Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MASTER OF ARCHITECTURE
2004
by
Committee Chair:
David Saile
Nnamdi Elleh
Anne Lund
Abstract
Spirituality and sanctity are some of the most important qualities that can be
expressed through architecture. These qualities and the spaces that express them also
play a fundamental role in our existence. They are experienced across many lands and
cultures and with many beliefs and practices. My argument maintains that these
powerful experiences should not be limited to only a certain group of users, but rather
should be open for all to experience. This type of architectural expression need not be
limited to merely religious uses or members of a particular religious group but should
extend beyond the limitations and rules of religion and embrace multitudes of people,
beliefs, uses and qualities. This thesis explores the idea of sacred space and what it
means in an urban context. It also questions how to create physical space that can be
the gateway or transition to spiritual communication with another realm of being, that
can allow healing and learning to take place, and that can provide an escape or retreat
To all my family and friends who have guided and supported me through the
past six years of challenges, successes, and this ultimate fulfillment of my life long
dream.
Table of Contents
Page
Abstract --
Acknowledgements --
Table of Contents --
Image List 01
Image Sources 03
Introduction 05
Foundation 08
Central Questions 13
Connections 21
Current Examples 26
Program
Inventory 33
Site
Introduction 41
History 43
Population 46
Site Analysis
Description 49
Transportation 51
Site Plans 53
Bibliography 55
Endnotes 59
McGahan 1
Image List
Description Page
3) Man in Mosque 09
13) Stonehenge 21
18) Grailville 28
27) My Site 49
Image Sources
2000 (66).
2) http://www.poyi.org/59/07/0707.html
4) http://www.enquirer.com/unrest/unrestphotos.html
5) http://www.cincinnati.com/local/newport/E60html_07292003__GNNBD
peacebell.ART_Other.html
7) http://www.ukstockimages.com/preview/searchpreview.php?operation=
preview&imageid=100GL0070
8) Heathcote, Edwin and Iona Spens. Church Builders. West Sussex: Academy
9) By author
10) By author
11) Chester, Laura. Holy Personal: Looking for Small Private Places of Worship.
12) Dupre, Judith. Churches. New York: Harper Collins, 2001 (133).
13) Devereux, Paul. The Sacred Place: The Ancient Origin of Holy and Mystical
14) Mann, A.T. Sacred Architecture. Rockport: Element Inc., 1993 (116).
15) http://www.sspx.org/miscellaneous/history_of_the_ignatian_reteat.htm
16) Smith, Huston. The Illustrated World’s Religions: A Guide to Our Wisdom
McGahan 4
17) http://www.eastretreat.org/
18) http://www.grailville.org/
19) http://users.rcn.com/chicagobuddha/chicagobuddha/ctour3garden.html
20) http://www.innerpeaceholistic.com/
21) http://www.innerpeaceholistic.com/
22) Crosbie, Michael J. Architecture for the Gods. New York: Watson-Guptill,
2000 (166).
23) http://www.archetects.net/Bristol/pages/hand-1_tif_jpg.htm
24) By author
25) http://www.structurae.net/en/photos/img6512.php
26) http://www.daap.uc.edu/library/archcinci/9unionterminal.html
27) By author
28) By author
McGahan 5
Introduction
Imagine a bustling city in midday just as most employees begin their lunch
break. Hear the sounds of the cars rushing past, the horns beeping, the doors
slamming. Voices can barely be heard over the noises of the city as people rush to get
to their lunch destination, hoping not to have to wait too long in line. Everything is
moving, pedestrians are crossing, cars are turning, buses are leaving; nothing is still.
Nerves are on edge, pressures push stresses to the limit; a profane world surrounds you.
It is a chaotic environment that doesn’t end at the door to the office or workplace; you
Now, imagine a peaceful and serene space amidst all this chaos of the city. Hear
the silence of your meditation; hear the thoughts inside your mind. Talk with others
without having to yell above the city noises, take your time and relax. Sit still or slowly
walk about, meanwhile the rest of the world goes on as always but your world changes.
Your world becomes quiet and serene, you are able to temporarily leave behind the city
and enter into a new realm-a spiritual realm. It is here that you can connect with a
side of yourself that the city does not allow. It is here that you can communicate with
yourself, with a divine being, with others. Here you can learn about new things, meet
new people, and explore new aspects of yourself. In this place you can unite your
mind, body and spirit into a renewed and healed state. What and where is this place?
Religion and spirituality are important elements of people’s lives throughout the
world. Despite a multitude of religions and belief systems, which have their own
cultural and regional qualities, spirituality plays a fundamental role in our lives. Many
would argue that this other worldly connection between the human and the divine is
among the most powerful communications possible. It is this connection that fascinates
me and is where I find that architecture, in the form of sacred space, plays a vital role
Each person experiences space differently, dependent upon factors such as,
feelings, memories, backgrounds, and values. However, for a person of faith, no matter
what that faith may be or what religion they may be a part of (if any), sacred space
serves a profound set of functions in their lives. These functions include providing a
location within which people can escape the ordinary in order to communicate and
connect with the divine, their spiritual selves, and/or with others. Other functions
could be to provide a place for healing, and space to learn new things about the divine,
these spaces to serve as a transition and gateway between the human realm and the
divine realm. Sacred space serves as a sort of pathway from one to the other allowing
this spiritual connection to take place. The sacred space is a break or transition
between the profane world of the non-sacred and the world of the divine. It provides a
space for the physical, human, and the spiritual to connect. Sacred space creates an
environment where one can escape the ordinary world and enter into spiritual
consciousness.
I propose that architecture uses these qualities and elements as the fuel for
transporting a person of faith from the human realm to the divine realm and allows
them to make a connection between the two. The Portuguese Architect Alvaro Siza
anything, they transform reality…, ‘“ which pinpoints my desire to explore how the
architecture of a sacred space transforms those who experience it into another reality, a
spiritual reality.1
McGahan 8
Foundation
Following the horrific terrorist attacks of September 11th, 2001, I began to think
more and more about religion and spirituality and how these elements in our lives can
religions and religious thought. After many of these classes, my increasing interest in
this subject, and the importance spirituality plays in my own life, I decided that I
people share my concern and know little or nothing about religious beliefs beyond their
own. It seemed that the whole nation was asking questions with little or no idea of
where to get answers. Americans were suddenly afraid of Muslims, yet they didn’t
know why or if they should be. Their ignorance of that which was different from their
own lives was a part of what kept the fear in their minds and hearts.
Years after the attacks, in a world that seems so advanced in every way, we still
shun what we do not know and what is different. We allow these differences to
separate and weaken us, instead of uniting us and making us a stronger whole. We go
to our sacred places to learn about our own religions and spirituality, but rarely do we
learn about others. We see people from other cultures and backgrounds around us, but
McGahan 9
do not interact with them. We know that other beliefs exist, but do not have or take the
I began to ask myself, where could someone go to learn about other belief
systems if they didn’t have access to college courses like I did? Is there a place that
exists where I could meet someone of another faith and discuss our differences and
similarities? Could a meeting like this deepen my own spirituality, and bring me to a
I began to dig deeper into why I felt that sacred spaces are so affecting and
powerful to me as an individual and to other persons. After more reading and research
3) Man in Mosque into the world’s alleged ordinariness.”2 A person can use
this sacred space as a gateway or pathway along their spiritual journey to reach and
Finally, I came to the conclusion that I wanted to create a sacred space that
would provide a setting for all of these activities (and more) to occur. Not only a sacred
space that allows for an individual or group to connect with the divine, but also for
individuals and groups to connect with each other and discuss their spiritual lives. As a
McGahan 10
result, they could learn more not only about other people and faiths that differ from
their own, but they could also learn more about themselves.
McGahan 11
Over a million Americans spend time at some sort of retreat center each year.3
Americans, including those in the Cincinnati area, are stressed out. There is an ongoing
war in Iraq, terrorism alerts continue to occur, the economy is anything but stable, jobs
are few and far between and those who have one are in fear of losing it.4 In an article
called “Take a break to combat work stress” by Bob Nelson in the Business Courier, a
survey done by ComPysch5 showed that Cincinnati employees are suffering from high
levels of stress. In the survey, 48% of employees reported “high levels of stress coupled
with extreme fatigue and a sense of feeling out of control.”6 In the same survey, 38% of
employees reported “constant but manageable stress levels.”7 Clearly this shows a
strong need for local employees to find ways to de-stress and get control of their lives,
Also, since the horrible terrorist attacks on our nation on September 11th of
2001, religious and cultural differences have been an issue among all of us, including
All of these issues contribute to the need for the people of the Cincinnati area to
have a place to retreat to find themselves and to meet others (like a spiritual retreat
center). Placing such a program within the city allows for easy access by some 80,000
McGahan 12
employees that work in the downtown area8. It would also be accessible to those
outside the downtown area including the diversity of people at the University of
Cincinnati, residents in Kentucky from Covington and Newport, and people from both
There is also an abundance of new additions to the city in recent years that seem
people, and to generate a sense of peace. Such similar additions to the city include the
the river, the International Friendship Park that runs along the
spread throughout the city, serve a variety of spiritual and cultural needs.
Of course, there are probably many cities that have similar issues and that are
feeling the effects of these national issues as well. However, I chose Cincinnati not only
for these reasons, but also because I have lived in a suburb of the city my entire life and
Central Questions
religions together for retreat, worship, prayer, and interaction, an obvious challenge
arises. Certain things that are meaningful in one faith may be regarded as insulting or
degrading to another. Rituals and practices vary greatly from one religion to the next.
Cultural and regional variations in one major religion also may create significant
of spirituality?
6) Taj Mahal in Agra, India practices that occur within it. Determining what
will help me to explore what kind of space I need to design in order to meet the needs
The next crucial question that I must answer is what exactly is a sacred space?
In terms of religion, this is a complex question when you consider that each major
group has their own elements and details, which they believe contribute to the sanctity
of their worship space. However, I believe that all these sacred spaces, regardless of
McGahan 14
religious denomination, have some common, intrinsic qualities, which allow for the
How or what about the sacred space allows for this communication to occur? I
about these spaces that provides for this unique and important event to take place.
What makes a ‘designated’ sacred space any different or better than a room in
one’s house or one’s office at work? A sacred space allows a person to completely
escape the chaos of the profane world, the everyday world that surrounds them at all
other times. A sacred space provides a sanctuary for their prayers and thoughts as well
How does the sacred space do this? I have explored this historically,
theoretically and physically by looking at various texts and designed and built works.
(This exploration can be found in the sections titled “History and Precedents” and
“Current Examples”.)
Why is it important to have sacred spaces? (I think that the answers to this
the need for a place of refuge and escape from this profane and stressful world are ever
increasing. Not everyone seeks out a spiritual means for stress relief, but for those that
do, it is our duty as architects to understand how and why these spaces are important
and how design can meet the needs of those who seek relief in this way. And for those
McGahan 15
who do come to sacred spaces for this escape or for the guidance or prayer, having a
space that allows for this divine communication is an essential part of their lives.
prayer. An escape from the profane world can be sought in many other ways that
commonly used medium for transporting mind, body and spirit into a new realm.
Designing a space that evokes an atmosphere of peace and serenity where a person
could simply sit and read and relax could be enough of an escape for some. Connecting
with nature, the outdoors and sunlight or warm breezes could provide an escape from
Spaces that provide healing to the mind, body and spirit could also be
considered sacred spaces. Massage therapy or spa treatments could begin with a
healing of the body and then gradually resonate throughout one’s mind and spirit.
Meeting new people, learning new things, having a space and time to think and relax,
One of the most influential writers I have come across in my research is Mircea
Eliade. In The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion, he describes the sacred
as something beyond human description, beyond our own worlds and something
is, above all, real.”10 By this I think he is describing the power of the sacred to make
homogenous, sacred space being a break from this sameness.11 If profane space is
reference from which to find your way.12 A sacred space, within the midst of this
homogenous world, is that point of reference.13 It is the center from which people can
orient themselves, find themselves, and figure out where they are and where they are
going.14 This, of course, is not necessarily meant in a physical way but rather in a
world.
and the divine.15 Between these two worlds lies the sacred
8) Chapel of Thanksgiving space, which is the link that brings these two, otherwise
in Dallas, Texas by
Philip Johnson separate, worlds together. So, the sacred space then
becomes a vehicle or passageway from one to the other. I think these ideas of
design. I must design spaces where not only communication and movement occur
physically, but also where these occur spiritually. The space is used as a sort of vehicle
for this transcendence beyond our physical environment “…toward the sacred center
sacred place.17
9) La Sagrada Familia in
Eliade also talks about the ideas of the Barcelona, Spain by
Antonio Gaudi
“axis-mundi”, the “cosmic pillar”, and the
“cosmic mountain”.18 All of these represent this vertical connection among the three
regions. Ascending to a higher place in most contexts can be associated with positive
generally, every ascent is an escape from the profane and human status to a more
sacred level.21 As a result, this element will likely play a role in my design as well. For
example, a break will sometimes occur in the roof of a sacred place to symbolize an
intersection of two worlds and to show this vertical axis, such as the oculus in the
Earth.24 Nature, a part of the Earth 10) The Pantheon in Rome, Italy
world, is then considered sacred and like sacred space, it exists both on Earth and at the
same time it also transcends Earth and the human realm.25 Eliade also describes the
many elements of nature such as the sky, sun, moon, water, stones, and plants, which
all have various sacred connections and meanings.26 For example, he suggests that
water (which plays a role in my program and design) “…symbolizes the whole of
potentiality, is the source of all possible existence, the essence of plant life, the elixir of
immortality, ensures long life and creative energy and is the principle of all healing.”27
spirituality and how that connects with your physical surroundings. Spirituality is
around us.28 He says all three of these elements must be present to create our
McGahan 19
spirituality.29 I think this is very important as far as the spaces and those who will
and group spaces will allow all aspects of the spiritual self to be accessed.
Hamma describes places as being “mediators” between the divine and the
human.30 The space is the physical mediator that separates you and the divine but yet
also connects you to the divine at the same time.31 Since you cannot experience the
divine in the flesh, you must do so in what he calls “mediated experiences” which
example gives a strong analogy to what I think every sacred space does, and that is to
bring a person closer to the divine. These spaces are not literally “thin” but rather they
provide a space where the barrier between the human and divine is lessened.
change from day to night and how very different the same space can be during these
times.36
Finally, one of the most important results that could come out of the spaces that
I design are summed up in a powerful quote that Hamma uses from the Bible. The
McGahan 20
words were said by St. Paul in 2 Cor 3:18, “we, with our unveiled faces, reflecting like
mirrors the glory of the Lord, all grow brighter and brighter as we are turned in the
places and communicate with our deity, and then we take with
peace and the calm, and we spread that to those around us.
Connections
How is a spiritual retreat center a sacred space? First let me address what a
‘sacred space’ means in terms of my personal definition and other more agreed upon
definitions. A few of the many descriptions of this word’s meaning from an internet
dictionary include such definitions as “dedicated to or set apart for the worship of a
deity”, “…not profane or common”, “reserved for the exclusive use of something”,
My personal meanings for this word also include the ideas of communication
with a deity, a place to escape the profane, ordinary world, a place to heal and be
healed, and a place to connect with both the spiritual and divine realm and with your
Eliade, describes ‘sacred’ as being “wholly other”39 and a break within the
Revered sacred spaces around the world include natural wonders like the Grand
house that one seeks for spiritual refuge. A sacred space could also be a hospital or
therapist’s office where healing of the body or mind can take place. A sacred space can
McGahan 22
exist in these varying scales and locations, as well as with or without the association of
a religious tradition.
sacred place for them. (A more detailed explanation of these sacred elements and
activities that will occur within the spiritual retreat center can be found at the end of
Retreats have been part of cultural and religious roots since time immemorial,
and each religion has their own unique history of how retreats came about. Buddhism
and Christianity are probably the most widely known religions that participate
In Christianity, St. Ignatius of Loyola is given credit as the ‘father’ of the retreat
within the Catholic faith at around the end of the 15th century.42
together a group of men known as “The Company of Jesus” (or the Jesuits), St. Ignatius
began 30-day ‘Spiritual Exercises’ where he and his men would preach the Gospels and
lead the ‘exercises’.44 Over time these ‘retreats’ became very popular and later were
included as a custom for the Catholic clergy. Monks continue to retreat within the
monasteries to practice their devotion to the faith. Often this includes long periods of
Much later in history the practice of ‘retreat’ was extended by the Church to
include its parishioners as well. Retreats became very popular in the United States
around the 1970’s in other Christian religious groups and it is now a part of many
denominations.45
As read in the Bible and other religious sources, ascetics of both Judaism and
Christianity had to leave behind their worldly lives and possessions in order to fully
McGahan 24
find and follow God. This represents a kind of retreat; one that is a more permanent
Most of the other major world religions have elements within them that relate to
Although the main focus of Zen Buddhism is this meditation, the retreats often include
periods of community work as well to bring spiritual awareness to both the individual
and others.48 Tibetan and other forms of Buddhist retreats sometimes include other
forms of spiritual growth such as scholarly research of Buddhism, studies of the Tibetan
In Hinduism, practices like yoga, which include physical, mental and spiritual
exercises, are meant to unite the believer with the deity or deities.50 Many Hindus seek
an escape from worldly luxuries in order to diminish the boundaries that separate them
Similar to the story of Jesus in the Christian faith, Islam tells of Muhammad also
retreating into the desert for contemplation and spiritual growth.52 A pilgrimage to
Mecca, the Islamic holy land, has elements of ‘retreat’ for Muslims as well. It is meant
each other.53 It is also a physical retreat from their homeland to a place rich with
sacred meaning. There are other spiritual retreats within Islam and each different sect
McGahan 25
of this religion has alternative ways to reach spiritual awareness. Some sects emphasize
Despite the various world religions, the many sects within those religions, and
the multitude of other spiritual belief systems that exist today, most retreats within each
of these include many similar elements. Most involve the opportunity for both
individual and group retreat and many have other means of spiritual growth besides
just mediation, like educational services and community-based events. I plan to include
these varying elements into my program as well to further reflect and welcome a
diversity of visitors.
McGahan 26
Current Examples
form of vacation,” there are a number of retreats of various religious affiliations all
over the United States and Canada.55 There are approximately five hundred Catholic,
about one hundred and fifty Protestant, a dozen or so Jewish, a few Quaker, and also
new sproutings of various retreats for those of the Islamic, Buddhist and Hindu faiths.56
Not included in this study are interfaith retreat centers, which is the kind of
retreat that my program falls within. Interfaith retreats are ones that are open to
people of all faiths and religions, and that provide activities and programs for more
than just one group of people. Some of the retreats mentioned above may, in fact,
accept and welcome visitors of any and all faiths, but are merely affiliated with or led
by a particular one. According to one website, there are about two hundred and
Of the few retreat centers that I was able to find online for people of Jewish,
Islamic, and Hindu faiths; most centered around teaching and reflection of their
religion and religious texts. Many were about educating guests about their own
religion, while a few were about educating guests of other religions or cultures about
the center’s religion. Some also had incorporated with the center or were fully
designed to provide a ‘camp’ for children of that faith. Since these types of retreats are
rooted in one particular religion, the activities and programs obviously are much more
Buddhist retreats differ somewhat from some others since the religion itself is so
different. Buddhism doesn’t focus on texts so much as it does on the practice of the
teachings of Buddha. Therefore, the retreats aren’t so much about learning about the
McGahan 27
religion as they are in having a space and time to practice the teachings and experience
them.
and therefore visitors are more free to use the retreat not just in religious terms but also
in other ways that they are seeking. For instance, many of these have a variety of
religious content at all. So, the religious elements can be included in one’s activities at
few centers in the United States that have similar ideas and discuss their programs and
facilities.
Some interfaith retreat centers focus more on the individual retreat as opposed
to a group retreat, such as the East Mountain Retreat Center in Massachusetts. This
house called Covenant Farm. Many of their goals listed on their website sound similar
to my own goals for my program. These include the need for the guest to remove
themselves from their daily routine in order to reconnect with the divine.60 This
retreat center has what they call a “Reflection Room” where many people can interact
and share their retreats and also a library nearby for reading, writing, etc.
McGahan 28
retreat center called the World Fellowship Center. Their mission is “to promote peace
facilities are incorporated at this retreat center.62 This organization is also non-profit
which further demonstrates their desires to bring people together and promote peace.
All of these retreats include a distinct and important connection with nature and
the outdoors whether it is merely by expansive views out to the surrounding scenery or
by including outdoor activities within the rest of their programs. All of the ones I have
mentioned so far are located in rural settings that provide an abundance of space for
these elements to occur. However, since my program will be in an urban setting, I also
looked at various urban retreat centers. Most of these focus on the ideas that many
people in the city do not have the time and/or money to go to a retreat far away, so one
in an urban setting is much more practical and readily available for urban participants.
This particular retreat happens to be a Christian retreat, but it is helpful to look at it due
to its location. Many of its programs and events focus on community in addition to the
McGahan 29
more religious and spiritual aspects of retreat.65 Their goals include bringing various
community members together to discuss and work towards enhancing the metropolis of
Richmond.66 I feel that this community element is very important, especially when the
center is placed in an urban context like this one. Existing in the heart of the city
makes it all the more important that the center make efforts to bring community
Another urban retreat center I found is called the Buddhist Society for
faith retreats and allows for a diversity of visitors due to its location.
nice, small outdoor courtyard area that has some gardens and an
19) B. S. C. W. eating area.68 Such a space allows for a bit of nature and the
courtyard
outdoors to come into this very urban setting. This issue is an
important goal for me, as my program will need similar outdoor spaces within the
Most retreat centers, since they are located in very rural, out-of-the-way places,
(and even some urban ones) have overnight lodging and also kitchen and dining
spaces. The capacity for these centers can range anywhere from around a dozen or so
will be accommodating participants who are not necessarily looking for a long stay, I
incorporate the important elements of nature and the outdoors into my program and
Program
This program will also allow me to pursue other thesis goals that other types of
sacred spaces may not allow. The first is my desire to have the program be open to all
people. This is partly in response to the many issues previously discussed concerning
the city of Cincinnati and my desire to unite and connect people who may not
otherwise have sufficient means. This is also in response to most people not feeling
welcome or comfortable visiting a sacred space that is linked with a particular religion
that is different from their own. So, by having the spiritual retreat center be an
interfaith organization, it will be open to all those who desire to use it, and will provide
the opportunities to both meet a diversity of people who are different than yourself and
In addition to learning and expanding one’s mind to other people and other
ways of living; the spiritual retreat center can also provide workshop spaces for other
educational programs like learning a foreign language or learning about the various
world religions, etc. These spaces can also be used for such things as community
meetings or places to teach other activities that occur in the retreat center, such as
teaching how to meditate. These programs and meetings can allow for this interaction
the mind or spirit and vice versa. In my program I hope to provide healing of the body,
mind and the spirit. The spiritual healing will consist of things already discussed like
spaces for worship, prayer and communication with the divine. Healing for the mind
like counseling and therapy-for individuals, families, or couples. The body can be
healed in various ways, which might include massage therapy, a sauna, acupuncture,
etc. In addition to speaking of these activities individually, most of them offer dual or
triple effects-healing not just one but two or all three-mind, body and spirit.
Healing can also occur by the lack of activities that one participates in. By this I
mean simple rest and relaxation can provide a great deal of healing to those who need
retreat. Simply having a quiet space to sit down and read a book or write, or a
comfortable place to lounge for a while may be all that is needed to renew one’s mind,
of mine in this program. Allowing for the fast pace of the city and of
time can even stand still for a moment, and where time is not quite as
21) A woman demanding or important for a small period. It should be a place
meditating
where a person can leave behind the ordinary, pressure-filled, stress-
filled world of the city and participate in the activities that create this spiritual, sacred
realm.
Most of these kinds of spaces are more for individual use, whereas some of the
more educational or interactive spaces would be more suited for groups. However, I
wish to not only provide spaces for both individuals and groups, but also allow some
interaction-visual or physical-between the two. I think that this will allow for a richer,
McGahan 32
deeper experience by all if, for instance, an individual using one particular space can
I also wish to have both interior and exterior spaces so that nature can be
included in the spiritual experience of the user. However, since my site is located in an
urban context, this goal is met with some challenges. I hope to maintain a connection
to the urban context while still allowing a ‘retreat’ in all aspects and allowing a
connection with nature not normally found within the city. So the challenge will be to
allow an escape from the urban chaos but yet not totally isolate the spaces from their
surroundings.
Lastly, most retreat centers are located away from the city and in very rural
areas, which require the guest to stay a longer period of time-be it a few days to a week
or more. My goal is, however, to have a more flexible retreat center that allows a
person to come for an hour, a few hours, or the entire day, which seems to be much
context. (So, my program provides an alternative to the usual spiritual retreat center in
multiple ways.)
McGahan 33
Inventory:
The following is a list of spaces and an estimation of the square footages that
each space might require. These estimations are based off of the research and
precedents that I have looked at and discussed earlier in the document (See “History
-Interior Spaces:
B) Worship spaces
-for workshops/educational
courses/etc.
-storage/backstage area
(one @ 200 ea.) 200 sq. ft.
F) Gathering spaces
N) Bathrooms
-female staff bathroom to accommodate
two people (one @ 100 ea.) 100 sq. ft.
-Exterior Spaces:
-Spaces for sitting as well as for paths and walking areas which lead
through the outdoor spaces.
-An entry space outdoors that allows for a sort of transition as one moves
from the profane, urban city to the sacred, spiritual retreat center.
-My overall site is roughly 99 ft. x 225 ft. = 22,275 sq. ft.
McGahan 36
At first glance, it seems that the more public, group spaces would be located in
one area of the building and the more private, individual spaces would be in another.
Perhaps the group spaces would be open to views of the city and allow views in as well.
However, I’m interested in playing with these spaces and seeing if I can prevent them
from becoming totally isolated from one another. I would like to try to allow for some
interaction between these two types of spaces, whether it is visual, physical or both.
Also the more service-oriented spaces like the offices, storage rooms, and the
like will probably all be located in one area which would be more separate from but
Diagram 2
There are already many design issues that have risen out of the sacred elements
and activities that will occur within this spiritual retreat center. Overall, these issues
include such things as: views (from inside out and outside in), lines of vision (views
from one space to another), lighting (both natural and artificial), noise, comfort,
First, from my desire for the center to be open to all, the location, entrance, and
overall exterior view of the center must be welcoming to everyone. This may be by
simply placing the entry in a prominent, easily viewed and accessed location, or by
some other means of welcoming ‘outsiders’. For instance, there could be walls of glass
that allow views in from the outside or by somehow creating an interaction between
both the users of the interior space and those that pass by on the exterior. Perhaps
merely allowing those on the exterior a small glimpse of the activities occurring inside
Interaction is not only physical but also can occur visually. Lines of vision play
an important role when trying to create spaces where interaction can occur among
various people who may not necessarily be sharing the same physical space. Since this
between these people may only be able to occur visually. This interaction could be
designed in such a way that allows for learning from one group yet while not
Another goal is to stimulate interaction between the two ‘groups’ of visitors; the
individual who will probably come to worship, meditate, receive counseling, massage
therapy, etc., and the group of visitors who will probably be coming for a lecture or a
class of some sort, etc. Providing opportunities to see and possibly hear what is going
on in other spaces nearby could be used as a tool to unite these two groups of
participants and spark interest in what the other visitors are experiencing.
Lighting plays a vital role in almost every kind of sacred space imaginable. Thus
in this program it will be important not only in the artificial lighting, but also in the
natural lighting of the sun and how these affect both the interior and exterior spaces.
Light often helps to create the ‘mood’ of a space, and this will be very important in
McGahan 38
certain spaces in the program such as the meditative spaces and the spaces of worship
and prayer.
and noise from the surrounding urban 22) Chapel of St. Ignatius in
Seattle, Washington by
landscape. Issues like comfort and atmosphere Steven Holl Architects
bring up design factors already mentioned like lighting, noise, lines of vision, and other
factors such as the location within the larger space, scale, transitions between spaces,
serenity and calm and yet also allows for the multiple uses
the building for small interior garden areas will be another way to bring these natural
elements indoors for the visitors to enjoy and connect with while inside.
occurring elsewhere. The background material of the wall can differ depending on the
desired effect. If glass, the wall could serve as a sort of ‘screen’ between spaces by
allowing sunlight to pass through it but having the moving water create a translucent
wall. This water wall would appeal to not only the visual and audible senses of the
visitors but would also allow them to physically interact with it by touching the water
Finally, designing transitional spaces not only among the various kinds of
calm, sacred space, but that it reorients the visitor’s mind as well so as to prepare
him/her for the experience to come. These transitional features mimic the main theme
of the ‘sacred space’ as being its own transition between the human, earthly realm and
Site
Introduction:
My site is located on the corner of Sycamore Street and East Fourth Street in the
downtown area of Cincinnati, Ohio. This site is currently undeveloped and owned by
the bank Western and Southern Life, located one block northeast. This bank also owns
many adjacent properties, including two of the parking garages within a block of my
Cincinnati is located in southwest Ohio and is bounded by the Ohio River to the
south, and the rest of Hamilton County to the west, north and east. It sits at the meeting
Cincinnati is the twenty-third largest city in the United States and the second
largest in Ohio.69 It is located within six hundred miles of more than half of the entire
nation’s population.70 The Downtown area’s population, as of the year 2000, was
5,447 people.71 However this number is growing rapidly as more and more developers
open up more lofts and apartments for downtown living. The population of the entire
city of Cincinnati was 331,285 people in the year 2000 (See Appendix I). Cincinnati’s
elevation rests at around 490 feet above sea level downtown and up to 560 feet and
The downtown area of the city is easily accessible from a multitude of locations
via a variety of types of transportation. These include not only the highway systems
that run through and around the city but also the city’s metro bus system, the shuttle
service from Kentucky to Cincinnati, the city’s pedestrian skywalk, and the new
pedestrian bridge from Kentucky to Cincinnati. There are also many parking lots and
garages for those who travel by car into the city. Some 80,000 employees make their
McGahan 42
way into the downtown area everyday using these modes of transportation as well as
120,000 visitors.73
the already existing spaces like the number of parks in the downtown area and
religious institutions that are spread throughout the city. There are many Christian
places of worship throughout the downtown area as well as one Jewish temple and a
History:
In ancient, prehistoric times, the land that we now know as Cincinnati was
home to Native Americans like the Adena and the Hopewell Indians.74 Southern Ohio
was later home to Miami and Shawnee groups, who were driven out by the Iroquois
around the 1660’s.75 Some of these Native Americans who were driven out returned,
only to be driven out again in 1730 by white American settlements.76 The area near the
intersection of four rivers was a crossing point for these and other Native American
Around 1789 this area was given its first name, Losantiville. One of its first
settlers, John Filson named it this because it means “town opposite the mouth” meaning
the mouth of the Licking River, which opens up onto the Ohio River. At Losantiville
there was a fort known as Fort Washington, which gave military protection to the
In 1790 the area was renamed Cincinnati, by the Northwest Territory governor
General Arthur St. Clair. He gave it this name in honor of two peoples, first the Roman
soldier Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus and the Society of Cincinnati who were an
Settlement began around 1794 after the area was opened to newcomers.80
Cincinnati was chartered as a town in 1802 and then as a city in 1819.81 After the war
of 1812, the city was in the center of the trade markets on the river.82 In 1827 the
building of the Miami Canal was completed and opened, which created an economic
surge in Cincinnati.83
Religious conflicts in Germany led to many German immigrants moving into the
city around the 1830’s.84 Also, a potato famine in Ireland added many Irish
population soared to over 46,000.86 These two cultural and ethnic groups would prove
to have a lasting effect on the city from their arrival up to the present day.
The 1850’s brought with it steamboats, which cluttered up the city’s harbors
with more than 8,000 of them docked regularly.87 This was also the time when
Cincinnati first got its nickname “Porkopolis”, which stems from its status as the
After the Civil War the city prospered from new trade with southern states and
its population grew to over 200,000 people.89 Businessmen of the time began to
arrange for railroads to be built to connect the city with southern cities to further this
across the United States. Finally in 1880 the city of Cincinnati built its first rail line to
In the 1920’s and 30’s there was an abundance of new construction going on in
and around the city, which gave us some great Art Deco styled architecture that we still
treasure today. The Carew Tower, Union Terminal, and the Times Star Building, are
just a few of these works that continue to stand out in the city.92
backgrounds. This richness has been gained not only by the more recent immigration
McGahan 45
by Europeans but also from the original, and often times forgotten, Native Americans
the history , present, and future (and all the 26) Union Terminal
Population:
Cincinnati’s population was 331,285, which included 5,447 of those who live in the
During the decade between 1990 and 2000, there were dramatic shifts in
population growth and decline, based on race. In Appendix II you can see these racial
population shifts broken down into areas of Hamilton County. Overall, the Caucasian
about 3%, and most interesting of all, the Hispanic population grew by an astounding
77%! This shows that within the county, racial diversity is increasing, which
only leaves a small percentage for a mixture of other races (mostly Asians and
Hispanics), all of which can be seen in Appendix I, in addition to some other Cincinnati
statistics.
research and I have included another chart in Appendix III regarding religious
adherence in the area. The survey was taken in 1990 and in 2000 and shows a graph
displaying the changes over this decade. Overall, Catholicism has the highest number
increase in people of the Jewish faith is shown, as well as in the category labeled
“other”, but we unfortunately do not know what makes up this category. Hinduism is
not listed as a part of this survey, and the Muslim category does not show any results.
McGahan 47
However, common knowledge of the area and organizations within Cincinnati tells us
Cincinnati has what is known as a ‘moderate’ climate. The city experiences four
distinct seasons per year ranging from harshly cold winters with snow and ice to
blazing hot summers with high humidity. Average annual rainfall for Cincinnati is
about forty inches with the most being during the spring and early summer.93 The
overall average low temperature is around thirty-one degrees Fahrenheit and the
temperature and weather history can be found in Appendix IV). Strong northwest
winds are the prevailing winds of this area and there is an average annual snowfall of
Site Analysis
Description:
My site is located on the corner of Sycamore Street and East Fourth Street in the
and is roughly 99 feet x 225 feet in area, which equates to nearly a half an acre of land.
the area is rarely used and not well maintained. 27) My Site
Across and also farther down the street toward the east the sidewalks are lined with
trees, which both brings down the scale of the area and adds some warmth.
The site is on a corner lot, which allows two of its sides to be open and a third
side is open to a parking lot. On the fourth (south) side there is a seven-story parking
garage that blocks most of the south boundary of the site and therefore the most
opportunity for southern sun exposure. There will be an abundant amount of morning
sun from the east but not as much from the west as there is multi-story office building
across the street on this side. These issues will provide an interesting challenge on how
Surrounding my site are many interesting organizations and services that will
support my program. First there are three major office buildings one block to the west
and one block to the northwest of my site, which will definitely provide a large number
of workers who might potentially use this program. Across Fourth Street to the north
McGahan 50
there is the Christ Church Cathedral, which includes a Christian church, store and
other related services. Adjacent to the church is the International Language Center,
different context.
Southern Life Bank one block over. Both of these will again add more opportunities for
potential users of the site. Next, on Broadway Street, which is one street east of
Sycamore, there are recently renovated apartments and another building which is
Immediately adjacent to my site, on the east, is a parking lot and building which
is owned by the Queen City Club. This is a private organization that houses social
gatherings, meals, and events for its members. As mentioned, there is a public parking
garage located directly behind the site to the south, which could provide parking to the
Moving farther out from the site there are more office buildings including the
Chiquita Building and also one of Cincinnati’s largest employers, Procter & Gamble.
Locating the site near all of these businesses, organizations, and apartments will provide
Transportation:
One major advantage to this site is the location of a bus stop immediately across
Fourth Street next to the Christ Church Cathedral. This will provide, for the users of
the site, an excellent means of transportation just a few steps away. The shuttle service
that runs among Newport, Covington, and Cincinnati passes just one block away from
the site as well. The city’s skywalk ends at the office building right across Sycamore
Street to the west and the pedestrian bridge is not too far of a walk to the east.
near the site including the public garage directly to the south which can provide
parking for users who might drive to the site. Finally, the site is located near the
various highway ramps, which will also allow for quick navigation to these parking
somewhat blocked by tall office buildings, because some wind gets tunneled down the
As mentioned, sunlight and sun patterns will be of great importance to this site
and design. Having a south façade that is almost completely blocked by a seven-story
parking garage will provide a great challenge for getting sunlight to interior spaces of
the program. Two tall, office buildings shade the western side, but since these are
separated by a large street, some sunlight can pass through at various times. The north
side has much shorter buildings, as does the east, which allows much more sunlight to
Pollution concerns around the site stem mostly from the various transportation
types that occur in the city. These include pollution and noise from cars and trucks,
from the local buses, and other exhaust and odor from nearby buildings. There is some
noise associated with the nearby riverfront and highway systems, however having
visited the site many times I have observed that this particular area of downtown is
noticeably more quiet than most others. In any case, noise will be an issue that will
have to be addressed in the design for both indoor and outdoor spaces.
McGahan 53
Site Plans:
The following site plans are attached within this document at the end of this
corner and is delineated by a solid black box. As this plan shows, the site is nearby the
major highway ramps and is only a few blocks from the riverfront area.
Plan B- This site plan notes all of the neighboring buildings and their functions
and user groups. As noted by the street directions, the approach to the site will be from
either traveling south on Sycamore Street or west on Fourth Street. Also shown are the
few trees that line Fourth Street near the site and in front of the Christ Church
Cathedral. The bus stop is pointed out directly across the street from the site as well.
Plan C- This plan is a figure-ground map, which shows the solids and voids
from the previous site plan. Here you can more easily see what is a solid building or
Plan D- This plan shows some notes and important features from the site
analysis. Noted here are wind directions in summer and winter, topography changes,
noise, views and a few other elements that may be important to the site and my design.
Plan E- This, along with Plan F, is showing an overall estimate of the sun
shadows produced if the sun was coming from the southeast direction. There are two
plans, one showing the shadows produced from the sun in winter when the sun angle
is low and the second from in the summer when the sun angle is high.
Plan F- Similar to the previous plan, this plan shows the same sun shadows only
this time if the sun was coming from the southwest direction. Again there are two
plans, one showing the winter sun and one showing summer.
McGahan 54
From both of these plans one can see that the low winter sun angles produce
shadows that extend out farther across my site from the neighboring buildings than the
summer sun shadows. Also shown is that the high-rise office building to the west will
put a great deal of shade upon my site when the sun is coming from that direction. So,
as previously believed, due to these general, estimated shadow conditions and the
inability to get much south sun exposure, I am presented with a challenge to get sun
into spaces in my program and still allow the site to communicate with nature and the
outdoors.
Other challenges will be to somehow block the northwestern winter winds and
perhaps somehow gain access to the southwestern summer breezes. Also, a need to
create outdoor spaces for the users of this program in both group and individual
settings may provide the opportunity for unique design solutions. Another challenge is
to not allow noise and other pollution from the passing vehicles and buses to disrupt or
Bibliography
Texts/Articles:
Brill, Mike and Robert Riley. “Workshop: Exploring the Notion of ‘Charged’ and
Tucson, 1989.
Eliade, Mircea. Patterns in Comparative Religion. New York: First Meridian Printing,
1958.
Eliade, Mircea. The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion. New York:
Harcourt, 1959.
Gawain, Shakti. The Four Levels of Healing. New York: MJF, 1997.
Hamma, Robert M. Landscapes of the Soul: A Spirituality of Place. Notre Dame: Ave
Heathcote, Edwin and Iona Spens. Church Builders. West Sussex: Academy Editions,
1997.
Hinnells, John R., ed. Dictionary of Religions. New York: Penguin, 1997.
Jones, Timothy. A Place for God: A Guide to Spiritual Retreats and Retreat Centers.
Kedar, Benjamin Z., and R.J. Zwi Werblowsky, eds. Sacred Space: Shrine, City,
Nelson, Bob. “Take a break to combat work stress,” Business Courier 23 June 2003.
http://cincinnati.bizjournals.com/extraedge/consultants/return_on_people/
2003/06/23/column236.html?market=Cincinnati
Quinn, Susan. The Deepest Spiritual Life: The Art of Combining Personal Spiritual
Practice with Religious Community. Ashland, OR: White Cloud Press, 2002.
Saile, David G. and Jim Postell, eds. “Making Sacred Places.” Built Form and Cultural
Sheldrake, Philip. Spaces for the Sacred: Place, Memory, and Identity. Baltimore: The
Websites:
http://www.christocenter.org/aboutus/history.html
http://www.cincinnati.areaconnect.com/statistics.htm
http://www.cincinnatiusa.org
McGahan 57
http://www.cincyusa.com/media/releases/pr0300d.asp?sec=med&cat=
http://www.cityrating.com
http://www.covenantfarm.com
http://www.dickshovel.com/up.html
http://www.dictionary.com
http://www.downtowncincinnati.com
http://www.eastretreat.org
http://www.enquirer.com/flood_of_97/science1.html
http://www.grailville.com
http://www.hamiltoncountyauditor.org/realestate/
http://www.hamilton-co.org/History.ASP?NavBar=1
http://www.msnbc.com/news/794262.asp
http://www.retreatfinder.com
http://www.richmondhillva.org
http://www.sspx.org/miscellaneous/history_of_the_ignatian_retreat.htm
http://www.uc.edu/news/ebriefs/stress03.htm
http://www.usacitiesonline.com/ohcountycincinnati.htm
http://users.rcn.com/chicagobuddha/chicagobuddha/ctour1door.html
http://www.uwec.edu/freitard/GroupAndMinority/Cincinnati/
CincinnatiDemographics.htm
http://www.worldfellowship.org
Appendixes:
Appendix I: http://www.cincinnati.areaconnect.com/statistics.htm
2000%20SNA%20Population%20Change.pdf
Appendix V: http://www.cincinnatiusa.org/pdf/pop/city_pop.pdf
McGahan 59
Endnotes