:"%O+&%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+'(+*'-24-'#(*+O'-.

+&%)"4&%&+'(,#"P4-'#(+

1*3%(+G6*-4&E+<4)(.'8&+R44"*-4&E+7#9%"-+<$S#(48&+
./!&0.1,$#$*$%&234&%1%45(&$%6-13+35(7&8&9!:;&<=+"%1&>%=6$34&)43?%6$@&A34B=(C&&
!DE=#+F&%,G%1C1(,$="H#2%C13@&E=51-#+"CI==4,$="H#2%C13@&43'%4$CE6"31=+"H#2%C13&
&

&
S2"'()+ 4(+ 49(#"P48+ %T%(-E+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+ #3%"4-#"*+ P2*-+ "%86+ #(+ -.%+ 4T4'8498%+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ '(+ -.%+ .2P4(J*6*-%P+
'(-%",4$%+ UV5FW+ -#+ 2(&%"*-4(&+ 4(&+ P4Q%+ *%(*%+ #,+ O.4-+ '*+ )#'()+ #(+ 4(&+ P4Q%+ -.%+ "').-+ &%$'*'#(*;+ X(&%"+ *#P%+
$#(&'-'#(*+-.%+'(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+P46+,4'8+4(&+"%*28-+'(+P'**'()+#"+'($#""%$-+'(,#"P4-'#(;+R8%'(Y*+&4-4N,"4P%+-.%#"6+
3#*-284-%*+-.4-+O.%(+P4Q'()+*%(*%+#,+4+*'-24-'#(E+3%#38%+*-4"-+O'-.+4(+'('-'48+.63#-.%*'*+#"+,"4P%+4(&+-.'*+,"4P%+
'(,82%($%*+O.4-+&4-4+-.%6+4--%(&+-#;+Z(&+$#(T%"*%86E+-.%+4T4'8498%+&4-4+'*+2*%&+-#+%849#"4-%+-.%+,"4P%+#"+-#+&%-%$-+
'($#(*'*-%($'%*+'(+4+,"4P%;+[.'*+343%"+3"%*%(-*+4(+%P3'"'$48+*'P284-#"+*-2&6+#,+.#O+-O#+$"%O*+#,+(2$8%4"+$#(-"#8+
"##P+ #3%"4-#"*+ .4(&8%&+ '($'&%(-+ *$%(4"'#*+ O'-.+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ [.%+ &4-4J,"4P%+ -.%#"6+ '*+ 2*%&+ 4*+ 4+
-.%#"%-'$48+ 433"#4$.+ -#+ '(T%*-')4-%+ -.%+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+ $"%OY*+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ O.%(+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ '(+ -.%+ V5F+ '*+
&%)"4&%&;+<#"%+*3%$','$4886E+O%+%\4P'(%+O.4-+*-"4-%)'%*+-.%+$#(-"#8+"##P+$"%O+2*%*+-#+&%$'&%+-.4-+'(&'$4-'#(*+4"%+
&%)"4&%&E+2(&%"+O.4-+$#(&'-'#(*+-.%6+,4'8+-#+(#-'$%+&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*E+4(&+.#O+#3%"4-#"*Y+49'8'-6+-#+.4(&8%+4(+
'($'&%(-+'*+'P34$-%&;++
+
J%(B34",H+ G4-2"48'*-'$+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()E+ (2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-E+ $#(-"#8+ "##PE+ &4-4J,"4P%+ -.%#"6E+ '(*-"2P%(-4-'#(E+
.2P4(J*6*-%P+'(-%",4$%E+&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*E+*'P284-#"+*-2&6;+
+
!

!"##$%&'()*+&,(%# !"%T'#2*+ '($'&%(-*+ '(+ -.%+ (2$8%4"+ '(&2*-"6E+

*2$.+ 4*+ -.%+ [."%%+ <'8%+ F*84(&+ 4$$'&%(-+ 4(&+ -.%+
[.%+&%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+3%",#"P%&+96+-.%+#3%"4-'()+
="#O(*+ a%""6+ ,'"%+ .4T%+ *.#O(+ -.4-+ &%)"4&%&+
$"%O+ '*+ 4+ *')(','$4(-+ %8%P%(-+ '(+ P4'(-4'('()+
'(,#"P4-'#(+$4(+(%)4-'T%86+'P34$-+-.%+#3%"4-#"*Y+
*4,%-6+ '(+ %(%")6+ 4(&+ 3"#$%**+ '(&2*-"'%*E+ *2$.+ 4*+
49'8'-6+ -#+ &'4)(#*%+ -.%+ *'-24-'#(E+ 8%4&+ -#+ O"#()+
(2$8%4"+3#O%"+384(-*;+[.'*+'*+%*3%$'4886+-.%+$4*%+
4**2P3-'#(*E+ ,#"$%+ #3%"4-#"*+ -#+ "%86+ #(+ '(&'"%$-+
&2"'()+ 4(+ 49(#"P48+ %T%(-+ #"+ '($'&%(-E+ O.%(+
4(&+ '(,%""%&+ '(,#"P4-'#(E+ 4(&+ "%P#T%+
$#(-"#8+"##P+#3%"4-#"*+P2*-+"%86+#(+-.%+4T4'8498%+
3#**'9'8'-'%*+ -#+ $.%$Q+ "%&2(&4(-+ '(,#"P4-'#(+
'(,#"P4-'#(+'(+-.%+.2P4(J*6*-%P+'(-%",4$%+UV5FW+
*#2"$%*+ ,#"+ $#(,'"P4-'#(+ UGX71_E+ A0K`]+
-#+ &%-%$-+ "%8%T4(-+ '(,#"P4-'#(E+ 2(&%"*-4(&+ 4(&+
R%P%(6E+A0K0W+
P4Q%+ *%(*%+ #,+ O.4-+ '*+ )#'()+ #(+ 4(&+ P4Q%+ -.%+
F(+ 4+ (2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-+ *'P284-#"+ *-2&6++
"').-+ &%$'*'#(*+ O'-.'(+ 4+ 8'P'-%&+ -'P%;+ X(&%"+
'(T#8T'()+ 4+ 3"'P4"6+ 4(&+ *%$#(&4"6+ ,428-+ O.%"%+
*#P%+ 8#OJ3"#949'8'-6+ $#(&'-'#(*+ -.%+
-.%+ *%$#(&4"6+ ,428-+ .4&+ P'**'()+ #"+ P'*8%4&'()+
'(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+ P46+ ,4'8+ 4(&+ "%*28-+ '(+
'(&'$4-'#(*E+ -.%+ P4b#"'-6+ #,+ -.%+ 34"-'$'34-'()+
2(4T4'8498%+ #"+ '($#""%$-+ '(,#"P4-'#(E+ -.%"%96+
$"%O*+,4'8%&+-#+P4Q%+-.%+$#""%$-+&'4)(#*'*+#,+-.%+
$#P38'$4-'()+ -.%+ $"%OY*+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+
*%$#(&4"6+ ,428-;+ a2"-.%"P#"%E+ *#P%+ $"%O*+ )#-+
3"#$%**;+ [.'*+ P46+ .433%(+ &2%+ -#+ *%(*#"+ ,4'82"%+
3"%#$$23'%&+O'-.+-.%+*%$#(&4"6+,428-+4(&+&'&+(#-+
#"+ $#(&'-'#(*+ -.4-+ 8%4&+ *%(*#"*+ -#+ 9%.4T%+
P4(4)%+-#+&'4)(#*%+4(&+$#""%$-+-.%+3"'P4"6+,428-+
%""4-'$4886+ UCYV4"4+ %-+ 48;E+ /@A@]+ V4*.%P'4(E+
O'-.'(+ -.%+ &%,'(%&+ 4$$%3-498%+ -'P%+ 8'P'-+
/@AA]+7%P3%+%-+48;E+/@AMWE+&2%+-#+8#**+#,+3#O%"+
UB42P4((+%-+48;E+/@@MW;++
UR'PE+ /@A^WE+ ,'"%+ UGX71_E+ A0K`WE+ #"+ 3#**'986+
CYV4"4+ %-+ 48;+ U/@A@W+ "%$#PP%(&+ P#"%+
%T%(+$69%"J4--4$Q*+UT4(+S'(%+%-+48;E+/@A`W;++
"%*%4"$.+#(+.#O+.2P4(+3%",#"P4($%+'*+4,,%$-%&+
!"!##$%%&'()#*%#+&,-.+&+#/0+/'.(/*0)# 96+ &%)"4&%&+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ '(+ "%48'*-'$E+ $#P38%\+
S%)"4&4-'#(+ '(+ '(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+ 4(&+ $#(-"#8+ *%--'()*;+[.%6+4")2%+-.4-+-.%+%\'*-'()+"%*%4"$.+'*+
*6*-%P*+ '*+ 3"%T48%(-+ '(+ (2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-*+ $#(&2$-%&+#(+*'P38%+-4*Q*+4(&+3"#$%**%*+4(&+&#+
(#-+ -4Q%+ '(-#+ 4$$#2(-+ -.%+ 'P34$-+ #,+ &',,%"%(-+
2*'()+&')'-48+*6*-%P*+4(&+'*+%\3%$-%&+-#+'($"%4*%+
-63%*+#,+&%)"4&4-'#(;++
O'-.+P#"%+*6*-%P*+9%'()+-4Q%(+'(-#+2*%+UCYV4"4+
%-+ 48;E+ /@A@W;+ S%)"4&%&+ '(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+ $4(+
#
$42*%+2(O4(-%&+"%*3#(*%*+'(+42-#P4-'$+*6*-%P*E+
*2$.+ 4*+ 4+ "%4$-#"+ -"'3E+ #"+ 'P34$-+ #3%"4-#"*Y+
*'-24-'#(+4O4"%(%**+4(&+&%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+UF9'&;W;++
!"#$%%&'()*+#,+-.%+/0-.+12"#3%4(+54,%-6+4(&+7%8'49'8'-6+:#(,%"%($%;+
Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference.
Edited by Michael Beer and Enrico Zio
Copyright
c 2019 European Safety and Reliability Association.
Published by Research Publishing, Singapore.
ISBN: 978-981-11-2724-3; doi:10.3850/978-981-11-2724-3 0523-cd 232
 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference
!"1# # 2&'/)/*034.5/0,# /0# '*467&8# *6&-.(/*0.7#
&09/-*04&0()#
[.%+ (4-2"48'*-'$+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ UGS<W+
433"#4$.+ -"'%*+ -#+ &%*$"'9%+ .#O+ 3%#38%+ P4Q%+
&%$'*'#(*+'(+"%48JO#"8&+*%--'()*+O'-.+2($%"-4'(-6E+
-'P%+ 3"%**2"%E+ 4(&+ $.4()'()+ $#(&'-'#(*;+ [.%*%+
$.4"4$-%"'*-'$*+-%(&+-#+9%+3"%*%(-+&2"'()+'($'&%(-*+
'(+(2$8%4"+3#O%"+384(-*E+4(&+-.%+GS<+433"#4$.+
-.%"%,#"%+ *%%P*+ *2'-498%+ ,#"+ 4(486D'()+ &%$'*'#(J
P4Q'()+ &2"'()+ *2$.+ '($'&%(-*;+ Z+ $#PP#(+
,%4-2"%+ #,+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ -.%#"'%*+ O'-.'(+ -.%+
GS<+433"#4$.+'*+-.4-+-.%6+'(T#8T%+2*%+#,+#(%Y*+
3"'#"+ %\3%"'%($%+ -#+ c2'$Q86+ $4-%)#"'D%+ *'-24-'#(*+
'(+ #"&%"+ -#+ &%-%"P'(%+ 433"#3"'4-%+ $#2"*%*+ #,+
4$-'#(+UR8%'(E+/@@IW;+++
F(+ (2$8%4"+ 4(&+ #-.%"+ *4,%-6J$"'-'$48+ 3"#$%**+
'(&2*-"'%*+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ '*+ 48*#+ 2*24886+
*233#"-%&+ 96+ #3%"4-'()+ 3"#$%&2"%*+ -.4-+ 4"%+
&%*')(%&+ -#+ )2'&%+ -.%+ #3%"4-#"*+ '(+ P#('-#"'()E+
&%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ 4(&+ .4(&8'()+ (#"P48+ 4(&+
49(#"P48+ *'-24-'#(*+ '(+ -.%+ 384(-+ UCYV4"4+ %-+ 48;E+
/@@@W;+ 7#-.+ UA00KW+ 2*%&+ 4(+ GS<+ 433"#4$.+ -#+
4(486D%+ .#O+ (2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-+ #3%"4-#"*+
.4(&8%+'($'&%(-*;+C(%+'P3#"-4(-+,'(&'()+O4*+-.4-+
-.%+ #3%"4-#"*+ &'&+ (#-+ *'P386+ ,#88#O+ -.%+
3"#$%&2"%*E+ 92-+ 4$-'T%86+ $#(*-"2$-%&+ 4+ P%(-48+
"%3"%*%(-4-'#(+#,+-.%+*-4-%+#,+-.%+384(-+4(&+2*%&+'-+
-#+ P4Q%+ &'4)(#*%*E+ 3"%&'$-+ O.4-+ O4*+ )#'()+ -#+
.433%(+ 4(&+ 4&43-+ -.%'"+ 2*%+ #,+ 3"#$%&2"%*+ -#+ -.%+
*'-24-'#(;++
[.%+ "=$=D24=E%& $-%34(+ UR8%'(+ %-+ 48;E+ /@@KW+
3#*-284-%*+-.4-+O.%(+P4Q'()+*%(*%+#,+4+*'-24-'#(E+
3%#38%+ *-4"-+ O'-.+ 4(+ '('-'48+ .63#-.%*'*+ #"+ ,"4P%;+
R8%'(+ %-+ 48;+ &%,'(%+ 4+ 24=E%+ 4*+ d4(+ %\384(4-#"6+
*-"2$-2"%+ -.4-+ &%,'(%+ %(-'-'%*+ 96+ &%*$"'9'()+ -.%'"+
"%84-'#(*.'3+ -#+ #-.%"+ %(-'-'%*d;+ 7#-.Y*+ UA00KW+
&%,'('-'#(+#,+4(+#3%"4-#"Y*+P%(-48+P#&%8+&2"'()+4+
(2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-+ '($'&%(-+ '*+ 48*#+ $#(*'*-%(-+
O'-.+ 4+ ,"4P%H+ d4+ P#&%8+ #,+ -.%+ ,4$-#"*+ Q(#O(+ #"+
.63#-.%*'D%&+-#+9%+'(,82%($'()+384(-+*-4-%+4-+4(6+
)'T%(+ 3#'(-+ '(+ -'P%d+ UF9'&;E+ 3;+ AKKW;+ [.%+ ,"4P%+
'(,82%($%*+ O.4-+ &4-4+ '*+ 4--%(&%&+ -#+ 4(&+
$#(T%"*%86E+-.%+4T4'8498%+&4-4+'*+2*%&+-#+%849#"4-%+
-.%+,"4P%+#"+-#+&%-%$-+'($#(*'*-%($'%*+'(+4+,"4P%;+
a2"-.%"P#"%E+ R8%'(+ %-+ 48;+ &%*$"'9%&+ *'\+ *%(*%+
P4Q'()+ 4$-'T'-'%*+ -.4-+ %\384'(+ -.%+ &6(4P'$+
"%84-'#(*.'3+ 9%-O%%(+ &4-4+ 4(&+ ,"4P%*;+ e.%(+
,4$%&+O'-.+4P9')2'-6E+O%+O'88+,%%I&=&24=E%+-.4-+
P46+.%83+2*+%\384'(+-.%+*'-24-'#(;+!+='34=$#31&32&
=& 24=E%& P46+ #$$2"+ 4*+ (%O+ &4-4+ '*+ &'*$#T%"%&;+
[.%+&4-4+'*+2*%&+-#+&%T%8#3+4+P#"%+&%-4'8%&+4(&+
"'$.%"+ ,"4P%+ O.'8%+ Q%%3'()+ '('-'48+ #9*%"T4-'#(*+
233
4(&+&4-4+%8%P%(-*+'(-4$-;+F,+O%+,'(&+&4-4+-.4-+4"%+
'($#(*'*-%(-+ O'-.+ -.%+ ,"4P%E+ O%+ P46+ *-4"-+ -#+
L*%,$#31&$-%&24=E%@&92-+'('-'4886+(#-+Q(#O+',+'-+'*+
-.%+ &4-4+ #"+ -.%+ ,"4P%+ -.4-+ '*+ '($#""%$-;+ e%+ P46+
G4%,%4M%&$-%&24=E%+4(&+%\384'(+4O46+'($#(*'*-%(-+
&4-4+ #"+ '&%(-',6+ #-.%"+ ,"4P%*+ -#+ 63EG=4%& O'-.+
4(&+b2&)%+&4-4+4)4'(*-+-#+,'(&+#2-+O.4-+'*+)#'()+
#(;+ F,+ O%+ *%%+ -.4-+ #2"+ ,"4P%+ &#%*(Y-+ *233#"-+ -.%+
4T4'8498%+ %T'&%($%E+ O%+ P46+ 4%24=E%@& $.##*%+ 4+
&',,%"%(-+,"4P%+-#+)#+#(+O'-.;++
F(+-.'*+343%"+O%+2*%+-.%+&4-4J,"4P%+-.%#"6+4*+4+
-.%#"%-'$48+ 433"#4$.+ -#+ '(T%*-')4-%+ -.%+ $#(-"#8+
"##P+ $"%OY*+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ O.%(+ '(,#"P4-'#(+
'(+ -.%+ V5F+ '*+ &%)"4&%&;+ <#"%+ *3%$','$4886E+ O%+
%\4P'(%+ O.4-+ *-"4-%)'%*+ -.%+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+ $"%O+
2*%*+ -#+ &%$'&%+ -.4-+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ 4"%+ &%)"4&%&E+
2(&%"+ O.4-+ $#(&'-'#(*+ -.%6+ ,4'8+ -#+ (#-'$%+
&%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*E+ .#O+ -.%+ #3%"4-#"*+ P4Q%+
*%(*%+#,+-.%+*'-24-'#(+O'-.+P'**'()+#"+2("%8'498%+
'(,#"P4-'#(E+ 4(&+ .#O+ -.%'"+ 49'8'-6+ -#+ .4(&8%+ 4(+
'($'&%(-+'*+'P34$-%&;++
[.%+ O#"Q+ .4*+ 9%%(+ *3#(*#"%&+ 96+ 4(&+
3%",#"P%&+ O'-.'(+ -.%+ "%*%4"$.+ 3"#)"4P+ #,+ -.%+
C1:S+V48&%(+7%4$-#"+!"#b%$-;+
-"##./&0()##
Z(+ %P3'"'$48+ *-2&6+ O4*+ $#(&2$-%&+ '(+ V48&%(+
<4(J<4$.'(%+ B49#"4-#"6+ UVZ<<BZ=W+ '(+ 4+
(2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+ *'P284-#"+
"%3"%*%(-'()+ 4+ )%(%"'$+ e%*-'().#2*%+ -."%%J8##3+
3"%**2"'D%&+O4-%"+"%4$-#"+U!e7W;++
+
a');+A;+!84$%P%(-+#,+#3%"4-#"+&%*Q*+4(&+&'*3846*+'(+-.%+
$#(-"#8+"##P+*'P284-#";+
[O#+ $"%O*+ #,+ 8'$%(*%&+ (2$8%4"+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+
#3%"4-#"*+ 34"-'$'34-%&+ '(+ -.%+ *-2&6E+ O'-.+ -."%%+
#3%"4-#"*+'(+%4$.+$"%OH+4+*.',-+*23%"T'*#"+U55WE+4+
"%4$-#"+ #3%"4-#"+ U7CW+ 4(&+ 4+ -2"9'(%+ #3%"4-#"+
U[CW;+ [.%+ *'P284-#"+ O4*+ $#P32-%"'D%&E+
3"%*%(-'()+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ 49#2-+ -.%+ *-4-2*+ #,+ 384(-+
*6*-%P*+ 4(&+ $#P3#(%(-*+ #(+ #3%"4-#"+ &'*3846*+
4(&+4+84")%+#T%"T'%O+&'*3846+U*%%+,')2"%+AW;+Z(6+
#,+ -.%+ *'P284-#"Y*+ //+ &'*3846+ 3'$-2"%*+
"%3"%*%(-'()+ &',,%"%(-+ 384(-+ *6*-%P*+ 4*+ O%88+ 4*+
234 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference
484"P*+4(&+-"%(&*+$#28&+9%+9"#2).-+23+#(+4(6+#,+
-.%+ #3%"4-#"+ &'*3846*;+ [.%+ &'*3846*+ 3"%*%(-%&+
3"#$%**+,8#O+&'4)"4P*+4(&+3"#$%**+34"4P%-%"*+'(+
-.%+ ,#"P+ #,+ (2P%"'$48+ T482%*E+ P'('J-"%(&*+ 4(&+
&6(4P'$+*6P9#8*+U*%%+%\4P38%+'(+,')2"%+/W;+[.%+
#T%"T'%O+&'*3846+3"%*%(-%&+'(,#"P4-'#(+&%*')(%&+
-#+3"#T'&%+4+c2'$Q+#T%"T'%O+#,+384(-+*-4-2*;++
[.%+ $"%O*+ %4$.+ .4(&8%&+ ,'T%+ '($'&%(-+
*$%(4"'#*+ O'-.+ 384(-+ P48,2($-'#(*+ U%;);+ 8#**+ #,+
$##84(-E+ *-%4P+ )%(%"4-#"+ U5_W+ -29%+ "23-2"%W;+ F(+
$#P9'(4-'#(+ O'-.+ -.%*%+ P48,2($-'#(*+ -.%"%+ O%"%+
48*#+ %8%$-"'$48+ P48,2($-'#(*+ -.4-+ 'P34$-%&+
'(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+U%;);+,428-%&+'(*-"2P%(-+92*W;++
+ $#(&2$-%&+ 2*'()+ 4(+ 4(486*'*+ -##8+ O.%"%+ T'&%#+
a');+ /;+ !4"-+ #,+ 4(+ #3%"4-#"+ &'*3846+ *.#O'()+ 3"#$%**+
34"4P%-%"*+,#"+4+*-%4P+)%(%"4-#";+
[.%+*$%(4"'#*+.4&+&',,%"%(-+8%T%8*+4(&+-63%*+#,+
&%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ 5$%(4"'#+ A+ O4*+ 4+ 94*%8'(%+
*$%(4"'#+ O'-.+ (#+ &%)"4&%&+ '(,#"P4-'#(;+ [.%+
#-.%"+ *$%(4"'#*+ '($82&%&+ P'**'()+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ '(+
-.%+V5F+UP%4('()+-.4-+'(*-"2P%(-*+,4'8%&+-#+D%"#+
T482%*+#"+,4'8%&+4-+-.%+9#--#P+T482%+#,+-.%+*$48%W+
#"+ 4+ $#P9'(4-'#(+ #,+ '($#""%$-+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ U%;);+
,"#D%(+4-+4(+'($#""%$-+T482%+#"+"4P3'()+&#O(N23+
-#+4+$%"-4'(+T482%+#T%"+-'P%+4(&+-.%(+,"%%D'()+4-+
-.4-+ T482%W+ 4(&+ P'**'()+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ [.%+ ,#2"+
*$%(4"'#*+ '($82&%&+ .').+ #"+ 8#O+ 8%T%8*+ #,+
&%)"4&%&+'(,#"P4-'#(E+4*+*.#O(+'(+,')2"%+L;+14$.+
*$%(4"'#+ 84*-%&+ 49#2-+ #(%+ .#2";+ [.%+ #"&%"+ #,+
*$%(4"'#*+O4*+$#2(-%"9484($%&;++
Z-+ -.%+ %(&+ #,+ %4$.+ *$%(4"'#+ -.%+ #3%"4-#"*+
"%*3#(&%&+ -#+ c2%*-'#((4'"%*+ 49#2-+ -.%'"+
%\3%"'%($%+#,+-.%+*$%(4"'#E+'($82&'()+4**%**P%(-+
#,+*$%(4"'#+$#P38%\'-6+U="44"2&+4(&+="%(&"6%(E+
/@@AW+ 4(&+ -.%'"+ #O(+ 3%",#"P4($%+ U5Q"44('()+ %-+
48;E+/@@KW;+[.%6+O%"%+48*#+'(-%"T'%O%&+49#2-+-.%+
%T%(-*+'(+-.%+*$%(4"'#+4(&+O.4-+.63#-.%*%*+-.%6+
.4&+ ,#"P%&+ 49#2-+ -.%+ 384(-+ *-4-%+ 4*+ -.%+ *$%(4"'#+
2(,#8&%&;+ Z-+ -.%+ %(&+ #,+ -.%+ *-2&6+ -.%6+ O%"%+
4*Q%&+ 49#2-+ -.%'"+ &%-%$-'#(+ 4(&+ .4(&8'()+ #,+
&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*;++
&'(')*+,
91.:
615512. 12-13041+25
-'./0-'- 723+//'34 12-13041+25
12-13041+25
&+8
" ! # $ %
+
a');+L;+B%T%8*+4(&+-63%*+#,+&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*+'(+-.%+
*-2&6+*$%(4"'#*;++
[.%+ $"%O*Y+ .4(&8'()+ #,+ -.%+ *$%(4"'#*+ O4*+
4(486D%&+ -#+ 3"#&2$%+ 4+ -'P%8'(%+ '($82&'()+ 384(-+
P48,2($-'#(*E+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*E+ .#O+ -.%+
$"%O*+ "%84-%&+ -#+ -.%+ &%)"4&%&+ '(,#"P4-'#(E+ 4(&+
-.%+ $"%O*Y+ ,#"P4-'#(+ 4(&+ &%T%8#3P%(-+ #,+
.63#-.%*%*+ U,"4P%*W+ "%)4"&'()+ O.4-+ O4*+
.433%('()+ 4*+ -.%+ *$%(4"'#*+ 2(,#8&%&;+ !"#$%&2"%+
2*%E+ '($82&'()+ -"4(*'-'#(+ 9%-O%%(+ &',,%"%(-+
3"#$%&2"%*E+ O4*+ 48*#+ (#-%&;+ [.%+ 4(486*'*+ O4*+
4(&+ 42&'#+ &4-4+ ,"#P+ -.%+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+ *'P284-#"+
O4*+ 3"%*%(-%&+ 4(&+ *6($."#('D%&+ -#)%-.%"+ O'-.+
*'P284-#"+ 8#)*+ #,+ #3%"4-#"+ $#PP4(&*+ U%;);+
#3%('()+ T48T%*WE+ V5F+ '(-%"4$-'#(+ %T%(-*+ U%;);+
$.4()'()+ &'*3846*W+ 4(&+ *'P284-#"+ P48,2($-'#(*+
U%;);+ *-%4P+ )%(%"4-#"+ -29%+ 8%4QW;+ C(%+ #,+ -.%+
42-.#"*+ '*+ 4(+ %\3%"'%($%&+ (2$8%4"+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+
#3%"4-#"+ 4(&+ 3"#T'&%&+ (2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-+
%\3%"-'*%+ &2"'()+ -.%+ 4(486*'*;+ [.%+ -'P%8'(%+ O4*+
2*%&+ 4*+ 4+ 94*'*+ ,#"+ )4'('()+ '(*').-*+ '(-#+ -.%+
$"%O*Y+ *%(*%JP4Q'()+ 4(&+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+
3"#$%**%*;++
1"##2/3*4&3#
F(+-.'*+*%$-'#(+O%+O'88+3"%*%(-+4(&+&'*$2**+*#P%+
%\4P38%*+ ,"#P+ -.%+ *-2&6+ -.4-+ '882*-"4-%+ .#O+ -.%+
$"%O*+ P4&%+ *%(*%+ #,+ *'-24-'#(*+ O'-.+ &%)"4&%&+
'(&'$4-'#(*+ 4(&+ .#O+ -.%'"+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ O4*+
'P34$-%&;+Z*+4+3#'(-+#,+$#P34"'*#(E+O%+O'88+,'"*-+
)'T%+4(+4$$#2(-+#,+.#O+#(%+$"%O+P4&%+*%(*%+#,+
4+ *'-24-'#(+ O.%(+ 488+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+ O#"Q'()+
$#""%$-86H+Z+*-%4P+*34$%+8%4Q+.4&+#$$2""%&+'(+-.%+
3"%**2"'D%"E+ 4(&+ -.%+ $"%O+ &%-%$-%&+ 3"%**2"'D%"+
3"%**2"%+ )#'()+ &#O(E+ "%4$-#"+ 3#O%"+ 8#O%"'()E+
P4'(+ )%(%"4-#"+ #2-32-+ 8#O%"'()+ *8').-86+ 4(&+ 5_+
O4-%"+ 8%T%8+ 8#O%"'();+ [.%+ $"%O+ $#""%$-86+
 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference 235

4**2P%&+ -.4-+ '-+ O4*+ (#-+ 4+ *-%4P+ 9"%4Q+ #(+ -.%+
*%$#(&4"6+*'&%+U-2"9'(%+*'&%W+9%$42*%+-.4-+O#28&+
$42*%+ "%4$-#"+ 3#O%"+ -#+ '($"%4*%;+ [.%+ $"%O+ 84-%"+
&%-%$-%&+-.4-+$#(-4'(P%(-+3"%**2"%+O4*+)#'()+23+
4(&+ -.%"%+ O4*+ 4+ "4&'4-'#(+ 484"P+ '(+ $#(-4'(P%(-;+
[.'*+8%&+-.%P+-#+-.%+$#($82*'#(+-.4-+-.%"%+O4*+4+
8%4Q+'(+$#(-4'(P%(-;++
[.%+$"%O+'*+2*'()+&4-4+,"#P+-.%+V5F+-#+92'8&+
4(+ 2(&%"*-4(&'()+ #,+ -.%+ 384(-+ *-4-2*+ U4+ ,"4P%W;+
1T%(+O'-.+'(-4$-+'(&'$4-'#(*E+-.'*+'*+4+3"#$%**+-.4-+
"%c2'"%*+4+.').+8%T%8+#,+Q(#O8%&)%+#,+-.%+"%4$-#"+
*6*-%P*+ 4(&+ .#O+ -.%6+ '(-%"4$-;+ F(+ -.%+ ,#88#O'()+
*%$-'#(*+ O%+ O'88+ &%*$"'9%+ .#O+ -.%+ $"%O*Y+
&%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ '(+ #2"+ *-2&6+ O4*+ 'P34$-%&+
O.%(+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ '(+ -.%+ V5F+ O%"%+ &%)"4&%&;+
1\4P38%*+ ,"#P+ -.%+ $"%OY*+ .4(&8'()+ #,+ -.%+
*$%(4"'#*+4"%+)'T%(+'(+-498%*;+[.%+8%,-+$#82P(+#,+
-.%+-498%*+&%*$"'9%*+-.%+$"%O*Y+9%.4T'#"E+4(&+-.%+
"').-+ $#82P(+ 3"#T'&%*+ 4(+ '(-%"3"%-4-'#(+ #,+ -.'*+
9%.4T'#"+2*'()+-.%+&4-4J,"4P%+-.%#"6;++
F(+ -.'*+ $4*%+ -.%+ $"%O+ $#28&+ (#-+ *'P386+ $#P34"%+
O'-.+ 4(#-.%"+ $.4((%8E+ 92-+ .4&+ -#+ $.%$Q+
48-%"(4-'T%+ %\384(4-'#(*+ 4(&+ T%"',6+ $#(*'*-%($6+
O'-.+ #-.%"+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ 1843*%&+ *$%(4"'#+ -'P%+ '(+
P'(2-%*+ '*+ )'T%(+ '(+ 34"%(-.%*%*;+ V%"%+ -.%+
42\'8'4"6+U42\W+,%%&+O4-%"+,8#O+'(&'$4-#"*+'(+-O#+
#,+ -.%+ -."%%+ 5_*+ ,4'8%&+ -#+ /@+ 4(&+ ^@E+
"%*3%$-'T%86;+ [C+ (#-'$%&+ -.4-+ -.%*%+ ,%%&+ ,8#O+
'(&'$4-'#(*+&'&+(#-+P4-$.+O'-.+.'*+$2""%(-+,"4P%+
9%$42*%+-.%+-."%%+,8#O*+*.#28&+9%+%T%(+U/;AW;+V%+
4*Q%&+.'*+$#88%4)2%*+ ,#"+'(32-;+ 55+3"#3#*%&+#(%+
48-%"(4-'T%+,"4P%+U/;/W+4(&+-.%(+4(#-.%"+#(%+U/;LW+
4,-%"+ -.%+ ,'"*-+ O4*+ "%b%$-%&;+ 7C+ 8%4(%&+ -#O4"&*+
')(#"'()+ -.%+ 4(#P48#2*+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ U/;LWE+ 4(&+
4,-%"+ *%%'()+ -.4-+ #-.%"+ "%84-%&+ &4-4+ O%"%+
$#(*'*-%(-+ O'-.+ -.%'"+ '('-'48+ ,"4P%E+ -.%6+ 4**2P%&+
-.4-+-.%+,%%&+,8#O+'(&'$4-'#(*+O%"%+,4'8%&+U/;^W;+
[498%+ A;+ f2'$Q86+ 4(&+ $#""%$-86+ '&%(-',6'()+ 4+
P'**'()+'(&'$4-'#(+U*$%(4"'#+/W;+

:"!# # ;*<# '-&<)# )=''&))%=77># +&(&'(&+# .0+# :"%O+9%.4T'#"+ SJa+'(-%"3"%-4-'#(+

9&-/%/&+#+&,-.+&+#/0+/'.(/*0)# NCN+55+4*Q*+49#2-+ 55+"%4$-*+-#+-.%+8%T%8+
e.%(+ -.%+ $"%O*+ ,'"*-+ 9%$4P%+ 4O4"%+ #,+ 4+ 3"%**2"'D%"+8%T%8;+7CE+ 9%'()+#,,J*$48%+8#OE+
&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(E+'-+O4*+2*24886+9%$42*%+#,+ 4+ 8##Q'()+4-+-.%+#3%"4-#"+ O.'$.+&#%*(Y-+,'-+O'-.+
&'*3846H+d!"%**2"'D%"+ .'*+P#&%8+#,+-.%+384(-+
P'*P4-$.+ 9%-O%%(+ -.%+ '(&'$4-'#(+ 4(&+ -.%+ $"%OY*+ 8%T%8+'*+#,,J*$48%+8#Od;+ *-4-2*;++
$2""%(-+,"4P%;+[.'*+O4*+-.%+$4*%+'(+-.%+%\4P38%*+ 55E+*8').-86+$#(,2*%&H+
'(+ -498%+ A+ 4(&+ -498%+ /;+ F-+ $#28&+ 9%+ 4+ $8%4"+ dC,,J*$48%+8#Ogd+
P'*P4-$.E+ #"+ '-+ $#28&+ 9%+ P#"%+ #,+ 4+ )"4&24886+ NCO&[CE+3#'(-'()+-#+-.%+ [C+$488*+4--%(-'#(+-#+
)"#O'()+4O4"%(%**+-.4-+*#P%-.'()+O4*+(#-+c2'-%+ #T%"T'%O+&'*3846H+dG#E+ 4(#-.%"+&4-4+3#'(-+-.4-+
"').-;++ '-Y*+/Ahd;++ &#%*+(#-+,'-+O'-.+-.%+
F(+-.%+%\4P38%+'(+-498%+A+-.%+55+"%4$-%&+-#+-.%+ & ,'"*-E+92-+-.4-+&#%*+,'-+
P'*P4-$.+ 9%-O%%(+ .'*+ $2""%(-+ ,"4P%+ #,+ 384(-+ O'-.+-.%+$"%OY*+,"4P%;++
*-4-2*+ 4(&+ -.%+ P'**'()+ '(&'$4-'#(+ -.4-+ 7C+ "%,%"*+ NCP&7CH+dFY88+$.4()%+ 7C+$.%$Q*+4+&',,%"%(-+
-#+ UA;AW;+ =2-+ -.%+ P'**'()+ '(&'$4-'#(+ O4*+ c2'$Q86+ $.4((%8*;+V#8&+#(;;;+ $.4((%8+,#"+-.%+
"%b%$-%&+4*+,428-%&+9%$42*%+-.%+[C+*4O+-.4-+-.%"%+ i%4.E+FY&+*46+'-Y*+/Ah+ '(&'$4-'#(E+O.'$.+
O4*+ 4+ &'*$"%34($6+ 9%-O%%(+ -.%+ -O#+ &4-4+ 3#'(-*+ 4(&+*-498%d;& P4-$.%*+O'-.+-.%+#(%+#(+
,#"+-.%+3"%**2"'D%"+8%T%8+UA;/W;+[.%+"%4*#(+O4*+4+ -.%+#T%"T'%O+&'*3846;+
[.%+'('-'48+'(&'$4-'#(+'*+
,4'8%&+$.4((%8+&2%+-#+4+,4'8%&+'(*-"2P%(-+92*E+4(&+
&'*$4"&%&+4*+,48*%;++
7C+ *4O+ -.4-+ 4+ &',,%"%(-+ $.4((%8+ *.#O%&+ -.%+
$#""%$-+ T482%+ UA;LW;+ [.%+ $"%O+ &%-%$-%&+ 4+ *'P'84"+ +
,4'8%&+'(*-"2P%(-+92*+'(+4+3"%T'#2*+*$%(4"'#E+4(&+ F(+ -.%+ '(-%"T'%O*+ -.%+ $"%O*+ 3#'(-%&+ #2-+ *#P%+
-.'*+ P46+ .4T%+ '($"%4*%&+ -.%+ $"%OY*+ ,4P'8'4"'-6+ *-"4-%)'%*+ -.4-+ -.%6+ 2*%&+ -#+ T%"',6+ ,4'8%&+
O'-.+ -.%+ P48,2($-'#(+ 4(&+ .%83%&+ -.%+ $"%O+ -#+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ C(%+ *-"4-%)6+ '*+ -#+ $#P34"%+ -."%%+ #"+
,4*-%"+ '&%(-',6+ -.%+ "%4*#(+ ,#"+ -.%+ ,4'8%&+ P#"%+'(*-4($%*+*.#O'()+-.%+*4P%+T482%+U*2$.+4*+
'(*-"2P%(-+ '(+ -.'*+ *$%(4"'#;+ R(#O'()+ -.4-+ #(%+ -.%+ $.4((%8*+ P%(-'#(%&+ '(+ -498%+ AW;+ F,+ #(%+ '*+
$.4((%8+ O4*+ ,4'8%&E+ -.%+ $"%O+ $#28&+ 2*%+ -.4-+ &',,%"%(-+ ,"#P+ -.%+ #-.%"+ -O#E+ -.4-+ '*+ 8'Q%86+ -#+ 9%+
'(,#"P4-'#(+-#+T%"',6+#-.%"+*2*3'$'#2*+'(&'$4-'#(*+ ,4'8%&;+Z(#-.%"+*-"4-%)6+'*+-#+T%"',6+96+$.%$Q'()+
84-%";++ #-.%"+ "%84-%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ F(+ -498%+ /+ U/;^W+ -.%+
[.%+ %\4P38%+ '(+ -498%+ /+ '882*-"4-%*+ 4+ *'-24-'#(+ #3%"4-#"*+*4O+-.4-+3"%**2"%E+8%T%8+4(&+T48T%+*-4-%+
O'-.+'($#""%$-+'(&'$4-'#(*E+O.%"%+-.%+$"%O+2*%&+4+ 488+ O%"%+ $#(*'*-%(-+ O'-.+ -.%+ $"%OY*+ ,"4P%+ #,+ -.%+
9'-+8#()%"+-'P%+-#+$#($82&%+-.4-+-.%6+O%"%+,4'8%&;+ *'-24-'#(+4(&+2*%&+-.'*+-#+$#($82&%+-.4-+-.%+,8#O+
'(*-"2P%(-+ '*+ ,4'8%&;+ [.%+ $"%O+ $4(+ 48*#+
236 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference

P4('3284-%+-.%+3"#$%**+4(&+*%%+',+-.%+'(&'$4-'#(*+ ,'(48+ *-"4-%)6+ '*+ -#+ )%-+ '(32-+ ,"#P+ $#88%4)2%*;+ F(+
9%.4T%+4*+%\3%$-%&E+%;);+'($"%4*%+,8#O+-#+-.%+5_+ -498%+/+-.%+[C+4*Q%&+,#"+'(32-+-#+,')2"%+#2-+O.4-+
4(&+*%%+',+-.%+8%T%8+"'*%*+4*+4(-'$'34-%&;++ '*+ )#'()+ #(+ O'-.+ -.%+ 42\+ ,%%&+ ,8#O+ '(&'$4-'#(*+
9%$42*%+ .%+ '*+ $#(,2*%&;+ [.%+ $"%O+ -.%(+ -%*-%&+
[498%+ /;+ 7%4*#('()+ 49#2-+ 4(&+ $#""%$-86+ T4"'#2*+ 433"#4$.%*+ 4(&+ %(&%&+ 23+ U$#""%$-86W+
"%b%$-'()+'($#""%$-+'(&'$4-'#(*+U*$%(4"'#+LW;+ "%b%$-'()+ -.%+ '($#""%$-+ ,%%&+ ,8#O+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ 4*+
,4'8%&;++
:"%O+9%.4T'#"+ SJa+'(-%"3"%-4-'#(++ 1T4824-'()+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ -#+ $.%$Q+ ',+ -.%6+ O%"%+
OCN+UALH/@W+[C+(#-'$%*+ G#-'$%*+4(#P486+'(+42\+ &%)"4&%&+ #"+ (#-+ U4(&+ $#(*%c2%(-86+ 3"%*%"T'()E+
-.%+42\+,%%&+,8#O+-#+-.%+ ,%%&+,8#O+'(&'$4-'#(*;+ c2%*-'#('()+ #"+ $.4()'()+ 4+ ,"4P%W+ O4*+ 4+ 3"#$%**+
-."%%+*-%4P+)%(%"4-#"*+ [.%+$"%OY*+,"4P%+'P386+
-.4-+ $#28&+ -4Q%+ -'P%+ 4(&+ &%T%8#3%&+ )"4&24886E+
*.#O*+&',,%"%(-+T482%*;+ -.4-+-.%+-."%%+T482%*+
55+4*Q*+-#+$.%$Q+O.6+ *.#28&+9%+*'P'84"E+92-+ 4(&+ -.%+ $"%O*+ &'&+ (#-+ 48O46*+ )#+ -."#2).+ -.'*+
-.%6+4"%+&',,%"%(-;+ -.%6+4"%+(#-;++ 3"#$%**;+ F(+ -.'*+ *-2&6+ -.%+ 3"#$%**+ *-4"-%&+ 96+
OCO+UAMHLLW+[C+'(,#"P*+ [C+4*Q*+-.%+$#88%4)2%*+
&%-%$-'#(+#,+4(+4(#P486E+4+3'%$%+#,+&4-4+-.4-+&'&+
-.4-+.%+'*+$#(,2*%&+49#2-+ ,#"+'(32-+O.%(+.%+'*+ (#-+ *%%P+ "').-+ 9%$42*%+ '-+ &'&+ (#-+ ,'-+ O'-.+ -.%+
-.%+,8#O+"%4&'()*;+[.%+ $#(,2*%&+49#2-+-.%+&4-4;++ $2""%(-+ ,"4P%;+ F,+ 4(+ %\384(4-'#(+ $#28&+ (#-+ 9%+
,%%&+32P3+T48T%*+4"%+ 55+3"#3#*%*+8#O+32P3+ ,#2(&+"').-+4O46E+-.%+7C+#"+[C+O#28&+P#('-#"+
,2886+#3%(E+92-+'-+P4Q%*+ *3%%&+4*+3#**'98%+"%4*#(+ -.%+'(&'$4-'#(+-#+*%%+.#O+'-+&%T%8#3%&;+<469%+4+
(#+&',,%"%($%+'(+-.%+,%%&+ ,#"+-.%+4(#P486+ -%(-4-'T%+ %\384(4-'#(+ O#28&+ 9%+ *2))%*-%&+ U4(+
,8#O;+55+4*Q*+49#2-+-.%+ U3"#3#*%&+48-%"(4-'T%+ 48-%"(4-'T%+ ,"4P%+ #"+ %849#"4-'#(+ #,+ -.%+ $2""%(-+
-2"9'(%J&"'T%(+42\+,%%&+ ,"4P%WE+4(&+7C+ ,"4P%W+4(&+'-+O#28&+9%+-%*-%&E+%;);+96+#3%('()+4+
32P3+*3%%&;+7C+$.%$Q*+ '($"%4*%*+32P3+*3%%&;+ T48T%+ -#+ *%%+ ',+ -.%+ '(&'$4-'#(+ "%*3#(&%&+
'-+4(&+P#T%*+#(+-#+"4'*%+
-.%+32P3+*3%%&;+
433"#3"'4-%86;+ [.'*+ O#28&+ P#T%+ -.%+ $"%O+ 4+ *-%3+
-#O4"&*+ 4$$%3-'()+ #"+ "%b%$-'()+ -.%+ '(&'$4-%&+
OCP&UA`H/@W+Z2\+,%%&+ F($"%4*'()+-.%+32P3+
,8#O+"%4&'()*+*-'88+&#(Y-+ *3%%&+&'&+(#-+$.4()%+
T482%+ 92-+ O4*+ P469%+ (#-+ %(#2).+ -#+ P4Q%+ 4+
'(&'$4-%+%T%(+,%%&'();+ ,8#O+"%4&'()*+U-.%+ &%,'('-'T%+b2&)%P%(-;+=2-+4,-%"+%(#2).+%T'&%($%+
!2P3*+4"%+"2(('()+4-+ 48-%"(4-'T%+,"4P%+O4*+ 92'8&'()+23+#T%"+ -'P%+#"+,"#P+ &',,%"%(-+*#2"$%*E+
P4\+*3%%&;+Z88+5_*+ "%b%$-%&W;+a8#O+"%4&'()*+ -.%+$"%O*+O#28&+*%--8%+#(+4+&%$'*'#(+#(+O.%-.%"+
*.#O+*'P'84"+8%T%8*;+7C+ &#+(#-+P4-$.+O'-.+#-.%"+ #"+(#-+-.%6+$#28&+"%86+#(+-.4-+3'%$%+#,+&4-4;++
*46*+-.4-+-.%+,8#O+ &4-4+U32P3+*3%%&*+4(&+
'(*-"2P%(-*+433%4"+(#-+ 5_+8%T%8*W;+55+3"#3#*%*+ :"1# # ?@&0# '-&<)# %./7&+# (*# +&(&'(# +&,-.+&+#
-#+9%+"%*3#(&'()+ 4(#-.%"+48-%"(4-'T%+ /0+/'.(/*0)#
$#""%$-86;+55+*46*+-.%"%+ ,"4P%+-.4-+P46+%\384'(+ [.%"%+O%"%+*#P%+$4*%*+O.%"%+-.%+$"%O+&'&+(#-+
P46+9%+4+,%%&+O4-%"+ -.%+*-"4()%+,%%&+,8#O+
P4(4)%+ -#+ '&%(-',6+ 4+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(+ 4*+
9"%4Q+*#P%O.%"%+-.4-+'*+ &4-4+U,%%&+O4-%"+9"%4QW+
$42*'()+'-;+ 92-+&#%*+(#-+32-+P2$.+ &%)"4&%&;++
$#(,'&%($%+'(+'-;+ [498%+ L+ *.#O*+ #(%+ *2$.+ %\4P38%+ O.%"%+ -.%+
OCQ&UAKH@@W+7C+4*Q*+[C+ C-.%"+"%84-%&+&4-4+ ,4'82"%+ -#+ '&%(-',6+ '-+ .4&+ 4+ 84")%+ 'P34$-+ #(+ -.%+
',+-.%+T48T%*+4"%+#3%(E+ U3"%**2"%E+8%T%8+4(&+ $"%OY*+49'8'-6+-#+*#8T%+-.%+*$%(4"'#+U4*+%\384'(%&+
-.%+3"%**2"%+'*+%T%(E+4(&+ T48T%+*-4-%W+9%.4T%+ '(+ *%$-'#(+ L;LW;+ F(+ -.'*+ *$%(4"'#+ -.%+ T#82P%+
8%T%8*+4"%+"'*'()+%T%(86;+ $#(*'*-%(-86+O'-.+%4$.+ $#(-"#8+-4(Q+Uj:[W+8%T%8+'(&'$4-#"+.4&+,4'8%&+4(&+
[C+$#(,'"P*;+7C+*46*+ #-.%";+[.%6+"%b%$-+-.%+ *.#O%&+ @h;+ [.%+ 55+ &'&+ ,'"*-+ c2%*-'#(+ -.%+
-.%+,8#O+'(*-"2P%(-*+4"%+ $#(,2*'()+,8#O+ '(&'$4-'#(+ UL;AWE+ 4*+ '-+ 3"#94986+ *%%P%&+ *-"4()%+
(#-+O#"Q'()+"').-;+ '(&'$4-'#(*+4(&+%\3%$-+ -.4-+-.%+j:[+*.#28&+9%+%P3-6;+[.%+$"%O+-"'%&+-#+
-.%6+4"%+,4'8%&;++ T%"',6+ -.%+ '(&'$4-'#(+ UL;/W;+ [.%+ ,4$-+ -.4-+ '-+ O4*+
+ -.%+*4P%+'(+9#-.+8#$4-'#(*+*2))%*-%&+U92-+&'&+(#-+
a2"-.%"P#"%E+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ $4(+ 9%+ T%"','%&+ 96+ 3"#T%W+ -.%+ &4-4+ O4*+ T48'&;+ + 55+ 4)4'(+ c2%*-'#(%&+
8##Q'()+ 4-+ .#O+ -.%6+ 9%.4T%;+ a#"+ '(*-4($%E+ -.%+'(&'$4-'#(H+O.6E+',+-.%+j:[+8%T%8+'*+4$-24886+
$#P38%-%86+ *-4-'$+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ 4"%+ 8'Q%86+ -#+ 9%+ @hE+ .4&+ -.%"%+ (#-+ 9%%(+ 4(+ 42-#+ P4Q%23+
,4'8%&;+[.%"%+'*+2*24886+*#P%+,82$-24-'#(+#"+(#'*%+ U42-#P4-'$+ ,'88'()+ #,+ -.%+ j:[W+ UL;LWg+ 7C+
'(+-.%+&4-4E+*#+'-+'*+(#-+(#"P48+-.4-+4(+'(&'$4-'#(+ *2))%*-%&+ -.'*+ P46+ 48"%4&6+ .4&+ .433%(%&+ 4-+ 4(+
*.#O*+-.%+%\4$-+*4P%+T482%E+#"+4+$#P38%-%86+,84-+ %4"8'%"+3#'(-;+55+'(-%"3"%-%&+7CY*+*2))%*-'#(+4*+4+
-"%(&+ #T%"+ -'P%;+ C3%"4-#"*+ $4(+ 2*%+ -.'*+ *-4-%P%(-+ #,+ ,4$-;+ [.'*+ &'&+ (#-+ 3"#T'&%+ 4(+
$.4"4$-%"'*-'$+ -#+ '&%(-',6+ 4+ ,4'8%&+ '(&'$4-'#(;+ Z+
 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference 237

%\384(4-'#(+,#"+-.%+,48*%+'(&'$4-'#(+#,+@h;+Z8*#E+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+ ,4'8%&+ #"+ (#-E+ 4(&+ 8#$4-'()+

',+-.%+j:[+8%T%8+O4*+"%4886+@hE+-.%+42-#+P4Q%23+ 48-%"(4-'T%+'(&'$4-'#(*E+4*+%\%P38','%&+'(+-498%+/;++
*.#28&+ 4$-24886+ *-'88+ 9%+ '(+ %,,%$-E+ 92-+ -.%+ $"%O+ 5$%(4"'#+ M+ .4&+ 4+ 84")%+ 4P#2(-+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+
*%%P%&+ (#-+ -#+ $#(*'&%"+ -.'*;+ [.%+ $"%O+ &'&+ (#-+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ 5#P%+ O%"%+ ,4'8%&+ -#+ 4+ *-4-'$+ T482%E+
"%4$.+ 4+ ,'(48+ $#($82*'#(+ 49#2-+ -.%+ &%)"4&%&+ 4(&+*#P%+O%"%+,4'8%&+-#+"4P3+-#+4+T482%+#T%"+-%(+
'(&'$4-'#(;+Z-+-.'*+-'P%+-.%6+O%"%+T%"6+#$$23'%&+ P'(2-%*;+F(+-.'*+*$%(4"'#+'-+O4*+T%"6+&',,'$28-+,#"+
O'-.+ 4+ *3%$','$+ 3"#$%&2"%E+ 4(&+ -.'*+ P').-+ 9%+ -.%+ -.%+ $"%O*+ -#+ )%-+ 4(+ #T%"T'%O+ 49#2-+ O.4-+ O4*+
"%4*#(+ O.6+ -.%6+ &'&+ (#-+ 2*%+ P#"%+ -'P%+ -#+ .433%('()+ ',+ -.%6+ &'&+ (#-+ ,'"*-+ ,')2"%+ #2-+ O.'$.+
'(T%*-')4-%+ -.%+ P4--%";+ [.%+ 55+ O4*+ 48*#+ 92*6+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+ &%)"4&%&;+ [.%+ P48,2($-'#(*+ '(+
-"6'()+ -#+ )%-+ 4(+ #T%"T'%O+ 49#2-+ #-.%"+ -.'()*+ '(+ *$%(4"'#+ M+ '($82&%&+ 4+ -29%+ 8%4Q+ '(+ 5_+ Z+ 4(&+ 4+
-.%+*$%(4"'#;++ *-2$Q+#3%(+*4,%-6+T48T%+#(+5_+=;+[.%6+(%%&%&+-#+
.4T%+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ ,#"+ -.%+ 5_*+ -#+ ,')2"%+ -.'*+ #2-+
[498%+L;+a4'8'()+-#+"%4$.+4+$#($82*'#(+49#2-+ 4(&+ .4(&8%+ -.%+ *$%(4"'#;+ C(%+ $"%O+ P4(4)%&+ -#+
4+P'**'()+'(&'$4-'#(+U*$%(4"'#+LW;+ &%-%"P'(%+ -.4-+ 488+ 5_+ 3"%**2"%+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+
,4'8%&+ 4(&+ ,'(&+ 4(+ 48-%"(4-'T%+ '(&'$4-'#(+ ,#"+ -.%+
:"%O+9%.4T'#"+ SJa+'(-%"3"%-4-'#(+ 3"%**2"%;+[.%+#-.%"+$"%O+&'&+(#-E+4(&+#(%+#,+-.%+
PCN+UL`HA@W+Z,-%"+ G#-'$%*+4+3'%$%+#,+&4-4+ #3%"4-#"*+ '(+ -.4-+ $"%O+ "%3#"-%&+ -.4-+ .%+ &'&+ (#-+
%(-%"'()+3"#$%&2"%+15J -.4-+&#%*+(#-+,'-+O'-.'(+ .4T%+4+)##&+,%%8+,#"+O.4-+O4*+)#'()+#(+O'-.+-.%+
A;A+k5F+-%"P'(4-'#(lE+-.%+ -.%+$2""%(-+,"4P%+U-.4-+
5_*+,#"+4-+8%4*-+-.%+,'"*-+.48,+#,+-.%+*$%(4"'#;++
55+4*Q*+7C+',+-.%+j:[+ -.%+j:[+'*+(#-+%P3-6W++
8%T%8+'*+4$-24886+@h+U';%;+ [.%+84$Q+#,+"%8'498%+'(&'$4-'#(*+48*#+'P34$-%&+
',+-.%+'(&'$4-'#(+'*+ -.%+ $"%O*Y+ 49'8'-6+ -#+ O#"Q+ -."#2).+ -.%+ #3%"4-'()+
,4'8%&W;+ 3"#$%&2"%*;+ F(+ *$%(4"'#+ LE+ O.'$.+ .4&+ -.%+ ,4'8%&+
PCO+[C+"%*3#(&*+-.4-+'-+ Z--%P3-+-#+T48'&4-%+-.%+ j:[+8%T%8+'(&'$4-#"+&%*$"'9%&+'(+-498%+LE+#(%+#,+
'*+@h+9#-.+4-+-.%+ &4-4+96+$.%$Q'()+ -.%+ $"%O*+ %(-%"%&+ '(-#+ -.%+ 5F+ -%"P'(4-'#(+
#T%"T'%O+&'*3846+4(&+4-+ 4(#-.%"+'(*-4($%+#,+-.%+ 3"#$%&2"%+ U-.%+ #-.%"+ $"%O+ &'&+ (#-+ .4T%+ -.%+
-.%+#3%"4-#"+*-4-'#(;++ '(&'$4-'#(;++ "%c2'"%&+ 384(-+ $#(&'-'#(+ ,#"+ %(-%"'()+ -.'*+
PCP+55+-.%(+4*Q*+O.6+ S'*$"%34($6+9%-O%%(+ 3"#$%&2"%W;+ [.%+ $"%O+ -"'%&+ -#+ 3%",#"P+ 4+ P4(248+
-.%6+.4T%(Y-+.4&+4(+42-#+ &4-4+4(&+,"4P%H+e'-.+4+ j:[+ P4Q%23+ 9%$42*%+ -.%+ j:[+ 8%T%8+ '(&'$4-#"+
P4Q%23;+7C+*2))%*-*+ @h+j:[+8%T%8E+4(+42-#+ *.#O%&+ @h;+ =2-+ -.%+ $"%O+ Q%3-+ 8##3'()+ -."#2).+
-.%6+$#28&+.4T%+.4&+4(+ P4Q%23+*.#28&+.4T%+ -.%+ 3"#$%&2"%+ O'-.#2-+ 4$$#P38'*.'()+ 4+ P4(248+
42-#+P4Q%23+4-+*#P%+ #$$2""%&;+[.%+55+ P4Q%23+4(&+4,-%"+AM+P'(2-%*+-.%6+&%$'&%&+(#-+-#+
%4"8'%"+3#'(-;+55+ 4**2P%*+4(+42-#+P4Q%23+ 32"*2%+-.%+j:[+3"#98%P+4(6+,2"-.%";+[.%6+(%T%"+
4**2P%*+-.4-+'*+-.%+$4*%+ .4*+48"%4&6+.433%(%&E+
4(&+)#+#(;+ 4(&+&#%*+(#-+"%4$.+4+
&'*$#T%"%&+ -.4-+ -.%+ j:[+ 8%T%8+ '(&'$4-#"+ O4*+
$#($82*'#(+49#2-+-.%+ ,4'8%&;+[.%+$"%O+48*#+,4'8%&+-#+&%-%$-+4+(2P9%"+#,+
&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(;++ #-.%"+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ '(+ -.'*+ *$%(4"'#E+ 4(&+
-.%+ %(%")6+ -.%6+ 2*%&+ -#+ ,#$2*+ #(+ -.%+ ,48*%+ j:[+
:":# # A46.'(# *%# +&,-.+&+# /0+/'.(/*0)# *0# (@&# 3"#98%P+O4*+3"#94986+4+$#(-"'92-'()+,4$-#";++
'-&<B)#.C/7/(>#(*#@.0+7&#.0#.C0*-4.7#)/(=.(/*0## [.%+ #-.%"+ $"%O+ 48*#+ "4(+ '(-#+ 4+ 3"#$%&2"%+
[.%+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ '(+ -.%+ V5F+ '*+ -.%+ P4'(+ *#2"$%+ 3"#98%P+ $42*%&+ 96+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*;+ F(+
,#"+ P4Q'()+ *%(*%+ #,+ -.%+ *'-24-'#(;+ e.%(+ *$%(4"'#+^+-.%+$"%O+*2*3%$-%&+4+5_+"23-2"%E+92-+
'(&'$4-'#(*+4"%+&%)"4&%&E+#3%"4-#"*+.4T%+-#+-"6+-#+ 9%$42*%+ #,+ ,4'8%&+ 5_+ 8%T%8+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ U'(+
,')2"%+ #2-+ O.4-+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ -.%6+ $4(+ "%86+ #(;+ F(+ 4&&'-'#(+ -#+ P'**'()+ 4+ "4&'4-'#(+ 484"P+ 4(&+ (#-+
-.%+49*%($%+#,+"%8'498%+'(&'$4-'#(*E+-.%+$"%O+P2*-+ 9%'()+498%+-#+)%-+4+"4&'4-'#(+*4P38%+,"#P+-.%+5_+
-"6+ -#+ ,'(&+ 4+ P#"%+ '(&'"%$-+ O46+ -#+ 4**%**+ -.%+ 9%$42*%+ #,+ (#+ 3#O%"+ -#+ -.%+ *4P38%+ T48T%*W+ -.%+
T482%+ -.4-+ -.%6+ (%%&;+ [.'*+ $4(+ $#P3"'*%+ $"%O+ O4*+ (#-+ 498%+ -#+ "%4$.+ 4+ &%,'('-'T%+
$48$284-'()+ -.%+ T482%+ ,"#P+ #-.%"+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ -.4-+ $#($82*'#(+-.4-+-.%+5_+O4*+"23-2"%&;+[.4-+O#28&+
-.%6+ -"2*-+ #"+ ,'(&'()+ 48-%"(4-'T%+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ -.%6+ .4T%+ 9%%(+ 4+ *6P3-#P+ -#+ -"'))%"+ 4+ -"4(*'-'#(+ -#+
$4(+ 2*%;+ C(%+ )%(%"48+ %,,%$-+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+ -.%+ 5_+ -29%+ "23-2"%+ 3"#$%&2"%;+ [.%6+ O%(-+ 94$Q+
'(&'$4-'#(*+ -.4-+ O4*+ *%%(+ *%T%"48+ -'P%*+ '(+ -.%+ 4(&+ ,#"-.+ 9%-O%%(+ #-.%"+ 3"#$%&2"%*+ 9%,#"%+ -.%6+
*$%(4"'#*+ O4*+ -.4-+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ O4*+ *8#O%&+ ,'(4886+P4&%+4+&%$'*'#(+-#+)#+-#+-.%+-29%+"23-2"%+
&#O(+ 9%$42*%+ #,+ $#(,2*'#(+ 4"#2(&+ &%)"4&%&+ 3"#$%&2"%E+92-+-.%(+O'-.#2-+*-"'$-86+,#88#O'()+-.%+
'(&'$4-'#(*+ 4(&+ -"6'()+ -#+ ,')2"%+ #2-+ O.4-+ 3#*-284-%&+3"#$%&2"%+34-.;+Z)4'(E+-.'*+,#"$%&+-.%+
238 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference
$"%O+ -#+ 2*%+ 4+ 8#-+ #,+ -'P%+ '(+ -.%+ 3"#$%&2"%+ 4(&+
$#(*%c2%(-86+-.%6+O%"%+(#-+498%+-#+'&%(-',6+*#P%+
#,+-.%+#-.%"+&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*;++
a')2"%+^+*.#O*+-.%+$"%O*Y+4T%"4)%+*%8,J"4-'()*+
#(+ 3%",#"P4($%+ 4(&+ 4P#2(-+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+
'(&'$4-'#(*;+ C(%+ c2%*-'#(+ '(+ -.%+ *$%(4"'#+
$#P38%\'-6+ c2%*-'#((4'"%+ 4*Q%&+ 49#2-+ &%)"4&%&+
'(&'$4-'#(*H+ dV#O+ &',,'$28-+ O4*+ -.'*+ *$%(4"'#+
O'-.+ "%*3%$-+ -#+ T4)2%+ #"+ 4P9')2#2*+ 3"#$%**+
&'*3846*E+ P'*8%4&'()+ #"+ P'**'()+ 3"#$%**+
'(,#"P4-'#(gdE+ O'-.+ 4+ "%*3#(*%+ *$48%+ ,"#P+ A+
UT%"6+%4*6W+-#+K+UT%"6+&',,'$28-W;+[.%+3%",#"P4($%+
"4-'()+ 2*%&+ 4(+ IJ'-%P+ c2%*-'#((4'"%+ O'-.+ 4+
"%*3#(*%+ *$48%+ ,"#P+ A+ U8#O+ 3%",#"P4($%W+ -#+ M+
U.').+3%",#"P4($%W;+[.%*%+-O#+"%*28-*+*.#O+-.4-+
-.%+ $"%O*+ %\3%"'%($%&+ -.%+ 4P#2(-+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+
'(&'$4-'#(*+ 4*+ %\3%$-%&+ ,"#P+ -.%+ 8%T%8*+ #,+
&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*+'(+-.%+*$%(4"'#*+U*%%+,')2"%+
^WE+ 4(&+ -.4-+ -.%"%+ O4*+ 4+ -%(&%($6+ -#O4"&*+ 4+
&%$8'(%+ '(+ *%8,J"4-%&+ 3%",#"P4($%+ O'-.+ .').%"+
8%T%8*+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*;
()*+,*-./0)1./212)3*.2)214/240.54,/6
' O#"Q8#4&+ #"+ #-.%"+ ,4$-#"*;+ e'-.+ #(86+ -O#+ $"%O*+
&
%
$
#
" '(&'$4-'#(*+P46+4,,%$-+&%$'*'#(+P4Q'();++
! a"#P+ -.%+ #9*%"T4-'#(*+ #,+ -.%+ $"%O*+ .4(&8'()+
! " # $ %
()*+,*-./0) 7)3*.2)214/240.54,/6
! $4(+ 9%+ P4&%;+ [.#*%+ *'-24-'#(*+ O.%"%+ -.%+ $"%O*+
a');+ ^;+ [.%+ $"%O*Y+ 4T%"4)%+ "4-'()+ #,+ 3%",#"P4($%+ 4(&+
&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*E+3%"+*$%(4"'#;++
5"##6,3+*33,(%#
R8%'(Y*+ &4-4J,"4P%+ -.%#"6+ 433%4"%&+ -#+ 9%+ 4+
*2'-498%+ ,"4P%O#"Q+ ,#"+ 4(486D'()+ -.%+ #3%"4-#"Y*+
&%$'*'#(JP4Q'();+ [.%+ "%84-'#(*.'3*+ 9%-O%%(+
,"4P%+4(&+&4-4+-.4-+4"%+&%*$"'9%&+'(+R8%'(Y*+*%(*%+
P4Q'()+ 4$-'T'-'%*+ ,'-+ O%88+ O'-.+ .#O+ -.%+ $"%O*+
-"'%&+ -#+ P4Q%+ *%(*%+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ 4(&+
,'-+ -.%P+ O'-.'(+ -.%'"+ "%3"%*%(-4-'#(+ #,+ -.%+ 384(-+
*-4-2*;+[.%+,"4P%O#"Q+-.2*+*%%P%&+-#+9%+,"2'-,28+
'(+2(&%"*-4(&'()+.#O+#3%"4-#"*+.4(&8%+*'-24-'#(*+
O.%"%+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ 4"%+ 3"%*%(-+ '(+ -.%+
V5F;+ C2"+ ,'(&'()*+ O%"%+ 48*#+ $#(*'*-%(-+ O'-.+ -.%+
#9*%"T4-'#(+ #,+ 7#-.+ UA00KW+ '(+ -.%+ *%(*%+ -.4-+
#3%"4-#"*+ O%"%+ 4$-'T%86+ *%%Q'()+ &4-4+ -#+ ,#"P+ 4+
"%3"%*%(-4-'#(+ #,+ -.%+ *-4-%+ #,+ -.%+ 384(-+ 4(&+ O.4-+
.4&+ $42*%&+ -.%+ '($'&%(-E+ 4(&+ (#-+ *'P386+
,#88#O'()+3"#$%&2"%*;++
[.%+ *$%(4"'#*+ O'-.+ -.%+ .').%*-+ 4P#2(-*+ #,+
&%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+ T%"6+ $.488%()'()+ ,#"+
-.%+$"%O*E+4(&+-.%+*$%(4"'#*+O%"%+48*#+P4&%+O'-.+
-.4-+ '(-%(-;+ 5#P%+ -63%*+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+
O%"%+ P#"%+ &',,'$28-+ -#+ .4(&8%+ -.4(+ #-.%"*;+ [.%+
$"%O*+ T'%O%&+ -.#*%+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ -.4-+ ,4'8%&+ 96+
"4P3'()+-#O4"&*+4+T482%+(#-+-#+9%+T%"6+"%48'*-'$;+
F(+ 4(+ 4(48#)+ $#(-"#8+ "##P+ -.'*+ P46+ (#-+ 9%+
"%48'*-'$;+ V#O%T%"E+ '(+ 4+ $#P32-%"'D%&+ $#(-"#8+
"##P+*2$.+4+9%.4T'#"+'(+'(&'$4-'#(*+P').-+9%+-.%+
"%*28-+#,+%;);+4+$69%"J4--4$Q;++
Z8-.#2).+ -.%+ $"%O*+ O%"%+ )'T%(+ A;M+ &46+ #,+
-"4'('()+ #(+ -.%+ *'P284-#"+ 3"'#"+ -#+ -.%+ *-2&6E+
2(,4P'8'4"'-6+ O'-.+ -.%+ *'P284-%&+ 384(-+ $42*%&+
*#P%+ 3"#98%P*+ ,#"+ -.%+ $"%O*+ -.4-+ O#28&+
3"#94986+ (#-+ .4T%+ #$$2""%&+ ',+ -.%+ $"%O*+ .4&+
%($#2(-%"%&+ -.%+ *4P%+ *$%(4"'#*+ '(+ -.%'"+ .#P%+
384(-;+ =2-+ -.%+ 32"3#*%+ #,+ -.'*+ *-2&6+ O4*+ -#+ 8##Q+
4-+ -.%+ 3#**'98%+ 'P34$-*+ #,+ &%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*E+
4(&+-.%+P'*-4Q%*+-.4-+-.%+$"%O*+P4&%+9%$42*%+#,+
2(,4P'8'4"'-6+ O'-.+ -.%+ *'P284-#"+ P').-+ '(+ #-.%"+
*'-24-'#(*+ #$$2"+ 9%$42*%+ #,+ *-"%**E+ ,4-')2%E+ .').+
O%+48*#+(%%&+-#+9%+$42-'#2*+49#2-+&"4O'()+*-"#()+
$#($82*'#(*E+ 92-+ O%+ $4(+ 3#'(-+ #2-+ *#P%+
-%(&%($'%*+ 4(&+ O46*+ '(+ O.'$.+ &%)"4&%&+
-.%+*$%(4"'#*+'(+-.'*+*-2&6E+*#P%+)%(%"48+'(*').-*+
O%"%+ P#"%+ *2$$%**,28+ '(+ -4$Q8'()+ -.%+ &%)"4&%&+
'(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+ O.%(+ -.%6+ *-#33%&+ -#+ )%-+ 4(+
#T%"T'%OE+&'*$2**%&+-#)%-.%"+-#+-"6+-#+,')2"%+#2-+
$#(,2*'()+ '(&'$4-'#(*E+ 4(&+ O.%(+ -.%6+ $8%4"86+
3#'(-%&+#2-+-#+%4$.+#-.%"+O.4-+'(&'$4-'#(*+*.#28&+
4(&+ *.#28&+ (#-+ 9%+ -"2*-%&;+ F(+ -%"P*+ #,+ -.%+ &4-4J
,"4P%+-.%#"6E+-.%*%+O%"%+-.%+*'-24-'#(*+O.%"%+-.%+
$"%O+ c2%*-'#(%&+ -.%+ &4-4+ -.4-+ -.%6+ *4OE+ Q%3-+ 4(+
#3%(+ P'(&+ -.4-+ 48-%"(4-'T%+ ,"4P%*+ P').-+ 9%+
$#""%$-+4(&+8##Q%&+,#"+&4-4+-.4-+P').-+"%b%$-+-.%'"+
$2""%(-+ ,"4P%+ #"+ $#(,'"P+ 4(+ 48-%"(4-'T%+ ,"4P%;+
:#(T%"*%86E+ -.#*%+ *'-24-'#(*+ O.%"%+ -.%+ $"%O*+
O%"%+P#*-+(%)4-'T%86+4,,%$-%&+96+-.%+3"%*%($%+#,+
&%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ O%"%+ -.%+ *'-24-'#(*+ O.%"%+
-.%6+ Q%3-+ O#"Q'()+ #(+ 4+ 3"#98%P+ O'-.#2-+
*-#33'()+ -#+ "%,8%$-+ #(+ -.%+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ -.%6+
"%$%'T%&+ ,"#P+ -.%+ V5F+ 4(&+ O'-.#2-+ $#(*'&%"'()+
48-%"(4-'T%+ %\384(4-'#(*+ ,#"+ O.4-+ -.%6+ *4O;+
[.%*%+ ,4$-#"*+ 4"%+ "%84-%&+ -#+ -.%+ ,'(&'()+ 96+ T4(+
&%(+V%2T%8+%-+48;+U/@A^W+49#2-+*-"4-%)'%*+-.4-+4"%+
2*%&+ -#+ "%&2$%+ 3%"$%'T%&+ 2($%"-4'(-6E+ #T%"$#P%+
&%846+'(+&%$'*'#(*+4(&+*233#"-+*-"4-%)'$+&%$'*'#(J
 Proceedings of the 29th European Safety and Reliability Conference 239

P4Q'();+ [.%6+ 3#'(-%&+ -#+ -.%+ *-"4-%)'%*+ #,+ R8%'(E+_;+U/@@IW;+G4-2"48'*-'$+&%$'*'#(+P4Q'();+V2P4(+

4%"*6$#31& 4(&& 4%2+%6$#31D#1& =6$#31C+ 7%&2$-'#(+ ,4$-#"*E+M@ULWE+^M`J^`@;++
'(T#8T%*+ 4$-'T%+ *%4"$.+ ,#"+ '(,#"P4-'#(E+ *%%Q'()+ B42P4((E+R;E+!;Jm;+="44"2&E++4(&+V;+5T%()"%(+U/@@MW;+
[.%+ -4*Q+ $#P38%\'-6+ %\3%"'P%(-+ /@@LN/@@^;+
4&T'$%+ ,"#P+ #-.%"*E+ 4(&+ 2*'()+ 3"%T'#2*+ Ve7JKMI;+ V48&%(E+ G#"O46H+ C1:S+ V48&%(+
%\3%"'%($%+ -#+ 3"%&'$-+ ,2-2"%+ %T%(-*;+ 7%,8%$-'#(J 7%4$-#"+!"#b%$-;+
'(J4$-'#(+$#T%"*+4+P%-4J$#)('-'T%+c2%*-'#('()+#,+ GX71_+ UA0K`W;+ 7%$#PP%(&4-'#(*+ "%84-%&+ -#+ -.%+
4**2P3-'#(*+4(&+3"%T'#2*+4$-'#(*;++ ="#O(*+a%""6+,'"%;+53"'(),'%8&E+j'")'('4E+X5ZH+X;+
F-+P46+9%+3#**'98%+-#+-"4'(+#(%Y*+*%(*%+P4Q'()+ 5;+G2$8%4"+7%)284-#"6+:#PP'**'#(;++
49'8'-'%*;+Z$$#"&'()+-#+R8%'(+U/@@`WE+-"4'('()+,#"+ CpV4"4+o;<;E+o;+:;+V'))'(*E+e;a;+5-298%"E+4(&+o;+R"4P%"+
U/@@@W;+ :#P32-%"J94*%&+ !"#$%&2"%+ 56*-%P*H+
*%(*%+P4Q'()+*.#28&+4'P+-#+'P3"#T%+-.%+*Q'88+-#+
[%$.('$48+ =4*'*+ 4(&+ V2P4(+ a4$-#"*+ 7%T'%O+
(#-'$%+ 4(#P48'%*E+ 3"#&2$%+ 4+ 9"#4&%"+ "4()%+ #,+ _2'&4($%+UGX71_J``L^WE+X5+G2$8%4"+7%)284-#"6+
,"4P%*+ 4(&+ "'$.%"+ ,"4P%*E+ '($82&'()+ $42*48+ :#PP'**'#(;+
P%(-48+ P#&%8*;+ [.'*+ O#28&+ 'P386+ -"4'('()+ -#+ CYV4"4E+o;E+=;+_2(-.%"E+_;+<4"-'(%DJ_2"'&'E+o;+r'()E+4(&+
'($"%4*%+ #3%"4-#"*Y+ %\3%"-'*%+ "%84-%&+ -#+ 3"#$%**+ j;+=4"(%*;+U/@A@W+[.%+1,,%$-*+#,+S%)"4&%&+S')'-48+
Q(#O8%&)%+4(&+3"#$%**+2(&%"*-4(&'();+C3%"4-#"*+ F(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+ 4(&+ :#(-"#8+ 56*-%P*+ #(+ V2P4(J
$#28&+ 48*#+ 9%+ -"4'(%&+ #(+ -.%+ *-"4-%)'%*+ ,#"+ *6*-%P+ F(-%",4$%*+ 4(&+ C3%"4-#"+ !%",#"P4($%;+
G!F:nV<F[;+
.4(&8'()+&%)"4&%&+'(&'$4-'#(*+P%(-'#(%&+49#T%;++ 7%P3%E+ o;+ B;E+ S;+ B;+ R(2&*#(E+ 4(&+ 7;+ o;+ B2-D+ U/@AMW;+
[.'*+ 343%"+ .4*+ 3"%*%(-%&+ *#P%+ %\4P38%*+ #,+ 5$#3'()+ *-2&6+ '(T%*-')4-'()+ !e7+ '(*-"2P%(-4-'#(+
(2$8%4"+ 3#O%"+ 384(-+ #3%"4-#"*Y+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ &2"'()+ 4+ *%T%"%+ 4$$'&%(-+ *$%(4"'#;+ FGBN1r[JAMJ
'(+ *'-24-'#(*+ O'-.+ &%)"4&%&+ '(,#"P4-'#(+ '(+ -.%+ LM0^@;+F&4.#+G4-'#(48+B49#"4-#"6;++
V5F;+ [.%+ "%*28-*+ *.#O%&+ -.4-+ #3%"4-#"*+ &%-%$-%&+ 7#-.E+ 1;+ <;+ UA00KW;+ Z(486*'*+ #,+ &%$'*'#(+ P4Q'()+ '(+
&%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ 94*%&+ #(+ '($#(*'*-%($'%*+ (2$8%4"+3#O%"+384(-+%P%")%($'%*H+Z(+'(T%*-')4-'#(+
9%-O%%(+ &4-4+ 4(&+ -.%+ #3%"4-#"*Y+ $2""%(-+ ,"4P%E+ #,+ 4'&%&+ &%$'*'#(+ P4Q'();+ F(+ :;+ 1;+ >*4P9#Q+ 4(&+
_;+ R8%'(+ U1&*;WE+ G4-2"48'*-'$+ &%$'*'#(+ P4Q'();+
4(&+ -.%(+ 2*%&+ T4"'#2*+ *-"4-%)'%*+ -#+ T%"',6+ -.%+ 1"8942P;+
'(&'$4-'#(*;+ S%)"4&%&+ '(&'$4-'#(*+ $#28&+ *8#O+ 5Q"44('()E+ _;+ o";E+ G;+ B42E+ 7;+ e%8$.E+ :;+ G'.8O'()E+ _;+
&#O(+ &%$'*'#(JP4Q'()+ 4(&+ P4Q%+ '-+ P#"%+ Z(&"%*%(E+ B;+ V;+ ="%T')E+ m;+ j%84(&E+ _;+ Z;+
&',,'$28-+-#+,#88#O+3"#$%&2"%*;+e%+.4T%+%\-"4$-%&+ o4P'%*#(E+ :;+ =2"(*E+ 4(&+ o;+ RO#Q+ U/@@KW;+ [.%+
*#P%+ '(*').-*+ 49#2-+ *-"4-%)'%*+ -.4-+ P46+ .%83+ %$#8#)'$48+ '(-%",4$%+ &%*')(+ %\3%"'P%(-+ U/@@MW;+
$"%O*+ P4Q%+ *%(*%+ #,+ *'-24-'#(*+ O'-.+ &%)"4&%&+ Ve7JILL;+C1:S+V48&%(+7%4$-#"+!"#b%$-;+
T4(+ S'(%E+ Z;E+ <;+ Z**4(-%E+ 4(&+ !;+ 5-#2-84(&+ U/@A`W;+
'(&'$4-'#(*;++
C2-34$'()+ $69%"+ -."%4-*H+ !"'#"'-'%*+ ,#"+
$69%"*%$2"'-6+4-+(2$8%4"+,4$'8'-'%*;+G[F;+
2/7/'/%+/3#
="44"2&E+!;+m;+4(&+="%(&"6%(E+V;+U/@@AW;+[4*Q+&%P4(&E+
-4*Q+ P4(4)%P%(-E+ 4(&+ -%4PO#"Q;+ Ve7J`MK;+
C1:S+V48&%(+7%4$-#"+!"#b%$-;+
V4*.%P'4(E+ V;<;+ U/@AAW;+ Fn:+ 3%",#"P4($%+ &2"'()+
4$$'&%(-+$#(&'-'#(*;+j'%((4E+Z2*-"'4H+FZ1Z;+
R%P%(6E+ o;+ _;+ UA0K0W;+ [.%+ G%%&+ ,#"+ :.4()%H+ [.%+
B%)4$6+ #,+ [<F;+ e4*.'()-#(E+ S:E+ X5ZH+ [.%+
!"%*'&%(-p*+:#PP'**'#(+#(+-.%+Z$$'&%(-+4-+[<F;+
R'PE+ <;+ :;+ U/@A^W;+ F(*').-*+ #(+ 4$$'&%(-+ '(,#"P4-'#(+
4(&+ *6*-%P+ #3%"4-'#(*+ &2"'()+ a2Q2*.'P4+ %T%(-*;+
R6#%16%& =1"& S%6-13+35(& 32& A*6+%=4& .1,$=++=$#31,E+
j#82P%+ /@A^E+ Z"-'$8%+ FS+ A/L/^@E+ A/+ 34)%*;+
.--3HNN&\;&#';#")NA@;AAMMN/@A^NA/L/^@+
R8%'(E+ _;E+ =;+ <##(+ 4(&+ 7;+ V#,,P4(+ U/@@`W;+ <4Q'()+
*%(*%+#,+*%(*%P4Q'()+/H+Z+P4$"#$#)('-'T%+P#&%8;+
F111+F(-%88')%(-+56*-%P*E+/AUMWE+IIJ0/;++
R8%'(E+ _;E+ o;+ R;+ !.'88'3*E+ 1;+ B;+ 7488E+ 4(&+ S;+ Z;+ !%82*#+
U/@@KW;+Z+&4-4J,"4P%+-.%#"6+#,+*%(*%P4Q'();+F(+7;+
7;+ V#,,P4(+ U1&;WE+ !TG%4$#,%& 3*$& 32& 631$%T$F&
)436%%"#15,&32&$-%&R#T$-&.1$%41=$#31=+&:312%4%16%&
31& A=$*4=+#,$#6& ;%6#,#31& K=I#15+ U33;+ AALqAMMW;;+
<4.O4.E+GoH+B4O"%($%+1"8942P+Z**#$'4-%*;+