Professional Documents
Culture Documents
If you have any comments to make about this, or any of our other titles, please send them to
educationenquiries@hodder.co.uk
Copyright © 2012 Maureen Smith, Teena Kamen, Jo Irvine, Mary Armitage, Corinne Barker
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical,
including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher or under
licence from the Copyright Licensing Agency Limited. Further details of such licences (for reprographic reproduction) may be obtained from
the Copyright Licensing Agency Limited, of Saffron House, 6-10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS.
Hachette UK’s policy is to use papers that are natural, renewable and recyclable products and made from wood grown in sustainable forests.
The logging and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin.
Acknowledgementsiv
2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2) 55
6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6) 188
9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9) 283
10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10) 301
12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13) 379
13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14) 415
Index457
Additional free material on the web at www.hoddereducation.co.uk/cache covering unit CP 18:
Supporting science and technology development in children and/or young people
Acknowledgements
I would like to thank my colleagues at Wakefield College for their support and encouragement. Thanks also
to the early years students who continue to inspire me. Special thanks to my dear friend Sue Smith who has
helped to keep me organised over the years.
Corinne Barker
Photo credits:
All photos © Andrew Callaghan, except:
Figures: 1.17 © Zakharov Evgeniy – Fotolia; 1.18a–h © Photographs by John Oates, from http://www.open.
edu/openlearn/body-mind/childhood-youth/early-years/attachment-parents © The Open University 2012;
3.2 © Carolyn A Mckeone/Science Photo Library; 3.4 © Jaren Wicklund – Fotolia; 3.5 © Dr. P. Marazzi/
Science Photo Library; 3.6 © Dr. P. Marazzi/Science Photo Library; 3.7 © CDC/Science Photo Library; 5.4
© ruzaimy – Fotolia; 5.13 © auremar – Fotolia; 6.1 © Monkey Business – Fotolia; 6.8 © Warrick Page/Getty
Images for UNICEF; 10.3 © Georgios Kollidas – Fotolia; 10.4 © The Granger Collection, NYC/TopFoto;
11.2 © Monkey Business – Fotolia; 11.4 © Roger Bamber/Alamy; 11.6 © MBI/Alamy; 11.9 © Julie Voigt/
ArtForSmallHands.com; 11.10 © bobo/Alamy; 11.12 © Visions of America, LLC/Alamy; 11.15 © Heini
Kettunen/Alamy; 12.9 © Jeff Gilbert/Alamy; 12.10 © Frank Baron/The Guardian; 12.11 © Monkey Business –
Fotolia; 13.5 © Photofusion Picture Library/Alamy; 13.9 © Losevsky Pavel/Alamy; 13.12 © Sally and Richard
Greenhill/Alamy.
Illustrations by Barking Dog Art (Figures 2.1, 3.3, 5.1, 5.2, 8.1, 8.2).
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v1.0.
Section 1
Mandatory units
The aim of this chapter is to increase awareness of childhood development and this presents one of the
theories and their benefit to children and young challenges in putting these theories into practice.
people’s care or development.
Behaviourist theories
Learning outcomes Behaviourist theories (or behaviourism) are based
1. Know the role of theories in informing on the assumption that learning occurs through
practice when working with children interactions with the environment and that all
and/or young people. behaviours are acquired through a person’s
interaction with their environment. Behaviourists
2. Be able to apply theories to
workplace practice. believe that internal thoughts and motivations
cannot be used to explain behaviour. Instead, they
3. Understand the relevance of
suggest that we should look only at the external,
identified theories in relation to own
observable causes of human behaviour, rather than
workplace practice and personal
development. thoughts and feelings, which cannot be observed.
2
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
The conditioned The conditioned stimulus is a previously In the earlier example, suppose that
stimulus neutral stimulus that, after becoming when you smelled your favourite food,
associated with the unconditioned stimulus, you also heard the sound of a whistle.
eventually comes to trigger a conditioned While the whistle is unrelated to the smell
response. of the food, if the sound of the whistle
was paired multiple times with the smell,
the sound would eventually trigger the
conditioned response. In this case, the
sound of the whistle is the conditioned
stimulus.
The conditioned The conditioned response is the learned In this example, the conditioned response
response response to the previously neutral stimulus. would be feeling hungry when you heard
the sound of the whistle.
ity
Research Activ
Activity
1. Find out more about the ‘Little Albert’ experiment.
A fun experiment in classical conditioning is For example, take a look at: http://psychology.
available to do at: www.simplypsychology.org/ about.com/od/classicpsychologystudies/a/little-
classical%20conditioning.swf. albert-experiment.htm.
Summarise your findings about classical 2. Share your findings with a group of students or
conditioning and share them with the group. colleagues.
3
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Figure 1.1 The ‘Little Albert’ experiment (Watson, from Swenson, 1980)
controlled by food rewards. One of Skinner’s best- reinforced with a reward. Skinner believed that
known inventions is the ‘operant conditioning positive reinforcement (rewards) and negative
chamber’ (the Skinner box). Skinner showed how reinforcement (sanctions) both contribute towards an
positive reinforcement worked by placing a hungry rat individual’s motivation for learning and behaviour.
in the box, which contained a lever in the side As the Skinner applied his findings about animals to
rat moved about the box, it would accidentally knock human behaviour and developed teaching machines
the lever; as soon as it did so, a food pellet would that enabled students to learn step by step, revealing
drop into a container next to the lever. The rat quickly answers for immediate feedback (reward).
learned to go straight to the lever after being put in
the box a few times – the consequence of receiving Activity
food if it pressed the lever ensured that the rat would
repeat the action again and again (McLeod 2007a) In your own words, explain the difference between
classical conditioning and operant conditioning.
This experiment demonstrates Skinner’s idea of
operant conditioning. Unlike Pavlov’s classical
conditioning, where an existing behaviour Some of the key concepts in operant conditioning
(salivating for food) is shaped by associating it with involve the use of reinforcement and punishment.
a new stimulus (ringing of a bell or a metronome), Reinforcement is used to increase appropriate or desired
operant conditioning is the rewarding of an act that behaviour. Reinforcement takes place when something
approaches a new desired behaviour. the child likes (such as a smiley face or sticker) is
offered to them to increase the frequency of the desired
This idea of operant conditioning can be applied behaviour (e.g. sitting still during assembly or story
to any situation where the required behaviour is time). When the desired behaviour is demonstrated by
4
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Speaker
Pellet
dispenser Signal
lights
Lever
Dispenser
tube
To shock
generator
Food cup Electric grid
Figure 1.2 The operant conditioning chamber (the Skinner box, http://www.simplypsychology.org/operant-conditioning.html)
5
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Reinforcement Punishment
Reinforcement is any event that strengthens or Punishment is the presentation of an adverse event
increases the behaviour it follows. There are two or outcome that causes a decrease in the behaviour
kinds of reinforcement. it follows. There are two kinds of punishment.
1. Positive reinforcement is a favourable event 1. Positive punishment (sometimes referred
or outcome that is presented after the behaviour. to as punishment by application) involves the
In situations that reflect positive reinforcement, a presentation of an unfavourable event or outcome
response or behaviour is strengthened by the addition in order to weaken the response it follows.
of something, such as praise or a direct reward.
2. Negative reinforcement involves the removal of 2. Negative punishment (also known as
an unfavourable event or outcome after the display punishment by removal) occurs when a favourable
of a particular behaviour. In these situations, event or outcome is removed after a particular
a response is strengthened by the removal of behaviour occurs.
something considered unpleasant.
In both of these cases of reinforcement, the behaviour In both of these cases of punishment, the behaviour
increases. decreases.
Table 1.2 Some key concepts in operant conditioning
Skinner outlined earlier. He thought that children Bandura concluded that all the children had learnt
learned through conditioning and reinforcement but the aggressive behaviour but that what they went on
also by observing and imitating. Bandura thought to do was influenced by what happened to the adult.
that children acquired many skills and behaviours
simply by watching and listening to others around There are many criticisms of this type of artificial
them. However, children mainly copy (model) the experiment and it is difficult to be certain how far
behaviours and skills of those who are important to Bandura’s findings would be true in a more natural
them – that is, people who: situation. However, there are possible implications for
how we work with children from the Bobo doll study.
●● they like and respect We know children will imitate aggressive behaviour so
●● have high status we want to minimise the amount of aggression they
●● are similar to them (e.g. same sex, around same age)
are exposed to. Dealing with aggressive behaviour
●● have desirable possessions or characteristics.
firmly and consistently so that children see there are
For many children, the practitioners who work with negative outcomes may lead to reduced imitation of the
them fall into some of these categories so they will behaviour. Sometimes, if the situation is not dangerous,
model your behaviour. ignoring aggressive behaviour and withholding
attention are sufficient to discourage copying.
Bandura also looked at how children learn aggressive
behaviour. In 1973, he conducted the Bobo doll
study. Three groups of nursery school children watch How behaviourist theories support
a short film with different endings. Each child sees meeting the needs of children
an adult punching a plastic doll. In one film, the Behaviourist theories can be useful in meeting
children see the adult rewarded, in the second the some aspects of children’s needs, especially helping
adult is punished and in the third there is no reward children to demonstrate appropriate behaviour – for
or punishment. After the film, the children are given example, using positive/negative reinforcement and
an opportunity to play with the doll. The children positive/negative punishment.
who had seen the adult rewarded and the children
who had not seen any consequences were equally Positive reinforcement occurs when a reward is
aggressive to the doll. The group who had seen the given after the child demonstrates appropriate
adult punished were less likely to be aggressive. behaviour, which then increases the frequency
6
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Tom Jennings
Merit Book
Figure 1.3 Positive reinforcement occurs when a reward is given after the child demonstrates appropriate behaviour, which
then increases the frequency of that behaviour
of that behaviour. For example, Tom is finding it punishment has occurred because the instructor is
difficult to finish his homework. As Tom is interested trying to decrease the frequency of the undesired
in video games, his mother makes an agreement behaviour through the presence of the punishment.
with him that he can earn stars for every homework
task he completes on time; she will then exchange Negative punishment occurs when something
the stars for cash so that Tom can purchase video desirable is removed after the occurrence of
games or accessories. Tom now regularly completes inappropriate behaviour. The most common form
his homework on time; positive reinforcement has of negative punishment is the removal of privileges
occurred because the frequency of the appropriate and can be effective in reducing unwanted behaviour
behaviour increased due to the reward (reinforcer). in the short term. For example, Tamika constantly
chats to her friends during class, despite frequent
Negative reinforcement occurs when something the reminders by the teacher to stop. The teacher does
child dislikes is removed after the child demonstrates not allow Tamika to go out to play with her friends
the appropriate behaviour. For example, Sarah rarely at break time; negative punishment has occurred
completes her class work, even though she is capable because the teacher is trying to decrease the
of doing the work. The teacher stands near Sarah undesirable behaviour by removing a desired event.
and keeps verbally prompting her to get on with her
work. However, Sarah does not like the teacher’s The impact of the behaviourist
frequent prompts and so she gets on with her work.
The teacher walks away and leaves Sarah to get on theories on practice
with her work. Sarah continues to finish her work Of course, in reality, people do not respond exactly
to avoid further prompts from the teacher; negative like Pavlov’s dogs. However, there are many ways
reinforcement has occurred because the frequency in which classical conditioning can be applied to
of the appropriate behaviour increased due to the work with children and young people. For example,
removal of the unwanted prompts. classical conditioning techniques are useful in
the treatment of phobias or anxiety problems as
Positive punishment occurs when something practitioners are able to apply classical conditioning
undesirable is introduced to the child to reduce in the setting by creating a positive environment to
the occurrence of an inappropriate behaviour. For help children overcome anxiety or fear. Pairing an
example, Denzel is playing about and not listening to anxiety-provoking situation, such as performing in
the instructor during sports practice. The instructor front of a group, with pleasant surroundings helps
tells Denzel to take a ‘time out’ on the bench; positive the child learn new positive associations. Instead
7
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
of feeling anxious and tense in these situations, the the next step; in addition, the sequencing of the steps
child will learn to stay relaxed and calm. is critical. More recently, research into Skinner’s work
in this area has led to breakthroughs in teaching
The work of Watson and others set the stage for children to communicate more effectively, especially
behaviourist theories, which soon rose to dominate those with autistic spectrum disorders.
the field of psychology. While behaviourist theories
became less popular after 1950, many of the concepts ity
and principles are still widely used today. Conditioning Research Activ
and behaviour modification are still widely used in 1. Select an article about behavioural theory – for
therapy and behavioural training to help children example, an article from a psychology/childcare
change problematic behaviours and develop new skills. magazine, journal or website. (See ‘Useful
resources’ at the end of this chapter.)
Operant conditioning, Skinner’s most widely
acclaimed work, is based on a system of both positive 2. Explore the relationship between this article and a
recent news story relating to children’s behaviour
and negative reinforcement. Children, parents and and learning.
practitioners all benefit when positive reinforcement
3. Evaluate the connection to your own life, personal
techniques are used to guide children’s behaviours,
interests and your practice when working with
making for a more pleasant and respectfully run children/young people.
setting. Even babies and very young children
respond well to a system where rewards exist,
repeating behaviours when they bring big smiles
and hugs from a caring adult. Using positive
Psychoanalytic theories
reinforcement to encourage appropriate behaviour Psychoanalytic theories originated with the work
can help practitioners to encourage children’s of Sigmund Freud. Through his clinical work
continued cooperation. Computer-based self- with patients suffering from mental illness, Freud
instruction programmes use many of the principles believed that very early childhood experiences and
of Skinner’s techniques. Effective teaching requires unconscious desires influenced behaviour. Based on
learners to respond to new information and receive his observations, he developed a theory that described
feedback on their performance before advancing to development in terms of a series of psychosexual
8
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Dear:............................................................
You have used your:
Listening Skills........................
Speaking Skills........................
Thinking Skills.........................
Looking Skills...........................
Concentrating Skills...............
And we are really happy that you are
trying so hard.
Figure 1.4 Effective teaching requires learners to respond to new information and receive feedback on their
performance before advancing to the next step (image based on the 5 Skills Notelet Pads from the Five Skills Series –
Jenny Mosley Consultancies www.circle-time.co.uk. Call 01225 719204 for a free catalogue)
stages (see Table 1.4). According to Freud, conflicts psychosexual stages are completed successfully, the
that occur during each of these stages can have a result is a healthy personality. If certain issues are
lifelong influence on personality and behaviour. not resolved at the appropriate stage, fixation can
occur. Until this conflict is resolved, the individual
Sigmund Freud (1856–1939) will remain ‘stuck’ in this stage.
The Austrian physician Sigmund Freud believed that
very early childhood experiences are responsible for Key term
how people think and feel in later life. Depending on
Fixation – a persistent focus on an earlier
these experiences, people are either well or poorly psychosexual stage.
adjusted to their everyday lives. Freud considered
that most of our thinking is done on a subconscious
level and is therefore beyond our control. Criticism of Freud’s theory of
Freud’s theory of psychosexual development is psychosexual development
one of the best known, but also one of the most Freud’s psychosexual stage theory is controversial
controversial. Freud believed that personality as it is based mostly on male psychosexual
develops through a series of childhood stages during development and has very little about female
which the desire for sexual pleasure would focus in psychosexual development. Freud’s theory is based
turn on different areas of the body. on the recollections of his adult patients, rather
than the actual observation and study of children
This psychosexual energy was described as over a period of time. In addition, basing current
the driving force behind behaviour. If these adult behaviour on a specific childhood experience
9
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
is very vague as the length of time between cause inspired her to write The Development of a Child.
and effect is too long – other factors may have Through Klein’s work, the technique known as
contributed to the adult behaviour. play therapy emerged and is still used extensively
today in psychotherapy. With Klein’s technique,
Activity instead of lying on a couch and free associating,
the child had a simple playroom with a collection
Find out more about Freud’s theories. A great of their own small toys, as well as play materials
starting point is www.all-about-psychology.com/ like paper, crayons, strings, a ball, cups and a sink
sigmund-freud.html, which includes an interesting with taps, which provided maximum opportunities
video about Freud. for the child’s own imagination to be expressed.
The adult also used simple and age-appropriate
language when interacting with the child,
Melanie Klein (1982–1960) including using role play where the child acts as
Klein met Sigmund Freud at the 1918 International a strict teacher and the adult is the naughty child
Psycho-Analytic Congress in Budapest, which (Anderson 2008).
10
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
11
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
psychological needs, not just their physical needs, ●● engaging with and providing focused attention to
by providing a caring, nurturing and appropriately individual children
challenging environment. ●● treating children with respect and consideration as
individual people in their own right
As a practitioner, you should encourage children’s
●● demonstrating understanding of their feelings and
self-reliance, self-esteem and resilience by:
points of view
12
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
FPO
13
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
14
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Humanistic theories needs are satisfied, then the need for self-
actualisation is activated. Maslow describes self-
During the 1950s, humanistic theories of actualisation as a person’s need to be and do that
psychology began as a reaction against which the person was ‘born to do’. ‘A musician
behaviourist and psychoanalytic theories, which must make music, an artist must paint, and a poet
dominated psychology at the time. Behaviourist must write’ (Simons et al. 1987).
theories study the conditioning processes that
Children’s needs
produce a person’s behaviour, while psychoanalytic
theories concentrate on understanding the Every child has these basic needs (PRICELESS):
unconscious motivations that drive a person’s ●● Physical care: regular, nutritious meals; warmth;
behaviour. Humanistic thinkers view these rest and sleep.
theories as failing to take account of personal ●● Routines: a regular pattern to the day; clear
choice. Humanistic theories focus on each explanations for any changes.
individual’s potential and stress the importance of ●● Independence: encouragement to do things for
growth and self-actualisation. themselves and make choices.
15
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Self-
actualisation
needs
Esteem needs
Belonging needs
Safety needs
Physiological needs
16
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
developed in early childhood and were formed main determinant of whether we will become
from the interaction of the child with the mother self-actualised is childhood experience. A person’s
and father. ideal self may not be consistent with what actually
2 Self-image – how we see ourselves, which happens in the life and experiences of the person.
is important to good psychological health. Hence, a difference may exist between a person’s
Self-image includes the influence of our body ideal self and actual experience. This is called
image on inner personality. At a simple level, incongruence (McLeod 2007b)
we might perceive ourselves as a good or bad
person, beautiful or ugly. Self-image has an
effect on how a person thinks, feels and behaves Key term
in the world.
Congruence – where a person’s ideal self and actual
3 Ideal self – this is the person who we would like experience are consistent or very similar.
to be. It consists of our goals and ambitions in life
Incongruence – the difference between a person’s ideal
and is dynamic (i.e. forever changing). The ideal self and actual experience.
self in childhood is not the ideal self in our teens
Self-actualisation – when we feel, experience and
or late twenties, etc. behave in ways which are consistent with our self-image
(McLeod 2007b) and which reflect what we would like to be like, our
ideal self.
Rogers believed that people are inherently good and
creative. They become destructive only when a poor
self-concept or external constraints override the
valuing process. Rogers believed that for a person Activity
to achieve self-actualisation they must be in a state
of congruence. This means that self-actualisation Find out more about Carl Roger’s views on
occurs when a person’s ideal self (who they would psychology – for example, his ideas about self-
like to be) is consistent with their actual behaviour actualisation. You could start by looking at: http://
(self-image). Rogers describes an individual who www.nrogers.com/carlrogersbio.html.
is actualising as a fully functioning person. The
Incongruent Congruent
The self-image is different from the ideal self. The self-image is similar to the ideal self.
17
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Mia Kellmer Pringle (1921–1983) same rights. Children’s rights are based on their needs,
but emphasising rights rather than needs demonstrates
Mia Kellmer Pringle (founder and first director
a commitment to viewing and respecting children as
of the National Children’s Bureau) laid the
valued citizens (The Children’s Rights Alliance for
foundations for the current focus on prevention
England: www.crae.org.uk).
and early intervention and on the importance
of the first five years of life and the role of Every child has individual needs as a special and
parents. Mia always saw children ‘in the round’. unique individual. Each child perceives the world
Mia’s personal childhood experience and her differently and interacts with other people in
training and work as a psychologist led to her different ways. Each child views the world in an
definitive book The Needs of Children, first individual way due to different life experiences.
published in 1975. Her book draws on the work Every child experiences different social and
of John Bowlby and Donald Winnicott, as well environmental factors, which, together with genetic
as her own clinical practice. Mia’s themes in differences, help to create a unique combination of
this book are the importance of: the early years personality, knowledge and skills.
of life to later development; the environment
in which children grow; and children’s social As an individual, each child belongs to various social
and emotional needs, as well as their physical groups – that is, their family, local community, school
needs. Failure to meet these needs has long-term and wider society. When working with children,
consequences. Parents have a key role in meeting you must appreciate the uniqueness of every child,
their children’s needs, and parenting should be while ensuring that the needs of both the individual
better supported and taken more seriously. (Pugh and the group are met (Brennan 1987). How each
2006) child reacts to the learning environment depends on
individual needs and life experiences. Some children
see the learning environment as an exciting challenge
Activity and are well motivated to learn. Some children find
the learning environment extremely daunting and
Find out more about Mia Kellmer Pringle’s views
on psychology – for example, her ideas about may experience learning difficulties. Some children
children’s needs. You could start by looking at: see the learning environment as boring or uninviting
www.nurseryworld.co.uk/news/716362/Putting- and may demonstrate signs of difficult behaviour.
children-first/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH.
Every child has social and emotional needs that
should be met by the setting through:
How humanistic theories support ●● assistance in adjusting to new learning
environments
meeting the needs of children ●● help in relating comfortably with other children
In the past decade, there has been a major shift
and adults
in attitudes towards children’s rights. In the past, ●● opportunities to interact and play with other children
children’s rights were mainly concerned with children’s ●● opportunities to find out about people and the
basic welfare needs. Now, as well as their basic rights
world they live in.
to life, health and education, children are viewed
as having a much wider range of rights, including Every child also has individual educational needs,
the right to engage in play activities, to express their requiring:
views and to participate in making decisions that ●● opportunities to explore the environment
affect them directly. Children’s rights, as stated in the ●● adult assistance to aid knowledge and
UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, are clear understanding
and universal: they apply to all children. Also, while ●● activities that are appropriate to individual abilities
children’s individual needs may differ, they all have the and development.
18
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Some children may have special or additional needs, needs to ensure that the needs of all children can
requiring: be met in an inclusive way. You may work as part
of the special educational needs team and your role
●● special equipment or resources
may involve supporting children identified as having
●● modified surroundings, e.g. wheelchair access,
special educational needs, including those with
ramps
●● extra learning support to access the national
individual education plans (IEPs) and/or statements
of special educational needs.
curriculum
●● a special or modified curriculum.
Carl Rogers viewed children as having two basic
About one in five children have special educational needs: positive regard from other people and
needs and the majority of these children are educated self-worth. Rogers believed that people need to be
in mainstream settings. Children with special regarded positively by others – we all need to feel
educational needs have additional needs arising valued, respected, treated with affection and loved.
from a physical disability, a learning difficulty or an Positive regard is to do with how other people
emotional or behavioural problem. Children with evaluate and judge us in social interaction. Rogers
special educational needs may require learning believed feelings of self-worth developed in early
support to enable them to access the curriculum. One childhood and were formed from the interaction
of the responsibilities of the practitioner may be to of the child with the mother and father. As a child
provide intensive learning support for an individual grows older, interactions with significant others
or small group of children with special educational will affect feelings of self-worth. (McLeod 2007b)
Figure 1.9 Meeting children’s needs: My World Triangle (source: Scottish Government, www.scotland.gov.uk)
19
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
growing interesting in positive psychology. With think it can be performed well merely because we
his emphasis on human potential, Carl Rogers had have all been children.
an enormous influence on both psychology and ●● The school curriculum should include human
education. Rogers agreed with most of what Maslow psychology, child development and preparation for
believed, but added that for a person to ‘grow’, parenthood.
20
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Figure 1.10 Children are our future, and their upbringing and
care is a skilled, responsible and demanding job
21
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
development as part of the social process of ability to think and learn. Cognitive development
childhood. Age is not the critical factor in intellectual occurs in four set stages, which are universal –
development; assisted learning can and does occur they apply to all forms of learning and across all
at any age. The key factor is the learner’s existing cultures (see Table 1.7).
knowledge and/or experience in connection with the
current problem or learning situation. Piaget viewed children as thinking and learning in a
different way from adults. Not only do children have
less experience of the world, but their understanding
Jean Piaget (1896–1980) of it is shaped by this entirely different way of
A Swiss biologist, Jean Piaget used observations of looking at their environment. Children will only
his own children, plus a wider sample of children, learn when they are ‘ready’ for different experiences
to develop his theories of cognitive development. as determined by their current stage of cognitive
Piaget’s theories of cognitive development have development.
had a major influence on early education for more Piaget did not see language and communication
than 40 years. Piaget believed that children went as central to children’s cognitive development
through different stages of cognitive development because this development begins at birth, before
based on fixed ages. Within these stages, the children can comprehend or use words. Young
children’s patterns of learning, or schemas as children’s use of language demonstrates their
he called them, were very different from adult cognitive achievements, but does not control
ways of problem-solving. He also believed in the them. He does see the importance of language at
importance of young children learning through later stages. Young children are egocentric. They
action and exploration of their environment using are unable to see or understand another person’s
their sensory motor skills. According to Piaget, viewpoint. This also means they are unable to
children are actively involved in structuring their convey information accurately or effectively to
own cognitive development through exploration others.
of their environment. Children need real objects
and ‘concrete experiences’ to discover things Piaget believed that children interact with their
for themselves. The adult’s role is to provide environment to actively construct their knowledge
children with appropriate experiences in a suitable and understanding of the world. They do this by
environment to facilitate the children’s instinctive relating new information to existing information.
22
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Piaget called this interaction: assimilation (the four-year-olds to use logical thinking and to
need for further information); accommodation (the understand concepts such as the conservation of
need for organised information); and adaptation number, volume and weight. For example, the number
(the need for revised/updated information). conservation task, which involves two identical rows of
All new information has to be built on existing objects where young children agree that there are the
information; there needs to be some connection same number in each row until the adult moves the
between them. Similar information can be stored objects in one of the rows so that it is longer than the
as it relates to existing information. Discrepant other row – although the number of objects remains
information cannot be stored because it is not the same, young children will say the longer row has
related to existing information. Piaget described more objects (see Figure 1.12). However, when this
internal mental processes as schemas and the task is done using a ‘naughty’ teddy bear to upset the
ways in which they are used when thinking as arrangement of the objects, then young children can
operations. Mental processes or schemas do state that the number of objects remains the same. The
not remain static; they continually develop as task has to make sense to the young child and the adult
we acquire new information and extend our needs to use language that the child can understand.
understanding of the world.
Donaldson also challenged Piaget’s claim that
Research by people such as Margaret Donaldson
children under seven years old are highly egocentric
suggests Piaget underestimated young children’s
– that is, they cannot see things from another
cognitive abilities – the use of appropriate language
person’s point of view. Piaget’s evidence for this
within a meaningful context enables three- and
claim included the ‘mountains’ task, in which young
ASSIMILATION
eyes
sights
ears sensory
sounds some information
nose receptors
smells not noticed or
tongue receive
tastes is ignored
fingers information
textures
skin, etc.
information
transmitted
to the brain
ACCOMMODATION
working memory
discrepant
accesses/retrieves existing
information
information (or schemas)
not registered
from long-term memory
similar
information
registered
ADAPTATION
new, revised information
stored in long-term memory
and can now be accessed as
part of existing information
(or schemas)
23
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Doll’s view
Child’s view
children had to indicate what a doll would see but Policeman Boy
instead would state their own view of the situation
(see Figure 1.13). Piaget described this as egocentric
illusion.
24
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
25
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
longer required. Vygotsky used the idea of the zone of Jerome S. Bruner (1915–)
proximal development, or area of next development, to
The American psychologist Jerome S. Bruner
describe this framework of support for learning (Tharp
emphasises the importance of the adult in
and Gallimore 1991). Children can be in different
supporting children’s thinking and learning. Bruner
zones for different skills or tasks. Each activity has its
uses the term scaffolding to describe this adult
own zone of proximal development (see Figure 1.15).
support. Picture a builder using scaffolding to
The zone of proximal development can be support a house while it is being built. Without the
represented in four stages. For example, children scaffold, the house could not be built, but once the
learning to read may progress in this way: house is finished, the scaffolding can be removed.
The adult supports the child’s learning until they
●● Stage 1: learning phonics, decoding and
are ready to stand alone. Bruner also emphasises the
comprehension skills with assistance of
adult’s skills of recognising where and when this
childcarers, parents, teachers, teaching assistants
support is needed and when it should be removed.
(assistance from others).
●● Stage 2: sounding out difficult/unfamiliar words,
The structuring of children’s learning should be
flexible; the adult support or scaffold should not be
reading aloud to self, lips moving during silent
rigid; it needs to change as the needs of the child
reading, etc. (self-help).
●● Stage 3: reading competently using internal
change – that is, as the child gains knowledge and
understanding and/or acquires new skills.
prompts (auto-pilot).
●● Stage 4: new words, complicated texts, learning to
The adult supports children’s learning and
read in a different language, etc. require further development by:
assistance (relapses to previous steps).
●● providing learning experiences within a
meaningful context
Activity ●● adapting tasks and learning experiences
●● selecting appropriate materials for each child’s
Draw your own diagram showing how the zone of
needs and abilities
proximal development could apply to:
●● encouraging children to make choices about what
• your own learning (e.g. learning to cook or they want to do and when.
learning to drive)
• a child’s learning (e.g. learning to write or learning Bruner believed that any subject can be taught to
a new mathematical skill). any child at any age as long as it is presented in an
STEP 3 Auto-pilot
(e.g. done automatically; Recurrent
internal prompts) learning
Skill developed loop
STEP 2 Self-help
(e.g. talking to self)
ZPD
STEP 1 Assistance from others
(e.g. parents, teachers, nursery
nurses, other adults, peers)
Skill starts
Figure 1.15 The zone of proximal development Source: adapted from Tharp and
Gallimore (1991, p. 50)
26
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
appropriate way. Learning does not occur in pre- extend children’s own ideas; and negotiate choices
determined stages, but is dependent on linking with children.
knowledge to children’s existing knowledge in a
holistic way.
Key term
Bruner’s sequence of cognitive development is
Scaffolding – Bruner’s term for adult assistance
divided into three areas: given to support child’s thinking and learning. As child
1 Enactive: understanding the world through action develops competence, the adult decreases support until
child works independently.
(relates to Piaget’s sensori-motor stage).
2 Iconic: manipulation of images or ‘icons’ in child’s Zone of proximal development – Vygotsky’s
description for a child’s next area of development
thinking about the world (corresponds to Piaget’s where adult assistance is only required until the
pre-operational stage). child has developed the skill and can do it
3 Symbolic: use of language and symbols to make independently.
sense of the world (similar to Piaget’s operational
stage).
Activity
Observe child
• Summarise the main points of Vygotsky’s and
identify child’s
Give further assistance learning needs
Bruner’s theories concerning children’s thinking
only if required and learning.
• Think about how these ideas relate to your
experiences of working with children.
Adapt activities to Adult supporting Provide meaningful
encourage child’s learning context for learning
independent learning
How social constructivist
theories support meeting the
Give assistance
as necessary
Select appropriate
learning materials needs of children
As appropriate to your particular role, you will need
Encourage child’s
choices to plan, implement and evaluate curriculum plans
according to the requirements of your setting. When
Figure 1.16 Scaffolding: supporting a child’s thinking and planning, implementing and evaluating curriculum
learning
plans, your overall aims should be to: support all
the children you work with; ensure each child has
Bruner views language as central to children’s
full access to the relevant curriculum; encourage
thinking and learning and stresses how language
participation by all children; meet children’s
is used to represent experiences and how past
individual learning and development needs; build
experience or knowledge is organised through
on children’s existing knowledge and skills; and
language in ways which make information
help all children achieve their full potential.
more accessible. Language connects a person’s
understanding of one situation to another. The It is vital that all children have access to a
adult has a particular role in establishing effective stimulating environment which enables learning
communication to encourage and extend children’s to take place in exciting and challenging ways. To
thinking and learning. Adults use language to: develop into healthy, considerate and intelligent
capture children’s interest and direct their attention; adults, all children require intellectual stimulation
develop children’s problem-solving abilities; assist as well as physical care and emotional security.
children’s understanding of concepts; encourage and Intellectual stimulation through play and other
27
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
28
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
The theories of Vygotsky and Bruner are relevant to a significant amount of time with the young child,
teaching and learning – for example, ‘scaffolding’, such as a grandparent or nanny. The security
in which an adult or more advanced peer helps to of these early attachments is essential to babies
structure or arrange a task so that a new learner can and young children because they provide a firm
work on it successfully. foundation for promoting emotional well-being,
positive relationships with other people and
ity confidence in exploring the environment. These early
Research Activ attachments enable children to feel secure about
1. Explore the relationship between the article their relationships and to develop trust in others.
you selected for the previous research activity Security and trust are important elements in young
(on page 28) and a recent news story relating children’s ability to separate from their parents and
to children’s intellectual development and carers in order to develop their own independence
learning.
and ideas.
2. Evaluate the connection to your own life,
personal interests and your practice when
working with children/young people.
John Bowlby (1907–1990)
John Bowlby’s theory was that, to ensure a child’s
mental health, the child required a continuous
1. A child has an innate (i.e. inborn) need to Although Bowlby did not rule out the possibility of
attach to one main attachment figure (i.e. other attachment figures for a child, he did believe
monotropy). that there should be a primary bond which was much
more important than any other (usually the mother).
2. A child should receive the continuous care of If the attachment figure is broken or disrupted
this single most important attachment figure during the critical two-year period, the child will
for approximately the first two years of life. suffer irreversible long-term consequences of this
maternal deprivation. This risk continues until the
age of five.
3. The long-term consequences of maternal Affectionless psychopathy is an inability to show
deprivation might include the following: affection or concern for others. Such individuals act
delinquency; reduced intelligence; increased on impulse with little regard for the consequences of
aggression; depression; affectionless their actions. For example, showing no guilt for anti-
psychopathy. social behaviour.
4. The child’s attachment relationship with their This internal working model is a cognitive framework
primary caregiver leads to the development comprising mental representations for understanding
of an internal working model. the world, self and others. There are three main
features of the internal working model: (1) a model of
others as being trustworthy, (2) a model of the self as
valuable, and (3) a model of the self as effective when
interacting with others.
29
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
theory of maternal deprivation is attachment theory, ●● Distortion: the child experiences distorted family
which suggests that the mother–baby attachment is relationships due to marital discord, inconsistent
unique and unlike any other relationship the child treatment or any form of abuse.
may have with another person. This instinctive
Bowlby’s theory suggests that any family, no matter
attachment which a child has to one mother figure is
how ‘bad’, provides children with the care they need
described as monotropy.
so that they do not experience maternal deprivation;
children in ‘good’ residential care do less well
Key term than children in ‘bad’ homes. Rutter suggests that
children in ‘bad’ families are suffering distortion;
Attachment – the strong bond between baby and
parent (usually the mother) or to another family member the children are still experiencing deprivation even
or anyone outside the immediate family who spends though they remain in the family setting. Children
a significant amount of time with the very young child, can experience violence, cruelty or neglect at the
such as a grandparent or nanny.
hands of their mothers (and fathers); many children
Maternal deprivation – the psychological damage can and do receive better care away from their
experienced by a child due to the lack of a continuous
relationship with one mother or mother substitute. biological parents in foster homes, small residential
homes or with adoptive parents.
Monotropy – instinctive attachment and unique
relationship between a baby and one mother figure.
Activity
Activity Find out more about Michael Rutter’s views on
attachment – for example, his ideas about maternal
Find out more about John Bowlby’s views on deprivation. You could start by looking at: http://
attachment – for example, his ideas about as-psychology.pbworks.com/w/page/9174253/
monotropy. You could start by looking at: www. DeprivationPrivation.
simplypsychology.org/bowlby.html.
30
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
1. Stranger joins parent and infant. 2. Stranger talks to parent then plays with infant.
3. Parent leaves infant and stranger alone. 4. The stranger stays and plays with infant.
5. The parent returns and stranger leaves. 6. Parent leaves; infant left completely alone.
31
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Table 1.10 Mary Ainsworth’s strange situation – three attachment styles (McLeod 2008)
3 Parent leaves infant and stranger alone. their mothers, alternating between being clingy and
4 Stranger stays and plays with infant being hostile. Bowlby believed that continued and
5 Parent returns and stranger leaves. persistent periods of this sort of separation caused
6 Parent leaves; infant left completely alone. permanent psychological damage. Although young
7 Stranger returns. children do experience distress when first separating
8 Parent returns and stranger leaves. from their mother when starting nursery or school, it
is short-lived and has no lasting effects on children’s
Ainsworth’s set of observational studies using the psychological development. Long-term effects have
‘strange situation’ revealed three distinct forms of been found in children in residential care; teachers’
attachment (‘attachment styles’ – see Table 1.10). reports indicate behavioural problems in such
children with effects including extreme need for
Activity adult attention and difficulties in making friendships
with peers (Tizard 1991).
Find out more about Mary Ainsworth’s views on
attachment – for example, her ideas about the These effects can also be apparent in young children
‘strange situation’. You could start by looking at: who have been mothered at home, where they
www.simplypsychology.org/mary-ainsworth.html. are used to one-to-one with their mother and so
sometimes find it difficult to be part of a group
(e.g. in nursery or school). Research shows that
How attachment theories children who have attended nursery/playgroup or
been cared for by a relative/childminder before they
support meeting the needs of
start school are often more independent, better able
children to interact with their peers, more willing to share
According to Bowlby, separation from their mothers and cooperate with other children, more sociable
causes intense distress in very young children, towards unfamiliar people and less timid or shy.
particularly in the critical period between the However, there was no difference in the percentage
ages of seven months and three years. Following of behavioural difficulties between children cared
reunion with their mothers, detachment may still for by their mothers and children who have attended
continue, leading to contradictory feelings towards day care prior to nursery or school (Tizard 1991).
32
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Bowlby himself recognised that the amount of time Nature versus nurture in
children spend with their mothers is not the crucial
factor; it is the quality of the time spent together, language development
not the quantity. Quality is also the key factor in The nature theory, put forward mainly by the
children’s other attachments. There is no evidence linguist Noam Chomsky, states that babies are born
33
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
with some knowledge of language. He argues that (a clean slate). This means that babies have to
language systems are too complex to be acquired learn everything, including language, from scratch.
solely from being copied from and/or taught by Language has to be learned in the same way as
adults. Language is innate and all humans have a any other skill. Children’s parents and other carers
genetic predisposition towards using language. shape the way in which children learn language by
encouraging the required sounds (and then words),
Chomsky concludes that humans have a ‘language while ignoring others. Children learn language by
acquisition device’ (LAD), which allows them to copying sounds, words and phrases around them
process and to use language. To reinforce this and through the positive reinforcement of their
argument, Chomsky points out how all children attempts to communicate.
appear to learn language in the same way and that
the early stages of language are the same for all Social constructivists (like Bruner and Vygotsky)
children. For example, all children (whatever their believe that a mixture of both nature and nurture
community language) first learn to speak using is essential for language development. Although
holophrases (one-word utterances to convey whole Bruner agrees with Chomsky that there is a language
sentences), followed by telegraphic speech (sentences acquisition device (LAD), he does not think this
of two or three words to convey meaning). is enough. He argues that there also needs to be
a ‘language acquisition support system’ (LASS).
The nurture theory originates from the work of By this, he means that the child’s family and the
the philosopher John Locke and was developed by whole context in which the child learns language
behaviourists such as Pavlov. This theory suggests are important. Social constructivist theory suggests
that a baby is born with a mind like a tabula rasa that young children acquire language as a means
Figure 1.19 Language arises from the need to understand the environment and from social interactions with others
34
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
to communicate more effectively than can be done research on children from ethnic minority groups
through non-verbal communication alone. This has shown that environment is also important
theory is similar to the behaviourist tradition in that because where there was racial discrimination the
children learn language through their interactions children did less well educationally, but when their
with others. However, social constructivist theory families moved to areas where there was little or no
differs in that even very young children are seen discrimination, these children’s IQ scores were the
as active participants in their own language same as non-minority children. Intelligence is not
development. For example, research has shown determined by just one factor, similar to the way
that babies can initiate and control pre-verbal children’s language and communication skills are
‘conversations’ with their parents, rather than the affected by other factors (see above).
other way round; babies make adults pay attention to
them through body language, crying and babbling Nature versus nurture in
and they end ‘conversations’ with adults by breaking
off eye contact or simply falling asleep! The role emotional and social
of the adult in children’s language development is development
to provide the social context in which meaningful Research indicates that, in the same way as babies
communication can take place. This theory inherit their physical characteristics (e.g. hair and eye
also stresses the strong link between language colour), they also inherit genetic information which
acquisition and children’s cognitive or intellectual contributes towards their personality development.
development. Children inherit their particular temperaments,
which are then influenced by the environment they
Nature versus nurture in are raised in. Researchers agree that personality is
cognitve development derived from a combination of inheritance (nature)
and environment (nurture).
Is children’s cognitive development derived from
their genetic inheritance (nature) or the result of their Studies of young babies show they already have
upbringing and experiences (nurture)? This is one distinct temperaments or personality types. For
of the questions concerning children’s cognitive (or example, one study found that 40 per cent were
intellectual) development. If a person’s cognitive skills ‘easy-going’, 10 per cent were ‘difficult’, 15 per cent
are dependent on heredity (nature), then it is possible were ‘slow to warm up’ and 35 per cent did not
to believe that people are born with a predetermined fit any category (Fontana 1994)! Remember that
level of intelligence that remains the same all their labelling personalities is not really a good idea as
lives – they can only be as intelligent as those every child is a unique individual.
intellectual abilities permit. However, if a person’s
cognitive skills arise as the result of their environment Environmental factors also affect children’s
(nurture), then it is possible to believe that people are emotional development. Consistent and loving care
as intelligent as their learning experiences allow. from a parent/carer who is sensitive to the child’s
particular needs enables the child to feel secure and
Research indicates that the development of to develop self-worth. Physical care is not enough
children’s cognitive abilities depends on both – every child needs love and attention from their
nature and nurture – babies and young children parent and/or carer. Having at least one secure and
have a predisposition towards learning, which is personal relationship with a parent/carer enables a
activated by environmental triggers such as social child to form other relationships (see the section on
interaction, language and learning opportunities. attachments from page 29).
For example, research with twins (separated and
raised in different environments) shows that genetics Different cultures within society may have different
is a key factor because the twins had similar IQ cultural expectations relating to behaviour and
scores despite their different life experiences. While emotional responses, including the expected roles
35
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
for men and women. For example, parents do treat or inadequate substitute care) which can lead to poor
boys and girls differently (often subconsciously), social adjustment and/or emotional difficulties.
such as giving girls more cuddles or expecting
boys to be tougher. Family size may also affect Key term
children’s personality. For example, children in
large families may find it more difficult to get Nature – genetic inheritance or biological factors; the
their parents’ attention and this may affect their characteristics a person is born with.
emotional (and social) adjustment in group settings, Nurture – environmental/social factors which influence
a person’s characteristics/skills (e.g. early childhood
but may have positive benefits, such as increased
relationships and experiences).
independence and ability to take turns. Some
Social context – any situation or environment where
research studies indicate that the position of children
social interaction occurs (e.g. home, early years setting,
in the family may also affect their personality. For local community).
example, first-born or only children are more likely
to be conscientious, cooperative, sensitive and
academically ambitious; second-born or middle Activity
children are more likely to be outgoing, aggressive
and competitive; the youngest child in the family What is your own opinion regarding children’s
tends to be the most sociable, spontaneous, passive development and the nature versus nurture debate?
and lacking in maturity. However, these differences Give a detailed account, using examples from your
in personality are probably due to the way in which own experiences of working with children.
adults treat the children rather than birth order.
For example, first time parents are more likely to
be anxious and overprotective of their first-born or Neuroscience and brain
only child; parents may be more relaxed with the
second-born or middle child, who in turn may feel
development
they are in the older child’s ‘shadow’; the youngest Neuroscience is the study of the brain and nervous
child may be ‘babied’ by the rest of the family. system. It is an area of study that has developed a
wide range of theoretical approaches to many areas
Children’s emotional (and social) development may
of children’s growth and development. The use of
also be affected by other factors, such as:
imaging techniques of the brain, in part, has made
●● special needs and/or difficulties at birth (e.g. this possible.
premature baby, forceps or caesarean delivery),
which are often stated as being the cause for a In recent years, investigation into babies’ developing
baby being ‘difficult’, but this is more likely to be brains has provided insights relevant to the work
the result of the adult’s treatment of the child, of early years practitioners. Shore (1997) provides
which then affects the child’s behaviour (e.g. over- an overview of some of the research and states
anxiety due to low birth weight of a premature that, throughout the entire process of development,
baby or concerns over a child’s special needs) beginning before birth, the environment plays a
●● family circumstances, such as parental separation/ key role in brain development and the ‘wiring’ that
divorce, single-parent families, step-families takes place in babies’ brains. A warm and loving
●● death, abandonment or other permanent environment that meets individual children’s
separation from parent needs is important in supporting positive brain
●● adoption, foster care or other temporary/ development. There is more information about the
permanent residential care. effects of stress on a baby’s developing brain in
Chapter 6.
These factors do not necessarily have negative effects
on children’s emotional development; there are The importance of physical activity for young
usually additional factors (such as financial hardship children’s learning has been supported by
36
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
brain-based investigation. Early years practitioners Froebel emphasised that everything in the world
have known for decades that sitting young children was linked together and that children perceived the
down to learn in a formal way is not the most world best through integrated activities. He stressed
effective form of supporting learning. Healy (2004) the importance of encouraging art, literature, natural
translates some of the key findings into practical sciences, mathematical understanding and the
ways of supporting learning and development. appreciation of beauty.
A number of companies have attempted to use the Froebel was concerned with the ‘whole child’ –
research into brain-based approaches to learning for example, he believed children should wear
to support their products and services. Some have comfortable clothes that allowed them to move about
developed materials that claim that specific activities freely and that they should have a simple but healthy
for children can exert effects on different parts of the diet. Froebel recognised that parents are the child’s
brain. Lindon (2012) states that ‘research reviews first educator and stated that teachers should be like
(Howard Jones undated, about 2008; Blakemore and ‘mothers’ to young children. He welcomed parents
Frith 2000) raise some serious questions over claims into schools and into the ‘communities’ where the
from some of the commercial brain-based learning children were cared for.
programmes.’
The influence of Froebel on current
Neuroscience has already made an important
contribution to the understanding of children’s practice
learning and development. It is clear, however, that Most mainstream early years provision in the UK is
there is much more research needed to understand based on Froebelian principles and, although most
how the brain works and how learning can best be of his ideas are now taken for granted, in his lifetime
supported. they were groundbreaking.
37
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Susan Isaacs (1885–1948) Isaacs and McMillan’s views on the nursery school as
a community and extension of the home are followed
Susan Isaacs worked in the Froebelian tradition
through today as parents are invited into schools and
but was also influenced by Melanie Klein. Isaacs
seen as partners in the care and education of their
believed that play gave children the opportunity to
children. As well as being a community in itself, early
think, learn and express feelings.
years settings extend provision into the community
Isaacs saw parents as the main educators of young and become part of the wider community as well.
children and felt that nurseries should be an
Other important influences on current practice
extension of the home. She felt that children should
include the following:
remain in nursery until the age of seven before
starting school and that careful records should be ●● Children are given access wherever possible to
kept of each child at the nursery. Through these outdoor areas and are encouraged to use make
records, she demonstrated that children actually gardens and use natural materials.
regressed after starting formal school. ●● Health, nutrition and medical services are part of
childcare provision.
Margaret McMillan (1860–1931) ●● Observation of children and accurate record
keeping is emphasised in early years settings.
Margaret McMillan was also unfluenced by
Froebel. She believed in learning through first-
hand experiences and emphasised feelings and
Maria Montessori (1870–1952)
relationships, as well as the physical aspects of Maria Montessori was a doctor who practised in
movement and learning. McMillan believed that play a poor part of Italy and who spent a good deal of
helped a child to become a ‘whole person’. time observing children, especially those with
special needs. Montessori believed that children go
McMillan believed in the introduction of nursery through periods in their development when they
schools as an extension of not just the home but are more open to learning particular skills and
communities themselves. She emphasised the value concepts.
of the open air and introduced gardens for families
Unlike McMillan and Isaacs, Maria Montessori did
to play and explore. She believed in partnership with
not emphasise play or the free flow of ideas. Children
parents, who developed with their children in the
were encouraged to work through the graded learning
nursery environment.
activities before undertaking creative activities. The
Margaret McMillan first introduced school meals emphasis was on a carefully prepared environment
and medical services and stressed the importance of where the child would be able to solve problems
having trained adults to work with children. independently, building self-confidence, analytical
thinking and the satisfaction that comes from
The influence of McMillan and Isaacs accomplishment.
38
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Maria Montessori did not think there was a need for several years. Steiner placed emphasis on correct
adult ‘correction’. She believed the role of the adult food and a balance of rest and activity.
was limited to facilitating the child’s own activity
and the teacher was known as the ‘directress’. The influence of Steiner on current
Allowing the child to become independent was
practice
emphasised. Montessori thought children should
work in a quiet and peaceful environment of total Schools that follow Rudolf Steiner’s principles are
concentration. called Steiner-Waldorf schools in the private sector in
the UK.
The influence of Montessori on current
Mainstream settings believe in early childhood
practice as a unique phase of life that is more than just
There are many Montessori schools in the UK within preparation for adulthood and that the individual
the private sector and some Montessori classes and child’s needs and personality are important.
schools in mainstream education. In early years As in Steiner-Waldorf schools, establishing
provision today, Montessori ideas and materials are relationships is valued and reaching out and
sometimes used, such as graded sizes of particular serving the community is considered part of the
shapes, such as small, medium and large blocks. nursery’s role.
Current mainstream practice is more likely to However, mainstream settings consider the content
intervene and support the child to work through that is being taught as well as the process of learning.
activities and to encourage group work. Also mainstream settings do not emphasise
spirituality as much as Steiner.
Rudolf Steiner (1861–1925)
Steiner was a strict vegetarian, as well as a believer
in reincarnation. Steiner believed in childhood Section 2: Applying
as a special phase of life and that the young child
needs a protected environment in which all-round
theories to workplace
development can take place. He believed that a practice
child’s temperament was important to overall
development and learning. As well as intellectual Understanding theoretical approaches to how
progress, Steiner emphasised spiritual, moral, social, children learn and develop may influence practice by
artistic, creative and altruistic (caring for each other) improving:
development. He did not emphasise what is taught ●● the quality of early education provision
but how and when it is taught. ●● the structure of the learning environment
●● the provision of materials and equipment
Steiner believed that young children need to be
●● the communication between adults and children
protected from formal learning and to learn through
during learning experiences
imaginative and creative play using simple tasks
●● the adult expectations of children’s development.
and activities with natural materials. In Steiner
schools, the learning opportunities are often Theoretical approaches to how children learn
repeated as many times as necessary so that all and develop increase adults’ awareness and
children, including those with special needs, feel understanding of the importance of:
confident.
●● observing and assessing children’s development
Steiner stressed the importance of community and very carefully
relationships with other people and, in Steiner ●● listening to children and the way they express
schools, the same teacher stays with the child for ideas
39
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●●
Planning for children
taking account of children’s interests
and experiences when planning learning
opportunities. and/or young people’s
Planning and organising care and development
environments for You will need to plan provision for the children
you work with based on your assessment of their
children developmental progress. You should recognise
that children’s developmental progress depends
It is important to plan and organise an environment on each child’s level of maturation and their prior
for children and families that is welcoming experiences. You should take these into account and
and user-friendly. This involves planning and have realistic expectations when planning activities
providing an enabling physical environment for and routines to promote children’s development.
children, including adapting the environment to This includes regularly reviewing and updating
meet children’s needs (according to their ages, plans for individual children and ensuring that
abilities and any special needs) and ensuring that plans balance the needs of individual children
any barriers to participation are addressed. It also and the group as appropriate to your setting. You
involves organising space and resources to meet should know and understand that children develop
children’s needs within an accessible, comfortable at widely different rates but in broadly the same
and stimulating environment. You should provide sequence.
a caring, nurturing and responsive environment
where children and their families feel valued and When planning provision to support children’s and/
respected. You should also facilitate children’s or young people’s development, it is essential to
personal care by encouraging children to care for always look at the ‘whole’ child or young person.
themselves as appropriate to their ages, needs and This means looking at all areas of their development
abilities. (e.g. Social, Physical, Intellectual, Communication
and language, Emotional) in relation to the
particular aspect of development or learning you
are focusing on. We therefore refer to children’s
and young people’s development as holistic, with
each area being interconnected. For example, when
observing a pupil’s writing skills, as well as looking
at their intellectual development, you will need to
Planning Start here
consider the pupil’s:
What next? Observation
Experiences and ●● physical development (fine motor skills when
opportunities, learning
environment, resources, The Child
Look, listen and note. using a pencil or pen)
Describing
routines, practitioners’ role. ●● language development and communication skills
(vocabulary and structure of language used during
their writing)
●● social and emotional development (interaction with
others and behaviour during the writing activity).
Assessment
Analysing observations
and deciding what they
tell us about children. Key term
Figure 1.20 Planning to support each child’s learning and Holistic – looking at the ‘whole’ child or young person
development (Source: ‘Development Matters in the Early (e.g. all aspects of the child or young person’s
Years Foundation Stage’, 2012)
development).
40
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Construction Tidy
BREAKFAST
Playgroup Playgroup
Visit the toys child’s
SNACK
LUNCH
SNACK
(local Children’s TV
TEA
41
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Planning cycle
for observations
and assessments
Write down the of activities
outcome of this activity. What is your role
Was our aim in this activity?
achieved?
If possible observe
Implement the
and record the
activity. What is
child during
the child’s response?
the activity.
Figure 1.22 Planning children’s activities (Source: Jackie Harding and Liz Meldon-Smith, 2001)
42
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
●● identify possible ways in which the routine or professionals about the successfulness of a
activity might be modified/adapted to particular routine or activity.
meet the individual needs of the child or
The senior practitioner, setting manager or your college
children
tutor/assessor should give you guidelines on how to
●● provide accurate information for the senior
present your routine and activity plans. If not, you might
practitioner, setting manager or other
find the suggested format in Table 1.11 useful.
43
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
theories ●●
●●
Praise and reward acceptable behaviour
Reduce the opportunities for unwanted behaviour
●● Avoid confrontations
Planning based on behaviourist ●● Ignore minor unwanted behaviour
In Practice
Think about the basic principles of behaviour ow to encourage the child to behave more
h
modification. appropriately.
1. Observe a child who regularly demonstrates 2. From the information in your observation, plan
challenging or unwanted behaviour during and implement a step-by-step approach (e.g.
group activities. In your assessment, include behaviour modification) to encourage the child to
information on: behave in more acceptable ways. Remember to
include appropriate rewards (and sanctions).
❏ the child’s behaviour during the activity
3. Analyse the outcome of the implemented plan
❏ the child’s communication skills
in relation to this behaviour theory and your
❏ how the adult responds workplace practice.
❏ how the other children respond to the child’s 4. Evaluate the benefit of using behaviour theories
behaviour to underpin the planning for children and/or
young people’s care or development.
❏ how to monitor the child’s future behaviour
44
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Focus on
child’s behaviour
Target reached
Target one aspect
(or reviewed)
of unwanted behaviour
Consult senior
colleageues/other Observe and
professionals if monitor child’s
necessary behaviour
Continue to observe
Discuss possible
and monitor child’s
strategies and
behaviour
resources
Implement
strategies
this can lead to either emotional dependence, ●● dependence on their own capabilities and personal
excessive shyness and an overcautious nature resources
or emotional detachment, anti-social behaviour ●● competence in looking after themselves
and a rebellious nature. Adults should also avoid ●● trust in their own judgement and actions
unrestricted independence as the child may be ●● confidence in their own abilities and actions.
exposed to danger and physical harm (e.g. from
fire, boiling water, traffic) and/or the child may
become selfish and unable to recognise the In Practice
needs and rights of others. Adults should strike
Think about encouraging children’s self-reliance.
a balance between these two extremes. You
should provide a balance between allowing for 1. Observe a child demonstrating self-help skills,
the individual child’s need for independence and such as feeding themselves, washing hands,
getting dressed/undressed (e.g. for PE) or
providing supervision with appropriate guidelines
tidying up. Assess the child’s ability to perform
for socially acceptable behaviour, which takes into the skill independently. Outline the adult’s role in
account the needs of everyone in the setting. developing the child’s self-reliance in this area.
Encouraging children’s self-reliance is an important 2. From the information in your observation, plan
part of helping them to develop their independence and implement a routine which will encourage
the child’s self-help skills.
and resilience, which will enable children to face
life’s demands and challenges in preparation for 3. Analyse the outcome of the implemented plan
their adult lives. Encouraging self-reliance involves in relation to psychoanalytic theory and your
workplace practice.
helping children to develop:
4. Evaluate the benefit of using psychoanalytic
●● independence (or autonomy) – for example, the theories to underpin the planning for children
ability to think and act for themselves and/or young people’s care or development.
45
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
46
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
In Practice
Think about supporting children’s emotional needs. ❏ suggestions for further activities to encourage
or extend the child’s emotional development,
1. Observe a child during imaginative play or
including appropriate resources.
creative activity. Focus on the child’s emotional
development. In your assessment, comment on: 2. From the information in your observation, plan
and implement an activity which will support the
❏ the child’s imaginative and creative skills
child’s emotional needs.
❏ the child’s ability to make choices or decisions
3. Analyse the outcome of the implemented plan in
❏ the child’s use of language to express needs relation to humanistic theory and your workplace
and/or feelings practice.
❏ the role of the adult in promoting the child’s 4. Evaluate the benefit of using humanistic theories
emotional development to underpin the planning for children and/or
young people’s care or development.
Lectures would be a waste of time for children. understand concepts through active learning and
Indeed, traditional lectures are a waste of time even communication. Language is a key component in
for adults! This is because the average attention children’s thinking and learning. Play is an invaluable
span of an adult is 20 minutes. (This is probably why way to provide opportunities for language and to
commercials are shown about every 15 to 20 minutes make learning more meaningful, especially for
on television.) The average attention span of a child younger children. Play enables children to learn about
is considerably less, more like five to ten minutes, concepts in a safe and non-threatening environment.
or even as little as two to three minutes, especially
for very young children and some children with Children need a combination of real and imaginary
cognitive difficulties or behavioural difficulties. experiences to encourage learning. This is why play is
an important aspect of young children’s thinking and
In all learning situations, it is important to provide learning. Play opportunities are particularly useful
information in small portions with plenty of for encouraging children to develop mathematical
discussion and activity breaks to maintain interest and scientific skills. Younger children need to handle
and concentration. It is essential that children real objects and materials to understand basic
become actively involved in the learning process. concepts – for example, in mathematics, using objects
Learning needs to be practical, not theoretical. for counting and addition, such as buttons, cones
Children need concrete learning experiences (e.g. or interlocking cubes. Once children have plenty of
using real objects in a meaningful context). This is practical mathematical experiences, they can cope
why providing appropriate play opportunities is so more easily with abstract concepts, such as mental
crucial to all children’s learning and development. calculations and algebra.
Active learning encourages children to be: Play activities are effective in developing children’s
●● Curious thinking and learning by providing opportunities for:
●● Handy at problem-solving ●● well-motivated learning
●● Imaginative
●● challenging and interesting learning experiences
●● Creative.
●● taking responsibility for their own learning and
solving abilities that are essential to developing ●● developing problem-solving skills and improving
47
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
In Practice
Think about the active learning process. involves the active learning process. Include
information on:
1. Observe a child involved in a play activity. In your
assessment, include information on: ❏❏ the intended learning objectives for the play
activity
❏❏ the learning objectives for the activity
❏❏ the organisation, resources and staff required
❏❏ the intellectual skills demonstrated by the
child during the activity (e.g. concentration, ❏❏ any special requirements (e.g. specialist
memory skills, imagination and creativity, equipment)
mathematical or scientific skills, language and
❏❏ the support to be provided by adults.
communication skills)
3. Analyse the outcome of the implemented plan in
❏❏ the level of adult support provided during the
relation to theories relating to active learning and
activity
your workplace practice.
❏❏ suggestions to encourage and extend the
4. Evaluate the benefit of using these theories to
child’s development and learning.
underpin the planning for children and/or young
2. From the information in your observation, plan people’s care or development.
and implement a play activity for the child which
48
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Planning based on attachment key person must seek to engage and support
parents and/or carers in guiding their child’s
theories development at home. They should also help
A meaningful relationship with a key person enables families engage with more specialist support
very young children to form a secure attachment if appropriate (Department for Education
to the adult. A very young child’s relationship and 2012).
attachment to a key person provides an excellent
context in which the child can feel safe to express To cope with, prepare for and accept transition and
and make sense of their emotions (Gillespie Edwards transfer, children need:
2002). ●● reassurance from adults to maintain their feelings
of stability, security and trust
The key features of an effective ●● adult assistance to adjust to different social rules
and social expectations
key person system ●● help in adapting to different group situations.
49
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Figure 1.25 The key person can help the young child to deal with separation anxiety when making the
transition to the setting
In Practice
Think about the role of the key person. ❏❏ encouraging parents to share information
that may affect their children’s emotional
1. Identify the factors that may affect new children
security
starting at your setting. For example:
❏❏ identifying the support the children will need
❏❏ each child’s age and level of maturity
to make a successful transition, including any
❏❏ any previous experiences in other settings special requirements
❏❏ any special needs (e.g. physical disability, ❏❏ the role of the key person (e.g. recognising
sensory impairment, communication difficulties, and responding promptly to signs of emotional
behavioural and/or emotional difficulties) distress; using different techniques to calm,
reassure and distract individual babies and
❏❏ the family circumstances of each child
children who are distressed; acknowledging
❏❏ the changes in expectations and activities and communicating respect for the very young
required of the children. children’s feelings; reassuring parents during
2. Devise a plan to help new children to settle into the transition process).
your setting – for example, developing an effective 3. Analyse the intended plan in relation to theories
induction programme for children that helps them relating to attachment and your workplace
to understand the new expectations and activities practice.
within the setting. Include information on:
4. Evaluate the benefit of using these theories to
❏❏ working with parents to ensure a full underpin the planning for children and/or young
understanding of the transition process people’s care or development.
50
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
To be an effective practitioner requires a sound ❏❏ Was your own particular contribution appropriate?
theoretical base. For example, a practitioner working ❏❏ Did you choose the right time, place and
with a distressed child who is struggling to settle into a resources?
new setting may find a useful link between theory and ❏❏ Did you intervene enough or too much?
practice in Bowlby’s theory of attachment, particularly
❏❏ Did you achieve your intended goals (for
his concept of separation response (protest, despair example, objectives/outcomes for the child or
and detachment), as this may help to illuminate the children and yourself)? If not, why not? Were
practitioner’s understanding of this child and, in turn, the goals too ambitious or unrealistic?
help the parent(s) to understand and to tolerate certain ❏❏ What other strategies/methods could have
behaviours. Using theory to guide practice should not been used? Suggest possible modifications.
involve becoming lost in concepts that are difficult to ❏❏ Where could you get further information or
understand or locked in professional jargon that sets advice about linking theory and practice (for
practitioners apart, but it should result in acquiring a example, from senior practitioners, other
greater understanding about what constitutes effective professionals, the internet, libraries, journals)?
practice (Trevithick 2000).
51
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● knowledge and understanding in order to actively achieved (e.g. best practice benchmarks, course
support and extend children’s learning in and certificate of attendance or qualification).
across all areas and aspects of learning ●● Achievable: avoid being too ambitious; set
●● practice in meeting all children’s needs, learning objectives which you know are attainable.
styles and interests ●● Realistic: be realistic about what you want to develop.
●● work with parents, carers, the wider community ●● Time-bound: plan a realistic time frame within
and other professionals (Department for Education which to achieve your objectives.
and Skills 2005).
You should discuss and agree these objectives with
those responsible for supporting your professional
In Practice development. This includes developing and
negotiating a plan to develop your knowledge,
1. How do you monitor the processes, practices
skills and understanding further (e.g. a personal
and outcomes from your work?
development plan). For example, you may consider
2. Give examples of how you evaluate your own
that some of your work tasks require modification or
childcare practice, including:
improvement and discuss possible changes with your
❏❏ self-evaluation
line manager. Or you may feel that you lack sufficient
❏❏ reflections on your interactions with others knowledge and skills to implement particular
❏❏ sharing your reflections with others activities and need to discuss opportunities for you
❏❏ using feedback from others to improve your to undertake the relevant training. To achieve your
own evaluation. personal development objectives, you should make
3. Describe how you have used theories to solve effective use of the people, resources (e.g. the internet,
problems and improve practice. libraries, journals) and other professional development
or training opportunities available to you.
52
Chapter 1 Extending understanding of theories of children and/or young person’s care or development (Unit CP 1)
Useful resources
Books
Anderson, R. (2008) Melanie Klein and child analysis, The Melanie Klein Trust, www.melanie-klein-trust.
org.uk/ra2009.htm (accessed April 2012).
Bandura, A. (1965) ‘Influence of models’ reinforcement contingencies on the acquisition of imitative
responses’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1: 589–595.
Bandura, A. (1973) Aggression: a social learning analysis, Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Bandura, A., Ross, D. and Ross, S.A. (1961) ‘Transmission of aggression through imitation of
aggressive models’, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 63: 575–582.
Blakemore, S. and Frith, U. (2000) The implications of recent developments in neuroscience for research
on teaching and learning, a consultation paper commissioned by the Teaching and Learning Research
Programme, ESRC, www.tlrp.org/pub/acadpub/Blakemore2000.pdf.
Boeree, C.G. (1998) Personality theories: Anna Freud 1895–1982, http://webspace.ship.edu/cgboer/
annafreud.html (accessed March 2012).
Brennan, W.K. (1987) Changing special education now, Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
Bruce, T. (2011) Learning through play: for babies, toddlers and young children, London: Hodder Education.
Bruce, T. (ed.) (2009) Early childhood: a guide for education students, 2nd edition, London: Sage Publications.
Chasnoff, I.J. (2011) ‘Catch ‘em being good! The only form of discipline that works is positive
reinforcement’, Aristotle’s Child, 27 May, Psychology Today website: www.psychologytoday.com/blog/
aristotles-child/201105/catch-em-being-good-0 (accessed March 2012).
Cole, J., Clark, S., Hirschheimer, S., Martyn, T. and Morrall, J. (2001) Helping young children learn
through activities in the early years, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Department for Education (2012) The Early Years Foundation Stage: setting the standards for learning,
development and care for children from birth to five, London: DfE.
Department for Education and Skills (2005) Primary national strategy: KEEP – Key Elements of Effective
Practice, London: DfES.
Donaldson, M. (1978) Children’s minds, London: Fontana.
Fontana, D. (1994) ‘Personality and personal development’, in D. Fontana (ed.) The education of the
young child, Oxford: Blackwell.
Gillespie Edwards, A. (2002) Relationships and learning: caring for children from birth to three, London:
National Children’s Bureau.
Glenn, A., Cousins, J. and Helps, A. (2003) Behaviour in the early years, London: David Fulton Publishers.
53
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Gopnik, A., Meltzoff, A.N. and Kuhl, P.K. (1999) The scientist in the crib: minds, brains, and how
children learn, New York: William Morrow & Co. Inc.
Gregg, P., Washbrook, E., Propper, C. and Burgess, S.M. (2005) ‘The effects of a mother’s return to
work decision on child development in the UK’, Economic Journal, 115(501): F48–F80.
Harding, J. and Meldon-Smith, L. (2000) Helping young children to develop, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Harding, J. and Meldon-Smith, L. (2001) How to make observations and assessments, 2nd edition,
London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Healy, J. (2004) Your child’s growing mind: brain development and learning from birth to adolescence,
3rd edition, New York: Three Rivers Press.
Hobart, C. and Frankel, J. (2005) A practical guide to activities for young children, 3rd edition,
Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes.
Howard-Jones, P. (undated, circa 2008) Neuroscience and education: issues and opportunities, London:
Teaching and Learning Research Programme, www.tlrp.org/pub/documents/Neuroscience%20
Commentary%20FINAL.pdf.
Lindon, L. (2002) Good practice in working with babies, toddlers and very young children, London: Sure Start.
Lindon, J. (2007) Understanding children and young people: development from 5–18 years, London: Hodder Arnold.
Lindon, J. (2012) Understanding child development 0–8 years, 3rd edition, London: Hodder Education.
McLeod, S.A. (2007a) Skinner – operant conditioning, Simply Psychology website: www.
simplypsychology.org/operant-conditioning.html (accessed March 2012).
McLeod, S.A. (2007b) Carl Rogers, Simply Psychology website: www.simplypsychology.org/carl-rogers.
html (accessed April 2012).
McLeod, S.A. (2007c) Bowlby attachment theory, Simply Psychology website: www.simplypsychology.
org/bowlby.html (accessed May 2012).
McLeod, S.A. (2008) Mary Ainsworth – strange situation, Simply Psychology website: www.
simplypsychology.org/mary-ainsworth.html (accessed April 2012).
Meggitt, C., Kamen, T., Bruce, T. and Grenier, J. (2011) CACHE Level 3 Diploma: Children and Young
People’s Workforce – Early Learning and Child Care, London: Hodder Education.
NDNA (2004) National occupational standards in children’s care, learning and development, Brighouse: NDNA.
Pound, L. (2005) How children learn: from Montessori to Vygotsky – educational theories and approaches
made easy, Salisbury: Step Forward Publishing Ltd.
Pugh, G. (2006) Putting children first, Nursery World website: www.nurseryworld.co.uk/news/716362/
Putting-children-first/?DCMP=ILC-SEARCH (accessed March 2012).
Rutter, M. (1991) Maternal deprivation reassessed, London: Penguin.
Shore, R. (1997) ‘What have we learned?’, in R. Shore ‘Rethinking the brain’, New York: Families and
Work Institute.
Simons, J.A., Irwin, D.B. and Drinnien, B.A. (1987) Psychology – the search for understanding, St Paul:
West Publishing Company.
Stoppard, M. (1990) The new baby care book, London: Dorling Kindersley.
Tharp, R. and Gallimore, R. (1991) ‘A theory of teaching as assisted performance’, in P. Light, S.
Sheldon and M. Woodhead (eds), Learning to think, London: Routledge.
Tizard, B. (1991) ‘Working mothers and the care of young children’, in M. Woodhead, P. Light and R.
Carr (eds), Growing up in a changing society, London: Routledge.
Trevithick, P. (2000) Social work skills: a practice handbook, Buckingham: Open University Press.
Vargas, J.S. (2005) A brief biography of B.F. Skinner, The B.F. Skinner Foundation website: www.
bfskinner.org/BFSkinner/AboutSkinner.html (accessed March 2012).
Woodhead, M. (1991) ‘Psychology and the cultural construction of children’s needs’, in M. Woodhead,
P. Light and R. Carr (eds), Growing up in a changing society, London: Routledge.
54
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies
in children and/or young people’s settings
(Unit CP 2)
In 2005, when launching a new guide to developing not living documents, they will not be effective in
policies for early years settings, Steve Alexander, who meeting legal requirements and improving practice.
was then Chief Executive of the Pre-School Learning
Alliance, said, ‘All settings have a responsibility
to provide high-quality services for parents and Learning outcomes
families. Clear policies help to ensure that parents
1. Understand the role of policies within
are aware of how settings are run, how their children
a children and/or young people’s
will be cared for and their own responsibilities when setting.
using the service.’ This statement highlights the
2. Understand the requirements which
importance of policies for services and settings for
underpin a policy.
children and young people.
3. Understand how to develop a policy
Policies and procedures are vitally important for a real work environment caring
in almost all work settings as they provide the for children and/or young people.
framework in which people work. In children and 4. Understand how to implement a policy
young people’s settings, they are particularly helpful in a real work environment caring for
as they will set the standard for high-quality working children and/or young people.
practice. Policies and procedures define the ethos
and values of the setting and clearly outline the
expectations for practitioners, other professional
groups and service users – that is, children, young Section 1: The role of
people and their families. Although we explore in this
chapter how policies and procedures are seperate and policies within a children
different, most of the chapter looks at these as one –
that is, where the learning outcomes relate to policies, and/or young people’s
this will normally assume an associated procedure. setting
Settings and services will approach policies and
procedures in different ways and with different The difference between
emphases. For example, although important in all
settings, a local authority social services department
the role of policies and
may emphasise safeguarding, whereas in a school the role of procedures in
setting there may be more emphasis on learning.
In social services, there will be great detail in
the workplace
both policies and procedures and a wide range of
circumstances to which the policy applies will be
Policies
outlined. Policies are principles, rules and guidelines to help
an organisation to reach its medium and long-term
Policies and procedures are only effective if they are goals and are used to help people make decisions.
followed. If they gather dust on a top shelf and are They often indicate the strategy the setting or service
55
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
will use to attain its aims and are based on what actions or ways of acting that must be followed to
can realistically be delivered. Policies must be legal accomplish tasks or solve problems. Procedures are
(i.e. not break the law) and will also explain the very useful to people within settings – for example,
ethos of the setting or service. Policies are designed they may be fixed steps to be followed correctly and
to be read by people external to the organisation in order. Procedures can form the basis of standard
as well as those within as they indicate what the routines, such as waste disposal. In other cases, it can
organisation believes and takes seriously – that is, be more difficult to define these when they attempt
the core principles and values of the setting and to cover values, attitudes and individual behaviours.
the quality standard to be met. One purpose of a For example, a policy may say that practitioners will
policy is to communicate to employees the goals treat children or young people with respect and value
of the organisation. Policies are usually not too their opinion, or it may include statements such as
detailed and state its aims – what has to be achieved ‘respond sensitively to children and young people’.
and why. They include how the setting or service A procedure that reflects these policy aims is very
operates and help employees understand their important but more difficult to define and measure.
roles and responsibilities. Policies are normally
written down and may be a legal requirement in In most settings or services, there are written
some settings. They are often published in an easily procedures for almost every area of work as they
understood booklet or other format that is widely clarify what needs to be done and how it is to be
accessible. done. Sometimes procedures are passed on verbally
and through established work practices.
Policies are not the same as contracts, which are
formal agreements between service providers and Sometimes a policy is combined with a procedure
service users. These contractual agreements are and, for other situations, they are separate. For
normally in place before the child or young person example, a safety policy may be combined with
starts in a setting. A contract will vary between a procedure in one statement; it will state that
settings, but is likely to include: the policy aim is to keep children safe and avoid
accidents but it will also provide a clear procedure to
●● business arrangements and fees follow when accidents occur.
●● method of payment
●● hours. A shortened example of the difference between
policy and procedure is shown in the following box.
The contract may specifically state that the service
users will accept the policies and procedures of the
setting or service. Some settings include the policies Difference between policy and
and procedures as part of the contract; others may
present these as separate documents.
procedure
56
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
57
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
58
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
providing one specific type of medication • In the case of medication that may need to
should parents wish to use this. be given to a child due to them becoming
• On registration, parents will be asked if they ill during the day, e.g. liquid paracetamol
would like to fill out a medication form for for temperature reduction, parents will be
a specific type of liquid paracetamol, which contacted as soon as possible to ensure all
can be given in the case of an increase in details are correct and that they agree with
the child’s temperature. This form will state the dosage being given.
the dose to be given, the circumstances in
which this can be given, e.g. the temperature Injections, pessaries, suppositories
increase of their child, the specific brand
As the administration of injections, pessaries
name or type of liquid paracetamol and a
and suppositories represents intrusive nursing,
signed statement to say that this may be
they should not be administered by any member
administered in an emergency if they CANNOT
of staff unless appropriate medical training is
contact the parent.
given to each member of staff caring for this
• If a child does require liquid paracetamol
child. If this causes a problem in providing
during the day and the parents cannot be
appropriate care of a child, please consult
contacted then the nursery manager will
*Ofsted/*Social Care & Social Work Improvement
take the decision as to whether the child is
Scotland (SCSWIS)/*Care and Social Services
safe to have this medication based on the
Inspectorate Wales (CSSIW).
time the child has been in the nursery, the
circumstances surrounding the need for this
medication and the medical history of the Staff medication
child on their registration form. The first aid box for staff should be kept in a
• For any non-prescription cream for skin readily accessible position, but out of reach of
conditions, e.g. Sudocrem, prior written the children.
permission must be obtained from the parent
First aid boxes should only contain items
and the onus is on the parent to provide the
permitted by the Health and Safety (First Aid)
cream, which should be clearly labelled with
Regulations Act 1981, such as sterile dressing,
the child’s name.
bandages and eye pads. No other medical items,
• If any child is brought to the nursery in
such as paracetamol, should be kept in the first
a condition in which he/she may require
aid box.
medication sometime during the day, the
manager will decide if the child is fit to be Storage
left at the nursery. If the child is staying, the
parent must be asked if any kind of medication All medication for children must have the child’s
has already been given, at what time and in name clearly written on the original container
what dosage, and this must be stated on the and kept in a closed box, which is out of reach of
medication form. all children and under supervision at all times. If
• As with any kind of medication, staff will this box is left unguarded at any time throughout
ensure that the parent is informed of any the day, we have a procedure in place to ensure
non-prescription medicines given to the child the safety of any child or adult in the nursery,
whilst at the nursery, together with the times including visitors, parents and siblings able to
and dosage given. access the area.
• The nursery DOES NOT administer any Emergency medication, such as inhalers and
medication unless prior written consent is epipens, will be within easy reach of staff in
given for each and every medicine. case of an immediate need, but will remain out
59
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
of children’s reach and under supervision at all expiry dates, before staff agree to administer
times. medication.
Any antibiotics requiring refrigeration must be
kept in an area inaccessible to children. Internal use only Insert date
All medications must be in their original This policy was adopted on
containers or they will not be given. All Signed on behalf of the
prescription medications should have the nursery
pharmacist’s details and notes attached to show Date disseminated to staff
the dosage needed and the date the prescription
Date for review
was issued. This will all be checked, along with
60
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
61
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The EYFS requires early years settings to maintain it is not always possible to keep a person’s confidence,
the records, policies and procedures that are required especially, for example, when concerns about a child
for the safe and efficient management of the settings or young person’s welfare are expressed. Practitioners
and to meet the needs of the children. can use the policy as a basis for stating that they
have no choice but to escalate the information
Ofsted guidance (2010) ‘Using the early years (e.g. speak to a supervisor or report safeguarding
evaluation schedule’ states that: concerns). Other issues, such as racist comments or
poor behaviour, may also be covered by policies and
The EYFS Inspectors should take into account:
’
procedures to which practitioners can refer.
• the maintenance of records and implementation
of policies and procedures required for the safe Where good-quality policies and procedures are
and efficient management of the Early Years developed and implemented effectively, this enables
Foundation Stage and for ensuring that children a setting or service to work professionally and
are safeguarded and their needs are met.’ consistently. Where policies are applied consistently
and fairly, they can clarify difficult situations and
Guidance to inspectors emphasises the importance
reduce frustration, enabling a better working
of policies and procedures, which must be effectively
environment.
and consistently implemented. Without these,
settings are unlikely to achieve an ‘outstanding’ or
‘good’ grading in their Ofsted report or may face
Improve health, safety and
heavier sanctions. welfare
All settings working with children and young people
Standardisation and should establish and maintain a safe and enriching
consistency of approach environment. They all also need to be clear about
how to respond if concerns about children and
A real benefit of policies and procedures is that they
young people’s health, safety and welfare are raised.
help standardisation within the service, with each
Policies and procedures establish a clear framework
practitioner working in similar and predictable ways
for safe and effective practice. They are particularly
to achieve the goals of the setting or service. In early
important when dealing with issues and activities
years settings, parents/carers will be reassured to
that are critical to health and safety, safeguarding
know that all practitioners deal in similar ways with
and where legal liabilities and regulatory
the wide variety of circumstances that may occur
requirements are involved.
in day-to-day work with their children. How issues
are dealt with should not depend, for example, on
how practitioners are feeling that day or whether the
Provide standards for high-
child is thought to be ‘difficult’, but should be based quality working practice
on the policies and procedures in the setting. This In children and young people’s settings, policies and
is not to be confused with issues about meeting an procedures will help to set a benchmark/standard for
individual child or young person’s needs. Policies high-quality working practice. Policies and procedures
and procedures are normally written to enable should clearly outline the expectations for practitioners,
individual needs to be met. other professional groups and service users – that is,
children, young people and their families.
Avoid misunderstandings
Clear, well thought-out policies and procedures can Improve efficiency
help a setting or service avoid misunderstandings Policies and procedures improve efficiency and save
and reduce ambiguity. When all concerned are practitioners time. Practitioners know what to do and
clear about policy and procedure, this helps to avoid have the confidence to proceed knowing they are
embarrassment and misunderstanding. For example, following agreed policies and procedures.
62
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
63
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
For practitioners, a policy and procedure should leave Each of these areas provide the opportunity for
them in no doubt about the correct actions to take practitioners to develop practice. In some cases, this
in certain circumstances. For example, all settings forces the pace of change. Changes to policies may
will have a safeguarding policy and a procedure mean more training opportunities are required to
for reporting concerns. Most settings have a introduce new forms of practice. This can provide
whistleblowing policy, where practitioners may report a basis for change even where practitioners may be
concerns about colleagues or others in the setting. reluctant. One of the first things the setting may
When followed, these policies and procedures act consider is a training needs analysis, which identifies
as a safety net for staff. In difficult and sensitive needs associated with specific policies. This can be
situations, a clearly written set of actions to take is undertaken, for example, using a formal survey, or
reassuring and protects staff from unfair blame. as part of an appraisal system. The idea being that
individual as well as group training needs are clearly
Some policies and procedures, such as safeguarding identified.
or food safety, are critical for the welfare of children
and young people. Other policies may contain The introduction of the EYFS provided a framework
statements of good practice and these may make a for most early years providers to follow. This included
huge difference in the quality of the experience for the development of policies and procedures that may
children and young people. For example, there may be not have been required before. Childminders have
a policy for animal health and safety. This policy will also been included in this change of practice, even
focus on the welfare of the animals in the setting but though the requirements for written policies may be
can also include material on how the child or young less stringent.
person is protected whilst actively involved in animal
care. Practitioners understanding this policy will
know that children and young people are expected to
Activity
be involved in care of animals in the setting.
Choose an area of work requiring a policy and
The relevance of policies develop your own version of the policy. Develop
a set of clear procedures to implement the
and procedures in policy. Test out whether a small sample of people
understand what you mean in the policy you have
informing practice developed. Take their views into account and make
changes to your policy. Does it still meet your
Developing policies and procedures that meet original requirements?
high-quality standards and reflect evidence-based
64
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
The relevance of costs to This service did proceed with the change but
65
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and others involved. Effective monitoring can let the evidence. In this case, the policies and procedures
setting or service know if: may define what constitutes a ‘hard-to-engage’
family. It may be a family from an estate or other
●● policies and procedures have been implemented
types of family, such as those where English is an
(or ignored)
additional language.
●● procedures have worked well
●● there are any unintended consequences
Both monitoring the processes involved in the new
●● adaptations to policies and procedures are
policy and procedure and the outcomes should be
required included. The outcomes may be easier to determine
●● greater flexibility is needed.
as this involves counting how many more are coming
In some cases, measuring the effectiveness of a to the setting. However, simply measuring outcomes
policy is more difficult, especially if it relates to is not enough. In the above policy, a 10 per cent
behaviour change or even changes to attitudes. increase in hard-to-engage families using the setting
Practitioners may resent new policy and, although could be seen as success. However, the process of
they give lip service to it, nothing much changes engaging with families may be so flawed that the
on the ground. A good example of this is changes 10 per cent could have been 25 per cent with better
to behaviour policies. Practitioners need to be ways of working.
involved in the development of this type of policy
and engaged right from the start. How they deal
Case Study
with children or young people’s behaviour should
be based on this policy, but much depends on the
In order to monitor a policy change, it is also
preparation and training given to practitioners
important to define what success looks like. A
who may have a strong culture of dealing with
setting has found that its outdoor play policy
behaviour in a different way. Monitoring a policy
has been challenged as it restricts access
can be challenging to some practitioners, so it has
to particular times and weather. The new
to be done with fairness and sensitivity. Sometimes
policy makes outdoor areas accessible at all
it involves asking for feedback from service users,
times, regardless of weather, unless there are
including children. Confidentiality may not be easily
exceptional circumstances. The setting has
maintained and children, young people, families
decided that success for this policy will take the
and carers should be encouraged to make open and
form of:
honest evaluations.
• 80 per cent or more of individual children
Whatever aspect of the setting or service is affected
using and enjoying the outdoor area over a
by policy change and development, monitoring
week
and measuring impact are essential to make sure
• children engaging in sustained periods of
changes are effective in meeting policy aims. When
outdoor play and learning
new policies or changes to existing policies are
• children moving independently from indoor to
introduced, it is good practice to set up a system of
outdoors
evaluation to see if the changes are effective or need
• outdoor curriculum/learning goals being met
adaptation. For example, if a new policy regarding
• the whole outdoor area being utilised
reaching families who have traditionally been hard
appropriately by children
to engage with is launched, some way of measuring
• supervision being appropriate and adequate.
its effectiveness is required. It is no longer enough
simply to gather anecdotal information in which These indicators of the success of the policy
practitioners or managers might comment informally: are measurable and staff are involved in
‘We seem to have more families from a particular observations, assessments and reflections.
estate.’ Now more than ever, settings need concrete
66
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
67
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Behaviour
Off-site visits Participation
Babies and
toddlers Intimate care
Outdoor play
Sun care
Child
Play and
Health and
learning
safety
Inclusion
Attendance
Medication Safeguarding
and welfare
Allergies Infection
and allergic control
reaction
Figure 2.2 This chart does not include all the policies and procedures that are developed to
support children and families. From your experience in your setting/s, list any gap areas.
or wrong. Policies will have been explained at ●● Cost policies may encourage or discourage
enrolment and practitioners can remind parents/ parents/carers to use services; greater use may lead
carers and other stakeholders that these are the to higher levels of parental employment.
baseline for good practice. Issues of behaviour can ●● Effective inclusion policies may mean greater take-
also be challenging and the same arguments apply. up from hard-to-reach groups in communities.
●● Greater inclusion of hard-to-reach families may
Policies also support staff with their employment lead to better outcomes for children and young
rights and responsibilities – for example, pay, people.
conditions of service and confidentiality. ●● Policies emphasising participation of fathers
can support development in areas where gender
The impact of policies stereotypes are strong and can lead to a greater
on communities involvement of fathers in their child’s life.
●● Involvement of parents/carers can lead to
Policies and procedures within settings and services community development projects.
for children and young people may have an impact ●● Involvement of parents/carers in the work of the
68
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
empowerment of parents and a greater sense of ‘The role they play in engaging parents in their
ownership of the setting and service. child’s and their own learning, in supporting
●● Where settings have a policy of including routes to qualifications and in combating social
parents in their child’s learning, this can lead exclusion is seen as crucial to sustaining healthy
to involvement of the whole family in family communities.’
learning projects, such as adult literacy and
numeracy.
The impact of policies
Research commissioned by the Pre-School
Learning Alliance (2004) found that pre-schools
on other stakeholders
play a wide-ranging, active role in supporting
communities, delivering a ‘range of tangible benefits Key term
for children, parents and wider communities’. The
Stakeholder – a person, group or organization that
researchers revisited a number of pre-schools in has direct or indirect stake in an organisation because
areas of social and economic disadvantage to assess it can affect or be affected by the organisation’s
their contribution to the overall strengthening of actions, objectives and policies (source: www.
BusinessDictionary.com). A key stakeholder refers to
communities. It concluded that: people, groups or organisations that have a significant
●● as well as providing high-quality services for stake and are most affected.
69
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
70
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
71
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
consuming as it will require staff and service users’ reference may be made to their role (e.g. the manager
time to develop an effective and useful policy. or qualified first-aiders). In some cases, their
However, there may be pressure from regulators responsibility will also be to make sure that others
such as Ofsted to make sure that effective policies in the setting understand the policy and procedure
are in place. In some cases, regulators such as Ofsted and to monitor their effectiveness. They may also be
will withdraw registration if effective policies are required to check that the policy and procedure are
not in place within a set period. This may mean being implemented correctly.
practitioners need to be trained and service users
involved and informed, and a period of trialling may Many policies and procedures form the basis of
also be required. This takes time and costs money work with children and young people. Often all
but may be critical to the success of the policy. practitioners and other professionals/colleagues
will be bound by the policies (e.g. safeguarding,
Market forces also may put pressure on providers to health and safety, behaviour, confidentiality).
develop and advertise clear policies to reassure and Within these policies, certain people may have
encourage parents/carers, children and young people. particular responsibilities – for example, the health
and safety policy affects everyone but there are
Exemptions to the policy named first-aiders within the policy with specific
At the time of development of a policy, any responsibilities. Equally, within safeguarding,
exemptions to the policy should be made clear, there is a general policy for all, but some people
but in a setting or service these are normally rare. will have specific responsibilities, often a manager
Exemptions at national level can sometimes be more or senior professional, to take forward a set of
easily identified – for example, foreigners are exempt actions.
from the ‘one child’ policy in China. In England,
there is guidance for exemptions from parts of the
EYFS statutory framework. Such exemptions will be Activity
reflected in the setting’s policies and procedures, and
Examine health and safety (or other) policies in your
service users will be made aware of these. setting – there may be several covering one topic.
Identify the actions that are general for everyone
In schools, sometimes children or young people and those that are specific to a named person.
can be exempted from religious assemblies and RE
lessons. Schools policies and procedures will make
this parental right clear.
Case Study
ity
Research Activ
In recent years, there have been a number
Look into the policies and procedures in your of high-profile cases of inappropriate photos
setting and in local services to consider the range being taken of young children in nurseries,
of circumstances where children, young people or
which have been circulated across the internet.
families may be exempt from particular policies.
Select examples of particular exemptions and This is the sexual abuse of vulnerable young
develop a list of points in favour of or against the children. In many settings, mobile phones are
exemptions. now banned. Settings have clear policies and
procedures covering this.
Person responsible for Check out what actions the policies and
procedures require you to take in your setting
implementation if you see someone using a mobile phone in a
People responsible for implementation of policies banned area, no matter how innocent the call.
will either be named personally or more often
72
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
A system for monitoring, and are now changing – that is, what works and
what does not work.
evaluating and Policies and procedures should be transparent and
reviewing a policy accessible by all who use the setting or service. They
should be reviewed regularly in consultation with
Key term staff and any other stakeholders. Real collaboration
is important for the effective implementation of
Monitoring – monitoring is about collecting data/ policies and procedures; in this way, all stakeholders
information to help determine whether objectives have involved can reach agreement and ownership and a
been met. Monitoring will need specific indicators on
which to measure progress. Data is best collected commitment to carry out the actions needed to make
systematically – that is, in a planned, organised and the policy work. Policies should be dynamic and
routine way. Data is best collected at set times – for flexible, not set in stone. This will ensure they meet
example, weekly or monthly but may be more frequent
the needs of the environment in which the setting
depending on circumstances.
or service operates. Regular monitoring, evaluation
Evaluation – evaluation is the systematic and objective
and review are needed to keep up-to-date with the
assessment of any activity including projects or policy
implementation. This helps lessons to be learned and changing world, new research or legal requirements.
changes to be made. In a customer-focused environment, the needs of the
Review – very similar to an evaluation, a review is customer are also important.
a critique or revision and includes looking back at
something – that is, a critical re-assessment or Policy monitoring, evaluation and review help
reconsideration. settings to sharpen up their accountability and
business outcomes, but primarily should focus on the
Monitoring, evaluation and review are required: outcomes for children and young people.
●● because, if results are not measured, it is
Monitoring, evaluation and review help with the
impossible to tell success from failure
detailed work involved in:
●● because, if success cannot be seen, it cannot be
recognised, rewarded and built on ●● formulating outcomes and goals
●● because, if success is not identified, failure will not ●● developing outcome indicators
be identified and cannot be put right ●● gathering baseline information on the current
73
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Case Study
An example of monitoring the process of implementing
a new policy
In an out-of-school setting, a new bullying policy The above was supported by a series of
is introduced. Most young people are closely structured questions and also took into account
involved and fully participate in its planning and informal feedback. For example, young people
implementation. Practitioners have planned to were asked if practitioners intervened too quickly
monitor the implementation of the new policy: or too often. Did the intervention by practitioners
support young people being bullied or did it
• informally through everyday work make things worse? Did the bullying worsen
• through structured observations off site? Did it draw embarrassing attention to
• through interviews with individual young people individual young people?
• through small groups.
74
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
The new policy seeks to strengthen and make Actions to enable effective
consistent the approach to negative behaviour. The monitoring
new policy spells out the aims. For example:
●● Staff have all been trained in the agreed system to
●● to ensure a safe and secure emotional and physical manage behaviour.
environment for children ●● Clear, transparent and consistent guidelines have
●● to work in partnership with parents/carers in been introduced and shared with parents, whose
supporting children’s development and behaviour comments have been incorporated.
●● to encourage children to respect themselves and ●● Practitioners have been encouraged to reflect on
others and to take responsibility for their actions their practice in this area and reflective practice
●● to promote kindness, understanding and recording documents have been provided.
compassion ●● Simple monitoring forms have been introduced
●● to encourage understanding of fairness and to encourage observation and assessment of
inclusion children’s behaviour at key points in the day/week.
●● to reduce episodes of difficult behaviour by ●● Monitoring forms are also being used in key places
introducing a programme that rewards positive in the nursery to see if the area itself needs to be
behaviour redesigned – for example, a long, empty corridor
●● to introduce ‘circle time’ to discuss feelings and encourages running, and children pushing at a
what is negative/positive behaviour. narrow point.
75
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
76
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
Reflect on the way you were introduced or ●● using appropriate aids to communication.
inducted into the policies and procedures of
your setting. Did you have enough information to In many settings, the full participation of children
implement these? What questions could you have and young people in decisions affecting their lives
asked that might have helped your understanding? is central, and changes to policies and procedures
should be explained carefully. Ideally, children
77
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and young people will have been part of the initial new policy development and implementation will lie
consultations and will be involved in drawing up the with leaders and managers of the setting or service.
policy, according to their age and abilities. Feedback
from children and young people often focuses on Leadership and management
how much they value being listened to. Leaders and managers need to understand how
change works and the processes involved. They
Communicating the use of need to be aware that change is challenging for
new/revised policies to service practitioners and service users. Some will find it
difficult and need a good deal of support to manage
users change. Key areas that managers and leaders need to
As we have commented above, service users take into account when promoting the use of policies
are normally included in the development and are shown in Table 2.2.
implementation of new policies. However,
some service users may have missed out on the Chapter 4 talks about different styles of leadership
consultation procedure and settings will have to and management and there is more information
work with this group to make sure they are fully there that can be applied to policy change.
informed as to the implications of the policy. Management and leadership styles will influence
Written information should always be available on how new policies are promoted in the setting. The
noticeboards or in leaflet form. Letters to parents/ two opposite extremes are the autocratic, on the
carers are sometimes used. In addition, this one hand, and the democratic (participative), on the
information should be freely available on websites other. In practice, the style will vary according to the
or in news sent by text to parents. It is important personality of the leader and to the culture of the
to recognise the specific communication needs of organisation but also to the specific situation.
stakeholders – for example, the need for translation
or interpretation, or the use of assistive technology.
Autocratic approach to
Different approaches promoting the use of policies
Autocratic leadership provides clear expectations
to promoting the use of of the policy change, including what, where, when
policies within the work and how to do it. It is sometimes called a ‘top
down’ or ‘command and control’ style. This style of
role leadership and management can be over-controlling
and dictatorial and does not listen to people. The
Promoting the use of policies in the work role is the changes may be introduced in a way that does not
responsibility of all practitioners, as most policies allow time for people to understand, support and
will have direct relevance to their work. Some become engaged with the issues. Many settings find
practitioners will have particular responsibility that autocratic leadership and management does
as their work role may cover specialism in that not work, and there is high staff dissatisfaction and
area of work. For example, everyone is involved a high turnover. This is bad for children and for the
in implementing care and education for disabled business in private settings. Attempting to change
children, but a special educational needs policy and practice in this way is unlikely to work
coordinator will have specific responsibilities. One well.
of their responsibilities may be to work with other
practitioners to help them to follow the special In emergency situations when a change is urgent,
educational needs policies and support children perhaps after mistakes have been made in a setting,
appropriately. However, the main responsibility for a more autocratic approach may be needed.
78
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
79
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
80
Chapter 2 Understand the role of policies in children and/or young people’s settings (Unit CP 2)
Useful resources
81
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of
children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
82
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
All organisations must have policies to ensure they do you should do and procedures state how you
not break the law – for example, in relation to health should do it.
and safety at work or employment law. Childcare
settings need to be registered in order to operate, If you are an independent practitioner, working
so are legally obliged to meet certain requirements, mostly alone with children and/or young people,
which include staff ratios and qualifications. For you must comply with the legal requirements
example, recruitment policy in a day nursery would of your role and should still follow government
need to ensure that all staff have been checked by recommendations and guidelines about promoting
the Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) as required by health and well-being in the same way as other
law and as part of safeguarding children and young childcare settings. You will find it both helpful
people. More detailed information on policies and and good practice to write down the key principles
procedures can be found in Chapter 2. underpinning your practice in the form of policies so
that you can share these with parents and carers as
It is crucially important that you follow government and when required. It will also provide evidence for
recommendations and guidelines when developing inspections.
your policies for maintaining children and young
people’s health and well-being and for dealing with It is important to recognise the difference between
ill health in the setting because this is based on organisational policy and the contract you might
research that identifies what is effective. have with parents/carers to look after their
children or young people. Both group settings and
Putting in place evidence-based practice for childminders need to have a contract with parents/
maintaining children’s health ensures that you carers, which sets out the care arrangements and
will be implementing best practice in your setting. clarifies the roles and responsibilities of both parents/
By embedding this in organisational policies and carers and the setting. The contract should state what
procedures, you are not only protecting children and the organisation’s policies are and parents/carers
young people’s health and well-being; you are also should understand that, by signing the contract,
safeguarding your organisation and yourself from they agree to abide by the policies. This is especially
any risks and challenges to your practice. important in the case of accidents and emergencies
or the child becoming unwell.
Policies need to be monitored to make sure everyone
follows them and to see how well they are working. It is important to understand that most legislation
It is usually the manager’s responsibility to decide if (Acts of Parliament) will have associated regulations,
any changes are needed by regularly reviewing all which state how the law is intended to be applied in
the policies to make certain they are up to date with practice.
current and emerging practice or, for example, to
meet a change in the law. The role of workplace
Key term
policies and procedures
Policies – these are written statements about how
when caring for an
you will operate in a specific area of practice. unwell child and/or
young person
Procedures or routine methods are established
that detail how work activities should be carried Workplace policies are intended to protect children
out in order to comply with a particular policy; and young people’s health, safety and well-being so
they are the actions needed to implement a that the risk of children being unwell or coming to
particular policy. In short, policies say what harm in the childcare setting is minimised.
83
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Safeguarding
Infection Immunisation
control
Policies for
Managing maintaining
health Record
long-term
keeping
conditions
Managing
illness in First aid
the setting
If you work in a group setting, you are likely to be serious consequences for adults who are exposed to
operating as part of a team of people with different them, especially when pregnant. These principles
skills and levels of responsibility. Therefore, it is also apply if you work alone, say, as a childminder,
important to have policies and procedures in place because many childhood illnesses are highly
so that everyone is clear about their individual contagious and can quickly spread within and outside
accountability for the health and well-being of the your setting.
children and young people in their care and that
practitioners understand what to do if a child or It is good practice for policies to state their aims or
young person becomes unwell. rationale, as it clarifies the purpose, which helps when
developing a policy and the associated procedures. The
If you work alone, you still need information about following are examples of policies concerned with the
the health of the children you care for and have health and well-being of children and young people.
procedures in place to deal with a sick child, so that
the other children in your care are protected at the
same time. You will probably want to develop a
Health and safety policy
‘Managing illness/sick child’ policy. A health and safety policy should be proactive in
preventing accidents. Larger organisations may
There are a number of different policies that have have a designated Health and Safety Officer, who
a role in protecting and maintaining the health will be responsible for ensuring that the underlying
of children and young people, and there can be procedures are in place to implement the policy. In
sometimes be overlap between them. Policies should smaller settings, it is likely that the manager will
also consider the health of staff and colleagues, since, take on this role; independent practitioners, such
for example, some childhood illnesses can have as childminders, will need to ensure that they have
84
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
85
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The procedures should state who is responsible for all the methods by which infection can be spread
collecting the information, how other members within the setting – for example, through sharing
of staff should be informed (e.g. through regular toys, through close contact between children and
staff meetings or daily briefings) and who is adults within and outside the setting and through
responsible for making sure everyone is aware of personal hygiene practices.
their responsibilities for confidentiality, including
the boundaries of confidentiality (e.g. the manager Key term
or deputy manager, or an allocated person to
whom this responsibility has been delegated). Pathogen – something (an organism) that causes
disease in humans, such as a virus or bacteria.
Precaution Description
Routine hand-washing Involves following proper procedures and using effective techniques, e.g.
using liquid soap, covering all surfaces of hands and fingers and rubbing
all for at least 30 seconds, rinsing under running water and drying
thoroughly with disposable towels. Hand-washing is the most effective
method of preventing infection.
Personal protective clothing Use disposable gloves and plastic, waterproof aprons whenever you
are likely to come into contact with body fluids. Personal protective
clothing is worn according to the level of risk identified, hence additional
protection such as face masks, goggles and special footwear are not
usually necessary in childcare settings.
Disposing of waste safely Use separate bags according to your local authority regulations (found
on the local website or on www.directgov.co.uk). For example, yellow for
potentially infected material.
Dealing with soiled clothing Place in a plastic bag to take home; use a professional laundry service
or wash using industrial washing and drying machines. Soiled laundry
should be laundered separately using a pre-wash cycle and washed on
a hot wash according to instructions.
Dealing with spillages Soak up with paper and dispose into infected waste bag. For blood and
other body fluids, soak affected area with a solution of bleach (one part
bleach to ten parts water) before cleaning with disinfectant and allowing
to dry thoroughly.
86
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
adopting universal precautions will protect everyone ●● Cleaning products and methods, including
in the setting from most pathogens and reduce the different cloths/mops for floors and surfaces,
risk of cross-contamination and infection. methods of cleaning, suitable cleaning agents and
safe storage of these (see COSHH regulations).
Sources of infection ●● Dealing with accidental spillages, especially
Infections and diseases are caused by micro- those which may be contaminated (see Table 3.1).
●● Hand-washing procedures for staff and children/
organisms (microbes or germs). These are present
everywhere, although not all micro-organisms young people (see Table 3.1). For example, when and
cause infection. Microbes that can cause infection how often hands should be washed and personal
are known as pathogens. The human body has a hygiene (e.g. uniforms, practical clothing, dealing
variety of defences available, so conditions have to with personal hygiene issues in children or staff).
●● Nappy changing procedure, including disposal
be right for pathogens to thrive, breed and become
sufficiently numerous to overcome the body’s of soiled nappies.
●● Personal protective clothing – for example,
defences.
gloves, aprons or similar to cover personal
Pathogens are spread by any of the following means: clothing and when to use them (see Table 3.1).
●● Food handling and storage procedure – for
●● Direct contact – in which microbes are spread
example, stock rotation, proper storage of raw and
through body fluids, such as saliva (through
cooked food.
kissing), blood, urine, faeces, nasal discharge or
●● Infectious illnesses and diseases notification
other infected body fluids (e.g. the pus from boils,
and exclusion procedure (see ‘Sick child policy’ on
abscesses, etc.).
●● Indirect contact – in which pathogens are spread
page 90).
through touching hands or objects, such as toys,
bedding, toothbrushes, water, food, animals and Food and nutrition policy
animal faeces. Food and nutrition are of crucial importance to the
●● Airborne – in which pathogens are spread through health of growing children and young people and
the air, carried on airborne particles such as dust or poor diet in the early years of life can have long-term
in respiratory droplets (e.g. sneezing or coughing). health consequences (see Section 3). It is important
●● Water – some pathogens breed in water, such to recognise that children, especially young children,
as legionella pneumophila, which causes have significantly different nutritional requirements to
Legionnaires’ disease. adults (see Table 3.2, Section 3), so it is crucial that you
●● Arthropods – these are insects or bugs such as follow government guidelines and recommendations
mosquitoes, lice, ticks and fleas that can carry for feeding babies, children and young people.
infection, which is transmitted to humans through
Food and nutrition requirements are set out in the
biting, sucking or burrowing under the skin.
Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS) Framework
Sometimes their droppings are also sources of
and the food standards for school lunches, which can
infection.
be found in ‘Guidance for food and drink provision
The principles of infection control are intended to in early years settings (March 2010)’ issued by the
prevent the spread of disease and infection by any of School Food Trust (see www.schoolfoodtrust.org.uk).
these routes.
Additional information can be found on the
Procedures to control infection in the setting include: following sites:
●● Routine and regular cleaning of the setting, ●● The Department of Health’s document Birth to
including floors, toys, equipment and hard Five: www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/
surfaces. Also routine cleaning of food preparation Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/
and storage areas. DH_107303
87
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
88
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
person until medical assistance is available. The key be unable to manage their medication without help.
purposes of first aid are: You may be required to supervise the child or young
person to administer his or her own medication. It is
●● to prevent further injury
important that you do not administer any medication
●● to preserve life
●● to promote recovery.
to a child or young person unless you are authorised
to do so by a parent or medical practitioner and your
organisation’s policy permits this.
The following procedures should be included in a
first aid policy: Your policy should cover the safe storage of
●● Accident and emergency procedures – the medicines and be clear about restrictions on
response of the first person on the scene and who is able to administer medicines, the range
procedure for summoning medical assistance of medications that can be given and under what
(999). circumstances. These may be either regular
●● Designated first aider/first aid coordinator medicines because of an ongoing health condition
responsibilities. (e.g. inhalers, insulin) or occasional medicines,
●● Emergency contact procedure, including such as antibiotics. In addition, a medicine policy
information and contact numbers. should cover the emergency administration of
●● First aid box – procedure for checking and medicines – for example, EpiPen for allergic reactions
replenishing contents, including responsibility for or analgesics such as paracetamol or ibuprofen to
this. reduce pain and fever.
●● Anaphylaxis procedure, including emergency
Procedures in place to implement the medicine
interventions (e.g. EpiPen administration). For
policy are likely to include the following:
more information on anaphylaxis, see www.
anaphylaxis.org.uk, www.allergyuk.org/severe- ●● Arrangements for storing medication – for
allergy-and-anaphylaxis/anaphylaxis or www. example, labelling. Some medicines need storing
resus.org.uk/pages/reaction.pdf, as well as NICE in the fridge.
guidelines (www.nice.org.uk/Search.do?x=25&y= ●● Consent form/authorisation from parents/
12&searchText=+anaphylaxis&newsearch=true#/ carers.
search/?reload). ●● Administration of medicines – for example,
who is authorised to give medicines in the
In addition to a first aid qualification, staff looking setting or supervise children/young people self-
after allergic children should seek medical training medicating.
on how to manage severe allergic reactions. This ●● Recording of medicines given, including time and
may be available from their local health authority. by whom.
They should also work closely with the parents of ●● Procedure for administering analgesics (links
any allergic child. with sick child policy; see below).
General information can be obtained from The It is good practice to ensure that staff are trained
British Allergy Foundation, Deepdene House, 30 in the administration and storage of common
Bellgrove Road, Welling, Kent DA16 3PY (0208 303 medicines before being allocated responsibility,
8525 or their helpline, 0208 303 8583) or from their to make sure they have the knowledge and skills
website (www.allergyuk.org). to administer medicines safely. See Chapter 2
for more details of the National Day Nurseries’
Medicine policy (NDNA) sample policy on medication (pages 58–60).
It is important to have a policy in place for managing Also see the Department of Health’s guidance on
medicines that children and young people may need managing medicines in schools: www.education.
to take. This is particularly relevant if you look after gov.uk/schools/pupilsupport/pastoralcare/b0013771/
children who have long-term conditions or who may managing-medicines-in-schools.
89
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
90
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
very seriously. We believe the welfare of the child is such as polio and measles because we are not aware
paramount, as stated in the Children Act 1989. Our of the devastating consequences that were all too
staff are carefully recruited and vetted and undertake frequent before immunisation. In recent years,
regular accredited training and development in Child there has been some controversy about the safety of
Protection. We work in an open and transparent immunisation, especially in relation to a suspected
way with both parents and children to ensure their link with autism. However, the research upon which
safety.’ these fears were based has now been thoroughly
discredited.
The procedures underpinning a safeguarding policy
should cover the following areas: It is not currently compulsory to have children
immunised in the UK. However, childcare settings
●● Child protection, including the designated
have a responsibility and a duty of care towards all
person for child protection, for example, liaising
the children they look after, as well as the staff. The
with other agencies, using the Common
prevention of disease requires a given number of
Assessment Framework.
people to be immune to the disease and vaccination
●● Safe working practices – for example, personal
is the best way to ensure this (see ‘Key term: herd
care procedures and the guidelines regarding
immunity’ in Section 6, page 114).
visibility; respecting personal boundaries with
young people; age-appropriate contact with Because of this, the immunisation of children
children and young people who are distressed wishing to attend the setting cannot be a matter for
and in need of comfort and reassurance; the individual parents to choose. While it is acceptable
importance of challenging and recording when for adults to take risks with their own health, by
such guidelines are broken. failing to immunise their children, they risk serious
●● Training and development – for example, harm to other children and adults, and leave their
the arrangements for regular staff training and own children exposed to the risk of serious disease,
what this should cover; when to suspect child which may have long-term consequences. This can
maltreatment; recognising signs of abuse; awareness be argued to be contrary to their own child’s best
of risk factors (child, family, community); dealing interests and poses unacceptable risk – because it is
with disclosure; what action to take – reporting and preventable – to others. Childcare settings have a
recording; dealing with parents/carers. clear role to play in supporting this important aspect
●● Reporting procedures – for example, who to of public health.
report to and in what format, including reporting
‘The Healthy Child team, led by a health
the behaviour of other staff that might cause
visitor working with other practitioners,
concern; how to contribute to multi-agency
should check the immunisation record
processes for dealing with child protection; record
(including the personal child health record)
keeping and confidentiality.
of each child aged up to 5 years. They should
For further information and guidance on good carry out this check when the child joins a day
practice, see: http://publications.nice.org.uk/when-to- nursery, nursery school, playgroup, Sure Start
suspect-child-maltreatment-cg89/guidance. children’s centre or when they start primary
school. The check should be carried out in
Immunisation policy conjunction with childcare or education staff
and the parents.’
Why have an immunisation policy? Immunisation
is the most effective method of preventing a range Source: NICE (http://publications.nice.org.uk/
of serious illnesses, many of which caused death or reducing-differences-in-the-uptake-of-immunisations-
disability in the past. One consequence of routine ph21/recommendations#recommendation-1-
vaccination is that we have lost our fear of diseases immunisation-programmes)
91
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
A policy statement about immunisation could we example, due to changes in temperature or weather
worded as follows: conditions, or if the child contracts a cold. In some
children, eczema can be worse in hot weather and
‘Happy Days nursery is committed to promoting and
asthma can sometimes be affected by exercise or by
supporting the health of all the children attending the
very cold weather conditions.
nursery. We therefore expect parents to have their
children immunised in line with the UK immunisation A suggested policy statement might be:
schedule, in order to protect all the children from
preventable diseases. We work closely with the health ‘Happy Days nursery offers an inclusive and holistic
services and will be happy to discuss your child’s learning environment for all children, including those
immunisation requirements with you.’ with special requirements. Our trained staff are able
to support children with a range of needs, including
Procedures underpinning the setting’s immunisation those with long-term health conditions. It is our policy
policy could include the following: to discuss your child’s particular needs and agree an
individual learning and support plan with you.’
●● Recording and updating the child’s immunisation
status in the setting’s child health records. Procedures may overlap with other policy areas –
●● Liaising with health professionals – for for example, recording children’s allergies and
example, the Healthy Child team to facilitate the communicating these to the other staff or following
uptake of immunisations. infection control procedures when dealing with
●● Identifying vulnerable children who may not eczema. It is good practice to develop an individual
have been immunised or who have an incomplete care plan for children with long-term conditions in
record and helping parents arrange for them to be partnership with the parents.
immunised.
●● Ensuring staff are fully immunised, Guidance on eczema and asthma can be found on
encouraging and facilitating this where necessary. the following websites:
●● Atopic eczema in children: http://publications.nice.
Some settings may be able to allow immunisation org.uk/atopic-eczema-in-children-cg57
to take place on the premises and this could also be ●● Guidance on the use of inhaler systems: http://
built into the policy. publications.nice.org.uk/guidance-on-the-use-of-
inhaler-systems-devices-in-children-under-the-
Managing long-term age-of-5-years-with-chronic-ta10.
conditions policy
Some children attending the setting may have specific Activity
health needs or possibly suffer from a long-term
condition. In most cases, the parents and the individual Develop a policy for managing allergies in the setting,
including first aid and emergency procedures for
child will be able to manage their own condition.
managing anaphylaxis. Include the following areas:
However, staff need to know what to look for if the
condition should deteriorate while the child is in the • common allergies (food and non-food)
setting and what actions must and must not be taken. • procedure for communicating allergic information
Details should be documented in the child’s records. within the setting
• identifying children who are at risk of anaphylaxis
Common long-term conditions include allergies,
diabetes, asthma and eczema. However, you may • recognising signs of anaphylaxis
also be caring for children who have treatable • emergency treatment of anaphylaxis in the setting
conditions such as heart defects and are awaiting • recording and reporting procedures
surgery, or those who have disabilities. From time
• a plan for monitoring and reviewing the policy.
to time, some conditions can become worse – for
92
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
93
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
for professionally and that they are at least as safe as might be responsible for their illness; this
they would be if cared for at home – if not more so information should be clearly documented in
as the majority of accidents for children under five the child’s records. For example, children who
years old take place at home. In addition, parents are diabetic may have episodes of hypoglycemia
can be confident that, if their child becomes unwell (low blood sugar) because their diabetes is not
in the setting, all the staff will know what to do and well controlled. Similarly, if a child with diabetes
appropriate action will be taken to manage their contracts an infection, it is likely to destabilise
illness until the parent or medical help is able to take their diabetes, making it more difficult to
over. control.
We have identified that policies are only worthwhile It is important for childcare workers to be able to
if they are properly implemented, monitored and recognise signs and symptoms of illness in the
reviewed regularly to make sure they keep up children or young people they care for in order to act
with best practice and meet legal requirements. responsibly and in the child’s best interests. Practical
This ensures that the staff in the setting are action may be needed; however, for the most part,
not inadvertently breaking the law. Policies are children who are ill in the setting need reassurance,
implemented through everyone following set comfort and monitoring.
procedures, so that everyone is clear about their roles
and responsibilities, thus minimising any likelihood For general information on managing long-term
of poor practice. conditions, see www.education.gov.uk/schools/
pupilsupport/pastoralcare/b0013771/managing-
medicines-in-schools.
Activity
1 Review your setting’s sick child policy, including Common signs that a
the reasons for the policy and arrangements for
monitoring.
child or young person
2 Carry out research to identify best practice in may be unwell
managing children who become ill in the setting.
The signs that a child or young person is feeling
3 Write a report comparing and contrasting
unwell often vary according to the particular illness
your setting’s policy with best practice,
making recommendations for any changes and the age of the child or young person. Whereas
that could be made and the rationale for your older children are able to articulate or explain how
recommendations. they are feeling – for example, ‘I feel hot’, ‘My head
hurts’, ‘I feel sick’ – babies and young children lack
the vocabulary. Because of this, it is important to
Section 2: The role of the know the difference between signs of illness and
symptoms of illness. Young children often complain
practitioner in supporting of ‘tummy ache’ when they feel unwell, whatever the
94
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
95
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
For more information on managing children with Until the child is collected, the manager should
diabetes in schools and childcare settings, see make arrangements for a member of staff to
www.childrenwithdiabetes.com/uk and the report remain with the child who is unwell or to check
of the UK Children With Diabetes Advocacy their condition regularly if they are fit to be left
Group. (e.g. if they fall asleep). It is important that the
child is assessed regularly – every ten minutes
The roles and or so – to make sure their condition has not
deteriorated.
responsibilities of the
If the situation becomes urgent and the child’s
practitioner if a child condition worsens (e.g. febrile convulsions,
and/or young person unconsciousness or severe asthmatic attack),
then medical assistance should be summoned
is unwell immediately and the parents informed. The child
will need to be accompanied on any hospital visit by
In most group settings, one childcare professional
a member of staff until the parents arrive.
will be in charge of a small group of children;
the number of children in a particular group will The nursery manager will need to ensure that
depend on the age and capabilities of the children there are sufficient members of staff to cover such
and will comply with registration ratios. This emergencies, perhaps by having staff on standby,
person will be the key worker for the children in for example. The manager will also need to ensure
the group. It is the responsibility of the child or that staff have the appropriate training to deal with
young person’s key worker to observe the children emergencies for those children with long-term
or young people they work with as part of their conditions, such as diabetes, allergies or epilepsy, in
duty to assess the learning and development of which medication may need to be administered as a
the child or young person. As such, they will first response.
be expected to notice any signs that the child is
becoming unwell or is actively ill.
Actions to be taken by
The key worker will be expected to follow the
setting’s policy and procedures for dealing with
the practitioner
illness, which should include reporting their concerns The actions required by the practitioner will, of
to the nursery manager or senior worker in the first course, depend on the situation and the child or
instance. Decisions should be taken jointly regarding young person in question. The appropriate response
the appropriate course of action (e.g. checking for is likely to be quite different if, for example the child
symptoms or administering medication). has an accident, from the response if the child has
a long-term condition that has deteriorated or if the
In the case of children with long-term conditions
child or young person becomes unexpectedly ill in
who become unwell at nursery, it is good practice
the setting.
to have an individual care plan drawn up with the
parents for managing the particular condition and
this should include any action that should be taken
The child and/or young person
if the situation is urgent. As a childcare practitioner working with small
groups, you will get to know the children in your
It is important to contact the parents or carers to care quite well, so you are in a good position to pick
make arrangements for the child to be collected and up on signs that they may not be well – for example,
looked after at home as soon as possible – this is best changes in usual behaviour. If you suspect a child
for the child who is unwell and the other children in is becoming unwell, you should take the following
the setting. actions.
96
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
●● Observation and assessment: you need to observe vomited or had a fit, or any other significant physical
the child and note any differences from normal, reaction, this must also be explained simply at the
including behaviour, appetite, complaints and time, not just ignored. Witnessing other children
anything unusual. being ill can frighten some children.
●● Monitoring: you need to monitor the child
throughout the session and take note of any In accident situations, you may need to gently
improvement or deterioration in the child’s question the other children to confirm what actually
condition. happened, especially if you did not see the moment
●● Recording: it is advisable to record your observations of the accident yourself. Write down what the
in the child’s records, making sure you stick to what children actually say, in their own words. This is
you observed or what the child said, rather than necessary for medical staff and so that parents have
speculating on what might be the matter. a clear understanding that accidents can happen
despite rigorous risk assessment, as you cannot plan
You need to be clear about lines of accountability and for all eventualities.
who is responsible for making decisions in relation
to the child’s well-being. Any action or intervention, Reporting procedures
such as giving medication, needs to be carefully It is crucial to report any accidents or illness to
documented, following the setting’s procedures your line manager or responsible person (e.g. first
and providing the parents/carers have given written aid officer); failure to do so can leave individual
permission. Other actions are likely to include practitioners or the organisation at risk of legal
removing the child to a safe, quiet space if they are action in some circumstances. Filling out correct
too poorly to participate in activities. They may need forms and completing daily records is an important
distraction if distressed or in pain and all will need aspect of this. Forms could include accident/incident
comfort and reassurance from familiar childcare forms (RIDDOR), medicine forms, health records,
workers/their key worker. etc. There should be protocols in place for when
to call emergency services (999) or to phone the
If the situation is urgent – for example, if there has
NHS helpline. It is also helpful to liaise with local
been an accident – it is important to remain calm and
health services and, although it is the parent/carer’s
not panic. The designated first aider should deal with
responsibility to report the child’s health issue to the
the injured child, following procedures, and other
GP, it would be helpful to ensure this happens.
staff should focus on the remaining children, who
may be frightened and concerned for their friend. If
you are a sole practitioner, you need to implement Parent(s)/carer(s)
first aid and call medical assistance (999) if necessary Whenever a child is unwell in the setting, a decision
and the parents/carers at the first opportunity. has to be taken regarding whether it is possible for
them to remain until they are collected at the usual
time or whether to contact parents immediately.
Other children and/or The point at which parents are informed of the
young people child’s condition will be the decision of the manager.
Other children in the setting may be aware when a However, in emergency situations or with serious
child is unwell and are likely to be curious, especially incidents, the parents should be contacted at once.
if the sick child is removed from the main area to a Similarly, if a child has vomited and is clearly
quiet space or designated medical room. It is best unwell, parents should be contacted and asked to
to explain, using simple language, that ‘Bobby is collect the child in line with managing illness in
feeling poorly and has gone to be quiet while he the setting (sick child) procedures. It is important,
waits for his mummy or daddy to come and take him when speaking to parents, to reassure them that
home’, keep calm, reassure the children and distract appropriate action has been taken and their child
them – perhaps with a group activity. If the child has is safe. You should clearly state the condition of the
97
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
child and what action has been taken, and arrange Food, diet and nutritional
for the child to be collected either from the setting or
from the medical treatment centre, confirming the factors affecting health
time they are likely to arrive. Bear in mind, it may The guidance on infant feeding is clear, evidence
take parents/carers some time to make arrangements based and available to the public. The government
to leave work and make their way to the setting. appoints the Scientific Advisory Committee on
Nutrition to carry out research and examine the
Completing workplace records evidence before advising on infant feeding practices.
When completing workplace records, the importance This forms the basis of health and nutritional
of accuracy cannot be overstated. Such records can advice to parents given by health professionals and
provide evidence that the setting acted properly and made available to parents (e.g. Birth to Five and the
in good faith, with the safety and well-being of the Healthy Child programme).
child paramount. As such, it is very important that
However, decisions about feeding and diet are
you only document what you observed yourself,
very personal and parents may choose not to
not what other people saw. You can include the
follow such advice. Children’s health over their
information and opinions of other staff, providing
lifetime is affected by the food choices that are
you make clear that is what it is.
made for them and that they, in turn, make for
themselves. As a childcare professional, you
Section 3: Possible factors should be aware of what current guidelines are
affecting health in children and the evidence on which it is based. You have
a responsibility to follow government guidelines
and/or young people and for the children in your care and help parents
to make informed choices about their children’s
how to promote health diet, starting from the very early days. You should
also be aware of the likely consequences for the
While there are many factors affecting the health child’s health if parents choose not to follow such
of children and young people, socio-economic advice and suggest they discuss any issues with
factors, including overall income levels, have been a health professional. You should be clear that it
consistently demonstrated to underlie many of the is the policy in your setting to follow government
issues. Income levels can affect people’s choices and recommendations on food, diet and nutrition
access to a healthy lifestyle, which in turn affects (see www.schoolfoodtrust.org.uk/download/
children’s health. documents/pdf/early_years_food_and_nutrition_
Children and young people need educating on how guidance.pdf).
to live healthy lifestyles and good role models from
Young children’s nutritional needs are quite different
the people around them, including childcare workers.
from adults. Because of their small size and hence
Possible factors which small stomachs, they need what are known as
‘energy dense’ foods. These are foods with a lot of
influence health in calories in small portions. However, it is important
that these foods provide proper nutrition, not
children and young just a lot of calories. For example, you could say
people that chocolate is an energy-dense food because it
contains a lot of fat and sugar. However, it does
Food and nutrition are important because they not not contain much nutrition, such as vitamins or
only impact on growth and development in the early minerals. It is better to offer starchy foods, such as
years but can impact on achievement as well as set peanut butter sandwiches or cheese, and things like
up eating habits for a lifetime. dried fruit instead of chocolate.
98
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
Common factors affecting babies’ and young the bedtime feed, once solid food is an established
children’s diets are as follows: part of the diet.
●● Overfeeding due to anxiety – for example, Older children and young people’s eating habits will
feeding the baby first when it is crying instead be determined by the type of foods they have been
of working out if the baby is crying for some exposed to and their own food preferences, in turn
other reason. If the baby’s natural mechanism for influenced by household eating habits and advertising.
regulating appetite is regularly overruled, it stops
being effective, predisposing the child to obesity.
●● Weaning too early – before six months of age. Case Study Infant feeding
This tends to happen more frequently if the baby
has been overfed. Sue McGregor is the single, teenage parent
●● Unsuitable foods introduced too early – for of Nathan, who you have agreed to look after
example, tea, chocolate, biscuits, breakfast cereal, as a registered childminder specialising in
cow’s milk. supporting young mothers. Nathan is almost
●● Too much milk due to a delay in weaning off six months old and Sue has started to work
breast or bottle. With breastfeeding, the milk part-time for three days per week. Nathan
gradually reduces as solid food is introduced and has started weaning and has two meals per
the infant only takes what it needs. If bottle-fed, day. There is a family history of eczema and
this is controlled by the parent and sometimes asthma.
the balance is wrong. If the child is refusing
Sue has brought Nathan’s food for the day,
solids, parents tend to overcompensate by giving
which is:
milk.
●● Poor family diet, including an over-reliance on • a jar of egg custard and rice
pre-prepared or microwavable meals. • a baby yogurt
●● Instant baby foods– while these are convenient • a chocolate flake.
and can be used as part of an infant feeding
regime, they are high in water content, bland and 1 Identify the advantages and disadvantages of
low in nutrition. Babies fed exclusively on these this diet for Nathan.
often have difficulty adjusting to a normal diet 2 Describe how you might support Sue in
and can turn into ‘fussy eaters’. feeding Nathan according to government
●● Maternal anxiety – mothers are afraid to let a guidelines.
young child go without food and, if solids are 3 What are the risks to Nathan’s health of this
refused, give milk to make sure they are fed (see diet?
above). It helps to introduce a cup and water to 4 Identify three reasons why Sue might be
drink and wean off the bottle or breast, except for offering such a diet to Nathan?
99
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Information on infant feeding can be found at: processed and this often forms the basis of dreams.
It is also thought that sleep is necessary for the
●● Department of Health: www.dh.gov.uk
●● The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition:
development of memory and it is also important for
achievement.
www.sacn.gov.uk
●● Food Standards Agency: www.food.gov.uk.
A toddler needs between ten and twelve hours of
sleep per day, although this does not all have to be
The influence of exercise or at night. Most young children benefit from a nap
recreation and leisure on health during the day. However, even if they do not sleep, it
is important to have a rest period during the day.
Babies and young children are very active as a
rule and it is important that they have plenty of Adolescents also experience a growth spurt,
opportunities to play both indoors and outdoors. including in brain development. It has been
suggested that, in adolescence, a person’s ‘body
Exercise helps to strengthen bones and muscles and
clock’ alters, changing their sleep patterns and
helps to prevent obesity. This is important because
making it more difficult for them to get up in
the number of children who are either obese or in
the morning. Adolescents need as much sleep as
danger of becoming obese is increasing rapidly.
young children because of this growth spurt so it
Obese children are more likely to develop health
is most unfair to label them as ‘lazy’ when they are
conditions such as diabetes, and extra weight also
undergoing a biological process.
puts a strain on joints and the heart.
As a result of changing lifestyles, children and young
All children need opportunities for exploring the
people of all ages have more access to technology
outdoor environment to increase their confidence.
than previously. Research has indicated that using
It is important to have a balanced approach so that
technology such as mobile phones, television,
calculated risks can be taken which enable the
computer games and ipods can stimulate the brain
child to feel a sense of achievement and heightened
and make it more difficult for children and young
self-esteem, while minimising obvious dangers. It
people to “switch off”, particularly as playing
has been suggested that children of parents who
games and social networking are extremely popular
are risk-averse lack confidence and are less able to
communal activities shared with friends. Many of
manage risk, leaving them in more danger.
these devices are small, portable and can be used
anywhere – including in bed, so it is more difficult
The influence of rest, sleep for parents to prevent over-use.
and/or lifestyle on health Poor sleep habits impair performance and this can
Sleep is crucial for babies, children and young have a profound effect on the ability to achieve
people. During sleep, the brain replenishes the potential and on mental health in the long term. It
chemicals that influence the functioning of the is important, therefore, to help parents and children
central nervous system – the neuro-transmitters such establish good sleeping patterns – for example, by
as dopamine and noradrenaline. These particularly insisting on switching computers off, having a wind-
affect coordination, mood and behaviour. It is down period, and leaving mobile phones downstairs.
therefore no surprise that sleep difficulties, including
insufficient sleep, are associated with behavioural The influence of preventing
problems in children, including hyperactivity and
difficulty concentrating.
infection on health
Children can easily catch infections, particularly in a
Children need more sleep than adults because they group setting as infections are quickly passed from
are growing physically, but also because their brain one person to another. This is why it is important for
is developing. During sleep, the day’s events get the setting to have an infection control policy and
100
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
pay attention to hygiene. Many children suffer from One of the most significant influences on children’s
frequent upper respiratory infections, especially if social and emotional health is child maltreatment,
they are regularly exposed to cigarette smoke. This which means physical, emotional, intellectual or
can have a lasting effect, causing such problems as, sexual abuse, neglect, bullying or harassment.
for example, glue ear or chronic chest infection. Glue Evidence shows that children who have been
ear is particularly problematic as it impairs hearing maltreated are much more likely to suffer from
and can therefore affect speech. Children who cannot depression as children and go on to develop mental
hear well may be thought to be naughty or not paying health problems as adults.
attention. It can also affect their confidence and
ability to form relationships with peers. Emerging research on brain development suggests
that the constant fear experienced by children
Some children also suffer from repeated diarrhoea – who are abused can affect the way the brain
so-called toddler diarrhoea. If it is accompanied by develops, with lifelong consequences. For very
vomiting, it is usually due to infection and the child young children, neglect can affect their ability to
should be excluded. Some children, however, suffer form strong attachments (see Chapter 6 page 197
from diarrhoea for no apparent reason. They are onwards), and in severe cases, such neurological
usually of normal weight and healthy with a good changes can result in Reactive Attachment
appetite. It has been suggested that it is caused by Disorder (see: www.psychnet-uk.com for more
food intolerance or following an infection. However, information).
its cause is unknown, although it has been associated
Brain scans have demonstrated the difference in
with excessive drinking. Stools typically contain
children’s brain development and particularly in
undigested food and are frequent and watery.
the amygdala – the structure that is involved in
Children who have chronic infections usually miss a processing many of our emotions, such as fear,
lot of schooling in the early days, which impacts on anger and pleasure, and motivations, particularly
overall school achievement unless they are actively those that are related to survival. The amygdala is
helped to make up for lost time. also responsible for determining what memories
are stored and where the memories are stored in
Emotional and social influences the brain. It is thought that this difference between
those who have suffered abuse, including neglect,
on health and others who have not is based on how huge an
Children need supportive relationships with adults emotional response an event invokes, how often it is
who care for them in order to provide a secure basis repeated and how long it continues.
from which to explore the world. This includes
developing friendships and becoming part of a Academics have concluded that what matters for
group. Clearly, any issue that impacts on a parent’s every child are:
ability to care for a child, such as parental physical ●● secure attachments to carers
or mental ill-health, or substance abuse, will have a ●● good-quality childcare provided by people who
corresponding affect on the child or young person’s are interested in the child
mental health and wellbeing: the child/young person ●● interest and love from parents and carers.
can feel powerless and overwhelmed in the face
of such problems. Similarly, bullying can make a If these are not available within the family, action
child or young person feel excluded from friendship has to be taken to ensure that they are provided
groups, and recent studies show that even very elsewhere. Just as food is necessary to nourish
young children can suffer from clinical depression, growth, security, positive regard and loving kindness
with some victims of bullying, including are necessary to nourish brain development (see
cyber-bullying (using technology and social http://publications.nice.org.uk/social-and-emotional-
networking), taking their own lives. wellbeing-in-primary-education-ph12).
101
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
102
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
The influence of advertising on Children and young people can be made to feel
very vulnerable, particularly during adolescence,
prevention of infection when the desire to fit in with peers is part of
The role of advertising in preventing infection is forming a separate identity from parents. This can
to promote products that kill germs. They include lead to low self-esteem and, in extreme cases, self-
household products that suggest anti-bacterial harm. Other young people might turn to crime in
wipes are all that is needed to keep homes clean and an attempt to secure money or goods to boost their
germ-free. Many of the personal hygiene products status.
are untested and some have been considered to
be unsafe (e.g. vaginal deodorants for women). While younger children do not feel the same pressure
Many of the chemicals in adult personal hygiene of brands, it is still the case that there will be certain
products have not been tested and some are known toys or games that are seen as the best and children
carcinogens in other species. will strive to have them. Manufacturers compete to
be the toy that is the ‘must have’ every Christmas
Products for children are more tightly regulated, and advertising contributes enormously to this.
especially since children are smaller and thus more
at risk from toxic chemicals. However, an anti- As long as brands, goods and products are intimately
bacterial chemical used in many products has been bound up with status, wealth and self-esteem,
linked to an increase in allergies. Similarly, arachis advertising will continue to contribute indirectly to
oil, derived from peanuts and found in some creams, poorer mental health.
has been linked to peanut allergy in children.
Activity
In terms of babies and children, many products
are advertised that are unnecessary and may even Describe the role of the Advertising Standards
contribute to poorer health outcomes. For example, Agency in the regulation of adverts.
dermatologists have tried to discourage the use
of baby wipes, as they seem to be associated with
eczema, due to the different chemicals the wipes are
impregnated with. Possible ways of
The most effective method of preventing infection
promoting health
is to ensure personal hygiene, particularly frequent Health promotion is only effective if it is able to get
hand-washing. a clear message across to the target audience in a
meaningful way. It is therefore important that, when
The influence of advertising promoting health among children and young people,
age, gender and a range of factors are considered
on emotional and social
when designing a campaign. It is helpful to have a
health focus group made up of a representative sample of
Advertising can affect emotional and social health your target audience.
in a negative way because it aims to make people
dissatisfied so they will want to purchase goods and Health promotion in itself does not change
services. In other words, it is intended to stimulate behaviour; however, it can stimulate discussion
consumption. The branding is powerful; nevertheless and make people think. Some people may change
many of the products advertised are beyond reach behaviour as a result and if sufficient people are
for a majority of people. This has led to children motivated to change – the ‘critical mass’ – then the
and young people being bullied as some brands, new behaviour becomes more socially acceptable
especially expensive designer brands, are seen as than the previous behaviour. An example of this is
high status and hence confer status on the wearer. smoking among young people, which is considered
103
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
socially unacceptable in some groups and an recommendations for exercise and learning how
unappealing habit to have on a date! exercise is necessary for your body throughout
life.
It is important to use things that are of interest to ●● Games and sport – for example, examining
children and young people to act as a vehicle for athletes and their lifestyle, including diet and
promoting health messages. If there is a particular nutrition, rest and sleep, training routines and
area in which a message is needed, you need to compare to children’s own lifestyles, getting the
stimulate the interest first before you can deliver the children to suggest what changes they could make
message. and how they think they would benefit. Progress
charts and prizes for most improved over a month
Food, diet and nutrition could be provided as an incentive.
There has recently been a great deal of work done ●● Making music could be used as a health
in relation to healthy school meals and raising promotion activity in several ways. For example,
awareness of healthy eating among children. A the dangers of music that is too loud and how
number of strategies were used to get children it damages hearing, with children making
interested in food and ready to try new foods, since suggestions on how to avoid this, perhaps
children and adults sometimes tend to stick to the inventing some ear protectors.
things they know and like. If the diet is poor and
children are only exposed to a limited range of foods, Rest, sleep and/or lifestyle
it becomes more difficult to eat healthily. Health promotion activities could cover issues such
as the following:
Suggested ways of engaging children’s interest in
food include the following: ●● Computer games – do children think they are
influenced by computer games? Is this positively
●● Ask children to bring in an item of food that
or negatively? Is there a difference for boys and
they are unfamiliar with and get small groups
girls? What actions can children take to enhance
of children to find out about their novelty food.
the positive and minimise the negative?
These foods could then be tasted by each child in
●● Alcohol and drugs could be the focus of health
the group and compared. Another strategy would
promotion activities for young people – for
be to incorporate the foods into a meal or dish that
example, designing their own programme and
the children help to cook.
carrying it out with peers.
●● Put together a cookbook with recipes from around
●● Importance of sleep – for younger children, look
the world – this works well in multicultural
at sleep in pets and animals (e.g. hibernation) to
settings. Alternatively, hold an open day for
raise awareness of its importance. They could then
parents and ask everyone to bring a national or
develop an individual ‘sleep plan’ and try it for
regional dish and be prepared to swap recipes.
two weeks before evaluating it (e.g. has it made a
●● For older children, find out about ‘celebrity diets’
difference to how they feel?).
and examine them for their nutritional content –
this activity could raise awareness of the problems All of these activities could be included in a lifestyle
of dieting. quiz or questionnaire to carry out as a competition.
104
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
demonstrations, competitions, using different lifestyles, children and young people are dependent
soaps/cleansers, making a video, using the on their parents. Therefore, you need to design a
laboratory to check bacteria on hands before and health promotion activity with the children or young
after washing for older children, etc. would all people you care for that will have an impact on
help to get the message across. parents and that children can help to encourage at
●● For older teens, a health promotion activity home.
about sexually transmitted infections could be
integrated into PHSE lessons. As there is a lot of Plan and implement an
material available on this subject, an activity to
compare and contrast approaches and evaluate activity to promote the
their likely impact on young people could be health of children and/
helpful.
or young people
Emotional and social aspects
You can use the suggestions in Section 3 to develop a
Health promotion activities in relation to social and
health promotion activity or devise you own. The key
emotional health must be very sensitively handled
criteria to consider are as follows:
as it may touch on personal issues that the child or
young person is not ready to deal with. However, ●● Who is the promotion activity for?
the following topics can be helpful for children and ●● What message are you trying to convey?
young people to consider: ●● Myth busting – what does your target audience
know already?
●● Bullying: what it is and how children and young
●● How is the activity going to empower your target
people can deal with it. It is likely that the setting
audience?
has an anti-bullying policy and it might be useful
●● How will you measure success (evaluation)?
to review it as part of a health promotion activity
to see how it could be improved so that children Once you have answered all these questions, you
and young people are empowered and their will need to devise an action plan. This should
resilience and self-esteem improved. clearly show the roles and responsibilities of all those
●● Gangs – good or bad? An activity to examine involved (e.g. devising questionnaires). You will need
different friendship groups, why they are important, to put timescales on your action plan and include a
etc. This activity could include how people behave review of the plan.
in groups, how individual young people can choose
105
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● For the learning of the child/young person, and the extent to which it empowered the child or
questions might include the extent to which young person to improve their own health.
the child or young person understands the
health message behind the promotional activity
and whether they will have more control over
Section 5: How to respond
their own health as a result of the activity to illness in children and/
(empowerment). It is difficult to measure this
objectively, but you can ask the child or young or young people
person themselves via interview or questionnaire,
It is relatively rare for children or young people to be
which you can tape or video (as long as you have
in the setting while suffering from serious infectious
parental permission).
diseases, especially if there is an immunisation
●● For the potential influence on the family,
policy and an exclusion procedure in place, as part
you might need to interview parents. Your
of a managing illness policy (see Section 1). Most
evaluation should allow for parents wanting
children and young people who are poorly with
more information about the health message. For
highly infectious diseases should be cared for at
example, if they ask you to refer them for help to
home and, unless you are working with looked-after
stop smoking following a promotional activity in
children, or are the sole carer in a home setting, you
this area, this would indicate some success. The
are unlikely to be required to care for children in the
health of the child will be improved as a result.
acute stages of their illness.
●● The involvement of the team within the work
environment is about how you work as a member Nevertheless, there are some children who have
of a team and how the roles were allocated and not been vaccinated and pose a risk to themselves
carried out according to your action plan for and others. It is therefore useful if you become
implementing the activity. You will need some familiar with the signs and symptoms of some of the
criteria against which to measure performance infectious diseases.
and this could be built into your plan at the
beginning.
Symptoms of common
Reflect on own role infectious illnesses
within the health A rise in confirmed measles cases in England and
106
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
extreme cases can lead to deafness can have serious long-term consequences (e.g.
●● inflammation of the brain (encephalitis) and its developmental delay)
coverings, called meninges (meningitis), which ●● viral pneumonia.
Chicken pox is another highly infectious illness Because chicken pox is so dangerous to pregnant
caused by a virus (varicella zoster) spread by women and their unborn babies, it is crucial that
droplet infection. Chicken pox is more common children with suspected chicken pox are kept away
in children but the virus can also cause shingles from pregnant mothers and the signs and symptoms
in adults who have had chicken pox. Adults with are recognised before the spots appear.
shingles can cause chicken pox in others who have
not been exposed to it. Symptoms of chicken pox Meningitis
include:
The term meningitis means inflammation of the
●● raised temperature – sometimes as high as 40C protective coverings of the brain – the three meninges.
●● symptoms of a common cold – runny nose, cough, It is a general term covering several different types of
sore throat, etc. meningitis, caused by either certain bacteria or a virus,
107
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and it is a notifiable disease. Many people – about ●● stiff neck and dislike of bright lights – all age
10 per cent of the population – carry meningococcal groups
bacteria in their throats without ill effect and it ●● muscle pain, often severe (older children and
is rare that they overcome the body’s defences to teens)
cause meningitis. There are different groups of ●● convulsions – all age groups.
meningococci, the two main ones being Type B
and Type C, which used to cause 35–40 per cent of Not all of these signs and symptoms need to
meningitis cases. Since vaccines were introduced for be present at the same time but if meningitis is
Type C in 1999/2000, there has been a significant suspected, medical help must be sought. If the
reduction, with only two deaths under 20 years of age condition of a child or young person suddenly
in the last five years, compared to 78 in the year prior deteriorates (e.g. convulsions begin), medical
to vaccination. Meningitis is not highly contagious. assistance is urgently required.
●● Bacterial meningitis – the most serious type The most serious symptom is the rash that does
caused by one of several bacteria: meningococcal, not fade under pressure because this is a sign of
pneumococcal, streptococcal, Hib (haemophilus meningococcal septicaemia (blood poisoning), which
influenzae type B), TB and E-coli. This is a life- is a medical emergency. The rash can be checked
threatening disease – one in ten people die – and using the glass test – if a glass is pressed against the
there are serious long-term health consequences if rash and the rash does not fade, it is septicaemia.
survived. It is important not to wait until there is a rash.
●● Viral meningitis – often caused by an enterovirus If any combination of the above symptoms is
(one which lives in the intestines), it is usually present, you should suspect meningitis and seek
much milder and, although it can make people immediate help. You can get further information,
feel very unwell, there is less likelihood of serious including a video of the ‘glass test’, at www.
complications and lasting damage than with meningitis-trust.org/meningitis-info.
bacterial meningitis. Recovery, however, is usually
slow. The consequences of meningitis are serious because
it can lead to brain damage and developmental delay.
The signs and symptoms of meningitis are similar, Complications include the following:
irrespective of the causal agent (pathogen). They
●● Physical difficulties, especially following
include:
meningococcal septicaemia, because the toxins
●● high temperature/fever with cold hands and feet – produced damage blood vessels and blood-flow
all age groups to all major organs, skin and muscles. This may
●● pale, blotchy skin, spots or rash – all age groups cause muscle weakness, scarring and in extreme
●● food refusal or loss of appetite cases there may be loss of limbs. Acute headaches
●● vomiting – all age groups are not unusual and there may be clumsiness
●● drowsiness and floppiness (babies and young due to impaired spatial awareness, hearing loss
children); unresponsiveness and difficulty to rouse (very common) and/or sight loss. There is often
(older children and teens) tiredness and fatigue, which can last for many
●● rapid breathing, often accompanied by grunting months.
(babies and young children) ●● Learning difficulties, including reduced
●● high-pitched or unusual cry (babies and young attention and concentration, short-term memory
children); confusion and irritability (older children loss, difficulty in number and word recognition.
and teens) Speech and communication difficulties are not
●● tense, bulging fontanelle (soft spot in babies); unusual. A significant number will have a
headache (older children and teens) reduced IQ.
108
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
●● Emotional and behavioural difficulties, (inflammation of the membrane covering the heart).
including depression, personality changes, loss of As you can probably see, words ending in ‘-itis’ mean
confidence, mood swings and anxiety. ‘inflammation’.
109
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
110
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
All children who are unwell are likely to be irritable can be protected as far as possible and so that
and distressed so it is important to be sympathetic the individual child or young person can receive
and reassuring. They will probably have little appropriate treatment.
appetite and will be unable to concentrate, although
It is also crucial that you know which infections are
they may appreciate a story being read to them.
notifiable (these are the diseases that are preventable
by immunisation) so that the appropriate authorities
The importance of can be informed and action can be taken to prevent
recognising and an outbreak.
children and/or young services to identify and follow up all the people
who had been in contact with the 441 suspected
people cases of measles. They discovered that the majority
of cases were in children under five who had not
It is important to be able to recognise common been vaccinated at 13 months, as advised in the
infectious diseases so that other children and staff immunisation schedule. The majority of the others
111
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Activity
Indicate whether you think the statements given in the table below are true (T) or false (F). If you are unsure,
put don’t know (DK).
Question T, F, DK
If a child’s temperature is above 37.5C/99F, the child is unwell and should see a doctor.
A child’s body temperature normally varies according to the time of day.
If the temperature is taken by mouth, the reading may be above normal because the child
has just had something hot to eat or drink.
➤
112
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
Question T, F, DK
When a child has a fever, it is important that they drink plenty of fluids.
Children with fevers often do not eat for several days. This does not matter as they will
make up for it when they are better.
When a child is ill and has a fever, it is a good idea to give paracetamol or ibuprofen.
When a child is ill and has a fever, it is a good idea to keep them warm and well wrapped
up.
When a child is ill and has a fever, it is a good idea to sponge them with tepid water.
When a child is ill and has a fever, it is a good idea to fan them with cool air.
Infections with rashes are usually more serious than infections without.
Rashes due to infections get better if antiseptic cream is rubbed on the rash.
A child who is unwell and develops a rash that looks like tiny bruises needs to see a doctor
straight away.
Rashes in children with infections can sometimes be caused by the antibiotic medicine they
are given and not the infection at all.
A child with meningitis may not seem very ill but just be a bit irritable, clingy and off their
food.
There is still a risk of meningitis in children who have been given the meningitis C vaccine.
Children with meningitis may complain of headaches and dislike bright lights.
Nearly all children who contract meningitis either die or suffer brain damage, despite
modern drugs.
If a child has meningitis at nursery or school, it is very likely that other members of the
group will get it too.
It is important that a child with diarrhoea and vomiting should drink plenty of fluids.
For a child with diarrhoea and vomiting, it is more important that the child continues to eat
rather than drink.
A child who is vomiting needs large drinks of water; sips are no good.
You can tell how ill a vomiting baby is by checking how often the nappy is wet.
Medicine to stop diarrhoea, such as that used on holiday, is useful for treating children with
diarrhoea.
Most children with diarrhoea need to see a doctor for antibiotics to cure them.
Diarrhoea in young children is always infectious.
Antibiotics are useful to cure sore throats in children.
Antibiotics are useful to cure runny noses and bad colds in children.
Antibiotics are useful to cure chesty coughs.
Antibiotics are useful to cure bad attacks of wheezing due to asthma in children.
Antibiotics are useful to cure earache in children.
Antibiotics are useful to cure chicken pox.
113
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
children and young people few months, depending on the duration of exclusive
breastfeeding and the strength of the mother’s
Children and young people are more susceptible immunity.
to common illnesses and diseases because their
immune systems are undeveloped. One of the key Active immunity
ways in which children and young people’s health is Active immunity is provided by the individual’s
protected is through immunisation. When babies are own immune system; it can be produced when
born, their organs and bodily systems are immature, an individual contracts an infection or disease, or
which makes them vulnerable. Because the immune the body can be stimulated to produce antibodies
system is underdeveloped at birth and continues through vaccination (immunisation). Vaccines are
to mature throughout the early years, infants are developed using the organism that causes disease, but
especially susceptible to infection so it is crucial to which is either no longer alive (known as inactivated)
start vaccination as early as possible for maximum or which has been treated so that it is harmless
protection. (known as attenuated). The body responds to the
organism as if it were alive by producing antibodies
For example, unimmunised children who contract so that, if they subsequently come into contact with
a preventable disease such as measles may infect the disease, they will be protected against it.
a baby who is too young to be immunised or who
has not yet completed the full schedule. Children The immunisation schedule in England and Wales
who develop rubella may come into contact with a starts at eight weeks after birth, when passive
member of staff or another parent who is pregnant, immunity will be waning. Vaccination is carried out
exposing their unborn baby to the risk of serious to stimulate the infant’s immune system to respond
abnormalities if they themselves have not been and develop its own active immunity. Even if the
immunised or their immunity is weak. infant is being exclusively breastfed, there is no way
of assessing the extent of any passive immunity from
What is immunity? the mother so it is safer to immunise than not.
114
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
protected depends on the specific disease; however, The immunisation schedule is developed from
it ranges between 70 and 95 per cent. This means, research-based evidence of the behaviour and
for example, that 85 per cent of the population transmission (epidemiology) of communicable
will need to be vaccinated against diphtheria in diseases. It is the role of the Joint Committee
order to prevent transmission so that everyone is of Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI),
protected. The idea of herd immunity underpins the an independent expert advisory body, to
programme of universal immunisation. review all the available evidence and make
recommendations to the Department of Health,
Activity who then decide on the UK vaccination policy. UK
vaccine policy is published in the ‘Green Book’,
Develop an immunisation policy for your setting. which is available on the Department of Health
website for doctors and public health professionals
to refer to.
The National The JCVI also advises the Secretary of State for
Immunisation Schedule Health in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland
for children and young on the diseases that are preventable or potentially
preventable through immunisation. This means
people from birth to that, because the immunisation schedule is
based on evidence, in practice the immunisation
18 years schedule is the same in all the countries of the
UK. The schedule is regularly reviewed and
Children in the UK are routinely immunised against
updated in the light of new knowledge and
diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis (whooping cough),
evidence.
polio, a specific type of influenza virus (Hib), a
specific type of pneumonia (pneumococcal virus The diseases currently within the scope of the UK
or PCV), a specific type of meningitis (meningitis immunisation schedule are serious diseases that
C), measles, mumps and rubella (German measles), can be fatal and often cause significant, permanent
starting at eight weeks and at intervals until the child damage for children who survive.
is three years and four months. When children reach
adolescence, they need a booster injection of some BCG (Bacillus Calmette-Guerin) protects against
of the early vaccines to establish lifelong immunity. tuberculosis and was routinely given to young people
Different vaccines are given at different times and in secondary school. However, it is now offered as a
in different combinations to ensure maximum targeted programme for babies, children and young
protection and minimum complications. Girls are adults considered to be at higher risk of TB. These
also offered vaccination against the human papilloma are:
virus (HPV), which is associated with cervical cancer.
●● children born or who live or have lived in areas
where there is a high rate of TB
Key terms ●● children whose parent or grandparent was
Vaccination – the process of introducing a harmless born in a country where there is a high rate
pathogen (see ‘Key term’ on page 86) into the body of TB.
to stimulate the production of antibodies so that the
individual becomes immune to that disease. For children at risk, it is recommended that those
Immunisation – the body’s response to vaccination babies less than 12 months old have the BCG and
by creating immunity. Sometimes the terms are used that older children are tested and vaccinated if
interchangeably.
needed.
115
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Threshold
(percentage Transmission
needed to route and
ensure herd incubation Symptoms, causes, effects and
Disease immunity) period complications
Diphtheria 85% Saliva. • Affects respiratory tract, forming a grey
– caused Two to five days. membrane that can obstruct breathing
by bacteria Infective period: • Produces a dangerous toxin (poisonous
corynebacterium up to four weeks. substance) that attacks the heart and central
diphtheria nervous system.
Complications – paralysis and damage to the heart
muscle, proving fatal in 10 per cent of cases.
HIB – caused Not known Airborne and • Meningitis (inflammation of the brain coverings)
by bacteria because droplet. • Septicaemia (blood poisoning)
haemophilus the bacteria Carried in nasal
influenzae causes a • Epiglottitis (swelling and obstruction of the throat)
passages.
number of • Septic arthritis (joint infection)
different • Osteomyelitis (infection of the bone).
diseases
All of these effects can be fatal or cause long-term
damage or disability.
Measles – 83–95% Airborne. • Rash
viral infection Ten days. • Fever
caused by a
paramyxovirus Infective period: • Cough, runny nose, sneezing
days 10–18. • Conjunctivitis.
Rash appears
about day four. The complications of measles are life-threatening
and include:
• severe conjunctivitis
• inflammation of the small intestines
• pneumonia
• encephalitis (inflammation of the brain), causing
brain damage in 40 per cent of sufferers
• death from encephalitis.
Mumps – 75–86% Airborne and • Characteristic swelling under the ear caused by
viral infection droplet. inflammation of the salivary gland on one or both
caused by a 14–21 days. sides
paramyxovirus • Can affect other glands, including pancreas,
Infectious for
several days testes and ovaries.
before swelling Complications can include:
appears. • deafness due to inflammation of the ear
• viral meningitis
• encephalitis
• infertility.
➤
116
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
117
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and young people paralysis with muscle wasting. For example, Ian
Dury, the famous rock musician, was a polio
Children are routinely immunised in the UK survivor. He maintained that he caught the
against a range of different diseases, which are now disease aged seven from a swimming pool and it
relatively rare. For example, before the polio vaccine permanently affected his left arm and right leg with
was introduced in 1955, there were 6,000 cases per partial paralysis, hence his famous stick and limp.
year, mostly affecting children and young adults. The success of routine immunisation is demonstrated
Polio is a viral infection affecting the central nervous by the fact that, in 1948, there were 241 deaths
system; it attacks the spinal cord causing paralysis from polio in England and Wales; today there are
of the muscles by damaging the nerve supply. It none and there have been no new cases reported
commonly affects the limbs and the inter-costal since 1998. This is not the case across the rest of the
muscles (between the ribs), which are necessary world, however, and polio still leads to paralysis for
for breathing. There were widespread outbreaks of thousands of children.
the disease in the UK, prior to the introduction of
vaccines, and sufferers whose breathing was affected Similarly, smallpox, caused by a viral infection and
were placed into a machine called an ‘iron lung’, responsible for thousands of deaths and permanent
which used compression and decompression to damage, has now been eradicated entirely worldwide
artificially inflate the chest wall. so vaccination is no longer required.
118
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
improvement to children sample of children. The data behind the theory has
since been rigorously tested and over 200 further
and/or young people’s experiments have been unable to replicate the
original findings. The theory has therefore been
health in relation to discredited; there is no evidence to indicate any link
immunisations between MMR and autism and the safety of the
vaccine is confirmed.
While immunisation against some diseases has
been extremely successful, others, particularly those Measles has been eliminated in Finland; before
regarded as childhood illnesses, such as mumps and 1975, there were 15,000 cases a year but there have
measles, have had a more erratic take-up in the UK been no cases since 1996 due to high vaccination
and still affect unvaccinated children, sometimes rates. Meanwhile, measles causes 500,000 deaths
with devastating consequences, including lifelong per year in Africa and 800,000 a year worldwide. For
disability and, in the worst cases, death. more information on vaccinations, see www.nhs.uk/
Planners/vaccinations/Pages/miracles.aspx.
The measles vaccine was introduced in 1968 and
the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine in
1998. Since that point, the incidence of these diseases Activity
steadily declined until recently, when the uptake of
the MMR vaccine in the UK began to fall and herd 1 Find out how the incidence of measles has
changed in the UK between 2000 and 2012.
immunity was compromised.
2 Identify any differences between the four
This was mainly due to a loss of confidence in countries of the UK.
the vaccine by parents, influenced by a highly
119
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Useful resources
Anaphylaxis Campaign
www.anaphylaxis.org.uk
Health Protection Agency: guidance on infection control in schools and other childcare
settings
www.hpa.org.uk/Topics/InfectiousDiseases/InfectionsAZ/SchoolsGuidanceOnInfectionControl
120
Chapter 3 Maintaining the health of children and/or young people (Unit CP 3)
NHS: measles
www.nhs.uk/conditions/measles/Pages/Introduction.aspx
School Food Trust: guidance for food and drink provision in early years settings
www.schoolfoodtrust.org.uk/download/documents/pdf/early_years_food_and_nutrition_guidance.pdf
121
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership
and management (Unit CP 4)
122
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
ity
Research Activ
●● being an agent for change
●● handling crises and uncertainty.
123
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Team – a team is any group of people organised to work ●● managing the requirement for a duty of care
together interdependently and cooperatively to meet ●● meeting regulatory requirements.
the needs of their setting or service by accomplishing
its purpose and goals (source: adapted from ‘What Managers are often thought of as supporting the
is a team?’: http://humanresources.about.com/od/
way things are and not as agents of change. Leader-
teambuilding/f/teams_def.htm).
managers have to cope with both supporting change
124
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
125
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
126
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
leaders motivate and inspire others to achieve 4 System models. This type of model is said to
the goals of the setting or service. The focus is operate effectively where there are significant
on supporting people to have a sense of purpose challenges and uncertainties. It shows how
beyond narrow self-interest. These leaders want a leader’s thinking and actions are linked
each follower to achieve their potential and they to the larger systemic structures within
focus on supporting the effective performance of an organisation. It is an attempt to avoid
individuals. fragmenting the work of the setting or service.
A systems approach would encourage leaders
Models of a team to make sure the team goals and
1 Participative/democratic leadership models. activities fitted in with the whole service. This
These are based on changing the balance of can be very complex and, if there is lack of trust
power between leader and follower so they and poor understanding of the whole service,
become more equal. Participative models this can act as a barrier, with individuals feeling
view the input of others to leadership as undervalued.
important. Leaders encourage participation
and contributions from group members into Case Study
decision-making. In this way, there is more ‘buy
in’ at all levels of the service or setting. There A successful team working to support children
is less competition between people and more and young people with additional needs has
collaboration when everyone has a chance to a goal to gain additional funding from a local
input into decisions. charitable trust. Gaining this funding could
2 Distributed leadership model. This is a type mean other parts of the service that are less
of participative/democratic leadership model. successful may lose out. A systems approach
Distributed leadership describes when leadership to leadership might mean that this goal is not
responsibilities are shared across a setting or pursued in the light of the needs of the whole
service. This is often in the form of leadership service. There is a tension here between an
teams who, although they have different levels individual team’s goals and that of the whole
of decision-making responsibility according to setting or service. This means that setting goals
individual circumstances, are able to influence the for teams must be carefully thought out to avoid
overall decisions that are made. For example, head causing conflict and demoralising people.
teachers in schools may have overall authority but
individual teams can strongly influence decisions
and policies for the school. Belbin (2004) and other Adair’s action-centred leadership
researchers describe this type of leadership model model (1997)
in detail. This is an example of a leadership model that is
3 Facilitative leadership model. This model simple to understand yet widely used and helpful
is linked to transformational leadership. It is for leaders building teams. Adair describes the core
designed to facilitate leadership rather than roles of leadership as three equal, overlapping and
impose decision-making. Facilitative leaders have interdependent circles or spheres. The circles represent:
a genuine interest in the individual and what they ●● achieving the task
have to contribute. They are interested in team ●● building and maintaining the team
members’ values and attitudes. Facilitative leaders ●● developing the individual.
often coach their team members and demonstrate
how to reflect on practice. Such leaders are able to Adair suggests that, when something significant
help individuals to see alternative points of view happens in one of the three circles, it will have
and will encourage debate. consequences in the other two.
127
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
128
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
workers feel their needs are being met. This style come into this category, such as ‘narcissistic’, which
does slow down decision-making, though, and is tends to describe leaders who are egotistic, vain or
still rather autocratic. conceited. Damage can also be done by leaders who
are insecure or overambitious or have poor social
Pace-setting style and interpersonal skills.
This is a leadership style where managers
lead by example and are role models for their Moral leadership styles
workers. Managers set high standards of personal Leaders may be driven by a strong moral code,
performance that they then expect workers to copy. such as caring for the environment or religious
It is possible for workers to feel overwhelmed by this beliefs. Moral leaders emphasise the importance
style as they may feel they will never achieve the of values in leadership and the ethical justification
standards. for actions taken. Some leaders lead by allowing
their actions to speak louder than their words (i.e.
Toxic leadership styles lead from behind, not in front). This type of leader
Sometimes leaders who may be abusive or leave a may give credit to other people rather than taking
service or setting in a worse state than when they it themselves but will take the blame if things go
arrived are called ‘toxic leaders’ (Whicker 1996). wrong. They are focused on seeing the organisation
There are many styles of leadership that could succeed.
129
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
130
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
131
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
132
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
●● decision-making ●● norming
●● managing information ●● performing
●● business skills. ●● adjourning.
133
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
one role, so the model can work even in a small There are four commonly recognised learning styles
team. The model works best when used openly in in management:
a setting or service and where workers in specific ●● Activists: those who like to immerse themselves
roles are recognised. In practice, managers need
fully in new experiences and who act first and
to apply the model flexibly as roles may overlap
consider consequences later.
and there may be situations where workers only ●● Reflectors: those who like to stand back and
lean towards some roles (i.e. they are not fixed in
observe and who tend to be cautious until they
concrete).
have all the facts.
●● Theorists: those who like to think through
Learning styles
problems in a logical manner and are keen on
The concept of learning styles is popular today basic assumptions, principles, theories, models
and there are a variety of models used. There is and systems thinking.
more about learning styles as applied to children ●● Pragmatists: those who like to put theories into
and young people in Chapter 8. Understanding practice and who are impatient with long-winded
learning styles is not limited to knowing how discussion.
people learn but is applied in slightly different
ways in management. The work of Kolb (1984) on Managers who understand their own learning style
experiential learning and Honey and Mumford and that of their team are more able to meet the needs
(1986, 2000) led to questionnaires, manuals and of the team. They will ensure the team’s strengths are
systems being developed to help ascertain a person’s utilised and avoid placing people in the jobs they find
learning style. less rewarding or more difficult to achieve.
134
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
If you want to find out more about learning styles, stage is the actual period of change. It is the stage
there is a mass of information on the internet. For when the workforce begins to accept the change and
example, see www.open2.net/survey/learningstyles. sees benefits for themselves. Managers will need to
recognise that this takes time and build in time for
Team building doubts and concerns to be discussed.
There are many examples of theories and approaches
Refreezing is the third stage, where the changes
to team building that you can investigate further. For
become an established part of the setting or service
example:
and stability returns. Training may be needed at this
●● Myers–Briggs type indicator. This looks at key stage, or earlier, and feedback systems should be put
features of individuals, such as extroversion/ into place.
introversion, thinkers/feelers, and so forth. It is
designed to help people understand themselves
and others within their team. Case Study
●● Social identity theory. This looks at how
individuals define themselves in terms of their In a day nursery, the manager comes in one day
group identity. and calls a staff meeting after the children have
left. At the meeting, the staff are told they will be
Change management extending the hours of the nursery to provide a
There are several models of change management wider range of services across an extended age
because, in today’s world, constant change is part range. This will enlarge the nursery by one-
of a manager’s territory. Recognising that change third and is to happen in two months’ time. Staff
is stressful and potentially damaging to a service are told that the rotas have been worked out to
or setting is important. It is not enough to impose make sure everyone is treated fairly.
change from above as this can lead to low morale Comment on the way this big change has been
and conflict. Managers need to make sure that the introduced. How do you feel the staff might
workforce is fully involved and understands the be feeling? Develop a plan covering the steps
reasons for change and the possible impact this will that should be taken by managers wishing to
have on them. This all takes time and managers have introduce this change.
to build in sufficient time during the planning stage.
If workers need new skills, the manager will need to
give training choices and opportunities.
Project management
Lewin’s change management model (1958) still Project management usually refers to managing
applies today and provides the basis for more up-to- a temporary or short-term activity with a defined
date variations. It recognises that change is difficult beginning and end. There are usually specific
but that acceptance takes place in stages. His three- outcomes that are required – for example, a project
stage model uses the analogy of a block of ice and to consult young people on the use of playing fields,
is known as ‘unfreeze–change (move)–refreeze’. or projects to consider the impact of lower funding
Unfreezing is the most stressful – the process of for children’s centres. There is a mass of software
melting the ice, which means preparing the setting available for project planning and management
or service for change. This means explaining to the (e.g. PRINCE2, Microsoft Project or MacProject).
workforce why things have to change and tackling Project management demands some of the same
entrenched ideas and ways of working. It is useful to skills as more general management but additional
have arguments that support the need for change, skills are sometimes required, such as the ability to
such as the declining use of the service or setting, use software effectively or to apply for funding for
which is threatening its survival, or increased specific projects. Negotiation skills are important
demands being met by competitors. The second for all managers but project managers whose project
135
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
may seem to others in a service to be insignificant performance is discussed and individual goals
sometimes have to work hard and exercise leadership are agreed and included in a set of performance
to persuade, inspire and involve others. goals/targets. These should be kept as simple as
possible. It is useful to use a standard pro forma to
Performance management formally record the agreements. Verbal feedback
Performance management systems are widely used and agreements should not be used. New staff
in settings and services today. Systems can cover may require frequent performance interviews.
both individuals and team performance, for all levels Targets should be agreed between the manager and
of staff, from the lowest to the highest. Performance individual team members and, where necessary,
management is conducted in different ways in negotiated with the help of others. The annual
different organisations and is part of the overall way interview should be backed up by regular support
an organisation aims to achieve its goals. Properly meetings and informal feedback so that it does not
implemented, it can be used as a tool to support contain any surprises.
people and enhance their contribution. Managers
To work effectively, individuals must:
and supervisors undertaking performance appraisals
need to be well trained and understand the goals of ●● have agreed job descriptions
the organisation. Performance management normally ●● agree and set objectives that enable them to clearly
follows a cycle similar to that shown in Figure 4.2. understand the outcomes and goals they need to
meet and the timescales for meeting them
For individual team members, performance ●● agree the tools, resources, training needs and
management can take the form of an annual or other support they can expect in order for them to
more frequent appraisal interview where their do the job
Plan
prioritising and
planning for
improvement
Revise Do
Review
understanding
the impact of
your actions
136
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
●● understand how their performance will be and derive their authority from the rules, not by
measured and when appraisals will take place relying on or using their own skills and attributes.
●● understand what is in it for them – for example,
promotion, recognition, better pay. Defensive management style
This is a negative management style that is the
There are difficulties in linking good performance hallmark of a blame culture. Managers using this
solely to pay and conditions as these rewards may not style are often harsh and blame others for the failure
be possible. Many people gain enormous satisfaction of their management. This style demotivates and
from their own personal achievement and this leads to lack of trust.
should be encouraged. Other forms of rewards may
be helpful, such as training and development, away
days, health club membership and time out. 3 Progress check
By carrying out realistic and sensitive appraisals Taking into account all the leadership and
of performance and by setting SMART objectives management styles you have covered, which do
you feel is the most desirable/undesirable? Give
(see Chapter 5), managers can help individuals to
reasons for your answers.
focus on what can be achieved, as well as provide
a fair measure of progress. Equally, managers
can demotivate by conducting hostile, unfair and
damaging performance appraisals. Activity
In any area of your life, think about the managers you
Management styles have encountered. What management styles have you
The information on leadership styles is applicable seen in operation? What has been the impact of the
to this section on management styles, so please see different management styles you have experienced?
the earlier information on pages 128–9. Although
the management styles described below can apply
to leaders, they may be more relevant to managers. How different theories,
Remember, most managers will use more than one
style of management. models and styles
Affiliative leadership and
of leadership and
management style management can be
This relates closely to the democratic leadership applied to different
style and is intended to create positive feelings of
harmony in the setting or service. It depends on situations
creating an emotional bond between managers and
Leaders and managers often have to vary their
workers and between workers. This can be successful
management style according to the situation they
but there are concerns that too much familiarity can
encounter. If they are not able to do this, they will find
cause lack of respect and possible conflict.
it more difficult to achieve the aims of the setting or
service. Earlier in the chapter, we looked at context
Bureaucratic style
or situational theories of leadership, which are about
This is a style used by managers who like rules finding the best solution for the situation. It is from
and work to them. These managers will expect this theoretical perspective that this section is written.
everything to be done according to the rules,
policies and procedures. This management style can Examples of common situations that require different
stifle creativity and become harsh and unfeeling. responses from managers and leaders are outlined in
Managers who use this style may lack confidence Table 4.4.
137
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Case Study
138
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
the workforce or the needs of the situation in the ●● pick up on key ideas
setting or service. ●● recognise non-verbal communication
●● provide feedback
139
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
is secretive and hides information from some and Other issues that need careful measurement
not others discourages trust. Building trust means will include financial probity where public or
treating people with respect and valuing them. private money is concerned. Meeting regulatory
Valuing equality and diversity also builds trust as requirements is also a key focus for managers, but
people feel they are important and their differences this should never be an end in itself. Regulatory
are a positive asset not a barrier. It is important for requirements are normally based on minimum
leaders and managers to be approachable and to be standards and provide a baseline on which to build a
empathetic with the people they lead. Leaders and high-quality setting or service.
managers need to be seen to treat people fairly and
equally, being responsive to their individual needs, Being able to motivate others
strengths and weaknesses. Arrogance and bossiness This is an important attribute for leaders and
will not get the best out of people. managers and is covered in Section 2.3 (see
pages 126–7).
Being able to encourage,
manage and support change Being able to train and develop
Change is a key feature of modern society. Settings others
and services that cannot change, adapt and update An important role for leaders and managers is to train
will not succeed. Leaders and managers need to and develop others. Instead of feeling threatened by
understand the change management process and other people’s success, effective leaders will always
plan for it when introducing change. Change may not seek to improve the skill base of their workforce
be for commercial reasons but, for example, to take and help them to do their jobs well. Understanding
on board new evidence of good practice, changes in training needs in relation to the needs of the
government policy or changes in ownership. setting or service and to meet the aspirations of the
workforce is an important attribute. Leaders and
Measuring what matters managers who coach their workforce use a leadership
This is a phrase often heard in management. Services style that empowers people to reach their potential.
and settings need to measure what is important, Coaching is a term that is changing but usually
not concentrate on things that are easy to measure. involves confidential one-to-one conversations with
Everyone in the setting or service needs to know what individuals about their goals or aspects of the work
constitutes success – in children and young people’s that they wish to develop. It may include looking
services, what matters is outcomes for children and at how they impact on other people, respond to
families, and everything else flows from that. For situations, take personal responsibility and learn from
example, staff retention rates can easily be measured their experience. Coaching can improve performance
and, although important to the individual concerned, and enhance job satisfaction.
the main issue for the service is how this will directly
affect children’s experience – that is, too much change In some circumstances, mentoring is another
upsetting their attachment to key people. It may also feature of effective leaders and managers. Mentors
indicate wider problems within the setting or service, are professional colleagues with experience who
which may have a knock-on effect on outcomes for can help you assess your training and professional
children. For example, if people feel undervalued, they development needs. However, not all leaders and
will seek to move elsewhere. managers can be mentors and not all mentors
are leaders and managers. Mentoring is most
Managers and leaders should expect to have their effective with participative, democratic leaders
performance managed in a similar way to the and managers who take on the role of ‘a wise and
people they manage. It is normal today to have trusted professional friend’. Mentoring from a
performance indicators and targets. This is covered senior colleague can really help people to make
in more detail later. good decisions about professional development.
140
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
141
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
How to encourage, from the task itself (i.e. seeing a job well done for
the satisfaction that brings, and not for an external
motivate and support reward). People who are motivated in this way gain a
sense of personal pleasure in achievement, especially
individuals to achieve of appropriately challenging tasks. This motivation
will not last if the tasks are clearly impossible or
The information in earlier sections and above also
beyond their expertise, or if they become bored or
relates to this section. Encouraging, motivating and
are put under excessive pressure.
supporting people to achieve is an important part
of a leader’s or manager’s role. Effective leaders and External motivation is where people need an
managers know that employment in children’s and external reward to keep them going. A person who
young people’s services is normally undertaken by is extrinsically motivated may or may not like what
people who have a ‘heart’ for the work and want they are doing but will continue for the reward. For
to make a difference to the lives of children, young children and young people, this reward may be a
people and families. Leaders and managers should good grade in a subject they do not like or a reward
have high but realistic expectations of people who sticker for a child who sits still. For adults, the
work for them. Low expectations can become a rewards can be money, status or other things.
‘self-fulfilling prophecy’ for the workforce. This
can be on an individual or a team level. If not Adair (1987) introduced the idea of the 50:50 rule,
much is expected, the message is that the people in which he suggests that half a person’s motivation
involved cannot be trusted, cannot succeed or is from within and half is from the external
cannot achieve at a higher level than their current environment. He suggests that an important factor
position. It is demotivating and depressing and will influencing external motivation is the quality of the
directly impact on outcomes for children and young leadership they encounter.
people as they will encounter people who have no
Adair suggests that there are eight rules for
real enthusiasm for their work. Taking a ‘one size
motivating people:
fits all’ approach to encouraging, supporting and
motivating is also unlikely to work as individual ●● be motivated yourself
needs must be met and personal contributions ●● select motivated people
valued. ●● treat each person as an individual
●● set realistic but challenging targets
Motivating people is at the heart of effective leadership ●● understand that progress itself motivates
and management. People need recognition and to be ●● create a motivating environment
valued and many organisations provide the opposite. ●● provide relevant rewards
Managers who try to control people can produce a ●● recognise success.
dependent culture and high levels of passivity. This
stifles creativity, new ideas and energy, which can One of the most motivating factors for people is to
benefit the setting or service. This can lead to: work for someone who is themselves enthusiastic
142
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
143
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
facilitate a positive working environment, to set ●● shared priorities and clarity about constraints
clear expectations and responsibilities and to let ●● opportunities to deal with misunderstandings and
144
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
How to identify
Training and development
Opportunities for feedback and updating skills
individual needs
should be provided on a personal basis and and motivate others
taken advantage of by team members. Training
and development needs are usually discussed in towards common goals
performance appraisals or supervision times. On according to their needs
other occasions, people will identify needs outside
formal arrangements and request specific training Section 3.1 covers much of this assessment criterion,
to help them to do their job. Leaders and managers and identification of individual needs has been
need to make sure their team members are up to covered already in the section on performance
date and that training opportunities are widely management (see pages 136–7). In addition, feedback
publicised and fairly allocated. A key way in which from colleagues, as well as children, families and
training and new knowledge can be disseminated is carers, may sometimes indicate a training need.
through a cascade approach, in which people share This has to be sensitively handled and the team
their learning. Shared training experiences across member should be offered appropriate training in
different levels of the setting or service also support a supportive way. Sometimes people have worked
work towards common goals. This is particularly the well for many years in a setting and understand the
case if leaders and managers share in some of the job role well. If they are required to undertake new
training and it is not then seen as ‘them’ and ‘us’. In training, this can cause resentment, so managers
some circumstances, parents/carers can also benefit often have a whole-team approach to updating staff,
from sharing in the training. rather than singling out individuals.
145
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
In addition to training needs, people may have be possible to overcome this completely, a good
personal needs that are hampering their ability workplace experience can help by:
to do the job well. These needs may be outside
●● not setting people up to fail by giving them goals
the workplace or may relate to situations in the
that they cannot achieve for whatever reason
workplace, such as harassment or hostility. Either
●● providing good support through training and
way, they may affect how people work. Formal or
development
informal meetings between managers and staff
●● individual managers and supervisors providing
should help to discover where there are problems
sensitive, high-quality, individual feedback and
and the types of support that may be available.
recognition
Sometimes people do need to have ‘time out’,
●● providing opportunities for progression and
work fewer hours, work more hours, take sick
promotion, sometimes through changing job roles
leave or have a change of environment. There is
internally or by encouraging them to move on.
a limit to how much settings can do, but every
effort should be made to support people in times of Although it may seem wrong to support a valued
difficulty. Confidentially is important and systems colleague to move on to another job, this is sometimes
are normally in place for ‘whistleblowing’ when the best thing to do. People will value the organisation
there are serious issues. If there are issues between that supports them in this way. Another way of
managers and staff, this can be difficult to deal looking at it is that people who are not supported to
with, but attempts should be made with a third move on when they are ready can sometimes become
party present – this is normally covered in the frustrated, bored and unhelpful to the team.
setting’s policies and procedures. There are legal
requirements in cases of workplace difficulties
and there will be systems in place to deal with
How to encourage
grievances. If this is taking place, for example, reflection on achievement
in a small-scale work setting, it makes the issue
challenging and difficult. of common goals
Encouraging common goals by
How to encourage team reflection
and support others to Reflection is well-established good practice in
services and settings for children, young people
make the best use of and their families. Reflecting is defined in different
their ability to achieve ways but essentially means thinking seriously
or contemplating upon something. When we
common goals refer to reflective practitioners, we usually mean
the processes involved in looking at professional
This assessment criterion has underpinned much of effectiveness – that is, strengths and weaknesses
the material in Section 3 and in other parts of the and determining areas for further development. It is
chapter. It is important to encourage and support closely linked to being able to think critically about
people to make the best of their ability and achieve our own practice and that of others. Work by Kolb
common goals, both for the sake of the service or (1984) and Schön (1983), amongst others, sets out
setting and for the individual themselves. Making the theoretical basis for reflection. Schön speaks of
the best of their abilities means people must be reflective practitioners who are not just skilful or
aware of the scope of their individual potential, and competent, but ‘thoughtful, wise and contemplative’.
this can be difficult. Many people have a sense of
failure through difficult personal experiences and Schön describes ‘reflection in action’, which is the
through educational failure. Although it may not kind of reflection that occurs as events take place. It
146
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
3 Progress check
in different ways, such as:
●● in staff meetings
●● on staff development days Cookie making
●● during performance appraisals
●● in informal meetings. Work with others to bake and sell cookies, or
something similar, to fellow learners for a good
During formal or informal meetings, leaders and cause, such as ‘Children in Need’. Reflect on each
managers may decide to undertake some activities to stage of the activity and suggest how the team
could work better in the future. Find out if team
highlight team effectiveness. These can include basic roles emerged. Relate this to Tuckman’s and
activities, such as team building, learning how teams Belbin’s theories (see pages 228–30 and 134).
can cooperate, contribute and communicate better,
and identifying team roles and who undertakes them.
Many settings will encourage activities such as:
●● games
●● team energisers Reflective practice
●● quizzes
Undertake a team activity with other learners
●● puzzles
where common goals for the activity were agreed
●● workshops in advance. Analyse your own contribution to the
●● problem-solving activities team activity. Reflect on how you contributed and
●● obstacle courses collaborated. How did your team members react
●● teamwork strategies to you and to each other? How could you improve
●● treasure hunts.
your teamwork? Explain how the activity supported
achieving common goals?
These activities are all designed to help the team
work together more effectively and reflect on
their team performance. They should be carefully Encouraging common goals by
managed as they have the potential to be destructive, individual reflection
as well as being useful.
Individuals should all reflect on their own practice
and make this part of their working norm. When
Activity people reflect on what is important to them in a
work situation, they will often need to check with
Develop a checklist to see if a team is working managers and supervisors that they are on the right
together. Consider the following questions: lines and working in an acceptable way. They may
• Did the team members have conflicts and power also request further training. This can be a chance
struggles? for managers to support them to work towards
• Did everyone participate or did some remain common goals. Use of reflective accounts or diaries
outside the action? as a basis for supervision or appraisal meetings can
• Did some people do all the work? also be useful in highlighting development needs
and reviewing job roles.
147
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Case Study
Phil has worked in a day care setting for some suggests he should have further training in areas
years. He is now working as a member of an directly related to his job role. Phil has been asked
outreach team, concentrating on work with to keep a reflective diary of his day-to-day work
parents and carers, especially fathers. The with fathers and to meet with the manager after a
outreach team has been set targets to involve month to discuss any specific training needs.
more fathers in their children’s learning,
especially those who have been identified as Identify the issues that exist in this case study.
disengaged. Phil feels he is sufficiently trained to How will keeping a reflective diary encourage
do his work well but feedback from other people Phil to work towards common goals?
Useful resources
148
Chapter 4 An introduction to leadership and management (Unit CP 4)
Sylva, K., Melhuish, E., Sammons, P., Siraj- management, New York: Harper and Brothers.
Blatchford, I. and Taggart, B. (2004) The Tuckman, B. (1965) ‘Developmental sequence in
effective provision of pre-school education (EPPE) small groups’, Psychological Bulletin, 63: 384–399.
project: final report, London: DfES and Institute Whicker, M.L. (1996) Toxic leaders: when
of Education, University of London. organizations go bad, Westport, CT: Quorum
Taylor, F.W. (1911) The principles of scientific Books.
149
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of
study skills (Unit CP 5)
150
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
playing an instrument for three hours per day. As part opinion. If you want information and research on
of your course you are required to undertake different nutrition, you may need to ‘focus read’ relevant
types of assessment including extended assessments. material in great detail. Different study purposes
You will need to carefully read the guidance provided might include:
for you and take time to understand what is required.
●● browsing/skimming to get a general impression
For the extended assessments, you will need to
●● getting background for the bigger picture
understand how to research and present material,
●● fact finding
and how to extract data and summarise key themes.
●● focusing on detailed information and argument.
This can be challenging, and you will find that this
chapter will help you to undertake these assessments When you start a course, you will have to cope
and to demonstrate your knowledge, understanding with a significant amount of reading, whether in
and skills. books, journals or online. You are not expected to
read everything line by line as you may have done
Methods of flexible in the past but you need to learn to read efficiently.
to read some of it in great detail. Reading for study ●● discussing your reading with other people
purposes is different as you need to understand it and ●● choosing easier material first and working up to
remember the key concepts and general content. There the more difficult material
are a number of reading styles that can be used when ●● taking regular breaks, about every 20 minutes
studying. These are explained later in the chapter. ●● reading aloud to help understanding
●● noting headings or key words on a card or in a
notepad
Study reading (academic ●● highlighting or underlining important sections of
reading) text or where more research is needed
How you read particular material will depend on ●● putting key areas of learning into your own words
why and for what purpose. For example, if you want ●● looking away from time to time and asking
to get a flavour of something in social studies, you yourself questions about the material you are
might ‘scan read’ many sources of information and reading.
151
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
152
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
on, rather than starting at the beginning, and make the material. How well the material is written is also a
notes. When you make notes from your reading, factor as some authors are easier to read than others.
remember to:
It is important when learning to speed read that you:
●● summarise key points
●● paraphrase into your own words ●● start and practise on something simple that you
●● synthesise what you read (integrate different have already read
strands into a whole) ●● use a large font in the first instance
●● evaluate and comment on your reading ●● only speed read where this is helpful (e.g. not
●● compare what you have read where this is poetry, legal documents or a friend’s letter or
appropriate email)
●● clarify the sources of your reading in case you ●● do not read when you are tired or are finding
153
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● Take frequent breaks to prevent getting tired or might skim read material to see if it is likely to be
straining your eyes. useful for your study.
●● Do not try to read when the TV is on or where
ity
Research Activ
there is a lot of background noise. Distractions
must be kept to a minimum.
●● It is important not to work your way through line Some people use the SQ3R technique for study
by line. Look up and down at the page layout and reading. SQ3R stands for Survey, Question, Read,
only read what is critical for your understanding. Recall and Review. Research where this technique
●● Practise for at least ten minutes daily. started and how it has been developed over
the years. Write a paragraph for each heading,
explaining the meaning. Test out the technique
In Practice yourself or with other people and report if it is
effective.
Check how fast you read a set amount of material
and note the result. After a period of trying out
speed-reading techniques, test yourself with the
same material. Keep practising till you see a real
improvement.
Activity
There is a famous Woody Allen saying, ‘I took a
speed-reading course and read War and Peace
Scan reading in 20 minutes – it’s about Russia.’ Get hold of a
We have already referred to this study skill a textbook chapter, a magazine or internet article
number of times, which highlights its importance. about any subject and skim read it for ten minutes.
Scanning is similar to when you are looking for a What have you found out?
name in a phone book. You are not reading every
detail but running your eyes across the page,
looking for some key details. You might need to Ways of using reference
scan read when you are looking for a specific piece
of information. You need to be able to move your sources
eyes quickly over paragraphs, lists, diagrams and
In preparation for an assignment or an exam, there
other material until you find what you want to
will be a need for you to refer to different sources of
know. Practice by looking up an address in the
information. Different sources of information and
telephone directory and being aware of how you do
academic referencing are covered in more detail later
this. Some people read every name and address but
in the chapter.
this is very slow and inefficient. You need to learn to
scan effectively. If you find you do read everything, Reference sources are used to:
you will need to practise scanning on a daily basis.
●● broaden your knowledge and understanding
Skim reading ●● help you to understand the research or evidence
base for current knowledge of the topic
Skimming is reading to get at the gist of the material
●● help you to come to conclusions about your topic
– that is, getting the general meaning without
●● convince your assessor or marker that you have a
concentrating on the individual words. You might
wide understanding of the topic.
skim through a newspaper or magazine article to
get at the key messages but not the detail. You might Different ways of using reference sources can be
start with the contents page or headings of an article summarised as:
or book and skim read the rest.
●● reading and researching around the subject to get
Many people skim read as a preview to a more a breadth of information
thorough read. If you are in a library or online, you ●● looking in more detail at specific aspects
154
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
●● finding out different points of view words that cannot be understood by anyone except
●● using your reference source to demonstrate your the writer. You may write on already printed
understanding – for example, if you agree or material to enhance its content but many people use
disagree with other people’s points of view, you separate notebooks. Always write the date on your
can use references to argue your point notes and your sources. For example, if you are in a
●● highlighting important points by quoting the work local library or listening to a visiting lecturer, make
of others a note of the subject, name of lecturer, date and
●● emphasising your own conclusions in the light of venue to remind yourself. Be as neat as you can as
research. this will help you to remember what you meant. In
the end, it does not really matter how you take notes
Reference sources can be used as direct quotes so long as the notes do their job and are meaningful
within your writing or used to inform your work for you.
without directly quoting. Using references and
a bibliography validates your work (i.e. gives it Some useful note-taking methods are as follows:
legitimacy) as it shows you have looked at others’
●● Read through the material first, then reread and
work and research and thought through your own
make notes as this will help with recall.
viewpoint. Always make sure you give credit for
●● Make a list of headings for information that is
other people’s work, either as a direct reference
essential.
or in a bibliography. See pages 179–182 for more
●● Use different coloured paper or folders to separate
information.
types of information.
●● Do not rewrite what is in the text you are reading
You should use more than one reference source –
do not base your work on just one book or article. unless it is a heading.
Look for different sources and quote them in
your work. Make sure they are reliable sources.
If they are printed, it is easy to check the author
and publisher but if you come across material that
seems simply to provide opinions (e.g. blogs on
the internet that are simply someone’s opinion),
do not use this. Make sure your information
sources are not too narrow as it is better to look
at the subject as a whole to begin with, before
looking at specific details. For example, look at
material on overall development, then social and
emotional development, before focusing narrowly
on attachment theory.
Taking notes
You will need to take notes as you read material
or listen to lectures. Making notes helps you to
remember what you have read or heard. Most of
us are unable to remember in any detail unless we
do this. If you take notes in lectures, review them
within 24 hours or you will have forgotten their
meaning and relevance. There are many different
ways to take notes. Some people can take neat,
orderly notes that are easy to read and understand, Figure 5.1 Notes can be tidy or untidy but must work
whereas others might write untidy lists or single for you
155
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Mind maps
Key term
Mind map – a mind map is a diagram used to
represent words, ideas, tasks or other items linked to
and arranged around a central key word or idea. Mind
maps are used to generate, visualise, structure and
classify ideas, and as an aid to studying and organising
information, solving problems, making decisions and
writing (source: Wikipedia). The concept was developed
further by Tony Buzan (2000).
for what you have read or heard and the other side
for your own comments. This can separate facts, We can all think of abbreviations that are
theories or opinions. Any combination of layouts commonly used in our sector, such as QCF
can be used according to how you wish to do this. (Qualifications and Credit Framework) or ml
●● Make numbered lists, tables or diagrams. (millilitre). We need to be careful when using
●● Note paragraph and page numbers that are abbreviations as they can confuse people outside
especially relevant. the area of work and can be misunderstood,
156
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
sometimes with serious consequences. An acronym 1 Using numbers when writing should be consistent
is a type of abbreviation. and most people write as follows:
• 1–10 are normally written as full words (e.g.
When presenting your academic work, you should seven, one).
be careful not to use too many abbreviations or • 11 onwards are written as numbers (e.g. 21, 1,019).
acronyms. Assessors or markers sometimes see this 2 Roman numerals are sometimes used to number a
as a form of ‘alphabet soup’ as it makes the writing list (i.e. i, ii, iii, iv…).
less easy to understand. If you have to use many 3 Other common abbreviations used in academic
acronyms/abbreviations, develop a glossary and writing are:
attach this to your work. • et al. – and others
• NB – note well (use when important
When using acronyms in academic writing, you
information is being presented)
must always write the words in full the first time
• ibid. – when referencing, this means the source
you use them and the abbreviation or acronym in
is the same as the one already cited
brackets afterwards. From then on, you can use the
• e.g. – for example
abbreviation. For example, ‘The nursery has three
• i.e. – that is.
qualified Early Years Professionals (EYPs) who
3 Progress check
work across the various rooms. The EYPs are able
to support families with children under five years
who have special educational needs.’ Abbreviations
Develop a piece of academic writing and use the
are not used in certain places in documents, such as above abbreviations accurately and appropriately.
the title page, and current practice is not to use a full Demonstrate the accurate use of abbreviations,
stop after an abbreviation. acronyms and numbers.
157
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
158
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
first and preferably today. If you are working on your are used to music in the background, choose
computer, do not start the day answering emails and tunes without vocals or complicated rhythms
then keep looking at emails or any new shopping that will distract you. Work out the needs of the
opportunities that float across the screen. In terms task and whether you will have to go elsewhere
of email, file messages or action immediately, for information (e.g. college library, local service
otherwise you will spend a lot of time reading and providers). Plan blocks of time for study – around
rereading the same items. 45–50 minutes is a good time to allow before
taking a break. Make sure you take regular breaks!
Making ‘to do’ lists based on your It is better to take a break when you are at an
study priorities interesting part of your study so you do not dread
going back. Try to do the most complex work when
Do not try to do too much work from your list. Your
at your most alert and study in daylight hours as
priority ‘to do’ list should not contain more than
this is more efficient. Do not study after a big meal
4–6 items. They should not include items such as
and be surprised that you are struggling!
‘walk dog’, though you can include a ‘take a break’
reminder. Make sure you are keeping a careful eye
on the volume of work you are setting yourself. Starting the task
Focus on one task at a time and do not try to multi- Do not put off what you are going to do. Make a
task when you are studying. ‘To do’ lists must be start and get over the hurdle of picking up your pen
specific, as in the examples in Table 5.1. or computer and put something down on paper.
Suddenly the weight of the task is eased a little.
Planning your study environment Postpone other unnecessary activity until later. Your
Set aside somewhere you can study and let people electronic media should not dictate your timetable!
around you know what is happening. If you have
a choice, do not choose somewhere where you Keeping to task
will experience constant interruptions. Minimise Review your progress regularly, at least once a week,
distractions from whatever source (e.g. turn the and identify resources to help on an ongoing basis.
phone onto silent, make sure you have everything Save time ultimately by reviewing notes and ideas
you need at the start of the study period). If you before lectures. After lectures, review lecture notes
159
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and materials within 24 hours of the lecture as you way through is not helpful and will lead to lost
will remember much more if you do this. Make motivation. Early on in your course, you will have
sure you allow correct amount of time for tasks – discovered if the subject and potential employment
for example, most people need to allow two hours’ is right for you. If you feel this is for you, stick
private study for every hour of lecture time. Start with it for the ultimate satisfaction of achieving a
well before deadlines and allow sufficient time. positive goal. Work out for yourself what motivates
you or what acts as a negative motivator.
Short-term planning
This is most useful on a week-by-week basis. Look at Motivation can be divided into extrinsic and
your course timetable and work out what you need to intrinsic. Extrinsic motivation is often associated
do over the next 1–4 weeks. There are many planning with external rewards, such as getting a good
formats you can use. Figure 5.5 shows an example of grade, getting more money or getting a better job.
a short-term plan, but you should use a format that Intrinsic motivation is more to do with personal
works for you. You will need to make sure you enter satisfaction, the pride in achieving a goal. Both types
all your deadlines and commitments into this plan. of motivation are important.
Then use the spaces to allocate your study times.
Before you start to study, try to get into the right
Long-term planning
frame of mind. Do not bang the chair and slam the
Any plan needs to work for you. Include all personal
keyboard. Turn off music or the TV and try to clear
and college commitments and deadlines. The plan
your mind. Take a few minutes to breathe deeply.
can cover the whole term or half a term and could
Some people use visualisation to see themselves
look like the example shown in Figure 5.6.
studying and achieving. There are other techniques,
such as saying encouraging words out loud or having
Motivation to study a cup of coffee in a certain chair next to your desk.
It is important that you remain motivated to Having a ritual helps some people to get into the
do your best in your course. Sleepwalking your mood for study.
160
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
10am Tutorial
Activity
Make a list of things that have motivated you in the past. For example, pleasing others, pleasing yourself, financial
motivators, treats, tutor support, family support. Make another list of things that have demotivated you. For
example, task too hard or too easy, lack of support, too tired, having to use maths or computers. Ask why you are
motivated or demotivated and think how you could change or improve your attitude. Finally identify likely sources
of support.
161
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Bearing in mind we are all different, some practical ●● achieve at higher levels than you have in the past
strategies to keep motivation going include: ●● become an independent learner
●● be more confident in your abilities
●● tackling the most difficult aspect first and then
●● train yourself to read efficiently and with
moving to easier or more interesting topics later
●● dividing harder areas into chunks of learning
understanding
●● develop organisational skills
●● taking regular breaks
●● develop planning and time management skills
●● building in treats for small and larger successes
●● work with less stress
(e.g. going for a swim, having a chocolate bar,
●● encourage those around you
buying a longed-for item of clothing, taking a
●● develop your thinking skills
holiday)
●● improve your memory.
●● planning well and planning for success
●● using positive language and not dwelling on the
There are many advantages to improving your
negative study skills and the time is worth investing. You
●● using photos and positive messages around the
will save time in the end and you will be more
house to remind you of your goal likely to achieve your full potential. For example,
●● socialising with people who share your goals or
it is not worth being held back by long-standing
who understand and support you reading habits that are inefficient and frustrating.
●● understanding that everyone fails sometimes and
When you become frustrated in your learning,
we can learn from failures. it is easy to opt out and ultimately miss out on a
rewarding career.
Activity Study skills are important in terms of efficiency
Select an assessment that you will be required when studying but also they are helpful life skills.
to undertake as part of your study. Based on the Organisational skills and improved confidence are
previous section of text, develop a detailed plan that very important for every aspect of life. For example,
includes all the steps you need to take to complete when entering work you will need organisational
the assessment. skills in every aspect of work, from getting up in
the morning and then throughout the day.
162
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
163
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
structured and do not really give much room for research where this is relevant. In many cases,
creativity. Other essays are more free-flowing – for including both positive and negative aspects
example, an essay title such as ‘My dream holiday’, shows the depth or your understanding.
as opposed to ‘The role of bath houses in Roman Try to link the paragraphs to remind the reader
Britain’. what you have covered and where you are going
next.
As part of your course you are likely to have to 3 Finish with a conclusion that summarises the
undertake an extended essay. You will be required main points and any conclusions you reach.
to plan the structure of the essay and to organise Sometimes it is useful to consider briefly the
your information logically. Although essays will vary implications of your findings. For example, if
according to an individual’s approach and the topics the essay was about raising the age of starting
covered, they often follow a similar format. school to six years, how would this affect families?
Possible essay format: Remember that a conclusion does not normally
introduce new information.
1 An introduction that sets out the aims of the piece
of the essay in relation to the title. This is normally Check whether your essay is well structured by
quite short and will cover briefly the main areas trying to write the content in one sentence. If you
you intend to include and why. The introduction have difficulty, this might mean you need to divide
should enable the reader to know what the essay the paragraph or omit some content.
is going to be about and possibly your reference
sources. Do not go into any detail. In some Report
cases, you will need to define briefly any difficult There are many different types of reports, each with
concepts or words so the reader knows where you their own formats and conventions – for example,
are coming from. medical reports, business reports, management
2 The body of the essay develops the theme. It reports and feasibility studies. Dictionary.com
will include a series of paragraphs for each main defines a report as ‘an account or statement
theme. For example, you may need to have describing in detail an event, situation, or the like,
paragraphs explaining or comparing theories usually as the result of observation, inquiry, etc.: a
you are covering, or the values and principles report on the peace conference; a medical report on the
that are relevant to the assessment theme. You patient.’ An academic report has some similarities but
should include a key sentence at the beginning also some differences to this definition. An academic
of each paragraph that sets out the main points report will put forward ideas as arguments, backed
you are going to make and that links back to the up with evidence and in a logical sequence. A report
title of the essay. For example, an essay that is is expressed in objective, unemotional language,
entitled ‘The importance of play for children’s which may include some scope for creativity, but this
development’ might have a paragraph on physical is limited.
play. You could introduce that paragraph by
saying: ‘Physical play underpins many areas of Reports require clear, concise presentation of
development. It supports both fine and gross material and include text and diagrammatic formats.
motor skills, but also the skills of locomotion, A report will be presented in sections with headings.
balance, strength and agility’. This statement For example:
shows you are intending to cover these areas in ●● Introduction
the paragraph. Use each paragraph to demonstrate ●● Background information
your knowledge and understanding, and give ●● Methodology
examples to make your points clear. You should ●● Purpose and scope of report
also link your work to underpinning theories or ●● Conclusions.
164
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
Describe Write or speak about the topic or activity, giving detailed information
Explain Make clear, detailed information giving reasons, and showing how or why.
Outline Identify or briefly describe the main points.
Compare Examine the subjects in detail, looking at similarities and differences.
Evaluate Review evidence from different perspectives and come to a valid conclusion or reasoned
judgement.
Discuss Give a detailed account, including a range of views or opinions.
Analyse Break the topic down into separate parts and examine each part.
Show how the main ideas are related and why they are important.
Justify Give a satisfactory explanation for actions or decisions.
Illustrate Give clear information or description with examples (e.g.: spoken, written, pictures,
diagrams).
Summarise Give the main ideas or facts in a concise way.
Apply Explain how existing knowledge can be linked to new or different situations, or in practice.
Table 5.2 Some examples of key task words in titles of essays, projects or assignments (adapted from CACHE
‘How to…’ A Guide to Assessing CACHE QCF Qualifications, Version 1.2, 2010)
165
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
3 Pausing and thinking as you plan. undertake some limited primary data collection,
4 Jotting down early thoughts in a notebook. such as interviewing other learners.
5 Deciding what you already know and what you
might need to investigate. Key term
6 Planning what will go into the introduction, the
body of work and the conclusions. Quantitative and qualitative data – quantitative data
7 Researching and analysing information sources. usually refers to numerical data (i.e. data that can be
measured and counted). This data often appears as
8 Initial reading round the topic but remaining a graph or table. Qualitative data deals more with
focused. descriptions and things that can be observed but not
9 Noting any initial ideas and organising into easily measured.
logical sequences. For example, if you have a group of children, your
10 Noting sub-groups of ideas that could form quantitative data will refer to:
paragraphs. • how many children
• how many girls/boys
Planning your structure • how many three-year-olds
• how many children with special educational needs.
●● Work out how you can introduce the topic and set
Your qualitative data might cover very different issues,
the scene.
such as:
●● Develop the main headings for the writing or
• children’s attitudes to learning
topic, usually about three or four. • parents’ values in relation to education
●● Check the task words in the title of the work • facial expressions
and make sure your structure reflects these (e.g. • emotional states
‘evaluate’ might require greater emphasis on • attitudes to disability.
argument and conclusions). It is possible to express qualitative data in numerical
●● Under each heading, list the points you wish to form – for example, how many parents support the
make. school – but this is a crude form of analysing something
that is quite subtle and with many potential variations
●● Estimate how many paragraphs you will need for
and underlying attitudes.
each point.
●● Estimate word numbers for each point in context
of overall word count.
●● Start to think about how you will present your
Secondary data
findings/conclusions. Secondary data is that which is collected by someone
other than the user – for example, material from
166
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
and analysis and this is often useful when you are ●● government reports
writing an assignment or project. ●● the internet
●● professional journals
Examples of relevant secondary data are: ●● dictionaries
●● thesauruses.
●● Child Poverty surveys: www.cpag.org.uk/
povertyfacts.
Please note that social media – for example,
●● The Effective Provision of Pre-School Education
Facebook or Twitter – are rarely suitable sources for
(EPPE) Project: the first major study in the academic writing.
United Kingdom to focus specifically on the
effectiveness of early years education. The EPPE Accessing lecture and course notes is normally
project is a large-scale, longitudinal study of the straightforward as you will be given these in class
progress and development of 3,000 children in and will take your own notes. College libraries will
various types of pre-school education (http:// be able to provide textbooks, including e-books,
eppe.ioe.ac.uk/). It is now taking the cohort journals and relevant reports.
through to later schooling through the Effective
Pre-School, Primary and Secondary Education Libraries
(EPPSE) projects.
Libraries now have a range of information sources
under one roof. There is usually a reference section
ity
Research Activ
where you can find newspapers, maps, atlases,
encyclopaedias, dictionaries, local information and
Sources of secondary data vary. They may use much more. The book section in a local library will
qualitative or quantitative data and they will be normally be divided into fiction and non-fiction,
of variable quality and validity. Find examples of which will be in separate areas of the library. This
secondary research in an area of your choice.
will be different in a college or school library as these
Prepare a report outlining the research and the
reasons why you think it would be useful for your may not stock fiction but instead focus on textbooks,
coursework. subject-based e-books, online and paper journals,
databases and so forth. Books may be available in
large type for those with poor eyesight as well as
‘talking books’ (on cassette) for blind and partially
Key term
sighted readers.
Valid – validity refers to data being fit for purpose
and relevant. It must be possible for the results to be Always attend any college induction for using library
checked to ensure they are accurate and not just a facilities as this will help you to get the best out of
result of random chance. these resources. Every library will be laid out in a
Reliable – this means that the data is free from error different way and getting familiar with your library
and provides repeatable and consistent results. is important. When you find the section of the
library that stocks relevant books, make a note of
where this is.
Sources of information
Catalogues
There are many sources of information that you may
Most libraries now have an electronic catalogue,
draw on when studying and preparing assessed
although some still have paper card indexes. If
work. These include:
you are searching a computerised catalogue by
●● lecture and course notes title, do not search using the ‘a’ or ‘the’ at the
●● library books/chapters start of the title. If you are searching by author
●● e-books of the book, these are usually listed by their last
167
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
names. In a paper card catalogue, you will search Each of these categories is divided and subdivided
alphabetically. according to the subject:
If you know what you want to read but do not know ●● 000 Generalities (includes computing)
the title of a specific book, try a subject search. Be ●● 100 Philosophy
specific. If your subject is very broad, you may find ●● 200 Religion
that too many results come up. For example, if you ●● 300 Social sciences
‘development’, you will get hundreds of different ●● 500 Natural sciences and mathematics
results (e.g. land development, animal development, ●● 600 Technology (applied science)
product development). If you are too narrow, this may ●● 700 The arts
year-old children’s motor skills, you may not get this ●● 900 Geography and history.
168
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
Typing key words into a search engine can bring 3 Modelling data is used to highlight, organise and
up far too much irrelevant information so be as structure useful information to get data ready
specific as possible. Use sites from well-known and for input into a database. Unstructured data or
preferably UK-based organisations, such as the information can be found in word-processed
NSPCC or National Children’s Bureau. documents or emails and this is unusable in a
database.
Compare different Using computer software is common to help with
methods of analysing data analysis and there is a range of programs
that can be useful – for example, SPSS or Excel.
information or data Once the data or information is in a usable format,
the main analysis can take place. There are many
Your analysis will depend on the type of research
different types of analysis, some of which are highly
or assessed work you are doing. In terms of any
specialised and complex.
kind of research, a good analysis begins with clear
questions, a representative sample of people or
situations and careful interpretation of the data.
Spreadsheets
This is necessary if your results are to be useful. If Spreadsheets such as those created using Excel or
you are undertaking a survey using a quantitative paper-based equivalents are useful tools to look at
method, you will find it useful to use a computer data and make sense of it. You can look at trends and
program to help you analyse the data. You can also may find some unexpected results.
draw up a table and enter data by hand. You may use
Examples are given below of some of the common
percentages or whole numbers, depending on what is
types of analysis. These types of analysis
most helpful.
present data in an easily understood format
If you are analysing information from a literature from which you can draw conclusions and make
review or using course notes and information from recommendations.
an essay, you will be undertaking a similar process to
Graphs
that described earlier in the chapter.
Graphs display data in visual formats that make it
easy to understand – for example, bar charts, pie
Computer data analysis charts and line charts.
Data and information analysis is a process that
has several steps within it. Analysis of information Simple tables
or data covers numerical and other types of data/ These tables show the possible responses, the
information as varied as hair colour, addresses and total number of respondents for each part and the
names, or detailed information from neuroscience or percentage of respondents who selected each answer.
astrophysics. The processes are usually similar and Table 5.3 shows a simple example.
include the following:
1 Data cleaning is where initial data or Red 8 children 40%
information is inspected for errors, such as Blue 4 children 20%
missing entries. At this stage, all the original Yellow 4 children 20%
data should be kept. Pink 2 children 10 %
2 Transforming data is when initial findings are
Green 2 children 10%
manipulated, if this is required, to make sense
of the information or to check if it is significantly Purple 0 children 0%
different from other studies. Table 5.3 Favourite colour
169
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
More complex tables why people answered in the way they did. In the
More complex tables are most often used to compare case of the children’s colour choice favourites, you
subgroups of information (e.g. demographic groups). might ask what factors made the sample of boys
Table 5.4 shows an example. prefer red and blue to all other colours.
Methods of Description
analysing
qualitative data
Thematic analysis Data is analysed by theme. For example, parents are asked what they think about
pre-school provision in the area. It soon becomes clear that most parents’ responses
include comments about public transport. This is then included as a specific theme and
parents with cars are compared with those without.
Comparative This is very similar to thematic analysis. Data from different people/sources is compared
analysis and proceeds until the researcher feels all the key areas are covered. The public
transport example above includes both thematic and comparative analysis.
Discourse analysis This method looks at people’s speech and how they talk about subjects. Researchers
might look at the type of vocabulary and language used and the way people converse.
For example, do they listen and take turns or disregard these conventions? Researchers
will look, for example, for insights into how people talk to each other and what factors,
such as age or income, affect this.
Computer software can help with the analysis of qualitative data, especially content data. However, it cannot
interpret sensitively or capture the nuances or contradictions of some research findings.
Table 5.5 Examples of methods used for qualitative data
170
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
for some people. Most will now use computer Carefully select materials for use in your work only if
software for the analysis. The techniques may they are:
include averages, frequency counts, scales and ●● relevant – do they relate well to the task?
other means. ●● current – are they up to date?
●● valid – see ‘Key term’ on page 167
Reporting ●● reliable – see ‘Key term’ on page 167.
After collecting and analysing all the data, the next
stage is to report your findings. The research chapter It is not always easy to know whether material you
(Chapter 10) has details of this final stage, which is find meets the criteria above and it may be necessary
not required for this unit. for you to discuss with people who can help you.
In most cases, you can apply the criteria yourself.
It is worth looking at the following websites and
Explain how to select publications, but there are many more:
relevant information ●● Government (Department for Education,
project
●● sector organisations – for example, Pre-school
Learning Alliance, National Childminding
Association, Barnardo’s, NSPCC, British
When you receive information about a required
Association of Adoption and Fostering, National
piece of writing or a project, it will normally be
Children’s Bureau
as part of or at the end of a period of study for a
●● Nursery World, Children Today, Times
unit of your qualification. You will therefore have
Educational Supplement.
information from your tutor, such as unit reading
lists or course notes. This can be your starting If you have to undertake a project or piece of writing
point. Reading through course notes will help you about a subject of your choice, it can sometimes
to gain an outline of what you need to do and what be difficult to select what you wish to research.
you need to know. However, researching relevant Remember to follow your interests as this will
information is not straightforward. You will need keep you motivated. It may be worth your while to
to keep re-visiting ideas, and adding and exploring consider available resources before making a final
new ones. choice of topic. If you select a narrow topic that
has not been researched by others, you will find it
Planning your project or piece of writing is covered
difficult to make progress.
earlier in the chapter and this will include:
●● analysing what is required and being clear about Using statistics
the task
Using statistical data is not as difficult as it sounds. If
●● deciding what you already know and what you
you are researching a topic – for example, smoking in
might need to investigate
pregnancy – there is a good deal of detailed statistical
●● researching and analysing information sources.
information available. You need to use this sparingly
Deciding relevant information sources may be but you might want to include a chart showing, for
constrained by what is available but many learners example, how many pregnant mothers smoke or how
need some guidance. You will normally find that a many give up in pregnancy, and so forth. Figure 5.7
number of seemingly relevant articles will come up shows at a glance some useful information about
as a result of an internet or another type of search. smoking in pregnancy across the UK.
171
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
40
35
30
Percentage of mothers
25
20
15
10
0
Wales England Scotland N. Ireland UK
Case Study
Critical thinking
Being critical of what you read is very important.
Based on the information provided in Figure 5.7, You may not be an expert in the subject but you
a local newspaper in Wales contains the should not simply accept what authors say. Almost
following headline: ‘Wales is the worst country all authors/researchers come from a particular
for smoking in pregnancy: babies in Wales perspective. They may have a point to make and may
are being born to mothers who smoke, even leave out the other side of the argument.
though they know it harms their babies.’ The
When you read material, ask the following questions:
article goes on to blame health professionals
and others for this situation. Even though the ●● What is the topic being covered?
headlines do represent the statistical facts, a ●● Is it based on reliable evidence or opinion?
lot is left out, such as the age of mothers, how ●● Does it come from a particular point of view/
the writer is taking a particular angle to shock ●● Do they make sense in the wider context of what
172
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
Section 3: How to present The next section covers some of these formats
to enable you to compare the key features in an
information academic context.
formal presentation of I think that the parents of kids in this nursery all need to
be told the rules.
information or data
Correct:
The formats for formal presentation of data will vary
widely according to the circumstances and purposes It is important that the rules are clearly displayed and
of the data. However, they all require information available for parents.
to be presented in a well-structured, consistent way.
Before preparing information or data: Activity
●● set your objectives
Think of some key messages your setting may
●● assess who will read the information or data wish to give to people outside the environment
●● decide on the information you will need who are new to using the service. Write out the key
●● prepare a format and framework messages ‘correctly’ and ‘incorrectly’ for use in
●● test and redevelop the format and framework as you formal communications.
go.
Formal presentations can take the form of: You will need to introduce new concepts or
terminology gradually and explain each of these
●● academic writing, such as projects, assignments, as you go along. You will need to pitch the writing
verbal presentations or essays at the correct level and structure it to meet the
●● formal letters – letters written for formal purposes
requirements of the task. For example, are you being
(e.g. from banks, solicitors, hospitals or schools), asked to ‘’describe’, ‘evaluate’ or ‘compare’. The
which normally contain important personal or material should be presented in a logical sequence,
business information with paragraphs following on from each other and
●● structured reports (e.g. for research, marketing or
appropriately linked. For example:
business activities, or formal reports, such as those
needed in safeguarding cases) Children’s development is very individual but usually
●● verbal presentations to individuals or groups follows the same pattern. The pattern of development is
●● case studies. explored in the next paragraph.
173
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Title page Unit number and title of work. Course title. College name. Your name. Date.
Contents List of contents and page number of where the content can be found. You can also
include an ‘abstract’, which is a brief summary of the report.
Introduction Introduce the writing or project and state briefly your understanding of it and what you
are setting out to do.
Methodology A paragraph stating how you went about the work. For example, literature review,
survey, internet research. Include everything you have used and referred to.
Results Present the results using a mixture of lists, graphs, writing and pictures, as is relevant to
your work. Do not use ‘over the top language’. Keep your comments brief and factual
and state your findings. Develop your argument and present your case.
Conclusions This is where you pull together the key points of your findings. There should not be
anything new in this section.
References List of references you have used.
Appendices if If you have undertaken a survey or there is additional information that does not sit in the
used body of the report, attach it here. Make sure you have made reference to the Appendix
in the report to justify it being there.
Table 5.6 Example of a report format for academic writing
5%
Key term
Diagram – a sketch, outline, drawing or plan that 0%
demonstrates relationships between things or the parts
1970
1973
1976
1979
1982
1985
1988
1991
1994-95
1997-98
2000-01
2003-04
2006-07
2009-10
2012
2015
174
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
Line graphs
Austra
From the line graph in Figure 5.8, you can see at
a glance that the percentage of children living
Ot
in poverty when housing costs are taken into Ca
ia l
na
he
consideration has risen and slightly fallen over a da
r
number of years. The graph also indicates how this
might develop in the future. This information is
much more difficult to explain in words.
UK
Charts (such as pie charts and bar
charts) US
A
Pie charts are normally circles that are divided up
according to percentage information (dividing up a
pie). Again, information is easy to see at a glance.
Venn diagrams
Venn diagrams are a visual way of presenting sets
Figure 5.9 Example of a pie chart: relative numbers of
of information and may consist of two or more native English speakers in the major English-speaking
circles or sets, which demonstrate similarities and countries of the world (Source: Wikipedia)
differences.
In the imaginary example in Figure 5.10, we own home. Where the three sets overlap, these
have three sets of individuals: the first group (A) fortunate individuals own all three and, where
own cars, the second are those who own a flat- only two overlap, only two out of the three items
screen television (B) and the third (C) own their are owned.
A, B & C
A&C B&C
175
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Pour water No
Read Tea bag in Do you
Make tea and add Drink tea
instructions cup have sugar?
milk
Yes
Flow charts
Flow charts normally represent a process. They can
Activity
be simple or complex, and use symbols or words. Develop a simple flow chart about another everyday
Flow charts can picture a straightforward process or activity.
something through which there are different routes.
In Figure 5.11, a flow chart has been developed about
a simple, everyday activity.
Recipient’s details
Name
Title
Company
Address
Date of letter
Your reference: XYZ
Undelivered Goods
I am writing to let you know that I have not received the goods I ordered and paid for three months ago. I have not received any reason
for the delay and require the goods urgently.
I would request that you look into this matter immediately and either despatch the goods or refund the money.
Yours faithfully,
Signature
Name
Enclosure
Cc: Name to receive copy
176
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
Formal letters ●● If you know the name of the person, then use this.
Otherwise, use ‘Sir or Madam’.
Formal letters normally follow a set format with
●● The date can go either side of the page underneath
some individual variations. Figure 5.12 shows an
address details – always include a date. In some
example of a formal letter.
countries, dates are presented differently from the
People tend to read business letters quickly to find out UK. Here, it is normal to place the date before the
the main points. Make your key points early in the month (e.g. 3 June 2011, 3/6/11, 03/06/2011 or any
letter, if possible in the first sentence or two. Letters other combination).
should be single spaced and many people use a ●● Include any reference number, NHS number or
typeface and font size that is set by their organisation. other relevant details.
For personal letters, some people prefer to use a ‘serif’ ●● End the letter with ‘Yours sincerely’ if you
font, in which small lines are added – for example, have written to a named person and ‘Yours
Times New Roman. These additional lines are used faithfully’ if you have written to ‘Sir or
to link words together better, thus making it easier ‘Madam’.
to read. They are also seen by some as classical or ●● Avoid everyday or slang language.
conservative, whereas fonts without serif (sans serif) ●● Avoid vague terms, such as ‘nice’.
are more modern. It is a matter of individual taste. ●● Do not use words like ‘you’re’ – use ‘you are’.
●● Try not to use emotional language, such as ‘you
Leave a line between paragraphs and use short,
give a rubbish service’.
succinct sentences that leave no doubt as to your
●● There are arguments about whether to use full
meaning. Keep your paragraphs as short as possible.
punctuation but some recipients, such as future
Space your letter so it looks good on the page and employers, may prefer this.
keep it as central as possible (do not have the letter
crowded into the first third of the page). Try and keep Verbal presentations
the space above and below the text roughly equal. It
These are a useful way of presenting information.
is best to keep the letter to one page as people tend
They can be used alongside a written report as a
not to read beyond the first page.
way of presenting key findings or features. A verbal
In the first paragraph, tell the recipient the nature of presentation can be made without supporting
the issue. In the final paragraph, make sure you tell materials but this is uncommon and less likely to
the recipient what you want them to do or what you provide an opportunity for you to demonstrate your
can do for them. understanding. Sometimes all that is required to
support a verbal presentation is a brief outline or
When you sign the letter, use your name with your ‘abstract’ of your work, but your tutor will guide you
title in brackets (e.g. Jenny Fisher (Mrs)). about the course requirements. It is very important to
Figure 5.12 shows an example of a personal formal be clear about what you want to say before you start,
letter, which the author wrote recently. It is an example otherwise it is easy to become nervous and to lose
and not intended to be a model for people to follow. the plot completely! It is useful to practise the whole
presentation beforehand. This helps you to find out
how long it takes and where the areas of weakness
Additional points
might be.
●● Recipient details always go on the left-hand side of
the page. Many verbal presentations use computer programs
●● Your address goes on the right but many business such as ‘PowerPoint’ to illustrate key points.
letters do not include a name here. Preparing PowerPoint slides is fairly straightforward
●● The purpose of the letter has been included in and you can use pictures, photographs and colour
bold before the first sentence. This is optional but to enhance your presentation. Key points to bear in
widely used today. mind in any verbal presentation are as follows:
177
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
178
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
7 Parenting capacity – as a learner, it is unlikely that from industry and quality management where
you will be making judgements about parenting processes and outputs are measured against quality
capacity but you need to be aware that this is an standards or customer requirements. In terms of
important area in safeguarding cases and for other presentation of writing or projects, everything
types of assessment contained in these should meet the stated
8 Conclusions and recommendations – for example, requirements of the assessment.
for future monitoring
9 Bibliography. The material in the writing or projects must:
●● be relevant
Not all these headings will be required and others ●● be presented on time
may be more relevant according to the situation. ●● be written at an appropriate level
●● give appropriate detail
Explain what is meant ●● be correctly structured
179
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
proofreading will also include checking for sense, views are important and, although they may not be the
layout and readability. A good proofread will check same as the authors’ views, they are valid so long as
the different layout elements, such as headings, you give a reasoned argument and can back them up.
paragraphs, illustrations, colours, fonts and so forth.
Carefully proofreading your writing or project before Developing and being confident in your own writing
presenting for assessment will ensure your work is style will help you to do this and practice makes
the best you can make it. perfect. If English is an additional language for you,
it is still important for you to write in your own
words, even though this may contain grammatical
Academic referencing errors. Your tutor and assessor will explain where
you can get help to improve your English.
Academic referencing within
your own writing Referencing systems
Academic referencing is very important to ensure There are different recognised academic referencing
that you do not take the credit for other people’s systems, which are formalised ways of referencing,
work. When you use other people’s work, research or as follows:
writing and do not reference it correctly, this is called
plagiarism (see below). Throughout your study, you
●● Harvard, also known as the author–date system
will build on the ideas of others as you develop your
●● MLA (Modern Language Association of America)
●● APA (American Psychological Association)
own understanding, and this is part of learning.
●● MHRA (Modern Humanities Research
Where you use these ideas in your work, you should
normally acknowledge the source of the information. Association)
●● Chicago and CBE.
It is easy to omit this step unknowingly or through
carelessness but it is important to guard against it. The Harvard system is considered here in more
Quotations can be: detail.
●● paraphrases – sections reworded in your own This section has drawn ideas from the ‘Bournemouth
language to clarify University Guide to Citation in the Harvard Style’,
●● summaries – concise versions covering key points September 2010: www.bournemouth.ac.uk/library/
●● direct quotes – taken directly, word for word, from citing_references/docs/Citing_Refs.pdf (accessed
the author’s work. September 2011). You can refer to this document for a
full explanation of the Harvard system.
Plagiarism
Harvard is a popular system. Here the sources of the
A tutor or assessor reading through plagiarised information are contained in brackets in the text.
work can usually tell if there are issues of concern. Footnotes and endnotes are not used. The name of
Sometimes learners link together sentences from the author, date of the publication and relevant page
different sources and it is obvious that they have not numbers are included. For example:
written it themselves as the style is different and the
content does not make sense. At other times learners ‘M. Smith (2010) discussed the subject of bedtimes
take large chunks of information from the internet with parents.’
or from another person’s work and this is usually
obvious as well. Your own thoughts and ideas are or
very important and, while you can draw from others’
‘Jones states that all children should be in bed by
ideas, you must interpret them and make sense of
9pm (Jones 2010, p. 34).’
them yourself. It has to be your own work and must
demonstrate your understanding of the subject and If there are two authors, both names should be
how you have thought about the topics covered. Your quoted but, for more than two, the reference should
180
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
only include the first author’s name with the addition Diagrams, graphs and figures
of ‘et al.’ – for example, Jones et al. (2010). If the
If you use diagrams, graphs or figures from other
author’s name is not given but only the organisation,
sources, you should always reference them in the
you should quote this in full – for example,
same way as text.
‘Department for Education’, rather than ‘DFE’.
Internet references
The rest of the information is contained in a list
of references at the end of the piece of work and Although there is no set way to cite internet
includes the title and publication details. References references, you will need to indicate the source of
should be given in alphabetical order using the (first) your information. This will include:
author’s name. Publication details should include the ●● the name of the author
publisher’s name and the place of publication. The ●● the title of the page as given in the taskbar at the
following is an example of a section of references top of your browser
according to the Harvard system. You might find this ●● the title of the site as given on the homepage
at the end of a piece of work. ●● the date the page was last updated
●● the date you accessed the page
1 Bruner, J. (1990) Acts of Meaning, Cambridge, MA:
●● the full internet address (URL) of the page.
Harvard University Press.
2 Piaget, J. (1962) Play, Dreams and Imitation in If essential information is not available, a note should
Childhood, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul. be made of this (e.g. publication date not known).
3 Vygotsky, L. (1978) Mind in Society, Cambridge, If there other information is available, such as a
MA: Harvard University Press. copyright date or ISBN, include this.
181
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Last updated: 29 September 2009 For example, Lindon, J. (2012) Understanding child
development 0–8 years, 3rd edition, London: Hodder
Date accessed: 12 September 2011 Education.
URL: www.patient.co.uk/doctor/Centile-Charts-and-
Assessing-Growth.htm Newspapers
Author’s surname, initials (date and edition if
Using academic referencing for available) ‘Title of article’, Name of newspaper, section
(e.g. leader column, supplement), page number/web
information sources address.
Key term For example, Marmot, M., Sir (15 February 2012)
‘Children denied opportunity to live up to their
Bibliography – a bibliography is a list of the sources potential’, The Telegraph, Health, available at:
you used to get information for your writing or project. It
www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/9083313/
is included at the end of your work, usually on the last
page. Children-denied-opportunity-to-live-up-to-their-
potential.html.
182
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
●● report formats check spellings that you are unsure about. If you
●● diagrammatic formats have specific problems with writing and spelling,
●● letter formats. make sure you use any available sources of help and
support.
You may be able to draw on other assessments
for other units to develop this information and
your tutor will provide the relevant guidance. It is Section 5: Evaluating
likely that your assessment will expect you to use
experience from your workplace or placement. The
the process involved in
following list provides examples of work you could gathering and presenting
develop and present to meet the assessment criteria.
For a report on aspects of work with children or information
young people, in consultation with your tutor, you
This learning outcome requires you to reflect on the
could include:
importance of:
●● a survey on advertisements relating to health,
●● identifying sources of information
presenting findings using diagrams, graphs or
●● gathering information
tables
●● planning
●● an analysis of attitudes to aspects of healthy
●● presenting information
living, presented in a table or pie/bar chart
●● analysing information.
●● a letter to parents
●● minutes of meetings In everything you do as a practitioner working
●● an event sample of behaviour issues, presented in with children and young people or managing
diagrammatic format services, you will need to be able to critically
●● child observations evaluate the effectiveness of what you are doing.
●● assessments of learning and development You do this to make sure you offer the best possible
●● learning materials for children that include use of service and continually update and improve your
ICT. own practice.
183
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Description
What happened?
Conclusion Evaluation
What else could What was good and bad
you have done? about the experience?
Analysis
What sense can you
make of the situation?
its simplest, learning styles can be divided into three organise and mark up notes
categories: visual, auditory and kinaesthetic. ●● study on your own.
184
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
185
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● the information used was from the most useful, ●● your planned references and reading met your
valid and reliable sources needs
●● you have learned and enhanced your ●● your piece of work met all your goals
understanding of the topic through the ●● your planning led to the piece of work being fit for
information sources used. purpose.
Reflect on the
●● you planned effectively
●● you used the stages of planning a project in ways
that enhanced your work importance of
●● you took note of the task word in your planning
(e.g. ‘evaluate’) analysing information
●● you planned effectively to cover all the main
As you reflect on the importance of your analysis of
points
information, consider whether:
●● your planning in terms of the length, breadth and
depth of your work was successful (e.g. did you ●● your analysis included reference to existing
cover the work in the right detail?) research and good practice
●● your planning enabled you to come to a ●● your analysis was based on the information/data
186
Chapter 5 Supporting the development of study skills (Unit CP 5)
Useful resources
Books
Buzan, T. (1996) The mind map book, New York: Penguin Books.
Buzan, T. (2003) The speed reading book, Harlow: BBC Active.
Gibbs, G. (1988) Learning by doing: a guide to teaching and learning methods, Oxford: Further
Educational Unit, Oxford Polytechnic.
Kolb, D.A. (1984) Experiential learning: experience as the source of learning and development, Upper
Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
Sylva, K., Melhuish, E., Sammons, P., Siraj-Blatchford, I. and Taggart, B. (2004) The effective
provision of pre-school education (EPPE) project: final report, London: DfES and Institute of Education,
University of London.
Tolman, E.C. (1948) ‘Cognitive maps in rats and men’, Psychological Review, 55(4): 189–208.
‘Bournemouth University Guide to Citation in the Harvard Style’ (September 2010, accessed
September 2011), www.bournemouth.ac.uk/library/citing_references/docs/Citing_Refs.
‘Child and family: the case study’, Research Mindedness in Social Work and Social Care, www.resmind.
swap.ac.uk/content/08_case_studies/case_studies_01_01.htm
187
Chapter 6 Working with families
of children and/or young people
(Unit CP 6)
Working with families is a key aspect of work with setting about themselves and how they relate to the
children and young people and will influence how outside world. For most children and young people,
the best outcomes for the child or young person can the family is the safe base from which they interact
be achieved. Although some children and young with the rest of the world and learn their values,
people are alone in the world, most are part of a gender and ethnic identities, as well as what is
wider family group, even when they do not live acceptable social behaviour. Many things affect the
together. Families are basic units in our society and families’ ability to care for their young and this is
family relationships significantly affect the lives of explored further in this chapter.
children and young people, forming an important
context for practitioners. The world of the family and There are no ‘one size fits all’ definitions of the
community is a ‘life support’ system for a child or family. Definitions are varied and sometimes
young person. Families provide for the basic needs confusing. However, the family is normally
of their young, and the young learn in the family understood to be the people who are legally related
188
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
to the child or young person and those who, through and evaluation for the setting and service. There is
relationships, have become an accepted part of their information on the internet regarding evidence-based
family. This will include, for example: practice and research into work with families. For
more information, you can refer to the Centre for
●● biological mothers and fathers, married or
Excellence and Outcomes in Children’s and Young
unmarried
●● biological brothers or sisters
People’s Services (C4EO) website (www.c4eo.org.uk),
●● non-resident parents
which will signpost to further reliable information.
●● live-in partners
●● step-parents and step-siblings
●● grandparents or other family carers
Section 1: The role of the
●● adoptive and foster parents
●● gay and lesbian parents and their partners
practitioner when working
●● residential care workers with families of children
●● carers of young offenders in secure units.
and young people
Some families do not have children or young people
and others may consist of groups of individuals in Currently, work with families emphasises the
various living arrangements. provision of support at an early stage when possible
difficulties are identified to prevent more substantial
difficulties developing. Early intervention can take
Learning outcomes place for any age, at any time; it is not just for the very
young child. A key goal is to work in partnership with
1. Understand the role of the
families to support their parenting role and to help
practitioner when working with
families of children and young people. build strength, health and resilience into the family.
it is important to be aware of the evidence base for expert with superior knowledge and parents and
practice. Why do practitioners do what they do? How families have little say in what happens
do practitioners know that what they are doing is right ●● the befriending model, where practitioners are
and will achieve the best possible outcomes? These seen as friends and there are no clear boundaries
questions form part of ongoing reflective practice or expected outcomes.
189
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Early years
practitioners
Family learning Health
practitioners professionals
Drug and
alcohol Practitioner Early support
projects roles service
Voluntary
organisations Play specialists
such as and therapists
Barnardo’s
Youth Education
service psychologists
Social
workers
Figure 6.2 Different practitioner roles for those working with families
The partnership model is the most widely mutual respect and partnership where views are
recognised and thought of as good practice, but exchanged and valued.
there may be occasions when it is appropriate to
use the other models. Practitioners have very clear In Practice
sets of values and principles to use when working
with families. The principles and values for the What is the aim of your organisation’s work with
National Occupational Standards for practitioners families? Observe how families are welcomed
who work with parents can be found at www. into the setting and suggest ways to improve their
experience. Consider how your own practice
parentinguk.org.
could be improved in this area.
Power relationships are very important when
working with families. It is easy for organisations
involved to fall into the trap of reproducing all the
The processes of
inequalities that exist in society. Organisations working with families in
may discriminate against families because,
for example, they are poor or have English as relation to the role of the
an additional language, without being aware practitioner
of it. Settings and services need to make sure
their policies and procedures work towards The processes of working with families will vary
equality and inclusion. Individual managers and with the nature of individual job roles and the
practitioners need to be aware that they may purpose of the setting or service. For example,
hold attitudes that value some families more someone who is working with children in a day
than others – for example, based on social class nursery, caring for children of fee-paying parents,
or race. Work with families must be based on will work with families differently from the person
190
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
providing targeted support to a family where ●● practitioners whose contact with the wider family
violence is suspected or alleged. In the first case, may be incidental to their main roles, such as
working with families, although important, may not some teachers or police officers.
be the main focus of the job role. In the second case,
the focus of the job role may be direct work with the In practice, the distinction is not always clear-cut as
family. services will overlap and may be co-located.
ity
Research Activ
As can be seen from Table 6.1, there are many
different job roles in working with families/
parents with different purposes. These can be Find out about different job roles where the
divided into: main work is with families. Compare the type of
work undertaken and highlight similarities and
●● practitioners whose main role is work with differences.
parents and families – for example, parent
support advisors in schools, outreach workers in
Sure Start centres, children’s centres or justice Levels of family need
settings Families will vary in their level of need, as Figure 6.3
●● practitioners whose main work is with children indicates. Tier 1 includes universal services with no
and young people but who interact with parents/ major additional needs. Tier 2 is where families need
families on a daily basis additional support to prevent problems in the future.
●● practitioners whose work with families is part Families within Tiers 3 and 4 have greater needs and
of a broader work role – for example, health the role of the practitioner will be different. There may
visitors be a high level of intervention and support required.
191
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Tiers of Need
Low Level of Need Medium Level of High Level of Need Child is Already
Need Accommodated
Figure 6.3 Levels of family need (taken from DfES Children’s Services, The Market for Parental & Family Support Services.
2006, PriceWaterhouseCoopers)
192
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
193
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
194
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
195
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
ethics that underpin confidentiality and security of required to take action themselves and contact
information. appropriate people or agencies.
●● In cases where there are concerns about a child or
Communication boundaries with external agencies young person’s health, development or learning,
are normally included within policies and procedures these are normally shared first with the family but
of the setting and depend on circumstances. For may also need to be shared with practitioners or
example, communication boundaries with the others on a ‘need to know’ basis.
library service may include informing the library ●● Where there are legal issues, such as substance
staff of specific learning needs but not about family abuse, the practitioner may not able to keep the
circumstances. information confidential.
●● Where there have been complaints from other
Confidentiality – the duty to maintain confidence and ●● Keep desks clear from any personal or confidential
thereby respect privacy. A person’s right to privacy information.
is enshrined in Article 12 of the United Nations (UN) ●● Exercise care when replying to emails from people
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948).
or organisations or when sending emails.
●● Lock computers when leaving the area.
families. It is closely related to communication ●● Lock cabinets at night and during the day when
boundaries, as discussed earlier. Practitioners should you are not using them.
work with families sensitively and, where possible, ●● Keep passwords private.
196
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
bring about the best outcomes for the child or young Confidentiality when working
person.
with the wider family
Establishing a positive relationship with a child or Sometimes situations arise that involve the wider
young person is very important for practitioners. family – that is, those who do not have legal
Practitioners need to be able to communicate responsibility for the child or young person but who
effectively and sensitively with children and young may have a close relationship with them. Policies and
people. As the relationship develops, or even early in procedures will provide general guidance on how
the relationship, the child or young person may share confidentiality issues are dealt with but individual
sensitive personal information. The practitioner then circumstances will influence the detail.
has to exercise professional judgement about what
to do with the information. It is also important that Confidentiality within the work
certain issues are shared with parents and often the
team
practitioner can support the child or young person to
The section covering communication boundaries on
do that. Practitioners can sometimes suggest sources
page 194 includes issues of confidentiality within
of advice or further help.
the work team. However, it is important to recognise
It is important to be sensitive to the wishes of the that, even where there are clear boundaries, there is
child or young person in keeping their confidence, sometimes a need to share confidential information
but there are occasions when this cannot be done. to protect the welfare of children or young people.
In cases of safeguarding where children or young Their welfare should always be paramount.
people allege abuse, especially where a parent or
family member is involved, they must be made aware Case Study
immediately that what they have shared cannot be
kept confidential. Liam is four years old and his mother cares for
him. At weekends and in emergencies, Liam’s
In some cases, however, the issues are difficult to
paternal grandparents often care for him.
interpret or manage. Practitioners can discuss issues
Liam’s mother tells the setting that Liam is being
with their managers to gain advice or to enable
investigated for Hepatitis B but asks them not
referrals to other agencies.
to tell his grandparents. She is concerned that
they will tell his father, who will blame her as
Confidentiality when working she is an ex drug addict.
197
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
more stable and secure adult. Although different 1 Proximity maintenance (wanting to be physically
researchers have different views on attachment, its close to the attachment figure)
basic concepts have been recognised as crucial for 2 Separation distress/anxiety
healthy development. Taking attachment needs into 3 Safe haven (retreating to mother/carer when
account affects practice today and has transformed sensing danger or feeling anxious)
the way young children are cared for in institutions, 4 Secure base (exploration of the world knowing
such as hospitals, residential care and day care. that the attachment figure will protect them from
danger).
Key term
Mary Ainsworth (1978)
Attachment – attachments are emotional bonds that
Mary Ainsworth was a colleague of Bowlby’s.
infants develop with their parents and other primary
caregivers, such as their key person in an early Ainsworth used a laboratory experiment called
childhood setting. These emotional bonds are central the ‘strange situation’. In the strange situation,
to a child’s well-being. 12-month-old babies and their parents were brought
to the laboratory and systematically separated from
The importance of attachment is emphasised in and reunited with one another. Babies fell into at
guidance to early years and care settings – for least three categories:
example, in the Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS). 1 Babies who were securely attached. These babies
were upset when the parent left but on their return
Key term they went to them and were easily comforted.
2 Babies who were ‘anxious resistant’. These babies
Separation anxiety – a normal developmental
stage during which a child experiences anxiety when were extremely distressed on separation and, when
separated from the primary carer. Separation anxiety is reunited, were difficult to soothe and demonstrated
normal between eight months of age and may last until conflicting behaviours, which sometimes showed a
14 months old, or may occur later at 18–36 months.
desire to ‘punish’ the parent for leaving them (e.g.
turning away, then clinging to them).
John Bowlby (1965) 3 Babies who were ‘avoidant’. These babies did not
seem distressed when the parent left and actively
There are a number of theorists who have
avoided contact on their return, continuing to play
contributed to attachment theory; the most
with toys on the laboratory floor.
influential is John Bowlby. Bowlby was a
psychologist, psychoanalyst and psychiatrist with an Ainsworth’s research found that how babies
interest in child development who researched and behaved in the strange situation was linked to their
published work between the 1950s and 1970s. experiences at home. Securely attached babies tended
to have parents who were responsive to their needs.
Bowlby felt that secure attachments are the basis of
our evolutionary survival as babies are completely
dependent on adults to meet their needs. Bowlby
J. Robertson and J. Robertson
found that babies and children under three years The Robertsons worked closely with Bowlby and
old could be psychologically damaged by being made a series of films that highlighted the plight of
in an institution and needed a close, consistent young children in hospital or who were separated
relationship for healthy emotional development. from their main carers. It was their work that helped
Bowlby called this psychological damage ‘maternal to change the experiences of young children in
deprivation’, as he felt this relationship should be hospital, who previously were taken away from
with the mother (or permanent mother substitute) their parents for extended periods and, as a result,
experienced high levels of separation anxiety/
According to Bowlby, attachment takes place in the distress. In severe separation anxiety, the child goes
early years of life and has four key features: through three stages (see Table 6.3).
198
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
Activity
Observe children in your setting as they settle in Reflective practice
or cope with a big change. Explain how you know
when a child is well attached: Engage with or observe a child who is distressed
1 to the parent, and because of separation from a parent or key person
and write a reflective account of the experience,
2 to the key person. drawing on attachment theory.
199
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
200
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
child and the adult who is their key person. This Listening and responding to children
means each baby or child feels special and cared
In order to support secure attachment and build
for when they are away from home. Although
up a special relationship, it is necessary for the
the relationship is professional, being a key
practitioner to listen and respond to the child.
person is also an emotional and loving role, and
This includes picking up and responding to the
practitioners will experience intense relationships
child’s verbal and non-verbal cues, such as early
with a child with all the feelings that may bring
signs of distress, boredom or need (e.g. facial
about. In the setting, there should be others
expression, quivering lip, distressed crying).
who know the child well and can step in to a key
Parents will have provided detailed information
person role in cases where the key person leaves or
on their child’s feelings, preferences, life story and
is away from work.
early experiences. Learning from this is vital for
Settings find that the key person approach provides practitioners to be able to respond sensitively to
the best possible experience for the child, as well as a child.
giving job satisfaction to practitioners and customer
satisfaction to parents/families. Everyday practice
When the child is well attached to a key person,
Activity this relationship comes first. Young children
need familiarity, consistent and predictable
Find out from key persons how they cope with the routines, and the opportunity to play freely. This,
emotional demands of attachment to a child they together with secure attachments, gives them
work with. What help do they need to enable them the foundation for their positive learning and
to remain attached yet professional? development.
201
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
202
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
The possible effects of 1983). These styles are described in Table 6.5. These
describe a normal range of parenting and are not
different parenting styles describing neglectful or abusive families, except
where indicated.
Key term
Although the original work by Baumrind was
Parenting style – parenting refers to the rearing of a undertaken some years ago, it remains relevant
child or young person and the care, love, and guidance today. In 2011, the Department for Education and
given by a parent. The style (way) in which parents rear
Department of Health quoted from Utting (2009).
their child or young person has been found to be linked
to their well-being, development and behaviour. The quote discusses the critical factors during the
early years and states that:
203
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Activity
Helicopter parents are overprotective and continually hover over their child. Some children may find this
very embarrassing and may want their parents to ‘back off’. A contrast is sometimes called ‘submarine’
parenting, where parents remain hidden, only surfacing when needed. Make a note of the pros and cons
of each approach for the parent and for the child or young person.
204
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
In Practice
In an early years setting, the boys are playing happily What are the issues raised by the father’s comment?
in the domestic play area. A father comes to collect
How should the practitioner respond?
his son who is play ‘ironing’. The father comments
that letting his son play in this way will turn him Although one incident cannot tell you about the
into a girl and he does not want that. He pulls the parenting style, what might this father’s behaviour
child away from the domestic play area and speaks indicate?
sternly to him.
205
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Many settings undertake work with parents to ●● understanding that they may be more dependent
increase understanding and, where possible, help on adults for approval and direction and may need
to change behaviour that may be damaging for extra support
the child or young person. This can lead to ethical ●● giving opportunities to enable them to think for
dilemmas for practitioners who need to respect a themselves
parent’s beliefs and culture. Policies and procedures ●● looking beyond the ‘good behaviour’
or a statement of the ethos of the setting may be a ●● building up self-esteem by giving praise and
good starting point. It is important to remember that encouragement
children or young people are all different and should ●● encouraging them to make choices
not be labelled just because they have parents with ●● modelling and encouraging assertive behaviour
particular parenting styles. In the case of uninvolved ●● modelling appropriate language to help them to
parents in particular, there may be a need for active challenge effectively
intervention if children are neglected or suffering ●● giving opportunities for them to succeed
psychological damage. ●● giving opportunities for risk taking in a safe
environment.
Authoritative (democratic)
Parents who are authoritarian in their approach may
parenting style find it difficult to agree with the values of the setting
Good professional practice has many similarities or understand the purpose of the way the child or
with the authoritative style of parenting. Although young person is treated. Practitioners need to work
every child and young person is different, those with parents to assist their understanding without
brought up with an authoritative parenting style may implying criticism or being patronising.
find it easier to settle in and take advantage of the
learning and development opportunities in a setting.
Permissive parenting style
Parents who understand this type of parenting will
generally understand and support the aims and Children or young people who have experienced
goals of the setting. permissive parenting may have high self-esteem but
can be unrealistic about themselves. They may find
it difficult to settle into a consistent routine and to
Activity consider others. Practitioners can support children
and young people by:
Being a parent
●● working with them to negotiate, set and
Write a job description and person specification for consistently maintain boundaries
a parent.
●● encouraging turn taking, sharing and fairness
●● modelling consideration for others
206
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
Uninvolved parenting style authorities (LAs) have a duty to ensure that parents
in their area have access to a PPS, which has a role
The child or young person who has experienced
in making sure that parents’ views are heard and
this parenting style has poorer outcomes than with
understood and that these views inform local policy
any other parenting style. Practitioners can support
and practice.
children and young people by:
●● providing extensive support to help them to Partnership can take different forms and does
overcome their disadvantage so far as is possible not just ‘happen’. It requires time, effort, skill and
●● supporting referrals for specialist help – for training. Partnership should be embedded in all
example, psychologists, play therapists or social aspects of the setting or service involved. Examples
workers of partnership activities that take place are:
●● providing age appropriate nurture groups/facilities ●● undertaking ‘hands on’ activities with children in
●● providing a structured environment the setting
●● providing consistent one-to-one as well as group ●● involvement in the leadership and management of
support the setting
●● being interested and concerned for their welfare ●● parents observing their own children at home and
●● providing praise and encouragement reporting back
●● providing consistent routines. ●● regular information exchange and feedback
●● encouraging participation in decision-making for
3 Progress check
their own children and for the way the setting
works.
Work alone or in a group to prepare a leaflet
explaining the advantages of an authoritative A number of different projects have been set up
parenting style. to research and support parent partnerships. The
following are examples but there are many more:
●● The Youth Justice Board has responded to the
Section 3: The importance introduction of ‘Parenting Orders’ for parents of
young people who are at risk of, or known to be,
of working in partnership offending or who are failing to attend school by
with parent(s)/carer(s) developing a parenting programme.
●● The Peers Early Education Partnership (PEEP)
The outcomes for children and young people is an early learning programme which aims
are better when settings and services work in to improve the life chances of children,
partnership with parents/carers. Partnerships are particularly in disadvantaged areas. Its purpose
so important they have been recognised in law. In is to raise educational attainment, especially
2006, the Scottish Parliament passed the Scottish in literacy, by supporting parents and carers in
Schools (Parental Involvement) Act. The Act was their role as the first educators of their
introduced to help parents, carers and schools children.
work together as partners in children’s learning. ●● Parents as partners in children’s early learning
In England, there is a statutory requirement for and development (PEAL) project: this supports
partnership working within the EYFS (2012). the EPPE research (2004, 2007) and shows
Parent partnership schemes (PPS) for children and that a good home learning environment is
young people with special educational needs or the most effective way of enhancing a child’s
disabilities have been in existence since 1994. Local learning.
207
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
work with both mothers and fathers who are the Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989) and
parents of the child or young person. Often work placing the child’s welfare at the heart of the process
with fathers requires different strategies to engage ●● understanding the needs of both parents,
them and support them in their parenting role. It including those of non-resident fathers and
is important to note that fathers are often more minority ethnic groups
involved with their children than in previous years. ●● having effective key worker/person systems in
208
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
●● supporting design of better services and ●● being able to improve own skills and knowledge
interventions ●● being aware of and using evidence-based practice.
●● making sure services are conveniently located
●● showing respect for the parent/carer regardless of
Power relationships
their behaviour or attitudes
It is important to remember that, when working
●● respecting diversity and the parents’ culture,
with families, there is often an imbalance of power.
language and beliefs
Parents may feel powerless and practitioners often
●● recognising that the parents have unique
have to work hard to make partnerships work.
information about their child or young person and
are their primary educators
●● building on parents’ strengths and experience Developing effective
●● establishing and maintaining positive
relationships
working with families
●● welcoming and valuing parents when supporting
●● effectively exchanging information with parents
●● taking time to get to know parents and families children and/or young
●● encouraging active participation of parents (and
people
the child or young person) in decision-making
●● providing relevant resources and information for Effective working means that practitioners will meet
parents the individual and unique needs of the families
●● supporting parents through difficulties and/or they work with. They are likely to use methods and
when the child or young person has to be referred strategies that have an evidence base and they will
to other agencies have built in regular evaluation of their work. An
●● having clear and accessible policies and procedures effective assessment of need will be required to
for work with families and parents determine the most appropriate support. The list of
209
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
210
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
will make the work more fulfilling and the child or Parent partnerships not only assist them in their
young person is likely to progress well. Partnerships parenting role but can go beyond. For example,
will often allow parents and carers to be honest they can:
about the service they receive and they have a ●● increase their confidence and self-esteem
positive input to the quality improvement cycle. ●● empower them to take decisions themselves
●● open doors into work or further training
If you have a genuine partnership, this will also lead
●● provide a way of developing new skills and
to a mutual and open dialogue. This means feelings
and issues can be expressed in a non-judgemental knowledge.
way. An atmosphere of openness and acceptance
If a child or young person has special educational
leads to less hostility and more involvement from
needs or disabilities, partnerships are very
parents.
important. Parents may have a lead professional or
Parents and carers often provide practical help someone to help deal with the multiple problems that
in settings in many different ways and this is may arise. This must be firmly based in partnership
encouraged in the best settings. They can help with to enable the parents/carer to grow in confidence and
learning activities and bring their own special skills understand the issues affecting their child. The days
to the setting. For example, a parent who is a chef in of ‘being done to’ should be long gone.
an ethnic restaurant can undertake cooking activities
with children, which would not only increase their Case Study
learning and skills but tell them about different
cultures. Partnerships with parents and carers from Alison has seven-year-old twins. She left school
different ethnic groups allow settings to build on the at 16 with no qualifications and has never
strengths of different parts of society. worked. When the twins were three, she started
Close relationships with families and children to help at the local pre-school and, although
and young people can become very demanding it took time, practitioners got alongside her
and sometimes difficult to handle. Practitioners and encouraged her to develop herself. Within
should remain approachable and involved, while nine months, Alison was on the management
maintaining their professional role. committee. In order to support the twins, she
took literacy classes and these improved her
confidence and self-esteem. Now the twins
Benefits of partnership working
are at school, Alison is working as a teaching
for parents/carers assistant and has nearly completed her Level 3
Developing close and supportive relationships with qualification. She takes time to be involved in
practitioners is beneficial to parents/carers: the local parent partnership scheme.
●● It gives them the confidence that their child or
young person is well cared for.
●● It opens doors to information and support.
Section 4: Factors which
For a parent lacking confidence or trust in services,
influence life experiences
forming a positive partnership with practitioners can There are many different factors that influence life
be a way to get the help and information they need. experiences and, although these may be common,
Parents value a partnership approach where they they are individual and unique to each family.
are involved, not judged and where their views are Certain life experiences are expected, such as the
respected. They want practitioners to get alongside experience of bereavement, but they will all have
them and show interest in their child or young an impact on a child or young person’s emotional
person and the life of the family. well-being. Good support will help the child or
211
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Family
breakdown
Abuse or Change in
bullying family structure
Child or young
Poverty Bereavement
person
Illness or
accident Moving home
New siblings
Figure 6.7 Commonly experienced major life events for children and young
people
Major life events affect children, young people, parents Possible effects of major
and families in similar ways but the impact on their
emotional and social well-being will vary according to:
life events
●● the severity of the experience It is important to recognise that practitioners will
●● the availability of high-quality support from time to time have to support children and
●● the resilience of the individual or family concerned. young people who experience mental health and
psychological well being issues. This is regardless of
It is important to emphasise that, with or sometimes dealing with major life events but may become worse
without support, most children, young people, parents during difficult periods. Parents, carers and families
and families will cope well with major life events. may also require support.
212
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
Possible effects of major life people may also experience additional major life
events. For example:
events on the child
●● becoming a young carer of a parent or family
To mature emotionally and socially, children interact
●● experiencing relationship difficulties
with people outside their home (e.g. close relatives,
●● developing sexuality
friends, neighbours, people at day care settings,
●● underage pregnancy
schools, sports and leisure activities). By coping with
●● exposure to drugs and alcohol abuse
common daily conflicts, stresses and strains, children
●● personal mental health issues
gradually acquire the skills to handle more significant
●● leaving home or care settings.
life events. Children also learn by watching how
adults deal with stress in their lives. Children need The young person under stress during major life
to be made aware that to be anxious or to feel sad is events may demonstrate any of the behaviours listed
normal and that these feelings will ease over time. above for children but may also:
The child under stress during major life events may ●● abuse drugs or alcohol
exhibit the following types of behaviour: ●● get into trouble with the law
●● engage in antisocial behaviour
●● withdrawn behaviour
●● make inappropriate relationships
●● aggressive behaviour
●● find themselves being groomed for sexual purposes
●● overactive or passive behaviour
●● play truant and be excluded from school.
●● sleep problems
●● irritability or a ‘short fuse’
ity
Research Activ
●● reverting to behaviour associated with a younger
child
●● changes in their relationships with families and Explain the factors that influence how children or
friends young people cope with major life events. Find out
●● being preoccupied with what happened to them different views on what makes a child or young
●● disruption to their learning person more resilient. How can practitioners support
children and young people to become more resilient?
●● exaggerated reactions to events.
213
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● caring responsibilities for their own parents more likely to experience poverty, poor health
●● poverty and wellbeing and be involved in antisocial
●● drug and alcohol abuse. behaviour. Families will go on evolving. As more
women have careers and seek more egalitarian
Adults may suffer stress for many reasons. One of relationships, men and women frequently need
the key pressures is concern about their children and to negotiate their roles within the family. This is
young people. On their website, the charity Family likely to be heightened as the economic downturn
Lives (www.familylives.org.uk) reports that, in 2010, takes its toll on employment and families have to
there was an increase in parents calling into their be flexible about who is in work.’
‘Parentline’. Parents were worried about their own
or their children’s mental health and were suffering This lack of stability means families are often
general stress, depression and anxiety. Depending on vulnerable to the effects of major life events. Families
circumstances, practitioners can support parents by: are reliant on the individual members to work
together and support each other. Whole families will
●● recognising need be deeply affected by events such as loss of income,
●● sensitive and timely intervention
poor housing or ill health of individual members.
●● personalising the outcomes approach to problems
The consequences of stress vary with the nature
●● offering a listening ear
and severity of the events, the family’s emotional
●● providing information
resilience and the availability of appropriate support.
●● signposting to specialist help
●● supporting a multi-agency approach if required.
214
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
The Child Poverty Action Group (CPAG, 2011) problems, withdrawal or restlessness
highlights the inequalities behind child poverty and ●● mental reactions, such as difficulty concentrating,
suggests ways that government and others can confusion or nightmares
take action to deal with it. Investigate child poverty ●● physical reactions, such as tiredness, panic
in your home country and prepare a report
attacks, headaches, dizziness or digestive
highlighting your findings.
problems.
215
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
216
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
217
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
218
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
Goal setting it, will try to keep things unchanged and, when a
crisis occurs, they may resist change in relationships
When working with parents/carers, it is sometimes
and the balance of power. Each family member may
appropriate to help them set goals for the future.
assume different roles when under stress (e.g. a
Recognising their strengths and existing resources
child may become a carer). There is a great deal of
may assist them to plan for the future. This needs to
published research into families as systems.
be done with sensitivity. Barriers should be identified
and, where possible, overcome. It is important to encourage every family member
involved to share their views and how they want
Provision of practical support things to change and develop. It can take a long time
Practical support, such as childcare, is often helpful. to understand complex family interactions and help
Being flexible and realistic about what can be offered the family to move on. Family therapy and other
is important. Practitioners may be able to support professional help may be needed.
access to other services and demonstrate using
support materials with the child or young person.
Work with families in crisis who have
Psychological therapy multiple or complex needs
This will depend on the nature of the crisis. For
example, for serious trauma, there is a form of Key term
cognitive behavioural therapy that can be used (and
other therapies are also available). The National Multiple or complex needs – families with many
complicated and related needs and/or serious, severe
Institute for Clinical Excellence’s (NICE) 2005 and and intense needs. For example, families with children
2006 guidelines may be helpful for this situation with many impairments, abusive families, families with a
(see www.nice.org.uk/CG26 and www.nice.org.uk/ child or young person with a life-limiting condition.
nicemedia/live/11568/33191/33191.pdf).
Families with multiple or complex needs may benefit
Strategies that could be used from a family-focused approach to assessing their
to support the family in times of needs and this often involves use of the Common
crisis Assessment Framework (CAF). The whole family
assessment model usually means:
Many of the strategies that have been identified for
children and young people and for parent/carers are ●● a greater level of family involvement
also useful for families. Initial assessment is key to ●● better understanding of the range of needs
unlocking appropriate support and raising awareness ●● practitioners and families getting to know one
in families about how things are and how they could another and building relationships
be improved. Dealing with the stigma that can be ●● both children and adult services becoming
219
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Figure 6.8 Disasters affecting families occur frequently and need a positive response
220
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
221
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● reducing substance abuse, violence and ●● make sense of the role of different agencies and
delinquency through various programmes of the many different people they meet
intervention, often through the justice system ●● manage multiple contacts with service providers
●● interventions for behavioural disorders (e.g. anger ●● get professionals to understand their child’s needs
management) in the context of the whole family
●● practitioners modelling positive behaviour and ●● have their own knowledge of their child
encouraging and working with families to do the recognised
same – this can be supported through group work ●● negotiate a better service when delay and
or one-to-one counselling bureaucracy seems to be affecting their child.
●● support for teenage pregnancy and/or young
carers (e.g. schools based to help them complete It is very important that services for children
their education) and young people of all ages are aware of the
●● multi-systemic therapy – an intensive family- and difficulties experienced by many families and take
community-based treatment programme that steps to make sure they offer an effective multi-
focuses on the entire world of chronic and violent agency or integrated team. When they become
juvenile offenders, including their homes and aware that a family is in crisis, practitioners need
families, schools and teachers, neighbourhoods to be sensitive to the situation and aware of the
and friends boundaries of their own role and expertise. They
●● media-based therapy – this includes cognitive need to be aware of the roles and responsibilities of
therapies which are sometimes used with children other professionals and agencies and the potential
and young people with behavioural issues for referrals.
●● programmes for coping and dealing with
bullying. Referrals
Settings and practitioners need to know about how
These interventions are found across the country but
referrals work, who is involved and the stages that
not all are available everywhere.
they go through (e.g. the work of multi-agency panels,
Team Around the Child (TAC) approaches, the role
How practitioners can of lead professionals). They need to be able to support
work with families in families to refer themselves where this is possible.
222
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
Case Study
Useful resources
Contact a Family
For families with disabled children.
www.cafamily.org.uk
Family Lives
A national charity providing help and support in all aspects of family life.
www.familylives.org.uk
Family Action
A leading provider of services to disadvantaged and socially isolated families since its foundation
in 1869.
www.family-action.org.uk
223
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Books
Ainsworth, .M., Blehar, M.C., Waters, E. and Wall, S. (1978) Patterns of attachment: a psychological
study of the strange situation, Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Baumrind, D. (1967) ‘Child-care practices anteceding three patterns of preschool behavior’, Genetic
Psychology Monographs, 75(1): 43–88.
Bowlby, J. (1965) Child care and the growth of love, London: Penguin.
Department for Education (2012) Statutory framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage. London:
Department for Education.
Department for Education and Department of Health (2011) Families in the Foundation Years – evidence
pack, London: Department for Education, Department of Health.
Department of Health (2009) Healthy child programme: pregnancy and the first five years of life,
London: Department of Health.
Doherty, J. and Hughes, M. (2009) Child development: right from the start, London: Pearson.
Elfer, E., Goldschmied, E. and Selleck, D. (2003) Key persons in the nursery: building relationships for
quality provision, London: David Fulton.
224
Chapter 6 Working with families of children and/or young people (Unit CP 6)
Evangelou, M., Brooks, G., Smith, S. and Jennings, D. (2005) Birth to school study: a longitudinal
evaluation of the Peers Early Education Partnership (PEEP), Oxford: DfES Publications.
Gray, A. (2006) ‘The time economy of parenting’, Sociological Research Online, 11(3), available at www.
socresonline.org.uk/11/3/gray.html.
Ipsos MORI (2009) Families in Britain, London: Ipsos MORI.
Maccoby, E.E. and Martin, J.A. (1983) ‘Socialization in the context of the family: parent–child
interaction’, in P.H. Mussen (ed.) and E.M. Hetherington (vol. ed.), Handbook of child psychology: Vol.
4. Socialization, personality and social development, 4th ed., New York: Wiley, pp. 1–101.
Ofsted (2008) Early years: leading to excellence, Manchester: Ofsted.
Rutter, M. (1981) Maternal deprivation reassessed, 2nd ed., Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Sammons, P., (2007) Summary report. Influences on children’s attainment and progress in Key Stage
2: cognitive outcomes in Year 5: Effective Pre-school and Primary Education 3–11 Project (EPPE 3–11),
London: Institute of Education, University of London and DfES.
Schore, A.N. (1996) ‘The experience-dependent maturation of a regulatory system in the
orbital prefrontal cortex and the origin of developmental psychopathology’, Development and
Psychopathology, 8: 59–87.
Sylva, K., Melhuish, E., Sammons, P., Siraj-Blatchford, I. and Taggart, B. (2004) The effective
provision of pre-school education (EPPE) project: final report, London: DfES and Institute of Education,
University of London.
Utting, D. (2009) Parenting services: assessing and meeting the need for parenting support services,
London. Family and Parenting Institute, literature review.
Youth Justice Board (2005) Sharing personal and sensitive information on children and young people at
risk of offending. A practical guide, London: Youth Justice Board.
225
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than
one team (Unit CP 7)
Most people have some experience of teams, through team working and provide some solutions to the
watching them or being in them. At its simplest, a most common challenges.
team is a group of people who come together to do
something. However, when working with children
and families, working as an effective team may be Learning outcomes
anything but simple.
1. Understand the value of team
Most parents do not need a team of people to bath working.
their child. However, if the child has complex health 2. Understand the rationale for working
needs and is too big to be carried upstairs, bathing as part of more than one team when
can be a problem. It can involve: occupational working with children and/or young
therapists, physiotherapists, paediatricians, people.
nurses, doctors, health visitors, social workers, 3. Understand the reasons for
educationalists, family support workers, outreach multi-agency working amongst
workers, architects, structural engineers, planning organisations that are involved with
departments, builders, joiners, plumbers, electricians, children and/or young people.
decorators and even the Citizens Advice Bureau. 4. Understand the benefits of cross-
functional working to an organisation
Now imagine if everyone gave different, possibly when working with children and/or
conflicting, information, advice and guidance on young people.
how best to support that child. There could be chaos 5. Know how teams and organisations
and confusion, which could well put the child at risk contribute to integrated working.
of harm.
226
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
227
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The growth and some teams can spend far too long in this stage
without ever really resolving individual differences.
development of teams This will have a negative impact on the long-term
team functioning. It can be an ongoing challenge
A forming–storming–norming–performing model expressed in different ways, from disruptive
proposed by Bruce Tuckman (1972) identifies stages behaviour to long-term sickness due to stress.
that teams go through. Teams may go backwards
and forwards through these stages. Their ability to Norming
move from one stage to the next both determines
At this stage, the team achieves a clear vision and
and is determined by their ability to realise benefits
plan that uses the combined skill and expertise of all
and overcome challenges.
members. Some necessary compromise is achieved
as individuals acknowledge the need to give up some
Forming of their own ideas in order to allow the effective
When any group of people first comes together to form functioning of the team. Each member feels valued
a team, each person is likely to focus on the need to be as an individual and contributes their skills and
accepted by the others and avoid conflict. They will, at knowledge to the collective functioning of the team.
the same time, be building a picture about each other. Everyone takes responsibility for the team’s goals.
They will be assessing each other’s skills and attitudes Leaders can ask team members to participate more in
and noting any weaknesses. Serious issues and feelings decision-making because they have worked through
are likely to be avoided in the early days. People focus their differences. Agreed policies and procedures
instead on routines, such as setting meetings and can provide a safe and effective framework through
producing timetables. Team members tend to behave which issues can be resolved.
quite independently of one another. This can be useful
for a manager to see how each member works and Performing
responds to pressure on an individual basis. At the performing stage, teams are able to function as
a unit. Team members have become interdependent,
Storming motivated and knowledgeable. They are now
As teams agree their vision and begin to function competent and able to handle the decision-making
collectively they may ‘storm’. The storming stage is process successfully. Disagreement is expected and
necessary for people to participate fully and feel able allowed because it is seen as appropriate to challenge
to express their opinions. It can be a challenging respectfully in order to promote more effective
stage if it gets out of hand. It is important that working. Team members have sufficient mutual
members expect some storming. Leaders need to trust and tolerance to manage conflict positively and
reassure people that they will be listened to and can resolve issues as a team without individuals taking
discuss their individual needs in supervision. If they things personally.
can put the collective needs of the team first, they
will be able to focus on achieving results. As previously identified, other stages may be
revisited as the team adapts to changes and
Members are likely to respond in different ways to challenges that may come from internal or external
these challenges. Often individuals begin to adopt factors, such as staffing or funding.
particular roles related to their personality types
as well as professional functions. There will be
the peace makers and challengers, ‘bigger picture’ Reflective practice
people and others who focus more on details.
How were you inducted as a new member of
a team? How might induction help to minimise
Team members may need strong leadership in
potential storming?
order to resolve their differences. Unfortunately
228
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
The different roles of Belbin’s research identified that people can take
on different roles at different times and play more
team members than one role at any one time. Not all teams will
have all the roles ‘covered’ but good leaders can
The roles people adopt within teams can be encourage members to fill in the missing functions.
experienced as a benefit or challenge by others. This Understanding the theory of team roles can identify
may be influenced by the personalities involved, where the challenges to teams’ effectiveness are
the maturity and understanding of other team because critical functions performed by ‘roles’ are
members and an individual’s effectiveness. Some missing.
roles are clearly nominated, such as administrative
assistant; others are subtle and characterised
by particular behaviours. Dr R. Meredith Belbin
(2010) discovered that often the difference Reflective practice
between success and failure for a team was not just
Explore your own role in the teams you are part of.
dependent on factors such as intellect, but more
Do you play different roles in different teams?
on behaviour. His research identified how distinct
team roles can impact on the team’s performance.
Table 7.1 highlights the benefits and challenges of
different roles.
229
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The benefits and wider range of tasks show more adaptability than
an individual practitioner undertaking a specific,
challenges of working separate, set of tasks is able to do.
230
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
team members and by leaders, who can come to a Some practitioners’ attitudes may present challenges
greater understanding of one another’s roles. if they see themselves working in teams, as opposed
to working as teams. Employees might simply work
For individual team members, the ability and alongside others, sharing a common work experience
opportunity to seek support from trusted but not truly engaging in the give-and-take of
colleagues with different perspectives can enhance working as teams. It is working as a team that brings
their understanding of an issue. Equally, the the full range of motivational benefits.
opportunity to be approached by another team
member to consider issues outside their current The structure and make-up of the team itself can
experience can be stimulating. The experience may be a challenge. Belbin found that teams with no
even encourage new ideas and ways of thinking ‘plant’ struggled to come up with the initial spark
about their own work and so enhance their own of an idea. With no ‘shaper’, the team was likely to
practice. cruise along without drive and direction, missing
key opportunities and failing to meet deadlines.
In summary, when a group of people come Too many ‘plants’ in the team could mean bad ideas
together as a strong, cohesive team, they have at concealed good ones. Too many ‘shapers’ could lead
their disposal a richness of skill, talent, expertise, to in-fighting and lower morale.
energy, enthusiasm, passion, creativity, imagination,
commitment, knowledge and understanding that can Challenges themselves may impact negatively on
become mutually enhancing so that the team grows team members. Stress can make people feel any
from strength to strength. combination of anxious, frustrated, unmotivated,
undervalued, disempowered, underpaid, overworked,
The challenges isolated or ignored. Individuals may even experience
Challenges are to be expected alongside benefits. bullying and victimisation if they do not fit in, or they
Some are external to the team, such as managing underperform or appear different in some way.
funding, coping with changes in legislation and
The ways in which leaders, managers and team
guidance, adapting to changes in local policy and
members themselves can support teams in
practice or responding to changes in the make-up of
overcoming problems will be discussed throughout
the local population.
the rest of the chapter.
A mixed team of professionals is likely to
experience more challenges more frequently. Section 2: The rationale
Internally, team members are likely to have
differences on personal, political, philosophical for working as part of
and practical levels. These differences do not have
to become challenges. This often depends on the
more than one team when
effectiveness of structures in place to support a
team to communicate effectively, manage change
working with children
and resolve their differences. and/or young people
Case Study
Support for a mother and her newborn child
Corinne recently gave birth to Ben. She had no child, James, and she is worried about coping
problems during the pregnancy but admits to with the new baby on her own.
being a bit of a worrier. The support from her
Corinne’s main concern is breastfeeding
Mum was invaluable after the birth of her first
Ben. The midwife gives her support with
231
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Case Study
Support for a mother and her newborn child (cont.)
breastfeeding and a copy of Ben’s health record Start, who visit families in their own home to offer
to share with practitioners supporting him. She practical support and friendship.
visits Corinne and her family two days after her
discharge from the hospital to see how they are Corinne agrees that the Home Start worker can
coping. They appear to be doing well and the be given information about the family in order
midwife updates the health visitor, who is based to request the service. She decides to attend the
at the children’s centre, with details of her visit. mother and baby café while James is happily
settled at the nursery. It provides space for
Building on the midwife’s information, the health mothers to relax, feed their babies and socialise
visitor makes a new-birth visit. Corinne is worried with other mothers. Staff know that Corinne may
that Ben is not gaining weight. She is also feeling attend and make her feel welcome.
tired as he is waking during the night and she
has difficulty getting him back to sleep. All this Corinne finds out more about one of the parent
is making James, her older son, irritable and his and toddler groups in the children’s centre.
behaviour is becoming quite challenging. The group is run by the local parenting support
team. It is facilitated by a play worker and family
The health visitor reassures Corinne that Ben’s support worker. It aims to promote positive
weight is fine and explores possible activities to parenting through building on the existing
engage James when Ben is feeding. She suggests expertise of parents themselves and increasing
the children’s centre outreach worker could call their confidence and skills.
with toys from the toy library and she reminds
Corinne about local activities, such as the weekly Corinne feels well supported by the local
postnatal drop-in, the mother and baby café team of professionals, who work together
and baby massage classes. They discuss Home seamlessly.
3 Progress check
Working with different
teams within an
Consider how people in the case study make an
effort to work as a team. organisation
How might the outcome differ if professionals did Sometimes it is difficult to distinguish between
not speak to each other? different teams within an organisation. People
How would you describe the benefits of team may say, ‘We are all one big team.’ Although this
working to a parent to gain consent to share may support a sense of belonging and can be
information with relevant professionals? useful when bringing different teams together, it
can also be confusing. The boundaries between
one team and another within a large organisation
are usually determined by their different
Reflective practice
accountabilities. We will use terms from the
Give examples of the ways in which your setting following ‘Key terms’ box to distinguish between
ensures important information is shared with different levels of team structures, functions and
relevant staff to support effective working. accountabilities.
232
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
233
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The social care sector Each of these teams regularly links to other social
work teams that are also internal to the organisation.
The family placement service A transition team enables adolescents with
One family placement service is structured around disabilities to transition from children’s to adult
three separate teams, all focused on different support services. An adoption team facilitates long-
but linked activities. The purpose of the team is term or permanent placements for children with
improving outcomes for children with disabilities adoptive parents. The child health and disability
who are looked after by foster carers. team has two ‘arms’, one assesses and one manages
ongoing care for all children with disabilities,
These teams are managed by one manager who including those fostered.
brings them together as a whole service but
also supports the needs of individual teams in Mainstream fostering teams and fieldwork teams
undertaking their specific tasks. who work with families on different issues may also
need specialist support from the placement service to
The teams need to work together to ensure long- take account of the needs of disabled children they
term foster carers are supported through access come across in their general work.
to short breaks and the sitting service. Although
there are similarities in the functions that they At times, any of these teams may also work with
undertake, the skills required to foster long- local safeguarding teams who may be reviewing
term or provide short breaks or a sitting service child protection plans or looked-after children
are not exactly the same. In order to overcome plans or possibly investigating allegations against
the different challenges involved in recruiting, professionals. It may be an allegation that a
assessing and matching the right people to the professional has harmed or neglected a child.
right children, a depth of experience of working in What unites different teams within a particular
each particular area is required. Each team builds service, such as early years or social care, is a shared
the necessary understanding to recruit staff to professional identity and culture. This involves
support the carers and the children as effectively shared policies, procedures, tools and processes for
as possible. training, development, quality assurance, assessment
and evaluation.
One team’s activity supports long-term foster carers.
The team recruits suitable candidates, assesses their
level of skill, knowledge and experience to undertake 3 Progress check
the role and offers long-term support to those
successful candidates who become carers. Consider a typical setting. How many different
teams may be involved in delivering services?
Another team focuses on recruitment, assessment For example, cooking, cleaning, training and
and matching of candidates who can support those development, administration, finance and human
children and young people who are fostered and resources.
require short breaks. The short break may be a trip to
the cinema or a weekend away.
234
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
235
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
AM School/Breakfast club School/Breakfast club School/Breakfast club School/Breakfast club School/Breakfast club
Greenhill Voluntary Greenhill College tutors Consultation meeting with Allocation of parenting Baby clinic
Group is running for English as a second parents on future groups, support meeting –
the parents’ cooking language and computer e.g. a breast-feeding clinic, professionals in the Baby Massage course
group. literacy courses. fathers’ group. locality. – TBC
Can you all have your We are using both This is a big consultation New allocation The health visitor will
lunch in the staff activity rooms for this so all help gratefully meeting for the family be here at 8am to start
Any comments!
room today please so Dan (caretaker) will received to put out chairs outreach workers is her clinic but don’t
and leave the kitchen set up but remember and then tidy away. now going to weekly worry as baby massage
free. to put away before so hopefully short doesn’t start until
CAB this PM. meeting. We have 11am today.
been asked if Sue can
take minutes?
Lunch Credit Union drop in. Credit Union drop in. Coffee morning for
mums.
PM Grandparents’ group Citizens Advice Bureau Grandparents’ group – Counselling for Grandparents’ group –
– toy library. and advice to parents. toy library. parents. toy library.
After-school club. After-school club. After-school club. After-school club. After-school club.
sick their manager will try to provide alternative serious issues of where crèche or transport costs will
staff. be paid. Agencies may also have to compete with
one another for funding.
Practically, the timing of groups has to be convenient
for the parents but it must also allow appropriate Boundary issues can be related to geography as
staff from different agencies to be available. For some agencies serve wider areas and may want to
example, staff may be asked to be available in the include more parents than others. Philosophical
evenings for working parents. boundaries can be disagreement on whether
medical tests should take place inside or outside the
Health and safety can mean running a parents’ setting. Professional boundaries may mean some
group with small children around prevents people workers feel they should not undertake certain
carrying hot tea and coffee. Similarly, tea and coffee tasks.
breaks for staff may be negotiated very differently in
different organisations. Language of ‘targeting’ resources to ‘vulnerable’
families may have to be negotiated. Language
Rules and regulations of one organisation may seem can be a source of great misunderstanding, with
silly to another. Putting resources away in specific acronyms, words and phrases perceived as being
places may seem petty to some, but getting it wrong used to deliberately confuse and confound.
can cause great inconvenience and resentment to
those providing them, who may use them later. Strategically, if senior managers focus on individual
agency agendas and targets it can prevent people
Funding for activities may be a source of conflict and from being sufficiently flexible. Leadership of
frustration, from who provides the biscuits to more activities may be unclear, leaving individual workers
236
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
uncertain about who is responsible for a session Professionals and parents often evaluate such
or who they are responsible to for their work with coordination positively.
parents on a particular activity.
Knowledge of the challenges facing families in the
Supervision of staff may be very different within local community, the make-up of agencies and the
different professional cultures, resulting in activities they offer are more comprehensive when
managers and practitioners having different teams work together. This improved knowledge can
ideas of what they can expect. This may cause then impact positively on all the benefits outlined
some people to be left feeling micromanaged or below.
abandoned.
Pooled budgets and the ability to enhance budgets
Recording activity is another area where practice of through bidding for funds across different ages and
each organisation may not be the same, leading to areas of work can allow teams to benefit collectively
too much or too little information being available. through achieving joint targets. Joint targets that
demonstrate improved outcomes are often fairer
Performance measures are often allocated to and more sustainable than individual targets that
individual agencies, rather than being specifically everyone claims they alone have ‘achieved’. In a
designed to measure the success of joint activities in complex world, it is very difficult to isolate the reason
an effective way. for, for example, improved road safety. It could be the
parental literacy classes, the neighbourhood policing
Qualifications, training and status are linked to
or the direct work with children in the nurseries,
employment terms and conditions and can be
primary schools or secondary schools. It is likely to
barriers to joint activities. Some people may feel
be because of all of it.
underpaid and others may feel under-used if they
are engaging in what they perceive to be similar Parents often respond better in a more informal
activities. However, others may feel overpaid or setting and want access to a variety of services in one
exploited. place to save time.
237
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Case Study
Children living with domestic violence
A local social services team received a request own records were interrogated before finally
for service from a primary school about Paul, contacting the Police Domestic Violence Unit to
aged five years, and Sally, aged three years, the see what information they held on the family.
children of Pat and Brian. A social worker rang The police had visited several times because of
the school to clarify referral information and domestic violence.
determine the level of risk to the children. Paul’s
teacher explained that she had contacted Pat The social worker visited the family home and
before because of Paul’s behaviour but Pat had spoke to Paul and Sally on their own. The
shrugged off concerns. When Paul then told his children were confused and scared and wanted
best friend that his dad gets drunk and hits his the violence to stop. Pat appeared anxious and
mum, the friend passed this information on to depressed. Brian was distressed but willing
the teacher, who spoke to Paul. He was reluctant to address his anger and alcohol intake. The
to talk but then said that he and his sister had social worker and her team manager therefore
seen his dad hit his mum. The teacher phoned decided that a core assessment was not
Pat to say that she would have to ring social care required as the parents were cooperating. A
in line with school policy. She then made the common assessment (CAF) was suggested
request to social services. for Paul. Mum agreed to an assessment but
wanted it to be with the children’s centre family
When Sally’s nursery was contacted, they had outreach worker and to focus on Sally. This was
recently told Pat that Sally was withdrawing from agreed by everyone and a plan was produced
activities and they were worried about her, but following the common assessment.
Pat seemed to be unconcerned. Social services’
What changes do people want to What action is required for this to Who will lead this? Attended?
see? happen?
Better understanding of the harmful Pat to access counselling and understand Anne Doe, Greenhill Health Yes
effects of violence and how it can be the options available to her if the violence Centre
limited. continues.
Reasons for violence to be addressed Brian to have accessed an anger Brian (Father) Yes
to try to prevent further occurrences. management course and progress to be
discussed at the next meeting.
Pat and Brian to understand the Louise to explain to parents the impact of Louise Goodhave, Greenhill Yes
impact of the violence on Sally and violence on children, also to provide Sally Children Centre
Paul. Paul and Sally to have some idea and Paul with age-appropriate support on
of how to keep themselves safe. keeping safe.
Pat to see an improvement in her Anne to provide information about Anne Doe, Greenhill Health Yes
physical and emotional health. services Pat can access. Centre
Paul to be better settled in school Paul’s response to behaviour strategies to Joanne Smith, Greenhill Primary Yes
and accessing support for his be monitored by his teacher. School
behaviour.
Sally to be better settled in the centre Sally’s key worker to identify strategies Joe Bloggs, Greenhill Children’s No
and engaging with staff. for more activity and engagement with Centre
staff and outcomes to be monitored for
improvement.
238
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
239
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
There will be opportunities for each team member if ...there is a willingness among staff to share their individual skills
to acquire new skills, which will lead to greater job and expertise.
satisfaction…
Understanding the competence of all team members if ...there is a safe and caring attitude where staff are willing to
and learning from their perspectives can greatly learn from others and adopt a positive approach to change.
enhance the development of the collective expertise of
the whole setting...
Individual team members can benefit from facilitating if ...they can challenge themselves and others regarding their own
better collaboration… claims to exclusive specialist knowledge and authority.
Cross-fertilisation of skills between willing professionals if ...people feel safe enough to make mistakes, experiment with
within teams can demonstrate the benefits of true different ideas and approaches and challenge one another
multi-skilling of individuals without sacrificing the respectfully.
distinct contribution or professional standards in each
discipline…
Multidisciplinary peer review of casework can allow if ...each professional offers their own perspectives and ways of
each team member to extend their skill base… working, and people can gradually build mutual respect and
both provide and accept support more readily.
Ensuring that all members of the multidisciplinary team if ...the challenges around different terms and conditions of
are used in a way that is maximally effective greatly employment, including pay scales, have been effectively
increases success... addressed and people feel safe and valued appropriately.
Professionals willingly sharing their skills with others to if ...there is an effective team spirit that focuses more on
benefit clients by enabling their needs to be met more outcomes for clients than internal structures and responsibilities.
creatively because people are working more flexibly…
Parents can easily access a wider variety of specialist if …no one is possessive about families. Everyone is encouraged
skills to meet the needs of their child… to consider the value of other colleagues’ skills, which may be
more appropriate to meeting particular needs.
Families have a wider choice as to who will lead the if …teams are neither too competitive about leading on cases, nor
work being undertaken with them… reluctant to take on the work, but accept joint decision making,
taking into account families’ wishes.
Children and young people can benefit from learning if …practitioners from (for example) adult services are supported
how to interact with different professionals… by colleagues to address new challenges in this case, working
with children rather than adults.
Children and young people benefit from knowing that if …team members understand family dynamics and actively
the wider needs of the family can be met… address the impact family members have on each other.
Even external agencies can benefit from the growing if …new teams adopt an action-research approach to capturing
expertise and innovation that generates new and sharing their learning with others.
learning…
240
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
241
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
addressed. This is often linked to professional the cross-functional working which will now be
cultures with a similar view. explored.
242
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
●● problem-solving across traditional boundaries The family want someone who is knowledgeable,
●● integration of systems and processes is respectful, listens to them, recognises their
●● coordination of ‘one stop shop’ or a single point of strengths, is honest about problems and works
contact. positively to overcome them. They frequently do
not remember what agency or service that person
Multi-agency, cross-functional working tends may be from.
to be of most benefit to families that have
additional needs beyond the routine. This requires
coordination of a number of different services. It Supporting other
is less useful when there are no additional and practitioners
interdependent needs.
A bad experience in the chain of service delivery
Consider the following opportunities for parents to If a negative experience is prejudicial, the opposite
build their knowledge and skills to provide children is also true and a positive experience can make a
with basic care: family more open to support.
243
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
skills as influencing others, handling conflict, Professionals also speak of becoming familiar with
active listening and giving constructive feedback. the requirements of others’ working methods,
It may even allow people to fundamentally re- professional standards, regulatory and statutory
think themselves and their own motivations, work requirements and so on. This allows them to be more
preferences and learning styles. comfortable in sharing responsibilities.
This learning can also improve understanding Many other advantages of these teams are the same
of the interdependencies of different parts of the as those delivered by effective multi-agency teams.
organisation and their related processes. Some In addition, the flexibility of workers to pick up
professionals identify improvement in managing appropriate cross-functions delivers the benefits
change, problem-solving and decision-making more frequently, more quickly and with better
by building on a process of collaborative enquiry understanding. This leads in turn to better outcomes
into issues using the full expertise of all team that are more sustainable in the longer term.
members.
The challenges of
Wider benefits to teams cross-functional working
of cross-functional Once again, it is important to consider the challenges
working that may ensue. Although cross-functional working
exploits similarities in core functions to maximise
Cross-functional teams eliminate the ‘no longer our professionals’ flexibility and deliver better services, not
problem’ mentality that passes a process or family everyone will feel safe doing this. Not all functions are
from department to department. easily undertaken, nor skills easily acquired.
All team members learn of the new process at the The following statements propose that, if certain
same time and begin working together. factors are present, there will be challenges.
Conversely, if the factors are minimised or removed,
If part of the process does not work, team members
the challenges will be as well. So once again,
can immediately sit down with colleagues and
problems and solutions are linked.
come up with a new process. They can then
meet, for example, with the assessment and care There will be challenges if:
management team members and discuss new ways
●● members have competing loyalties to their home
to embed the process. The result, say proponents, is
agency that conflict with their new role
an improved process in less time.
●● teams are used on a part-time basis, putting
People are more likely to want to speak up and point members under greater pressure
out problems when they feel more responsibility ●● early development of stable and effective
for issues and more ownership of solutions. Before communication is not prioritised
cross-functional teams, people could be passive ●● teams are held to higher performance standards
and quiet, reasoning that the problem was not their than conventional teams
responsibility. ●● team members are not open-minded or motivated
as they are forced to be involved
People in such teams can recognise that there is ●● members are not from the right service areas but
strength in diversity; not everyone has to agree the willing and available service areas
on an issue. They know they are more likely to be ●● leaders of the team do not command the respect or
understood, but that some people may still choose authority needed
to disagree with them, and that such differences are ●● teams do not have the resource, authority or
acceptable. accountability to accomplish their task
244
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
245
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
246
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
A ‘non expert’ could sometimes trigger a Finally, family members were positive about
revelation in an expert because something being able to discuss issues with one person
they said added to the understanding of a who could bring a wider knowledge and
situation. Each team member from a different understanding into one holistic view and provide
professional culture would perceive a different comprehensive support.
247
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
expectations. This can begin with value of creativity and new ideas. Reward people
communicating overall outcomes to show the who take reasonable risks to make improvements
links to clear performance measures for teams, and provide the training, education and
which are then translated into targets for professional development necessary to stimulate
individuals. new thinking.
●● If individuals cannot see the bigger picture, ●● If coordination is poor, ensure central leadership
communicate the overall role and function of the teams assist the teams to obtain what they need
organisation to which the team belongs. Provide for success and resource appropriately.
a team planning template that shows the whole ●● If teams are challenging the necessary cultural
organisation’s aims and how the team’s objectives change, support staff to recognise that the
fit within the overall vision. team-based, collaborative, empowering, enabling
●● If there is a lack of commitment, ensure the culture is different to the traditional, hierarchical
value of the team is emphasised, successes are organisation they may be used to. Demonstrate
celebrated and individuals’ contributions are how the process of change can reward, develop
recognised. Encourage opportunities and motivate people more effectively to improve
for skills to grow and develop and build in outcomes.
excitement, promotion and challenge wherever ●● If there is too much blame, plan to use failures for
248
Chapter 7 Working as part of more than one team (Unit CP 7)
Useful resources
249
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Twelve tips for team building: how to build practice: a review of the literature, Reading: CFBT
successful work teams Education Trust.
http://humanresources.about.com/od/ Belbin, R.M. (2010) Management teams: why they
involvementteams/a/twelve_tip_team.htm succeed or fail, 3rd edition, Oxford: Butterworth
Business management Heinemann.
www.jrank.org/business/pages/1635/teamworking. Friedman, M. (2005) Trying hard is not good
html enough: how to produce measurable improvement
for customers and communities, Bloomington, IN:
Books Trafford Publishing.
Atkinson, M., Jones, M. and Lamont, E. (2007) Tuckman, B.W. (1972) Conducting educational
Multi-agency working and its implications for research, New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
(5th edition, 1999, Wadsworth).
250
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to
behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
‘We see the development of pupils’ social, by people on different sides of the debate. This
emotional and behavioural skills as integral to chapter does not take the view that one model is
good learning and teaching. It is also integral right and others are wrong but accepts that there
to making classrooms orderly places for are many grey areas, especially in how models are
learning. This means teaching all pupils from implemented, and it is important for learners to come
the beginning of education to manage strong to their own conclusions based on the evidence from
feelings, resolve conflict effectively and fairly, their own research.
solve problems, work and play cooperatively,
and be respectful, calm, optimistic and
resilient.’ Learning outcomes
Sir Alan Steer (2005) 1. Understand models of behaviour
management.
Although the quotation above refers to schools,
2. Understand the detail of a behaviour
its meaning can be applied to early years and
management model.
other settings and emphasises the importance of
behaviour management. Behaviour is an action that
3. Understand positive support strategies
within a behaviour management
you can see and describe. Behaviour management
model.
is a term that is used in different ways but usually
means how acceptable behaviour is promoted 4. Understand why a safe environment
and reinforced and unacceptable behaviour is for children and/or young people
supports positive behaviour.
discouraged. Different terms are used to describe
behaviour – for example, acceptable, unacceptable,
positive or negative, unwanted, good, constructive,
poor, normal and misbehaviour. All of these and
more are used in research and in everyday practice Activity
and you will find a range of terms used in this
Listen to how children’s and young people’s
chapter.
behaviour is described:
Concerns about behaviour have led to the • in your setting
development of different models of behaviour • among your friends and family
management, some of which are explored later in
• in the media.
the chapter. Settings and practitioners, as well as
researchers, often feel strongly about which Question people and make notes on how behaviour
is described. Work out whether there are similarities
model to use and this can be seen in the media,
and differences among the groups included. What
where arguments about who is right are played out. does this tell you about how children and young
Understanding of behaviour management models people are viewed in our society?
need to take into account the strong feelings held
251
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Key term
Positive behaviour – positive behaviour is that which is
seen as socially, culturally and developmentally acceptable
and approved by most of the people in the society.
Challenging behaviour – challenging behaviour
includes unacceptable negative behaviour that is
extreme, frequent and intense and can threaten the
quality of life or physical safety of the child or young
person and others. The competence and capacity of
settings can influence when a child or young person’s
behaviour is defined as challenging. For example, if
practitioners are under stress themselves through low
staffing levels or lack of training, they are more likely to
label behaviour as challenging.
individuals will vary to some extent but there are others or damaging property
certain basics which most people agree with. ●● behaviour which is destructive to the child or
young person
Acceptable (positive) behaviour includes: ●● illegal or antisocial behaviour
252
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
Challenging behaviour can include any of the about. Antisocial behaviour is a problem for some
above. Unacceptable behaviour is context specific. communities and this has been highlighted again by
For example, in schools, it is unacceptable to run in the riots in some of England’s towns and cities. In
corridors, chew or shout. schools and other settings, some children and young
people are too talkative, avoid work and disrupt
Causes of unacceptable the learning of others. This low-level disruption
can be very difficult for practitioners to manage.
behaviour Incidents of extremely challenging behaviour are
less common.
There are many biological, psychological and
environmental factors that contribute to unacceptable Other research has highlighted the effect of
behaviour. unacceptable behaviour on a child or young person’s
●● Biological factors, such as genetics, temperament, life chances. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation
developmental delays or disorder, chronic illness (2010) cites behavioural problems as one factor in
and learning disability. explaining the gap in attainment between children
●● Psychological factors, such as low self-esteem,
from rich and poorer families. Where children
mental illness and poor coping skills. and young people exhibit negative or challenging
●● Environmental factors, such as poor role models,
behaviour, they will not be able to take best
dysfunctional families, poor diet, exposure to advantage of their learning experiences at school or
violence and aggression through media, peer elsewhere.
pressure, gang culture, bullying and abuse.
253
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
254
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
255
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
256
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
given – for example, ‘Well done, George, for sitting Practitioners using the AD model need to learn to:
quietly and waiting your turn.’ The practitioner ●● use assertive responses
should always use positive support to encourage ●● avoid negative statements (e.g. ’how many times
children and young people to continue appropriate have I told you…?’)
behaviour. Consequences must be followed through ●● set and apply rules consistently
each time a child or young person chooses to break ●● consistently follow through on the rules and
the rules. The consequences must be administered in consequences
a firm, calm manner. Shortly after the consequence ●● offer consequences as a choice
is given, practitioners should try to find something ●● use a broken record technique (i.e. repeating the
positive the child or young person is doing to get rule or consequence in response to an incident)
them back on track. ●● make positive assertions (e.g. ‘it is good when we
all work quietly’).
Practitioners using this system are encouraged not
to show emotion but to remain calm and to apply Although AD can be seen as a rather uninvolved
consequences to undesirable behaviour by being model, supporters claim that practitioners do build
assertive, not hostile or angry. They should remain positive, trusting relationships with their children
calm and quiet and deal with the situation without and young people and teach appropriate behaviour
giving the child or young person any particular through direct instruction, modelling behaviour
attention. Maintaining eye contact and speaking and other means. Although they demand positive
in a firm tone of voice is important, both for praise behaviour and do not allow excuses for bad behaviour,
and reward but also when reminding the child of they are respectful to the child or young person.
the rules. Repeating positive statements is a way of
repeating your rules so that all children or young How the AD system is applied is important. In
people know what to do – for example, ‘Very good. some settings, AD is applied more strictly than in
Rowan put his hand up to ask a question, and so others. Some practitioners allow for discussion with
did Tom and Ruby.’ Using ‘proximity control’ is also children and young people to help them find a way
an effective way of reinforcing the rules – that is, out outside the predictable consequences. This is
moving to be closer to the child or young person important for children and young people who are
who is choosing to break the rules. For younger upset. They treat the ‘consequences’ as a guide not
children, moving nearby and praising those children a law. One-to-one meetings with a child or young
who are keeping to the rules can be effective. With person are used so that the practitioner can show
adolescents, it may be better to talk to them outside empathy and try to find the root of the problem and
the room to remind them of the rules to avoid agree a way forward.
embarrassment.
Case Study
Being assertive is a key part of AD. Assertive
practitioners react confidently, consistently and In a setting, raffle tickets are given to children
quickly in situations that require behaviour or young people for acceptable behaviour. The
management. They do not see the child or young child or young person writes their name on a
person as the enemy, nor do they use sarcasm or piece of paper and puts it into a box for a daily
hostility. Assertive practitioners need to avoid non- prize. All children can participate if they have
assertive behaviour to make the system work (i.e. been able to show acceptable behaviour.
they should not react in a passive, inconsistent or
Do you feel this is a positive way of encouraging
timid manner). Assertive practitioners do not plead
acceptable behaviour? Discuss with others
with children and young people to behave. Getting
to get their viewpoints and develop a list of
into a debate with angry and arguing children or
strategies to encourage acceptable behaviour
young people is not an appropriate response in most
you could use in your setting.
situations.
257
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
258
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
Supportive behaviour management (SBM) aims to on SEAL in today’s schools and this remains
help organisations change or modify their overall a cornerstone of work in the early years. SEAL
culture from being punitive to being supportive. recognises that to develop and learn successfully,
SBM does not rely on behaviour modification but children and young people need to feel happy and
takes as a basis that children and young people need secure in their environment. Critics of SEAL (e.g.
to become emotionally intelligent in order to make Craig 2007) say it is a pessimistic, over-controlling
the most of their lives and learning opportunities. approach that could alienate children and young
Mike Temple (2008) is the founder of SBM in the people. They claim that there is too much emphasis
UK. He is a behaviour consultant and says that on children being told what they should think or feel
schools often treat badly behaved children and young and this could bring about problems of dependency
people like criminals or like people whose emotions on adults to tell them how to feel and relate to others.
occasionally get in the way. He suggests that
punishments meted out to children and young people Key term
perpetuate misbehaviour. Mike Temple suggests that
compliance-based behaviour management, such as Coaching – coaching is the support given to help
AD, fails to work for at least 5 to 10 per cent of young children and young people identify the skills and
capabilities that are within them and enable them to use
people and this number is growing. them to the best of their ability. It encourages positive
actions and the ability to learn from experience and build
The focus of SBM is on supporting children and on success. It is not the same as counselling or therapy.
young people to become emotionally intelligent Coaching is performed with individuals and groups, in
through coaching and other activities and by person and sometimes over the phone or online.
259
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
or young person and the practitioner, it assumes issues may try to hide their feelings through low-level
that there needs to be a means of providing distance disruption to divert attention away from themselves.
between them. This requires ‘time-out’ rooms in Low-level disruption will vary by age but includes
settings staffed by, for example, teaching assistants behaviour such as being late, not having their bags or
or other suitable practitioners. Time-out spaces are equipment, disrupting others, shouting or swearing.
helpful to put distance between the teacher and the SBM practitioners would offer a child or young
child or young person. A child or young person might person the chance to have a discussion about their
be asked by time-out staff to describe what happened. feelings, rather than increasing the level of sanctions.
Practitioners might respond to the child or young
person by saying, ‘I understand how you feel and Key term
why you reacted as you did. How will you react next
time?’ This type of approach is based on coaching Circle time – a time in the day when about 6–18
and is thought to enable the child or young person to children or young people sit in a circle, usually with a
trained practitioner as facilitator. Circle time may have
reflect on their reactions and learn from the incident. different formats and rules but its goal is to create a
Teachers or practitioners are also offered coaching by safe, inclusive and nurturing space where children and
the time-out staff as to how to receive the child back young people can explore and share their feelings and
find solutions to problems. It provides them with the
into the classroom to avoid a repeat of the incident.
language and vocabulary to describe feelings. Circle
time is designed to encourage children and young
Some children or young people take several hours people’s:
to become calm enough to return but gradually
• emotional intelligence
learn that there is a quiet place for them to go if
• supportive listening
things become difficult. After the policy has been • empathy with others.
in place a while, some children or young people ask
to go to the time-out room or a teacher suggests it
before things become fraught. Each incident is given Criticisms of SBM
individual attention and practitioners listen to and As with criticisms of AD, it is important to remember
support the child or young person. that these are expressed by people who do not agree
It is claimed that SBM is particularly effective with with the basis of SBM or the way it is used in schools
children or young people with challenging behaviour. It and other settings. Many people will not share these
has been estimated that around 10 per cent of children views and concerns.
and young people experience some sort of mental ●● It can be expensive to set up and operate.
disorder, which can include challenging behaviour ●● It can be time consuming.
(source: www.mentalhealth.org.uk/information/ ●● To ensure children or young people do not fall
mental-health-overview/statistics). For example: back in their learning due to time-out needs, this
●● depression approach requires high levels of cooperation –
●● anxiety for example, teachers need to provide time-out
●● post-traumatic stress disorder
practitioners with learning materials.
●● It needs well-trained and dedicated practitioners
●● self-harm
●● eating disorder
to operate.
●● It may need external expertise from behavioural
●● being a victim of abuse
●● diagnosed disorder, such as ADHD
specialists.
●● It can be seen as rewarding bad behaviour (e.g.
●● Asperger syndrome
●● autistic spectrum disorder.
giving time and focused attention).
●● It can be seen as unfair to children and young
High-quality, personalised support is required to people who do behave well and exhibit a good
help children and young people with these additional attitude.
needs. Children and young people with emotional ●● It can be seen as individualistic.
260
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
●● It can be seen as offering ‘therapy’, which is social or emotional needs. These needs may be
inappropriate for settings that are not set up for this. linked to children and young people’s challenging
●● It requires a whole-school/organisation approach. life circumstances. Nurture groups aim to provide
●● The focus is on both academic subject teaching a consistent and predictable environment in which
and teaching good behaviour (behaviour children and young people can build trusting
coaching), which might not be compatible. relationships with adults and gain the skills they
●● It could jeopardise ‘standards’ in its support for need to learn in larger classes or groups. The Ofsted
inclusion. (2011) report ‘Supporting children with challenging
behaviour through a nurture group approach’
Examples of other behaviour explains the benefits and challenges of this model.
management models Positive behavioural support
The Kounin model (1970/1977) (PBS)
This model suggests that behaviour management This is an evidence-based approach grounded in
can have a ‘ripple effect’, meaning that correcting behaviourism. Its aim is to work with children and
one child’s or young person’s behaviour changes the young people, often with learning disabilities, who
behaviour of others. The practitioner also needs to have challenging behaviours and replace them with
effectively manage groups and avoid boredom by prosocial skills. It claims to decrease the need for
introducing variety. punishment-based approaches, such as exclusion or
physical interventions. PBS targets an individual child
The Glasser model (1965, 1998) or young person or a whole organisation. In operation,
This model sees children and young people as ‘rational it does not focus exclusively on an individual, but
beings’ that are capable of making their own choices also looks at the environment, changing it to be more
and controlling their own behaviour. They learn suitable for the child or young person.
responsible behaviour by examining the consequences
As a starting point, PBS assumes that all behaviour
for their behaviour. Behaviour is seen as an effort to
has a function for the child or young person – for
satisfy personal needs and increase self-esteem.
example, is being disruptive, the only way a child or
young person can gain attention? When a child or
The Dreikurs model (1998,
young person finds communication difficult, they may
2nd edition) use challenging behaviour to express themselves. They
This model suggests that misbehaviour is a result may have needs, such as boredom, hunger, tiredness
of a child’s or young person’s mistaken belief that or agitation, and these needs may be reflected in
it will gain them recognition from their peer group their behaviour as they cannot communicate them
and is directed at ‘mistaken goals’, such as attention- any other way. Practitioners need to understand the
seeking, revenge and power-seeking. The model also importance of getting to know the child or young
emphasises encouragement, rather than focusing person well and observing and drawing conclusions
on the end result. Dreikurs emphasised logical about feelings and behaviour. PBS assesses the
consequences – for example, if work has not been done function of the behaviour for the individual child or
in school, it would have to be completed after school. young person to find out why it occurs. It then helps
practitioners, families and children and young people
Nurture groups to develop strategies that do not reward negative or
The nurture group approach has some links to the unwanted behaviour but encourage the positive.
supportive behaviour management model described
in detail later in the chapter. Nurture groups are The restorative justice model
small, structured teaching groups for children and Restorative justice brings into contact those who have
young people who have or may have behavioural, caused harm and those who have been harmed. It is
261
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Research Activ
ity Benefits for real work
Research how practitioners deal with behaviour
environments
issues in early years settings. Do they use There are benefits for real work environments
punishment and rewards as tools for managing
when children and young people are ready to
children’s behaviour? When behaviour problems
arise, how do they deal with these? What outcomes cooperate and learn. In order for this to happen,
do they look for in the children and in the setting? behaviour management policies are needed and,
when consistently implemented by well-trained
practitioners, they will all work to some extent.
However, there is a cost in time and resources to
ity
Research Activ implement many of these models. Many people
argue that this is time and money well spent, both
Research behaviour management policies from
different settings. Find out if they are based upon a for the child or young person concerned but also for
particular behaviour management model, or if they the rest of the group or class. The group are freer to
use elements from many different models. Explain learn and develop without frequent disruption. The
your findings. children and young people with behavioural issues
thrive in an environment that meets their needs.
262
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
263
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● time out means that there is a recognised ●● decreases the need for punishment
method of removing an angry or troubled ●● changes the environment to support the child
child or young person in order to avoid a major ●● looks at the roots of disruptive behaviour and aims
confrontation to find solutions
●● after time out, there is support for practitioners ●● allows practitioners to get to know the child or
and for children and young people to re-enter the young person, which leads to more rewarding
classroom or area in a safe and controlled way work.
●● practitioners know they have support in dealing
with unacceptable behaviour as there are Restorative approaches
dedicated support staff and separate rooms or Restorative approaches:
spaces to support the child or young person
●● escalating support is more positive for the whole
●● are seen to be fair to both sides
organisation than escalating consequences/ ●● support the development of emotional intelligence
sanctions and the ability to see others’ points of view
●● a blame culture is minimised as there is an
and therefore enjoy many of the advantages of
acceptance that conflicts will arise from time to supportive behaviour management.
time
●● individual needs and circumstances are How are human rights
recognised and individualised support is offered
●● conflict is seen as an accepted part of life and
fully respected in
mistakes are an opportunity to learn behaviour management
systems?
●● children, young people and involved adults learn
the benefits and techniques that support solutions
and conflict resolution
Children and young people have human rights,
●● it fits well with the social and emotional learning
just like anyone else. The rights of children and
approach in schools
young people have been identified in the UN
●● it increases support, not consequences or
Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989
sanctions, as the behaviour becomes more
(UNCRC). The UK also has its own general
challenging.
framework for rights within the Human Rights
Act (1998). It is important to ensure that models
Nurture groups of behaviour management do not affect the
Nurture groups are closely linked to SBM and are human rights of children and young people. Any
a way of supporting vulnerable children outside proposals regarding behaviour and discipline
the mainstream environment. Sometimes nurture must comply with the UK’s legal obligations under
groups are full-time but they can also be for part human rights legislation.
of the day or week. In a real work environment,
Children and young people have rights to:
a nurture group can give a child much-needed
personal space, time and support. ●● be listened to
●● be involved in decision-making
Positive behavioural support ●● be respected for themselves and for their race,
culture, language and religion
This model:
●● be in contact with their families if they are ‘looked
●● is often used with children or young people with after’
learning disabilities and challenging behaviour ●● have concerned, consistent and caring adults
and aims to replace these behaviours with involved in their lives who have their best interests
prosocial behaviour at heart
264
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
●● have personalised care that includes effective and Extreme forms of behaviour modification exist,
appropriate behaviour management, even though such as behaviour modification camps that claim
they may not always like or want this. to sort out young people’s behaviour problems
but are emotionally and physically abusive. The
As well as rights, children and young people also use of extreme forms of behaviour modification
have responsibilities and they should be encouraged is also found in some prisons in different parts of
to respect the rights of others – for example, the right the world. This type of intervention can be seen to
not to be ill-treated but the responsibility not to treat go against the UNCRC, especially Article 37 – the
others badly. right not to be tortured or treated in an inhuman or
degrading way.
Activity
Many would argue that using behaviour
In your setting, look at how the rights of children or modification within assertive discipline in UK
young people are respected. For every right, there schools and organisations is a far less extreme
is a responsibility. How do children or young people version and its effectiveness makes it justified.
learn their responsibilities? They would argue that children and young people
who exhibit unacceptable or challenging
behaviour take away the human rights of others
Behaviourist approaches, who want to learn and engage with the setting.
Behaviourist practitioners argue that children
such as assertive discipline or
deserve structure and limits to help them to get
positive behavioural support, the best out of their education. Children and
and human rights young people need to recognise that, as well
Assertive discipline and positive behavioural support as rights, they have responsibilities to others.
are based on behaviour modification systems. Practitioners believe that they can utilise this
Behaviour modification relies on a system of rewards behaviour management method fairly and with
and sanctions and has been found to be effective compassion. For example:
in changing behaviour and in supporting positive ●● ground rules are discussed with children, young
behaviour. However, some people believe that people and families
behaviour modification is a system of ‘mind control’ ●● there is clarity in what is expected from each child
and takes away individual freedom. They believe and young person
that: ●● there is an emphasis on the positive
●● there is acceptance that some children with
●● behaviour modification is ‘done to’ children or
young people, not with their best interests in mind additional needs may need extra support
●● diversity is recognised and accommodated fairly.
but rather to control unwanted behaviour and
perhaps make life easier for those working with
them Supportive behaviour
●● using behaviour modification techniques management, restorative
requires specific objectives for behaviour to be
approaches and human
defined and this, to some extent, takes away the
rights of the child or young person to do what rights
they wish Practitioners and organisations who use these
●● behaviour modification does not teach ethical or methods say that they fully respect human rights
caring behaviour as they meet individual needs and empower
●● behaviour modification does not encourage children and young people to become emotionally
children and young people to think for intelligent (i.e. able to gain control over their
themselves, which is the basis of rights. emotions and manage their own behaviour). They
265
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
266
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
modification may breach human rights and could These differences make a ‘one size fits all’ model
lead to impaired emotional and social development difficult to work with for this group.
in a child or young person. A more thoughtful
application, such as assertive discipline that is Supportive behaviour management
applied in many settings, is considered to benefit In SBM, children and young people are seen as
children and young people. more active, needing to be ‘unfolded’ rather than
moulded. (Temple 2009). They are seen as being
Different roles in able to actively manage their own behaviour if given
the right support and coaching, including taking
relation to behaviour responsibility for their own feelings and behaviour.
management systems The role of staff in models of
The role of children and young behaviour management
people in models of behaviour The role of the practitioner is detailed in Section 1 of
this chapter.
management
Assertive discipline The role of parents/carers
In AD, children and young people can be seen as in models of behaviour
needing to be moulded into a particular shape to management
fit the needs of the school, organisation or society.
Parents/carers have a role in all models of behaviour
There is less emphasis on the individual and their
management. Many parents/carers go along with
needs and more on the compliant majority. Children
what is required of them by the organisation without
and young people who experience AD may respond
being presented with real alternatives. They may be
well to it but they do need to comply with the
distressed because their child or young person has
rules. Their role tends to be passive as they are less
behavioural issues and want to support the setting.
involved in setting the behaviour framework, which
Some parents may feel alienated and hostile to the
is external to them. Some settings allow discussion
setting and do not support the consequences or
with children and young people about the rules that
proposed solutions that exist for poor behaviour. This
they set but this might be minimal in other settings.
creates difficulties for any behaviour management
AD has been called a ‘compliance’ model, based on
model.
a compliant majority being more important than
the disruptive minority. In AD, children and young Organisations have to work hard to build
people’s behaviour is moulded by an ever more tough partnerships with parents/carers, especially those
series of sanctions (i.e. negative reinforcement). For who are hard to reach. Where partnerships work,
some children and young people, especially those this helps with children and young people’s learning
with behavioural disorders, this model could lead and development and can be an empowering
to increasing frustration. For example, impulsive process for parents and carers. Partnerships are
or hyperactive children and young people will especially important for behaviour issues because
not respond well to negative consequences. These these can be sensitive as parents/carers may feel
children and young people do not think through guilty or hostile. Where organisations can involve
the impact of their behaviour prior to executing parents/carers, the outcomes for children and young
the behaviour. When they then receive negative people are better.
sanctions for behaviour that is largely outside their
self-control, they respond with anger, anxiety and In AD, parents/carers are an integral part of the
frustration. There is a view that the basis for many model. In order for the model to work, parents/carers
challenging behaviours is neurological differences. have to support the consequences (e.g. detentions,
267
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
being excluded). In SBM, there is a less obvious parents in receipt of benefits, mothers reporting
role in the model itself but parent support is seen depression, alcoholism or drug abuse, and parents
as important. Some settings will provide dedicated with previous involvement with child protection
parenting support, including classes and one-to- services. Although they are more likely to drop out,
one counselling. In some cases, family learning all these groups have participated in programmes
opportunities will exist for those people who need that have been found to improve their children’s
literacy and numeracy support. behaviour. Many children from these backgrounds
do well and it is important not to label families or
Regardless of any particular behaviour have lower expectations.
management model, some school settings will
have parent support advisers. These practitioners The role of multi-agency
work in partnership with parents/carers to
improve children’s lives, by involving them in workers in models of behaviour
identifying appropriate support for the child and management
family. This can be a positive way of delivering The role of the multi-agency team in behaviour
early intervention and preventative support to management is very important. The need to refer
families. Parent support advisers can also support difficult and challenging behaviour to specialist
referrals to other services and provide a range of services may become urgent, especially if early
information for parents. In settings where there are intervention is required to prevent things getting
established methods of behaviour management, worse. There are many agencies and professionals
the parent support adviser will take this into involved in behaviour management and this can be
account but will have a range of alternative confusing for parents, families and practitioners.
strategies they can offer. The lead practitioner or key person role is designed
to simplify this for the child, young person and
Parent partnership services (PPS) also exist to
family. A lead professional takes a primary role to
support parents/carers of children or young people
ensure frontline services are coordinated, coherent
with special educational needs (SEN). These are
and achieve intended outcomes. The Children’s
statutory services offering information, advice and
Workforce Development Council’s information
support to parents and carers of children and young
factsheet ‘The lead professional’ states that:
people with SENs. PPS make sure that parent/carer
views are heard and understood and that these views ‘The lead professional is not a new role. Instead,
inform local policy and practice. s/he delivers three core functions as part of their
work:
The ESRC (2003, updated 2006) report ‘Group-
●● acts as a single point of contact for the child or
based parenting programmes can reduce behaviour
family
problems in children aged 3–12 years’ provides
●● coordinates the delivery of the actions agreed
a useful evidence base for the effectiveness of
●● reduces overlap and inconsistency in the
parenting programmes. This research draws
services received.’
together evidence from different sources and finds
that children with behaviour problems are more The roles of the professionals and services in
likely to be living in lone-parent families, with Table 8.2 will vary slightly but they are likely to be
parents who have no educational qualifications, involved in some form wherever there are behaviour
in families where neither parents are employed, in management issues for individuals and for groups in
low-income households or in social sector housing. schools and other settings.
The report states that there is research evidence
that group-based programmes can be effective in It is often difficult for practitioners to record and
improving the behaviour of children from these share information about behaviour. Although
higher-risk backgrounds. For example, single practitioners may be aware of a child or young
268
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
Service Purpose
Special Employed mainly in early years and schools and includes children with or without
educational needs a Statement of Special Educational Needs. Includes children or young people with
coordinators behavioural, emotional and social difficulties (BESD). Liaises between setting and
(SENCOs) parents/carers. Ensures that individual education plans (IEPs) are in place where
needed, regardless of whether child or young person has a Statement of Educational
Needs. Supports and drives setting policies for SEN. Advises other practitioners and
puts in place a graduated response for each child or young person to meet their needs.
Educational Helps a child or young person who has problems in an educational setting (e.g. social,
psychologists emotional problems or learning difficulties). Advises teachers, parents, social workers
(EPs) and other professionals on how best to help a child or young person. Assesses a child
or young person through observation, interviews and test materials. EPs offer a wide
range of appropriate interventions, such as learning programmes and collaborative work
with teachers or parents.
Primary care (e.g. Professionals such as doctors and nurses who work in local primary care services
health visitors or (e.g. GP surgeries). Health visitors promote health in the whole community. Primary
GPs) care teams may be the first port of call for parents and carers where children or young
people have behavioural issues.
Child and NHS-provided services for children in the mental health arena in the UK. Issues of
Adolescent Mental challenging behaviour and mental health issues are included in scope of services.
Health Services CAMHS is for children and young people from birth to 18, and for their families, where
(CAMHS) there is concern about emotional or behavioural difficulties.
Paediatricians Hospital or community-based doctors who specialise in work with children and young
people.
Speech and The role of a speech and language therapist is to assess and treat speech, language
language and communication problems in people of all ages to enable them to communicate to
therapists (SLTs) the best of their ability. They may work with children and young people at home or in
schools or early years and other settings.
Parent support Parent support advisers promote good parenting and encourage parents and children
advisers to have conversations and communicate. They also encourage appropriate styles of
establishing discipline and boundaries, often using coaching strategies.
Parent partnership Provide impartial support for children and young people with special educational needs
services and their families outside the decision-making system for SEN. All local authorities (LAs)
have a duty to provide information, advice and support to parents of children with SENs
through dedicated staff working separately from the LA’s SEN team.
Youth offending These are multi-agency teams coordinated by a local authority. They deal with young
teams (YOTs) offenders and attempt to prevent reoffending and prison. Antisocial behaviour is a key
part of their remit in many areas.
Behaviour A multi-agency team dedicated to preventing the development of emotional, social,
education and behavioural and/or attendance difficulties in children and young people. BESTs provide
support teams support where there are early signs of such difficulties developing and aim to prevent
(BESTs) this getting worse.
Clinical Work as part of multidisciplinary teams, often in health or social care settings, to
psychologists assess a child or young person’s needs or behaviour. They may use psychometric
tests, interviews and direct observation of behaviour. They may offer direct therapy and
treatment or provide advice to other professionals as part of their role.
Family therapists Family therapy is a special form of psychotherapy that focuses on changes within a
family and recognises that family relationships have an impact on the feelings and
behaviour of every family member. Instead of meeting with one individual, all or most
family members are involved in the therapy process.
➤
269
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Service Purpose
Specialist social These are social workers who specialise in children, young people and families.
workers
Family support Family support workers provide emotional and practical help and advice to families who
workers are experiencing long- or short-term difficulties. They aim to help children (who may
otherwise be taken into care) stay with their families. They may work for a local authority
or the voluntary sector in Sure Start projects, children’s centres or schools, depending
on their exact role. They may support children and families in severe difficulties,
including behavioural issues.
Ethnic minority These are agencies set up to support children and families from ethnic minorities. They
agencies are valuable to ensure clear communication and cultural sensitivity.
Table 8.2 Examples of professionals and services that may be involved in behaviour management
model difficulties
●● feel they have positive skills they can offer others.
270
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
●● may feel unsure of themselves and lack confidence integral part of the model. Other models, such
●● may not be able to take physical risks and push as SBM, also use acknowledgment of positive
themselves to succeed in sports and academic behaviour.
work
●● may make inappropriate and exploitative Only where the child or young person has
relationships behavioural disorders or other serious issues may
●● may not have the confidence to interact with acknowledging positive behaviour be less effective.
others or to develop independence. In these cases, and where children or young
people are seen to have behavioural, emotional
All models of behaviour management would claim and social difficulties (BESDs), specialist support
some success in building self-esteem as practitioners may be needed. BESD teams exist in local areas
recognise its importance for overall development and to support children, young people, families and
learning. practitioners. Even in the worst of situations,
acknowledging positive behaviour will form part of
In terms of behaviour, a child or young person the individual behaviour plan and is still important
with positive self-esteem is more likely to be and worthwhile. It remains important to criticise
emotionally intelligent – that is, be able to assess, the behaviour and not the child or young person.
manage and control their own emotions and respond For example, ‘I do not like the way Ali has become
appropriately to others. Emotional intelligence is upset’, rather than ‘You have been very naughty and
explicitly associated with SBM. The goals of the AD upset Ali.’
model of behaviour management for children and
young people also include being able to manage their Acknowledgments can take many forms, including:
own behaviour and develop self-discipline and self-
worth. Almost all behaviour management systems
●● giving appropriate and genuine praise and
emphasise the benefits to children and young people encouragement
●● using a personalised approach (e.g. use the child
of having a sense of control over their world and the
benefits to settings through less low-level disruption or young person’s name)
●● being specific about what has been positive
and challenging behaviour.
●● highlighting what a child or young person does
well
Acknowledging positive ●● giving rewards during the day, such as more
behaviour choice
●● giving rewards for good behaviour during the
It is important that, when a child or young
person behaves well, this is acknowledged. If whole week, such as golden time in a primary
practitioners only respond when a child or young school (a time for relaxation and fun as a reward
person is disruptive and are constantly negative, for good behaviour during the week)
●● using star/sticker charts.
this is disheartening to those who are trying hard.
As most children and young people do want to
Behaviour is reinforced by what happens after
gain approval from adults, acknowledgements
particular behaviour is demonstrated. For example:
of positive behaviour serve to motivate the
child or young person to continue the positive ●● a one-year-old who receives smiles and hugs
behaviour. Almost all forms of behaviour after she waves and claps is likely to repeat that
management include an acknowledgement of behaviour
positive behaviour and this should take up much ●● a teenager who helps in the garden is taken
more time each day than dealing with negative somewhere special afterwards
behaviour. Models of behaviour management ●● a four-year-old is shouted at for snatching toys and
that are based on behaviourism, such as AD, repeats that behaviour if it is the only way to get
use acknowledgment of positive behaviour as an attention.
271
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Children and young people may need to be taught ●● being verbally aggressive
what positive behaviour is required. They may not ●● not listening
know what constitutes positive behaviour in the ●● not respecting others’ points of view
situation. For example, where children do not clean ●● raising your voice
up after activities and are threatened with loss of play ●● showing lack of respect in non-verbal ways, such
time, they may need to be taught how to clean up. as shrugging shoulders
Regular and consistent acknowledgement of positive ●● staring
behaviour should be part of normal everyday practice. ●● walking out in a rage
●● being confrontational
When practitioners provide acknowledgment of ●● being inconsistent
positive behaviour, they should explain why they are ●● trying to set unreasonable boundaries
doing so. For example, ‘Thank you, Niall, for sitting ●● being vague and unclear.
quietly and waiting for Talia to finish.’ This rewards
Niall but reminds everyone else of what is expected. In the assertive discipline model, a key focus is
It is important to regularly teach, remind, model, on the practitioner remaining calm yet assertive
discuss and reward all your positive expectations. when poor behaviour takes place. Assertiveness is a
powerful tool for self-control and remaining calm in
difficult circumstances. In the supportive behaviour
In Practice management model, remaining calm and assertive
is also important but this model recognises that,
Check over a session how often you or others
when behaviour becomes very challenging, time
use positive and negative interactions with a child
or young person. Are they about equal? Are you out may be required to allow all concerned to calm
emphasising the positive sufficiently? What are down.
the reasons for your results? What action can be
taken to improve the situation? Physical intervention
Sometimes physical intervention is required – for
Handling conflict calmly example, when an angry toddler is lying on the
floor in a public place or a young person is engaged
When conflict begins and escalates, it is easy to
in violent confrontation. There are strict rules
panic and become alarmed. Conflict can be between
about physical intervention and these are normally
children or young people, between adults and
made clear in a setting’s policies and procedures.
children or young people or between adults. The
Remaining calm in these circumstances can be
priority for practitioners faced with conflict is to try
difficult for practitioners, who should access support
to stay calm and defuse the situation. Appropriate
from managers and others, including parents and
intervention may prevent deterioration into violence
families.
or destructive behaviour. How adults deal with
conflict provides a model for the child or young
person.
Teaching by example
Almost all theories of children and young people’s
All conflict situations require practitioners to be learning recognise that there is some element
as calm as possible. You may need to practice self- of teaching and learning by example. Modelling
calming, using techniques such as deep breathing, positive behaviour is thought to be a powerful way
before these situations arise. of encouraging children and young people to change
or adapt their behaviour. Albert Bandura’s Bobo
The following are to be avoided when trying to deal doll studies (1961, 1965) demonstrated how nursery
with conflict: children displayed more aggressive behaviour
●● becoming anxious and agitated simply by watching adults being aggressive. They
●● using inappropriate language were less aggressive when they had seen the adult
272
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
Give verbal
reassurance Move close,
Present do not shout
choices across the
room
Change the
Find common environment
ground in appropriate
ways
Support Focus
problem- on the
solving immediate
approaches situation
Child or young
person
Give personal Do not take
space sides
Suggest
Use calm
self-calming
voice
techniques
being punished for aggressive behaviour. Although Children learn from adults’ words and actions,
critics state that social learning theory does not take especially adults who are important to them. They
account of individual differences (e.g. genetic, brain learn far more from the behaviour they see modelled
and learning differences), the Bobo doll experiment than they do from ‘being told’. They learn social,
(part of social learning theory) has been influential. emotional and practical skills by observing adults
Another common example of social learning is and they learn values and principles from seeing
advertising, which may suggest, for example, adult’s actions and how they manage everyday life.
that wearing branded trainers will make us more Adults can show children and young people that
popular. A child or young person may accept this they respect others and demonstrate compassion
and feel very upset if they cannot have what they and concern when others are suffering. They can
have ‘learned’ are items that will raise their status. demonstrate empathy, self-discipline and positive
This can be the basis for bullying and difficulties behaviour when dealing with the children and young
can arise when particular brands are common in people in their care. They do need to demonstrate
a young person’s peer group and are necessary to consistency in their reactions and avoid saying one
‘belong’ to that group. thing and doing another.
273
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
‘If children live with criticism, they learn to If children live with acceptance, they learn to
condemn. love.
If children live with hostility, they learn to If children live with approval, they learn to
fight. like themselves.
If children live with fear, they learn to be If children live with recognition, they learn it
apprehensive. is good to have a goal.
If children live with pity, they learn to feel If children live with sharing, they learn
sorry for themselves. generosity.
If children live with ridicule, they learn to feel If children live with honesty, they learn
shy. truthfulness.
If children live with jealousy, they learn to If children live with fairness, they learn
feel envy. justice.
If children live with shame, they learn to feel If children live with kindness and
guilty. consideration, they learn respect.
If children live with encouragement, they If children live with security, they learn to
learn confidence. have faith in themselves and in those about
them.
If children live with tolerance, they learn
patience. If children live with friendliness, they learn
the world is a nice place in which to live.’
If children live with praise, they learn
appreciation. Dorothy Law Nolte, PhD
Ensuring genuine care that adults really care and may severely test the
boundaries of the practitioner’s skills and patience
Children and young people will see immediately
before they believe it.
if the care they are offered is not genuine or just
offers a ‘one size fits all’ approach. Genuine care In other settings, it is not unusual to find a child
is personalised and should meet the individual or young person who has suffered from similar,
needs of children and young people. There have possibly milder, forms of neglect and abuse.
been many research projects focusing on what Providing positive messages and building self-
children and young people want from their carers esteem, as described earlier in the chapter, is
and high on the list is always ‘someone who essential for children and young people to become
knows me’. happy and confident achievers.
Many children in social care settings have suffered An important aspect of ensuring genuine care is
abuse and neglect and have been raised in building positive relationships and trust between
environments where they may have been repeatedly practitioners and children or young people. All
criticised and experienced little love and warmth. interactions should include the message ‘I like you,’
They will have repeatedly received negative even though those words are not used. Practitioners
messages about themselves, which will have may not like the child or young person’s behaviour
impacted on their self-esteem and self-confidence. but this should be communicated without saying ‘I
Such children and young people need to know do not like you.’ Building positive relationships will
274
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
have already been covered in other parts of your Learning styles include:
course but the simple rules are: ●● verbal: children and young people learn best
●● show genuine interest in all aspects of the child or through speech and the written word
young person’s life ●● aural: children and young people learn best
●● learn their name through sound and/or music
●● greet them appropriately ●● kinaesthetic: children and young people learn best
●● listen to them without interruption through ‘doing’ (i.e. movement and the sense of
●● ask questions in a supportive way touch)
●● affirm them as individuals ●● social: children and young people learn best
●● be consistent and approachable through group work or with a partner
●● involve families as partners ●● individual: children and young people learn best
●● encourage participation by the child or young in private, through individual study.
person in decisions affecting their life.
Knowing the children or young people well
Case Study
and understanding their learning styles can
help practitioners to incorporate these into the
management of behaviour. As well as this, using
A ten-year-old boy is in residential care after
their knowledge of learning styles in everyday
being neglected by his parents, who have not
work can help practitioners to ensure interest and
been able to care for themselves or him. He
involvement from the children or young people and
moved from his parents’ home to live with his
encourage them to stay ‘on task’.
grandparents, who found his behaviour too
difficult to deal with. Even though he is young,
he has had three different social workers and The importance of clear
has tried to run away.
expectations for children
How is the child likely to be feeling? What does
this situation mean for him? Do you think he will
or young people
be able to trust adults? What might help him to consistent with their
learn to manage his behaviour and feel better
about himself? development capacity
275
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
child or young person has a disability or impairment The above represents only a small range of strategies,
and may not be able to function at the level expected so continue to add your own and assess their
of their age group. effectiveness.
276
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
277
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Preventative strategies ●●
●●
making good choices
having positive thoughts.
It is obviously best if incidents of unacceptable
or challenging behaviour can be prevented. Reactive strategies
Preventative strategies will be individual for
each child or young person and based on risk Reactive strategies are used when behaviour has
assessment. Risk assessments for each child or become challenging or when there is an incident.
young person are developed so a clear plan can be These strategies should be well planned and staff
put into action if required. Preventative strategies should agree to use them as required. Practitioners
can include: often see early warning signs and try to calm the
child before escalation takes place (i.e. defuse the
●● changing the environment situation). Interrupting and redirecting at the first
●● counselling warning signs of poor behaviour can be effective –
●● cognitive behavioural therapy (solution focused)
for example, changing the situation, using humour or
●● anger management
diverting attention.
●● learning new skills
●● individual and small group work Reactive strategies will not result in any future
●● supporting different self-expression (e.g. play, art change in a child or young person’s behaviour. Their
or music therapy) aim is to help practitioners achieve rapid, safe and
●● letting go of bad memories and looking to the effective control of challenging behaviour. Reactive
future strategies are not used on their own but alongside
278
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
plans for changing behaviour and preventative In 1996 (and revised in 2008), the British Institute
strategies. for Learning Disabilities developed policy guidelines
to help services improve their practice in this area.
Sometimes when violence or threat is taking place, Some of the key principles are that:
physical intervention has to be used to protect the
child/young person and others in the environment. ●● restrictive physical interventions should only
There are strict rules and laws affecting physical be used in the best interests of the person with
intervention. The decision whether to intervene learning disabilities
●● they should only be used in conjunction with
physically will rely on professional judgement based
on risk assessment. Physical intervention can take other strategies to help people learn to behave in
the form of: non-challenging ways
●● they should be individualised and subject to
●● direct physical contact, such as safe touch, holding regular review
and restraint strategies ●● they should employ minimal force and not cause
●● barriers, such as locked doors, to limit freedom of
pain.
movement
●● materials or equipment to restrict or prevent Some settings have detailed regulations, such as
movement, such as the use of arm splints to never withholding food or drink, no locking in
reduce self-injury rooms, no sleep deprivation, no withholding of
●● prescribed medication, which is a frequently medical or dental care and no intimate physical
used method of intervention in these searches, although searching for potentially
circumstances. dangerous items is allowed.
279
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Case Study
Asher and Sara
Asher is three years old and continually bites and playing outdoors, practitioners make sure he is
physically attacks other children in the nursery. If engaged in one-to-one activities or remains in
he is prevented from doing this, he throws himself close proximity to a staff member.
to the ground and screams, sometimes for long
Sara
periods, until he becomes racked with sobs and
very unhappy. Practitioners have tried several
Sara is at an after-school club and is often heard
techniques but are at their wits’ end. They decide
name calling and verbally bullying another child.
to take action by observing the behaviour each
When challenged, she lies about the incidents,
time it occurs and assessing what the triggers
saying it was the other person’s fault. Practitioners
are. His key person, supported by his concerned
plan a strategy to deal with this each time it
mother, observes and records incidents of the
happens by immediately bringing together both
behaviour, while making sure the other children
parties to explain what happened and include
are kept safe. They notice a pattern emerging
others who may have observed the incident. This
as Asher seems to have the worst outbursts first
is sometimes called a restorative approach.
thing in the morning and just before lunch. They
also notice the behaviour follows periods of Consider both case studies and discuss the
outdoor play. The observations help them to try following questions.
different strategies. They make sure Asher has
regular healthy snacks to keep his blood sugar at 1 Are the strategies preventative or reactive?
a constant level and his mother starts to give him 2 Are there other strategies that could be used
oat-based cereals instead of sugary breakfast for each child?
cereals. After a few days, there has been a 3 Do these strategies support a safe
noticeable improvement. After Asher has been environment for the children?
280
Chapter 8 Supportive approaches to behaviour management (Unit CP 8)
that provide the basis for a positive settling-in This ‘safe base’ supports positive learning and
experience. For younger children, and in many development experiences as secure children and
settings for older children and young people, the young people are more able to learn and take
‘key person’ approach is used and this is vital to appropriate and managed risks in learning and
encourage attachment and help cope with separation relationships. Sometimes siblings or other young
anxiety. people who are consistent and reliable fulfil
this ‘safe base’ role. On other occasions, more
Work with children and young people will often unsuitable influences take over, such as street
mean that practitioners have to draw on all gangs, which provide this security but are often
their skills and knowledge to support acceptable negative influences on the young people. Young
behaviour. Routines, predictability, structure and people need a sense of purpose and belonging
consistency in their environment are key to settling to help them navigate through this stage of their
in and remain important, ongoing features of lives.
emotional well-being.
Useful resources
281
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Search for ‘behaviour management’ on the primary school classrooms: a systematic review of
following website to bring up a number of useful the effectiveness of interventions, EPPI-Centre (part
resources. of the Social Science Research Unit, Institute of
www.nspcc.org.uk Education, University of London) and The National
Foundation for Educational Research.
Department for Education Gibbs, J., Underdown, A., Stevens, M., Newbery,
The lead professional role and schools: fact J. and Liabo, K. (2003, updated 2006) Group-
sheet (2008) based parenting programmes can reduce behaviour
www.education.gov.uk/publications/standard/ problems of children aged 3-12 years, What Works
Teachersandschoolworkforce/Page5/IW46/0708 for Children group, Evidence Nugget, April,
Economic and Social Research Council.
Books Glasser, W. (1965) Reality therapy: a new
Bandura, A. (1965) ‘Influence of models’ approach to psychiatry, New York: Harper & Row.
reinforcement contingencies on the acquisition Glasser, W. (1998) Choice theory: a new psychology
of imitative responses’, Journal of Personality and of personal freedom, New York: HarperCollins.
Social Psychology, 1: 589–595. Goodman, A. and Gregg, P. (2010) The importance
Bandura, A., Ross, D. and Ross, S.A. (1961) of attitudes and behaviour for poorer children’s
‘Transmission of aggression through imitation educational attainment, York: Joseph Rowntree
of aggressive models’, Journal of Abnormal and Foundation.
Social Psychology, 63: 575–582. Kounin, J. (1970/1977) Discipline and group
Canter, L. and Canter, M. (1992) Assertive discipline: management in classrooms, New York: Holt,
positive behavior management for today’s classroom, Rinehart and Winston.
Bloomington, IN: Canter and Associates. Life Skills Company (2008) ‘Exit strategy for the
Carr, E.G., Horner, R.H., Turnbull, A.P., Marquis, overheated’, TES, 7 November.
J.G., McLaughlin, D.M., McAtee, M.L., Smith, Ofsted (2005) Healthy minds: promoting
C.E., Ryan, K.A., Ruef, M.A., Doolabh, A. and emotional health and well-being in schools, HMI
Braddock, D. (1999) Positive behaviour support for 2457, Manchester: Ofsted.
people with developmental disabilities: A research Ofsted (2011) Supporting children with challenging
synthesis, Washington: American Association on behaviour through a nurture group approach,
Mental Retardation. report number 100230, Manchester: Ofsted.
Craig, C. (2007) The potential dangers of a Palmer, S. (2009) 21st century boys: modern life
systematic, explicit approach to teaching social is driving them off the rails and how we can get
and emotional skills, Glasgow: Centre for them back on track, London: Orion Books.
Confidence and Well-Being. Steer, A., Sir and the Practitioners’ Group on
Department for Education (2010) Guidance on School Behaviour and Discipline (2005) Learning
school behaviour and attendance partnerships, behaviour: the report of the Practitioners’ Group
London: Department for Education. on School Behaviour and Discipline, London:
Department of Health (2007) Mansell report. Department for Education and Skills
Services for people with learning disabilities and Steer, A., Sir (2009) Learning behaviour: a
challenging behaviour or mental health needs, review of behaviour standards and practices in
revised edition, London: Department of Health. our schools, London: Department for Children,
Dreikurs, R. (1998) Maintaining sanity in the Schools and Families.
classroom: classroom management techniques, 2nd Temple, M. (2008) An emotionally intelligent
edition, Philadelphia, PA: Taylor & Francis. approach to behaviour management, The Life
Evans, J., Harden, A., Thomas, J. and Benefield, Skills Company.
P. (2003) Support for pupils with emotional and Temple M. (2009) Emotionally intelligent
behavioural difficulties (EBD) in mainstream behaviour management, The Life Skills Company.
282
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within
the work environment (Unit CP 9)
Early years, care and education settings have a It is of paramount importance that all records are
legal duty to keep accurate formal records to ensure accurate and recorded in a timely manner so that
compliance with relevant legislation. the information is recorded while it is fresh in the
writer’s mind. This is vitally important as the records
Providers must maintain records and obtain and
may be used as evidence when making significant
share information (with parents and carers, other
decisions about a child’s education or well-being or
professionals working with the child, and the police,
they may even form part of the ‘evidence’ related to
social services and Ofsted as appropriate) to ensure
legal action being taken by individuals or authorities.
the safe and efficient management of the setting and
to help ensure the needs of all children are met (3.67 The appropriate sharing and safe storage of any
Statutory Framework for the Early Years Foundation records are a major consideration for any organisation.
Stage, Section 3 – The Safeguarding and Welfare Under the Data Protection Act 1998, there is a legal
Requirements 2012). requirement for the maintaining of confidentiality
related to all personal information. Therefore,
Key terms settings must have a written policy outlining the
procedures they have in place to comply with this legal
Informed decision – when you have lots of relevant requirement.
information about something which helps you to make a
decision.
Conditions of registration – when a provider is given
permission to operate (for example, from Ofsted), there
Learning outcomes
are many rules and regulations that must be followed by
the provider to ensure they work within the law and can
1. Understand the rationale for recording
remain registered. information in a formal format.
Objectivity – not being influenced by thoughts or 2. Understand which format should be
feelings, not taking into account prior conclusions. used relevant to target reader.
Pro forma – a pre-designed form or document. 3. Be able to use formal recording in the
real work environment.
Authoritative organisations such as Ofsted, the
Department for Education and the Health and
Safety Executive set down rules and regulations
which settings must adhere to as a condition of Section 1: Understand the
registration. It is a requirement that settings have
policies and procedures in place that ensure the rationale for recording
accurate recording of a wide range of information.
The records kept by a setting include those related information in a formal
to children and young people using a setting,
staff, visitors, the physical environment and the
format
activity that takes place within and outside the Formal record keeping is of paramount importance
environment. for supporting the effective management of a
283
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
284
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
to reflect on how well they handled a situation that the practices took place and should include
or to consider if an activity they provided for the particular details, such as the length of time taken
children was suitable and enjoyable. Practitioners to evacuate the building. A record detailing the
reflect back on the children’s observations firefighting equipment inspection, confirming it
and development records and use them when was undertaken by a registered fire safety expert,
planning for the child’s next steps. Records such will also need to be kept. The accurate records
as practitioner’s activity plans or observations will confirm that the provision is following the
might be reviewed by supervisors when deciding written procedure and conforming to health and
what training might be beneficial for an individual safety legislation. The records will need to be made
practitioner or team of practitioners. available for inspection on request by the fire safety
officer.
Informing decisions
Records kept in a consistently similar format,
Sharing information
such as registers, forms or charts, allow a reader A multi-agency approach brings together
to review information quickly and make rapid, practitioners from different sectors and professions,
informed decisions. For example recording who work together to provide the additional
information about the number of children support that some children, young people and
booked into a session in a register allows staff to families need. Formal records often form the basis
quickly determine the number of staff required to of the discussions and decisions made related to
ensure ratios are maintained. safeguarding or support required by a child or
family. Therefore, all relevant information should
A risk assessment record check may highlight be recorded accurately and shared appropriately.
where changes are necessary within a setting. Remember, the Data Protection Act 1998 should be
For example, if a review of the risk assessment adhered to at all times!
records highlights a piece of equipment as being
responsible for a number of minor injuries, a Many settings provide parents and carers with
decision may be made, based on the evidence information about the setting, including policies
within the records, to remove the equipment from and procedures, information about the daily
the setting to avoid further injury. routine, introductions to the staff and other general
information about the service they provide. This
Following policies and information is often contained in a brochure or
information pack, and/or on a website. Giving all
procedures parents and carers information in this way ensures
that everyone has access to the same information
Formal recording might be an integral part of a
and the information recorded is up-to-date and
procedure that has been put in place within the
accurate.
setting to comply with a legal requirement. A
written procedure outlines what steps the setting
takes to fulfil their legal responsibility, including 3 Progress check
the recording process undertaken. For example, it
is the legal responsibility of all provisions to have You should now understand that the value of
recording information formally includes the
a fire safety policy. The policy will acknowledge
following:
that the setting is required to carry out regular
fire evacuation practices, along with ensuring • Adhering to legal requirements. This means
making sure that the conditions of registration
the firefighting equipment is inspected annually.
as a care/education provider are fully met
The records should document the dates and times
285
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● reports
by recording all necessary information in an
●● pro forma
appropriate format.
●● formal letters
• Ensuring consistency of quality. By recording ●● observations
certain types of information in a similar way or
●● records of telephone calls/memos
on a pre-designed form, consistency in quality is
●● minutes of meetings/meeting agenda
more likely to be achieved.
●● numerical documents
• Supporting reflective practice. When
●● charts and diagrams.
information is recorded in a set way, it is
easier to find particular pieces of information
to review details of a situation or to review
The contents of all records must be:
performance. ●● timely
• Informing decisions. When information is written ●● informative
in a format that is easy to read and relevant ●● accurate
information is accessible when required, it ●● presented in the appropriate format clearly
supports practitioners to make informed understood by the target reader.
decisions.
• Ensuring policies and procedures are followed.
When practitioners follow a set procedure (for Pro forma (pre-written
example, when recording information), it helps
to ensure that all the relevant facts are always forms)
included whoever carries out the recording and
that all practitioners are following the setting’s Pro forma are most often used when it is essential to
procedures. This relates to ensuring information include certain facts when recording – for example,
is stored appropriately. when recording children’s personal information or
• Supporting the sharing of valid information. recording accidents in a setting. The form sets out
There are many occasions when information exactly what information is required and will ensure
is shared appropriately between practitioners, the writer records all the relevant facts, which may
parents and other professionals. Formal be needed to comply with legislation (see an example
recording helps to ensure the information is valid of an accident/incident form on page 295).
and written in a format that is understandable
by all. Pro forma usually support the writer to record a
lot of important information concisely, rather than
give a long descriptive account. When reviewing
Section 2: Understand information on a pro forma, the reader knows where
to look to quickly gain the information they require.
which format should be It is easier to compare information from a selection
of records when the information is recorded in the
used relevant to target same format – for example, when reviewing where in
reader the setting accidents happen most frequently.
When information is recorded within a setting, it Examples of pro forma used for recording include:
is imperative that it is documented in a suitable ●● children’s personal information, including
way. A wide range of information needs to be safeguarding issues
formally recorded and the way it is recorded, ●● children’s attendance
shared and stored depends on a number of factors, ●● children’s daily routines
including the purpose of the record and the target ●● staff rotas
reader. Professionals will be required to record ●● accidents/incidents
information in a variety of formats, including: ●● medication
286
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
287
288
Reports ●● informative
●● understandable – aimed at the target reader
subject or problem and supports the writer to gather ●● written in the past tense – the report is a summary
relevant information and facts and present them as of what has happened in the past
accurately as possible. A report may include analysis, ●● signed and dated at the end.
Example of a report
289
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
snack table. Two settings encouraged the The experience the children in each setting
children to select their snack and help gain varies greatly.
to prepare it themselves. For example,
5. Recommendations
children at Back Lane helped to peel the
carrots and wash the fruit. • A company policy is required to ensure
consistency.
(d) The availability of snacks during the day
• All settings should source produce locally
Bear House offered snacks for the longest and purchase twice weekly to ensure
period of time – between 9.45am and freshness.
11.15am and then again in the afternoon • Children should be included in the selection
between 1.30pm and 2.45pm. and preparation of snacks wherever
4. Conclusions practical.
There are differences between the range of • Snack time should be used as an
snacks and the length of time the snacks are opportunity to educate children about
offered within the five settings. healthy food choices.
Signed S. Smith (Manager) 19th January 2013
290
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
Yours sincerely,
Teddy Barker
T. Barker
Meetings are held for many reasons and the numbers When a formal meeting is planned, an agenda
attending can range from only two or three people to will often be drawn up and sent to those invited
large gatherings of hundreds of people. Therefore, the to attend. This allows time for the items to be
format of a meeting or where a meeting might take considered by individuals before the meeting.
place will depend on the purpose of the meeting.
291
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Example of an agenda
AGENDA
Teddy Barker’s Nursery
September 17th, 2013
7.00–8.45pm
292
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
meeting ends so that the content is still fresh in Recording children’s development accurately and
the writer’s mind. It is important that participants objectively is vitally important for a number of
get a copy of the minutes promptly to enable reasons. Being objective means only recording the
them to carry out any actions they have taken facts as they are presented and not allowing personal
responsibility for. opinions, beliefs or feelings to impact on the
recording of those facts.
Recording children’s Take, as an example, a practitioner undertaking a
development tick-list observation of a child. He observes the child
trying to climb onto a small, three-wheeled bike.
The Early Years Foundation Stage (2012) identifies The child is struggling to get on and then gives
the importance of formative and summative up. The practitioner is sure he saw that same child
assessment of children’s development and makes it riding on the exact bike yesterday, so puts a tick next
a legal requirement for practitioners to keep accurate to the box which reads ‘The child can climb onto
records of children’s progress. and ride a three-wheeled bike’. The information
is then added to the child’s learning journey or
The framework requires early years practitioners to
development record. However, a practitioner might
review children’s progress and share a summary
have lifted the child onto the bike yesterday or
with parents at two points:
another child might have helped. Therefore, what
●● between the ages of 24 and 36 months has been recorded is incorrect information. The
●● at the end of the EYFS in the EYFS profile. practitioner actually recorded his own opinion or
belief, rather than what he saw the child doing
Therefore, it is of paramount importance that
that day.
practitioners are able to undertake formative
assessment by objectively observing and accurately Children’s observation records are used by
recording children’s development. practitioners to gain an understanding of the
child’s current stage of development. The
The EYFS also states that practitioners are required
information practitioners get from reviewing the
to undertake summative assessment of children.
observations of a child is invaluable when providing
Both approaches support information sharing with
experiences, planning activities and considering
staff, parents/carers, other settings and multi-agency
the support a child may need to strengthen
professionals.
and extend their learning and development.
Summative assessment requires practitioners to If this information is not recorded accurately,
make objective, accurate, short written accounts incorrect decisions may be made for the child –
of children’s development and progress, which are for example, it could result in a child being given
referred to as ‘summaries’. activities that are too challenging and therefore
could have the potential to damage the child’s
Observation self-esteem.
293
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Practitioners need to carefully consider the most Accident and incident records are important
appropriate form of observation. Observations documents that are required for a number of reasons,
recorded by practitioners may be viewed by including:
external agencies such as doctors, psychologists ●● informing other staff in the setting
or other health professionals when gaining ●● notifying parents/carers of the child/children
an understanding of a child’s development or
concerned
behaviour. If observations are not recorded ●● providing information to assist doctors or other
accurately or the observer has failed to record a vital
health professionals, if medical assistance is
piece of information, planning for a child may not be
required
suitable and this could affect a child’s progression or ●● informing the risk assessment process
well-being. ●● providing the relevant facts when an
investigation is undertaken by a regulatory
authority (e.g. Ofsted or the Health and Safety
Reflective practice Executive)
●● informing insurance companies when a claim is
Look at a piece of information you have recorded
made against the setting.
– for example, a child observation or information
about a child’s day. Think about how you recorded
The records need to contain all the relevant
the information and reflect on the following:
information, recorded objectively, clearly and
• Was all the information relevant? accurately. Accident or incident forms should
• Did you record the information objectively? be completed as soon as possible after the
• Could you have recorded the information in a event to ensure facts are recalled and recorded
more suitable format? accurately. Information should be concise,
with only the relevant details given, so that
the reader can quickly get a clear picture of the
ity situation.
Research Activ
Information to be recorded on an accident/incident
Research the following:
form:
• Data Protection Act 1998
●● name of child
• Health and Safety Executive (HSE) ●● date and time of accident/incident
• Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous ●● names of practitioners present
Occurrences Regulations 1995 (RIDDOR). ●● what happened (where/how)
Think about how each of these pieces of legislation ●● nature of injury and which part of the child was
impacts on care/education provision. injured
●● what action was taken by the practitioners
●● who was informed
294
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
Name of child: Include child’s full name Date: The date the accident/ Time: The time of the
incident happened accident/incident
Name/s of practitioners present: Include all the names of those present
What happened: State what was happening before the accident/incident, how the accident/incident
happened, where it happened.
Example:
Zac was playing with three other children in the outdoor area. The children were digging in the raised beds
using small spades.
Zac was sitting on the ground holding his spade when another child stood on Zac’s hand.
Nature of injury: Provide details of the injury
Example:
Zac has small cut/graze to right index finger where he was holding the spade and a swelling on his knuckles
where the child stood on his hand.
Action taken: Include details of what action the practitioner took, such as calling a first aider or seeking
medical assistance if the injury was serious.
Example:
Jenny reassured Zac that he was going to be fine. A first aider washed the wound, checked the movement in
Zac’s hand, which appeared good, and then applied a cold compress.
After ten minutes, Zac seemed OK and asked to go back out to play, so a small plaster was applied to the cut.
Zac was observed by practitioners and seems to be using his hand in the way he normally would.
Details of person reporting the accident: Signed:
Rebecca Issac (nursery nurse) Rebecca Issac
Manager/Health and Safety Officer: Signed:
Stephanie Barker (manager) S. Barker
Is this a reportable accident/incident (yes/no)?
If yes, add details of when and to whom the accident was reported.
Advice/information given to parent/carer: This should include information such as what to do if the child seems
to be getting worse. For example, if the child has suffered a bump to the head, the parents/carers should be
advised to seek immediate medical attention if the child:
●● has a headache which gets worse or does not go away within four to six hours of the accident or incident
●● becomes drowsy or difficult to wake up
●● feels sick or vomits.
Name of parent/carer: Signed:
in place following a risk assessment, are not proving In some circumstances where the injury is significant
effective. – for example, when bones are broken or an injured
person requires hospital treatment – the accident
Accident and incident forms should be stored safely must be reported verbally to the relevant external
(complying with the Data Protection Act 1998) authorities, such as Ofsted and/or the Health and
for a minimum of three years and be available for Safety Executive (to comply with RIDDOR) within
inspection as requested by a regulatory authority. 24 hours and a copy of the report sent within seven
295
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Current
occupancy F.T.E.
(full-time equivalent)
Places booked –
to be taken up in
the next three months
Spare places
(April 2013)
296
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
297
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
298
Chapter 9 Formal recording for use within the work environment (Unit CP 9)
Writing clearly, at the and useful to the reader. Having systems in place
that highlight the recording procedure will help
appropriate level to ensure all practitioners are familiar with when
and how to record information in line with setting
Information is recorded for many different reasons policies. When all practitioners understand how to
and for a range of people. Therefore, it is crucial follow the recording procedure, it ensures that all
that the language used is appropriate for the reader. similar situations are recorded in the same way,
For example, using very academic words within whichever practitioner is recording the information.
3 Progress check
You should understand the following:
• Recalling and recording information accurately means including the relevant facts.
• Writing succinctly is often important. Giving long, detailed accounts is not necessary when a brief
overview, including relevant details, is adequate.
• Being objective is crucial. Recording only the facts and not including feelings, beliefs or prior
judgements support objectivity.
• Time management skills are essential to ensure records are written up in a timely manner, so that facts are
easily recalled accurately.
• Using an appropriate level of language should be considered so the records are clearly understood by the
target reader.
• Writing clearly when handwriting ensures the record can be read easily and is not misunderstood by
others.
• Following setting procedures is very important to ensure that information is recorded in the appropriate
format.
299
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
• A sound understanding of confidentiality and data protection is necessary to protect the practitioner, the
setting, children and families.
• Reflective practice is supported by effective formal recording as reviewing records supports practitioners
to make informed decisions based on facts.
The above list identifies just some of the skills in line with the setting’s confidentiality policy.
practitioners need to develop when recording Remember, records within a setting are often kept as
in a real work environment. However, the most a legal requirement and therefore every practitioner
important considerations are to ensure that records has a legal responsibility to make sure that they
are objectively written, accurate, recorded in the follow the setting policy in all aspects of record
correct format, stored appropriately and only shared keeping.
Useful resources
HSE: investigations
www.hse.gov.uk/foi/internalops/og/ogprocedures/investigation/report.htm
Ealing Early Years Childcare and Play: summarising and tracking children’s progress
www.childrenscentres.org.uk/ey_tracking_tools.asp
300
Chapter 10 Research to support practice
when working with children and/or young
people (Unit CP 10)
This chapter will help you to understand what from start to finish, developing your project so
is meant by the term ‘research’, how research is that the information produced through your
carried out and how it can be used, particularly research investigations is fit for your intended
in relation to your work with children and young purpose.
people. Research contributes to many specialist
areas of work and study and is central to many You will understand the particular issues that must
disciplines, but this chapter will focus on the be taken into consideration when doing research
contribution made by research to work with with children and young people, and how you can
children and young people. use more than one approach to ensure your findings
are legitimate. Reflecting on the process, you will
You will begin to understand how research, and consider how you might use your conclusions to
the results of research, can be used in your work inform your work with children and young people, or
with children and young people – for example, to that of your organisation.
improve practice. You will become familiar with
the way in which research findings are presented
in different styles and in different formats to suit
particular audiences. In addition, you will be able Section 1: The value of
to plan and carry out your own research project
research when working
Learning outcomes with children and/or
1. Understand research and its value young people
when working with children and/or
Most research with children and young people
young people.
is aimed at improving their life chances and
2. Understand the role of a hypothesis in opportunities and enabling all children to reach
research. their full potential, rather than just adding to the
3. Understand methodologies in sum of knowledge. It does this by helping us reach
research. a better understanding of children and young
4. Be able to identify a research people’s development and experiences and how
hypothesis. they see the world, so that we begin to recognise
5. Be able to plan and implement how to contribute to their development in our
research in relation to working with practice.
children and/or young people
Children and young people’s services include:
6. Be able to present data in relation to
the hypothesis. ●● childcare provision and nursery services
7. Be able to reflect on the research ●● education, school and boarding school services
undertaken. ●● children’s health services, including child and
adolescent mental health services (CAMHS)
301
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● children’s social services for looked-after children, models to see which seem to be the best fit to
including fostering and adoption services and your needs and consider how reliable they are and
residential childcare services how much they cost to run, tax and insure, and
●● voluntary and charitable organisations providing so on. Your decision will be affected by all these
specialist services for children and young people. factors.
All organisations concerned with children and Research can be defined as:
young people can use the results of research to help
●● organised study, or the act of studying something
improve their services.
methodically
●● investigating or studying a subject closely;
What is research? a course of critical or scientific inquiry; an
investigation directed to the discovery of some fact
Often when we think of research, we imagine
by careful study of a subject.
someone in a laboratory wearing a white coat,
surrounded by test tubes and machines, doing The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, vol. 2, third edn.
complicated experiments. In fact, some research,
particularly scientific research, can be exactly like Research includes both the search for knowledge
this but it is important to recognise that there are and the process through which new knowledge
many different ways of doing research and it can is gained and understanding increased; by the
actually be part of everyday life. The overall aim of time you have researched your new car, you will
research is to add to the sum of human knowledge. certainly be very knowledgeable about different
Research does this by asking questions to find things types of cars!
out, then producing data that can be measured and
Some research, such as academic or medical
tested. Consequently, research can be thought of as
research, may be carried out to investigate a
a process for finding things out in an organised and
particular issue or specialist area, to find out
systematic way.
new information, for example, or seek to better
understand a particular disease so that new
Key term treatments can be developed. Research might be
carried out in organisations working with children
Data – the facts, figures and numbers that, when
analysed, provide meaningful information. and young people, including those such as charitable
organisations or social services, to see how well
new practices, policies or ways of doing things are
For example, we all undertake a form of research
working; other research is carried out to test the
when we make decisions about things. If you
feasibility of new ideas or thinking.
were planning to buy a new car, you would think
about the reasons for needing a car; for instance, Using the internet to find things out is not research
it would be no use buying a two-seater sports car because there is usually no way of checking the
if you regularly need to drive your three children accuracy of information or the validity of the studies
to school. Because there are so many cars available that such information may be based on. However, it
and you cannot research them all, you might can be useful as part of the research process.
then draw up some criteria to narrow down your
requirements, such as how much you could afford
and whether to consider a new car or buy second Types of research
hand, your preference for manual or automatic ●● Applied research – this uses the outcomes of
gears, petrol or diesel engine; all these factors will research to decide what interventions (treatments,
affect the type of car you are prepared to consider. actions, ways of working) are effective.
You would probably look at reviews of several Organisations that use applied research include
302
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
303
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
304
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
305
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
instance, about children and young people – and (e.g. Winston’s Wish), services for older children
how these are formed. An example of how opinions and young adults, bullying and child protection
are identified through research is the ‘British Social services. Needs might be identified for individuals or
Attitudes Survey’ (http://data.gov.uk/dataset/british- groups and/or geographically – locally, regionally or
social-attitudes-survey), carried out annually by nationally across the different countries of the UK.
the government. Opinions are also tested through
market research, the results of which help companies Highlighting gaps in provision
and businesses to make decisions that respond to Research has previously identified gaps in services,
people’s opinions, needs and preferences, increasing such as respite care for children with additional needs
sales and profits. However, it is only recently that (short-break foster care) and Child and Adolescent
children and young people have begun to be asked Mental Health Services (CAMHS). Services for child
their opinions and views directly. carers supporting disabled or sick parents might be
insufficient to meet current or predicted demand or
Trends may not be offered locally if the provision is non-
Surveys are used to predict trends, events and statutory (not legally required to be offered by local
people’s behaviour by asking about an individual’s authorities). Often charities are involved in providing
intentions, such as how they would vote in an some services to make up for gaps in provision
election, how likely they are to use private health – for example, for unaccompanied child refugees
services or whether they intend to return to work entering the country and seeking asylum (see www.
after having a baby. They may ask questions about refugeecouncil.org.uk). There is often overlap between
people’s lifestyles – for example, how they travel identifying needs and highlighting gaps in provision.
to work and whether they have a car, how many
children are in the household, their household Planning health, education and care
income and expenditure. It is important for
services
governments to be able to identify trends in order to
The use of research by government to evaluate
plan services and allocate resources (see http://data.
current service levels or respond to significant issues,
gov.uk/dataset/social_trends). Again, it is only more
such as child deaths resulting from safeguarding
recently, as a result of the adoption of the principles
failures. An example is the Laming Report, in which
contained in the United Nations Convention on the
Lord Laming was commissioned by the government
Rights of the Child (UNCRC), that children and
to examine how safeguarding children could be
young people have become involved in helping to
improved following the high-profile death of a child.
shape services that affect them. Prior to this, their
Lord Laming’s recommendations led to the ‘Every
views were not usually sought.
Child Matters’ policy, which aimed to improve
Companies also like to have information about integrated working between all the agencies involved
consumer (customer) buying habits to identify new with safeguarding children and young people –
trends so that they can produce products that people, health, social services and education. Research
including children and young people, want to buy; also informs the provision of maternity and child
this is an aspect of market research. health services, schools and early years services – for
example, to see whether the number of school places,
Research in children and young maternity beds or midwives is likely to be sufficient
to meet the predicted changes in population.
people’s services
Identifying needs Evaluating existing provision
For example, school readiness, literacy and numeracy, For example, the Steer Review was a government-
care facilities for children with life-threatening and commissioned review of behaviour standards and
life-limiting conditions, childhood bereavement practices in schools. The researchers examined
306
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
a large amount of evidence on different ways of causing progressive muscle weakness in boys and
managing children’s behaviour in schools, using that severely shortens their lives. This discovery has
a range of methodologies, and made a number of helped further research to identify a drug which may
recommendations to help schools improve their encourage the body to ignore the genetic mutation
practice. (defect) which causes DMS.
The Human Genome Project is an example of large- ●● Research can confirm facts and things already
scale research leading to new knowledge. Research known – for example, it can replicate experiments
was carried out over a number of years to identify that confirm existing theories.
the chemical construction of DNA (deoxyribonucleic ●● Research clarifies and improves our understanding
acid – the basic building block of human existence), of the world and how it works.
together with the 20,000–25,000 genes that carry ●● Research provides opportunities to explore ideas
specific DNA information, and create the uniqueness and follow our interests, stimulating debate and
of each human. Indeed, so big is this research that new thinking.
we keep discovering more information that can ●● Research provides evidence and answers to
potentially benefit humans. One recent example is questions – that is, evidence-based practice, such
the discovery of the gene responsible for Duchenne as ‘why we do this (X) and not this (Y)’ (i.e. what
muscular dystrophy (DMS) – an inherited condition works and what does not).
Plan health,
Highlight gaps in
education and
service provision
care services
Discover new
Evaluate
knowledge to
existing service
inform policy and
provision
practice
307
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● New questions that need to be asked can emerge point for further investigations. It is basically a way
from research and additional areas that need to of asking a research question – you formulate a
be better understood may be identified, triggering research question to find things out.
further research investigations. For example, data
from large-scale studies may highlight small A hypothesis starts as a suggested explanation for
areas that do not fit the common pattern. Further something that is observed – a phenomenon. This
research may then be carried out in these areas to explanation might be based on a belief, an idea, an
understand why and in what ways they differ from assumption or a supposition. Much social science
the general pattern, improving understanding and is about trying to find the reasons for behaviour
adding depth to the knowledge base developed and how society works, so while behaviour can be
from the initial proposal. observed, the reasons for behaviour are not always
clear. Therefore, you have to use deductive reasoning
308
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
out because you can usually only test one thing at a planning your research and takes considerable
time. Types of hypothesis include the following: preparation.
●● Causal hypothesis – this is an assumption that A common example of how a hypothesis works is to
one thing causes another. In other words, it think of a court.
predicts a cause and effect: X causes Y.
●● Null hypothesis – this a reverse way of thinking,
●● Someone has been accused of a crime (the
in which you make a statement that you then try hypothesis statement).
●● The prosecution presents the evidence (following
and disprove through your research.
●● Alternative hypothesis – this is the opposite research).
●● The defence tries to discredit the evidence
of a null hypothesis and claims that there is a
difference. (challenging the validity of the evidence).
●● The jury find the person either guilty or not guilty
For example, suppose you believe that children according to the evidence presented.
who attend nursery have a better vocabulary at
three years old than those who do not. Your null This does not mean that the person is innocent –
hypothesis statement might say: they may have actually committed the crime but
there is insufficient evidence to prove it beyond all
There is no difference in the vocabulary of
reasonable doubt.
three-year-old children who attend nursery and
those who do not.
Section 3: Methodologies
In other words, the null hypothesis makes the claim
of no difference. in research
The results of your research, depending on what you How do we know that what we are told or see in the
find, will either reject the statement or not. In other paper is true, when we read ‘research has shown
words, there will either be a difference or there will that…’ or ‘studies indicate that…’?
be no significant difference. A significant difference
We can evaluate the work being referred to by using
means statistically significant (see Section 6). The
research criteria, the standards against which any
idea behind a null hypothesis is that it is easier
research should be judged.
to disprove than prove something, especially in a
subject area that is as broad as social science. You can Methodology means the systematic approach
continue experimenting and researching the area to doing research, and different disciplines will
until you have a body of knowledge. use different methodologies – social science uses
different methodologies from those of the natural
Of course it would be impossible to test all three-
sciences. The methodology will include the way
year-old children who go to nursery, so you would
in which research is undertaken (the process of
have to take a representative sample of three-year-
research), including:
olds in nursery. To ensure you were comparing like
with like, you would have to choose your sample ●● the stages of the research process and a
carefully, allowing for variables such as sex, cultural chronology or timeline
background, family structure and so on (see Section ●● the activities to be carried out during the research
5), as well as the type of nursery they attend. There (e.g. literature review, data collection, fieldwork,
may be geographical differences or other variables statistical analysis)
that you would need to consider. You would also ●● the approach to collecting data and the tools used
need to define what you mean by vocabulary – for by researchers to find out information, such as
example, do you mean words understood or words questionnaires or interviews
used? Are you examining speech patterns? All ●● the way in which the research is reported
this is part of designing your methodology and depending on the intended audience.
309
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
310
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
Ratiocination
(and logic)
Mathematics
Physics
Chemistry
Xeno–sciences
(cosmology, astronomy Biology Nano–science
and planetary science)
Earth sciences
Computer
(geology, oceanography Brain science
technology
and meteorology)
Eco–environmental Medical
Agro-science Engineering
science science
Socio-economic
sciences
Law
(and ethics)
311
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● biology, sometimes known as the life sciences, and therefore reasonable, from other beliefs that are
which includes disciplines such as neuroscience not supported by any evidence and do not have a
(the study of the brain) and environmental science rational foundation. Once you understand how to
(study of the natural world). apply critical thinking to your work with children
and young people, you will be able to make decisions
The social sciences are sometimes known as social based on evidence, justifying those decisions and the
and behavioural sciences because they are concerned outcome of your decision making with confidence,
with the study of people and society. The social knowing that your actions were based on evidence
sciences broadly include: from sound research.
●● anthropology – the study of humanity and the
origins of humanity Key term
●● sociology – the study of societies, including
theories of how societies function Critical thinking – the process of questioning
common beliefs and explanations for things (including
●● psychology – the study of human behaviour,
one’s own).
including social psychology and child
development
●● history (especially social history) – the study of the
The scientific method has been used since the
past, including politics and society in the past seventeenth century, emerging from work by
●● political science – the study of politics and the
philosophers such as Descartes (1596–1650). It
influence of politics on the economic and social was further developed as a result of investigations
world and scientific inquiry into the natural sciences –
●● philosophy – the study of meaning; for example,
mathematics, biology, chemistry and physics – in the
the meaning of life and problems concerned with, early nineteenth century by scientists such as Isaac
for example, knowledge and language, values and Newton (1642–1727), who was influenced by Descartes.
morals, reason and logic.
The scientific method is a way of questioning what Although subject to much debate over the years,
we are seeing or being told and relies on critical the scientific method is based on the idea that the
thinking to distinguish those beliefs that are logical, truth or facts can be discovered logically, through
312
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
rational, reasoned arguments, rather than feelings or said to be reliable. All of the answers must be able to
experience. By using a set of recognised and agreed be proved and the results repeated by other scientists
principles and a logical, step-by-step approach, ideas using exactly the same methods and procedures.
and thoughts can be tested out to see if they are true. The scientific method has generally been seen as the
main method of academic and scientific discovery.
The sequence of stages in the scientific method
You have probably used it yourself if you studied
consists of the following:
chemistry or physics and carried out experiments
●● Observation. This may be natural observation which gave the same results each time the correct
using the naked eye or observation using process was followed.
scientific equipment, such as a microscope, or in
the form of experiments, such as those carried Key term
out in a laboratory (e.g. mixing two substances
in a test tube and applying heat). The subject of Replicated – findings can be reproduced when the
investigation has to be capable of being seen and experiment is repeated.
reproduced.
●● Description. The next stage is an accurate We know that the findings are accurate because, if
description of what has been observed; this is the research has followed the principles, the results
sometimes known as a phenomenon. are based on evidence and are therefore valid. It is,
●● Hypothesis. Once the phenomenon has been however, important to recognise that, in science,
observed and described, a hypothesis (an nothing is ever proved conclusively; it is merely
educated guess, sometimes known as a premise) accepted as fact until it is proved otherwise.
is developed. This is an attempt to explain the
reason for what has been observed and predict The scientific method is an example of inductive
what might happen. reasoning, sometimes known as a ‘bottom
●● Testing. The hypothesis is then tested, using the up’ approach to research because it starts with
same methods and processes – observation or observations, seeks to find a pattern, then offers an
experiment – as the original. If the hypothesis explanation for this before finally developing a theory
(statement or premise) conflicts with what after the explanation has been tested and found to be
actually happens, it does not hold true, the reasonable. It moves from the specific to the general.
prediction was wrong and the hypothesis must The main problem with inductive reasoning is that
be changed. In other words, ‘if the map does not everything can be observed. For example, when
not agree with the ground, the map is wrong’ atoms were first discovered, their existence had to
(Livingston 2006). be assumed or deduced from the facts available to
●● Theory. The hypothesis continues to be tested and
scientists because they could not be observed. This
the results repeated by other scientists. It becomes approach is called deductive reasoning, which is also
a theory or a scientific law (e.g. Boyle’s Law, which based on reason and logical analysis but is the opposite
describes the relationship between the pressure approach from inductive reasoning because it starts
and volume of a gas within a closed system). from a general principle and follows this logically to
To be considered as scientific, investigations must a conclusion. When deductive reasoning is used, a
be objective – that is, not biased against or towards pattern is identified, a tentative explanation or premise
the likely or possible outcome – as this could affect is put forward to explain the pattern and a hypothesis
the way the results are interpreted and lead to wrong is developed to test the theory using a range of
conclusions being drawn. The methods used must be techniques or methodologies, including observation,
capable of producing evidence that can be measured. before conclusions are made. The most famous
practitioner of deductive reasoning (though a fictional
If the findings from a research experiment are valid, character) was Sherlock Holmes. See, for example,
they can be replicated and the results are therefore http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Study_in_Pink.
313
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Different research
methodologies
The social sciences are concerned with human
Figure 10.4 A practitioner of deductive reasoning – beings and the societies they create, so there is
Sherlock Holmes
inevitable overlap with other disciplines, such as
languages, literature, religion and the performing
Deductive reasoning is the approach most used in
arts. Also, some disciplines overlap with one or
the social and behavioural sciences because human
more of the social sciences previously described –
behaviour is complex and the workings of the brain
for example, social work will include elements of
and mind cannot be directly observed.
sociology, psychology and political science.
In order to use deductive reasoning, it is often the
case that you might need some previous knowledge All of these disciplines will have something to say
in order to make sense of different pieces of about children and young people in society – for
information. example, how children were seen and treated at
different times in history (e.g. being seen as small
adults and sent to work); theories of how children
Case Study
Deductive develop and how they are socialised into society (e.g.
reasoning Bowlby’s theory of attachment); and how politics has
influenced children’s lives (e.g. through education
It was a Sunday evening in midsummer and compulsory schooling).
and Sue and Roger were travelling on the
underground, returning from a shopping trip Although the scientific method is difficult to apply to
in west London. When the tube train stopped much social science research, social sciences do apply
at Paddington, a young man got on with a scientific methods, such as experiments or trials, to
rucksack. He was slightly sunburned, had the social investigation. It is interesting to note that the
beginnings of a beard and was wearing shorts, early sociological investigations into how society
hiking boots and a hat decorated with several functions used scientific methods to ensure that
colourful pin badges. He was also carrying their findings were taken seriously and comparable
a large, circular, flat object and had a plastic to scientific experiments in the natural sciences. This
bracelet on his wrist. school of sociological perspective was known as
positivism.
314
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
However, there are difficulties involved in applying learn to swim. The Census is another example of
the scientific method to social research because quantitative methodology. It is usual for governments
it is important when carrying out experiments to invite specialist research or academic organisations
to compare things that are the same – ‘like with to tender (place bids) to undertake such large-scale,
like – to ensure your research has validity. Things population-wide research.
that could affect validity are called variables and
might, when carrying out scientific experiments Qualitative methods
on inanimate objects, include things such as What quantitative approaches cannot shed light
temperature or other physical conditions in which on is the reason why something is as it seems – for
the experiment takes place. example, why there might be more or fewer children
However, people are not inanimate objects; they in two-parent households in some neighbourhoods
are all unique individuals, so when trying to make than others or why some children learn to swim and
comparisons, you cannot compare like with like others do not. This type of information is obtained
– there are many variables. It is therefore very using qualitative methods and is subjective in its
important to consider the differences between people approach. The primary aim of qualitative methods
that could influence the outcome (e.g. age, gender, is to provide a complete and detailed description of
culture and ethnicity). These will be the variables that the research topic; it is often used in social science
could affect the outcome. Social scientists often try research. The researcher is very much concerned
to place people into common groups (e.g. all children with understanding and consequently tends to use
between the age of five and 12 years in school). very different methods of data collection, sometimes
They can then use more defined categories to make even becoming involved in the social area being
comparisons (e.g. all boys aged seven years without studied (ethnography).
siblings, or all primary-school children living with a
single parent). This helps to minimise variability. Mixed methods approach
Sometimes a research project will use both
The social and natural sciences have developed
quantitative and qualitative types of methodology
different methodologies to ensure that the results of
in order to obtain a much broader understanding of
their investigations are scientifically rigorous. There
the issues being studied. For example, a quantitative
are two main methodological approaches to carrying
study might count how many portions of fresh fruit
out research.
children in a group (e.g. a reception class) eat per
week as one measure of a healthy diet. The results
Quantitative methods will be presented in numerical form, such as a
Based on the model used in the natural sciences, graph or pie chart. What this cannot tell you is why
this is the standard method used by most scientific some children eat more fruit than others; however,
disciplines and is concerned mainly with number if you supplemented the survey with interviews
and measurement. The aim is to collect facts to with the children and their parents – a qualitative
see whether a hypothesis can be disproved; it is a approach – you might find the reasons for the
key aspect of the scientific method. Quantitative difference (e.g. cost, personal preference or access to
research tends to focus on numerical measurement shops).
and assessment – how many, how often, etc. – and
therefore it relies mainly on the analysis of statistics. Mixed methods can be useful to discover the
Quantitative approaches have generally been reasons for differences in the data collected through
regarded as the dominant approach to research. An quantitative research and can provide a more
example of a quantitative approach to research might rounded picture. It is important to recognise that the
be a large-scale survey that uses a questionnaire results might be conflicting, however, and further
to identify how many children live in two-parent investigation may be needed. Mixed methods use
households, or how many primary-school children more than one approach, combine more than one
315
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
kind of research data and ask questions that aim to being that this is more likely to be true or real than
both explore and explain the area under study. any theory suggested by an external researcher.
Hence, grounded theory is essentially a method for
Ethnography the collection and analysis of data, with both taking
Ethnography is a qualitative methodology that has its place simultaneously, and ultimately providing a
roots in anthropology. The word comes from ethnos, theory or explanation of the area being studied.
which means folk or people in Greek, and graph,
Grounded theory research starts with the
which is also Greek and refers to writing.
researcher’s area of interest. There is a difference of
It is an interactive approach in which the researcher opinion as to whether a literature search should be
has a central role, living among the research subjects used in order to identify an area of interest – Glaser
and within their culture for several months, in order advised against it, fearing it might unduly influence
to better understand the perspective of the group the way in which the data was analysed, with other
and the issues that are important to them. The aim is people’s research unconsciously influencing the
to understand and explain the world as seen through researcher. Others have suggested a general reading
the eyes of the subject group. It is important that of literature may help narrow the focus, identify
the researcher is honest about their motives and the issues already covered and identify gaps in the
role, and that they are accepted into the group. The existing body of research.
researcher will observe, interact with and participate
The data may be qualitative or quantitative, or a
in the activities of the group, sharing the experience
mixture of the two, and as the data is collected it is
in order to understand and explain it – this is known
coded, which means collecting different pieces of
as participant observation.
information with similar content and allocating a
For research purposes, data is also collected through level of importance to each category of information.
interviews and questioning, taped conversations and For example, if during interviews or questioning,
video, with the researcher keeping detailed notes. many people mentioned the same issue, you could
It is important that the researcher tries to remain reasonably assume it was important to the subject
impartial, even when participating. In some cases, group and would code it accordingly. From the
researchers have ‘gone native’ and actually joined the identification of similar concepts, key issues can
groups they were originally researching. be identified according to their importance, and
grouping these together can generate a theory.
The formats of some popular television shows are
based loosely on this type of research methodology Once the data has been collected and collated (put
– for example, Secret Millionaire, in which individuals in order) and an initial theory has been deduced, it is
wishing to donate money to worthy causes join in with tested using focus groups. Depending on the outcome
charities and communities to see what work they do of the focus group, the theory may be validated
and how a donation could assist their work. Undercover (held as true), gaps in the data may be identified
Boss is similar, in that an owner or senior manager of that require more data or further research, or the
a company spends time in disguise working with the theory may be modified. It is important that the focus
workers in different parts of the company to get a more group is made up of the right people – they must be
rounded picture of how the company is operating and representative (e.g. children and young people whose
what improvements could be made. lives or areas of interest are being studied or those
with specialist knowledge of the area of research).
Grounded theory (Glaser and The key stages in grounded theory research are:
Strauss 1967) ●● Identify research area – brief, general literature
The key feature of this methodology is that the theory search.
is allowed to emerge from the data, the assumption ●● Collect data using a range of methods (tools).
316
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
●● Code the data according to themes, frequency, critical pedagogy, in which children are recognised
importance, etc. as active participants in their own learning and not
●● Write memos and notes detailing the relationship ‘blank slates’ or ‘empty vessels’ to be filled with
between codes. facts and information decided by adults. Friere saw
●● Collate data into concepts and categories. children as actively engaged with shaping their own
●● Develop theory from this and your notes. world and defining their place within it.
●● Test theory using focus groups – at least three are
needed to validate the theory. Action research is a methodology that is used most
●● Collect more data, add/change concepts, modify frequently with communities to support community
theory. development. It works by involving members of the
●● Test again. community as co-researchers, using their knowledge
●● Repeat last two stages until theory is confirmed. and engaging them in interventions that are
intended to promote change and development within
Grounded theory is a mixed method because it can
the community or group. The essential feature is that
use both quantitative and qualitative data. However,
people are involved in the research process, rather
it is usually considered as qualitative because,
than being separate subject matters.
although statistics may be used as part of the data
collected, it does not use statistical methods for Action research can be described as ‘the systematic
analysis and figures are not presented as part of a collection of information that is designed to bring
theoretical explanation for the area of study. about social change’ (Bogdan and Biklen 1992).
1.
Identify
idea
7. 2.
Second Fact
action finding
6.
3.
Amend
Planning
plan
4.
5.
First
Evaluate
action
Figure 10.5 The key stages of action research. Stages 5, 6 and 7 are repeated
until the goal is reached (informed by Kurt Lewin’s change process)
317
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
people, for example, when they feel that their example, blind tasting of foods to identify
community is not meeting their needs. preference, famously used to advertise a
margarine – ‘I can’t believe it’s not butter.’
Activity ●● Single-blind experiment. This is where some
of the facts are withheld from the participants if
In small groups, examine the publication ‘An they would be likely to influence the outcome.
overview of child well-being in rich countries’ from However, the researcher has all the facts.
UNICEF (United Nations Children’s Fund), available ●● Double-blind experiment (randomised,
at www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/rc7_eng.pdf,
and the UK government’s website on ‘Measuring
placebo-controlled, double-blind trial) – this is
national well-being’, available at http://webarchive. commonly used in clinical trials of new drugs.
nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110422103457/http:// Patients are randomly assigned either to the
www.ons.gov.uk/well-being (NB, the content of control group or to the experimental group by
this website is archived and may be available for a the study coordinator (not the researcher) and
limited time only). the treatment they receive is coded so that no
• Identify and list which of the approaches used one knows whether they received the actual
are quantitative and which are qualitative. Which drug or an identical-looking placebo (non-
approach is used most often in each?
active substance) until the experiment is
• Discuss and write down the merits of each completed.
approach for understanding well-being.
There are ethical difficulties in using controlled
experiments as part of research with children and
Data collection tools young people because it is unacceptable to withhold
treatment or interventions from some children – the
There is a range of methods you can use to collect
control group – if they are expected to be effective.
data – facts, figures, statistics, numbers, etc. It is
usual to use several data sources as this gives greater
weight to the findings, providing validity and
Surveys
consistency. However, the methodology you choose A survey is, strictly speaking, a research strategy
will influence the types of data you need. rather than a data collection method. It refers to the
population or group from which the data will be
Controlled experiments collected. For example, you might decide to carry
out a survey of young people in your area to see
These are used primarily during scientific
how many use youth clubs, what they think of them
experiments in order to prevent unintended bias
and what improvements they would like to see. You
affecting the results. There are several aspects to
might decide to survey two year groups in three
controlled experiments:
schools – this would be your sampling frame as it
●● Using a control group. Two groups are chosen, would be broadly representative of all the schools
each having the same characteristics and profile in your area. The size of your sample is important
(e.g. age, sex, economic status) so that they are, – the larger the sample, the more representative
as far as possible, identical. One group is the it is, but large-scale surveys can be expensive
control group and the other is the experimental and time-consuming to carry out. It is important,
group, which is active in the experiment. For however, to consider the number of responses you
example, the experimental group might be given are likely to get; it is not unusual to receive only a
a drug being tested and the control group given a 30 per cent response to questionnaires, so if you
placebo (a non-active substance, such as a sugar need 100 responses, you would need to send out at
pill). least 334 questionnaires (30 per cent of 334 = 100.2),
●● Blind experiment. This is where only the even more if you allow for some to be incomplete or
researcher knows who is participating. For spoiled.
318
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
319
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Once you have put together your questionnaire, it a little more about…’). They are a rich source of data
is a good idea to pilot it with a few members of your and are frequently used in qualitative studies.
target group, but not necessarily your sampling
frame. You want to know, for example: The advantages of semi-structured interviews are that
they allow a relaxed atmosphere and the development
●● Is the wording of the questions clear and explicit? of a relationship between researcher and interviewee,
●● Will they get the desired response? they can be used for telephone interviewing and they
●● Are they in the right order?
allow a lot of data to be collected
●● Are there any gaps?
●● Are the instructions adequate and easy to The disadvantages of semi-structured interviews are
understand? that they can be time-consuming, they require skill
●● Is it clear how the completed questionnaires on the part of the interviewer and they can be more
should be returned? difficult to analyse because not all the data collected
may be relevant.
Interviews
Interviews are extremely useful for obtaining an
Structured interviews
in-depth understanding of issues that are important These have rigid rules and strict protocols in which
to people and obtaining their personal perspective. sometimes the interviewer is required to remain
An interview is basically an organised conversation neutral and disengaged, maintaining the same body
between two people, in which the interviewer asks posture and facial expression for each interview.
questions that aim to understand the interviewee’s They ask the same, closed questions, which must be
point of view and the world as they see it. read as written, and the interviewer should not react
to interviewee responses.
There are several types of interviews, as outlined
below. The advantages of structured interviews are that the
strict protocols minimise unconscious researcher
Unstructured interviews bias, the responses are consistent and easy to analyse
quantitatively and they are useful when looking for
These are open and informal. They tend to be
specific information.
conversational, using open questions but based
around a number of themes or topics, often in the The disadvantages of structured interviews are
form of a checklist. They are qualitative and are often that the information is limited by the questions,
used in ethnography and for case studies. interviewers will only be able to obtain information
that is included in the questions set by the researcher
The main advantage of this type of interview is that
and interviewees may be put off by the formality.
the interviewee is relaxed and likely to be more open.
Interviews are very useful when working with children
The disadvantages of unstructured interviews and young people but care should be taken when
are that they require a degree of skill on the part choosing an interview style to ensure that the child or
of the interviewer, it is more difficult to maintain young person can remain relaxed and untroubled.
consistency in the responses and they are more
difficult to analyse.
Observation
This is one of the most effective methods of data
Semi-structured interviews
collection used in qualitative studies. Observation
These are also fairly informal. While the same open- can be used as an initial exploration to inform
ended questions may be covered, the interviewer is further research – for example, whom to observe,
free to ask additional questions and explore issues when, where and how.
raised by asking for clarification (e.g. ‘just to clarify,
you feel that…’) or for more information (e.g. ‘tell me Types of observation include the following.
320
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
321
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
322
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
323
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
fussiness” in toddlers’. You could then turn this into In research, ethics are crucial to avoid researchers
a null hypothesis and aim to test it. intentionally or unintentionally exploiting research
subjects and participants. They aim to ‘embed the
Clearly in this example, you would be working with principles of justice, respect and avoidance of harm
parents and it is a sensitive area, so you would need into research by using agreed standards’ (Morrow
to ensure that your plan was ethical and feasible. The 2009).
results of your research could help you develop a plan
for helping such children in the childcare setting. By taking an ethical approach to your research, you
are aiming to balance the interests of children and
The aim of your research should be to improve your young people with the goals of the research project.
practice for the benefit of the children or young You can only do this by building trust between the
people you work with. participants and the researcher/s.
324
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
example, where children or young people are being sensitive areas such as drug use, teenage pregnancy,
observed unknowingly. gang culture, sexual habits, youth crime, etc. can
stigmatise whole groups of young people, leaving
Independence them with feelings of embarrassment, humiliation
You should be able to demonstrate that you are and anger. You need to be careful that you are not
acting independently and have no conflict of interest making assumptions about all young people based
– that is, that you are not going to gain in any way, on a sample group.
whatever the outcome of the research.
Child protection
Non-discrimination You must follow the requirements, procedures and
You must make sure that you treat everyone protocols for protecting children according to the
involved with your research project fairly and organisation in which you are working. If you are
equally. This means being aware of power interviewing or observing children outside the
relationships, especially between children and boundaries of organisational rules, you must make
young people and the adults involved in the project. sure you put in place arrangements for protecting
For example, adults may make assumptions about and safeguarding children and make parents,
children’s experience, competence and capability, children and young people and other participants
knowledge and understanding, depending on aware of these protocols.
their age and ability/disability. As a researcher, Ethics should inform the whole of your approach to
you should not let any assumptions you may hold research, including your choice of methodology.
influence the research – it is safer to assume ability
and competence until proven otherwise and you
may want to do a small pilot of your methodology to Developing your
check this.
research plan
Confidentiality Once you have decided on your area of research,
As you will be collecting information for and about you need an action plan so that you can undertake
individuals, it is crucial that you are able to keep it your research in an orderly and systematic way –
confidential. You must be clear to participants about for example, by setting out a time frame. When
how you will use their information and who will developing your research (action) plan, you need to
have access to it. You must be able to ensure the state who will be involved and what each person’s
confidentiality of information and also be aware of role is if you are not working alone. It is sometimes
the requirements of the Data Protection Act. This helpful to divide the project into stages. For
will mean making arrangements to store your data example:
securely, including any audio or video recordings. ●● Stage 1: the preliminary stage is usually the
You must also ensure that children and young people collection of secondary data, such as statistics and/
cannot be identified and, if video is used, parental or a literature search. It can be helpful to write
consent must be obtained. down the aims of this first stage (e.g. to identify a
research topic and inform your hypothesis).
Respect ●● Stage 2: this might be to identify your sampling
You need to demonstrate that you are respecting frame – who are you going to approach and who
children and young people and their privacy, do you need permission from?
ensuring that by undertaking your research you do ●● Stage 3: this might identify the steps in the data
no harm – physical or emotional. This is especially collection process – for example, developing
relevant if your research is to be published and in questionnaires and how you will carry out any
the public domain. For example, some research in interviews.
325
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● Stage 4: this section should outline how you will and you will need sufficient evidence to do this.
collect, analyse and store data, including the You may choose to use mixed methods, examining
methods of analysis you will use and how you will existing statistics and following this up with
maintain confidentiality. interviews or questionnaires.
●● Stage 5: this should cover how you will present
your results – for example, will it be a presentation Rationale for chosen
or a written report?
methodology
When drawing up your plan, you should take
an ethical approach and think about the ethical The rationale for your research should show why
implications of implementing your plan. You should you have chosen your particular methodology and
be able to say how you have embedded ethics into data collection tools and why other approaches were
your project when you write up the final report or unsuitable. You should aim to show clearly how it
present your findings. will improve your practice.
Create
hypothesis
Draw conclusions for Identify how
hypothesis based on to validate
data analysis hypothesis
Data
Review and
collection
analyse data
plan
326
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
to keep a diary (audio or written) to help you ●● Introduction, background and objectives – an
remember. explanation of the aims of and rationale for the
research and choice of methodology.
Gathering and ●● The methodology – how the research was carried
out. You would include your literature search
recording research data here, how you developed your hypothesis, etc.,
what interventions were carried out and the
This aspect involves gathering in questionnaires,
types of methods used to collect the data (e.g.
interview responses, and facts and figures gleaned
questionnaires).
from both primary and secondary research, and
●● The sample size – this should include eligibility
then grouping the responses together into categories
criteria, setting and locations. For example, how
or issues raised in order to analyse them. You
participants were recruited and where the research
need to make sure you have a system for keeping
took place.
records.
●● Control for variables – identifying things
that could affect the objectivity of the outcome
Section 6: Present data in (including researcher bias) and how these were
managed: for example, by having clear criteria for
relation to the hypothesis participants and randomly selecting them to either
There are agreed criteria for scientific research, a control group or an active group.
●● Implementation – how the research was carried
known as the CONSORT (Consolidated Standards
of Reporting Trials) statement, which is an evidence- out and by whom. For example, how children and
based set of minimum recommendations offering young people were included and involved in the
a standardised way of reporting randomised implementation.
●● Statistical methods – how the data was analysed,
controlled trials (RCTs). The aim of such standards
is to prevent problems arising from poor trial design, the significance of the statistical results and what
analysis and interpretation. Although the CONSORT this means (this will be explored further when we
criteria focus mainly on clinical trials (medical and look at presenting data).
●● Results – what conclusions can be drawn from
pharmaceutical research), the guidelines can equally
apply to all types of research. the results and how can they be used? You might
include some recommendations – these might
The CONSORT Statement is intended to improve even be for further research if your results were
the reporting of a randomized controlled trial inconclusive.
(RCT), enabling readers to understand a trial’s ●● Bibliography and references – it is crucial to name
design, conduct, analysis and interpretation, and your sources to avoid any charge of plagiarism.
to assess the validity of its results. It emphasizes
that this can only be achieved through complete
transparency from authors.
Methods of analysing
www.consort-statement.org
data
This will depend on the methodology used.
CONSORT includes broad criteria covering how Quantitative methods require analysis of the
aspects of research should be reported, so these are numbers. There are software packages that can be
helpful to use as a basis for thinking about how to used to analyse large amounts of numerical data (e.g.
write a report of your findings. For example: SPSS – Statistical Package for the Social Sciences)
●● Title and abstract – this is a summary of the and which provide statistical analysis. However,
research and findings, rather like an executive it is also possible to collate data using an Excel
summary. spreadsheet or similar standard computer program.
327
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
It is important to have some understanding this by selecting ‘Insert Function’ and one of the
of statistics to be able to examine and assess following:
quantitative data. Statistical methods can be applied ●● For the Mean function, choose AVERAGE
to data in order to analyse and interpret it. Some
(starting cell : ending cell).
examples that can be used to understand numerical ●● For the Median, choose MEDIAN (starting cell :
data include the following:
ending cell).
●● Mean – this is the average. You can work out ●● For the Mode, choose MODE (starting cell :
the mean by dividing the total sum of the ending cell).
figures (number of sweets) by the number of ●● For the Standard Deviation, choose STDEV
individual representations (number of children). (starting cell : ending cell).
See Table 10.2.
Interpreting your data
Number of sweets each
child has Interpreting statistics can be fraught with
problems, mainly because when looking at
Chloe 6
reported statistics we often do not have the full
Jack 4
information to make a judgment. For example, see
Bethany 8 the following article:
Joe 2
www.guardian.co.uk/science/blog/2010/sep/29/
Alice 5
statistics-lies-abuse.
Total number of sweets = 25
Total number of children = 5 Once you have your information, you have to be
Mean value of sweets = 25 divided by 5 = 5 able to interpret your data and understand what
might be statistically significant. This just means
Table 10.2 Working out the mean
that any difference has not happened by chance. It is
important to recognise that, with a large sample size,
●● Median – this is the middle value in a list or data small differences will show up but they may not be
set. In the example above, the numbers are 2, 4, 5, important.
6, 8, so the middle value is 5.
●● Mode – this is the number occurring most
frequently. In the example shown, there is no
Drawing conclusions
mode as all the numbers are different. Once you have analysed your data, you can draw
●● Standard deviation – this shows how close the conclusions by comparing various aspects of the
whole data set (number of sweets) is to the average information – using percentages, for example.
(mean) value – in this example, 5. A data set with a
small standard deviation has data within a narrow
range, whereas a data set with a large standard
Activity
deviation has data spread out over a wide range of Examine the information presented on the height of
values. boys aged between 11 and 18 years in Figures 10.7
●● Range – this is simply the highest value and the and 10.8.
lowest value; in the example above, this is the • Write down all the facts you can about how boys
difference between 2 and 8 = 6. grow over this period.
• State three things you can deduce from the
Microsoft Excel has built-in functions to analyse information.
a set of data for all these values. You can use
328
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
Age
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
1.2 1
1.25 3 1
1.3 8 1 1 1
1.35 11 4 2 1
1.4 13 7 3 1 1 1 1
1.45 9 12 6 3 1 1 1 1
1.5 6 11 10 7 2 3 2 1
Height 1.55 4 11 11 10 5 5 4 4
1.6 3 7 11 13 10 8 5 5
1.65 1 3 7 11 12 9 9 6
1.7 1 1 4 7 11 12 12 10
1.75 1 3 3 8 10 10 11
1.8 1 1 1 4 6 8 11
1.85 1 1 3 3 4 5
1.9 1 2 1 2 4
1.95 1 1 1 1
2 1 1
Age 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Mean 1.413 1.502 1.563 1.601 1.677 1.681 1.689 1.732
Median 1.450 1.525 1.575 1.600 1.675 1.675 1.700 1.775
Mode 1 1.400 1.450 1.550 1.600 1.650 1.700 1.700 1.750
Mode 2 1.600 1.800
Making young people use youth clubs and find out from
research that the youth clubs are poorly used (from
recommendations your quantitative data) but that the activities on offer
do not appeal to young people (from your qualitative
Recommendations will very much depend on the data), you may recommend that young people are
rationale for your research. If you have undertaken a consulted and involved in upgrading the existing
project aimed at identifying an issue of importance facilities. You may recommend that more research
to children and young people, you should be able is carried out to find out what sort of facilities
to use the conclusions from your research to make would attract more young people. A piece of action
some recommendations on how the issue could be research would involve children and young people
addressed. For example, if you researched how many in community-led change – perhaps to raise funding
329
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
14
10
0
1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2
Height in metres
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
1.9
1.8
Height in metres
1.7
1.6
1.5
1.4
1.3
1.2
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Number of boys in sample at each height
330
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
See Figures 10.7, 10.8 and 10.9 for examples of how and be honest about this in your report. You may
data can be presented. suggest that further research is necessary.
331
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Useful resources
332
Chapter 10 Research to support practice when working with children and/or young people (Unit CP 10)
Books
Bogdan, R. and Biklen, S. K. (1992) Qualitative research for education, Boston: Allyn and Bacon.
Denscombe, M. (2010) The good research guide for small-scale social research projects, 4th edition,
Buckingham: Open University Press.
Glaser, B.G. and Strauss, A.L. (1967) The discovery of Grounded Theory: strategies for qualitative
research, Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company.
Goldacre, B. (2008) Bad science, London: Fourth Estate.
Livingston, G. (2006) Too soon old, too late smart, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Morrow, V. (2009) ‘The ethics of social research with children and families in young lives: practical
experiences’, Working paper no. 53, Oxford: Young Lives.
333
This page intentionally left blank
Section 2
Optional units
The aim of this chapter is to enable the learner to However, schools (and other settings working
support children and/or young people’s development with children and/or young people) are facing
of art, drama and music. problems of curriculum overload. The changing
nature of society means that schools are under
immense pressure to ensure that young people
Learning outcomes have the necessary knowledge and skills for
1. Understand art, drama and music adult life (for example, languages, information
development when working with technology, citizenship, drugs education and
children and/or young people. sexual health). Some countries (e.g. England)
place a greater emphasis on developing the
2. Understand learning needs of
individual children and/or young basic skills of literacy and numeracy, and this
people when supporting the has led to pressures on the balance between
development of art, drama and compulsory and elective subjects as well as the
music. content and organisation of the arts within the
3. Be able to plan and implement art, curriculum. Some of the important features
drama and music activities for of a curriculum that are beneficial to high-
children and/or young people. quality learning experiences in the arts include
a strong focus on three principles of entitlement,
4. Be able to reflect on own practice.
openness and flexibility. (Sharp and Le Métais
2000, p. 10)
working with children out of interest and are usually well motivated (e.g.
art groups, choirs, orchestras, drama clubs and
and/or young people theatre trips). Arts activities should encourage
openness and flexibility, regardless of whether
The study and experience of art, drama and music they take place during or outside school hours. The
are universally considered to be an indispensable challenge is to provide children and young people
part of a well-rounded education. Art, drama and with an arts experience of sufficient depth and
music form part of the compulsory curriculum up to quality, of relevance to their lives and which they
the end of the lower secondary stage (at about 14–16 find enjoyable and stimulating. This has to happen
years of age) and then are usually offered as elective within an environment that values the arts and
subjects for upper secondary students. (Sharp and Le celebrates their contribution to society. (Sharp and
Métais 2000, p. 5) Le Métais 2000, p. 11)
336
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
the curriculum frameworks for education are the and feelings by using a widening range of
Early Years Foundation Stage (0–5 years) and the materials, suitable tools, imaginative and role play,
National Curriculum Key Stages 1 to 4 (5–16 years). movement, designing and making, and a variety
of songs and musical instruments.
●● Explore colour, texture, shape, form and space in
The Early Years Foundation
two or three dimensions.
Stage ●● Recognise and explore how sounds can be
The Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS) is the changed, sing simple songs from memory,
statutory framework that sets the standards for the recognise repeated sounds and sound patterns
care, development and learning of children from and match movements to music.
birth to five years old. Orders and regulations under ●● Use their imagination in art and design, music,
section 39 of the Childcare Act 2006 brought the dance, imaginative and role play and stories.
EYFS into force in September 2008. This framework
(DCSF 2008)
includes six areas covered by the early learning goals
and educational programmes. None of these areas
The 2012 Early Years Foundation Stage
can be delivered in isolation from the others. They
are equally important and depend on each other to On 6 July, a revised draft EYFS framework was
support a rounded approach to child development. issued for consultation, taking forward Dame Clare
All the areas must be delivered through planned, Tickell’s proposals for reform: reducing paperwork
purposeful play, with a balance of adult-led and and bureaucracy for professionals; focusing strongly
child-initiated activities (DCSF 2008). on the three prime areas of learning most essential for
children’s healthy development and future learning
The six areas of learning and development are: (with four specific areas in which the prime areas are
applied); simplifying assessment at age five, including to
●● personal, social and emotional development
reduce the early learning goals (ELGs) from 69 to 17; and
●● communication, language and literacy
providing for earlier intervention for those children who
●● problem solving, reasoning and numeracy
need extra help, through the introduction of a progress
●● knowledge and understanding of the world
check when children are aged two (DfE 2011, p. 1).
●● physical development
●● creative development.
This revised EYFS was published on 27 March 2012
and will be implemented from September 2012.
Creative development in the EYFS (The 2008 EYFS will continue to be in force until
Art, drama and music are included within creative 31 August 2012.) There are seven areas of learning
development within the EYFS. Children’s creativity and development that must shape educational
must be extended by the provision of support for programmes in early years settings. Three areas are
their curiosity, exploration and play. They must be particularly important for igniting young children’s
provided with opportunities to explore and share curiosity and enthusiasm for learning, and for
337
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
building their capacity to learn and to thrive. These The National Curriculum in
three areas, known as the prime areas, are:
England
●● personal, social and emotional development
The National Curriculum sets out the statutory
●● physical development
requirements for the knowledge and skills that every
●● communication and language.
child is expected to learn in schools. The National
Early years providers must also support young Curriculum applies to children of compulsory school
children in four specific areas of learning and age in schools in England. The National Curriculum
development, through which the three prime areas sets out what pupils should study, what they should
are strengthened and applied. The specific areas are: be taught and the standards that they should
literacy; mathematics; understanding the world; and achieve. It is divided into four key stages:
expressive arts and design. ●● Key Stage 1: Year groups 1 and 2 (5–7-year-olds)
●● Key Stage 2: Year groups 3, 4, 5 and 6 (7–11-year-
Expressive arts and design in the
olds)
revised EYFS ●● Key Stage 3: Year groups 7, 8 and 9 (11–14-year-
Expressive arts and design involve enabling children
olds)
to explore and play with a wide range of media and
●● Key Stage 4: Year groups 10 and 11 (14–16-year-
materials, as well as providing opportunities and
olds).
encouragement for sharing their thoughts, ideas
and feelings through a variety of activities in art, In Key Stages 1 and 2 of the National Curriculum,
music, movement, dance, role play, and design and the compulsory subjects consist of: English;
technology (DfE 2012, p. 5). mathematics; science; information and
communication technology; design and technology;
By the end of the EYFS, children should have achieved
history; geography; art and design; music; and
these early learning goals in expressive arts and design:
physical education.
●● Explore and use media and materials: sing
songs, make music and dance, and experiment In Key Stage 3, the compulsory subjects are:
with ways of changing them; safely use English; mathematics; science; information and
and explore a variety of materials, tools and communication technology; design and technology;
techniques, experimenting with colour, design, history; geography; art and design; music; physical
texture, form and function. education; citizenship; and modern foreign
●● Be imaginative: use what they have learnt about languages.
media and materials in original ways, thinking
In Key Stage 4, the compulsory subjects are:
about uses and purposes; represent their own
English; mathematics; science; information and
ideas, thoughts and feelings through design and
communication technology; physical education;
technology, art, music, dance, role play and stories.
and citizenship. Secondary schools must make
(DfE 2012, p. 9) entitlement curriculum areas (e.g. the arts, design
and technology, the humanities and modern
(For detailed information about the EYFS, see foreign languages) available to all students who
Chapter 13.) wish to study them. In addition, there is a statutory
requirement for work-related learning and a non-
ity
Research Activ statutory framework setting out the minimum
experience that schools should provide for work-
Find out more about art, drama and music in the
EYFS. For example, have a look at The Foundation related learning. In January 2011, the Secretary
Years website: www.foundationyears.org.uk. of State for Education announced a review of the
National Curriculum in England. While the review
338
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
is being conducted, the existing National Curriculum ●● begin to understand colour, shape and space and
requirements for both primary and secondary pattern and texture, and use them to represent
schools will remain in force. (Detailed information is their ideas and feelings.
given in Chapter 13.)
(DfE 2011)
Art in the primary years In Key Stage 2, the curriculum should provide
opportunities for pupils to:
In the primary years, supporting children’s
development in art should ensure that ‘investigating ●● develop their creativity and imagination through
and making’ include ‘exploring and developing ideas’ more complex activities
and ‘evaluating and developing work’. ‘Knowledge ●● build on their skills and improve their control of
and understanding’ should inform this process. materials, tools and techniques
●● increase their critical awareness of the roles and
In Key Stage 1, the curriculum should provide purposes of art, craft and design in different times
opportunities for pupils to: and cultures
●● become more confident in using visual and
●● develop their creativity and imagination by
exploring the visual, tactile and sensory qualities tactile elements and materials and processes
of materials and processes to communicate what they see, feel and
●● learn about the role of art, craft and design in their think.
environment (DfE 2011)
339
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
340
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
341
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
own and others’ performances; watch live processes and content of the subject. As part of the
performances in the theatre wherever possible key processes for ‘speaking and listening’ in English,
to appreciate how action, character, atmosphere, students should be able to:
tension and themes are conveyed; participate
●● use a range of dramatic approaches to explore
actively in drama workshops and discuss with
complex ideas, texts and issues in scripted and
actors, playwrights, directors and other drama
improvised work
professionals the impact and meaning of
●● select different dramatic techniques to convey
different ways of performing and staging drama,
action, character, atmosphere and tension, and
wherever possible. As part of the key processes
justify choices
for ‘speaking and listening’ in English, students
●● evaluate drama performances that they have
should be able to:
watched or taken part in.
●● use different dramatic approaches to explore ideas,
(DfE 2011)
texts and issues
●● use different dramatic techniques to convey action,
In addition to drama being included as part of the
character, atmosphere and tension English curriculum, which is compulsory until age
●● explore the ways that words, actions, sound
16, students may opt to study drama as an elective
and staging combine to create dramatic subject depending on what is available in their
moments. school – for example, GCSE Drama.
(DfE 2011)
Drama choices for 16–18-year-olds in England
In Key Stage 4, the curriculum should provide include continuing in full-time education, either
opportunities for students to: evaluate and at school/college through studying for academic
respond constructively to their own and others’ qualifications such as AS or A levels (e.g. drama
performances; watch live performances in the and theatre studies, film studies) or vocational
theatre wherever possible and consider how action, qualifications (e.g. BTEC Diplomas in drama,
character, atmosphere, tension and themes are performing arts, production arts). Selected colleges
conveyed that are integral to their learning and also offer the Diploma qualification for 14–19-year-
enhance their engagement with the concepts, olds (e.g. Creative and Media).
342
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
Find out more about drama in Key Stage 3, Key ●● listen carefully and respond physically to a wide
Stage 4 and beyond. For example, have a look at range of music
the following Department for Education web pages: ●● play musical instruments and sing a variety of
343
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
344
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
ity
Research Activ Northern Ireland
The revised Northern Ireland Curriculum was
Find out more about music in Key Stage 3, Key introduced in September 2007. The Northern Ireland
Stage 4 and beyond. For example, have a look
Curriculum sets out the minimum requirements
at the following Department for Education web
pages: that should be taught at each key stage while giving
practitioners the flexibility to provide a broad and
• Music in secondary schools: www.education.
balanced curriculum that meets children’s individual
gov.uk/schools/teachingandlearning/curriculum/
secondary/b00199601/music needs with opportunities for every child to experience
success in learning in order to achieve as high a
• GCSEs: www.education.gov.uk/schools/
standard as possible. The primary phase consists of:
teachingandlearning/qualifications/gcses
• The 14 to 19 Diploma: www.education.gov.uk/ ●● The Foundation Stage: Years 1 and 2 (4–6-year-olds)
a0064416/what-is-the-diploma. ●● Key Stage 1: Years 3 and 4 (6–8-year-olds)
●● Key Stage 2: Years 5, 6 and 7 (8–11-year-olds).
345
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The secondary phase consists of: the most disadvantaged communities in Wales. It
aims to create positive outcomes in the medium
●● Key Stage 3: Years 8, 9 and 10 (11–14-year-olds)
●● Key Stage 4: Years 11 and 12 (14–16-year-olds).
and long term. It is a prescriptive programme,
based on international evidence of what works.
The relevant section of the curriculum is the Area For more information, see: http://wales.gov.uk/
of Learning entitled ‘The Arts’, which includes topics/childrenyoungpeople/parenting/help/
art and design, music and drama. (More detailed flyingstart/?lang=en.
information about curriculum frameworks in
In Wales, the revised school curriculum for 3 to
Northern Ireland is given in Chapter 13.)
19-year-olds has been implemented since September
2008. This includes:
Scotland
In Scotland, the national guidance ‘Pre-Birth to ●● The Foundation Phase: Nursery, Reception and
Three: Positive Outcomes for Scotland’s Children and Years 1 and 2 (3–7-year-olds)
●● Key Stage 2: Years 3, 4, 5 and 6 (7–11-year-olds)
Families’ replaces ‘Birth to Three: Supporting our
●● Key Stage 3: Years 7, 8 and 9 (11–14-year-olds)
Youngest Children’. It includes important information
●● Key Stage 4: Years 10 and 11 (14–16-year-olds).
on pre-birth and brain development and it reflects the
principles and philosophy which underpin the Early
(More detailed information about curriculum
Years Framework and Curriculum for Excellence.
frameworks in Wales is given in Chapter 13.)
For more information, visit: www.ltscotland.org.uk/
earlyyears/prebirthtothree/index.asp.
ity
The curriculum in Scotland has been under review
Research Activ
and, from August 2010, all schools are expected Find out more about the curriculum frameworks for
to adopt the new ‘Curriculum for Excellence’. The art, drama and music in Northern Ireland, Scotland
Curriculum for Excellence is Scotland’s curriculum or Wales. For example, have a look at the following:
for children and young people aged 3 to 18, which • Northern Ireland Curriculum website: www.
replaces ‘A Curriculum Framework for Children 3 nicurriculum.org.uk/
to 5’ and the ‘5–14 Curriculum’. The Curriculum for • Curriculum for Excellence website: www.
Excellence includes: ltscotland.org.uk/curriculumforexcellence/
curriculumoverview/index.asp
●● Early Level: Nursery and P1 (3–6 years)
●● First Level: P2, P3 and P4 (5–9 years) • Welsh Government website: http:/wales.gov.
uk/topics/educationandskills/schoolshome/
●● Second Level: P5, P6 and P7 (8–12 years)
curriculuminwales/arevisedcurriculumforwales/?l
●● Third and Fourth Level: S1, S2 and S3 (11–15 years)
ang=en.
●● Senior Phase: S4, S5 and S6 (14–18 years).
346
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
learning to take place in exciting and challenging and then gradually through imaginative play (e.g.
ways. To develop into healthy, considerate and pretend play or role play). As children explore their
intelligent adults, all children and young people environment and find out what objects and materials
require intellectual stimulation as well as physical can do, they use their imagination to increase their
care and emotional security. Intellectual stimulation understanding of the world and their role within it.
through play and other learning opportunities allows For example, through imaginative play, children can
children and young people to develop their cognitive become other people by dressing up and behaving
abilities and fulfil their potential as individuals. like them. Imaginative play assists the development
of children’s imagination through activities such as
The children and/or young people you work with will dressing up, small-scale toys, doll play, shop play and
be constantly thinking and learning (e.g. gathering hospital play.
new information and formulating new ideas about
themselves, other people and the world around Creativity is the use of the imagination in a wide
them). When supporting the development of art, variety of activities, including play, art, design
drama and music skills, you should provide children technology, music, dance, drama, stories and poetry.
and/or young people with opportunities to: Children can express their creativity through creative
activities such as painting, drawing, collage, play
●● explore their environment and/or investigate new
dough, clay, cooking, design and model making.
information/ideas
Creativity involves a process rather than an end
●● discover things for themselves through a wide
product. It cannot be measured by the end result
variety of experiences
of an activity, but is based upon how the child
●● feel free to make mistakes in a safe and secure
works and why. Creativity involves: exploring and
environment using ‘trial and error’
experimenting with a wide range of materials;
●● develop autonomy through increased
learning about the properties of materials (e.g.
responsibility and working independently colour, shape, size and texture); developing fine
●● encourage and extend their knowledge and skills
motor skills to manipulate materials; developing
with appropriate support from adults (and other problem-solving techniques; and developing an
children/young people) understanding of the world and our personal
●● learn to make sense of new information within an
contribution to it.
appropriate curriculum framework.
Key terms
Developing imagination and
Creativity – the use of the imagination in a wide variety
creativity of activities, including play, art, design technology,
music, dance, drama, stories and poetry.
Imagination involves the individual’s ability to invent
ideas or to form images. Children express their Imagination – the individual’s ability to invent ideas or
to form images.
imagination through imitative play to begin with
1. Painting with brushes, sponges, string; finger reels) and pattern making (e.g. with rollers,
painting, bubble painting, ‘butterfly’ or ‘blob’ stamps).
painting, marble painting, wax resist painting; 2. Drawing using pencils, crayons, felt tips or
printing (e.g. with leaves, potatoes, cotton chalks on a variety of materials, including
347
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
different kinds of paper, card, fabric and biscuits, making sandwiches or peppermint
wood. Include colouring activities linked creams.
to the children’s interests by drawing your
7. Making music can provide opportunities
own colouring sheets, buying ready-made
for children to explore different sounds
colouring books or using free printable
and to experiment freely with the musical
colouring pages from the internet.
instruments. Provide a portable box/trolley
3. Model making using commercial construction with a range of percussion instruments,
kits (e.g. Lego Explore, Mega Bloks or Stickle including: drum, tambourine, castanets,
Bricks), wooden blocks or clean and safe ‘junk’ wood blocks, shakers, bell stick, Indian bells,
materials to enable children to create their triangle, xylophone and chime bars.
own designs.
8. Water play with plain, bubbly, coloured, warm
4. Collage using glue and interesting materials or cold water helps children learn about the
to create pictures involving different textures, properties of water (e.g. it pours, splashes,
colours and shapes, and provide an enjoyable runs, soaks). Provide small containers to fill
sensory experience too. and empty, as well as a sieve and funnel.
5. Clay, play dough and plasticine can be used 9. Sand play provides opportunities for exploring
creatively; they are tactile too. the properties of sand (e.g. wet sand sticks
together and can be moulded, while dry
6. Cooking provides a similar experience to
sand does not stick and can be poured). Use
working with play dough or clay, except that
‘washed’ or ‘silver’ sand (not builder’s sand,
the end product is (usually) edible. Remember
which might contain cement). Provide small
to include ‘no cook’ activities, such as icing
containers, buckets, sieves and funnels.
(There is more detailed information on creativity in for spontaneous painting and drawing, undirected
Unit CYPOP7 of CACHE Level 3 Diploma Children by adults. Children should be offered frequent
and Young People’s Workforce: Early Learning and Child opportunities to paint and draw when they feel like
Care, available at www.hoddereducation/cache.) it. For very young children especially, spontaneous
painting and drawing are a valuable means of
Activity expression. The benefit of children being able to
express themselves in this way is reduced if adults
1 Give an example of an activity (one each for art, insist on questioning children about their paintings
drama and music) which encourages a group or drawings, suggesting additions to the work and
of children to express themselves freely in an wanting titles for every painting or drawing (Hobart
imaginative and creative way. and Frankel 2009, p. 71).
2 Suggest ways to support the development of
children’s imagination and creativity. Children and young people also need opportunities
to engage in art activities, which are generally adult
directed. Children and young people should be allowed
Supporting the development to use their own ideas, even when following adult-
directed activities. Art activities will help to stimulate
of art skills
children’s imagination and an aesthetic awareness.
Supporting the development of art skills in children
Art activities encourage children’s creativity as well
and young people includes providing opportunities
as their social development by sharing materials
348
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
and turn-taking, learning about the properties of an adult supervising, and sometimes the whole class
various materials and developing language skills as is involved as part of a theme that is being explored,
the children have to understand instructions and ask providing links to other areas of the curriculum
questions. Children usually work in small groups with (Hobart and Frankel 2009, p. 77).
349
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Understanding children’s paintings and their use has declined. Research also shows
that some children with cognitive and language
and drawings difficulties (e.g. children on the autistic spectrum)
Adult interpretations of children’s paintings and have exceptional drawing abilities, perhaps
drawings may often be incorrect. Most children love because this is their only means of self-expression
to do all dark, one-colour paintings at some stage in (Kamen 2000, p. 123).
their development. This does not necessarily mean
that something terrible has happened to them that Children’s drawings (and paintings) are also used
they wish to forget! However, understanding what as a way to assess young children’s emotional
stage of development children might have reached development. For example, preoccupation with
by interpreting their paintings and drawings is the use of black may be seen as a warning sign of
interesting (Hobart and Frankel 2009, p. 71). emotional trauma but could equally be a reflection
of the child’s interest in exploring dark colours, and
Children’s paintings and drawings are often used nothing more sinister. Similarly, anatomically correct
as indicators of children’s intellectual abilities. drawings of people do not necessarily indicate that
For example, intelligence tests such as Florence a child is being sexually abused; they may have seen
Goodenough’s ‘draw-a-man’ test (1926), and the people in quite natural situations (e.g. bath time or
updated test of drawing a man, woman and self getting dressed). We need instead to look at what
by Dale Harris (1963) had been used to measure children mean to express through their drawings and
children’s intelligence according to the presence of paintings, rather than use adult interpretations of
set criteria (e.g. head, mouth, fingers, etc.): the more their creative activities. This is easier once children
detailed the drawings, the more intelligent the child have language to express their ideas verbally as
(Kamen 2000, p. 122). well as pictorially, but it is more difficult with
babies, toddlers and children with communication
The difficulty with this is that children’s drawing
difficulties (Kamen 2000, p. 123).
and painting abilities depend on a number of factors,
such as: Another factor to consider is that Western society
does not place much importance on the teaching of
●● physical ability, e.g. fine motor skills in holding
drawing or painting. Especially for young children,
and using a pencil, crayon or brush
the emphasis is on allowing children to develop
●● opportunities for mark making
their drawing and painting skills in their own
●● interest in drawing and painting activities
way. Children do not see many adults drawing
●● concentration levels
and painting, unless they receive a Rudolf Steiner
●● visual input from books, television, displays,
education, where specific artistic techniques are taught
posters
from five years old upwards (Kamen 2000, p. 123).
●● the teaching of drawing and painting skills
●● adult reactions to children’s artistic attempts.
None of these factors is related to IQ (intelligence Find out more about teaching children to draw and/
or paint. For example, have a look at Rudolf Steiner
quotient). Children can demonstrate obvious
education, where drawing is an integral part of
intelligence in other ways (e.g. reading ability children and young people’s learning, including their
and comprehension skills), but fail to complete academic studies: www.steinerwaldorf.org. This
the drawing of a recognisable person with the website includes the 2010 ITN short film The Gift
detail expected from a child of their particular of Learning, which shows how art, music, play and
age. The validity of such tests has been challenged active learning are central to the curriculum: www.
steinerwaldorf.org/thegiftoflearningdvd.html.
350
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
The National Curriculum has promoted the idea Drawing is often seen as children’s first attempts
of introducing young children to the work of at writing. While the same skills (e.g. hand–eye
famous artists, such as Van Gogh and Monet, and coordination and pencil control) are required for
encouraging children to try out different artistic both, drawing and writing are actually two distinct
techniques. The results have been surprising; activities. Writing is speech written down, while
children have produced paintings with detail drawing is an individual’s pictorial representation
far exceeding the children’s usual artistic output of their world. Both activities do involve the use of
(Kamen 2000, p. 123). symbols. The simplistic and stylised nature of
young children’s drawings shows more about
You may have noticed that if an adult draws or their use of drawing rather than their cognitive
paints alongside the children in your setting and abilities or drawing skills. Young children use their
talks about what they are all doing, the detail in drawings to convey meaning in the same way as
the children’s drawings or paintings increases quite they will later use words – for example, a young
markedly. The process of drawing or painting, and child’s drawing is a pictorial symbol for ‘bird’ in
the context in which the art activity takes place, is as the same way as the written word bird (Kamen
important as the drawing/painting itself – that is, the 2000, p. 124).
end product (Kamen 2000, p. 124).
351
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
From the age of seven years, visual realism world around them and their relationship to it.
becomes more important as children’s Limitations for this expression are imposed by
understanding of the function of drawings the medium used (e.g. crayons or paints) and the
changes. Through drawing and painting, children ability to translate 3D objects into the images.
express themselves, their understanding of the For example, even adults have problems with
perspective in drawings/paintings and plans or
maps rely on symbolic representation rather than
realism.
18 • Cannot lift crayon off paper, draws round and round in circular
months movements.
to 2 • Very limited control of stroke direction.
years
• Explores sensation of paint textures, rather than creating
pictures.
• Imitates adults’ and other children’s artistic efforts.
352
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
Figure 11.11 The development of young children’s drawings and paintings (images A, D, E and F reproduced from Understanding
Children’s Drawings: Tracing the Path of Incarnation by Michaela Strauss, published by Rudolf Steiner Press, 2007)
353
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Activity
1 Observe a child drawing or painting a picture of a person.
2 In your assessment, comment on the child’s: imaginative/creative skills; concentration level; use of colour;
and fine motor skills (e.g. pencil or brush control). You might also consider the emotional value of the activity.
3 Compare to the usual pattern of development for drawing/painting for a child of this age. See Figure 11.11
and the timeline of drawing development in children aged 2 years to 16 years available online: www.
learningdesign.com/Portfolio/DrawDev/kiddrawing.html#anchor2480790.
1. Provide lots of paper, crayons and pencils. attention to detail (e.g. self-portraits,
Chunky crayons and thick-stemmed pencils drawing pictures of their own models and
are best for young children. still life such as flowers, fruit and toys).
2. Encourage children to hold the pencil/crayon 7. Provide variety in drawing and painting
as best they can. They will control these activities by offering different materials,
better with a grip about two centimetres tools and techniques (e.g. chalks, pastels,
from the point. charcoal, felt tips; sponges, different-sized
brushes, rollers; different-sized paper,
3. Keep drawing sessions short. Be guided by
shaped paper, different textures).
the child’s interest and concentration. A
child’s first attempt is usually their best, so 8. Provide plenty of interesting experiences,
do not ask them to do a picture over and including outings to provide stimuli for
over to get a better copy. drawing and painting activities.
4. Let the children in your setting see you 9. Provide opportunities for children to see and
drawing and painting. appreciate the work of famous artists (such
as Pollock, Picasso, Monet, Van Gogh, Toulouse-
5. Draw outlines for children to fill in details
Lautrec, Dali and Warhol) through books with
(e.g. adding facial features to a circle).
examples of their work, displaying copies of
However, do not do this all the time; children
famous artwork and visiting art galleries.
also need freedom to draw what they like,
how they like, when they like! 10. Provide opportunities for children to experiment
with using different art styles (e.g. abstract,
6. Encourage observation skills by getting
cubism, impressionism, post-impressionism,
children to copy patterns and shapes.
realism, surrealism, pop art), including those
As children get older, encourage them
from other cultures, and creating their own art
to represent 3D objects in 2D and pay
galleries and/or art portfolios.
Activity
1 Suggest ways to support the development of children’s art skills. Use your own experiences of working
with children if possible. You could use your observation of a young child drawing or painting as the starting
point for this activity.
2 Visit an art gallery in your local area. Which art styles/artists are displayed at the gallery? Does the gallery have
an educational department, provide art workshops for children or have an artist-in-residence programme?
3 Think about how you could use a visit to an art gallery with the children from your setting to develop their
art skills.
354
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
355
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
consoles, kings and queens, which allows children ●● Drama activities, such as: working in role;
to experiment with being in power and in control; presenting drama and stories to others (for
pretending to be someone else can also help example, telling a story through tableaux or
children to understand what it is like to be that using a narrator); improvisation during role-play
person and encourages empathy and consideration scenarios; responding to performances.
for others.
●● Dolls and puppets to help children to deal with
their feelings – for example, jealousy over a new Activity
baby can be expressed by shouting at a teddy or
doll; puppets are also a useful way of providing 1 Observe a child involved in a drama activity.
children with a ‘voice’ and may encourage shy or 2 In your assessment, comment on the
withdrawn children to express themselves more child’s: language and communication skills;
easily. social interaction; imaginative/creative skills;
concentration level; and memory skills. You might
●● Miniature worlds, such as: play with small-scale
also consider the emotional value of the activity.
toys (e.g. dolls’ houses, toy farms and toy zoos), Also comment on the level of adult support
as well as vehicle play, where children can act out provided during the activity.
previous experiences or situations while sharing
3 Suggest ways to encourage and extend the
ideas and equipment with other children; this can development of the child’s drama skills.
also help them establish friendships.
356
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
357
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
358
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
popular genres, by well-known composers and ●● Learning to play a musical instrument (e.g.
performers). recorder, piano, guitar, violin, cello, etc.).
●● Using ICT to capture, change and combine ●● Integrating performing, composing and
sounds. appraising.
Activity
1 Observe a child involved in a music activity.
2 In your assessment, comment on the child’s: language and communication skills; auditory discrimination;
imaginative/creative skills; concentration level; and memory skills. You might also consider the emotional
value of the activity. Also comment on the level of adult support provided during the activity.
3 Suggest ways to encourage and extend the development of the child’s music skills.
359
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Richard, Aretha Franklin and Ray Charles) (Beijing Opera); Irish and Scottish folk
through listening to CDs, watching concerts music (Gaelic music and dancing); Spanish
etc. on DVDs, visiting concert halls and music (flamenco, jota, trikiti); and Welsh
other suitable music venues, and inviting music contests (Eisteddfodau). In addition,
music groups to perform within the setting. provide opportunities for children to
produce and perform music, as well as film
10. Provide opportunities for children to
and review their own musical activities.
identify and explore a variety of music
genres from past and present (e.g. Bach 11. Gradually encourage children to create their
and the Baroque Suite, Haydn and the own music by getting them to copy clapping
Classical Symphony, Brahms and the patterns, making clapping patterns using
Romantic Concerto, Lennon and McCartney their own names etc. Use pictures, stories
and ‘60s pop songs). This includes those and rhymes as a stimulus for the children to
from different countries/cultures, such as make their own musical creations, on their
traditional: African music (Apala, Benga own, with a partner or as a group. Encourage
and Fuji); Balinese music (Gamelan); them to represent their music using symbols
Brazilian music (capoeira music, choro, and/or words before introducing them to
bossa nova, samba, lambada); Chinese music formal music scores. For example:
clap wave clapclap wavewave clapclapclap wavewavewave
SS # # S S # #
bangbangbang BOOM bangbangbang BOOM
ooo O ooo O
360
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
that play is the business of young children; play To succeed in today’s economy of ideas, students need
is the way children promote and enhance their to have the ability to use words, images, sounds and
development. The arts are a most natural vehicle for motion to communicate. Active participation and
play (Goldhawk 1998, p. 7). learning in the arts also improve overall academic
achievement, socialisation and preparation for college
The arts are also a source of joy and wonder, which and the workforce. A child’s education is not complete
bid students to touch, taste, hear and see the world. unless it includes the arts. A comprehensive strategy
Children are powerfully affected by storytelling, for a complete education includes high-quality,
music, dance and the visual arts. They often continuing arts instruction in the classroom, as well as
construct their understanding of the world around participation and learning in community-based arts
musical games, imaginative drama and drawing programmes (Americans for the Arts 2001).
(Hamblen 1993).
Children and young people learn to appreciate and The benefits of art for children
value images and artefacts across times and cultures
and to understand the contexts in which they were
and young people
made. In art, craft and design, pupils reflect critically Childhood represents a very productive period of
on their own and other people’s work, judging picture making; children create a massive collection
quality, value and meaning. They learn to think and of pictures, particularly paintings and drawings.
act as artists, crafts people and designers, working What are the benefits of children and young
creatively and intelligently (DfE 2011, p. 1). people engaging in art, both in terms of their own
361
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
creations and appreciation of pictures made by improving concentration, patience, motor skill and
others? There are many general benefits of art for hand–eye coordination; developing social skills in
children and young people, such as: encouraging a group art projects; and providing relaxation and
sense of achievement and pride in learning a skill; fun! (Jolley 2010)
The benefits of developing art skills for children and/or young people
1. Stimulating imagination and creativity: the subject matter from the real-world scene
children can take their experiences of the they are drawing from, and therefore makes
world and transform these by making new them more observant of the details in the
connections and relationships through their world around them. Together with visual
inventive minds. Their knowledge, memories thinking, developing observational skills
and fantasies all feed their imagination, and through picture making facilitates the child’s
art allows children to explore, build on and visual sensitivity of the world.
record their own creative and imaginative 5. Learning problem-solving and analytical
ideas. skills: pictures enable children to explore
2. Providing a means of expression: making and test out ideas, while making decisions
pictures allows children to express their on how they choose to represent them. For
feelings and ideas, both as a means of self- instance, children will learn problem-solving
expression and to communicate to others. skills as they grapple with trying to create
These may include reliving a happy event they a three-dimensional scene from the world
recently experienced (e.g. a birthday party or on a two-dimensional page. With practice,
a day out) or drawing out some sad feelings children learn that through concentration and
as a therapeutic exercise. In addition, older persistence they can produce more successful
children may use pictures for conceptual pictures of what they are trying to achieve.
purposes – that is, for expressing their 6. Increasing autonomy: a child’s picture is
concerns and ideas. his or her own. It has worth in its own right,
3. Encouraging visual thinking: pictures without having to be measured or judged by
encourage us to think about and understand others as right or wrong. The child has the
the world visually, instead of only thinking authority to say what the picture is of, or
about things in terms of what name they are what it communicates, therefore building up
called and their function. the child’s confidence and self-esteem.
4. Developing observational skills: making (Jolley 2010)
pictures helps children observe more closely
The benefits of drama for communicate, even with limited language, using
non-verbal communication, such as body movements
children and young people and facial expressions. There are also a number of
Drama is not only about the product (the other factors which make drama a very powerful
performance); it also helps in the process of language tool in the language classroom. This is because
learning. Using drama and drama activities has clear drama involves children at many levels, through
advantages for language learning. It encourages their bodies, minds, emotions, language and social
children to speak and gives them the chance to interaction (Phillips 1999, p. 6).
362
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
The benefits of developing drama skills for children and/or young people
1. Motivation: drama activities are very teacher can use roles to encourage children
motivating and can be fun. The same activity who would otherwise hold back, and control
can be done at different levels at the same children who dominate the weaker ones.
time, which means that all children can 4. Group dynamics: children often work in pairs
do it successfully. The end product (the or groups when engaged in drama activities.
performance) is clear and so children feel safe This group work may be very structured, where
and have a goal to work towards (even though children reproduce a model, or it may mean
this might not coincide with their teacher’s children taking responsibility for their own
aims). Children are motivated if they know work. Children have to make decisions as a
that one or two groups will be asked to show group, listen to each other and value each
what they have done, or if they are being other’s suggestions. They have to cooperate to
videoed or putting on a public performance. achieve their aims, find ways of settling their
2. Familiar activities: dramatising is part of differences and use the strengths of each
children’s lives from an early age. Children member of the group.
act out scenes and stories from the age of 5. Language personalisation: drama can
about three or four years. They play at being help bring texts to life, making them more
adults in situations which are part of their meaningful – for example, dramatising allows
everyday lives (like shopping and visiting the children to add an emotion or personality to
doctor). Many of these day-to-day situations a text that they have read or listened to. Take
are predictable. Children try out different any word, sentence or short dialogue (two to
roles in make-believe play. They rehearse the four lines) and ask the children to practise
language and the ‘script’ of the situation and saying it ‘in character’. It is surprising how
experience the emotions involved, knowing the meaning of something as simple as ‘What’s
that they can switch back to reality whenever your name?’ can be changed according to
they want to. Such pretend play prepares how and where you say it. For example, think
children for the real-life situations they will about how a policeman asks a robber and
meet later on: play is a rehearsal of the real how Father Christmas asks a hopeful child the
thing. Make-believe encourages children’s same question. By interpreting the words, the
creativity and develops their imagination, and children make them their own. This also makes
at the same time gives them the opportunity language memorable.
to use language that is outside their daily
needs. For example, by acting out situations 6. Cross-curricular content: when using drama,
such as being Little Red Riding Hood, your aims can be more than linguistic. You
Aladdin’s Magic Carpet or a bank robber and can use topics from other subjects: the
then using all the language that grows out of children can act out scenes from history or
that personality or role. the life cycle of a frog. You can work on ideas
and issues that run through the curriculum,
3. Confidence: by taking on a role, children can such as sexism, respect for the environment
escape from their everyday identity and lose or road safety. Important messages can be
their inhibitions. This is useful with children conveyed and explored through sketches
who are shy about speaking, who do not and role play. Drama can also be used to
like joining in group activities or who speak introduce the culture of new languages
English as an additional language. If you give through stories and customs, and with
them a special role, it encourages them to the context working on different kinds of
be that character and abandon their shyness, behaviour.
reluctance or embarrassment. This is especially
true when you use puppets and masks. The (Phillips 1999)
363
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The benefits of developing music skills for children and/or young people
364
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
365
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
366
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
1 Think about a group of children that you work An understanding of intellectual development is
with. Are they visual, auditory or kinaesthetic essential for practitioners because it helps them to
learners? Think about how the children you work work with others in supporting learning activities
with gather information. Do they prefer to: through: a well-organised and structured learning
• work as an individual or in a group? environment; careful planning and preparation
• follow step-by-step instructions or have open-
of learning activities; the provision of appropriate
ended projects? learning resources; effective communication with
children during learning activities; high adult
• read and talk about work?
expectations for learner development; and accurate
• engage in practical activities and experiment evaluation of learning activities and assessment of
for themselves?
children’s abilities.
2 Think about how the children you work with
process information. For example, are they
analytic or global learners? Section 3: Plan and
implement art, drama
The benefits of and music activities for
acknowledging children and/or young
individual learning people
needs to identify support Encouraging creativity requires careful planning
It is vital that all children have access to a stimulating so that children and/or young people are helped to
learning environment that enables them to learn respond creatively to challenges that have been set
in exciting and challenging ways. Intellectual for them. Practitioners need to place the activity in a
stimulation through appropriate learning activities context that will be relevant to their lives, select an
allows children to develop their intellectual abilities interesting challenge and ensure that the children
and to fulfil their potential as individuals. and/or young people have the necessary artistic
skills to meet the challenge. Providing choice,
Research into how children think and learn has ensuring the children and/or young people can work
made adults more aware of the need to observe and independently, encouraging teamwork, allowing
367
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
experimentation and encouraging children and/or ●● providing a stimulating, enjoyable and carefully
young people to persevere are key components of planned learning environment, including using
fostering creativity in art, drama and music (Sharp indoor and outdoor spaces
and Le Métais 2000, p. 9). ●● using everyday routines to enhance learning
●● ensuring a balance between structured and freely
Planning and implementing activities to enhance chosen play
children’s development should be based on your ●● supporting and extending play to encourage
observations of each child, your relationship with learning by using your knowledge of individual
each child and your understanding of holistic children and their preferred learning styles
development and learning. Effective planning for ●● using appropriate materials and support strategies
young children involves: for each child’s needs and abilities
●● viewing children as powerful and competent ●● encouraging children’s participation and providing
●● observing children closely and respecting them commitment to raising their achievement based
as individuals in order to plan rich, meaningful on a realistic appraisal of their capabilities and
experiences what they might achieve
●● recognising that an experience must be holistic to ●● encouraging children to make choices about their
whole child, not around a specific area of learning the needs of all the children.
●● taking a holistic approach to the planning process
by recognising and building on the child’s needs, Planning art, drama
skills, interests and earlier experiences
●● making your planning flexible and flow with the child. and music activities for
(Abbott and Langston 2005) children and/or young
(More detailed information about holistic people
development can be found in Chapter 5 ‘Understand
You will need to plan the provision of art, drama
child and young person development’ in CACHE
and music activities for the children you work with
Level 3 Diploma Children and Young People’s
based on your assessment of their developmental
Workforce: Early Learning and Child Care, pp. 49–66.)
progress. You should recognise that children’s
developmental progress depends on each child’s
Key term level of maturation and their prior experiences. You
should take these into account and have realistic
Holistic – looking at the ‘whole’ child or young person
(e.g. all aspects of the child or young person’s
expectations when planning activities and routines
development). to promote children’s development. (See Chapter 6
‘Promote child and young person development’ in
CACHE Level 3 Diploma Children and Young People’s
Implementing curriculum plans involves working Workforce: Early Learning and Child Care.)
with other people (e.g. parents, colleagues and
other professionals) to deliver the appropriate This includes regularly reviewing and updating
curriculum for the children in your setting. You plans for individual children and ensuring that
should implement planned curriculum activities and plans balance the needs of individual children
experiences that meet the needs of the children in and the group as appropriate to your setting. You
your setting by: should know and understand that children develop
368
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
369
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
development, gained through observational How are art, drama and music
assessment and genuine partnerships with parents
(Jaeckle 2008).
activities connected to other
areas of learning?
Activity Learning in the expressive arts offers rich and exciting
opportunities for combining art and design, dance,
Think about how planning in your setting is drama and music with other areas of the curriculum.
underpinned by the EYFS principles of ‘Every child Examples include dance activities that contribute
is a unique child…’ and ‘Children develop and to children and young people’s physical activity;
learn in different ways and at different rates…’. For therefore the experiences and outcomes in dance can
example:
be linked with those for physical education. Films
• How does the setting celebrate the uniqueness and DVDs provide opportunities to experience dance,
of every child? drama, music, art and design within the context of
• Do practitioners take the time to observe, listen a story. Children and young people will develop,
and tune in to individual children? enhance and apply skills gained in the expressive arts
• How do practitioners identify the children’s in a very broad range of activities, including role play
strengths, interests and preferences? and participation in whole-school events, community
• How do practitioners identify the children’s events and outdoor learning. Such activities promote
different developmental pathways? the development of skills in areas such as talking and
• How do practitioners plan for meaningful working with others and contribute to children and
experiences which are tailored to the children’s young people’s mental, emotional, social and physical
individual needs? well-being (Education Scotland 2012, p. 4).
Activity
Relating art, drama and music
activities to other areas of Think about how planning in your setting relates
art, drama and music activities to other areas of
learning learning. For example:
When planning art, drama and music activities, it is • How does the setting plan play-based
essential to relate each activity to at least one other experiences?
area of learning. For example, one of the central
• How do practitioners plan art, drama and music
principles of the EYFS emphasises the connections activities?
between all areas of learning and development: ‘All
• How are these activities connected to other
areas of learning and development are important and
areas of the relevant curriculum framework?
are interconnected’ (DfE 2011, p.4).
370
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
371
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
372
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
group of children ready (e.g. prompt cards, worksheet, ●● assess whether the activity has been successful
work card or written on the board); ensuring sufficient (e.g. have the aims and objectives or outcomes
materials, including any specialist equipment; setting been met?)
out the materials and equipment on the table ready or ●● identify possible ways in which the activity might
letting the children get the resources out for themselves, be modified/adapted to meet the individual needs
depending on their ages and abilities. of the child or children
●● provide accurate information for the senior
Implementing an activity may involve: practitioner, setting manager or other
1 Giving out any instructions to the children. professionals about the success of a particular
2 Showing children what to do (e.g. demonstrate a routine or activity.
new technique).
The senior practitioner, setting manager or your
3 Keeping an individual child and/or group on task.
college tutor/assessor should give you guidelines on
4 Clarifying meaning and/or ideas (e.g. explaining
how to present your activity plans. If not, you could
any difficult words or concepts to the children).
use the suggested format on page 43 in Chapter 1.
5 Assisting children with any special equipment
(e.g. hearing aid or a Dictaphone).
6 Providing any other appropriate assistance. In Practice
7 Encouraging the children to tidy up afterwards as
1. Plan an art activity for children and/or young
appropriate to the ages and abilities.
people that will include: the aim of the activity;
8 Remembering to maintain the children’s safety at recognition of individual needs; how the activity
all times. relates to one other area of learning. (As the
starting point for this activity, you could use
Evaluating the activities your observation of a child drawing or painting,
plus your suggestions to support children’s art
implemented in relation skills from page 354.)
After you have planned and implemented the art, 3. Analyse the outcome of the activity
implemented in relation to the children and/or
drama or music activity, you will need to evaluate it.
young people’s learning.
Some evaluation also occurs during the routine or
activity, providing continuous assessment of a child’s 4. Evaluate the outcome of the activity
implemented in relation to the aim and the one
performance. It is important to evaluate each activity
other area of learning identified.
so that you can:
373
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
In Practice
Reflecting on the
planning process for
1. Plan a music activity for children and/or young
people that will include: the aim of the activity; each art, drama and
recognition of individual needs; how the activity
relates to one other area of learning. (As the music activity
starting point for this activity, you could use your
observation of a child involved in a music activity As a practitioner, you need to know and understand
from page 359, plus your suggestions to support the techniques of reflective analysis: questioning
children’s music skills from page 360.) what, why and how; seeking alternatives; keeping
2. Implement the music activity planned for an open mind; viewing from different perspectives;
children and/or young people. thinking about consequences; testing ideas through
3. Analyse the outcome of the activity comparing and contrasting; asking ‘what if?’;
implemented in relation to the children and/or synthesising ideas; and seeking, identifying and
young people’s learning. resolving problems (NDNA 2004).
4. Evaluate the outcome of the activity implemented
Self-evaluation is needed to improve your own
in relation to the aim and the one other area of
learning identified. professional practice and to develop your ability to
reflect upon activities and modify plans to meet the
individual needs of the children and/or young people
Section 4: Reflect on own you work with. When evaluating your own practice
you should consider the following:
practice ●● Was your own particular contribution appropriate?
Effective practice requires committed, enthusiastic
●● Did you choose the right time, place and
and reflective practitioners with a breadth and depth resources?
●● Did you intervene enough or too much?
of knowledge, skills and understanding. To be an
●● Did you achieve your goals (e.g. objectives/
effective, reflective practitioner, you should use your
outcomes for the child or children and yourself)?
374
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
If not, why not? Were the goals too ambitious or arts and the role of the arts in supporting children’s
unrealistic? creativity in all aspects of their development.
●● What other strategies/methods could have been You should work with parents and carers in
used? Suggest possible modifications. designing and implementing activities that will
●● Who should you ask for further advice (e.g. foster creativity in all aspects of their children’s
senior practitioner, setting manager, other development.
professional)?
You can extend and refine future practice by:
future practice playing)
●● using a child’s language in as many experiences
You should work together with your colleagues and as possible (e.g. labelling objects and works of
other professionals to create a learning community art)
●● recognising the child’s efforts and works (e.g.
that includes art specialists, artists (e.g. painters,
sculptors, illustrators, designers, actors, composers, displaying artwork and giving positive feedback)
musicians), parents, families, carers, teachers and and having a place for all children’s efforts, not
educational consultants. You should assist parents just the ‘best’
●● recording and communicating each child’s
and carers in understanding the importance of the
progress and achievements in the arts
375
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Useful resources
Education Scotland
This website provides detailed information about the expressive arts, including principles and
practices, experiences and outcomes, as well as support materials.
www.educationscotland.gov.uk/learningteachingandassessment/curriculumareas/expressivearts/index.
asp
Foundation Years
This website (developed by 4Children) is the ‘one-stop-shop’ for resources, information and the
latest news on the foundation years. The website provides advice and guidance for practitioners on
working effectively with parents as partners in their children’s learning.
www.foundationyears.org.uk
376
Chapter 11 Support children and/or young people’s development of art, drama and music (Unit CP 11)
Books
Abbott, L. and Langston, A. (2005) Birth to three matters: supporting the framework of effective practice,
Maidenhead: Open University Press.
Americans for the Arts (2001) Making the case to Congress for federal support of arts education, Arts
Advocacy Day 2001, available at: www.americansforthearts.org/get_involved/advocacy/aad/issue_
briefs/2001/advocacy_issuebrief_004.asp (accessed May 2012).
Bance, L. (2012) Music for early learning: songs and musical activities to support children’s development,
London: Routledge.
Booth, D. and Hachiya, M. (eds) (2000) The arts go to school: classroom-based activities that focus on
music, painting, drama, movement, media, and more, illustrated edition, Ontario: Pembroke Publishers
Limited.
Bruce, T. (2011) Cultivating creativity: for babies, toddlers and young children, 2nd edition, London:
Hodder Education.
Bruce, T. (2011) Learning through play: for babies, toddlers and young children, 2nd edition, London:
Hodder Education.
DCSF (2008) Statutory framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage: setting the standards for learning,
development and care for children from birth to five, London: Department for Children, Schools and
Families.
DfE (2011) Secondary curriculum subjects: art and design, London: Department for Education,
available at: www.education.gov.uk/schools/teachingandlearning/curriculum/secondary/b00199239/
art (accessed April 2012).
DfE (2012) Statutory framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage: setting the standards for learning,
development and care for children from birth to five, London: Department for Education, available at:
http://media.education.gov.uk/assets/files/pdf/e/eyfs%20statutory%20framework%20march%20
2012.pdf (accessed April 2012).
DfES (2005) Primary national strategy: KEEP – Key Elements of Effective Practice, London: Department
for Education and Skills, available at: http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/7593/1/pns_fs120105keep.pdf (accessed
May 2012).
Drake, J. (2009) Planning for children’s play and learning, London: David Fulton Publishers.
Education Scotland (2012) Curriculum for excellence – expressive arts: principles and practice,
Edinburgh: Scottish Government, available at: www.educationscotland.gov.uk/Images/expressive_
arts_principles_practice_tcm4-540037.pdf (accessed May 2012).
377
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Goldhawk, S. (1998) Young children and the arts: making creative connections – a report of the task force on
children’s learning and the arts: birth to age eight, Washington: Arts Education Partnership, available at:
www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED453968.pdf (accessed May 2012).
Griffiths, F. (2009) Supporting children’s creativity through music, dance, drama and art, London:
Routledge.
Hallam, S. (2010) ‘The power of music: its impact on the intellectual, personal and social
development of children and young people’, International Journal of Music Education, 38(3): 269–289,
available at: www.devon.gov.uk/dms-powerofmusic.pdf (accessed May 2012).
Hamblen, K.A. (1993) ‘Theories and research that support art instruction for instrumental outcomes’,
Theory into Practice, 32(4): 191–198.
Hobart, C. and Frankel, J. (2009) A Practical Guide to Activities for Young Children, 4th edition,
London: Nelson Thornes.
Hutchin, V. (2012) The EYFS: A Practical Guide for Students and Professionals, London: Hodder
Education.
Jaeckle, S. (2008) ‘The EYFS principles: a breakdown’, Early Years Update, September, available at:
www.teachingexpertise.com/articles/eyfs-principles-breakdown-4117 (accessed February 2012).
Jolley, R.P. (2010) Children and pictures: drawing and understanding, Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Kamen, T. (2000) Psychology for childhood studies, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Meggitt, C., Kamen, T., Bruce, T. and Grenier, J. (2011) CACHE Level 3 Diploma: Children and young
people’s workforce: early learning and child care, London: Hodder Education.
Melling, B. (2006) Creative activities for the early years: thematic art and music activities, Dunstable:
Brilliant Publications.
National Advisory Committee on Creative and Cultural Education (NACCCE) (1999) All our futures:
creativity, culture and education, London: Department for Culture, Media and Sport/Department for
Education and Employment (this is a lengthy report – 243 pages – but a helpful summary is available
at: www.creativetallis.com/uploads/2/2/8/7/2287089/all_our_futures_summary.pdf or you can
access the full report at: http://sirkenrobinson.com/skr/pdf/allourfutures.pdf).
NDNA (2004) National occupational standards in children’s care, learning and development, Brighouse:
NDNA.
Ofsted (2012) Making a mark: art, craft and design education, Manchester: Office for Standards
in Education, Children’s Services and Skills, available at: www.education.gov.uk/publications/
eOrderingDownload/110135.pdf (accessed May 2012).
Phillips, S. (1999) Drama with children, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sharp, C. and Le Métais, J. (2000) The arts, creativity and cultural education: an international
perspective, London: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority, available at: www.inca.org.uk/pdf/
finalreport.pdf (accessed May 2012).
Swale, J. (2009) Drama games for classrooms and workshops, London: Nick Hern Books.
Tobias, C. (1996) The way they learn, Colorado Springs: Focus on the Family Publishing.
Williams, D. (2007) Creative art activities for the early years foundation stage, Preston: Topical Resources.
378
Chapter 12 Learning about planning
from a given framework of curricula
(Unit CP 13)
The aim of this unit is to enable the learner to gain When planning, implementing and evaluating
an understanding of planning for children or young curriculum plans, your overall aims should be to:
people’s learning within a given framework or ●● support all the children you work with
curriculum. ●● ensure each child has full access to the relevant
curriculum
Learning outcomes ●● encourage participation by all children
●● meet children’s individual learning and
1. Understand the rationale for working
development needs
within given frameworks or curricula.
●● build on children’s existing knowledge and skills
2. Understand a range of models used ●● help all children achieve their full potential.
when planning for children and/or
young people’s learning.
Key terms
3. Be able to plan to a framework or
curriculum. Curricula – programmes of study provided by a school,
college or other education setting.
Frameworks – structures for supporting the concepts,
values and practices relating to the development, care
and learning of children and/or young people.
Section 1: Understanding Rationale – the logical basis for a course of action
the rationale for working (e.g. the fundamental reasons for working within given
frameworks or curricula).
379
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
380
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
381
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Figure 12.2 Children learn to be strong and independent through positive relationships
382
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
383
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
reflect on the possibilities that it has to offer. When their learning and practitioners’ confidence soars as
the environment is right, there is a contagious they are free to support each child constructively on
sparkle in the air, the children are deeply engaged in their learning journey (Jaeckle 2008).
In Practice
Think about how curriculum planning in your setting is underpinned by the principle of ‘an enabling
environment’. For example:
❏❏ Are there sufficient opportunities for children to get deeply involved, discover new lines of enquiry,
experiment, explore and solve problems?
❏❏ Is the environment full of inspiration, with provocations for learning that will capture the child’s imagination?
❏❏ Does the environment enable children to be independent and make their own choices of materials and
resources?
❏❏ Are there quiet spaces where children can ponder and play, as well as larger, open spaces for them to
test their new physical skills?
Children develop and learn in different ways years provision, including children with special
and at different rates. The framework covers educational needs and disabilities.
the education and care of all children in early
Figure 12.4 Children develop and learn in different ways and at different rates
384
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
Children learn from everything they do. The EYFS ●● understanding the world
affirms that young children learn best through ●● expressive arts and design.
carefully planned, play-based experiences that start
with their strengths, interests and capabilities. It Each area of learning and development must be
acknowledges that young children are active learners implemented through planned, purposeful play
and that they need opportunities to explore and make and through a mix of adult-led and child-initiated
sense of the world, supported by knowledgeable, activity. Play is essential for children’s development,
interested and sensitive adults. This principle building their confidence as they learn to explore,
recognises that all areas of learning are interconnected to think about problems and to relate to others.
and that, while children will need to be taught Children learn by leading their own play and by
new skills, these should always be balanced by taking part in play which is guided by adults. There
opportunities for them to independently apply, practise is an ongoing judgment to be made by practitioners
and consolidate their new learning through a richly about the balance between activities led by children
resourced environment, inside and out. The EYFS and activities led or guided by adults. Practitioners
places the child firmly at the heart of the learning must respond to each child’s emerging needs and
experience and demands an informed approach to interests, guiding their development through warm,
supporting children’s learning and development, positive interaction. As children grow older, and
gained through observational assessment and genuine as their development allows, it is expected that the
partnerships with parents. (Jaeckle 2008) balance will gradually shift towards more activities
led by adults, to help children prepare for more
formal learning, ready for Year 1 (DfE 2012, p. 6).
In Practice
Alongside the updated EYFS framework, there are
Think about how curriculum planning in your additional support materials, including:
setting is underpinned by the principle of ‘children
develop and learn in different ways and at different ●● guidance and exemplification for completing the
rates’. For example: Early Years Foundation Stage Profile
❏❏ How do practitioners identify the children’s ●● best-practice models for presenting information
385
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
386
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
(1) (a) of the Childcare Act 2006. The safeguarding put the relevant framework or curricula into practice in
and welfare requirements are given legal force the day-to-day running. Curriculum planning should
by regulations made under Section 39 (1) (b) of influence and determine decisions and actions relating
the Childcare Act 2006. Together, the order, the to supporting learning and development.
regulations and the statutory framework document
The first stage in this is to create a curriculum policy.
make up the legal basis of the EYFS (DfE 2011a).
A curriculum policy provides a set of guidelines and
Frameworks and curricula provide structured these guidelines give a general overview of the kind
approaches to supporting the learning of children of action which will be taking place in the setting and
and young people. They form the basis for each will be consistently followed by all staff members.
setting’s curriculum planning, including how they
Curriculum policies provide the basis upon which
meet the statutory requirements for all children
more detailed procedures and plans can then be built.
and/or young people and any variations to meet the
Curriculum policies also give practitioners an indication
needs of individuals.
of what their particular roles and responsibilities are
in implementing the policies. Curriculum policies are
Activity not only a legal requirement but they also distinguish
the setting as a unique organisation tailored to the
Explain why frameworks or curricula are required. particular needs and abilities of its staff, children, their
families and the local community.
adhere to and work and/or young people are provided with activities
at the appropriate level for their development and
within given frameworks learning. For example, there should be a balance
between encouraging younger children to develop
or curricula their own problem-solving skills through play with
minimal adult intervention and complying with the
As a practitioner, it is important that you understand
early learning goals in the EYFS.
and follow the frameworks or curricula which
support the learning of the children that you work Adhering to and working within the given
with. This includes knowing and following policies frameworks or curricula which support the learning
and procedures relating to teaching and learning. of the children and/or young people are important
Every setting should have policies and procedures because they improve:
which put into practice the legal requirements under
●● the quality of the education provision
which they work. You should have access to copies
●● the structure of the learning environment
of the policies and procedures relevant to your work
●● the provision of materials and equipment
in the setting. For example, in an early years setting,
●● the communication between adults and children
you should know what your role and responsibilities
are to implement the EYFS. during learning experiences
●● the adult expectations of children’s development.
Detailed information about a setting’s curriculum
Adhering to and working within the given
planning can be found in: policy statements for the
frameworks or curricula also increase the
whole curriculum and for each area of the curriculum;
practitioner’s awareness and understanding of
schemes of work and teaching plans for each key stage;
the importance of: very carefully observing and
class or group timetables; weekly and daily planning
assessing children’s development; listening to
grids; activity plans; and individual education plans.
children and the way they express ideas; and taking
Curriculum planning is the detailed process of working account of children’s interests and experiences when
out how, and using what methods, a setting is going to planning learning opportunities.
387
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
relevant curriculum documents (see above) and on learning activities for children and/or young
consulting with relevant colleagues. You should people in each group/class on a weekly and daily
include children, parents and other professionals basis, including lesson plans and/or activity plans
in the planning process as appropriate to your with details of specific targets, organisation,
setting. You must ensure that your plans reflect anti- resources and strategies to support learning.
discriminatory practice and inclusive practice. (See (QCA 2001)
the section ‘Understand how to support diversity,
inclusion and participation in early years settings’ on You must draw up long-term, medium-term and
pages 317–321 of Meggitt et al. 2011). short-term plans according to the requirements of
the curriculum framework in your home country.
Depending on your role and the setting, you will be
Key terms
involved in the planning and preparation of schemes
Anti-discriminatory practice – taking positive action to of work and teaching plans by having regular planning
counter discrimination and prejudice. meetings with colleagues (e.g. weekly, monthly, every
Inclusive practice – identifying barriers to participation half-term or once a term). You will need to prepare
and taking positive action to eliminate those barriers and plans which take into account the pattern of children’s
encourage participation in the full range of activities
provided by the setting.
attendance (e.g. part-time or full-time) and their need
for a balanced programme of activities.
388
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
389
390
Role-play areas – Bedouin tent, Inuit igloo. Simple origami. Role-play areas – Bedouin tent, Inuit igloo,
Invite visitors to talk about other cultures and Use chopsticks. market stall from another country, sari shop.
religions. Dressing up in different costumes from other Collect artefacts from around the world –
Topic: Look at different national or religious countries. Russian dolls, African drums or masks, bells,
costumes/head coverings. Have a go at tai chi or yoga. Indian sari material, etc.
Circle times. Play children’s games from other countries. Memory games – ‘I went to market and I
Puzzles and games depicting pictures from Action songs from around the world. bought…’.
All Around the around the world. Carry things in baskets on your head/water in Holiday photos from abroad.
Learn to say ‘hello’ in different languages. a bucket/bundles of washing on your back. Small-world toys – e.g. airport.
Make contact with an early years setting in Dance to music from around the world. Boats to travel in water tray/desert in sand
World another country and write/draw pictures to
them.
tray.
Stories and songs from other countries.
Collect water in containers in the garden and Storytelling using props.
talk about the importance of water in Talk about festivals and celebrations from
different countries and how we need to use other countries.
water carefully.
Stories and songs.
Specific areas
Figure 12.5 Topic web based on the 2012 Early Years Foundation Stage (adapted from an article by J. Mickelburgh from: http://www.eyfs.info/resources/topics/topic.php?
Around-the-world-4)
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
their short-term planning that promote progress to raising their achievement based on a realistic
and achievement for all children. Staff may need appraisal of children’s abilities and what they can
to adjust the balance in the curriculum to focus on achieve. You may be involved in regular reviews of
particular areas of learning so that their planning individual educational plans in consultation with the
takes account of group or individual education plans. child or young person’s class teacher/form tutor, the
SENCO, the child/young person and their parents
Medium-term plans also include: (e.g. at least three times a year).
●● a group/class timetable outlining when and
A child or young person’s IEP should include the
where the play and learning activities will take
following information:
place, periods when children can rest and restore
energy (e.g. story time), and routines that must ●● the child or young person’s strengths
be done at specific times (e.g. registration, break/ ●● priority concerns
playtime, lunchtime, tidying-up time, home time) ●● any external agencies involved
●● practical guidelines for staff assisting the ●● background information, including assessment
delivery of each curriculum subject or area of details and/or medical needs
learning (e.g. general information about resources ●● parental involvement/child participation
and important teaching points) ●● the short-term targets for the child/young person
●● structured learning programmes for individual ●● the provision to be put in place (e.g. resources,
children, including particular activities to strategies, staff, allocated support time)
encourage the development of children with special ●● when the plan is to be reviewed
educational needs (e.g. individual education plans). ●● the outcome of any action taken.
391
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Area/s of Concern Literacy, Maths, Behaviour Year Group/IEP No. Year 2, Class 7/IEP No 2
Achievement Criteria:
1. Accurate when tested at random on three separate occasions.
2. Use number bonds to answer sums accurately on three separate occasions.
3. Achieved on 6 out of 10 occasions over a period of a week.
4. Achieved on 4 occasions.
Figure 12.6 Example of individual education plan (from Teaching Assistant’s Handbook Level 3, page 257, Hodder
Education, 2011)
392
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
early learning goals as appropriate to each child’s level different preferences for the presentation of learning
of development. Short-term plans should also include activities and materials. For example, they may prefer
details of the proposed implementation of each to learn through visual, auditory or kinaesthetic
activity, including organisation and staff required, stimuli. Planning for learning activities needs to take
resources needed, including any specialist equipment, account of these learning needs. (See Chapter 11,
and strategies to be used to support children’s page 366.)
learning and development.
Working with others is an important aspect
Short-term planning provides the details of activities of learning. Short-term planning can help
to support learning on a weekly, daily and lesson-by- practitioners to group children together during
lesson basis. To plan appropriate activities, you need to: different activities to support learning in a variety
of ways: whole class, cross-class groups (e.g. within
●● identify the intended learning outcomes that
the same year group), ability sets, mixed-ability or
promote inclusion, participation and achievement
‘friendship’ groups, pairs or one-to-one (adult and
for all children
child/young person).
●● use information about children’s interests, skills
and prior achievements to structure the content The new EYFS framework makes clear that
and progress of activities/lessons practitioners should observe and respond to each
●● take into account children’s individual learning child in their care on an ongoing basis. It gives a
needs, including their different learning styles broad steer that there should be a focus on prime
●● include targets from individual education plans for areas for younger children, with gradual building-in
children with special educational needs of support in the specific areas for older age ranges,
●● define the roles and responsibilities of those involved as children develop, and as appropriate to their
●● ensure that adequate and appropriate resources individual level of development and progress. This
are available reflects the importance of the prime areas of learning
●● use ICT to support children’s learning and for other areas, but practitioners should of course be
development. flexible in their approach, responding to each child as
an individual. There is nothing in the framework that
Short-term plans should include an appropriate
holds back a practitioner from introducing specific
balance between familiar activities and new learning
areas to a particular child’s learning experience earlier
challenges. Children and young people need to
than they might for other children, if they judge that
be motivated and stimulated by a wide range of
to be appropriate. Experiences which support younger
activities to support learning in a variety of contexts.
children’s learning in the prime areas, moreover,
Some children/young people may need frequent
will also support their learning in the specific areas.
repetitions of the same activity in the same context
Sharing rhymes and picture books, for example, lays
so that they begin to notice events and start to learn.
the foundations for reading and writing, as well as for
Others may need to repeat similar experiences over
communication and language (DfE 2011b, Section 4).
an extended period. A particular activity may remain
relevant to a group for many months or even years, An effective short-term plan for young children will
but its context should be modified according to the usually include:
subject, motivation, current interest and age of the
children and/or young people. This is especially ●● clear learning intentions for individual or groups
relevant to supporting children/young people with of children informed by observations and based
learning difficulties. (Information about supporting on the early learning goals
●● a brief description of the range of activities and
children with disabilities can be found on pages
188–194 in Chapter 11 of Meggitt et al. 2011.) experiences, including adult-directed and child-
initiated activities, indoors and outdoors
Children and young people have different learning ●● how activities and experiences can be adapted for
styles and will learn at different rates. They will have individual or groups of children
393
394
Links to EYFS
PSED: Learn that their voices and actions have effects on others/feel safe and secure PSED: Show a strong sense of self as a member of different communities, such as their
within healthy relationships with key people. family or setting.
CLL: Enjoy babbling and increasingly experiment using sounds and words to represent CLL: Use single-word and two-word utterances to convey simple and more complex
objects around them. messages.
PSRN: Through their manipulations of objects. PSRN: Use blocks to create their own simple structures and arrangements.
PD: Use increasing mobility to connect with toys, objects and people. KUW: Are curious about the environment.
CD: Move their whole bodies to sounds they enjoy, such as music or a regular beat. PD: Express themselves through action and sound.
CD: Begin to move to music, listen to or join in with songs and rhymes.
Questions to ask:
Different places – what do you see?
How did we get here?
Language to use:
Travel, journey, smells, sounds, things to do, things to eat.
Differentiation (birth to three): Extension:
Give the children the opportunity to explore Put together a different story bag and leave the rug
the objects in the bag. Make breakfast with and cushions out in a quiet space as a place where
the croissants, wear a hat, play the drum, etc. the children can go to tell their own ‘around the
world’ stories. Add books about other countries.
Evaluation:
Figure 12.8 Example of an activity plan (adapted from focus plan by J. Mickelburgh from: http://eyfs.info/cmsAdmin/
uploads/CLL-Around-the-World-Story-Bag.pdf)
395
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● how the children will be organised 2 Do: the children participate in the activities of
●● the resources and equipment required their choice and are encouraged to talk during this
●● the role of the adult(s), including parents time, with adults helping to extend the children’s
●● questions and/or vocabulary that the adult(s) will language and learning.
use during the activity 3 Review: at the end of the session, the group
●● opportunities for observation and informal come together again to look back on the session’s
assessments of individual or groups of children. activities, including talking about what they liked
best and giving reasons why they made any changes
In Practice to their original choices. For example, a child might
say: ‘I enjoyed making a really big sandcastle with
Give examples of the short-term plans (e.g. activity my friend Tom. Then I painted a red dinosaur for my
plans, lesson plans) used within the curriculum mum. I didn’t play in the shop today as Tom wanted
framework applicable to the children and/or young to play with the cars instead. We made a great big
people in your setting. traffic jam with all the cars and trucks!’
396
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
397
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
398
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
You should report children’s progress to their parents When planning and implementing activities to
on a regular basis depending on the requirements of support learning, your overall aims should be to:
your setting. You should provide information about ●● support all the children you work with according
their children’s achievements and targets for future
to the relevant framework (e.g. EYFS)
development and learning, as well as any difficulties ●● ensure each child has full access to the curriculum
they may have. This may include, in consultation ●● encourage participation by all children
with children and parents, seeking additional ●● meet children’s individual learning needs
support from appropriate sources if children are ●● build on children’s existing knowledge and skills
not progressing as expected and, where necessary, ●● enable all children to achieve their full learning
referring to external agencies.
potential.
399
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
implications for practice – for example: ensuring ●● The child lacks concentration.
assessment opportunities are built into the planning ●● The child is bored or uninterested.
provision to promote children’s development and ●● The child finds the activity too difficult or too
learning; providing support for individual staff easy.
members as necessary; and reviewing assessment ●● The child is upset or unwell (if so, you may need to
outcomes and data in order to evaluate overall abandon/postpone the activity).
standards throughout the setting.
Children’s responses should also be considered
Monitoring and reflecting on the implementation when providing support for learning activities.
of curriculum frameworks involve developing You should be sensitive to children’s needs and
monitoring strategies and documentation as required preferences. You should take notice of non-verbal
by the relevant curriculum framework in your home responses and preferences demonstrated by the
country. You should regularly communicate with children; these are just as important as what
parents and colleagues to support monitoring of they say. Remember to give the children positive
curriculum frameworks. You should check that each encouragement and feedback to reinforce and
area of the curriculum is implemented to a consistent sustain their interest and efforts in the learning
quality according to the requirements of your setting process. You can use children’s positive or negative
and the relevant inspection regime. You should responses to modify or extend activities to meet
monitor the participation and learning of all the each child’s needs more effectively. For example,
children in the setting. You should reflect on your if the learning intentions prove too easy or too
practice in the light of your work in planning and difficult, you may have to set new goals. By
implementing curriculum frameworks. breaking down learning activities into smaller
tasks, you may help individual children to achieve
success more quickly. In modifying plans, you are
In Practice continuing a cycle of planning and implementing
Outline the monitoring strategies and
activities.
documentation required by the curriculum
framework relevant to your setting. Include
Even in settings where children are working within
information on how you: the National Curriculum framework or towards the
‘early learning goals’, your planning needs to be
❏❏ communicate with parents/colleagues
flexible enough to allow for children’s individual
❏❏ monitor children’s participation and learning interests and unplanned, spontaneous opportunities
❏❏ reflect on practice. for promoting children’s development and learning.
For example, an unexpected snowfall can provide a
wonderful opportunity to talk about snow and for
Keeping planning flexible children to share their delight and fascination for
Despite careful planning, you may find that a this type of weather. Or a child might bring in their
learning activity is not appropriate for all the collection of postcards, prompting an unplanned
children you are working with. You need to monitor discussion about the collections of other children;
children’s responses to learning activities and take this might be developed into a ‘mini-topic’ on
appropriate action to modify or adapt activities to collections if the children are really interested. It is
achieve the intended learning goals/objectives or important that children have this freedom of choice
provide additional activities to extend their learning. to help represent their experiences, feelings and
You may need to provide an alternative version of the ideas. Adults may still be involved in these activities,
activity or you might be able to present the materials but in more subtle ways, such as encouraging
in different ways or offer a greater/lesser level of children to make their own decisions and talking
assistance. You may need to modify or adapt learning with children while they are engaged in these types
activities for the following reasons: of activities.
400
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
401
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● viewing children as powerful and competent to a different purpose than intended. For example,
learners a child might prefer to pour water into a hole to
●● using your knowledge of children as active make a puddle rather than watering the plants as
learners to inform your planning the adult intended. Other child-initiated activities
●● observing children closely and respecting them may be instigated when the child brings something
as individuals in order to plan rich, meaningful to the setting – such as an experience of having
experiences been on a bus or visiting hospital. This might lead
●● recognising that an experience must be holistic to to the provision of resources, stories and pictures
be meaningful and potentially rich in learning to support this interest. Whatever children bring is
●● planning a rich learning experience around the an indication of their current interest and should be
whole child, not around a specific area of learning supported (DCSF 2008, p. 7).
●● taking a holistic approach to the planning process
by recognising and building on the child’s needs, Key term
skills, interests and earlier experiences
●● making your planning flexible and flow with the Child-initiated play – self-chosen activities in which
child. children and young people follow their own ideas, in
their own way and for their own reasons.
(Abbott and Langston 2005)
402
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
Planning adult-directed
activities
Early years settings should ensure a balance of
child-initiated play (see above) and adult-directed
activities. Practitioners use their judgment and
knowledge of the children in their care to decide
what this balance should be. Examples of adult-
directed activities include small group times in
Figure 12.13 Example of opportunity for child-initiated play
which an adult selects the time to encourage
403
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
404
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
●● listen to others, such as singing a short song, the cultural diversity of the setting); inclusion (e.g.
sharing an experience or describing something ensuring activities are accessible to children with
they have seen or done disabilities/special needs); and links to the relevant
●● develop phonological awareness (awareness early years curriculum (e.g. EYFS).
of sounds), particularly through rhyme and
alliteration (e.g. the happy hippo hopped) and their You can write down your plans for play opportunities
knowledge of the alphabetic code on a planning sheet or in an activity file. Your
●● talk for a wide range of purposes – for example, plans may be brief or detailed depending on the
to present ideas to others as descriptions, requirements of your setting. Some activities may
explanations, instructions or justifications require more detailed preparation and organisation
●● focus on mathematical learning – for example, than others (e.g. arts and crafts, cooking, outings, etc.).
exploring shape, size and pattern during block play
A plan for a play activity could include the following:
●● experiment with a number of objects, the written
numeral and the written number 1 Title: A brief description of the activity.
●● develop number skills through matching activities 2 When? Date and time of the activity.
with a range of numbers, numerals and a selection 3 Where? Where the activity will take place – for
of objects example, indoor play area, outdoor play area, local
●● learn scientific skills during practical activities – for park or playground.
example, learning about the characteristics of liquids 4 Why? Outline why you have selected this
and solids by melting chocolate or cooking eggs particular activity – for example, identifying
●● use a range of ICT to include cameras, children’s play needs and preferences through
photocopiers, CD players, tape recorders and research, observation or consultation.
programmable toys, in addition to computers 5 What? What you need to prepare in advance – for
●● participate in physical challenges during example, selecting or making appropriate resources
opportunities for physical activity and buying ingredients, materials or equipment.
●● enjoy energetic play, both indoors and outdoors 6 How? How you will organise the activity.
●● enjoy creative activities, such as painting, Consider any safety requirements. Think about
drawing and model making using a wide variety tidying up after the activity (e.g. encouraging the
of equipment and resources in a variety of ways. children to help tidy up).
405
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
• Discuss the benefits of the planned adult- Planning activities to support learning involves a
directed activity in supporting the child’s learning. continuous cycle of: identifying learning needs;
• Include a list of resources for the activity. preparing, organising and implementing learning
• Give examples of how the adult will support the activities; observing and recording child responses;
child’s learning evaluating learning activities; and identifying future
learning needs.
406
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
Issues to
think through
What to observe?
Pass it on? • the importance of
quality observation
• whom to pass it on to?
• what to pass on? • meeting the requirements
• when to pass it on? of the course
• recognising a suitable
opportunity to observe
Making assessments
• background information
• aims
• areas of development Where to observe?
• recommendations • working in a variety
• personal learning of settings
• bibliography
How to observe?
Methods of recording
• planning
observations • preparation
• choosing a suitable • aims
method • front sheet
• advantages and • observing
disadvantages of • evaluations
each method • presenting work
• record keeping • getting work assessed
Figure 12.16 Thinking about observing, by Jackie Harding and Liz Meldon-Smith (from
Teaching Assistant’s Handbook Level 3, page 2, Hodder Education, 2011)
1. Specify intended learning outcomes for • What instructions and/or questions will you
the child or children: require for the child or children?
• What is the main purpose of the activity? • Do you need prompt cards for instructions or
questions?
• How will it encourage the child or children’s
learning and development? 3. Select resources for the activity:
• What will the child or children gain from • What materials and equipment will you
participating in the activity? need?
• How does the activity link with the early • Do you need any specific audio, visual or
learning goals or National Curriculum tactile aids?
subjects? • Where will you obtain the necessary
2. Prepare for the activity: resources?
• What do you need to prepare in advance? • Are there any special resources required
for children with special educational
• Will you need to make work cards or needs?
photocopy worksheets?
407
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
• Are there any particular safety requirements? • Record these using methods as appropriate
to your role.
• How will you organise any tidying up after the
activity? • Report achievements, difficulties or concerns
to the senior practitioner/setting manager.
• Will the children be encouraged to help tidy
up? 9. Evaluate the activity:
5. Identify your role: • Did the child or children achieve the intended
learning outcomes?
• Are there any specific instructions from a
senior practitioner (e.g. class teacher)? • How effective were the preparation,
organisation and implementation of the
• What strategies will you use to support activity?
learning?
10. Identify future learning needs:
• How will you promote independent learning?
• Have you identified any future learning needs
6. Implement the activity: for the child or children as a result of their
• How does/do the child or children respond responses during this activity?
to the learning activity? • Are there any possible modifications you
• Do you need to adapt the original plan (e.g. could make for future activities?
change the resources or the timing of the • Discuss your ideas with other people who
learning activity)? work with the child or children.
Planning provision based on balance the needs of individual children and the
group, as appropriate to your setting. You should
observations and assessments know and understand that children develop at
You will need to plan provision for the children widely different rates but in broadly the same
you work with based on your assessment of their sequence. When planning provision to promote
developmental progress. You should recognise that children’s development, you need to recognise that
developmental progress depends on each child’s children’s development is holistic, even though it
level of maturation and their prior experiences. is divided into different areas (e.g. Social, Physical,
You should take these into account and have Intellectual, Communication and language, and
realistic expectations when planning activities and Emotional). You should remember to look at the
routines to promote children’s development. This ‘whole’ child. You need to look at all areas of
includes regularly reviewing and updating plans children’s development in relation to the particular
for individual children and ensuring that plans aspect of development or learning you are focusing
408
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
on when planning provision to promote children’s to promote children’s independent learning. This
development. (More detailed information is in includes: encouraging and supporting children
Chapter 5 ‘Understand child and young person in making decisions about their own learning;
development’ in Meggitt et al. 2011.) providing appropriate levels of assistance for
individual children; using ICT to enable children to
work more independently; providing challenges to
Activity promote independent learning; and encouraging
children to review their own learning strategies,
Observe a child involved in an activity to support
achievements and future learning needs.
learning. In your assessment, you should:
• specify the learning objectives for the activity
• identify the development and skills demonstrated In Practice
by the child during the activity (e.g. social,
physical, intellectual, communication and Describe how you plan provision to support
language, and emotional) children’s learning in your setting. Include
examples of any planning sheets you use.
• comment on the level of adult support provided
during the activity
• suggest ways to encourage and extend the Preparation and organisation
child’s learning and development. Good preparation and organisation are essential
when implementing plans to promote children’s
development, including: having ready any
Following your observation and assessment of a
instructions and/or questions for the child or group
child’s development, learning and/or behaviour, your
of children (e.g. prompt cards, worksheets, work
recommendations can provide the basis for planning
cards or written on the board); ensuring sufficient
appropriate routines and/or activities to encourage
materials and equipment, including any specialist
and extend the child’s skills in specific areas. Effective
equipment; and deciding on whether to set out the
planning is based on children’s individual needs,
materials and equipment on the table ready or to let
abilities and interests, hence the importance of accurate
the children get the resources out for themselves,
and reliable child observations and assessments. (See
depending on their ages and abilities.
Figure 1.22 ‘Planning children’s activities’ in Chapter 1,
page 42.) Depending on the type of setting, you may Short-term plans (e.g. individual lesson plans and/
also need to plan provision based on the requirements or activity plans) should include information about
for curriculum frameworks for early education. your role in preparing and organising activities.
These plans should include the learning objectives
When planning activities to support the learning
and what the intended learning outcomes for the
of children and/or young people, your overall aims
children/young people might be. Use your personal
should be to:
timetable, the group/class timetable and the available
●● support the care and development of all the systems of communication within the setting to
children you work with help you know and understand: what you have to do
●● ensure every child has full access to the before you implement the activity; where, when and
appropriate curriculum with whom the activity will take place; and why the
●● meet children’s individual developmental and activity is being implemented.
learning needs
●● build on each child’s existing knowledge, You need the relevant activity/lesson plans at least
understanding and skills. the day before so that you have time to prepare what
you need for the activities. This preparation may
You need to plan, in consultation with your involve: finding resources; doing some photocopying;
colleagues, the strategies and resources to be used checking equipment and its availability; reading up
409
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
on a subject; finding artefacts or reference books activities. You should ensure that you are adequately
for the children/young people; and asking a senior prepared for your contribution to the activities, such
colleague for further information. as understanding the relevant subject knowledge and
support strategies, as well as obtaining appropriate
The learning resources in the setting should support resources. This may mean discussing development
learning activities across the full range of the opportunities to improve your skills in areas where you
curriculum. A wide variety of learning resources currently lack experience or expertise (see the section
will help to maintain interest in the curriculum area on ‘Learning opportunities and personal development’
and help to support individual learning needs. The on pages 23–25 in Chapter 2 of Meggitt et al. 2011).
setting should decide on spending priorities when
allocating resources as some areas of the curriculum Your role will depend on the setting you work in, as
may require more substantial or expensive learning well as your own experience and/or qualifications.
materials than others. Careful criteria should be As a practitioner, you may have a general role
set for selecting and using learning resources. For working with different classes in a year group/key
example, health and safety, ages/ability levels of the stage or specific responsibilities for a child/young
children or young people, quality and durability, person, subject area or age group. When working
versatility and value for money, special educational with a specific child or children, you should have
needs (e.g. specialist or modified learning materials) information regarding their special educational
and equal opportunities (e.g. resources reflecting needs and any special provision, including details of
positive images of cultural diversity, gender roles and statements of special educational needs, individual
people with disabilities). education plans and/or behaviour support plans.
You may be involved in implementing a structured
The organisation of learning resources is also an
programme designed by a specialist, such as a
important consideration. For example, to encourage
speech and language therapist (see the section
independent learning, resources should be organised
‘Develop a plan with an individual child or young
in ways that allow children and/or young people to
person to support learning, play or leisure needs’ on
locate the learning resources they need and to put
pages 456–458 in Chapter 21 of Meggitt et al. 2011).
them away afterwards. Learning resources should be
clearly labelled and stored where they are accessible When implementing activities, you should ensure
to the children/young people. Learning resources that you make accurate and detailed records of what
must be regularly maintained, cleaned and checked has been planned and delivered in order to: clarify the
for damage. Items that are incomplete, unhygienic or aims and learning objectives of activity plans; avoid
past repair should be appropriately discarded. contradictory strategies/unnecessary duplication of
work; use the time available more effectively; evaluate
Implementing plans the success of plans/activities; and provide continuity
and progression for future planning.
Implementing curriculum plans involves working
with other people (e.g. parents, colleagues and other Implementing an activity may involve: giving out any
professionals) to deliver the appropriate curriculum instructions to the children; showing children what
for the children and/or young people in your to do (e.g. demonstrating a new technique); keeping
setting. To provide effective support for children an individual child and/or group on task; clarifying
and/or young people’s learning, you must know and meaning and/or ideas; explaining any difficult words
understand the objectives of the activities and the to the children; assisting children with any special
strategies to support their learning. equipment (e.g. hearing aid or Dictaphone); providing
any other appropriate assistance; encouraging the
As a practitioner, you should be aware of your children to tidy up afterwards as appropriate to the
experience and expertise in relation to supporting ages and abilities; and remembering to maintain the
activities and how these relate to the planned children’s safety at all times.
410
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
Figure 12.17 Implementing a plan to support the learning of a child with disabilities
Implementing activities
You should implement planned activities that • using appropriate materials and support
meet the needs of the children in your setting strategies for each child’s needs and abilities
by: • encouraging children’s participation and
• providing a stimulating, enjoyable and providing assistance at an appropriate level for
carefully planned learning environment, each child, including supporting children with
including using indoor and outdoor spaces special needs
• using everyday routines to enhance learning • having high expectations of children and a
• ensuring a balance between structured and commitment to raising their achievement
freely chosen play based on a realistic appraisal of their
• supporting and extending play to encourage capabilities and what they might achieve
learning by using your knowledge of • encouraging children to make choices about
individual children and their preferred their own learning
learning styles • changing and adapting plans to meet the
needs of all the children as required.
411
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
412
Chapter 12 Learning about planning from a given framework of curricula (Unit CP 13)
In Practice
1. Develop a long-term plan: for example, a topic 3. Devise, implement and evaluate a short-term
web for half-term. Ensure that you provide links to plan: for example, activity plans. Describe two
the relevant framework or curriculum, such as the activities you have planned, implemented and
EYFS. evaluated (one with the focus on child-initiated play
and one adult-directed activity). Include: a brief
2. Produce a medium-term plan: for example,
description of each learning activity; the objectives
a weekly plan of activities. You could use the
of each learning activity; a list of materials and/or
observation from page 409 as the basis for
equipment used; your contribution to the learning
your plan. Include information on: the intended
activities; the type and level of support for the child
learning outcomes/objectives for each activity;
or children; the specific strategies for supporting
organisation, resources and staff required;
learning activities; and an evaluation of each
any special requirements (e.g. specialist
learning activity. Include copies of planning and
equipment); and the support to be provided by
evaluation sheets.
adults.
Useful resources
Books
Abbott, L. and Langston, A. (2005) Birth to three matters: supporting the framework of effective
practice, Maidenhead: Open University Press.
DCSF (2008) Practice guidance for the Early Years Foundation Stage, London: Department for Children,
Families and Schools.
DCSF (2009) Learning, playing and interacting: good practice in the Early Years Foundation Stage,
London: Department for Children, Families and Schools.
DfE (2011a) Statutory framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage: setting the standards for learning,
development and care for children from birth to five, draft for consultation, 6 July 2011, London:
Department for Education, available at:
http://kathybigio.com/pdf/revised_early_years_foundation_stage.pdf (accessed February 2012).
DfE (2011b) Reforming the Early Years Foundation Stage (the EYFS): government response to
consultation 20 December 2011, London: Department for Education, available at: www.education.
gov.uk/consultations/downloadableDocs/Government%20response%20doc%20191211%201630%20
finaltext%20KM%20CB%201808(v2).pdf (accessed February 2012).
DfE (2012) Statutory framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage: setting the standards for learning,
development and care for children from birth to five, London: Department for Education, available at:
www.education.gov.uk/publications/standard/AllPublications/Page1/DFE-00023-2012 (accessed March
2012).
Gillespie Edwards, A. (2002) Relationships and learning: caring for children from birth to three, London:
National Children’s Bureau.
413
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Harding, J. and Meldon-Smith, L. (2001) How to make observations and assessments, 2nd edition,
London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Hobart, C. and Frankel, J. (2005) A practical guide to activities for young children, 3rd edition,
Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes.
Hutchin, V. (2012) The EYFS: A Practical Guide for Students and Professionals, London: Hodder
Education.
Jaeckle, S. (2008) ‘The EYFS principles: a breakdown’, Early Years Update, September, available at:
www.teachingexpertise.com/articles/eyfs-principles-breakdown-4117 (accessed February 2012).
Langston, A. (2011) ‘EYFS Review special – what it means for you and your practice’, Nursery World, 30
March, available at: www.nurseryworld.co.uk/news/1062969/EYFS-REVIEW-special—means-practice
(accessed March 2012).
Lindon, J. (2012) Understanding child development: linking theory and practice, 3rd edition, London:
Hodder Education.
Meggitt, C., Kamen, T., Bruce, T. and Grenier, J. (2011) CACHE Level 3 Diploma: Children and young
people’s workforce: early learning and child care, London: Hodder Education.
QCA (2001) Planning, teaching and assessing the curriculum for pupils with learning difficulties,
Coventry: Qualifications and Curriculum Authority.
Sheridan, M.D. (1997) From birth to five years: children’s developmental progress, London: Routledge.
SWSF (2008) What is Steiner education?, Stourbridge: Steiner Waldorf Schools Fellowship, available at:
www.steinerwaldorf.org/whatissteinereducation.html (accessed May 2012).
414
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and
literacy development in children and/or
young people (Unit CP 14)
The aim of this unit is to enable the learner to with colleagues how these learning activities will
support the development of numeracy and literacy be organised and what your particular role will be;
skills in children and/or young people. providing the agreed support as appropriate to the
different learning needs of children/young people;
and giving feedback to colleagues, parents and
Learning outcomes other professionals about the progress of children in
1. Understand numeracy and literacy developing numeracy and literacy skills.
learning when working with children
and/or young people. What is literacy?
2. Understand learning needs of
individual children and/or young Literacy means the ability to read and write. The
people when supporting the word ‘literacy’ has only fairly recently been applied
development of numeracy and as the definitive term for reading and writing
literacy skills. (especially when the National Literacy Strategy was
3. Be able to plan and deliver numeracy introduced in schools). It makes sense to use the
and literacy activities for children term ‘literacy’ as the skills of reading and writing do
and/or young people. complement one another and are developed together.
Reading and writing are forms of communication
4. Be able to reflect on own practice.
based on spoken language. Children need effective
speaking and listening skills in order to develop
literacy skills. Literacy unites the important skills of
415
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
measuring, and is presented in graphs, diagrams and The revised 2012 Early Years
tables.
Foundation Stage
On 6 July 2011, a revised draft EYFS framework was
Key terms
issued for consultation, taking forward proposals
Numeracy – competency in arithmetic. for reform: reducing paperwork and bureaucracy
Literacy – the ability to read and write. for professionals; focusing strongly on the three
prime areas of learning most essential for children’s
healthy development and future learning (with four
Curriculum frameworks specific areas in which the prime areas are applied);
simplifying assessment at age five, including to
which support reduce the early learning goals (ELGs) from 69
to 17; and providing for earlier intervention for
numeracy skills and those children who need extra help, through the
literacy skills introduction of a progress check when children are
age two (DfE 2011a, pp. 1 and 2).
You should know the relevant national regulatory
This revised EYFS was published on 27 March 2012
frameworks and curriculum guidelines for
and will be implemented from September 2012.
supporting numeracy skills and literacy skills which
(The 2008 EYFS will continue to be in force until
are relevant to the children and/or young people
31 August 2012.) There are seven areas of learning
you work with. In England, the relevant statutory
and development that must shape educational
frameworks are the revised Early Years Foundation
programmes in early years settings. Three areas are
Stage and the National Curriculum in England.
particularly important for igniting young children’s
In the schools white paper The Importance of curiosity and enthusiasm for learning and for
Teaching, published on 22 November 2010, building their capacity to learn and to thrive.
the coalition government set out its plans to These three areas, known as the prime areas,
reduce the amount of guidance and materials are: personal, social and emotional development;
offered to schools. The government believes physical development; and communication and
that schools should be free to use their own language. Early years providers must also support
professional judgment about how they teach, young children in four specific areas of learning
without unnecessary prescription. Non-statutory and development, through which the three prime
materials and guidance (such as the Literacy areas are strengthened and applied. The specific
Framework and Every Child a Writer) have areas are: literacy, mathematics, understanding the
been removed from the National Curriculum world, and expressive arts and design.
website and the site restructured accordingly. All
material previously available is preserved on the Prime area: communication and
UK government web archive: http://webarchive. language
nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110809091832/http:// Communication and language development involves
www.teachingandlearningresources.org.uk. giving children opportunities to experience a rich
language environment; to develop their confidence
Practitioners can make their own judgment about
and skills in expressing themselves; and to speak
the resources they use to prepare and teach the
and listen in a range of situations. By the end of the
curriculum or other related topics. Where guidance
EYFS, children should have achieved these early
is required, online copies of QCDA materials are still
learning goals in communication and language:
available for schools and other settings to access if
they wish: http://archive.teachfind.com/qcda/www. ●● Listening and attention: children listen
qcda.gov.uk/default.html. attentively in a range of situations. They listen
416
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
to stories, accurately anticipating key events write. Children must be given access to a wide
and respond to what they hear with relevant range of reading materials (books, poems and other
comments, questions or actions. They give written materials) to ignite their interest. By the end
their attention to what others say and respond of the EYFS, children should have achieved these
appropriately, while engaged in another activity. early learning goals in literacy:
●● Understanding: children follow instructions
●● Reading: children read and understand
involving several ideas or actions. They answer
simple sentences. They use phonic knowledge
‘how’ and ‘why’ questions about their experiences
to decode regular words and read them
and in response to stories or events.
aloud accurately. They also read some
●● Speaking: children express themselves effectively,
common irregular words. They demonstrate
showing awareness of listeners’ needs. They use past,
understanding when talking with others about
present and future forms accurately when talking
what they have read.
about events that have happened or are to happen ●● Writing: children use their phonic knowledge to
in the future. They develop their own narratives and
write words in ways which match their spoken
explanations by connecting ideas or events.
sounds. They also write some irregular common
(DfE 2012, pp. 7 and 8) words. They write simple sentences which can
be read by themselves and others. Some words
Specific area: literacy are spelt correctly and others are phonetically
Literacy development involves encouraging children plausible.
to link sounds and letters and to begin to read and (DfE 2012, pp. 8 and 9)
417
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
418
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
and in the world around them. Development is not The National Curriculum in
an automatic process, however. It depends on each
unique child having opportunities to interact in England
positive relationships and enabling environments The National Curriculum sets out the statutory
(Early Education 2012, p. 2). requirements for the knowledge and skills that
every child is expected to learn in schools. The
The four themes of the EYFS (A Unique Child, National Curriculum applies to children of
Positive Relationships, Enabling Environments, compulsory school age in schools in England.
and Learning and Development) underpin all The National Curriculum sets out what pupils
early years practice. Development Matters shows should study, what they should be taught and the
how these themes, and the principles that standards that they should achieve. Supporting
inform them, work together for children in the the learning of numeracy and literacy skills is
EYFS. part of the compulsory subjects of mathematics
and English in all key stages. In January 2011,
ity
Research Activ
the Secretary of State for Education announced
a review of the National Curriculum in England.
Find out more about supporting numeracy and While the review is being conducted, the existing
literacy in the EYFS. For example, have a look at the National Curriculum requirements for both
Foundation Years website: www.foundationyears. primary and secondary schools will remain in force.
org.uk. (Detailed information is given in Chapter 12.)
419
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Every child is a unique Children learn to be Children learn and develop Children develop and learn
Principles child who is constantly strong and independent well in enabling in different ways. The
learning and can be through positive environments, in which framework covers the
resilient, capable, relationships. their experiences respond education and care of all
confident and self-assured. to their individual needs children in early years
Practitioners Positive relationships are and there is a strong provision, including children
• understand and observe • warm and loving, and partnership between with special educational
each child’s development foster a sense of practitioners and parents needs and disabilities.
Practice and learning, assess belonging and carers.
Practitioners teach children
progress, plan for next • sensitive and responsive Enabling Environments by ensuring challenging,
steps to the child’s needs,
• value all people playful opportunities
• support babies and feelings and interests
• value learning. across the prime and
children to develop • supportive of the
specific areas of learning
a positive sense of their child’s own efforts They offer
and development.
own identity and culture and independence • stimulating resources,
• identify any need for • consistent in setting relevant to all the They foster the
additional support clear boundaries children’s cultures characteristics of
• keep children safe • stimulating and communities effective early learning
• value and respect all • built on key person • rich learning opportunities
children and families relationships in early • playing and exploring
through play and playful
equally. years settings. • active learning
teaching
• creating and thinking
• support for children to
critically.
take risks and explore.
Figure 13.4 How the four themes of the EYFS underpin all early years practice (adapted from’Development Matters in the Early
Years Foundation Stage’, p. 2, available at: http:// www.media.education.gov.uk/assets/files/pdf/d/development%20matters%20
in%20the%20eyfs.pdf)
English in the primary years in discussions and making relevant points. They
also learn how to listen carefully to what other
Teaching should ensure that work in ‘speaking and
people are saying, so that they can remember
listening’, ‘reading’ and ‘writing’ is integrated. The
the main points. They learn to use language in
programme of study for English and the National
imaginative ways and express their ideas and
Literacy Strategy Framework for teaching are
feelings when working in role and in drama
closely related. The framework provides a detailed
activities.
basis for implementing the statutory requirements
●● Reading: pupils’ interest and pleasure in
of the programmes of study for reading and
reading is developed as they learn to read
writing.
confidently and independently. They focus
In English, during Key Stage 1, pupils learn to on words and sentences and how they fit into
speak confidently and listen to what others have whole texts. They work out the meaning of
to say. They begin to read and write independently straightforward texts and say why they like
and with enthusiasm. They use language to explore them or do not like them.
their own experiences and imaginary worlds. For ●● Writing: pupils start to enjoy writing and see the
example: value of it. They learn to communicate meaning
●● Speaking and listening: pupils learn to speak in narrative and non-fiction texts and spell and
clearly, thinking about the needs of their listeners. punctuate correctly.
They work in small groups and as a class, joining (DfE 2011b, pp. 1–5)
420
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
In English, during Key Stage 2, pupils learn to reflect on the meaning of texts, analysing and
change the way they speak and write to suit different discussing them with others.
situations, purposes and audiences. They read a ●● Writing: pupils develop understanding that writing
range of texts and respond to different layers of is essential to both thinking and learning, and
meaning in them. They explore the use of language enjoyable in its own right. They learn the main
in literary and non-literary texts and learn how rules and conventions of written English and start
language works. For example: to explore how the English language can be used
to express meaning in different ways. They use the
●● Speaking and listening: pupils learn how to
planning, drafting and editing process to improve
speak in a range of contexts, adapting what
their work and to sustain their fiction and non-
they say and how they say it to the purpose
fiction writing.
and the audience. Taking varied roles in
groups gives them opportunities to contribute (DfE 2011b, pp. 6–9)
to situations with different demands. They
The Department for Education has published draft
also learn to respond appropriately to others,
primary National Curriculum programmes of study
thinking about what has been said and the
for English, mathematics and science; the final
language used.
programmes will be introduced into primary schools
●● Reading: pupils read enthusiastically a range
in September 2014. In English, children will be
of materials and use their knowledge of words,
taught to read using systematic phonics and there
sentences and texts to understand and respond to
will be a stronger emphasis on reading for pleasure.
the meaning. They increase their ability to read
In grammar, children will be expected to understand
challenging and lengthy texts independently. They
how to use apostrophes correctly and how to use
421
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
the subjunctive. Learning to recite poems and Mathematics in the primary years
taking part in debates and presentations will also be
During Key Stage 1, pupils learn to count and
expected (Gaunt 2012).
do basic number calculations, such as addition
and subtraction. Pupils learn how to talk about
ity
Research Activ mathematical problems and work out how to solve
them through practical activities. Pupils demonstrate
Find out more about English in Key Stage 1 and their thinking and problem-solving skills by using
Key Stage 2. For example, have a look at the
objects, pictures, diagrams, simple lists, tables,
section about primary ‘English’ on the Department
for Education website: www.education.gov.uk/ charts, words, numbers and symbols. They do
schools/teachingandlearning/curriculum/primary/ mental calculations (e.g. work out sums in their
b00198874/english. heads) without relying on calculators. They handle
and describe the various features of basic shapes.
They learn to estimate and measure a range of
English in the secondary years everyday objects.
During Key Stage 3, pupils should continue to
During Key Stage 2, pupils learn more about
extend the effective use of the four key English
numbers and the number system, including
skills by speaking clearly, listening closely, reading
doing more difficult number calculations, such
carefully and writing fluently. These skills will
as multiplication and division. Pupils talk about
help pupils to express themselves creatively and
mathematical problems and decide on strategies
increase their confidence about speaking in public
to tackle them. Pupils demonstrate their thinking
and writing for others. Pupils should read classic
and problem-solving skills by using mathematical
and contemporary prose and poetry from around
language, diagrams, words, numbers and symbols.
the world, examining how writers use language and
Pupils learn how to use calculators to solve certain
considering the social/moral issues raised.
mathematical problems but they are expected to
During Key Stage 4, pupils learn to use language solve most problems using mental calculations
confidently, both in their academic studies and in (e.g. working out sums in their heads) or writing
the world beyond school. Pupils use and analyse them down on paper. They handle and describe the
complex features of language; they are keen various features of more complex shapes. They learn
readers who can read many kinds of text and to answer questions by selecting, organising and
make articulate and perceptive comments about presenting appropriate data using tables, charts, and
them. graphs.
ity
ity Research Activ
Research Activ
Find out more about mathematics in Key Stage
Find out more about English in Key Stage 3, Key 1 and Key Stage 2. For example, have a look at
Stage 4 and beyond. For example, have a look the section about primary ‘mathematics’ on the
at the following sections on the Department for Department for Education website:www.education.
Education website: gov.uk/schools/teachingandlearning/curriculum/
primary/b00199044/mathematics.
• English in secondary schools: www.education.
gov.uk/schools/teachingandlearning/curriculum/
secondary/b00199101/english
Mathematics in the secondary years
• GCSEs: www.education.gov.uk/schools/
teachingandlearning/qualifications/gcses During Key Stage 3, pupils learn more about
numbers and the number system, more
• The 14 to 19 Diploma: www.education.gov.uk/
a0064416/what-is-the-diploma.
complex calculations, different ways of solving
mathematical problems and algebra. Pupils talk
422
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
423
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and/or young people’s Will a graph, chart or diagram help find the solution?
424
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
425
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
426
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
Activity Activity
• How did you develop your numeracy skills? Observe a young child during a numeracy activity.
How did your own children (if you have any) Then answer these questions:
develop their numeracy skills? (For example:
• Did the child achieve the learning objectives set?
singing number songs and rhymes; practical
If not, why not?
mathematics activities, such as sorting shapes,
measuring or shopping; playing number games; • If the child has achieved the learning objectives,
learning by rote, such as reciting times tables; what effect has it had (e.g. on the child’s
learning formal number operations, such as behaviour, learning, any special need)?
addition, subtraction, multiplication and division.)
• Were the learning objectives too easy or too hard
• What are the methods used to support the for the child?
development of numeracy skills in your setting?
• How did any staff involvement affect the child’s
• Consider the similarities and differences between achievement?
these methods.
• Was the activity plan successful? If not, why not?
You can help children to develop their numeracy 3. Providing opportunities for children to
skills by: use and apply mathematics in the setting
1. Using numbers in everyday activities and wider environment, such as through
with babies and toddlers, such as counting orientation exercises, nature walks and
stairs, and finger and toe games. geography and environmental studies, can
develop numeracy skills; educational visits
2. Encouraging children to use and apply can also contribute to mathematics across the
mathematics to tackle and solve everyday, curriculum (e.g. visits to science museums).
practical mathematical problems – for
example, giving change in shop play 4. Encouraging young children to explore
and real shopping trips (addition and numbers through playing games like
subtraction);exploring volume and capacity dominoes, snakes and ladders and other
during sand and water play, filling various simple board games; looking for shapes/
containers to encourage understanding of sizes and making comparisons, price tags and
full, empty, half-full, half-empty, nearly quantities in shop play and real shopping
full, nearly empty, more/less than, the trips; number songs and rhymes like ‘One, two,
same amount, then introduce idea of three, four, five, Once I caught a fish alive…’.
standard measures (e.g. litre of juice, pint 5. Supporting children engaged in counting,
of milk); using weighing and measuring calculating and solving mathematical
activities, such as shop play (using balance problems – for example, addition and
scales to compare toys and other items), subtraction, then multiplication and
real shopping (helping to weigh fruit and division. Supporting older children in
vegetables), sand play (heavy and light) and employing standard methods to perform
cooking activities (weighing ingredients to mental and written calculations, including
show importance of standard measures). addition, subtraction, multiplication and
427
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
division using whole numbers, fractions, minutes and solving problems relating to
decimals and percentages. time using a 12-hour or 24-hour clock.
6. Prompting children to communicate their 10. Encouraging children to explore shape
reasoning about problems and explaining and space through activities such as games
their solutions using objects, pictures, involving shape recognition; handling and
diagrams, numbers, symbols and relevant describing the various features of basic shapes
mathematical language: for example, using (e.g. using correct names for basic 2D and 3D
letter symbols in algebra and setting up and shapes and knowing how many sides, corners
using simple equations to solve problems. or right angles a shape has); and physical
activities involving whole turns, half turns
7. Supporting children’s use of calculator
and quarter turns or right angles, as well as
functions to complete complex
spatial awareness (e.g. PE, movement, dance).
calculations and understand the answers
Helping older children to learn more about
calculators give in relation to the initial
shapes and coordinates, constructing shapes
mathematical problem.
(geometry) and measurement, including using
8. Encouraging children to compare, estimate a ruler, protractor and compass to create
and measure a range of everyday objects – lines, angles and 2D or 3D shapes.
for example, developing an understanding
11. Using information and communication
of length by comparing everyday objects/
technology (ICT) to encourage or extend
toys and using mathematical language,
children’s knowledge, understanding
such as tall/taller/tallest, short/shorter/
and skills in mathematics – for example,
shortest, long/longer/longest, same height,
playing shape recognition games; writing
same length; and measuring objects using
instructions to create and change shapes
appropriate units, such as centimetres,
on a computer; and providing opportunities
metres, kilograms or litres.
for children to select, collect, organise
9. Helping children to tell the time – o’clock, and present appropriate data using lists,
half past and quarter past the hour; with charts, graphs, diagrams, tables, surveys,
older pupils telling the time in hours and questionnaires and CD-ROMs.
428
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
429
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
discuss cause and effect in history and geography; Being able to read does not happen suddenly.
and discuss social or moral issues in PSHE and RE. Reading is a complex process involving different
skills, some of which (e.g. visual discrimination
Speaking and listening skills involve: and communication skills) the individual has
●● speaking: being able to speak clearly and to been developing since birth. Being able to use and
develop and sustain ideas in talk understand spoken language forms the basis for
●● listening: developing active listening strategies developing reading skills. A child who has a wide
and critical skills of analysis variety of language experiences will have developed
●● group discussion and interaction: taking many of the skills needed for learning to read.
different roles in groups, making a range of Children who are pushed too hard by being forced
contributions and working collaboratively to read and write before they are ready may actually
●● drama: improvising and working in role, be harmed in terms of their literacy development as
scripting and performing, and responding to they can be put off reading, writing and other related
performances. activities. The prime area ‘communication and
language’ and the specific area ‘literacy’ included
(DfES 2003a)
in the revised Early Years Foundation Stage provide
guidelines to help early years staff (and parents)
Developing reading skills understand the importance of informal approaches
Reading is the process of turning groups of written to language and literacy.
symbols into speech sounds. In English, this
means being able to read from left to right, from There is no set age at which children are magically
the top of the page to the bottom and being able ready to read, although most children learn to read
to recognise letter symbols and their combinations between the ages of four and a half and six years old.
as words. Reading is not just one skill; it involves The age at which a child learns to read depends on a
a variety of different abilities: visual and auditory number of factors: physical maturity and coordination
discrimination; language and communication skills; social and emotional development; language
skills; word identification skills; conceptual experiences, especially access to books; interest in
understanding; comprehension skills; and memory stories and rhymes; concentration and memory skills;
and concentration. and opportunities for play.
430
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
Reading approaches
Most adults helping children to develop Phonics approach
reading skills use a combination of the ‘look
and say’ approach to introduce early sight With this approach, children learn the sounds that
vocabulary and then move on to the more letters usually make. This approach helps children
intensive phonics approach to establish the establish a much larger reading vocabulary fairly
children’s reading vocabulary. It is important quickly as they can ‘sound out’ new words for
for you to be flexible to meet the individual themselves. The disadvantage is that there are
literacy needs of children. You should also many irregular words in the English language;
work with parents to develop their children’s one letter may make many different sounds –
reading skills. for example, bough, rough, through. However,
children do better with the phonics approach than
Whole-word or ‘look and say’ approach any other approach.
431
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
●● functional writing (e.g. shopping lists, recipes, Developing writing skills is much more difficult
menus, recording experiments or data) then reading because of the considerable physical
●● sharing stories and ideas (e.g. story writing, and cognitive demands of writing – for example,
poetry). coordinating movements to write; writing legibly
(e.g. letters of consistent size and shape); leaving gaps
Children do not learn to write just through between words; using the correct punctuation and
exposure to a writing environment. Writing is sentence structure; following the correct spelling
a skill that has to be taught. Learning to write requirements; and writing material of the required
involves learning specific conventions with regard length, which also makes sense. Remember that some
to letter shapes, the sequence of letters in words, children may have special needs which require them
word order in sentences, the direction of writing, to use alternative means or specialist equipment (e.g.
etc. It is usual to teach writing skills alongside Braille, voice-activated computer or word processor).
reading. This helps children to make the connection
between written letters and the sounds they
make when reading. Most of the activities used to
Activity
develop children’s reading skills will also help their
1 How did you learn to write? How did your own
writing skills. In addition, children need plenty of children (if you have any) learn to write?
opportunities to develop the coordination skills
2 What are the opportunities provided to develop
necessary for writing – for example, hand–eye
children’s writing skills in your setting?
coordination, fine manipulative skills for pencil
control and being able to sit still with the correct 3 Consider the similarities and differences between
these experiences.
posture for writing.
432
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
Activity
Observe a young child during a literacy activity. Then answer these questions:
• Did the child achieve the learning objectives set? If not, why not?
• If the child has achieved the learning objectives, what effect has it had (e.g. on the child’s behaviour,
learning, any special need)?
• Were the learning objectives too easy or too hard for the child?
• How did any staff involvement affect the child’s achievement?
• Was the activity plan successful? If not, why not?
You can help children to develop their literacy opportunities for discussion, such as: circle
skills by: time; story time; problem solving during
activities; follow-up to activities (e.g. after
1. Providing plenty of opportunities for
television programmes or stories); cooperative
children to talk – children who are effective
group work; games and puzzles; and talking
communicators often transfer these skills
about key features when on outings.
to reading and writing. Provide plenty of
433
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
2. Sharing books, stories, poems and rhymes memory skills (e.g. snap, matching pairs,
to introduce children to different literary jigsaws and games like ‘I went shopping…’).
styles or genres, including picture books, Provide fun activities to develop letter
storybooks, ‘big’ books, novels, poetry recognition, such as ‘I spy…’ using letter
books, information books, dictionaries, sounds; going on a ‘letter hunt’ (looking
encyclopaedias and atlases. This also includes around the classroom for things beginning
looking at other types of printed materials with a particular letter); hanging up an
(e.g. newspapers, magazines, comics, signs). ‘alphabet washing line’; and singing alphabet
These will encourage children’s listening songs and rhymes.
skills and auditory discrimination and provide 7. Providing opportunities for the children
stimulus for discussion and literacy activities, to write for different purposes and for
as well introducing or extending their different audiences, such as: writing about
vocabulary. their own experiences as appropriate to their
3. Encouraging children to participate age and level of development (e.g. news
in appropriate opportunities for play, and recording events); creating their own
especially activities that encourage language stories and poems as a means of expressing
and communication – for example, role/ their feelings and ideas; using class or group
pretend play, such as dressing-up, home topics as well as the children’s own interests
corner, shop play, creative activities. to stimulate their ideas for stories and
poems; and using storybooks as a starting
4. Using displays as a stimulus for discussions
point for the children’s own creative writing.
and to consolidate learning– for example,
Provide children with opportunities to
wall and interactive tabletop displays with
write in different styles, such as: writing
interesting objects to talk about, look at
letters; writing reports; writing step-by-
and/or play with, as well as recorded sounds
step instructions; and designing posters,
to listen to, including voices, music, songs,
signs and notices. Encourage children to use
rhymes and musical instruments.
independent spelling techniques (e.g. word
5. Providing opportunities for children to banks, personal word books and dictionaries).
follow and give instructions, such as:
8. Using alternative writing methods to release
introducing or extending knowledge on a
younger children or those with coordination
specific skill; specifying tasks (verbal and/
difficulties (such as dyspraxia) from their
or written on a board); listening to step-by-
physical limitations of writing – for example,
step instructions; explaining worksheets,
allowing them to dictate their ideas while an
work cards or textbooks; verbal instructions
adult acts as scribe or use a tape recorder or
during an activity to keep children on task
word processor.
or providing extra support for individual
children; and delivering verbal/written 9. Considering the individual interests and
messages or errands. abilities of children, including valuing
children’s home experiences/cultural
6. Encouraging children to participate in
backgrounds and being aware of possible
games to develop auditory and visual
developmental or psychological difficulties
discrimination, like sound lotto and ‘guess
that may affect their speaking and listening
the sound’ using sounds of everyday objects
skills by carefully observing children’s
or musical instruments. Encourage children to
development and learning. (See section on
participate in matching games and memory
supporting children with special numeracy
games to develop visual discrimination and
and/or literacy needs on page 441.)
434
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
10. Using ICT to encourage or extend children’s on topics and themes within the setting.
literacy skills, including television, CD- Remember that ICT is not a substitute for
ROMs and the internet as additional stimuli other forms of communication, such as
for discussions and ideas. ICT can also be conversation and children’s play.
used to introduce or reinforce information
Activity
1 Suggest ways to support the development of Does the library have an educational department
children’s literacy skills. Use your own experiences or provide workshops for children?
of working with children if possible. You could use
3 Think about how you could use a visit to a library
your observation of a young child engaged in a
with the children from your setting to develop their
literacy activity as the starting point for this activity.
literacy skills.
2 Visit a library in your local area. What activities are
available to support children’s literacy learning?
435
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
and/or young people you to understand the ways children learn and
to assist them in achieving educational success.
when supporting the (See ‘Different learning styles’ on page 366 in
Chapter 11.)
development of numeracy
Visual learners
and literacy skills Visual learners learn best by seeing the learning
Effective planning to support the development of material – for example, looking at charts, tables,
children’s numeracy and literacy skills is based on illustrated textbooks, overhead transparencies,
each child’s individual needs, abilities and interests. videos, flip charts, handouts and maps. Visual
This is why accurate observations and assessments learners need clear sight lines without irrelevant
are so important. These needs have to be integrated obstructions, such as other people’s heads. Visual
into the curriculum requirements for your particular learners should look at the practitioner when they are
setting and the age group(s) of the children you speaking, participate in group/class discussions and
work with – for example, in England, the Early Years take detailed notes during lectures. Visual learners
Foundation Stage or the National Curriculum (see enjoy watching the practitioner’s body language and
page 416). The curriculum sets out the standards to facial expression as this helps them to understand
be used to measure the progress and performance the content of the topic under discussion.
of children/young people in each subject to help
Visual learners often have trouble working while
practitioners plan and implement learning activities
having a conversation, even if the discussion directly
that meet the individual learning needs of the
relates to the subject matter. When studying, visual
children and/or young people they work with.
learners tend to work alone in a quiet place and try to
(Detailed information about curriculum planning
transcribe their material on paper, including making
can be found in Chapter 12.)
designs, drawings, graphs or tables of complex,
abstract ideas. Completing tasks using diagrams,
Potential individual time lines, charts or graphs helps visual learners to
learning needs in remember important concepts. Visual learners need
to either take written notes or underline important
relation to numeracy facts and dates in colours. When they are learning
and literacy auditory concepts such as phonics, visual learners
need to see the letters to learn. (Morris 2011)
Children and young people have different ways
of processing information. They use the skills of Auditory learners
looking, listening or touching in varying amounts Auditory learners tend to learn mainly by hearing
depending on their individual learning style. For information. They learn best through their ears,
example, some children require visual stimulation especially via verbal discussions, talking things
(visual learners), some respond well to verbal through and listening to the words of others.
instructions (auditory learners), while others They interpret the underlying meanings of speech
need more ‘hands-on’ experiences (kinaesthetic through listening to tone of voice, pitch, speed and
learners). In addition, different times of the day other nuances. When they have pages to read, they
affect individual levels of concentration; some need to quietly say the words aloud in order to hear
436
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
437
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
• create mnemonics to aid memory (e.g. the • provide opportunities for learners to take
mnemonic SPICE to help learners remember the frequent breaks from more formal learning
different aspects of children’s development: • encourage them to handle learning materials
Social, Physical, Intellectual, Communication, (e.g. 3D models, props during story time)
Emotional) • allow them to move around to learn new
• provide opportunities for them to discuss their things (e.g. read while on an exercise bike,
ideas verbally mould a piece of clay to learn a new concept)
• get them to dictate while you write down their • allow them to work at a standing position
thoughts • use bright colours to highlight reading
• use verbal analogies and storytelling to material
demonstrate your point. • play music in the background to aid
concentration during activities
With kinaesthetic learners:
• provide space for freedom of movement
• provide plenty of opportunities for active • use the local environment to provide a
learning, such as play activities stimulus for learning (e.g. outings to the park).
In Practice
Suggest ways to support the following children’s activities. She can be distracted during some
numeracy and literacy skills according to their learning activities by chatting too much with her
learning styles. best friend, Miriam.
Visual learners: ❏❏ Johnson is a studious but very talkative child.
He has very good language and communication
❏❏ Lucy is a fairly quiet child who needs lots of
skills and is always a keen participant in group/
encouragement to participate in group/class
class discussions. He particularly enjoys history
discussions but who works well in individual
and geography activities.
and small-group situations. She particularly likes
learning activities that involve ICT graphics. She Kinaesthetic learners:
needs extra support for numeracy activities.
❏❏ Chrissie is a capable child who enjoys learning
❏❏ Tom is a very able, articulate child with a lively activities involving practical construction skills,
imagination and sense of humour. He has such as design technology. She needs extra
excellent language and communication skills. He support for literacy activities.
loves books and stories, especially those with an
❏❏ Peter finds it difficult to concentrate during some
historical or religious background.
learning activities and can be easily distracted by
Auditory learners: his best friend, Jonas. He likes practical activities
and enjoys PE, particularly games involving
❏❏ Rebecca is a studious and articulate child who
climbing or ball skills. He requires some additional
participates fully in group/class discussions. She
support for both literacy and numeracy skills.
is very competent in both literacy and numeracy
438
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
439
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
each child and your understanding of holistic Depending on the type of setting, you will also need
development and learning. (More information about to plan provision based on the requirements for the
holistic development can be found on pages 49–66 relevant curriculum frameworks for numeracy and
of Chapter 5 ‘Understand child and young person literacy. Providing numeracy and literacy activities
development’ in Meggitt et al. 2011.) for young children involves the following:
Following your observation and assessment of a ●● Planning: defining aims and objectives, including
child‘s development, learning and/or behaviour, planned and possible outcomes in play. Building
your recommendations can provide the basis for on previous outcomes from play.
●● Organisation: indoor and outdoor environments:
planning appropriate activities to encourage and
extend the child’s skills in specific areas, such as space, resources, time, daily routines, activities,
numeracy and literacy. Effective planning is based what adults do, what children do.
●● Implementation: the ways in which adult-
on children’s individual needs, abilities and interests,
hence the importance of accurate and reliable child initiated activities and tasks are presented in
observations and assessments. (See Figure 1.22 order to support intended and possible learning
‘Planning children’s activities’ on page 42.) outcomes and build on previous learning
experiences and interests. The ways in which
440
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
adults allow time for and follow play and child- When planning numeracy and literacy activities, you
initiated activities. need to be able to:
●● Assessment, documentation and evaluation:
●● understand the intended learning outcomes for the
understanding patterns of learning, interests,
children
temperaments. Identifying learning outcomes ●● agree on the support strategies to be used for each
from adult- and child-initiated activities.
child
Documenting learning in order to provide a ●● obtain the resources required for the activity
feedback loop into planning. Using evidence from ●● implement the agreed strategies to develop
all adults in the setting to evaluate the quality and
children’s numeracy or literacy skills
effectiveness of the curriculum. ●● provide feedback and encouragement during the
(Wood and Attfield 2005, p. 139) numeracy or literacy activity
●● monitor the progress of the children during the
When planning numeracy and literacy activities, numeracy or literacy activity
your overall aims should include: ●● report achievements and any problems relating
●● supporting the care and development of all the to the children’s numeracy and/or literacy
children you work with development to the relevant people (e.g.
●● ensuring every child has full access to the colleagues, parents, specialists).
appropriate curriculum
●● meeting children’s individual developmental and Supporting children with
learning needs
●● building on each child’s existing knowledge,
special numeracy and/
understanding and skills. or literacy needs
Some children may have special numeracy and/
In Practice or literacy needs because the language used in
Describe how you plan the provision of numeracy numeracy and literacy activities may be too complex
and literacy activities to promote children’s for them to understand. Lack of concentration and/or
development in your setting. Include examples of poor memory skills can prevent some children from
any planning sheets you use. learning important techniques, such as times tables
or letter sounds. Frequent experiences of failure
during numeracy or literacy activities can make
Recognising individual some children anxious, discouraged and lacking in
confidence so that they fall behind in their numeracy
needs when planning or literacy development.
numeracy and literacy Mathematical skills involve a wide range of specific
activities capabilities, any of which can prove difficult for
particular children and affect their numeracy
When planning numeracy and literacy activities, it development. It is important to find out what
is essential to recognise the individual needs of the the child knows and where the problem lies. It is
children. The practitioner has a key role in providing important to make sure that the child’s problem
support for children during numeracy and literacy with numeracy is not in fact a problem with literacy.
activities. You need to understand how numeracy For example, some children may: not be able to
and literacy activities are organised in your setting understand the written question; have handwriting
and your specific role in supporting various learning or directional problems, resulting in inaccurate
activities, including class discussions, group work recording and errors; or have poor motor skills,
and tasks for individuals. causing miscalculations when using a calculator.
441
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The following support strategies can be used to • Playing a mathematical game with an
help children to develop their numeracy skills individual child or small group.
(appropriate for their age, ability and individual • Helping children to use computer software and
needs): learning programmes.
• Helping children to select and use appropriate
• Using questions and prompts to encourage
mathematical resources (e.g. number lines,
mathematical skills.
measuring instruments).
• Repeating instructions as necessary.
• Assisting children with special equipment (e.g.
• Taking notes for a child while a colleague is
a hearing aid or a Dictaphone).
talking.
• Encouraging shy or reticent children to
• Explaining and reinforcing correct
participate in conversations and discussions.
mathematical vocabulary.
• Providing any other appropriate assistance
• Reading and clarifying textbook/worksheet
during an activity.
activity for a child.
• Monitoring children’s progress during an
• Introducing follow-on tasks to reinforce and
activity.
extend learning (e.g. problem-solving tasks,
• Reporting problems and successes to
puzzles).
colleagues, parents and other professionals.
The following support strategies can be used • Promoting the use of dictionaries.
to help children to develop their literacy skills • Reading and clarifying textbook/worksheet
(appropriate for their age, ability and individual activity for a child.
needs): • Reading a story to an individual child or small
group.
• Using targeted prompts and feedback to
• Playing a word game with an individual child
encourage independent reading and writing.
or small group.
• Encouraging children to participate in shared
• Directing computer-assisted learning
reading and writing activities.
programmes.
• Developing phonic knowledge and skills to
• Assisting children with special equipment (e.g.
help children read and spell accurately.
a hearing aid or a Dictaphone).
• Using specific reading or writing support
• Encouraging shy or reticent children to
strategies (e.g. paired reading, writing frames).
participate in conversations and discussions.
• Using specific reading or writing support
• Providing any other appropriate assistance
programmes (e.g. graded reading books).
during an activity.
• Repeating instructions as necessary.
• Monitoring children’s progress during an
• Taking notes for a child while another
activity.
practitioner is talking.
• Reporting problems and successes to parents,
• Explaining difficult words and phrases to a
colleagues and other professionals.
child.
442
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
Some children may have special numeracy and/ Many children with special educational needs
or literacy needs due to special educational needs (e.g. those with physical disabilities or sensory
(SEN), such as cognitive and learning difficulties, impairment) will not require a separate learning
sensory impairment, physical disabilities or programme for developing numeracy and/or
behavioural difficulties. The range of children with literacy skills. For most of them, access, materials,
SEN varies from setting to setting. Many children equipment and furniture may require adapting
with SEN may not have special numeracy or to meet their particular needs so that they can
literacy needs and will not require extra or different work alongside the rest of their group or class.
numeracy or literacy support. However, many They should work on the same objectives for their
groups/classes will have one or more children with year group with emphasis on access and support.
identified SEN who require a modified approach to Adaptations that may be necessary include sign
developing numeracy and literacy skills. language, Braille and symbols, tactile materials,
technological aids and adapted measuring
The two broad groups of children equipment. Some children will need to work on
the development of particular numeracy or
with special numeracy and literacy skills for longer than others – for example,
literacy needs children with speech and language difficulties
may need to work on programmes devised
1. The first, larger group comprises children by a speech therapist or specialist language
who experience minor difficulties in teacher.
learning, which is reflected in their
attainment of levels of numeracy and/or
literacy, which are below those expected
for children of their age. These children
can usually overcome these difficulties Assisting children with special
through normal teaching strategies and numeracy and literacy needs
will soon develop the essential numeracy
and literacy skills that will enable them to You may provide assistance for children
catch up and work at a comparable level to with special numeracy and literacy
the rest of their year group. needs by:
2. The second, smaller group includes • signing to support a child with hearing
children with severe and complex learning impairment during shared numeracy/
difficulties that require the use of different literacy activities
teaching strategies. These children may • supporting a child during group work to
require different levels of work from the develop specific numeracy or literacy
rest of their year group. They may need skills
to be taught at a different pace for all or • asking questions aimed at the appropriate
most of their school years. Some children level
with SEN will always need access to • giving the child some extra help in a
systems such as symbols, signing, Braille group
or electronic communicators. • sitting next to the child to keep them on
(DfES 1999) task.
443
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
444
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
●● remembering sequences (e.g. days of the week/ ●● memorising and recalling maths facts (e.g.
months of the year) recalling tables, mental arithmetic).
●● following verbal and/or written instructions.
445
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
learning, supporting their language development English but need a little extra support with literacy
at home. Practitioners must also ensure that and numeracy activities
446
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
447
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
The Unique Child reaches out to Prime areas are fundamental, work
relate to people and things through together, and move through to
the Characteristics of Effective support development in all other
Learning, which move through all areas.
d
l an t Lite
areas of learning.
S o cia pmen racy • Personal, Social and Emotional
• Playing and exploring a l , velo
son De Development
• Active learning pl Per ional
ay Emot • Communication and Language
• Creating and thinking critically. in
g ng • Physical Development.
an rni
d ea
Comm guage
ex l
e
and La
pl iv
or t
Expressive Arts
in ac
and Design
g
unicati
n
Unique
on
Child
lly
Ph
ys
g critica
ica
lD
ics
at
ev
m
el
op
he
& thinkin
Children develop in the
at
m Specific areas include essential
en
M
context of relationships t g
standin skills and knowledge for children to
and the environment Under orld participate successfully in society.
around them. the W
creating
• Literacy
This is unique to each • Mathematics
family, and reflects • Understanding the World
individual communities
and cultures. • Expressive Arts and Design.
Figure 13.15 The prime and specific areas of learning and development are all interconnected (adapted from ’Development
Matters in the Early Years Foundation Stage’, p. 4, available at link provided in Figure 13.4 caption, page 420)
opportunities which will allow children to reflect on, learning through curriculum subject areas. These
use and develop their literacy and numeracy skills – subject areas provide children with powerful tools
in the early years setting, this is delivered through for making sense of the world and incorporate
play (see below). Children should be involved in distinctive, as well as interconnected, ways
discussions about what they are good at and what of learning. (Wood and Attfield 2005, p. 122)
they need to do to improve and extend their learning. Practitioners need a good understanding of the
Practitioners should plan how best to enhance structures of the subject areas of the curriculum – the
children’s literacy skills, given that the opportunities concepts, skills, tools for enquiry and investigation,
to do so are embedded across the curriculum – and ways of thinking and reasoning. They also need
especially through speaking and listening. Effective to understand the way that different curriculum
planning should ensure that numeracy is highlighted subjects are connected – how these connections
in relevant and meaningful ways across learning can be made and what connections children make
– and not simply forced to fit into every learning through their own activities. (Wood and Attfield
activity. (LTS 2010, p. 7) 2005, p. 137)
448
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
solve a variety of addition and subtraction word Linking play and literacy involves imaginative
problems. These strategies are often evident in planning, varied resources and engaging with
play contexts as children encounter problems and children to provide an appreciative audience and
develop their own solutions. Practitioners can build support their developing skills and confidence.
on children’s invented strategies and create contexts Provision that has breadth and relevance to
in which they move through different stages of children’s lives helps them to engage in reading and
learning to explore the relationships between writing for a variety of purposes in real situations.
ideas and to link their own informal strategies to Playing their way into literacy provides powerful
the more formal symbol system of mathematics. stimuli for learning. Practitioners can extend
Like all the subject areas, mathematics has its own children’s understanding of the literacy events which
language, ways of thinking, reasoning, problem take place in real-world contexts. For example:
solving, methods, rules and procedures. Children’s ●● writing a menu
success in solving mathematical problems depends ●● reading a recipe
on their ability to relate mathematics to familiar, ●● filling out cheques, signing receipts
everyday practices. Play activities can provide a ●● reading brochures and filling out booking forms in
range of contexts for integrating mathematics into
a travel agency
everyday practices that children encounter in and ●● drawing maps and plans of journeys
out of the setting. ●● drawing plans for buildings, parks, playgrounds
●● designing cards, posters, badges, clothes, book
449
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
450
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
451
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
452
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
If not, why not? Were the goals too ambitious or your self-assessments with those responsible for
unrealistic? managing and reviewing your work performance
●● What other strategies/methods could have been (e.g. during your regular discussions/meetings
used? Suggest possible modifications. with your colleagues or with your line manager).
●● Who should you ask for further advice (e.g. senior You should also ask other people for feedback how
practitioner, setting manager, other professional)? well you fulfil the requirements and expectations
of your role. You can also reflect on your own
professional practice by making comparisons with
Reflecting on own appropriate models of good practice (e.g. the work
practice in supporting of more experienced practitioners supporting the
development of children’s numeracy and literacy
the delivery and skills within the setting).
outcome of the
Drawing conclusions
activities
which show how to
You need to know and understand clearly your exact
role and responsibilities in supporting the delivery extend and refine future
and outcome of numeracy and literacy activities. practice
Review your professional practice by making regular
and realistic assessments of how well your working You should work together with your colleagues
practices match your role and responsibilities. Share and other professionals to create a learning
453
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Useful resources
454
Chapter 13 Supporting numeracy and literacy development in children and/or young people (Unit CP 14)
DfE (2011c) Primary curriculum subjects – Mathematics, London: Department for Education,
available at: www.education.gov.uk/schools/teachingandlearning/curriculum/primary/b00199044/
mathematics(accessed May 2012)
DfE (2012) Statutory framework for the Early Years Foundation Stage: setting the standards for
learning, development and care for children from birth to five, London: Department for Education,
available at: www.education.gov.uk/publications/standard/AllPublications/Page1/DFE-00023-2012
(accessed March 2012).
DfES (1999) The national numeracy strategy – framework for teaching mathematics from reception
to Y6, London: Department for Education and Skills.
DfES (2003a) Primary national strategy – speaking, listening, learning: working with children in Key
Stages 1 and 2 handbook, London: Department for Education and Skills.
DfES (2003b) Electronic adult numeracy core curriculum with access for all, London: Department for
Education and Skills.
DfES (2005) Primary national strategy: KEEP – Key Elements of Effective Practice, London: Department
for Education and Skills, available at:http://dera.ioe.ac.uk/7593/1/pns_fs120105keep.pdf (accessed
May 2012).
Drake, J. (2009) Planning for children’s play and learning, London: David Fulton Publishers.
Early Education (2012) Development matters in the Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS), London: The
British Association for Early Childhood Education, available at: http://media.education.gov.uk/
assets/files/pdf/d/development%20matters%20in%20the%20eyfs.pdf (accessed June 2012).
Gaunt, C. (2012) ‘Primary curriculum overhaul for maths, science and English’, Nursery
World, 11 June, available at: www.nurseryworld.co.uk/news/bulletin/nurseryworldupdate/
article/1135745/?DCMP=EMC-CONNurseryWorldUpdate (accessed June 2012).
Godwin, D. and Perkins, M. (2002) Teaching language and literacy in the early years, London: David
Fulton Publishers.
Goldhawk, S. (1998) Young children and the arts: making creative connections – a report of the task
force on children’s learning and the arts: birth to age eight, Washington: Arts Education Partnership,
available at:www.eric.ed.gov/PDFS/ED453968.pdf (accessed May 2012).
Hobart, C. and Frankel, J. (2005) The EYFS: A Practical Guide for Students and Professional children, 3rd
edition, Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes.
Hutchin, V. (2012) The EYFS: A Practical Guide for Students and Professionals, London: Hodder
Education.
LTS (2010) Developing literacy and numeracy across learning – professional development pack,
Glasgow: Learning and Teaching Scotland, available at: www.educationscotland.gov.uk/Images/
Developingliteracyandnumeracyacrosslearning_tcm4-645064.pdf(accessed June 2012).
Meggitt, C., Kamen, T., Bruce, T. and Grenier, J. (2011) CACHE Level 3 Diploma: Children and young
people’s workforce: early learning and child care, London: Hodder Education.
Morris, C. (2011) Best way to learn, ‘Success is working smarter and harder’ website, available at:www.
igs.net/~cmorris/best_way_to_learn.html (accessed June 2012).
Moyle, D. (1976) The teaching of reading, East Grinstead: Ward Lock Educational.
NDNA (2004) National occupational standards in children’s care, learning and development, Huddersfield:
National Day Nurseries Association.
Palmer, S. and Bayley, R. (2004) Foundations of literacy: a balanced approach to language, listening and
literacy skills in the early years, Stafford: Network Educational Press Ltd.
Siraj-Blatchford, J. and Clarke, P. (2000) Supporting identity, diversity and language in the early years,
Maidenhead: Open University Press.
455
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
Taylor, J. (1973) Reading and writing in the first school, London: George Allen and Unwin.
Tobias, C. (1996) The way they learn, Colorado Springs: Focus on the Family Publishing.
Topping, K. and Bamford, J. (1998) The paired maths handbook: parental involvement and peer tutoring
in mathematics, London: David Fulton Publishers.
Whitehead, M.R. (2004) Language and literacy in the early year, London: Sage Publications Ltd.
Williams, S. and Goodman, S. (2000) Helping young children with maths, London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Wood, E. and Attfield, J. (2005) Play, learning and the early childhood curriculum, 2nd edition, London:
Sage Publications Ltd.
Wright, R.J., Martland, J., Stafford, A.K. and Stanger, G. (2002) Teaching number: advancing children’s
skills and strategies, London: Paul Chapman Publishing.
456
anxiety 7–8
Index see also stress
appetite, loss of 95
applied research 302
abdominal pain 94–5 appraisals 136
abnormal skin colour 95 art
academic activities 367–76
reading 151 benefits of 360–2
referencing systems 180–2 interpreting 350
writing 173–7, 179–80 in the primary years 339
see also research; study skills in the secondary years 340
accidents skills 348–54
prevention of 85 see also creativity; drama; music
reporting 85, 97, 294–6 arthropods 87
see also first aid assertive discipline (AD) model 255–8, 262–3, 267
accommodation 23 see also behaviour management
acronyms 153, 156–7 assertiveness 255–7
action-centred leadership model 127–8 assimilation 23
see also leadership asthma 92
Action for Children 221 attachment disorder 254
action research 317–18 attachment theory 29–33, 49–50, 197–200
active avoidant attachment 32
immunity 114 informing practice 33, 49–50, 200–1
learning 47, 380 multiple attachments 199
reading 151 secure attachment 197–8
Adair, J. 127–8 separation anxiety 198–9
adaptation 23 ‘strange situation’ 198
adjustment disorders 254 attention
admission policy 64 seeking 253
adolescence 12 span 47
and sleep 100 attention deficit hyperactivity disorder 254
adult-directed activities 403–6 auditory learning style 185, 366, 436–8
adult role authoritarian parenting style 203, 205–6
in children’s development 25–8 authoritative (democratic) parenting style 203–6
when to step in 39, 44–5 Autism 254
see also families; parents; practitioner autobiographical accounts (diaries) 321
advertising, effect on diet and nutrition 102–3 autocratic leadership style 78, 129
advocacy 218 see also leadership
aggression, in children 6, 254 avoidant attachment 32
see also behaviour; behaviour management see also attachment theory
Ainsworth, M. 30, 198
Alexander, S. 55 babies
allergies 85, 92 in crisis 221
alternative hypothesis 309 and personality 35
anal-retentive personality 10 and stress 199
analytic learners 366 baby foods 99
anaphylaxis procedure 89 Bandura, A. 5–6
457
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
458
Index
459
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
psychoanalytic theories 8–15 Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS) 49, 61–2,
social constructivist theories 21–9, 34–5 252, 293, 337, 380–87, 416–19
social learning theory 5–6 guiding principles 381, 419–20
developmental capacity 275–6 see also curriculum; Key Stages
diabetes 92, 94, 95–6 eczema 92
diarrhoea 95, 101 educational psychologists 269
diets, special 88 egocentric illusion 24
see also food and nutrition egocentricity 22–4
diphtheria 116 emergency procedures 89
directed research 303 see also illness: signs/symptoms of
disabilities, children with 92, 241, 279 emotional
Disability Discrimination Act 1995 65 dependence 45, 350
discipline 256 development 35–6
see also behaviour management intelligence (EI) 132, 258–9
discourse analysis 170 safety 280–1
discrimination 190 well-being 46
diseases emotions, expressing 218
infectious 106–113, 116–18 encephalitis 107
notifiable 90 English, as additional language 446–7
see also illness environmental triggers 35
disposal of waste 86 environments
distributed leadership model 127 and behaviour 253
see also leadership for children and families 40
divorce 213 for expressive arts and design 346–7
dolls 356 influence of 20
Donaldson, M. 23–5 positive behaviour 276–7
drama safety of 280–1
activities 356–7, 367–76 Effective Provision of Pre-School Education
benefits of 362–3 (EPPE) project 207, 210
in the primary years 340–1 equality 65, 190
in the secondary years 341–2 Equality Act 2010 65
skills 355–7 Erikson, E. 11–12, 15
see also art; creativity; music essays 163–4
drawing 347–54 ethics 324–5
as first writing attempt 351 ethnic minority agencies 270
drinks 88 ethnography 316
drowsiness 95 ethos, of setting 144
Drucker, P. 131 evidence-based practice 189
dyscalculia 445 exercise 100, 102, 104
dyslexia 444–5 experiential learning cycle 183
expert model, working with families 189
ear expressive arts and design 338
infection 107 see also art; creativity; drama; music
pulling on 95 extended family 202
early
educators 37–9 facilitative leadership model 127
intervention 189 see also leadership
460
Index
461
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
462
Index
through play 37, 47 measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine 119
see also study skills; training and development medicine policy 89
legislation, and policy development 63 meetings 291–3
leisure and recreation 100, 102, 104 meningitis 107–9
letters, formal 177, 290–1 middle ear infection (otitis media) 107
life experiences, factors influencing 211–15 middle manager 130
line graphs 175 Millennium Cohort Study (MCS) 205
listening, in children 420–1, 429–30 mind maps 156
literacy 415, 417, 420–2 minutes, of a meeting 292–3
activities 439–42 mission statement 123
and dyslexia 444–5 MMR (measles, mumps and rubella)
English, as additional language 446–7 vaccine 119
and play 449 model making 348
and special educational needs (SEN) 443–7 monotropy 30
supporting learning 428–35, 437–8, 442 Montessori, M. 38–9, 396
‘Little Albert’ 3 Montessori method 396
Locke, J. 34 motivation 141–3, 160–2
logical thinking 23 ‘mountains’ task 23
long-term illness 92, 95–6 multi-agency working 235–49, 297–8
longitudinal studies 322 multiple attachments 199
looked after children 201 see also attachment theory
mumps 109, 110, 116, 119
maltreatment, effect on health 101 music
see also child protection; safeguarding activities 348, 358–60, 367–76
management 78 benefits of 364–5
of change 135, 140 primary years 343–4
definitions of 124–5 secondary years 344–5
learning styles 134–5 skills 358–60
‘measuring what matters’ 140 see also art; creativity; drama
performance 136–7, 143 musical instruments 358–9
project 135–6 Myers-Briggs type indicator 135
quality assurance 141
soft skills 132–3 National Curriculum 385–6, 419–23
styles 137 see also curriculum; Early Years Foundation
of teams 133–4, 136 Stage (EYFS); Key Stages
theories and models of 130–7 National Immunisation Schedule 115
training and developing others 140–3, 145 naturalistic theories, of leadership 126
see also leadership see also leadership
Maslow, A. 15, 20, 131 nature versus nurture debate 33–6
maternal anxiety, and infant nutrition 99 negative reinforcement 5–7, 44
‘maternal deprivation’ 29–30 neglect, effects of 199
see also attachment theory see also maltreatment
mathematics 418, 422–3 negotiation skills 135–6
see also numeracy neuroscience 36–7
Mayo, E. 131 Northern Ireland, curriculum framework in
McMillan, M. 38 345–6, 423
measles 106–7, 110–12, 116, 119 note-taking 155
463
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
464
Index
465
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
466
Index
467
CACHE Level 3 Children and Young People’s Workforce Extended Diploma
468