Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Finance in Nigeria
1 2 3
F. C. Okpaleke , C. R. Emele , and Y. L. Gambo
1
Managing Partner, Mark Odu & Co. - Estate Surveyors and Valuers
2
Department of Estate Management,
University of Lagos
3
Department of Estate Management & Valuation,
Abubakar Tafawa Balewa University Bauchi
Abstract
Traditional real estate funding sources in Nigeria have been overwhelmed by challenges facing the
housing finance providers; leaving an estimated housing gap of over 16 million units. This
exploratory study investigated advocacy for the use of dormant and unclaimed dividends in
providing alternative source of funding for housing development. The study adopted the review
approach in examining relevant literature on unclaimed dividend and highlighted the conceptual,
legal and institutional frameworks guiding the administration of unclaimed dividend in Nigeria.
The paper found that currently there is no advocacy from the real estate professionals on the
utilisation of unclaimed dividend in financing housing development. Therefore, the paper
recommend that the Nigerian Institution of Estate Surveyors and Valuers (NIESV) and Real Estate
Developers Association of Nigerian (REDAN) should initiate and spread advocacy for the
utilisation of unclaimed dividend in financing housing development; on the other hand, the Federal
Government could channel unclaimed dividend to real estate sector for greater socio-economic
impact and multiplier effect on the economy.
for housing development are searching for foregoing, how can the large, latent, unused
sources of real estate funding with reasonable and unclaimed dividend provide an alternative
interest rates and favourable repayment terms. source of funding for housing development
The problems associated with securing finance with appropriate legislation? The answer forms
therefore place them in a difficult situation. the main objective of the paper. The study
Short, medium and long term measures remain identifies unclaimed dividend, an indirect
vital to addressing the present housing delivery derivative of the capital market, as one of those
challenge. Short term measures describe dormant and unutilized resources that can serve
interventions in the housing finance system; as an alternative and innovative source of
medium and long term solutions provide cheap funds to partly address the existing
inflow of funds from multiple low rate sources housing development funding challenge. The
which have been identified as innovative, paper considers the unclaimed dividend as
multi-dimensional and sustainable given the latent because of its present dormant nature
magnitude of the housing challenge. although it has capacity of emerging or
In the midst of the highlighted paucity of developing as a finance source especially now
fund, there exists growing incidences of that the fund has progressively grown and
misapplication of scarce resources, advocacy by interest groups have intensified
underutilization and dormancy of financial agitation for means of addressing the malaise
resources or, apparent confusion on their as well as appropriate ways of channelling the
utilization. In this regard, unclaimed dividend accumulated fund to vital areas of the
has become a topical issue in the capital market economy. The study adopts the exploratory
as posited by Ekanem (2002). Every year approach because previous studies that directly
unclaimed dividend value increases and the linked unclaimed dividend and real estate
measures adopted by regulatory institutions finance appear to be lacking. The exploratory
and shareholders' associations do not yield any approach according to Domeika, Jatkunaite
meaningful result. According to Opara and and Aleknaviciene (2006) involves logical
Emenike (2014), unclaimed dividend poses analysis of research results and evaluation of
negative implications on the economic different submissions made by experts in the
development of Nigeria in terms of reducing finance industry. Therefore the study exposes
investors' confidence. It also negatively affects the opportunities inherent in the utilization of
the availability of long-term fund for idle funds in housing, being a critical sector of
investment; and, portends grave consequences the economy, by reducing the housing deficit.
in the operation and regulation of the capital In addition, the study also provides a common
market. As at today, there are no identified ground in the controversy surrounding
studies in Nigeria linking unclaimed dividend unclaimed dividend because companies are
and real estate as all the literature on unclaimed claiming the right to control the unclaimed
dividend are within the domain of finance and dividend while the Securities and Exchange
economics. This underscores the significance Commission (SEC) claims that by statute after
of this study and opens the path for more 12 years of dividend declaration, every
innovative discourse and research by unclaimed dividend should be placed under its
stakeholders on this topical issue. In view of the custody, under the guise that a property without
Okpaleke / Emele / Gambo 13
an heir is placed under the care of the instance, when a company gives bonus of 1
government. to 4, it means that for every 4 units of shares
held, 1 unit of share is given as bonus.
The Concept of Dividend and Some companies do pay both stock and
Unclaimed Dividend cash dividends.
• Property Dividend: This type is not too
Dividend in relation to shares is a product of the common in Nigeria; it involves payment in
capital market given that it represents the profit the form of products or services; or, the
distributed to shareholders as a part of their company may offer its shareholding in
equity or indirect investment in the companies other companies.
that operate in the capital market. According to • Interim Dividend: These are dividend
Olowe (1997), dividend is a payment that is payments before the annual general
taxable (withholding tax mostly 10% is meeting and final annual report. In Nigeria,
deducted from dividends) which is declared by some companies pay interim and final
the board of directors of a company to its dividend yearly.
shareholders from the company's retained When the declared dividend warrants fail to
earnings and this payment can be made reach the different shareholders fifteen months
quarterly or yearly depending on the company. after the date of declaration, it becomes
The concept of dividend therefore presupposes unclaimed and a liability on the company
that profit has been made by the company (Companies and Allied matters Acts [CAMA],
during the financial year and it is part of the 1990; Ifuero and Osarodo, 2006; & Unegbu,
profit that is distributed to the shareholders as a 2002).
return on their equity investments in the
companies. Dividends are distributable Problems and Causes of Unclaimed
earnings of a company after taxation depending Dividend in Nigeria
on the number and class of shares held by the
holder. It represents the return on capital The problems of unclaimed dividend can be
invested by the members as a reward for the traced to as far back as 1972 and 1977 when the
risk of such investment. According to Owolabi Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) came into
and Obida (2013) dividend may take the form existence and subsequent indigenization of
of: Nigerian companies. During these periods,
• Cash Dividend: This represents dividend there were no sufficient means of keeping track
warrants or cheques sent to shareholders of share certificates and signatures. In addition,
who on receipt of such warrants deposit CAMA, 1990 provision of a maximum period
them to their respective current bank of 12 years after which any unclaimed dividend
accounts. (This procedure was in operation is declared status barred marked the beginning
before the beginning of the e-dividend of the growth of unclaimed dividend in
platform). Nigeria. Several other reasons have been
• Stock or Scrip Dividend: This is paid in the attributed to the increasing rate of unclaimed
form of bonus share to the shareholders in dividend. Akinkugbe (2011), Mgboji (2011),
proportion of their shareholding. For Nwachukwu (2011) and Ugwu (2012a) stated
14 Unclaimed Dividend: A Latent Alternative Source for Housing Finance in Nigeria
the major reasons why cases of unclaimed people bought shares in fictitious names
dividends are rising in Nigeria. However and died intestate and the shares are
Yuguda (2000) and Unegbu (2002) grouped unknown to the next of kin.
the causes of unclaimed dividend under the • Delay in the postal system of getting
following: dividend warrants to their destinations
• Shareholder related causes which include within stipulated time.
(i) improper completion of application forms, • Problems of poor (village or town) street
omission, inaccessible or wrong addresses identification and changes in house
and irregular signature; numbering due to urbanization.
(ii) Failure to communicate changes of address • Company Registrars related causes: - i)
to the registrar due to relocation of Poor collation of application forms and
shareholders either by employment, better mistakes in compiling addresses of
accommodation, civil unrest, natural shareholders; (ii) Failure to effect changes
disaster or marital status; in the shareholder's address when such has
(iii) death of the shareholder; been duly communicated to the Registrar;
(iv) Poor attitude of shareholders when the (iii) Mistakes of omission and commission
value of the dividend is low; in the issue of dividend warrants; (v) Late
(v) Inactivity on the shareholders bank account posting of dividend warrants or failure to
leading to dormancy (in most cases, low- post at all in order to manipulate the funds
income earners and other investors in rural and make illegal profit before payment.
areas have no current account where • Chief Executive Officers of companies
dividend warrant can be deposited); may delay the release of declared funds for
(vi) Litigation by the shareholder's family dividend in order to solve their short term
when the shareholder dies without a will or cash flow challenges although this action
inability to obtain letter of estate contravenes the provision of CAMA, 1990,
administration on time as amended.
(vii) Closure of accounts by the shareholder or • Stockbrokers related causes that affect
when the banks where the shareholder mostly the shareholders that purchased
maintains accounts are liquidated. shares through their stockbrokers and a
(Viii) Inability of the shareholder to track the delay in communication between the
progress of the company in order to know stockbrokers and Registrars.
when profits are made and dividend • Causes due to policy changes in the
declared, as majority of shareholders do not regulation of the financial market. More
attend annual general meetings; companies being listed and increased
(ix) none provision of next of kin, death of next awareness of the public on investment
of kin or, unawareness of next of kin about opportunities in the capital market. Also
the benefactor's shareholding altogether; more foreign investors are investing in
(x) Low patronage of stock market Nigerian economy due to the privatization
professionals and experts by low income policy implemented in the various sectors
shareholders; of the economy that are yielding results and
(xii) Where during indigenization era, some increasing profits every year. Included in
Okpaleke / Emele / Gambo 15
this group is the banking industry distress Legal and Institutional Frameworks of
where some banks had some departments as Unclaimed Dividend in Nigeria
Registrars which led to the disappearance The Company and Allied Matters Act
of unclaimed dividends when the banks (CAMA) 1990 as amended is the recognized
were liquidated. law that regulates companies' operations in
Nigeria. The law provides that dividends that
Overview of the growth of unclaimed dividend are unclaimed after 15 months of declaration
in Nigeria should be returned to the company from where
According to Osundolire (2011) and Unegbu the shareholders may still claim the dividends
(2002), the value of unclaimed dividend as within 12 years after which the unclaimed
released by SEC was N2.09 billion in 1999; dividends become “unclaimable” and forfeited
this rose from N5.1billion to N6 billion by the shareholders (Section 383 of CAMA).
between 2002 and 2004. In 2003 unclaimed CAMA in Section 382(1) provides that where
dividend increased to N6.4 billion. At the end dividend are returned to the company
of 2008, unclaimed dividend was valued at unclaimed, the company shall send a list of the
N17.9 billion. The value of unclaimed dividend names of the person entitled with the notice of
has continued to rise despite awareness, the next annual general meeting to the
reforms such as the e-dividend introduced by members. Sub-section (2) says that after the
SEC in 2008 and various campaigns by expiration of three months' notice mentioned in
stakeholders in the capital market. Osundolire subsection (1) of the Act, the company may
further stated that within a period of 9 years invest the unclaimed dividend for its own
(1999 - 2008) unclaimed dividend increased by benefit in an investment outside the company
756.46% thereby resulting to a yearly average and no interest shall accrue on the dividend
of 84.05% increase. As submitted by against the Company. In summary therefore, a
Leadership (2012), SEC quarterly report, puts dividend warrant which has the attributes of a
the value of unclaimed dividend as at cheque has a life span of six months from the
December 2011 to be N52.2 billion and this date issued after which it becomes stale and
grew one year later, to 60 billion as at could be revalidated on appeal to the registrar
December 2012 (Opara & Emenike, 2014; of the company for another six months. It
Punch, 2014). According to Punch (2014), the becomes unclaimed with an additional 3
Institute of Capital Market Registrars revealed months (that is, a total of 15 months) and could
that unclaimed dividends were valued at be claimed through application by the
N50.94 billion as at December 31, 2013. shareholders. It becomes status barred and
However, the unclaimed dividends committee unrecoverable after 12 years.
inaugurated by SEC in its report has put the SEC is the recognized regulator of the
figure of unclaimed dividends at N45 billion stock market in Nigeria which by implication is
(Business day, 2013). Thus, the actual value saddled with the responsibility of overseeing
of unclaimed dividends to date in Nigeria may the fund. In an attempt to discourage
not have been exactly quantified. companies and registrars from using
unclaimed dividends in their business
operations, SEC in its New Consolidated Rules
16 Unclaimed Dividend: A Latent Alternative Source for Housing Finance in Nigeria
and Regulation 2011 (Rule 137) with regard to of unclaimed dividends. According to the Act,
payment of dividends made several regulatory a shareholder may present a claim to the
guidelines. However, the level of compliance company Registrar for payment of any
and implementation of the rules are outside the unclaimed dividends prior to the expiry of
scope of this paper and thus cannot be verified. twelve months period. After that period, a
shareholder can only request or apply for a
Unclaimed Dividend in other Countries refund of any unclaimed dividends from the
The issue of unclaimed dividend is a Registrar of Unclaimed Moneys.
worldwide capital market phenomenon and not
peculiar to Nigeria alone. However, some Unclaimed Dividend as an Alternative
countries have made provisions through Housing Finance Source
appropriate legislation on unclaimed dividend Investors, capital market regulators, financial
and other assets. In Kenya for example, Kirimi experts, the three arms of government and
(2012) reports that the volume of unclaimed finance academics have shown remarkable
assets given by Accountants and Actuaries interest in ensuring that the issue of unclaimed
stand at 9.2 billion shillings and 200 billion dividend is brought to an end. However, the
shillings respectively. According to Kirimi, the housing sector is silent on this. This perhaps
value of unclaimed dividends with the Barclays may be as a result of limited training of estate
Bank of Kenya was 573 million shillings, 384 surveyors and valuers and other built
million shillings and 148 million shilling in environment professionals in finance and also
2011, 2010 and 2009 respectively. In an in the operation of the capital market and how it
intervention that ensures that unclaimed assets can be deployed to resuscitate the housing
and dividends are traced to the owners, the sector. In view of this, the unclaimed dividend
Government of Kenya in 2011 established the can through appropriate legislation be
Unclaimed financial Assets Authority Board to channelled into housing. Recognising the
carry out valuation of unclaimed financial important role of capital market in housing
assets, inventories, and make delivery, the new National Housing Policy in
recommendations for an appropriate legal, its policy thrusts identifies the “collaboration
regulatory and institutional framework to and partnership with the financial sector
govern these assets. Currently, the abandoned operators and regulators to develop effective
property bill already passed and sent to the primary and secondary mortgage finance
president was returned to the parliament for systems and facilitate linkage of that market to
amendment of the section that deals with the capital market to provide long term
management of abandoned properties. affordable and sustainable liquidity for
In the United Kingdom, the Unclaimed housing development”. This will help in
Asset Register (UAR) estimates that the value achieving as part of the goals, the provision of
of unclaimed financial assets (unclaimed adequate and affordable housing finance to all
dividend inclusive) though not properly Nigerians. In addition, as provided by the new
defined is approximately between £15 billion National Housing Policy that, housing
and £20 billion. In Malaysia, the Unclaimed development in Nigeria requires “an
Moneys Act 1965 governs the administration intervention fund to improve substantially, the
Okpaleke / Emele / Gambo 17
liquidity of the mortgage sector for housing Dematerialization: The E-divided system
development”, using the huge unclaimed ensures that accounts of the investors are
dividend fund can provide an innovative credited directly within 24 hours after the
housing finance strategy and increasing declaration of dividend by the companies.
investment in the housing sector. The These measures were put in place by SEC
accumulated unclaimed dividend fund and Central Securities Clearing System
estimated at N60 billion may be a meagre (CSCS) with the collaboration of NSE,
amount relative to the huge fund needed to registrars, the tax authorities and the
bridge the housing deficit but when applied as a Nigerian interbank system. However
revolving intervention fund together with other apathy on the part of the investors and the
unconventional sources like dormant accounts non-provision of the requisite mandate
and other abandoned financial asset like and information has reduced the impact of
insurance policies, pension, lottery, etc. would the system.
be impactful. The value of the other unclaimed (b) Enforcement of existing rules by
financial assets is unclear for now as the regulators: Strict implementation by
records unlike unclaimed dividends are companies and registrars of the provisions
difficult to collate. One important aspect of of CAMA 1990 as amended, Investment
housing provision available for the unclaimed and Securities Act and SEC rules and
dividend fund is affordable mass housing or regulations against illegal use of
social housing. The fund could be administered unclaimed dividend as free fund for
by the FMBN or the newly established company operation.
Mortgage Refinance Company of Nigeria (c) The proposed bill on unclaimed dividend
(which will shape the mortgage and housing and abandoned property trust fund: The
industry in Nigeria in the future) with close SEC through an executive bill proposed
collaboration with the States and Local an Unclaimed Dividend Trust Fund in
Government Areas, the various interest groups 2002 as part of solution measures. The
and stakeholders through appropriate Trust Fund was to enable investors have
legislation, distinct from their regular funding. access to their dividend and accrued
The study therefore calls for the expansion of interest whenever they show up. The bill
the scope of the proposed trust fund by the could not be passed by the National
National Assembly. Assembly due largely to pressure from
powerful forces that have vested interest
Key Amelioration Measures Against the in the fund. In its place the National
Incidence of Unclaimed Dividend Assembly Committee on Capital Market
in 2010 sponsored a bill to the National
Several solutions have been put in place and Assembly will guide unclaimed dividends
proposed by the mix of stakeholders to and abandoned property as a Trust Fund.
ameliorate the problem of unclaimed dividend The Fund is to take over and manage
in Nigeria. Some of these measures include the dividend from all quoted companies
following: (Owolabi and Obida, 2013). This bill has
(a) E-dividend and Share Certificate passed through the second reading
18 Unclaimed Dividend: A Latent Alternative Source for Housing Finance in Nigeria
Ugwu, C (2012). Nigeria: Awareness for law reform. The Nigerian Stock
Campaign Germane for Reduction of broker. July - September, 3.
Unclaimed Dividends Retrieved from Unclaimed Asset Register
http://www.allafrica.com/stories/20120 https://www.uar.co.uk/Help/AboutLost
7231490.html. Assets.Yuguda, Isa (2000). Unclaimed
Unegbu, O.C.K (2002). The problem of Dividends: Matters Arising. Seminar
unclaimed dividends in Nigeria: Need paper, Institute of Chartered Accountant
of Nigeria (ICAN),Lagos Mainland
District, June 30.