‘ a cneapes poe 9 aap Y88 7, 107 run Cn eammeoe wiry. ae ante 2 Core apt 8 1978 40 ayy oro ME ACT TOE. — ABTORDATON A ae emer texan panTArr0 138 CHEITOARIS uh penogseT AEN PBST ym, 202109 Prbisgstseaacucias Ha eonpocs: mastoro peaakropa wypiaa «3AKOH> saa Tiacryosa oTaeNaer gamectuTenb MpeacenaTena Beicwero ApowrpaxKHoro Cyna P®, AOKTOp KOPHAMYECKHX HAYK, nporbeccop, gacnyMeHHbiii HOpHCT Po Bnapnnnp JIbBOBHY CMECAPEB fipo6nemb! HenelicTBUTeNbHOCTM cpenok B CBETe apGuTpaxHon npakTukin TFracxonano, © Bauuel TONRH apeHiAs, CYIMEETESN pashinya menay TaK NaseIBaeMbIMM HecocToABIIMMA- Pa (wesaKmowenmmn) CREMKAMN u CRETKENI wenelt- Jonouounti np pocTacennn 8 TPeOyeMOn hope cTOR eee goenauieni ro BCOM CyNECTEEHHIM YETOBNTRL= SAKOH Ne 6 HOH 2008 Tarore nonoxene, onperenniousee, TO 8 OTRENEHIK ‘nya Aorosop MoXeT CarTaTBCR SaKTIOHOFHE TOKO nocne ero rocynapcrseHHoii perscroauy. Tponorkan {TY nonity, MoxKo creat BsiB08 To eon TH YEnORAR i Hagneaitony orpoptaneriio noroBopeKwocTem CTopOR He coBmonets, To enema We saKnovena. Buecte c TeMt apyusenan TpeGosaiiti x cbopMe CRENK M K €@ PervcT- Palyat © oTperiix cry¥anx ebLanBaicT pextna HE;eRCT- srTensiooms cpemme (cr. 162, 165 FK PO upp.) B Aak- HOM cnyae Mb OTK CKAGRTE, 470, XOTR dPOpMEl HET, CREMKY Ni AOMORI! ROCSHTATS SaKNIOVEHHOM, a NOTOM saKniovennivio npvoHae HepeiicrevTenbwof,FloToMy “0 HO MOET SbITb HEAEMCTBUTENbHbIM TO, 4eTO HET. ‘Sxjec ecre onpeRenennan HenorAIHOCTE, NopoxAaIOWIAA ‘yHeGre ouAb. Tax, CRENKA, COBEPILIEHHAR © OHI “TeM ke oTCTyMNeHVEM OT YCTaHOENeHHEK NpaEHN (TPO Baka K cbopMe, K rocynapcTeekHod porucrpaLriy), 8 PALE ‘nysaes npwsiiaeros HesakmioveHnod, a voTna — Hemel ‘oronrensioh, Pasiiua Mexiy KaTeropintan HeneFCrEl ‘TensHooTa i HeaakmiovotsiocTA cHanoK Wo Sesrna yur aston Kax yuacrann OSopoTa, TaK v npasonpiaMestt- ‘Tenet, viiorza ROMYcKBIOTER OWWHGK, 8 PeeymsTATE Hero K 7peSoparuny 0 NpuHaHiN cnerioK HeaaKMO4sHHtNMM inptetioron nonoxetian cr. 184 TK P@ eOpor wexo- ‘50f RABHOCTH no HeReliTaxToTSHIM GROAKAN —Bonpoc, cassatioiit ¢ HesMcAeHeM CpOKOB HCKO- Boi AasHOCTH. Mo MeKam o NpUMeHeHHM NocKeACTEM WepelicTenTensNoctTu HuMTOXHbIX CAeROK OH PeWeH ‘omHosHaMHo: TeveHNe cpoKa NpHBAaHO K HaYany Me ommenna cRenkn. MpyMenuTenbHo x cAenkan Hesa- KnloNeHHbI TaKOM ACHOCTH HET. APSUTPAMHIEIC cy Pewaior oot aonpoc no-pasHomy. C KaKoro MomeHTa HOOBXOAIMMO MCHNERATE CpoK HCKOBOR AabHOCTA No KOHAMKUMOHHbIM TpeGoBaKKnM o BoSBpaTe nepenaH- Horo No HesaKnioveHHoMy Aorosopy? OnpaBaaH nl AuchcpepenyuporaHlelit noRXoR K pewieHme Bonpo- OB NCYNcHeHHA HaBHOCTH No OTHCWIEHNIO K HeneliCT- BUTeMbHbIM H HecocToRBUIMMeR cREnKaM? — Bonpoc 0 Morisax Henpiicteri K HesaKmIOYOHHDIN ‘enenkam nonoxeHit © epoKax cKoBo RaBHOCTH, Kaca- oUKen HenevIcTBUTeNSHX CReNoK, RENRETCA TeOpeTH- eck npocTaim. Cyulecrayior o6uyMe HOpM! 0 opoKaX WekOBOM AABHOCTH M NopAEKe Ux MeHMoNeHA, A TACK HopMl creuWanbHble, BEOARUIME 8 OTY permaNeHTalyHO Te unl wiible ocoGeKHocTH. HopMii O cpoKax wcKOBO aBHOCTH NO KenelicTeHTenbkeIM CReNKAM OTHOCATER K ‘neRy CnelyraNsHbM, a NOTOMY He MoryT NpHMEHATECS, & ToM 4iicne 1 nO aHaNOTHM saKOH, K eRenKaM HeAKmO- soni, Avro racaoren Bawioro yreepxmieh 0 toMy, so 80@ R= Ho 8 OTHOWIOHIA HoKOESM ABBHOSTA no HenelicTBAToN- Hunt cxenkau, 10 xoren 61 oTMeTITD, Ho Sjoce eyNeCT- yer PAK copbeaHe npoGneW. Tpynhis, w vacTHOCTH, anROTcA Bonpoc 0 sau\Te Nas mAs, saviTepecoBaH bbc 8 MpHGHAMAK GHenAM HUNTONOOI B Tex OnyaRX, KOr- 1a. OF Ho RONROTCA YMACTHAKANN HARK GRENA M HE aHaloT 0 Havane © HcronHeHAn, a vHOrRA M © cbaKro 68 ‘akmiovonin Moxay Tew cr. 181K PO npwesauieaer a- ‘ano Tevet cpora noxDeOH AaBHOCTH 10 yRADaHH TpebosaH4HH KO BHO HonORKONAR BTOA eAlnat. M Nony- ‘aeron, sro no HeTeNeiAA cpoKa HexOBO! ABHOCTA NPM oni cyne6ro NpHcras W TOsopsT: «Bcenaittecen, — M370 Ha OcHOBAHIAK NOFOBOpA, CTOPOHO! KoTOporo COGcT- oii KRapTApH He RENAETOR UO CylecTaORAAN KOTO- oro He nonospesan. Mlocnenkii, KoHesHO, x0¥eT NEM ame Taxyo cHlenky HeneRTeHTeNsHOA, a no cr. 181 pena aToro yxe He CMON. Cypbl 8 pane cnysass npn nojoGHbK oScTorTenLcTeax pavers OGuIne NONOXEHHA O HavaNe Te4eHYA CpoKa aBHOCTH M HCURENAMH Wx.co AL, KOT NiayO YaKANIO WIA ‘OMKHO Geino ysHars 0 HapyuieHiu cBoero npaBa. Npepnosturrensiee saxohonatensHoe pewonve AaHtoro Bonpoca. Kak uapecTuo, 8 FocynaperasHyio flymy PO BHeceH saKoHonpoeKT 06 uateHeHMn n. 1 or. 181 TK PO. ‘Cumicn npegmaxeun & Tom, 706s! coxpaHuTe cyiyocrBy- fouywe nonomenutn o HaNane TeHeHIR CpoKAa NABHOCTH ANA CcTOpOM cgenkn, a ANA nM, He asnsouxcA cTopoHANMA ‘epenki, nputeovtaTe o6ujoe npasiino — onpenenaTe Hava- ‘no TewewAA ABHOCTH CO AKA, KOTNAa TWO YsHANO UTM ROMKHO Gsuno ysHars o HapyUleHiNA cBOero NpaBa 8 CoA ‘9H ¢ HonOnHeHHeM 9TOF omen. Bropoh momen. Oust acto samsnnicr TpsSosaHin 0 MpHOHAHIA HUNTOKHED CHETOK Ges MpHMeHOHUR nO- ‘onencraini. Yitorpa avo wacTan acbepa. Moray 410 Wor LUbt MONMMaIOT HEDOAMOKHOCTE BARIKALAA, — B STON UM OTKAMYT 1o-28 AoSpocoRecnHocTH navOSpeTaTen, (On sassniioT TpeGosanve 0 npusHaMn caenkn HeRel CTExTenbHO!i, NOTOM WAyT C CyYAECHEIM aKTOM 8 oprarts Perverpaiii, rie perucrpypyict npaso coGcTeenHoCTA, ‘DoSpocosectueii npuotperarenis KOHeSHo xe cchinaeTon Ha HeBooMONHOCTS HaLATH MMyWJeCTBa, a eMy CTBOYa-VHTEPBBIO HOMEPA lot: «fla, nobaTs He noMyaToA, Ho Tel nociAM 683 AOKY- ‘Monroe ta coBcTBeHHOCTS Eorb ewe apyrie cnyvan: sanenmior TpeGosaltne 0 pH ‘Hann onenkn HeneicreMTensHol Ges, IpAMSHEHMA NO- cilencTaiii. VicTub! CHNTaIOT, TO ecnH OHM MpHaHAIOT onenky HeneficTeMTenbHOM HB CneAyloUleNd NPOMSEORCT- be sanaAr TpeGonatin © BUNAIAKALIM, TO 3TO APANT“PY- ferns yerex. Xorenocs Gv OSpaATvT BHAMAKH Ha TO, ¥TO TK npawo He npenyeMaTpveact BosMoxHooTH sanBaneHR “TpeGopahits 0 NpHGHaHH HUYTOXNO! GAesKM HeneliCTEH- ‘Tennolt. B costecT#om Tlocranosrenwn Mnehyia Bep- xpanoro Cyna « Mnenywa BAC PO or 01.07.1996 Ne 6/8 Guino pasvacteHo, “To TK He MoKmioNaeT osMoKHOCTH npesABnenin TaKAx ucKo8. — Sapnour mi Gynb6a WeKa © BuARNKaLINN HMyECT- ta, nepenaitioro no cAeAKe, coBepwleHHOH NOR BIA wen Hacunina (ocHopHMoi eplem, cosepwreKnno’ TnoMuMo sont), oT eenapHBeHua TaKo CHEAKH OT lnenbo © cyReSHiOM mopaaxe? ViyBIK CHOBaMI, BOS~ MoxHo Mi BAAWUAPOBATS TaKOS MMLeCTRO, eCrM ‘cnenka ovAembHo He ocrapuearach, a FOAMNHDNT CPOK xa ee ochapwanme weTeK? —Bonpoc, no oyna, caReaH c ONPEAeNeHHEM BIER OC THOpUMOM CHEN, HeNeMCTEWTertsHOGTI: KOTOPOH CYAOM He nowshaka 8 cHy pasninsHicx PYM, Ha BOOMOKHOCT BuKgeKalynn HMyLeCTEA, NepenaNoro no TaKOM cABrMe. ‘10 mirepecntih Bonpoc. © npaxTHvecKoit TONKA Spe Tia Hie NEACTASMACTOR, HTC He TPBGYETOR NpMSHA ‘nave ccnopumylo onanky HanBicTMTENSHOA AAA TOFO, ‘yroSi SuAAiUMpoBATe KyecTBO. Bro XO KaCABTER iW musToxHOd onenku. B cooTBeTeTRMM co oT. 307 TK Pm ‘coGcTBoHHMK BMpaBS HoTPeBOBATE CBOE HmNyLIECTBO HO ‘spnoro HosaxonHoro BnageHn. BbIGbITHe MMyLYoCTBA Mo Bnanenun coBcrBeHKiKa no OCROPHNOM cAeNKe, pH ‘aHaHHOl HeNelICTEMTORSHOA 8 cyReSHOM nopAAKe, 6e- ayenoBio, RORTBepXAaeT HesaxoHHOcTe BNAReHAR APY Toro nkya. MnaA cHryauNis cxniaRbiaaeToR & TOM CHYNA, korn caenka (KoTopyio HoTeU Kea puaMypOBAA KAK OC ropiyio Wn HAWTOXHy!O) 8 KeNecTBe NeReliCTeNTEN- oll no TeMt NK MHBIM MpHMMEM CyAOM He MHaNAHa, More nonaraict, TO HeaaKoHHOCT> MOxHO HoKaabr Barb TOnsKo 8 paNKaX NpHSHAHMA CHENKH HeACHACTBY- ‘Tenbtioi, Ho Hep TO CAMOCTOATENLMLIA MRCTATYT ¢ C2 MMocromrensibivi RocnencTavAMM W éyakuunnan. FIpeA: crasnaooa, 470 CnoaMuMK CT. 301 TK PO ninusb ovKas B inpuahanie CpeNkn HeneMiCTBMTENEHOM 6 CORGH ¢ OTCYT- CcTeveN OcHOBAHMI! APIA ©@ NDMGHAHNA HUYTOXKOM HGS ‘ocnopmMolt ogketaeT HeBosMaXxHocTs KBanicbMKauMn pnameHAn BUR OTBETPKOM KaK HEGaKOHHOTO 1 NRA. ‘Tua peuleniin 06 oTKage B yRoBNeTBOpeHAN BUNAMKALM ‘onnioro Moxa. B vitix onysanx oTKasa 8 Hoke (saNBTeH10 “Tpe6ooahiea HegauTepecosenbnd Vix HeynOMHOMOweH- Hin ninyoM, HoTeNEHMe cpoKa MeKoBOA NaBHOCTH) MMGO HeaaneneHka TpeSoBalian o mpusaHAn ocropMMoit Ccaenki HepeoTBHTENLHOM chakT HeSAKOHHOCTH MIM HO- SaKOFHOCTA ShaeHINA BELA OTBSTHMKOM HE MOXET carrarvon'yeranopnesitin. B cascH ¢ STAM HET NPS narcreuil nna poKaauieadust cpaxTa HevaKOHHOTO BAAAB HA BeULLIO-OTBETHAKOM HenocpeneTBeHHO B Npoyecce paccwoTpeHta ennmKaUMOHiorO TpesoBaHtan. Ho onATS xe XOMY OTHETHTE, TO GTO MOS JIRSHO® MHEHHO, — Speck 5 KavecTee BospaxeHin MOXKHO mpMBecTA "ApYTYO NoTHKy: B cooTeeTeTEMH co cT. 301 TK PO npe- bon Ha BUHAMKaYWO MuyujecTBa O6NaRAeT COGCTREH- HK GO sIM\O, BRaneIOLee HMYLYECTBOM HA SaKOH- oN ocHtosarnl. Tlo coBeplueNHO! OcnopHMolt cAENKE ‘Twryn nopelwen K WoBoMy COGCTEeHHAKY, M, noKa Ta kan cnenka He npnsiana cyqoM HenoiicranTenbHom, nao, sassnaulee HK, CPopManbHo He COGCTREHHMK, Kax ke MOXeT npeRBARNET® ENHANKAYHOHHOS TPO BaHwe MYO, He RENHOWIeECA COBCTOOHHNKON? — Eien 61s 6tino aK, TO Torga cMbiona B SHHAIWKALHOH Hb0« Hoxax He Grind 6b! BoRce. Llano B TOM, HTO KAKA, to 2amnaeT BHNAMKALMOHHIC® TpeGOBAHHe, CHITTAeT Ce Gn coBeTeeHiMKOM HezasHci4a OF TOTO, KAK ocbOpMIeHO ‘ero mpaBo, Kakoe npaso ocpopMiteNo Y APYTOM cropOHEL Aro y Hac nonysaeren uoxona us sauleri nora? Boe na HyxHo cHavana NORaBATS HK 0 NpMaHAHNN NpAza (i HeBaxro, Ha REVOKHNIO HIN HEABIKMMYIO BES), @ [Yk nOTOM BANANKAUMOHHELe TpeGoBAhvA NpeALABNATS ‘Avex o npusiaiin npaa ~~ sto epoero pona tbanror, ‘oH cyujeoteyer ToNGHO B Sige HeKnepauy. C1poro Fo Ops, 2x/aKOCROCOBHK TONED NPAMO NPOTHCAEHNG BM [nel HoKO8 0 M"SHAHHN ABA: MEK O NPHOKAHAK PABA Ha caMOBONbHyIO TlOCTpOMiKy, "NOX O-MpHBHAAMA NpaBa coGcrBeHHOCTH AoSpocosecrHoro snanenbua. A paccva- ‘ypubare fleno No wexy o NpHsHaNiAA Npasa Us Tex, TO Inpamo & saKoHe He NOvMeHOBAN, TAKENO: 8 GaKOHOHa- “Tenscree He OnpenenoHtel Hh YorIORH, HA HTIB! — HUNO- ro. B GonsiuiHETBe Xe cAy4aes TAKOH WOK 2aABNACT, KOF- [ha no Kaxane-TO NpHiniant He YAAGTER AKDCTITHYT KENa-OE ee BAKOH No 6 WOH 2008 ‘eMoro vba cnocodom, HanpnMep Koraa TOKMMAIOT, STO B eHaMKalin Gyper OTKAsaHO, W 7.9. Monaraio, 8 TaKOM eayrate nyse peulfTe BECb KOMTEK BONPOCOS: B PAN ax onvoro NPOveRORICTBA He PasMeHNBAACe POLIT BO- pocs! w 0 cienke, v 0 Xapaktepe BbIGRTUR nMyUleCTEA. ‘A pefle 270 eile W NROUECCYaNEHO HEH YAOGHO: MOKTIO NaeTen EOSMOKHOCTS NpMNATHA PASTIYHK PELeHIA NO conn # Tem xe BorpocaM, — AB oTHoWeHUH HCKOBO! RaBHOCTH? ByAGT Mi K Mo- Kam 0 BMHAMKAUNK HMyuIeCcTBa, Nlepewenulero B HY >Koe BnapenMe no OCROPAMO! CHENKe, MPHMEHATLCA ‘oSuynit TpexneTHnil CpoK HNN cheyManbHEIM AMA OC- nopumex cnenok — 1 roa? —locwontny TpeGonanie 0 nplsHeNMM BRATEHAS Se lubio orBeTavKons HegaKoHHbiM JamenAETEA HCTUOM NOM paccmoTpeNvit BHEVKaLMOHHOTO TReSOBaHAR A HO FE [nReTCA SNeMeHTOM vioKa © MpwaHaHi onENKK HeAeHCT= piTenbHol, K HeMY He NpAMEHAIOTES NONaXeKMA 0 Cpo- ax WCKOBO ABMOCTH, YCTEMOBMEMHEIX ANA NPHOHA- ta cnenox weneficTaurencitim, — 1 ron, Speck Rei CcTayior o6uive faBHocHeIe cpox” — 3 rona. MonMere- hve uckoBoro epoka 8 1 roj np peuleNAH Bonpoca O6 HC- speSobanin vinyujectba, HaxOARLAerOCR B MYON Hesa- oHHOM Bnagenin, WoKNIOHeHO, NOCKONSKY & NPOTHBHOM ‘ony'ae MOMET GurTe CHVOKEM ypOBeM> FApaHTHHA NDAs COO CreeHKiNOR, yoTAHOBNEHHLX FeiICTBYOLWM rpaKnar ‘oni saxoHopaTenbcTBOM. —4ro Kacaetca HesMeneHiA epoKo® HCKOROH ABHO- (OTH no MeKaM © MpM3HaHMM CReNKI HHYTOKHOMt: KOK peulaerea stot Bonpoc B OTHOWIeHMM cAENOK, SAKNIO~ NeHHEIX 20 2005 F., KAKOiI MPHMeHRETER K HHM CPOK moKoBoil ABBHOCTA? _—Tlo epoxam vexoRolt naBHOCTH Gbino HECKONEKO NOCTa osnenni Mpeamamynea. Mi onpenasianvce 10 STOMY BO- pocy: 8 coorrercreim c 4. 1 cr. 203 TpaxknaHcKoro Ko- inenca Poconcxoli Denepaunn TeyeHve cpora WoxOBOI ‘RADHOCTH NpepsiBaeTCA NpesTeABNEHHEN HCKA B YCTSHOB- rnentom nopanke. Eon cooTesToTByiOUy WOK NpesteAB- ‘net! ® yoraHosnaHHom nopsxe AO 26.07.2005 (nara crynnesta 8 cuny Denepansuoro saxoria oT 21.07.2005 No 109-03), TeHeHHe HeMicTexauiero opoKa WCKOBOA saB- HocrH rerinoTer nipepaaritim, B Takom cnywae 8 yRoBNe- ‘TBopeHinh Tpe6OBaHIMA No MOTHBY VCTeNEHAR CPOKA HCKO- Bo” nasHocTm Ha ocHOBAKNM BcTynneHUR B ciAny SaxOHa He Maxer Obire orkasaHo, — Kak Bhi nonaraere, nocne npunnras Mneky¥o BAC PO Noctanosnenus ot 10.04.2008 Ne 22 «O He- KoTOpLIX BonpocaX npakTuKH paccmoTpeHHtA eno- pos, CBRSAMHEIX € MPHMeHEHHEM cTaTbH 169 TK PO» kaxen npo6nema wa acero Maccusa Bonpocos Henel- GTBKTeMBHOCTH CeNOK octaNeTca HaKGone® AKTY- anbHon? — Kax nasecrHo, Rakin loctanoanetvew FinenyMa on penenoxa cibepa npawenonua cr. 169 [K Po. B ¥acTHO- (CTH, HOM AAHO paguAcHeHe TOTO, KAKUe GEMM MOXHO (CAMTAT HUSTOXHBIMA Hal OCHOBAHM BaKTIONEHAR WK C UO- ‘nwo, sazenoMo NPOTNBHOM CCHOBSM NpaBONOPAAKA 1 pascraerHiocTH. Sto, ® vacrHOcTH, cnemkn, Hanpasrter- ble Ha MpONABORCTEO M OTHYKREHHO ONpEDEAOHHN BM ‘n08 OBvextos, ERATED HNM OrpAHMNeHHeX & TpaxNaH- ‘ekout 0Gopore (cooTBeTCTAyOUWe BNE OpyKHE, GOeNpH- hhacoB, HAPKOTHMECKUX CpenCTS, APYFOM NPOAYKUMK, CO rnanaioujel ceovicreamn, onacHMn AMR MSHA WA s10pO~ bon papa, 47.1); Cen, HanpaBreHHese Ha HSTOTOS- neve, PacnpocTpANeHHe JMTEpATYPb! M WHOM NPOAYK: umn, nponaranspyiowjo? BoMy, HALMOHANSHy'O, PACO- Byio Win penuTvESHYIO BPAXKAY; CAENKIA, HANDABIOHHDIC Ha varoTosnenine Whi CObIT NOABeMbHED OKYMEHTOR chix 6yMar. OcHostan npoGnema npamenania cr. 169 TK PO it- wTon 8 TOW, HTO6s! Gee HaneKauye OchoRAH He ACNpATs RepeveHb cRanoK, KeAnKbrUMpyrOUyNCA B ‘ykasaution nopRAKe, Spect HEOGXOAHMO HMETb B BH: Iny, “70 rpaxaakeKoe Mpeso NO cEoelt Cyr ABmACTCA ‘mo2eonuTeNbHAIM CpENCTEOM B MeXAHVEMe Npasosero perynmposanita o6wecTBeHHEK oTHOWIEHH. Tip HaBy- Wenn yuacrivKama akoHOMUMECKOrO OGopoTA NpAB W ‘S@KOHHLIX UHTEPACOR CHOMK KOHTPAFEHTOB NPUMCHAIOTER Mopbi rpaxXAANcKO-np@eosor SALLI, HMEIOULWE TPE: MyWecTBeHHo BOCcTAHOBMTeNIbHO-KOMMIeHCAUIMOHHD xapaxrep. Korepnckalonible Mepbl, NPEAYEMOTPEHHLIE pb er. 169 PK P®, auicrynar 8 Kavecrse HoKnosMTe- Hux npaBoabix CpeACTB, KOTOPHIE NpMMEHAIOTCA WUE ‘orna, Korna RYSNM4NbIe OTpacrn npasa, MMOIOUWE SHA ren NpHIYANTONGHO-oxPaHHTensHbiA NOTeHUMA, ho ToM HAM WHbIM NpUNHAM He MoryT OBeCneNiTE AO CTWKeHAA canis, NocraBNeHMEN nepeR HANK, TyEOKO yéexner, 470 co BpeMeHeN, no Mepe COBEpLISHCTEOBA Hua ny6nuuko-npaRosofi vaca cveTeMl PocoWoKOrO nnpasa W npaxTunH ero MpHMeHeHHA, CoxpaHste cr. 169 TK Po apa na norpesyerca.HTEPBBIO HONEPA ~ Kak Bot oTHociTecs K wmpoxo oScyxnaemoii une sa parenl ceowx NoMoMONI, TO oTBeT SyseT-OTpHLa- Tomitam. A mmole 9 BHAy cnenytoujee nonoxoKe pac: cwarpueaemoro MocTaHosneHits:. «..Popwmposane Boiownen Ap6impaxsti CynoM Poccisicror Genepawan ‘TpaBos0r noshuMA He RenReToA OcHOBAiIveM nepecNaT- Pa nen, no KOTO yrpaNeHa BOsMOXHOCTE OOpauKoHt Cc aaneneHven 0 nepecMoTPe CyneEHEN aKTOS B OpARKe appopa. Taxon o6pasom, nosnwin BAC PO nonwocTs10 6asvpyer- of Ha nonoxeHuaX ANIK PO 0 aanavax 1 byHKLMSX Ha'SAKOH Ne 6 MIOH 2008 opto WHCTAMUHIA 4 BOSMOKHOCTAK YrOTa O10 OBCTOR- TTemwcra, KOTOPSIE MOFYT OuITe OTHECOHD! K SHICHY BHOBE ‘orxpuieuMnca —B nponommenne TeNbI MPeueReHTHOTO sHANCHAA ‘axroe BAC P® xorenoce Obi oTMeTHTE cneAyIoUIee. Tipaxrixa ap6wrpaxnirx cyROB M cyAOE OGL OPH” ‘AMKun MHOTAa PACKOAMTEA B peWleHMM ORHMX TEX bee npasopsix sonpocos. KaK But nonaracte, He MpM- eer nu Tlocrawoanenne Ninewya No 14 x Tony, 470 chaxrirvecn Ha ocHOBe ORHNX M Tex xe HOpM 2aKOHA B etpane GynyT cyulecTBOBaTb pasnwyNbie CHCTeM! x eyaeSHoro TonKoBaHuA W yUACTRAKH O6OPOTE BbI- ymnenti 6yAyT eule M YUNTbIBAT PHCXM TOFO, B KS- Kot cncreMe cyAOB MM OOM MpHReTER SaLyULATE pon npasa? _—Tonkosanine HopM ripaca — cnoxKHbIM, TBOPYECKI npoyecc. OSecneveHMe enHMOOBpasHs & NPaBoNPHMe- Henn — rnapHan aanava BAC PO. Ecnw roBopiTs 0 HanKinn npoTHBOPENKI 8 npAKTHKe cyROB CCUIOH TOpHOAMRUMM M apSHTPAXHENX CYAOB, TO OHM, K COxANe- two, eotpoyaioren, BMecTe C TeM MaBeCTHE! MeKAHHS- Mui npeonloneriia TaKoro COCTOAMIEA, B TOM Mice Ny= Tem npHunTHa COBMECTHLIX NOCTAHOBNeMMA MyneHYMOB BepxosHoro Cyfa PO « Beicwiero Ap6uTpaxiioro CyAa PO, B nocnenvee BpeMA aKTHBHY!O por 6 YTONHEHHH nosnulth yKaganHirx eygoe Buinoniner KOHOTATYUMOH- hei Cy PO, HaNpMMep Mo BonpocaM CoOTHOWEHNR BuHaKayan (weTpeGoBAHKE MMyLECTBA va ~4YKOrO HesakKonHoro enaReHisA) M pecrvTy¥NK no Heneiicrsy- TTenbibim cfenkam, BosMeUIeHHA HelMyWuecTBeHHOro pena, npraMHenvoro lopwamHeckmM ninyaM. CONWKE- ino nlosuuni cnocoBcTByeT TaKKe y4eT NpasonpHMe- huTenbHo npaxrin Esponelicxoro cyaa no npasaw venosera. — B swnape sroro roa norynuna 8 chny YerBepTan Wacts Fraxnanexoro KoneKca. Npaxtaxa ap6urpax bm cyROB YxKe yortena SacbuKcMpoBaTb KaKMe-NM6O inpoGnemei, cenaanibie € MpHMeHeHMet HOEOrO SaKO- woneTensorsa? — Yepasnenve avannaa v o606weHus mpaxtann BAC PO Toros Flocravosnenue Mnexyiva no sonpocan NPHME- fhowus vorbepTon 4acTa TK PO. Speck HaitnyT oTpaKe- tore Kax BONpOCH!, CBRAHLIE C BBTENMEM B AMICTEHE Inakworo saxoKa, Tak HexoTopHIe MPOGNeMUs!, KOTOPLIE Guinn puineneHbi Hg GANpocoe OTAENSHEIX CYAOB, PASPE- 10 alow eypesrte nope © MpmveneHneM YRAseHHOl, vacru TK PO. = Oxnnaeren nm p Grinxaiiusee spemn MocraHos- neue Mnexyma BAC, noceaujennoe pewleHMlo BO” Mpocos, CBAZAHHDIX ¢ COMOBONEHBIM CTPOMTENECT- Bom? — Martie paspewiena cnopos, caRsahHbix ¢ CaMO- BONBHLIM CTpoMTeRteTeoM, nocsAUIeH cooTBETCTBYO- uni O6a0p, Koropetli chaxTu4ecks noproTosneH W OY- net pueces Ha obcyxneKne Mpesunnyma BAC PO & Gnwoxainwee epenie, XoTesIoce Gut BLIgENMT> sAecb MO Kpaliveli Mope Ba MoMeHTa: BoNPOCE! TONKOBAMME! CT. 222 TK Po 6 yueTOM HaMaHeHHit, BHECeHHEIX B Hee SO ion 2008 r., & HaCTHOCTH # WMeIO B BMA BONPOC O nnpase aperaatopa SeMerisioro yuacTka Wa NpMSHAHMS papa coScTeeHHocTn Ha caMoEonbHy'o nocTPOMKy. KpoMe Toro, BaxHibim OcTaeToR TONKOBAHME NonOeHHE 10 Tott, 470 npago cobcTBEHHOCTH Ha CaMOBONbHY'O NO- crpofiky He MOMET OLiTE MpMsHaHO 2a TMYOM, ECNH CO xpaniohve NocTpovkn Hepywaet npasa M OxpaHAeNBO ‘aKoHoM MiTepecb! APYTIK MIA, MAO CosAaET YTPOSY >xnsHH W SROpOBLIO Taxa. SHANI MM 9TO, TO CANO ponbian MocTpoiixa npm OToyTCTaHM yKAsaHHE O6CTO- srenber® MOXer ObiTb MpHsHaHa COOCTRHHOCTHIO 32 euvenn? A nonaraio, TO MeT, NOCKOMLKY CYA HE MO~ FYT aahowinri vcronHiTenbHble oprakbl 8 BbiRave Pas pewonn, sbineneHMil, cormacceaxnn, coBepuieHHl box ARMAHCTPATHBHENX EKTOB. — Beinn nn enysian, Kora Bb murano He cornausanitce nosuusel Tpoiikn cyael, oTKasaewel & nepenaHe lena va paccmorpenme e Mpesmanym BAC? — Berio @ Tom, 70 8, K caxaneHino, caHIeCKH He Croco Gen sHaKOMITLcA © GrKaaHLe onpenencHiaan. B BAGH ‘© paboroii Tpoek cyAei xCTenoce Get OTMETHTE Ove BAX: iit momenT. K coxaneHio, B Fpeaupyst BAC Po ann epecwoTpa ® RopagKe Hansopa NepenaioTor, Kak MPABM: ‘no, eyeSHbIe AKTeI, © KOTOPEIN cYBbA HE COTnaceH. Mae xaxeren, S70 repegasan. 6 MIpeanyyn HyxHO AE ‘na, ® KOTOPLEX HARHL|O OTeyTCTANe efHOOSPAsisr NpaK- "rik ro KaKMNE-THGS SoNpOTEH, He FoNNIASACS, Kora Gyner OSKaNOBATECA AIK, c KOTOPENA CyBisA HE COMA ‘coi. OXURaTe OOMANOEAMIR TaKOFO aKTA MOXHO MCA yen, 28 9T0 eats 6yReT AOnyuypHO SoMkALDS KOHN crmo OYAESHLK OUMEOK, KoTODLE MKD GbINO Gt! YT pentVINTEPBbIO HOMEPA so 0 Bo. saber amo In 6y- —Aomxen nv peiiersyiouptii cyaba axrHBHo yuacTBO- bare & OSWeCTBEHHOM musHM? PoNb HET o HneHCTEE 8 O6uleCTBEHHEIX OSBEAMHEHHAK H T.A. 51 cunrato, 470 NOMUETYKO! Mil 3aHMMATECA HO AOTAHEI Boe nible BMA NeATENLHOCTH CYA ROMXHEA ObmT> CBA Bait © nporheccveli. OTo MOKET 6biTE nperionacatent- kas WM GHaroTeopuTentHas AesTansHocT:. A npeno- ‘hao & Poccuiicxof axanemnn rocymapcreennolt cryxGek ‘pa Npeannerme PO. —B vem, na Bau earns, OcHOBHBIe HeAOCTATKH Npo- cbeccnoransnenx topnamecwx nsnaHnit? — Henocraran, x coxanenio, He B Hux, 2 BO Mie. ¥ MeHs, K COXaneHIIO, HET BOSMOXHOCTH aHaKOMMTECA co Belt nepwonwKoi. Ecnm # saviMaiocs KaKMN-TO KOHKPeTHLIM BONpOCOM, f, KOHEYHO, ero Hayuarc. Ho a BCe OcTAaNbHOe MpocTo He xBaraeT spemern. Mo- 2TOMY HAKEKHX MPeTeHOHil K xKYpHANAM Y MOA HOT, TonkKo k e960. Yraaom Mpeonnenta Pocchs or 27.05.2008 Ne 856 2a aacnyrn b ykpennennn saKoHHOCTH, aauprTe npae W 2aKOKHBIX MHTepeco® rpaxsaH M MHOrONeTHIOI NNOFOTBOPHYIO pacoTy BJT. Cnecapes Gein narpaxnen opneviou Novera. PepaKyn kypiana «3AKOH» cepaeuo nosapaenser Bagumupa jILeonm4a ¢ Marpaxqlennen sbicoKoi rocynapcTBennoli Harpanoi!