You are on page 1of 6

[Downloaded free from http://www.jioh.org on Wednesday, June 23, 2021, IP: 27.6.59.

233]

Review Article

COVID-19 and Dental Education: A Malaysian Perspective


Mohamad Syahrizal Halim, Tahir Yusuf Noorani, Mohamad Isaqali Karobari, Noorshaida Kamaruddin
Conservative Dentistry Unit, School of Dental Science, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kelantan, Malaysia

Abstract
Dental education in Malaysia has been struck badly by the novel SARS-CoV2 coronavirus (COVID-19). This has brought to a halt
all teaching and learning activities, aimed at stopping the spread of COVID-19, forcing students and lecturers to shift to online
teaching and learning activities. However, dental education teaching and learning is unique in nature as it involves close contact with
patients and aerosol-related procedures. This article discusses the challenges faced by the lecturers and students during this pandemic
and offers some alternative strategies to bridge the gap in dental education during an unprecedented time. Although COVID-19 has
ceased all clinical teaching and learning activities in most universities, it is imperative for the delivery of dental education to continue
to ensure students are always engaged in learning activities. Although for many dental lecturers this change to online learning is a
steep learning curve, they need to be fast learners, embrace the incorporation of technology into learning programs, and adapt to the
new norms. They need to familiarize themselves with online learning to ensure that the course syllabus is covered comprehensively.
For students, they must have the right mindset that this change is bound to exist until COVID-19 has been brought under control and
lockdown is no more relevant.

Keywords: COVID-19, Dental Education, Educators Perspective, Malaysia Education, Students Perspective, University Students
Received: 15-01-2021, Revised: 25-03-2021, Accepted: 09-04-2021, Published: 18-06-2021.

Introduction the pandemic towards dental or medical education have


not been fully studied except in Hong Kong,[2] China,[3]
Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-
and South Korea.[4] Patil et al. advocates the restriction of
CoV-2) or better known as coronavirus disease 2019
mass gathering of medical students in a lecture hall. The
(COVID-19) infection is caused by the novel coronaviridae
use of information technology into teaching and learning
virus, originating from Wuhan Province, China. This has
was encouraged.[2] This was further highlighted by Meng
led to a global COVID-19 pandemic,[1] forcing universities
et al., where they recommend adopting to online lectures,
to close their operations, thus sending students back to
case studies, and problem-based learning during outbreak
their homes or locked down in their hostels. Hospitals
in China. Students are also encouraged to take part in
suspended all nonessential services, including dental
self-improving themselves by self-directed learning.[3] Park
procedures, only to cater for emergency procedures.
et al. suggested more detail measures to ensure protection
Although in the last two decades alone, there have been to medical students by advocating the discontinuation of
two cases of coronaviridae virus outbreak, Severe Acute bedside case clerking, self monitoring of health status,
Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) in 2002 and Middle East closure of the medical school and adjusting the academic
Respiratory Syndrome (MERS) in 2004, coronavirus has calendar in affected teaching hospital, arranging schedule
still become an issue that cannot be contained. Special
attention should be given to dentistry as coronavirus tends
to infect the human lungs and is transmitted via aerosol
Address for correspondence: Dr. Mohamad Syahrizal Halim,
and droplets. This respiratory virus outbreak has affected Conservative Dentistry Unit, School of Dental Science, Universiti Sains
many sectors, particularly education and dentistry, which Malaysia, Health Campus, 16150 Kubang Kerian, Kelantan, Malaysia.
is the prime interest of this article. The repercussions of E-mail: drsyah@usm.my

This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the
Access this article online
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows
Quick Response Code: others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as
Website: appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
www.jioh.org
For reprints contact: reprints@medknow.com

DOI: How to cite this article: Halim MS, Noorani TY, Karobari MI,
10.4103/jioh.jioh_8_21 Kamaruddin N.  COVID-19 and dental education: A  Malaysian
perspective. J Int Oral Health 2021;13:201-6.

      © 2021 Journal of International Oral Health | Published by Wolters Kluwer ‑ Medknow 201  
[Downloaded free from http://www.jioh.org on Wednesday, June 23, 2021, IP: 27.6.59.233]

Halim, et al.: Dental education during COVID-19

patient clerking at another teaching hospital, and remote is almost impossible. A  dentist needs to be trained
lectures and problem-based learning tutorials. with adequate knowledge together with good clinical
skills to be competent during undergraduate training.
The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted many normal
Dental education is designed to cover specific cognitive
daily activities all around the world, including dental
(knowledge) and psychomotor aspects (skills) to equip
education. Schools and universities across the globe have
dental students in treating patients effectively. These skills
suspended face-to-face teaching, learning activities and
cannot be taught through a video demonstration alone;
are encouraged to resume lectures via online platform
it requires a certified tutor or lecturer to show and guide
to curb the spread of COVID-19.[1] Social gatherings,
them to be competent in certain procedures. Students need
including those in educational institutions, are banned
to be taught on the responsibility of treating patients,
due to the threat of promoting the spread of COVID-
following the standard operating protocol for specific
19. Some students were sent back to their hometown
clinical procedures and observation of chairside etiquettes
until further notice. This is the scenario that was faced
in dealing with patients complaint and problems. This is
by the Malaysian dental universities students when the
necessary especially in Malaysia because every dental
government imposed a strict Movement Control Order
school is checked regularly by a governing body, that
(MCO) from 18 March to 17 May 2021, where all face-to-
is the Malaysian Qualifying Agency (MQA) and every
face teaching and learning was halted.[5] Then on 27 April
dental school is obliged to adhere to the criteria and
2020, the Malaysian Higher Education Ministry started
requirements that have been set by them. Many dental
the process of sending most of the universities student to
schools in Malaysia still uphold the minimum clinical
their hometown. All teaching and learning activities needs
experiences together with a competency-based assessment
to be continued via online distant learning including dental
in every discipline before a student can graduate as a
students until 31 December 2020.[6] This has caught many
competent dentist.
students and educators off guard with a drastic transition
to distant online teaching and learning (e-learning) to What We Already Know
ensure students are not left idle during this pandemic
• COVID-19 is affecting every sector of daily life.
lockdown. Even though we are already in the digital era,
• COVID-19 has left the educational sector with
most students are still comfortable with conventional
uncertainty future and instability.
didactic lectures and face-to-face teaching and learning
• Dentistry is at high risk of spreading the COVID-19
activities, while they cope with online learning.[7] This was
disease
made more difficult as the directive and information from
the Government keep changing from time to time due to What this Article Adds
different phases of MCO in Malaysia.[8] There was a time • Insight of dental students perspective towards COVID-
when that face-to-face teaching and learning was allowed 19 pandemic to their routine academic activites.
to be done with minimal attendance especially among • Dental educators perspective towards online distance
students that need practical session and final year students learning in dentistry and the repercussions towards
after the CMCO was implemented.[9,10] But sudden spike resulting dental education standards.
in cases in Malaysia led to a 2nd MCO which again
halted face-to-face teaching and learning.[11] This setback The aim of this article is to provide an insight on the
imposed stress to students, lecturers, and administrators. challenges faced by the dental education system and
contains recommendations to dental schools and faculties
Dentistry has been categorized as a very-high risk
on alternative to fulfill the expected requirements to
occupation for potential COVID-19 infection spread.[12]
nurture and help competent dental graduates.
This is due to the aerosol generating procedures associated
commonly with all patient treatments.[7] Dentistry deals
with the oral cavity of a patient which harbors millions Students’ Perspective
of bacteria and viruses. Furthermore, aerosols are created Tuition fees
when dental personnel use high speed hand pieces and There are two types of dental colleges in Malaysia currently,
ultrasonic scalers in a patients’ mouth. This leads to one being government funded universities and the other is
easier transmission of airborne diseases, particularly the private universities. The former has minimal fees ranging
COVID-19 virus in dental clinics, potentially affecting between MYR 14,000 and the later may reach up to MYR
the dental practitioner, assisting staff and the patient 600,000 for 5 years course.[13] The impact of this COVID-
themselves. Thus, the nature of dentistry makes it even 19 on students in public or government universities may
more challenging in delivering dental education during not be as hard as that of private institute dental students.
the COVID-19 pandemic. The balance between protection Nonetheless, students are still expected to pay their fees
of dental students, staffs, and patients while fulfilling the in full, regardless of the class being postponed and halted
requirements of nurturing a competent future dentist due to this pandemic. Online classes are still conducted,
is difficult. Social distancing in practising dentistry but without practical or clinical session.

      
202 202  Journal of International Oral Health ¦ Volume 13 ¦ Issue 3 ¦ May-June 2021
[Downloaded free from http://www.jioh.org on Wednesday, June 23, 2021, IP: 27.6.59.233]

Halim, et al.: Dental education during COVID-19

This leads to students’ acceptance towards online learning and motivation since it is proven that increased screen
beyond satisfactory. The online classes did not seem time may deviate students’ attention.[9] Additionally, the
equivalent to the amount of money they invested in the environment the students face at home may also deter
tuition fees. They hoped online learning will not resume them from focusing on the online classes. Distraction
after the pandemic is under control and the movement from siblings, parents, improper place to study may result
control order (MCO) ends.[7] Some of them hoped they in loss of focus. The absence of social interaction and
can get reimbursed for their missed classes and clinical formation of study groups are some of the drawbacks
sessions. But this is unlikely as the university has invested of online learning. Lecturers cannot sense students’
a lot of money in human resources, equipment, and incomprehension through facial expression, change in the
facilities to ensure the classes can resume online and mood by small jokes in between the tutorial, and absence
students were not left idle during COVID-19 associated of students engagement and interaction are some of the
MCO. This requires a forbearance from both sides. drawbacks of online learning.[7]
Many students also feel overburdened with the current
COVID-19 pandemic. They are not allowed to go Internet connection for online learning
to classes, meet their peers and lecturers. Pre-clinical To have suitable online classes, lecturers and students need
practical sessions cannot be done at the university and to have a very good and stable internet connection together
clinical students cannot see patients. Some students with sound technical computer skills.[10] These are one of
who are sponsored candidates feel stressed because they the major issues being faced by both parties during distant
are tied to a fixed timeline given by their sponsors to online learning.[11,12] This is worrying because 60% of the
finish their study. With MCO or lockdown, they cannot students did their online learning from their home which
complete their clinical requirements. Hence they cannot is in town or city areas with only 6% of students have a
fulfill the necessary requirements to appear for the very good internet connection and 40% with good internet
final exams. Students’ sponsors need to be aware of the connectivity.[7] Not to mention some lecturers are also not
unforeseen circumstances faced by the students under familiar with this new norm during COVID-19 pandemic.
their sponsorship during these unprecedented times. Since most university students, including dental students
were sent home by their respective universities during
Some self-sponsored students have also had a difficulty the MCO imposed by the Government of Malaysia, the
in paying their tuition fees. This may be because their internet connection was a major setback. In Malaysia,
parents or guardian were laid off due to the recession and there are areas still without good internet coverage. This
slowdown in most economic sectors. The universities need will affect some students and their learning experience,
to be mindful of this condition and work out some easy especially those from rural areas. Even though internet is
payment scheme or direct the students to financial aid easily accessible in most places in Malaysia, the stability
to ensure the continuity of education for these affected of the internet connection was not good during MCO
students. time. A  sudden increase in internet traffic shocked most
internet providers in Malaysia, forcing them to improve
Peer connection their service.
Peer connection is very important as an informal teaching
This issue may be tackled by increasing the asynchronous
and learning process. Exchange of ideas and revision of
rather than synchronous online learning. Lecturers can
individual understanding of certain topics might vary.
record a video presentation, edit, and upload their lecture
Hence they need to get in touch with their peers. Meeting
content in specific online learning platforms for their
and discussion with peers during seminars, problem-
students to revise. This is very useful where students can go
based learning (PBL) activities, case-based learning
to a specific place such as near the main road in rural areas
(CBL), and tutorials will enhance their critical thinking
to download the video content shared by their lecturer.
towards problem-solving. Face-to-face communication
This method is suitable when two-way communication is
during seminars will boost their confidence in talking to
not necessary for the learning outcome of that specific
a colleague, lecturers, and patients. Good communication
topic. This way, students can use their internet data
skills are very crucial to extract information from the
cautiously, when compared with synchronous teaching
patient regarding their disease or problem, developing a
and learning activities which uses big internet data.
diagnosis, and formulating a treatment plan. This platform
This also is a challenge to telecommunication carriers to
is useful in case of introvert students since they must face
widen their coverage and improve the stability of internet
a tutor or lecturer in the seminar, CBL, or PBL session.
connection. Not every student has the luxury of having
Without doubt this can also be done through online or a fixed home broadband, most of them rely on mobile
distant learning as was undertaken in School of Medical internet which can sometime become unstable especially
Sciences Universiti Sains Malaysia;[8] however, the in rural areas or when there is an increase in internet
experience may not be the same. Students may lose focus traffic at specific point of time such as during the MCO.

      Journal of International Oral Health ¦ Volume 13 ¦ Issue 3 ¦ May-June 2021 203  


[Downloaded free from http://www.jioh.org on Wednesday, June 23, 2021, IP: 27.6.59.233]

Halim, et al.: Dental education during COVID-19

Lack of student’s engagement during online classes correct way to extract a tooth or proper way to do a crown
Some students are reluctant and resilient towards online preparation. This cannot be achieved by online learning
classes. This may be due to individual preferences and alone. A tutor or lecturer needs to be at their side to ensure
attitudes. They prefer online learning to be a supplemental the proper procedure being conducted, be able to correct
form to conventional classes, in the form of flash lectures the students’ mistakes together with ensuring the patients’
and procedural videos.[13] safety throughout the dental procedure.
This can be improved by introducing online learning Although it has been suggested that the solution to this is
to the students at the very beginning of dental school to have peer reviews of the students clinical work together
enrolment, expectations of distant learning made clear to with a panel of supervising faculty member, this is still
each student including explaining to them in the course not very convincing.[18] One suggestion would be to delay
or module description. Extra points for continuous the academic year until COVID-19 cases can be brought
assessment can be given for students’ participation during to a controllable number or until a vaccine is made
online seminar, case-based discussion or journal club, available. This may result in many students and university
whether synchronous or asynchronous classes. This authorities being unhappy since the students cannot
requires the creativity of dental lecturers to encourage achieve graduation on time. This will be unpopular but
students to participate in online classes. a necessary sacrifice during unprecedented COVID-19
pandemic. Maybe this is the time where universities, faculty,
Quality of online learning activity materials and regulatory agencies to be more flexible regarding
Online learning has shown to save time, reduce cost, curriculum fulfillments and competency assessment. This
allowing students to learn in their flexible time outside has to be taken into account as the students also face
the classroom and with broader knowledge transfer. This pandemic-related and financial stress.[16] Up to date, there
methods also allows a shift towards more active learner was no official press release from Malaysia Dental Dean
centered rather than passive teacher centered learning.[14,15] Cauncil regarding this requirement for undergraduate
But to ensure the success of online learning, student students to graduate, but nonetheless this issue has been
satisfaction is one of the key factors.[16] This can be fulfilled sorted out internally.
by ensuring the contents of the online lecture is interactive,
with the intended learning outcomes being coverage and Academia Perspective
ease of access.[17] Lecturers need to ensure they have this
Online learning skills and competencies
expertise in online teaching and this challenge should be
It has been brought to attention that it is important to
accepted with open arms. Students need to be offered
systematically plan and train lecturers on online teaching
a valuable and interactive online learning activities to
in medical education as well as dental education.[19]
ensure their acceptance and readiness to change. This is
Firstly, as an academician cum clinical specialist in each
important to avoid the withdrawal from online learning
discipline, lecturers need to have good understanding
activities and shift towards traditional face-to-face
on different types of pedagogies in online teaching.
teaching and learning activities in the future once face-to-
Synchronous teaching is a real-time interaction between a
face learning activities is resume.[7]
lecturer and the students, whereas asynchronous teaching
is a pre-recorded video or slides before or after the classes
Practical-based competencies begin.[20] These different teaching methods serve its own
Competency refers to the expected qualification of an purposes. Synchronous teaching aims to fulfill knowledge
individual who is about to begin an independent practice delivery to a novice and encourage peer interaction like
of a profession with specific skills, knowledge, and values a classroom setting. Didactic lectures can be delivered
expected in that profession. Most dental schools in to students, supported by online seminars to encourage
Malaysia adhere to competency-based exams, requiring students to discuss on issues related to the topic. By this
students to be assessed by lecturers while treating patients. method, lecturers can engage actively with the students,
Competency-based procedure cannot be taught or grade the students during online classes and show a demo
examined via online learning. Since conventional chairside on certain clinical procedures. Critical thinking can be
teaching is forbidden during MCO, practical-based assessed during synchronous teaching, but limited to one
subjects are lacking in exercise including communication person discussion at one time to ensure proper delivery
skills with patients. Students’ self-perceived competency of messages and input. This synchronous teaching can
also may also be affected because of inadequate credit be done with various video webinar platforms such as
hours in practical session including chairside clinical Microsoft TEAMS, WEBEX, Zoom, Skype, or Whatsapp.
teaching. Most dental students are taught to treat a
patient’s problem, not just by observing. They need to Asynchronous teaching involves preparing a lecture
learn how to communicate with the patient during history material and uploading it to the institutional e-learning
taking, know and feel how to do a correct restoration, platform to be accessed at the students’ convenience.

      
204 204  Journal of International Oral Health ¦ Volume 13 ¦ Issue 3 ¦ May-June 2021
[Downloaded free from http://www.jioh.org on Wednesday, June 23, 2021, IP: 27.6.59.233]

Halim, et al.: Dental education during COVID-19

This will facilitate collaborative learning and ensure Research activities and publication
effective embedded knowledge to the students. In this Since many dental schools closed their operations when
method, students are encouraged to seek out of classroom the government imposed a lockdown or MCO, laboratory
knowledge, videos, and tutorials to ensure they observe research-based activities were also put on hold. Any
the clinical procedures before they do it on live patients. ongoing laboratory procedures and some time-sensitive
But with this, sometimes the information from the internet specimens were damaged when researchers could not go
can be overwhelming and irrelevant to students expected to the laboratory. Most researchers that are involved in
programme outcome. The videos and tutorials from the a laboratory-based study are either financed by a local
web may not be the standard operating procedure from or international grant and are in a rigid time line, where
the universities, which makes it dangerous for students to their research needs to be finished before the due date,
practice. not to mention the report of findings from the research
During this difficult time, it is necessary for lecturers to activities. No doubt this made many researchers sleepless
keep themselves updated with the current trends and and distressed. The sponsoring body needs to be aware
knowledge especially in online learning skills to get the of this unprecedented COVID-19 pandemic lockdown
attention from the students. It is not an easy change, which forces every activity to be put on hold. Indeed, they
but a change that must be done although it has resulted should be able to negotiate their contract regarding the
in substantial adjustment. The Ministry of Higher timeline to finish their research project.
Education of Malaysia has been promoting the usage of During COVID-19 pandemic, there were some silver
online e-learning platform to deliver the course teaching linings observed. Since many researchers were forced to
material. Preclinical lectures and case-based exercise stay at home, pending manuscripts could be completed
can be delivered using a video recording followed by an resulting in a sudden surge of publication submissions to
online quiz. Clinical video related to certain topics can be various journals.[17-19] This has forced journal editors to
shared from the internet source if not readily available at really scrutinize the research papers with more caution
the lecturers’ disposal. This is necessary to keep students for their respective journals. Three months after the
engaged during lockdown or MCO.[21] lockdown, it was far more difficult to publish an article due
to this increase in submissions for publication according
Assessment for cognitive (knowledge), psychomotor to various authors’ experience.
(skills), and affective domain
During the lockdown or MCO, dental students are not
allowed to be in campus. Examinations can be difficult to
Conclusion
be conducted if MCO or lockdown is extended. Although Although COVID-19 has ceased all clinical teaching and
theory exams in the form of Multiple choice Question learning activities in most universities, it is imperative for
(MCQs), Short answer question (SAQs), and clinical delivery of dental education to continue to ensure students
scenario with photos for objective structure clinical are always engaged in learning activities.[23] Although for
examination (OSCE) can be done via e-learning platform, many dental lecturers this change to online learning is a
the psychomotor assessment for clinical examination steep learning curve, they need to be fast learners, embrace
still cannot be undertaken. Lecturers may not be able to the incorporation of technology into learning programs,
assess students’ performance for psychomotor domain and adapt to the new norms. They need to familiarize
or clinical skills aspects during this MCO. This is very themselves with online learning to ensure that the course
disturbing as dentistry deals a lot with clinical skills syllabus is covered comprehensively. For students, they
together with affective domain or professionalism aspect. must have the right mind set that this change is bound to
A suggestion was to have the psychomotor assessment at a exist until COVID-19 has been brought under control and
later date once the MCO is lifted and results from current MCO or lockdown is no more relevant.
examination considered provisional until subsequent
psychomotor component examinations were done.[8] This Recommendation
may be suitable in other years of the dentistry program but Future respiratory disease outbreak is difficult to predict as
not the final year; because they are going to be registered this depends so much on the ability of certain virus strains
as qualified dental practitioners once final exam results to mutate and causing severe manifestation in human once
are announced. Alternatively, dental schools can opt for it cross-infects from animals. Therefore, it is paramount to
alternative competency examinations during final year all dental schools to equip themselves with the equipment
professional exam that does not involve direct patient and facilities to continuously cater treatment to patients
contact such as procedures on typodont teeth in the even during the pandemic. It has been acknowledged
pre-clinical laboratory. Dental schools can also consider that dental treatment is highly potential for the spread
a more longitudinal and global assessment of students of airborne disease, hence there is no reason for dental
overall competence rather than a single point during final school to not be prepared for future outbreak to ensure
professional examination.[22] the ongoing dental treatment and dental education during

      Journal of International Oral Health ¦ Volume 13 ¦ Issue 3 ¦ May-June 2021 205  


[Downloaded free from http://www.jioh.org on Wednesday, June 23, 2021, IP: 27.6.59.233]

Halim, et al.: Dental education during COVID-19

the outbreak. Every dental school should allocate an area 9. Bernama. Higher Education Ministry: Students allowed back
on campuses in limited numbers from 1 March 2021. Available
for highly infectious disease treatment delivery for at least
from: https://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2021/01/31/higher-
30% from their allocated dental chair. education-ministry-students-allowed-back-on-campuses-in-limited-
numbers-from-march-1 [Last accessed on November 23, 2020].
Acknowledgement 10. Landau E. University lectures to go online until Dec 31, except for 5
groups. New Straits Times 2020.
Not applicable. 11. Bunyan  J. Higher Education Ministry recommends postponement
of physical intakes at Malaysian public universities. 2020. Available
Financial support and sponsorship from: https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2020/10/02/
higher-education-ministry-recommends-postponement-of-physical-
Nil. intakes-at-ma/1908845#:~:text=KUALA%20LUMPUR%2C%20
October%202%20%E2%80%94%20The,classes%20could%20be%20
Conflicts of interest shifted%20online [Last accessed on October 25, 2020].
Authors declare there are no conflict of interest. 12. Occupational Safety and Health Act. Guidance on preparing
workplaces for COVID-19. Washington, DC: Department of Labor.
2020. Available from: https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/
Author contributions publications/OSHA3990.pdf [Last accessed on April 28, 2021].
MH and MK: Final draft and conceptualization; MH,TN, 13. 32 Dentistry Courses offered by 14 Unis/Colleges in Malaysia:
TimesDigicliff Sdn.Bhd; 2020. Available from: https://afterschool.
MK: First draft, revision, and final approval; MK,NK: my/dentistry-courses [Last accessed on March 7, 2021].
Revision and plagiarism check; MH,MK,NK: Article 14. Ruiz  JG, Mintzer  MJ, Leipzig  RM. The impact of e-learning in
writing and first draft; MK: Advisor, first draft, revision, medical education. Acad Med 2006;81:207-12.
and final approval; TN,NK: Advisor, first draft, and 15. Ramlogan  S, Raman  V, Sweet  J. A comparison of two forms of
teaching instruction: Video vs. live lecture for education in clinical
revision. Finally, all authors approved the final version of periodontology. Eur J Dent Educ 2014;18:31-8.
the manuscript for publication. 16. Hung  M, Licari  FW, Hon  ES, Lauren  E, Su  S, Birmingham  WC,
et  al. In an era of uncertainty: Impact of COVID-19 on dental
education. J Dent Educ 2020;85:148-56.
Ethical policy and institutional review board statement 17. Palayew  A, Norgaard  O, Safreed-Harmon  K, Andersen  TH,
Not applicable. Rasmussen  LN, Lazarus  JV. Pandemic publishing poses a new
COVID-19 challenge. Nat Hum Behav 2020;4:666-9.
Patient declaration of consent 18. Brainard J. Scientists are drowning in COVID-19 papers. Can new
tools keep them afloat? American Association for the Advancement
Not applicable. of Science; 2020. Available from: https://www.sciencemag.org/
news/2020/05/scientists-are-drowning-covid-19-papers-can-new-
Data availability statement tools-keep-them-afloat [Last accessed on October 25, 2020].
19. Kambhampati  SB, Vaishya  R, Vaish  A. Unprecedented surge
Not applicable. in publications related to COVID-19 in the first three months of
pandemic: A  bibliometric analytic report. J Clin Orthop Trauma
References 2020;11(Suppl 3):S304-6.
20. Control of Academic Programs in Public Universities and Private
1. Bedford  J, Enria  D, Giesecke  J, Heymann  DL, Ihekweazu  C, Higher Educational Institutions [Internet]. https://www.mohe.gov.
Kobinger G, et al. COVID-19: Towards controlling of a pandemic. my/en/media-mohe/press-statement/1031-pengendalian-program-
The Lancet 2020;395:1015-8. akademik-di-universiti-awam-ua-dan-institusi-pendidikan-tinggi-
2. Patil  N, Yan  YCH. SARS and its effect on medical education in swasta-ipts: Ministry of Higher Education; 2020; 28 March 2020.
Hong Kong. Med Educ 2003;37:1127-8. Available from: https://www.mohe.gov.my/en/media-mohe/press-
3. Meng  L, Hua  F, Bian  Z. Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19): statement/1031-pengendalian-program-akademik-di-universiti-
Emerging and future challenges for dental and oral medicine. J Dent awam-ua-dan-institusi-pendidikan-tinggi-swasta-ipts [Last accessed
Res 2020;99:481-7. on December 27, 2020].
4. Park  SW, Jang  HW, Choe  YH, Lee  KS, Ahn  YC, Chung  MJ, 21. Universities Students to Return Home from 27th April 2020
et  al. Avoiding student infection during a Middle East respiratory [Internet]. 2020. Available from: https://www.mohe.gov.my/en/
syndrome (MERS) outbreak: A  single medical school experience. media-mohe/press-statement/1079-pergerakan-pulang-pelajar-
Korean J Med Educ 2016;28:209-17. ipt-ke-kampung-halaman-mulai-27-april-2020 [Last accessed on
5. Iyer  P, Aziz  K, Ojcius  DM. Impact of COVID-19 on dental December 27, 2020].
education in the United States. J Dent Educ 2020;84:718-22. 22. Education Malaysia Global Services. COVID-19 Guidelines and
6. Emanuel  EJ. The inevitable reimagining of medical education. Advice for International Students 2020. Available from: https://
JAMA 2020;323:1127-8. educationmalaysia.gov.my/covid-19-guidelines-and-advice-for-
7. Chung  E, Subramaniam  G, Dass  LC. Online learning readiness international-students/ [Last accessed on March 7, 2021].
among University Students in Malaysia Amidst Covid-19. Asian J 23. Karobari  MI, Marya  A, Venugopal  A, Nalabothu  P, Parveen  A,
Univ Educ 2020;16:45-58. Noorani  TY. The state of orthodontic practice after the outbreak
8. Saeed SG, Bain J, Khoo E, Siqueira WL. COVID-19: Finding silver of COVID-19 in Southeast Asia: the current scenario and future
linings for dental education. J Dent Educ 2020;84:1060-3. recommendations. Asia Pac J Public Health 2020;32:517-8.

      
206 206  Journal of International Oral Health ¦ Volume 13 ¦ Issue 3 ¦ May-June 2021

You might also like