, with pluses including
He wants to bring 3,000 hydrogen-powered buses to U.K. streets added strength and flexibility.
and said the government support “can kick the hydrogen economy
into full swing.”
London-based Green Tomato Cars already uses 15 Toyota Mirai fuel-
South Korea
cell vehicles for taxi work. U.K. HFCEV users may soon have access A country that is taking fuel-cell technology seriously,
(although not all easily accessible by the general public) to 17 hydro- South Korea has some 5,000 HFCEVs on its roads able
gen refueling stations. “The U.K. is well placed to utilize hydrogen as an to refuel at 34 stations. Its government wants to see 6
energy carrier for transport,” said Dave OudeNijeweme, head of tech- million sold on its domestic market by 2040 as it sup-
nology and trends at the Advanced Propulsion Center UK. ports a “hydrogen economy” with the slogan, “The
Land of the Clear Morning.” Hyundai is busy increasing
its fuel-cell car and commercial vehicle profile and
The Netherlands, Austria, Italy model range.
The Netherlands has announced plans to establish instructional test-
drives of HFCEVs, including how to refuel, using Hyundai Nexo and
China
FROM LEFT: HYUNDAI; BOSCH
(see North America section), approximately 70% of that distance has VW’s Dr. Ferdinand Piëch, who died last year, was a
been covered in China, with the remaining vehicles deployed in North stickler for getting most things right — but not all. His
America and Europe. 2011 fuel-cell arrival projection remains among a pleth-
ora of postulated dates — hedged around by caveats
— uttered by the world’s best and brightest engineers:
Rest of the world “maybe, could be, possibly, potentially, hopefully” and
Although not a precise figure, estimates put the HFCEV world pop- even “deo volente.”
ulation at some 11,000 units — minuscule compared with a guessti- But promising markets like California, Switzerland
HYUNDAI
mated global figure of around 1.5 billion cars, trucks and buses — and China keep the hope alive that fuel cells will one
and rising. day fulfill their high expectations.
Durable
inside every REDTech™ 4H Power Unit.
The Isuzu 4H 5.2L (129-140 kW) engine has always been reliable,
eco-friendly, durable, and technologically advanced. The same qualities
that make the best Power Units. Contact your local Isuzu Distributor and
d
experience durable power today.
Isuzu Motors America, LLC :: 46401 Commerce Center Drive, Plymouth MI 48170 :: 734.582.9470 :: www.IsuzuREDTech.com
S
peed has become a more critical factor as the “I’m not always focused specifically on technology; a lot of my fo-
commercial vehicle (CV) industry races to cus is on how they can help us go faster,” said Stephan Tarnutzer,
meet global market demands and stricter president of AVL. “The whole world is focused on how to get prod-
emissions regulations. The need for quicker ucts to market faster. If I’m not able to work faster when my custom-
decision-making and action is enabling startup com- ers want to go faster, I may not have a customer.”
panies to play a growing role, helping established
manufacturers improve operations, even during this
era of pandemic-driven isolation.
Getting off the ground
Several speakers at the 2020 SAE COMVEC Digital Swiftness was front and center in presentations by the University of
Summit agreed that startups are gaining a foothold Waterloo and the University of Wisconsin. They are among many
throughout the industry, supplying technologies and universities that have established accelerators that aim to help entre-
products that range from systems and software preneurs speed up their efforts. Accelerators provide a range of ser-
through full vehicles. For most startups, the ability to vices such as access to mentors, office space and development tools,
devise ways to augment development efforts by es- to name a few. That saves time for the small staffs of startups. It also
tablished companies is a critical step. Technologies like lets them focus on their projects rather than tasks like hiring support
software and artificial intelligence are being used in staff or ordering supplies.
new areas like electrified powertrains and autonomous Entrepreneurs can also get support from government agencies.
operation, opening a space for young companies in an Chicago-based startup ClearFlame Engine Technologies is working on
industry that has shown a longstanding desire to work engine technology that lets existing diesel engines burn low-carbon
mainly with well-established companies. and carbon-negative fuels. The company has received grants from the
In multiple sessions that addressed the role of start- Department of Energy, the National Science Foundation and Argonne
ups, newcomers and representatives from major CV National Laboratory.
suppliers noted that young companies need to focus Julie Blumreiter, CTO at ClearFlame, said grants were critical to
on their product while also learning how to integrate help the company continue developing its technology while founders
KODIAK ROBOTICS
their hardware and/or software with technologies of worked with venture capitalists. “The grants helped us bridge the val-
Tier 1s and OEMs. Additionally, many panelists at the ley of death faced by many startups,” she said. “It gave us the ability
virtual summit stressed increased speed as a primary to move to the next phase.”
benefit of dealing with startups. Taking the next step typically means working with Tier 1s or OEMs.
Coronavirus impact
These many challenges are now com-
pounded by COVID-19 restrictions. The
pandemic is changing more than the
working conditions for employees who
work from home. It has fueled online
purchases, increasing truck deliveries at
a time when concerns about infection
prompted many drivers to leave the
field, exacerbating the driver shortage.
Autonomous-vehicle developers feel
they have a solution. “Increased de-
mand during COVID has only borne out
how much we need this technology,”
said Jordan Coleman, general counsel
and VP of policy at Kodiak Robotics,
which is developing SAE Level 4 trucks.
“Autonomous technology is needed to
future-proof the industry.”
The coronavirus impact is forcing start-
ups to expand their creativity to product
the power to go green and save on startup’s CEO, a delivery van was not of each driver, across the entire country,
ownership costs, while neighborhoods part of Bollinger Motors’ original prod- that’s a big difference for them.”
will benefit from a reduction in air and uct plan. “The whole delivery space
noise pollution.” completely came from outside re- Dedicated delivery platform
The Deliver-E will employ the same quests,” Bollinger explained. “It was not The Bollinger Deliver-E certainly has a leg
major components (motors, battery, in the plan from when the company up on its competition being engineered
“It is a clean sheet, and it starts off using our battery technology
that’s already on our B1 and B2 vehicles.” — Erik Hardy, Bollinger Motors
for a specific task. The van’s platform has A flat, expansive and
been designed to be as low as possible low load floor with
based on 8 in (20 cm) of ground clear- minimal wheelwell
ance, with a 16-in (41-cm) load floor. “It intrusion is key to
eliminates one step of your traditional maximizing the
UPS or FedEx truck or any other delivery Deliver-E’s cargo
capacity.
van for walk in,” Hardy explained. “To do
that, you have to have a unique rear sus-
pension to go outside the frame rail,
which centers the battery pack in the
middle, very low to the ground. There
won’t be CG [center of gravity] problems
of the traditional ICE delivery van.”
A savvy suspension design, Hardy ex-
plained, affects frontal area and there-
fore vehicle range without impacting
interior volume, and the Deliver-E is ex-
pected to use a rear trailing-arm setup.
“It’s important to note that a lot of dura-
bility of your traditional walk-in van is
actually based on the rear suspension,” save money, but also make the drivers to 30 miles per hour all day long, and
Hardy noted. “They’re not generally de- want to drive the vehicle.” the logistics managers are going to en-
signed for a Class-3 vehicle. They’re joy it not being the traditional box van’s
scaled down Class-4, Class-5 suspen- Leveraging existing components 10-second zero-to-30 [mph].”
sions, so they ride extremely rough.” An electrified delivery van makes sense The Deliver-E will utilize many of the
“Which means that the drivers get as it spends much of its use cycle in same components destined for
beat up. It means that all the structure low-speed acceleration and decelera- Bollinger’s other more off-road-capable
in the box itself gets beat up,” Hardy tion events, where the ample instanta- models, tied to the bespoke chassis.
continued. “It’s taking all the param- neous torque and regenerative braking “It’s a different frame from our B1 and
eters that we expect to be in a Class-2B can pay the largest dividends. “There’s B2 vehicles, but that’s for a very specific
to Class-3 segment, and defining what no second-guessing the performance of reason,” Hardy explained. “Our B1 and
the suspension needs and what the the electric motor, especially from that B2 have a lot of curvature in them be-
body needs. Which is going to help low-speed-torque acceleration,” Hardy cause they have to meet our very tight
long-term durability of the vehicle and noted. “Most of these guys, they’re zero packaging restraints for the wheelbase.
It actually simplifies things a lot for
Access to the Deliver-E [Deliver-E] production, as it means that
cargo area is engineered the frame rails can be straight.”
around the fewest “Making a new frame rail is one of the
possible movements. easier parts of the system — it’s just a
little different than our B1 and B2 plat-
form — but we use all of the [same]
high- and low-voltage electronics,”
Hardy said of the goal of maximizing
electrified-parts commonality. “But
making a running platform — a skate-
board per se — is easily accomplished
and that’s our full intent. We have to be
as cost efficient as we can for the com-
mercial side, so we have to make those
decisions early on.”
Paul Seredynski
Diagnostic software
ZF’s (Auburn Hills, Mich.) Commercial
Heavy-duty alternators
Vehicle Control Systems released the WAI’s (Miramar, Fla.) complete line of
WABCO TOOLBOX PLUS, which is the lat- heavy-duty alternators is suitable for
est generation of its PC-based advanced Class-1 to Class-8 trucks and construc-
diagnostics software that expedites vehicle tion equipment. According to the
and trailer diagnosis. TOOLBOX PLUS has a “roll call” feature company, millions of units have been
that automatically detects and populates WABCO systems in- installed and tested to OEM specifica-
cluded on the vehicle. With a click, users can diagnose fault tions and include TRANSPO electron-
codes, view repair and installation instructions and access ics manufactured by WAI, as well as premium-grade WBD
maintenance manuals. The latest TOOLBOX software offers bearings. WAI alternators feature a high level of proven perfor-
expanded diagnostic capabilities and support for the current mance with thorough testing of output current at idle and full-
WABCO product portfolio — including latest product releases load RPM. Additionally, validation testing for all products in-
Intelligent Anti-lock Braking System (iABS) for trailers, Modular cludes endurance, humidity, power thermal cycling, vibration,
Braking System Platform (mBSP) for trucks and TailGUARD salt spray and thermal shock. New alternators result in war-
reversing collision avoidance system for trucks and trailers. ranty rate reduction through extended field life of new units.
For more information, visit http://info.hotims.com/76533-461 For more information, visit http://info.hotims.com/76533-462
FTP [Federal Test Procedure] and low- What set of technologies are required to
load cycles. We looked into different av- meet the 2027 NOx standards?
enues, how we can use electrically-heat- Farrell: As we work toward 2024 and meet-
ed catalysts or substrates, how we can ing 0.05, we’re going to learn what it’s really
enhance the aftertreatment heating by Gustav going to take. The challenges are not just
doing the exhaust bypass; we looked into Johnson, FTP and RMC-SET [Ramped Mode Cycle-
cylinder deactivation [as part of the chief engineer Supplemental Emissions Test], there’s the
at AVL Powertrain
SuperTruck program], and we found pros new low-load cycle and that lab test is
Engineering.
and cons of each application. probably not even the greater challenge.
“One of the
Singh: Absolutely. There are two kinds of will be key in adoption.
prevalent dosing technologies available, one In North America, when we sell the trucks
with Bosch and one with Cummins. I think
both technologies are feasible. We believe, biggest challenges to customers, to a fleet of like 10,000 trucks,
think about a scenario that they need a
based on the data we have, that controlling
the dosing and trying to dose at a lower
we’re still facing is 1,000-kWh battery system. One battery is
running at about 2.2 kWh per mile; that will
temperature doesn’t make much difference.
What we believe is that the challenge is how
how to control the give them about 500 miles. Basically, we’re
talking 10 million kWh of energy needed by
to heat up the system that is ahead of it.
That is a big challenge, because even if you
engine-out NOx one company per charge — think about
what kind of a charging infrastructure the
start dosing early, if your catalyst is not hot, that’s produced U.S. needs to provide them power.
reactions will not take place. But I don’t want
to discourage the manufacturers who are in the first 60 We do see other applications where
electrification is going to take over faster,
making the new dosing technologies — we
would encourage them to keep developing. seconds.” like bus and vocational applications —
school buses are ideal because you drop
off the kids, you pick up the kids, you
- Navtej Singh, Navistar
What are the control implications for have a 5-hour window you can charge
meeting low-NOx standards? them up. But for freight, if you’re asking
Johnson: The main thing to keep in mind specifically on the heavy-duty applica-
with controls for a lot of these [solutions], tion, I think IC engines are going to stay
there are some low-level things like any longer than expected.
increase in sensor accuracy is going to
make diagnostics and similarly engine-out Farrell: We’re in the process of putting
CONTINENTAL EMICAT
NOx decisions less of a competition. So out early learners now and hopefully
that’s on the low level — precision of the within the next few years we’ll have a
individual components. That is an enabler, better understanding. But I don’t think
it’s by no means a solution to the challenge. we know that right now.
I think the real ‘magic,’ so to speak, is Ryan Gehm
WE INNOVATE.
Imitation is easy.
Innovation is hard work.
Leighton Lee II was an innovator. He founded
our company on that spirit, and it’s how we
solve tough problems today. Every product
you see here—from miniature check and relief
valves to shuttle valves, flow controls, precision
orifices and plugs—was developed to solve a
customer’s fluid control challenge. Since 1948,
we’ve been delivering engineered solutions
for a wide variety of demanding applications.
We have the experience, product breadth, and
technical know-how to provide engineered
performance, with zero risk. Don’t let an imitator
ruin your day—or your design. Contact us
today to put our knowledge to work for you.
®
2 Pettipaug Rd, Westbrook CT 06498-0424
860-399-6281 | 1-800-LEE PLUG | www.leeimh.com
The Lee Company WESTBROOK•LONDON•PARIS•FRANKFURT•MILAN•STOCKHOLM