Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sliding On The Surface of A Rough Sphere
Sliding On The Surface of A Rough Sphere
of a Rough Sphere
Carl E. Mungan, U.S. Naval Academy, Annapolis, MD
A
well-known textbook problem treats the mo-
tion of a particle sliding frictionlessly on the
surface of a sphere. An interesting variation
is to consider what happens when kinetic friction is
present.1 This problem can be solved exactly.
A free-body diagram is sketched in Fig. 1 and de-
fines many of the relevant variables. The radial com-
ponent of Newton’s second law is
sphere.6 The final solution therefore becomes Subsequently the particle leaves the surface at angle
= 69.6 with a dimensionless speed of V = 0.59,
(2 – 42)(e 2 – cos ) – 6 sin
V 2 = + V 02 e 2. plotted as curve 4 in Fig. 2.
1 + 42
(A3)
References
Appendix B: Approaching the Equator 1. H. Sarafian, “How far down can you slide on a rough
ball?” AAPT Announcer 31, 113 (Winter 2001). Sarafi-
Setting V = 0 at = /2, Eq. (A3) can be solved for an has analyzed this problem using Mathematica for a
special issue of the Journal of Symbolic Computation to
V02 to obtain be published in late fall of 2003.
42 – 2 + 6e- 2. Many introductory textbooks now include an overview
V02 = . (B1) of Euler’s method of numerical integration in a spread-
1 + 42
sheet such as Excel. For example, see P.A. Tipler and G.
(In order for this to be positive, must be larger Mosca, Physics for Scientists and Engineers, 5th ed. (Free-
than approximately 0.6034.) Substitute this back man, New York, 2003), Sec. 5-4.
into Eq. (A3) and put = /2 – to obtain 3. For many values of and V0, there are two mathemati-
cal solutions of for which V = 0. Only the smaller so-
lution has physical significance for 0 = 0.
(42 – 2) sin + 6(e- – cos ) 4. Integrating factors are discussed in standard differential
V 2 = . (B2) equation texts, such as D.G. Zill and M.R. Cullen, Dif-
1 + 42
ferential Equations with Boundary-Value Problems, 3rd
By design, this is zero at = 0. However, it equals ed. (PWS-Kent, Boston, 1993), Sec. 2.5.
(3 – 2) when it is expanded to second order in 5. Students who have taken an introductory course in dif-
ferential equations will recognize Eq. (A1) as a particu-
, i.e., V 2 is negative when is infinitesimally small.
lar solution and Eq. (A2) as the complementary solu-
This means the particle cannot reach the equator: It tion of the homogeneous equation corresponding to
must stop at some smaller angle.3 Eq. (5). If even this alternative approach (without the
But how close to the equator can one get? In order technical terminology) is too advanced, students could
to maximize the final angle , we want d/d(V 2) → 0 still be challenged to verify that Eq. (A3) satisfies both
at V = 0. Consequently → according to Eq. (5). Eq. (5) and the initial conditions.
In this limit, Eq. (B2) becomes 6. Another reasonable choice of initial conditions has been
adopted in W. Herreman and H. Pottel, “Problem: The
3 sliding of a mass down the surface of a solid sphere,”
V 2 = sin – cos . (B3) Am. J. Phys. 56, 351 (April 1988).
2
PACS codes: 46.02C, 46.30P
Therefore, the object comes to rest near /2 – Carl E. Mungan is an assistant professor and coordinates
1.5/. For example, curve 5 shows what happens the classical mechanics course at the Naval Academy. His
when = 100. The particle actually stops at 89.2°, current research interests are in organic LEDs and solid-
state laser cooling.
in good agreement with this prediction.
Physics Department, U.S. Naval Academy, Annapolis,
This is an unrealistically large value for . The fi- MD 21402-5026; mungan@usna.edu