Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/330176269
CITATIONS READS
3 367
2 authors, including:
David Nylund
California State University, Sacramento
24 PUBLICATIONS 339 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by David Nylund on 25 November 2020.
CHAPTER
12
Queer Informed Narrative Therapy:
Radical Approaches to Counseling
with Transgender Persons
David Nylund and Annie Temple
159
Queer Theory
Queer theory is a range of post-structuralist critical practices that challenges pub-
lic sensibilities towards the relationship between sex, gender, and sexuality in the
social context with the intent of changing hegemonic understandings of gender
and sexual identities (Butler, 1990; Warner, 2000). Queer theory argues against the
notion of fixed identities, claiming instead that identity is constructed, multiple,
and fluid. Queer theorists have taken the lead in critiquing normative discourses
of gender and sexual identities, rejecting binary categories such as male/female or
heterosexual/homosexual.
Judith Butler, a key queer theorist, suggests that gender and sexual identities
are in constant flux and therefore cannot be delineated with clear boundaries
set in binary opposition to one another. Premised on Michel Foucault’s (1980)
work, Butler (1990) posits that binary understandings of sex and gender iden-
tities are regulatory and constraining and work to reinforce heteronormativity. For
example, a person who does not identify exclusively as male or female is forced to
pick one gender to represent themselves on a driver’s license. In Gender Trouble,
Butler (1990) writes that gender is not natural but performative, that it is what you
do at particular times rather than universally who you are. All gender is a perform-
ance; it is just that certain expressions of gender have seized a hegemonic hold and
appear to be natural.
Butler’s vision is to denaturalize and subvert dominant understandings of gen-
der and sexuality that are based on binary understandings of masculinity and
femininity. This project encourages a proliferation of genders and sexualities.
Envisioning a multiplicity of sexualities and genders allows space for the experi-
ences of individuals who fall outside the binary, including transgender individ-
uals. In a sense, transgender persons are lived, corporeal challenges to gender and
sexual binaries. Queer theory is brought to the forefront by people whose bod-
ies and experiences challenge the very notion of stable identities and sexualities.
Transgender persons illustrate the limitations of such binary systems, and their
experiences provide some of the foundation for queer theory.
Narrative Therapy
Narrative therapy (Freedman & Combs, 1996; Madigan, 2011; White & Epston,
1990) shares a great deal in common with queer theory as both draw from post-
structuralism for their philosophical underpinnings. The key narrative therapy
tenet is “the person is not the problem, the problem is the problem.” Separating
the problem from the person, known as externalizing, is achieved by a discur-
sive shift where problems become nouns. Externalizing, developed by Michael
White and David Epston (1990), allows persons to separate from problems
that have been located in their identity reinforcing a problem-saturated story.
Through an externalizing conversation, the client develops a relationship with
the problems, which creates space to attend to alternative stories that contradict
Drew
A significant aspect of culturally responsive work is familiarization with health
and mental health care standards of care (SOC) for professionals working with
transgender clients. The most widespread and recognized SOC is set forth by
the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH). The
overall goal of the SOC is to provide guidelines for health care professionals
and counselors to help transgender persons achieve “lasting personal com-
fort with the gendered self in order to maximize overall psychological well-
being and self-fulfillment” (Coleman et al., 2011, p. 166). The WPATH-SOC
I’m searching for a doctor who can hopefully help me in my semi-transition. But
I worry that if I go see a doctor and say I don’t fit with the binary but would
like my body to match the “in-between-ness,” will they outright deny me them
Drew’s experience is quite common for genderqueer persons and other non-binary
persons. They tend to be misunderstood by health care professionals and even
within the transgender community itself (Tilsen, 2013). Many genderqueer per-
sons have shared with me that they feel excluded and judged by some in the trans-
gender community for being, as one of my clients explained, “not trans enough.”
My response to Drew’s experiences and worries was to inform them of the
changes in the latest revision of the WPATH-SOC (2011). The SOC, seventh ver-
sion, allow for a broader spectrum of gender identities, including referring to
genderqueer and legitimizing non-binary identities. The new SOC could be con-
sidered “queer,” as they are compatible with Judith Butler’s vision of proliferat-
ing genders. Informing Drew of these changes relieved some of Drew’s concerns.
I referred Drew to an MD who was culturally responsive to transgender clients
and receptive to learning about gender and queer issues. I wrote a letter to the MD
recommending HRT, with particular emphasis on Drew’s genderqueer identity
being honored (I also sent the MD a copy of the latest SOC). Cultivating working
relationships with medical professionals and educating them about transgender
issues is key to a Queer Informed and social justice informed therapy. Drew started
hormones soon after the MD received the letter.
Jasper
When working with transgender clients, it is imperative that therapists do not
individualize problems that clients may be experiencing. In order to avoid indi-
vidualizing client problems, it is critical to engage clients in discussions about the
social construction of gender. In openly examining issues of gender and transpho-
bia in session, therapists can reduce client shame, show greater understanding
and empathy, and avoid re-stigmatizing transgender individuals. Additionally, in
externalizing (White & Epston, 1990) and locating problems in cultural discourses
rather than in clients, therapists can assist clients in separating themselves from
problems and opening up new possibilities for alternative client stories.
Jasper was a 20-year-old FTM (female to male) transgender client who came to
the Gender Health Center experiencing depression and anxiety. Jasper began tes-
tosterone four months prior to our first session and had frequently expressed his
fear of his family finding out that he is a man. Jasper shared that he was influenced
by self-hatred, partially believing that he was “flawed” because of his transgender
identity. In this transcript (edited for clarity) of one of our early sessions, I (AT)
J: I’m always feeling bad about myself and afraid, like if anyone finds out that
I am trans, they won’t think I’m a real man.
AT: I’ve talked to a lot of people who worry a lot about others finding out that
they are transgender. What about our society? How does our society pro-
mote the idea that you aren’t a real man? What makes a “real” man?
J: Well, I guess the fact that people don’t consider you a man unless you’re
born that way. I fear my family will never see me as a man because I wasn’t
born that way.
AT: So there’s this fraudulent assumption that someone’s gender is the same
as their biological sex … that someone’s identity matters less than their
biology and that somehow you have to explain yourself instead of just being
you. As someone with cisgender privilege, I never have to explain or justify
my gender. Do you think everyone should practice asking for preferred
pronouns regardless of whether they are cisgender or transgender?
J: Yes, I do. I’ve known I was a boy since I was five. It was other people tell-
ing me that I was something that I wasn’t that made me feel so terrible. My
grandparents have always insisted I was a girl but I knew who I was. I’m just
afraid now that if people find out, they won’t believe me. But yeah, I don’t
think it’s fair that cispeople are treated like their gender is more valid than
mine is.
AT: So it seems like transphobia has wreaked havoc in your life. It recruited
your grandparents to be unsupportive of you and tries to tell you that you
aren’t a “real” man and leads you into self-hate. Do you think it’s fair that
transphobia has produced a lot of pain for you and your family?
J: It’s not fair. People don’t understand at all. They think if you’re born a girl,
then you’re a girl and that’s that.
AT: Can I assume that you value justice and see a need for increased educa-
tion about issues of gender identity?
J: Exactly. There needs to be more education out there about people like me.
People don’t understand and are fearful of things they don’t understand.
I shouldn’t have to hide who I am. I’ve been this way forever.
AT: It’s kind of absurd isn’t it, that people who don’t conform to arbitrary
social norms are feeling depressed and ashamed of who they are. How have
you committed to being yourself, going to school and living your life in
spite of the effects of transphobia?
J: I won’t let it bring me down. I am who I am. It’s other people who need
to be educated. There’s so much misinformation out there. I’ve spent too
much time hiding in fear, at school with my friends and at home with my
grandparents.
Zack
Zack, a 16-year-old person assigned female at birth who identified as male, was
referred to me by his therapist, Debi, to assess readiness to start hormones (testos-
terone). Zack saw Debi for three sessions prior to my interview with him. Gender
was not the focal point in therapy; he was very clear about his male identity. Zack
“passed” as a male completely including using the men’s washroom in school and
other public places. He had been living full-time as a male since age 11 with com-
plete support of his family, friends, and school. This is an important point for
therapists to understand in their work with transgender clients: not all problems
are related to gender issues.
In my (DN) meeting with Zack (Z), I felt no need to ascertain his readiness for
hormones. Rather, I was drawn to what he had learned and come to value about
himself in his transition process. Zack and I explored and deconstructed Zack’s
ideas about masculinity, a common practice in narrative therapy. I had a sense that
Zack had some valuable insights into the social construction of manhood. Below
is an excerpt taken directly from our conversation:
Conclusion
Due to a lack of education about gender and sexuality in most graduate programs,
many transgender clients are unable to find culturally responsive clinicians. In
adopting a Queer Informed approach, cisgender clinicians can work to flatten power
hierarchies through openly examining their privilege. In addition, Queer Informed
clinicians can help clients expose the socially constructed nature of gender and assist
clients in externalizing and locating problems in transphobia and other social dis-
courses. Several transgender clients at the Gender Health Center who were inter-
viewed for a graduate research project felt that the solution to the deficiency in
quality mental health care for transgender clients is creating more community clin-
ics that address the needs of the transgender community (Temple, 2013). This chap-
ter has not only described ways to provide excellent care for transgender clients, but
is also a call to action for creation of more social service agencies that specialize in
this area. With the development of agencies that practice Queer Informed Narrative
Therapy, more transgender clients can receive help from social justice informed
counselors committed to undermining transgender oppression.
Reflection Questions
1. In what specific ways might a deeper awareness of cisgender privilege impact
your practice?
2. How might you integrate queer theory in your work with your clients—
including those who identify as heterosexual?
3. Is it possible to conduct assessments with transgender clients who need med-
ical services (hormones and surgery) while staying congruent with a “non-
expert” stance? If so, what would it take?
4. What specifically might your practice and/or agency do to be welcoming to
non-binary clients?
References
Alderson, K. G. (2015). Working with clients seeking support for gay, lesbian, bisexual,
transgender, two-spirited, and questioning experiences. In L. Martin (Ed.), Canadian
counselling and psychotherapy experience: Ethics-based issues and cases (pp. 357–382).
Ottawa, ON: Canadian Counselling and Psychotherapy Association.
Alegria, C. (2011). Transgender identity and health care: Implications for psychosocial and
physical evaluation. Journal of the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners, 23(4), 175–
182. doi: 10.1111/j.1745-7599.2010.00595.x
American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental dis-
orders (5th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
Benson, K. (2013). Seeking support: Transgender client experiences with mental health
services. Journal of Feminist Family Therapy, 25(1), 17–40. doi: 10.1080/08952833.
2013.755081
Bockting, W. O. (2009). Transforming the paradigm of transgender health: A field in tran-
sition. Sexual & Relationship Therapy, 24(2), 103–107. doi: 10.1080/14681990903037660
Butler, J. (1990). Gender trouble: Feminism and the subversion of identity. New York,
NY: Routledge.
Byne, W., Bradley, S., Coleman, E., Eyler, A., Green, R., Menvielle, E. J., … Tompkins,
D. A. (2012). Report of the American Psychiatric Association task force on treatment
of gender identity disorder. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 14, 759–796. doi: 10.1007/
s10508-012-9975-x
Coleman, E., Bockting, W., Botzer, M., Cohen-Kettenis, P., DeCuypere, G., Feldman, J., …
Zucker, K. (2011). Standards of care for the health of transsexual, transgender, and gen-
der non-conforming people: Version 7. International Journal of Transgenderism, 13, 165–
232. doi: 10.1080/15532739.2011.700873
Foucault, M. (1980). The history of sexuality: An introduction. New York, NY: Vintage.
Freedman, J., & Combs, G. (1996). Narrative therapy: The social construction of preferred
realities. New York, NY: Norton.
Korell, S. C., & Lorah, P. (2007). An overview of affirmative psychotherapy and counsel-
ing with transgender clients. In K. Bieschke, R. Perez, & K. DeBord (Eds.), Handbook
of counseling and psychotherapy with lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender clients
(pp. 271–288). Washington, DC: American Psychological Association. doi: 10.1037/
11482-011