Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Heidi Druehl, MS
Nancy R. Rodriguez, PhD, RDN
The essential amino acid (EAA) content of animal-based vegetarian, vegan energy matched, and vegan protein
proteins contributes to their superior quality compared with matched, were determined. The EAA content of all 4 meal
plant-based proteins. Recently, there has been a growing patterns met established EAA Recommended Dietary Allow-
trend toward plant-based meal patterns. However, the im- ances. However, matching total protein to accommodate
pact of adapting a primarily plant-based meal pattern in recommended protein intakes for healthy aging resulted
the context of US Department of Agriculture’ Healthy Eating in an additional 300 calories for the vegan protein
Patterns based on the Dietary Guidelines for Americans and matched eating pattern. The implications for this work
healthy aging is not known. The EAA content, adequacy, for healthy aging with specific regard for protein ade-
and density (the amount of EAA relative to total calories or quacy, energy balance, EAA density, current dietary rec-
total protein) of animal- and plant-based protein equiva- ommendations, and professional practice are considered.
lents in the context of 4 healthy eating patterns, omnivore, The surplus calories that accompany higher-protein, EAA
adequate plant-based meal patterns require further con-
sideration in the context of healthy aging. Essential amino
acid density is a novel approach with potential for effective
Maya Fussell, MS, RDN, completed her MS degree in Nutritional Sci- integration of protein quality and protein quantity in con-
ences with Dr. Rodriguez at the University of Connecticut. figuring healthy eating patterns for optimal health across
Allison Contillo, BS, RDN, is a doctoral student in Nutritional Sciences at the lifespan. Nutr Today 2021;56(2):70–75
the University of Connecticut where her research with Dr. Rodriguez fo-
cuses on rehabilitative nutrition.
he benefits of higher-protein diets for supporting
Heidi Druehl, MS, completed her graduate degree in Nutritional Sciences
at the University of Connecticut under Dr. Rodriguez's direction.
Nancy R. Rodriguez, PhD, RDN, is from the Department of Nutritional
Sciences, University of Connecticut. She is a professor of Nutritional Sci-
ences in the College of Agriculture, Health, and Natural Resources (CAHNR)
T increases in and maintenance of muscle is well es-
tablished. Most of this work has been done using
high-quality animal protein sources such as meat and dairy
with joint appointments in the Departments of Kinesiology and Allied products. Available science shows that animal-derived
Health Sciences. Her current scholarship efforts focus on relationships be- proteins better support muscle protein synthesis than
tween protein quantity, protein quality, and muscle health, with specific re- plant-based proteins because of their higher amounts of
gard for healthy aging and rehabilitative nutrition. She has been a practicing
dietitian for more than 35 years. essential amino acids (EAAs), nutrients that cannot be
This work is supported in part by the Beef Checkoff and the US Depart- made by the body and must be provided in the diet.1 The
ment of Agriculture National Institute of Food and Agriculture, Hatch pro- lower quality of plant-based proteins may be overcome
ject accession number 1016873. by eating more total protein or blending complementary
N.R.R. serves on speaker bureaus for National Cattlemen's Beef Association plant-based proteins to provide EAAs in amounts similar
(NCBA) and National Dairy Council (NDC) and on Danone's Sports Nutrition
Advisory Board. She has received research funding from NCBA, NDC, the to animal proteins.2–4 Although this may be an acceptable
Egg Nutrition Center, and the US Department of Agriculture. The other way to achieve a higher-protein diet and provide the EAA
authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose. needed to promote optimal muscle health, there may be
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative unintended consequences in the context of the total diet
Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives License 4.0 (CCBY-
NC-ND), where it is permissible to download and share the work provided for older persons.
it is properly cited. The work cannot be changed in any way or used The impact of these dietary protein options in the frame-
commercially without permission from the journal. work of the US Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Health
Correspondence: Nancy R. Rodriguez, PhD, RDN, Department of Nutritional Eating Meal Patterns based on the Dietary Guidelines for
Sciences, 27 Manter Road, Unit 4017, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT
06269-4017 (nancy.rodriguez@uconn.edu). Americans (DGA) and healthy aging is not known. Notably,
Copyright © 2021 The Authors. Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights protein quality, a critical concept in considering nutrient
reserved. density of foods, is not addressed in the DGA. Furthermore,
DOI: 10.1097/NT.0000000000000466 the DGA definition of nutrient-dense foods focuses on foods
Fat, g 58 57 58 68
Fat, energy % 32 31 33 31
Carbohydrate, energy % 52 56 57 56
Protein, g 75 73 56 73
Protein, energy % 18 18 14 16
Animal protein, g 49 38 0 0
Plant protein, g 20 21 56 73
among US adults continues to increase.14,15 Critically, the pattern achieved the 2.5 g leucine threshold. This meal in-
calorie cost of obtaining adequate protein and meeting cluded 3 oz of extra lean beef, which provided 1800 mg of
EAA requirements from plant-based protein sources should leucine and 130 calories. In comparison, the lunch in the
not be overlooked when developing and implementing VPM meal pattern provided approximately 2 g of leucine
healthy eating patterns for older populations. sourced from 1 cup of soymilk, 1 cup of quinoa, and 1/2
cup of soybeans.
EAA Density Thoughtful assembly of these plant-based proteins,
All of the healthy eating patterns presented met the RDA however, did not provide sufficient leucine to elicit an an-
for EAA and BCAA.7 However, this information must be abolic response in muscle of older adults.17 To increase
cautiously considered given the diligence and knowledge the leucine content of exclusively plant-based meals, larger
specific to food exchanges and ounce-equivalents required amounts of soymilk (>1 cup), tofu, tempeh, or soy beans
to develop the vegan meal patterns for this work. In fact, all (>3/4 cup) may need to be consumed at each meal. The
meal patterns were developed by a proficient registered volume of food needed to provide comparable leucine in-
dietitian nutritionist with expertise in mindful construction takes is substantial, increasing the caloric density of exclu-
of individual meal plans.16 To increase the EAA content of sively plant-based meal patterns. These additional calories
the vegan meal pattern, a mix of legumes, soy products, may pose a greater challenge for older women compared
and whole grains was added. These plant-based proteins with older men since males have higher energy require-
have a lower EAA density (EAA: energy) compared with ments across the lifespan. Further, the sodium content of
animal-based proteins. Therefore, the 23 g of EAA in the plant-based meat substitutes may inadvertently increase so-
VPM meal pattern was accompanied by 300 additional cal- dium intake. Because plant-based proteins exhibit a com-
ories. The low EAA density of both vegan meal patterns plete EAA profile that is often limiting in amounts of 1 or
demonstrates the challenges in achieving a calorie-conscious, more EAA,17,19 combining plant- and animal-based proteins
high-quality protein pattern that is plant-protein sourced and at each meal facilitates the complete and balanced EAA pro-
meets dietary protein recommendations for healthy aging. file necessary for maintaining muscle mass, strength, and
High-quality proteins such as lean beef, dairy, and eggs function in older individuals.
have a more robust and consistent EAA profile and are rich Our findings suggest that including moderate amounts
sources of the BCAA leucine. As whole foods consumed in of leucine-rich animal proteins is a feasible strategy to opti-
healthy eating patterns, higher-quality animal-based pro- mize dietary protein intakes, meet EAA requirements, and
teins are more anabolic than their plant-based protein enhance leucine content and protein quality of meals in
counterparts.17 Because leucine is a nutrient signal that healthy eating patterns to maintain muscle in older adults.
stimulates skeletal muscle protein synthesis,18 protein recom- The calorie efficiency of animal-based proteins, such as
mendations for aging include consuming 2.5 to 4 g of leucine beef, eggs, and dairy, coupled with the EAA and nutrient
at each meal as a countermeasure to the age-related anabolic density of these foods, remains a cornerstone of a whole
resistance to dietary protein.9 Only the dinner in the O meal foods approach to healthy eating patterns.