Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Wound Healing: Is Oral Zinc Supplementation Beneficial?: Review
Wound Healing: Is Oral Zinc Supplementation Beneficial?: Review
Sarah Bradbury
N
utrition is an important CINAHL and Embase databases via as free ions, but over 95% of total body
extrinsic factor influencing Ovid, and also PubMed. The key terms zinc is bound to proteins within cells
wound healing, and malnutrition used were ‘zinc’, ‘wound healing’, and cell membranes. In the plasma,
has an adverse effect on a wound’s ‘pressure sores’ and ‘leg ulcers’, both approximately 30–40% of zinc is bound
ability to heal efficiently and effectively separately and then in combination. to α2-macroglobulin or transferrin,
(Barbul and Purtill, 1994; Pontieri-Lewis, This yielded a mixture of randomised 60% to albumin and 2% to amino acids
1997; Carlson, 1999). The significance and non-randomised clinical trials, (Russell, 1980). The main form that zinc
of thorough nutritional assessment in laboratory experiments and systematic takes in the cellular environment is as
the prevention and treatment of acute reviews. Further studies were identified part of metalloenzymes and is involved
and chronic wounds is widely accepted from the references cited in these in the stimulation of multiple enzyme
(George and Bugwadia, 1996; Flanigan, papers. No limit was set on the pathways (Collins, 2003).
1997), and yet it is often considered a dates for the published literature. A
low priority in the clinical setting (Gray significant amount were pertinent On a basic, but critical, cellular level,
and Cooper, 2001). trials conducted from the 1960s which zinc is necessary for deoxyribonucleic
required review alongside more recent acid (DNA) synthesis and replication,
A growing proportion of the work. The Cochrane Database of and therefore is essential for growth
available nutritional literature considers Systematic Reviews was also searched (Gray, 2003). Zinc is involved in
the importance of trace elements and for systematic reviews involving zinc and haemostasis through its interaction
minerals, throughout the wound healing wound healing. with platelets, and is necessary for
process, alongside the acknowledged antibody production and immune
role of macronutrients (Berger and The function of zinc cell function (Collins, 2003). McLaren
Shenkin, 1998; Todorovic, 2002). Zinc is Wound healing is a complex process (1992) suggests it also inhibits bacterial
involving the stages of inflammation, growth. Zinc plays a central role in the
Sarah Bradbury is Community Staff Nurse, Den- proliferation and maturation that occur proliferation of inflammatory cells and
scombe Clinic, Caerphilly, Gwent Healthcare NHS on a continuum from injury to healing modulates cutaneous inflammation
Trust, Wales Scholl and Langkamp-Henken, 2001). (Tenaud et al, 1999).
88
54 Wounds UK
UK, 2006,Vol 2, No 1
Throughout the proliferation and element of bias because of wounds not achieved complete healing, despite having
maturation phases, zinc is required healing at the same rate, but this was suffered with the ulcers for at least 2 years
for collagen synthesis. The element is favoured towards the control group previously.This could indicate some effect
also necessary for the proliferation of as their wounds were of a smaller size. from the zinc sulphate.
fibroblasts and keratinocytes and quickens This could indicate some evidence to
the process of re-epithelialisation, while support the results as, despite the bias, This study, however, was
strengthening the wound (Tenaud et al, the treatment group still showed quicker fundamentally flawed in that it used
1999; Todorovic, 2002). healing times and rates. no control group to compare rates of
healing without zinc supplementation
The influence of zinc on wound healing Assumptions were also made that and so the results have diminished
Although it is generally considered the study participants were taking their significance. The sample size was
throughout the literature that zinc does medication properly as no serum zinc also small, casting doubt over the
influence the wound-healing process measurements were taken or similar generalisability of the results to a bigger
(Agren, 1993; Sullivan et al, 1999; Kohn evidence of treatment compliance population. In addition, no mention
et al, 2000), the exact mechanisms for presented. Despite methodological flaws, is made of control over confounding
this are unclear. In addition, the evidence this study was useful as it demonstrated variables or baseline differences, which
for the supplementation of zinc to aid the need for further research into the could introduce bias.
healing is conflicting. area and prompted subsequent trials.
Myers and Cherry (1970) also found
Zinc and sinus healing Zinc and skin complaints no difference between the healing rates
A study by Pories et al in 1967 was the Greaves and Boyde (1967) conducted a of patients receiving zinc supplementation
first to look at the influence of zinc in preliminary study looking at the plasma and a control group, but again the trial was
the healing of human wounds. Previous zinc concentrations of patients suffering not rigorously conducted. Assumptions
encouraging work with zinc and rats with psoriasis, other dermatological were made that wounds heal at the same
led to this trial of zinc supplementation conditions and venous leg ulceration. rate over time, and different elements of
in 20 young healthy airmen following They found that patients with these bias were introduced through differences
excision of chronic pilonidal sinuses. The conditions had a statistically significant in ulcer size and follow-up time between
participants were randomly allocated decrease in plasma zinc levels compared the groups.
either to a treatment group where they to a control group with no existing
received 220mg of zinc sulphate three skin conditions. Withers et al (1968) A small trial conducted by Hallbook
times daily, or to a control group where completed a similar study and found no and Lanner in 1972 looked at healing in
no medication was received. Healing difference in plasma zinc concentrations patients with chronic venous ulcers who
was assessed through measurement of in patients with psoriasis, but found that were given either a zinc supplement or
changes in wound volume giving a rate those with chronic venous leg ulceration a placebo. The trial had a small sample
of wound closure. Complete healing was had significantly lower levels than controls. size of 27 patients, which was due mainly
defined as re-epithelialisation. to the strict exclusion criteria because
Zinc and leg ulcers of difficulties relating to assessment
Results indicated that wounds healed These results led to Greaves and of healing with different-sized ulcers.
in 80.1±13.6 days in the control group Skillen undertaking a trial in 1970 to This, however, did decrease the risk
and in 45.8±2.6 days in the treatment determine the effect of long-term of bias of differing healing rates. Also,
group. Rate of wound closure was zinc supplementation on the healing despite mentioning that patients were
0.44ml/day in the control group and of chronic venous leg ulcers. Again, randomised, no explanation is given
1.25ml/day in the zinc-treated group. This 220mg of zinc sulphate was given of how this was performed leading to
indicated that zinc supplementation had three times daily, but this time plasma doubts of possible bias and poor reliability.
a beneficial effect on wound healing. zinc was monitored pre- and post-
treatment. Healing was determined The participants were given 200mg
The authors acknowledged that the using measurements of ulcer area, of zinc sulphate three times daily and
study was susceptible to bias because of which were used to calculate linear re- serum zinc levels were monitored pre-
not being double-blinded, but explained epithelialisation over time. treatment. Ulcer area was determined
that this was due to a lack of knowledge weekly, and photographs taken at 6
of the effects of oral zinc sulphate Results indicated again that baseline and 12 weeks to assess ulcer healing.
administration at the time of the study. plasma zinc concentrations are reduced The trial had the advantage of being
This would seem reasonable from an in patients with leg ulcers. However, double-blinded to reduce bias during the
ethical viewpoint but did necessitate despite increases in these levels with zinc assessment and analysis stages.
the need for further methodologically supplementation, the study failed to find a
sound research in order to draw valid correlation between healing rates and zinc Analysis of the results was separated
conclusions. Differences in baseline levels. Nevertheless, all 18 subjects displayed into two groups — those who had
sizes of the sinuses also introduced an evidence of re-epithelialisation, 13 of which below normal serum zinc levels at
the start of the trial and those whose elements with one another and the 1000µg of zinc per gram of a specified
levels were normal or high. The results effect this can have on healing. This powder diet for 2 weeks. Serum and
suggest that zinc supplementation has could be important from a clinical skin zinc concentrations were assessed,
no effect on the healing of patients with perspective when considering using wound closure measured and biopsies
normal zinc levels, but an improvement zinc-medicated dressings. It suggests taken to assess influx of neutrophils
was seen in patients with pre-existing that zinc is required more in the earlier and inflammatory mediators into the
zinc deficiency. A systematic review of rather than the later stages of healing, wounds. It was found that wound-
the effect of zinc supplementation on and using it beyond that could alter the closure rate, presence of neutrophils
venous ulcers conducted by Wilkinson function of other trace elements within and expression of inhibitory messeger
and Hawke (1988) supports this finding. the wound and actually impair rather RNA, IL-1β and TNF-α was significantly
than promote healing. increased in mice receiving 500µg/g
Laboratory experiments on zinc supplementation zinc diet when compared to both
More recently, experiments have been the zinc-deficient diet mice and also
conducted on animal models to look
Lim et al (2004) propose that the mice receiving the higher dose
at the effect of zinc on a more basic the antioxidant role of zinc of zinc. This led to the conclusion
cellular level at different stages of the is affected when inadequate that supplementing dietary zinc at
wound-healing process. levels are present, leading to 500µg/g has a positive effect within the
increased oxidative stress- inflammatory stage of wound healing,
Lansdown et al (1999) attempted to induced tissue damage. but that high-dose zinc actually has a
determine the sequential changes in zinc negative effect.
concentration (alongside the other trace
This...in turn decreases the
metals metallothionein and calmodulin) expression of cytokines This study was particularly interesting
in an incisional wound in rats. The neccessary for neutrophil as again it attempted to explain how
study was thorough and detailed in infiltration and tissue repair. zinc affects healing, whereas older
its explanation of scientific techniques research is more intent on proving
used, which improves reproducibility, Lim et al (2004) also investigated the whether or not a relationship actually
and results indicated good validity effect of zinc on the early inflammatory exists. Lim et al (2004) propose that the
by addressing the original question. phase of wound healing in mice. The antioxidant role of zinc is affected when
Wounding was also standardised well study was presented well with clearly inadequate levels are present, leading to
to decrease risk of bias. Full-thickness defined hypotheses and outcome increased oxidative stress-induced tissue
surgical wounds were inflicted on measures. It incorporated a thorough damage. This reduces the effect of NFkß
anaesthetised rats who were then methodology using referenced scientific that, in turn, decreases the expression of
euthanised at different periods between techniques, which gives evidence of the cytokines necessary for neutrophil
one and 10 days. During autopsy, the good reliability and validity. A control infiltration and tissue repair.
wound sites were excised and samples group was used for comparative
taken for trace metal analysis using reference and baseline differences Zinc and surgical wounds
atomic absorption spectrophotometry. and other confounding variables were Finally, Zorrilla et al published a study in
controlled in order to reduce bias 2004 that looked at using serum zinc
Results indicated that zinc and improve reliability of findings. The levels as a prognostic tool for delayed
concentrations increased at the main concern is that as the study was wound healing in 97 patients who had
wound site until the fifth day before performed on mice, the findings cannot undergone hip hemiarthroplasty surgery.
decreasing over the next five days. necessarily be extrapolated to humans. Preoperative serum zinc levels were
Metallothionein, an intracellular metal- measured and postoperative wound
binding protein that has a particular The basis for the study was the healing was assessed using predefined
affinity to zinc, was used as a marker for stimulation of neutrophil recruitment parameters to diagnose delayed healing.
modulation of trace elements. Increased by interleukin-1β (IL-1β) and tumour
metallothionein reactions were seen necrosing factor-α (TNF-α), which Thirty study participants were
at the wound site during the early is regulated by a transcription factor, diagnosed with delayed healing and
influx of inflammatory cells and during nuclear factor κB (NFκB). It was statistical tests demonstrated a significant
collagenesis, which, the authors suggest, hypothesized that zinc promotes correlation with low zinc levels in these
indicates the need for zinc at this time wound healing through its action on patients compared with the group
for repair. NFkß, which is involved in regulating the with no healing problems. The authors
inflammatory response. concluded that low serum zinc levels will
The study concluded that wound predict delayed wound healing with a
healing would be adversely affected Full-thickness cutaneous wounds sensitivity of 80%, which they considered
if the uptake of trace elements were were inflicted on mice that were could indicate a place for preoperative
impaired. Awareness should also then either fed a zinc-deficient diet zinc supplementation in patients
be made of the interaction of trace or supplemented with 500µg or undergoing elective surgery.