Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Figure 1
Key Points
The OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex TM
BGMS meets the user accuracy criteria of EN ISO ColourSure technology makes it easy for
TM
i
The Bluetooth word mark and logos are registered trademarks owned by
®
Bluetooth SIG, Inc. and any use of such marks by LifeScan Scotland Ltd. is under
license. Other trademarks and trade names are those of their respective owners.
Introduction Table 1
The OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS provides
™
OneTouch Ultra Plus Test Strip
®
a no-coding test strip platform that has been Features and Specifications
designed to meet the requirements of EN ISO
15197:2015.
Feature Specification
The studies described in this paper (system
accuracy, user performance, hematocrit Operating Glucose in the blood sample
performance, repeatability precision, intermediate principle mixes with the enzyme
precision, and effect of interferences) were FAD-GDH (flavin adenine
dinucleotide dependent
conducted to evaluate the performance of glucose dehydrogenase)
the OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex system. system.
™
in the test strip and a small
electric current is produced.
Ethics committee approval was granted both for
clinical protocols where informed consent of the
participants was required and where consent was Sample types Fresh capillary (fingertip)
whole blood
required to allow use of participants’ blood samples
in laboratory investigations.
Calibration Plasma-equivalent
Evaluations were performed in a manner consistent
with guidelines published by the International Coding Calibration codes not
required
Organization for Standardization (ISO). 1
Figure 2 Figure 3
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex Meter ™
OneTouch Ultra Plus Test Strip
®
Display
Data port
Unit of measure: mmol/L is
Range Indicator the preset unit of measure
Arrow and cannot be changed
OK button
Range Indicator
Color Bars
Up and down
buttons
2
System Accuracy Table 2
EN ISO 15197:2015 minimum system accuracy OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGM ™
performance criteria 1
System Accuracy
• For each test strip lot, 95% of the measured
glucose values shall fall within either ±0.83 A. Overall System Accuracy
mmol/L of the average measured values of the
reference measurement procedure at glucose
EN ISO 15197:2015 SPECIFICATION
concentrations <5.55 mmol/L or within ±15% at
glucose concentrations ≥5.55 mmol/L.
Within ±0.83
mmol/L 595/600 99.2%
• 99% of individual glucose measured or ±15% of
values shall fall within zones A and B of the reference
Consensus Error Grid for type 1 diabetes.
Difference Plot: The difference plot (Figure 4)
Methods represents the difference between each OneTouch
• Testing was performed by study facilitators at Ultra Plus Flex BGMS result and corresponding
TM
the clinic sites using capillary blood samples reference result (y-axis) vs. the corresponding
reference result (x-axis). The dashed lines represent
from 100 subjects and for 3 individual test
the system accuracy performance criteria of EN
strip lots.
ISO 15197:2015, with 99.2% (595/600) of measured
• The number of samples within the glucose glucose values meeting these criteria.
concentration ranges was defined by EN ISO
15197:2015.
• For each subject, the facilitator tested 6
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex™ meters using
fingertip capillary blood.
• Reference glucose testing was performed
using the reference YSI 2300 STAT Plus™
Biochemistry Analyzer (YSI, Inc., Yellow
Springs, Ohio, USA).
• The ISO acceptance criteria, based on
percentage of accurate results, were used to
evaluate the results.
Results
• Overall accuracy (Table 2 and Figure 4): 99.2%
(595/600) of the OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex ™
3
Figure 4 User Performance Evaluation
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex System ™
EN ISO 15197:2015 user performance evaluation 1
4
mmol/L.
50
Bias / mmol / L
Bias / mg / dL
0 0 Methods
-2
-50 • 166 evaluable subjects took part in an open,
-4
non-randomized clinical evaluation across 4
-1 00
-6
clinic sites.
-8
-1 50
0 1 00 200 300 400 500 600 7 00
• Subjects were briefed on study procedures
YSI Reference / mg / dL
and requirements but received no training
Consensus Error Grid Analysis on the use of the OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex ™
(y-axis) vs. the corresponding reference results (x-axis) • Each study subject lay-user collected their
that is overlaid with a grid that divides the plot into own blood sample by skin puncture (finger
zones. Each zone signifies the degree of clinical risk stick) and performed one test using the
posed by inaccuracy of the BGMS result. According OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex meter and test strip,
™
to the error grid, 99.7% (598/600) of OneTouch Ultra which was chosen from 3 OneTouch Ultra
Plus Flex™ BGMS results were in zone A (no effect on Plus test strip lots.
®
clinical action).
• Following this test, the study staff (healthcare
Figure 5 professionals) collected blood from the same
finger puncture for hematocrit and reference
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex ™
600 A
35 Ultra Plus Flex BGMS lay user self-test results
™
30
500
B
25 accuracy performance acceptance criteria.
400
20
300
• Consensus Error Grid analysis (Table 4; Figure
15
C 7) shows 100.0% (166/166) of OneTouch Ultra
200
10
Plus Flex BGMS lay user self-test results were
™
1 00 D 5
in zone A (no effect on clinical action).
0 0
0 1 00 200 300 400 500 600 7 00
• Linear regression analysis yielded the
YSI Reference / mg / dL
following results: slope=1.02; y-intercept=
Zone definitions:
-0.08 mmol/L; standard error (S )=0.75
y,x
4
Table 3 Figure 6
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS ™
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS ™
6
1 00
Lay Users 4
50
Bias / mmol / L
Bias / mg / dL
2
161/166 0 0
97.0% -2
-50
-4
-1 00
-6
Table 4 -8
-1 50
User Performance:
Consensus Error Grid Analysis Figure 7
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS Lay ™
Zone definitions:
Zone A: No effect on clinical action
Zone B: Altered clinical action - little or no efffect on clinical outcome
Zone C: Altered clinical action - likely to affect clinical outcome
Zone D: Altered clinical action - could have a significant medical risk
Zone E: Altered clinical action - could have dangerous consequences
Zone definitions:
Zone A: No effect on clinical action
Zone B: Altered clinical action - little or no efffect on clinical outcome
Zone C: Altered clinical action - likely to affect clinical outcome
Zone D: Altered clinical action - could have a significant medical risk
Zone E: Altered clinical action - could have dangerous consequences
5
Packed Cell Volume (Hematocrit) Methods
Performance • Venous blood from 3 donors was adjusted in
EN ISO 15197:2015 packed cell volume the laboratory to 5 target hematocrit levels
(hematocrit) interference performance criteria: ranging from 19% to 61% and 6 target glucose
levels ranging from 2.2+0.3 mmol/L to 31.1+1.6
The packed cell volume effects shall be described mmol/L.
in the instructions for use if they meet either of the
following performance criteria: • Blood glucose testing was performed using 8
production-equivalent OneTouch Ultra Plus
• For glucose concentrations <5.55 mmol/L, the Flex meters and 3 lots of OneTouch Ultra Plus
™ ®
Figure 8
OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS Hematocrit Performance: Average
™
Bias at high and low Glucose for each Hematocrit Level tested
Bias to nominal equates to the average measured value at each hematocrit level tested compared to the nominal hematocrit level of 42%
6
Precision: Repeatability Precision: Intermediate Precision
Methods Methods
• From one venous blood donor (one sample), • The testing procedure involved 3 control
100 replicates were tested per 5 target glucose solution levels determined by the BGMS
levels ranging from 1.94 mmol/L to 21.21 system as: low (2.05 mmol/L); mid (6.55
mmol/L as defined in EN ISO 15197:2015. mmol/L); high (19.54 mmol/L); 3 lots of
OneTouch Ultra Plus test strips, and 30
®
• The testing procedure involved 3 lots of OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex meters (10 meters
™
for 3 Test Strip Lots (N=300 tests for Intermediate Precision: Pooled Data
each glucose level) for 3 Test Strip Lots (N=600 for each
control solution level)
OneTouch Ultra
SD CV
Plus Flex Average
™
mg/dL %
mmol/L
1.94 0.05
5.48 0.10 2.05 0.05
7.73 2.11 6.55 1.86
12.34 1.92 19.54 2.25
21.21 2.13
7
Interferences Results
EN ISO 15197:2015
• The study showed that the accuracy of
The EN ISO standard requires that interference the OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS is not
™
8
Table 7
List of substances tested and shown not to interfere with the OneTouch Ultra
Plus Flex BGMS ™
Hemoglobin Heparin
Triglycerides Ibuprofen
Urea Levodopa
Salicylate
Tetracycline
Tolazamide
Tolbutamide
9
OneTouch Ultra Plus Test Strips
®
Figure 9
Algorithm
Manufacturing precision
The blood sample is scanned 500 times controls the size of the
over a 3-phase application of voltage. The reaction chamber to the
resultant current response is interrogated micron level, reducing
variability for a consistent
to deliver high accuracy readings that take and accurate results with
account of variations in hematocrit and also no-coding convenience.
common interfering substances that may be
present in a blood sample.
10
Enabling effective use of SMBG ColorSure Technology
™
Effective utilization of structured SMBG requires The OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex meter features
™
that patients are able to correctly interpret their ColourSure™ technology, a range indicator that
blood glucose results and take appropriate instantly shows if a blood glucose result is low,
actions when needed. Studies suggests that
4
high or in range. When a blood glucose result
many patients with diabetes do not know how is displayed, the Range Indicator Arrow points
to identify and interpret SMBG results. This 5,6
to a corresponding Range Indicator Colour Bar;
not only impacts patients’ ability to achieve and blue (below range), green (in range) or red (above
maintain their target blood glucose but can also range). Studies have evaluated the clinical utility
negatively affect adherence to their prescribed and perceived benefits of support tool use by
testing frequency. 7
individuals with type 1 (T1D) and type 2 diabetes
(T2D).6.8
Date Time them better manage their highs and lows to avoid
Unit of measure: hypoglycemic and hyperglycemic events.
Range Indicator mmol/L is the
Arrow preset unit of
measure and Range Indicator Settings
cannot be
changed • The OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex meter is preset
™
8 The low and high range limits set in the OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex meter apply
™
to all glucose test results. This includes tests taken before or after mealtimes,
medications, and around any other activities that may affect blood glucose.
Patients are advised to talk to their healthcare professional about the high and
low limits that are right for them.
11
Conclusions References
The accuracy, precision, hematocrit, and 1. EN ISO 15197:2015 In vitro diagnostic test
interference performance of the OneTouch Ultra systems - Requirements for blood-glucose
Plus Flex have been assessed in laboratory and
™
monitoring systems for self-testing in
clinical studies. In both the system accuracy managing diabetes mellitus (ISO 15197:2013)
and the user performance studies, accuracy
levels met the recognized EN ISO 15197:2015 2. Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute
criteria. The OneTouch Ultra Plus Flex BGMS ™ (CLSI). Appendix D: interference test
is not sensitive to 26 common interfering concentrations for endogenous analytes,
substances at high normal/high therapeutic EP7-A2. Interference Testing in Clinical
levels and has been shown to deliver accurate Chemistry; Approved Guideline - 2nd Ed. 2005.
blood glucose readings according to the EN ISO 3. Rankin D, Cooke D, Heller S, Elliot J, Amiel S,
15197:2015 standards. The OneTouch Ultra Plus Lawton J. Experiences of using blood glucose
Flex meter features Bluetooth connectivity
™ ®
understand their test results. If patients know 4. International Diabetes Federation. Global
when they are in or out of range, it may help guideline on self-monitoring of blood glucose
them to stay in better control and reach their in non-insulin treated type 2 diabetes. 2009.
blood glucose goals. 6
No updates since 2009. Accessed online at
https://www.idf.org/e-library/guidelines.html.
August 3, 2017
12