Professional Documents
Culture Documents
According to Spengler, the meaningful units for history are not epochs but whole
cultures which evolve as organisms. He recognizes at least eight high cultures:
Babylonian, Egyptian, Chinese, Indian, Mesoamerican (Mayan /
Aztec), Classical (Greek/Roman), Arabian, and Western or European. Cultures have a
lifespan of about a thousand years of flourishing, and a thousand years of decline. The
final stage of each culture is, in his word use, a "civilization".
According to Spengler, the Western world is ending and we are witnessing the last
season—"winter time"—of Faustian Civilization. In Spengler's depiction, Western Man
is a proud but tragic figure because, while he strives and creates, he secretly knows the
actual goal will never be reached.
Albert Toynbee
Albert Toynbee, in his monumental study of world history, used the concepts of
“Challenge and Response” to explain how civilizations rise and fall. He felt that
traditional explanations – environment, race, leadership, possession of land, access to
natural resources – were wrong or too narrow. Instead, he looked for the underlying
cause that explained societal success or failure. By “challenge” Toynbee meant some
unpredictable factor or event that posed a threat to the ways in which a group of people
had made their livelihood in the past. But “challenge” was not all negative. It carried in
it the germ of opportunity. “Response” was the action taken by the same group of
people to cope with the new situation. A challenge would arise as the result of many
things – population growth, exhaustion of a vital resource, climate change. It was
something that nobody had knowingly created. Response required vision, leadership,
and action to overcome the threat and create a basis for survival and, hopefully,
prosperity.